Norway
A Hydrogen-Air Explosion in a Process Plant: A Case History
Sep 2005
Publication
In the summer of 1985 a severe hydrogen-air explosion occurred in an ammonia plant in Norway. The accident resulted in two fatalities and the destruction of the building where the explosion took place. This paper presents the main findings from an investigation in 1985 and 1986 of the gas explosion and its consequences. The event started when a gasket in a water pump was blown out. The water pump was situated inside a 100 m long 10 m wide and 7 m high building. The pump was feeding water to a vessel containing hydrogen gas at pressure of 30 bars. This pressure caused a back flow of water flow through the pump and out through the failed gasket. The hydrogen reached the leakage point after about 3 minutes. The discharge of gas lasted some 20 to 30 seconds before the explosion occurred. The total mass of the hydrogen discharge was estimated at 10 to 20 kg hydrogen. The main explosion was very violent and it is likely that the gas cloud detonated. The ignition source was almost certainly a hot bearing. Several damage indicators were used to estimate the amount of hydrogen that exploded. The indicators include deflection of pipes and panels distances traveled by fragments and the distribution of glass breakage. We found that 3.5 to 7 kg of hydrogen must have been burning violently in the explosion. Window glass was broken up to 700 m from the centre of the explosion. Concrete blocks originally part of the north wall of the building and weighing 1.2 metric tons were thrown up to 16 meters. The roof of the building was lifted by an estimated 1.5 meters before resettling. The displacement of the roof caused a guillotine break of a 350 mm diameter pipe connected to the vessel that was the source of the original gas discharge. The gas composition in the vessel was 65 - 95 % hydrogen. This resulted in a large horizontal jet fire lasting about 30 seconds. Minor explosions occurred in the plant culvert system.<br/><br/>To our knowledge this gas explosion is one of the largest industrial hydrogen explosions reported. We believe this case history is a valuable reference for those who are investigating the nature of accidental<br/>hydrogen explosions.
An Intercomparison Exercise on the Capabilities of CFD Models to Predict Deflagration of a Large-Scale H2-Air Mixture in Open Atmosphere
Sep 2005
Publication
This paper presents a compilation of the results supplied by HySafe partners participating in the Standard Benchmark Exercise Problem (SBEP) V2 which is based on an experiment on hydrogen combustion that is first described. A list of the results requested from participants is also included. The main characteristics of the models used for the calculations are compared in a very succinct way by using tables. The comparison between results together with the experimental data when available is made through a series of graphs. The results show quite good agreement with the experimental data. The calculations have demonstrated to be sensitive to computational domain size and far field boundary condition.
Experimental Measurements of Structural Displacement During Hydrogen Vented Deflagrations for FE Model Validation
Sep 2017
Publication
Vented deflagration tests were conducted by UNIPI at B. Guerrini Laboratory during the experimental campaign for HySEA project. Experiments included homogeneous hydrogen-air mixture in a 10-18% vol. range of concentrations contained in an about 1 m3 enclosure called SSE (Small Scale Enclosure). Displacement measurements of a test plate were taken in order to acquire useful data for the validation of FE model developed by IMPETUS Afea. In this paper experimental facility displacement measurement system and FE model are briefly described then comparison between experimental data and simulation results is discussed.
Structural Response for Vented Hydrogen Deflagrations: Coupling CFD and FE Tools
Sep 2017
Publication
This paper describes a methodology for simulating the structural response of vented enclosures during hydrogen deflagrations. The paper also summarises experimental results for the structural response of 20-foot ISO (International Organization for Standardization) containers in a series of vented hydrogen deflagration experiments. The study is part of the project Improving hydrogen safety for energy applications through pre-normative research on vented deflagrations (HySEA). The project is funded by the Fuel Cells and Hydrogen 2 Joint Undertaking under grant agreement No 671461. The HySEA project focuses on vented hydrogen deflagrations in containers and smaller enclosures with internal congestion representative of industrial applications. The structural response modelling involves one-way coupling of pressure loads taken either directly from experiments or from simulations with the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) tool FLACS to the non-linear finite element (FE) IMPETUS Afea Solver. The performance of the FE model is evaluated for a range of experiments from the HySEA project in both small-scale enclosures and 20-foot ISO containers. The paper investigates the sensitivity of results from the FE model to the specific properties of the geometry model. The performance of FLACS is evaluated for a selected set of experiments from the HySEA project. Furthermore the paper discusses uncertainties associated with the combined modelling approach.
A Socio-technical Perspective on the Scope for Ports to Enable Energy Transition
Jan 2021
Publication
The paper applies the multi-level perspective (MLP) in a descriptive study of three Norwegian ports to shed new light on the sociotechnical processes that structure their efforts to develop into zero emission energy hubs. While exogenous pressures cause tensions over port governance the studied ports utilize their full spectre of functions; as landlords operators authorities and community managers to enable transition. The respective approaches vary related to their local context market situation and social networks including port's relations with their owners. Individual orientations and organizational capacity further influence their engagement with radical innovation niches (e.g. OPS hydrogen LNG). The study highlights the active role of ports in sustainability transition. It shows how the interaction between geographical factors and institutional work influences the scope for new solutions around the individual port and how this makes for different feedback loops and contributions to sustainability transition in wider transport and energy systems.
Validation of CFD Modelling of LH2 Spread and Evaporation Against Large-Scale Spill Experiments
Sep 2009
Publication
Hydrogen is widely recognized as an attractive energy carrier due to its low-level air pollution and its high mass-related energy density. However its wide flammability range and high burning velocity present a potentially significant hazard. A significant fraction of hydrogen is stored and transported as a cryogenic liquid. Therefore loss of hydrogen containments may lead to the formation of a pool on the ground. In general very large spills will give a pool whereas moderate sized spills may evaporate immediately. Accurate hazard assessments of storage systems require a proper prediction of the liquid hydrogen pool evaporation and spreading. A new pool model handling the spread and the evaporation of liquid spills on different surfaces has recently been developed in the 3D Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) tool FLACS [1-4]. As the influence of geometry on the liquid spread is taken into account in the new pool model realistic industrial scenarios can be investigated. The model has been validated for LNG spills on water with the Burro and Coyote experiments [56]. The model has previously been tested for LH2 release in the framework of the EU-sponsored Network of Excellence HySafe where experiments carried out by BAM were modelled. In the large scale BAM experiments [7] 280 kg of liquid hydrogen was spilled in 6 tests adjacent to buildings. In these tests the pool spreading the evaporation and the cloud formation were investigated. Simulations of these tests are found to compare reasonably well with the experimental results. In the present work the model is extended and the liquid hydrogen spill experiments carried out by NASA are simulated with the new pool model. The large scale NASA experiments [89] consisted of 7 releases of liquefied hydrogen at White Sand New Mexico. The release test 6 is used. During these experiments cloud concentrations were measured at several distances downwind of the spill point. With the new pool model feature the FLACS tool is shown to be an efficient and accurate tool for the investigation of complex and realistic accidental release scenarios of cryogenic liquids.
Can the Addition of Hydrogen to Natural Gas Reduce the Explosion Risk?
Sep 2009
Publication
One of the main benefits sought by including hydrogen in the alternative fuels mix is emissions reduction – eventually by 100%. However in the near term there is a very significant cost differential between fossil fuels and hydrogen. Hythane (a blend of hydrogen and natural gas) can act as a viable next step on the path to an ultimate hydrogen economy as a fuel blend consisting of 8−30 % hydrogen in methane can reduce emissions while not requiring significant changes in existing infrastructure. This work seeks to evaluate whether hythane may be safer than both hydrogen and methane under certain conditions. This is due to the fact hythane combines the positive safety properties of hydrogen (strong buoyancy high diffusivity) and methane (much lower flame speeds and narrower flammability limits as compared to hydrogen). For this purpose several different mixture compositions (e.g. 8 % 20 % and 30 % hydrogen) are considered. The evaluation of (a) dispersion characteristics (which are more positive than for methane) (b) combustion characteristics (which are closer to methane than hydrogen) and (c) Combined dispersion + explosion risk is performed. This risk is expected to be comparable to that of pure methane possibly lower in some situations and definitely lower than for pure hydrogen. The work is performed using the CFD software FLACS that has been well-validated for safety studies of both natural gas/methane and hydrogen systems. The first part of the work will involve validating the flame speeds and flammability limits predicted by FLACS against values available in literature. The next part of the work involves validating the overpressures predicted by the CFD tool for combustion of premixed mixtures of methane and hydrogen with air against available experimental data. In the end practical systems such as vehicular tunnels garages etc. is used to demonstrate positive safety benefits of hythane with comparisons to similar simulations for both hydrogen and methane.
Opportunities and Challenges for Thermally Driven Hydrogen Production Using Reverse Electrodialysis System
Jul 2019
Publication
Ongoing and emerging renewable energy technologies mainly produce electric energy and intermittent power. As the energy economy relies on banking energy there is a rising need for chemically stored energy. We propose heat driven reverse electrodialysis (RED) technology with ammonium bicarbonate (AmB) as salt for producing hydrogen. The study provides the authors’ perspective on the commercial feasibility of AmB RED for low grade waste heat (333 K–413 K) to electricity conversion system. This is to our best of knowledge the only existing study to evaluate levelized cost of energy of a RED system for hydrogen production. The economic assessment includes a parametric study and a scenario analysis of AmB RED system for hydrogen production. The impact of various parameters including membrane cost membrane lifetime cost of heating inter-membrane distance and residence time are studied. The results from the economic study suggests RED system with membrane cost less than 2.86 €/m2 membrane life more than 7 years and a production rate of 1.19 mol/m2/h or more are necessary for RED to be economically competitive with the current renewable technologies for hydrogen production. Further salt solubility residence time and inter-membrane distance were found to have impact on levelized cost of hydrogen LCH. In the present state use of ammonium bicarbonate in RED system for hydrogen production is uneconomical. This may be attributed to high membrane cost low (0.72 mol/m2/h) hydrogen production rate and large (1281436 m2) membrane area requirements. There are three scenarios presented the present scenario market scenario and future scenario. From the scenario analysis it is clear that membrane cost and membrane life in present scenario controls the levelized cost of hydrogen. In market scenario and future scenario the hydrogen production rate (which depends on membrane properties inter-membrane distance etc.) the cost of regeneration system and the cost of heating controls the levelized cost of hydrogen. For a thermally driven RED system to be economically feasible the membrane cost not more than 20 €/m2; hydrogen production rate of 3.7 mol/m2/h or higher and cost of heating not more than 0.03 €/kWh for low grade waste heat to hydrogen production.
A Review on the Properties of Iron Aluminide Intermetallics
Jan 2016
Publication
Iron aluminides have been among the most studied intermetallics since the 1930s when their excellent oxidation resistance was first noticed. Their low cost of production low density high strength-to-weight ratios good wear resistance ease of fabrication and resistance to high temperature oxidation and sulfurization make them very attractive as a substitute for routine stainless steel in industrial applications. Furthermore iron aluminides allow for the conservation of less accessible and expensive elements such as nickel and molybdenum. These advantages have led to the consideration of many applications such as brake disks for windmills and trucks filtration systems in refineries and fossil power plants transfer rolls for hot-rolled steel strips and ethylene crackers and air deflectors for burning high-sulfur coal. A wide application for iron aluminides in industry strictly depends on the fundamental understanding of the influence of (i) alloy composition; (ii) microstructure; and (iii) number (type) of defects on the thermo-mechanical properties. Additionally environmental degradation of the alloys consisting of hydrogen embrittlement anodic or cathodic dissolution localized corrosion and oxidation resistance in different environments should be well known. Recently some progress in the development of new micro- and nano-mechanical testing methods in addition to the fabrication techniques of micro- and nano-scaled samples has enabled scientists to resolve more clearly the effects of alloying elements environmental items and crystal structure on the deformation behavior of alloys. In this paper we will review the extensive work which has been done during the last decades to address each of the points mentioned above.
Mapping of Hydrogen Fuel Quality in Europe
Nov 2020
Publication
As part of FCH-JU funded HyCoRA project running from 2014 to 2017 28 gaseous and 13 particulate samples were collected from hydrogen refuelling stations in Europe. Samples were collected with commercial sampling instruments and analysis performed in compliance with prevailing fuel quality standards. Sampling was conducted with focus on diversity in feedstock as well as commissioning date of the HRS. Results indicate that the strategy for sampling was good. No evidence of impurity cross-over was observed. Parallel samples collected indicate some variation in analytical results. It was however found that fuel quality was generally good. Fourteen analytical results were in violation with the fuel tolerance limits. Therefore eight or 29% of the samples were in violation with the fuel quality requirements. Nitrogen oxygen and organics were the predominant impurities quantified. Particulate impurities were found to be within fuel quality specifications. No correlation between fuel quality and hydrogen feedstock or HRS commissioning date was found. Nitrogen to oxygen ratios gave no indication of samples being contaminated by air. A comparison of analytical results between two different laboratories were conducted. Some difference in analytical results were observed.
The Role of Hydrogen in the Transition from a Petroleum Economy to a Low-carbon Society
Jun 2021
Publication
A radical decarbonization pathway for the Norwegian society towards 2050 is presented. The paper focuses on the role of hydrogen in the transition when present Norwegian petroleum export is gradually phased out. The study is in line with EU initiatives to secure cooperation opportunities with neighbouring countries to establish an international hydrogen market. Three analytical perspectives are combined. The first uses energy models to investigate the role of hydrogen in an energy and power market perspective without considering hydrogen export. The second uses an economic equilibrium model to examine the potential role of hydrogen export in value creation. The third analysis is a socio-technical case study on the drivers and barriers for hydrogen production in Norway. Main conclusions are that access to renewable power and hydrogen are prerequisites for decarbonization of transport and industrial sectors in Norway and that hydrogen is a key to maintain a high level of economic activity. Structural changes in the economy impacts of new technologies and key enablers and barriers in this transition are discussed.
Gas Switching Reforming for Flexible Power and Hydrogen Production to Balance Variable Renewables
May 2019
Publication
Variable renewable energy (VRE) is expected to play a major role in the decarbonization of the electricity sector. However decarbonization via VRE requires a fleet of flexible dispatchable plants with low CO2 emissions to supply clean power during times with limited wind and sunlight. These plants will need to operate at reduced capacity factors with frequent ramps in electricity output posing techno-economic challenges. This study therefore presents an economic assessment of a new near-zero emission power plant designed for this purpose. The gas switching reforming combined cycle (GSR-CC) plant can produce electricity during times of low VRE output and hydrogen during times of high VRE output. This product flexibility allows the plant to operate continuously even when high VRE output makes electricity production uneconomical. Although the CO2 avoidance cost of the GSR-CC plant (€61/ton) was similar to the benchmark post-combustion CO2 capture plant under baseload operation GSR-CC clearly outperformed the benchmark in a more realistic scenario where continued VRE expansion forces power plants into mid-load operation (45% capacity factor). In this scenario GSR-CC promises a 5 %-point higher annualized investment return than the post-combustion benchmark. GSR-CC therefore appears to be a promising concept for a future scenario with high VRE market share and CO2 prices provided that a large market for clean hydrogen is established.
Consequence Models for Vented Hydrogen Deflagrations: CFD vs. Engineering Models
Sep 2017
Publication
This paper compares two approaches for predicting the consequences of vented hydrogen deflagrations: empirical engineering models (EMs) and computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations. The study is part of the project ‘Improving hydrogen safety for energy applications through pre-normative research on vented deflagrations’ (HySEA) funded by the Fuel Cells and Hydrogen 2 Joint Undertaking (FCH JU) under grant agreement No 671461. The HySEA project focuses on vented hydrogen deflagrations in containers and smaller enclosures with internal congestion representative of industrial applications. Data from experiments conducted as part of the HySEA project are used to evaluate predictions from a selection of EMs and the CFD tool FLACS. The experiments involve various obstacle and venting configurations and initially quiescent homogeneous hydrogen-air mixtures with hydrogen concentrations in the range 15–24 vol%. There is a significant scatter in the maximum reduced overpressures predicted by the different EMs in the present study. For certain configurations there is an order of magnitude difference between the different EM predictions. Two versions of the CFD tool FLACS are used in the present study: i) the standard commercial release FLACS v10.7r2 and ii) an in-house development version termed FLACS-beta. The commercial release generally over-predicts the maximum overpressures measured in the experiments while the development version of FLACS gives improved results for several configurations.
Materials Considerations in Hydrogen Production
Sep 2007
Publication
Correct selection and application of materials is essential to ensure safety and economy in production transportation and storage of hydrogen. There are several sources of materials challenges related to hydrogen. Established component producers may have limited experience in this specific field. Process developments may involve new process conditions with new demands on the materials. Further new materials will be added to the engineering toolbox to be used. The behaviour of these materials for hydrogen service may need additional documentation. Finally focus on hydrogen susceptibility and hydrogen damages alone may take away awareness of other subjects as trace elements by-products and change in raw materials which may be of as high importance for safety and quality. This overview of challenges and recommendations is made with emphasis on water electrolysis.
Hytunnel Project to Investigate the Use of Hydrogen Vehicles in Road Tunnels
Sep 2009
Publication
Hydrogen vehicles may emerge as a leading contender to replace today’s internal combustion engine powered vehicles. A Phenomena Identification and Ranking Table exercise conducted as part of the European Network of Excellence on Hydrogen Safety (HySafe) identified the use of hydrogen vehicles in road tunnels as a topic of important concern. An internal project called HyTunnel was duly established within HySafe to review identify and analyse the issues involved and to contribute to the wider activity to establish the true nature of the hazards posed by hydrogen vehicles in the confined space of a tunnel and their relative severity compared to those posed by vehicles powered by conventional fuels including compressed natural gas (CNG). In addition to reviewing current hydrogen vehicle designs tunnel design practice and previous research a programme of experiments and CFD modelling activities was performed for selected scenarios to examine the dispersion and explosion hazards potentially posed by hydrogen vehicles. Releases from compressed gaseous hydrogen (CGH2) and liquid hydrogen (LH2) powered vehicles have been studied under various tunnel geometries and ventilation regimes. The findings drawn from the limited work done so far indicate that under normal circumstances hydrogen powered vehicles do not pose a significantly higher risk than those powered by petrol diesel or CNG but this needs to be confirmed by further research. In particular obstructions at tunnel ceiling level have been identified as a potential hazard in respect to fast deflagration or even detonation in some circumstances which warrants further investigation. The shape of the tunnel tunnel ventilation and vehicle pressure relief device (PRD) operation are potentially important parameters in determining explosion risks and the appropriate mitigation measures.
The Role of Lock-in Mechanisms in Transition Processes: The Case of Energy for Road Transport
Jul 2015
Publication
This paper revisits the theoretical concepts of lock-in mechanisms to analyse transition processes in energy production and road transportation in the Nordic countries focussing on three technology platforms: advanced biofuels e-mobility and hydrogen and fuel cell electrical vehicles. The paper is based on a comparative analysis of case studies.<br/>The main lock-in mechanisms analysed are learning effects economies of scale economies of scope network externalities informational increasing returns technological interrelatedness collective action institutional learning effects and the differentiation of power.<br/>We show that very different path dependencies have been reinforced by the lock-in mechanisms. Hence the characteristics of existing regimes set the preconditions for the development of new transition pathways. The incumbent socio-technical regime is not just fossil-based but may also include mature niches specialised in the exploitation of renewable sources. This implies a need to distinguish between lock-in mechanisms favouring the old fossil-based regime well-established (mature) renewable energy niches or new pathways.
A Review of Cohesive Zone Modelling as an Approach for Numerically Assessing Hydrogen Embrittlement of Steel Structures
Jun 2014
Publication
Simulation of hydrogen embrittlement (HE) requires a coupled approach; on one side the models describing hydrogen transport must account for local mechanical fields while on the other side the effect of hydrogen on the accelerated material damage must be implemented into the model describing crack initiation and growth. This study presents a review of coupled diffusion and cohesive zone modelling as a method for numerically assessing HE of a steel structure. While the model is able to reproduce single experimental results by appropriate fitting of the cohesive parameters there appears to be limitations in transferring these results to other hydrogen systems. Agreement may be improved by appropriately identifying the required input parameters for the particular system under study.
Link to document download on Royal Society Website
Link to document download on Royal Society Website
Techno-economic calculations of small-scale hydrogen supply systems for zero emission transport in Norway
Jun 2019
Publication
In Norway where nearly 100% of the power is hydroelectric it is natural to consider water electrolysis as the main production method of hydrogen for zero-emission transport. In a start-up market with low demand for hydrogen one may find that small-scale WE-based hydrogen production is more cost-efficient than large-scale production because of the potential to reach a high number of operating hours at rated capacity and high overall system utilization rate. Two case studies addressing the levelized costs of hydrogen in local supply systems have been evaluated in the present work: (1) Hydrogen production at a small-scale hydroelectric power plant (with and without on-site refuelling) and (2) Small hydrogen refuelling station for trucks (with and without on-site hydrogen production). The techno-economic calculations of the two case studies show that the levelized hydrogen refuelling cost at the small-scale hydroelectric power plant (with a local station) will be 141 NOK/kg while a fleet of 5 fuel cell trucks will be able to refuel hydrogen at a cost of 58 NOK/kg at a station with on-site production or 71 NOK/kg at a station based on delivered hydrogen. The study shows that there is a relatively good business case for local water electrolysis and supply of hydrogen to captive fleets of trucks in Norway particularly if the size of the fleet is sufficiently large to justify the installation of a relatively large water electrolyzer system (economies of scale). The ideal concept would be a large fleet of heavy-duty vehicles (with a high total hydrogen demand) and a refuelling station with nearly 100% utilization of the installed hydrogen production capacity.
Pathways to Low-cost Clean Hydrogen Production with Gas Switching Reforming
Feb 2020
Publication
Gas switching reforming (GSR) is a promising technology for natural gas reforming with inherent CO2 capture. Like conventional steam methane reforming (SMR) GSR can be integrated with CO2 -gas shift and pressure swing adsorption units for pure hydrogen production. The resulting GSR-H2 process concept was techno-economically assessed in this study. Results showed that GSR-H2 can achieve 96% CO2 capture at a CO2 avoidance cost of 15 $/ton (including CO2 transport and storage). Most components of the GSR-H2 process are proven technologies but long-term oxygen carrier stability presents an important technical uncertainty that can adversely affect competitiveness when the material lifetime drops below one year. Relative to the SMR benchmark GSR-H2 replaces some fuel consumption with electricity consumption making it more suitable to regions with higher natural gas prices and lower electricity prices. Some minor alterations to the process configuration can adjust the balance between fuel and electricity consumption to match local market conditions. The most attractive commercialization pathway for the GSR-H2 technology is initial construction without CO2 capture followed by simple retrofitting for CO2 capture when CO2 taxes rise and CO2 transport and storage infrastructure becomes available. These features make the GSR-H2 technology robust to almost any future energy market scenario.
Assessment of Hydrogen Quality Dispensed for Hydrogen Refuelling Stations in Europe
Dec 2020
Publication
The fuel quality of hydrogen dispensed from 10 refuelling stations in Europe was assessed. Representative sampling was conducted from the nozzle by use of a sampling adapter allowing to bleed sample gas in parallel while refuelling an FCEV. Samples were split off and distributed to four laboratories for analysis in accordance with ISO 14687 and SAE J2719. The results indicated some inconsistencies between the laboratories but were still conclusive. The fuel quality was generally good. Elevated nitrogen concentrations were detected in two samples but not in violation with the new 300 μmol/mol tolerance limit. Four samples showed water concentrations higher than the 5 μmol/mol tolerance limit estimated by at least one laboratory. The results were ambiguous: none of the four samples showed all laboratories in agreement with the violation. One laboratory reported an elevated oxygen concentration that was not corroborated by the other two laboratories and thus considered an outlier.
Simulating Vented Hydrogen Deflagrations: Improved Modelling in the CFD Tool Flacs-Hydrogen
Sep 2019
Publication
This paper describes validation of the computational fluid dynamics tool FLACS-Hydrogen. The validation study focuses on concentration and pressure data from vented deflagration experiments performed in 20-foot shipping containers as part of the project Improving hydrogen safety for energy applications through pre-normative research on vented deflagrations (HySEA) funded by the Fuel Cells and Hydrogen 2 Joint Undertaking (FCH 2 JU). The paper presents results for tests involving inhomogeneous hydrogen-air clouds generated from realistic releases performed during the HySEA project. For both experiments and simulations the peak overpressures obtained for the stratified mixtures are higher than those measured for lean homogeneous mixtures with the same amount of hydrogen. Using an in-house version of FLACS-Hydrogen with the numerical solver Flacs3 and improved physics models results in significantly improved predictions of the peak overpressures compared to the predictions by the standard Flacs2 solver. The paper includes suggestions for further improvements to the model system.
On Capital Utilization in the Hydrogen Economy: The Quest to Minimize Idle Capacity in Renewables-rich Energy Systems
Oct 2020
Publication
The hydrogen economy is currently experiencing a surge in attention partly due to the possibility of absorbing variable renewable energy (VRE) production peaks through electrolysis. A fundamental challenge with this approach is low utilization rates of various parts of the integrated electricity-hydrogen system. To assess the importance of capacity utilization this paper introduces a novel stylized numerical energy system model incorporating the major elements of electricity and hydrogen generation transmission and storage including both “green” hydrogen from electrolysis and “blue” hydrogen from natural gas reforming with CO2 capture and storage (CCS). Concurrent optimization of all major system elements revealed that balancing VRE with electrolysis involves substantial additional costs beyond reduced electrolyzer capacity factors. Depending on the location of electrolyzers greater capital expenditures are also required for hydrogen pipelines and storage infrastructure (to handle intermittent hydrogen production) or electricity transmission networks (to transmit VRE peaks to electrolyzers). Blue hydrogen scenarios face similar constraints. High VRE shares impose low utilization rates of CO2 capture transport and storage infrastructure for conventional CCS and of hydrogen transmission and storage infrastructure for a novel process (gas switching reforming) that enables flexible power and hydrogen production. In conclusion all major system elements must be considered to accurately reflect the costs of using hydrogen to integrate higher VRE shares.
HYDRIDE4MOBILITY: An EU HORIZON 2020 Project on Hydrogen Powered Fuel Cell Utility Vehicles Using Metal Hydrides in Hydrogen Storage and Refuelling Systems
Feb 2021
Publication
Volodymyr A. Yartys,
Mykhaylo V. Lototskyy,
Vladimir Linkov,
Sivakumar Pasupathi,
Moegamat Wafeeq Davids,
Gojmir Radica,
Roman V. Denys,
Jon Eriksen,
José Bellosta von Colbe,
Klaus Taube,
Giovanni Capurso,
Martin Dornheim,
Fahmida Smith,
Delisile Mathebula,
Dana Swanepoel,
Suwarno Suwarno and
Ivan Tolj
The goal of the EU Horizon 2020 RISE project 778307 “Hydrogen fuelled utility vehicles and their support systems utilising metal hydrides” (HYDRIDE4MOBILITY) is in addressing critical issues towards a commercial implementation of hydrogen powered forklifts using metal hydride (MH) based hydrogen storage and PEM fuel cells together with the systems for their refuelling at industrial customers facilities. For these applications high specific weight of the metallic hydrides has an added value as it allows counterbalancing of a vehicle with no extra cost. Improving the rates of H2 charge/discharge in MH on the materials and system level simplification of the design and reducing the system cost together with improvement of the efficiency of system “MH store-FC” is in the focus of this work as a joint effort of consortium uniting academic teams and industrial partners from two EU and associated countries Member States (Norway Germany Croatia) and two partner countries (South Africa and Indonesia).<br/>The work within the project is focused on the validation of various efficient and cost-competitive solutions including (i) advanced MH materials for hydrogen storage and compression (ii) advanced MH containers characterised by improved charge-discharge dynamic performance and ability to be mass produced (iii) integrated hydrogen storage and compression/refuelling systems which are developed and tested together with PEM fuel cells during the collaborative efforts of the consortium.<br/>This article gives an overview of HYDRIDE4MOBILITY project focused on the results generated during its first phase (2017–2019).
Decarbonization Synergies From Joint Planning of Electricity and Hydrogen Production: A Texas Case Study
Oct 2020
Publication
Hydrogen (H2) shows promise as an energy carrier in contributing to emissions reductions from sectors which have been difficult to decarbonize like industry and transportation. At the same time flexible H2 production via electrolysis can also support cost-effective integration of high shares of variable renewable energy (VRE) in the power system. In this work we develop a least-cost investment planning model to co-optimize investments in electricity and H2 infrastructure to serve electricity and H2 demands under various low-carbon scenarios. Applying the model to a case study of Texas in 2050 we find that H2 is produced in approximately equal amounts from electricity and natural gas under the least-cost expansion plan with a CO2 price of $30–60/tonne. An increasing CO2 price favors electrolysis while increasing H2 demand favors H2 production from Steam Methane Reforming (SMR) of natural gas. H2 production is found to be a cost effective solution to reduce emissions in the electric power system as it provides flexibility otherwise provided by natural gas power plants and enables high shares of VRE with less battery storage. Additionally the availability of flexible electricity demand via electrolysis makes carbon capture and storage (CCS) deployment for SMR cost-effective at lower CO2 prices ($90/tonne CO2) than for power generation ($180/tonne CO2 ). The total emissions attributable to H2 production is found to be dependent on the H2 demand. The marginal emissions from H2 production increase with the H2 demand for CO2 prices less than $90/tonne CO2 due to shift in supply from electrolysis to SMR. For a CO2 price of $60/tonne we estimate the production weighted-average H2 price to be between $1.30–1.66/kg across three H2 demand scenarios. These findings indicate the importance of joint planning of electricity and H2 infrastructure for cost-effective energy system decarbonization.
Large Scale Experiments and Model Validation of Pressure Peaking Phenomena-ignited Hydrogen Releases
Jan 2021
Publication
The Pressure Peaking Phenomena (PPP) is the effect of introducing a light gas into a vented volume of denser gas. This will result in a nonequilibrium pressure as the light gas pushes the dense gas out at the vent. Large scale experiments have been performed to produce relevant evidence. The results were used to validate an analytical model. Pressure and temperature were measured inside a constant volume while the mass flow and vent area were varied. The analytical model was based on the conservation of mass and energy. The results showed that increasing the mass flow rate the peak pressure increases and with increasing the ventilation area the peak pressure decreases. Peak pressure was measured above 45 kPa. Longer combustion time resulted in higher temperatures increasing an underpressure effect. The experimental results showed agreement with the analytical model results. The model predicts the pressures within reasonable limits of+/-2 kPa. The pressure peaking phenomena could be very relevant for hydrogen applications in enclosures with limited ventilation. This could include car garages ship hull compartments as well as compressor shielding. This work shows that the effect can be modeled and results can be used in design to reduce the consequences.
Vented Hydrogen Deflagrations in Containers: Effect of Congestion for Homogeneous Mixtures
Sep 2017
Publication
This paper presents results from an experimental study of vented hydrogen deflagrations in 20-foot ISO containers. The scenarios investigated include 14 tests with explosion venting through the doors of the containers and 20 tests with venting through openings in the roof. The parameters investigated include hydrogen concentration vent area type of venting device and the level of congestion inside the containers. All tests involved homogeneous and initially quiescent hydrogen-air mixtures. The results demonstrate the strong effect of congestion on the maximum reduced explosion pressures which typically is not accounted for in current standards and guidelines for explosion protection. The work is a deliverable from work package 2 (WP2) in the project “Improving hydrogen safety for energy applications through pre-normative research on vented deflagrations” or HySEA which receives funding from the Fuel Cells and Hydrogen Joint Undertaking (FCH JU) under grant agreement no. 671461.
Magnesium Based Materials for Hydrogen Based Energy Storage: Past, Present and Future
Jan 2019
Publication
Volodymyr A. Yartys,
Mykhaylo V. Lototskyy,
Etsuo Akiba,
Rene Albert,
V. E. Antonov,
Jose-Ramón Ares,
Marcello Baricco,
Natacha Bourgeois,
Craig Buckley,
José Bellosta von Colbe,
Jean-Claude Crivello,
Fermin Cuevas,
Roman V. Denys,
Martin Dornheim,
Michael Felderhoff,
David M. Grant,
Bjørn Christian Hauback,
Terry D. Humphries,
Isaac Jacob,
Petra E. de Jongh,
Jean-Marc Joubert,
Mikhail A. Kuzovnikov,
Michel Latroche,
Mark Paskevicius,
Luca Pasquini,
L. Popilevsky,
Vladimir M. Skripnyuk,
Eugene I. Rabkin,
M. Veronica Sofianos,
Alastair D. Stuart,
Gavin Walker,
Hui Wang,
Colin Webb,
Min Zhu and
Torben R. Jensen
Magnesium hydride owns the largest share of publications on solid materials for hydrogen storage. The “Magnesium group” of international experts contributing to IEA Task 32 “Hydrogen Based Energy Storage” recently published two review papers presenting the activities of the group focused on magnesium hydride based materials and on Mg based compounds for hydrogen and energy storage. This review article not only overviews the latest activities on both fundamental aspects of Mg-based hydrides and their applications but also presents a historic overview on the topic and outlines projected future developments. Particular attention is paid to the theoretical and experimental studies of Mg-H system at extreme pressures kinetics and thermodynamics of the systems based on MgH2 nanostructuring new Mg-based compounds and novel composites and catalysis in the Mg based H storage systems. Finally thermal energy storage and upscaled H storage systems accommodating MgH2 are presented.
Safe Hydrogen Fuel Handling and Use for Efficient Implementation – SH2IFT
Sep 2019
Publication
The SH2IFT project combines social and technical scientific methods to address knowledge gaps regarding safe handling and use of gaseous and liquid hydrogen. Theoretical approaches will be complemented by fire and explosion experiments with emphasis on topics of strategic importance to Norway such as tunnel safety maritime applications etc. Experiments include Rapid Phase Transition Boiling Liquid Expanding Vapour Explosion and jet fires. This paper gives an overview of the project and preliminary results.
Flexible Power and Hydrogen Production: Finding Synergy Between CCS and Variable Renewables
Dec 2019
Publication
The expansion of wind and solar power is creating a growing need for power system flexibility. Dispatchable power plants with CO2 capture and storage (CCS) offer flexibility with low CO2 emissions but these plants become uneconomical at the low running hours implied by renewables-based power systems. To address this challenge the novel gas switching reforming (GSR) plant was recently proposed. GSR can alternate between electricity and hydrogen production from natural gas offering flexibility to the power system without reducing the utilization rate of the capital stock embodied in CCS infrastructure. This study assesses the interplay between GSR and variable renewables using a power system model which optimizes investment and hourly dispatch of 13 different technologies. Results show that GSR brings substantial benefits relative to conventional CCS. At a CO2 price of V100/ton inclusion of GSR increases the optimal wind and solar share by 50% lowers total system costs by 8% and reduces system emissions from 45 to 4 kgCO2/MWh. In addition GSR produces clean hydrogen equivalent to about 90% of total electricity demand which can be used to decarbonize transport and industry. GSR could therefore become a key enabling technology for a decarbonization effort led by wind and solar power.
Validation of Flacs-Hydrogen CFD Consequence Prediction Model Against Large Scale H2 Explosion Experiments in the Flame Facility
Sep 2005
Publication
The FLACS CFD-tool for consequence prediction has been developed continuously since 1980. The initial focus was explosion safety on offshore oil platforms in recent years the tool is also applied to study dispersion hydrogen safety dust explosions and more. A development project sponsored by Norsk Hydro Statoil and Ishikawajima Heavy Industries (IHI) was carried out to improve the modelling and validation of hydrogen dispersion and explosions. In this project GexCon carried out 200 small-scale experiments on dispersion and explosion with H2 and mixtures with H2 and CO or N2. Experiments with varying confinement congestion concentration and ignition location were performed. Since the main purpose of the tests was to produce good validation data all tests were simulated with the FLACS-HYDROGEN tool. The simulations confirmed the ability to predict explosions effects for the wide range of scenarios studied. A few examples of comparisons will be shown. To build confidence in a consequence prediction model it is important that the scales used for validation are as close as possible to reality. Since the hazard to people and facilities and the risk will generally increase with scale validation against large-scale experiments is important. In the 1980s a series of large-scale explosion experiments with H2 was carried out in the Sandia FLAME facility and sponsored by the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission. The FLAME facility is a 30.5m x 1.83m x 2.44m channel tests were performed with H2 concentrations from 7% to 30% with varying degree of top venting (0% 13% and 50%) and congestion (with or without baffles blocking 33% of the channel cross-section). A wide range of flame speeds and overpressures were observed. Comparisons are made between FLACS simulations and FLAME tests. The main conclusion from this validation study is that the precision when predicting H2 explosion consequences with FLACS has been improved to a very acceptable level
A Microstructure Informed and Mixed-mode Cohesive Zone Approach to Simulating Hydrogen Embrittlement
Mar 2022
Publication
Hydrogen induced failure under uniaxial tension is simulated in a duplex stainless steel considering microstructural feature of the material. There are three key ingredients in the modelling approach: image processing and finite element representation of the experimentally observed microstructure stress driven hydrogen diffusion and diffusion coupled cohesive zone modelling of fracture considering mixed failure mode. The microstructure used as basis for the modelling work is obtained from specimens cut in the transverse and longitudinal directions. It is found that the microstructure significantly influences hydrogen diffusion and fracture. The austenite phase is polygonal and randomly distributed in the transverse direction where a larger effective hydrogen diffusion coefficient and a lower hydrogen fracture resistance is found compared to the specimen in the longitudinal direction where the austenite phase is slender and laminated. This indicates that the proper design and control of the austenite phase help improve hydrogen resistance of duplex stainless steel. The strength of the interface in the shear direction is found to dominate the fracture mode and initiation site which reveals the importance of considering mixed failure mode and calibrating the hydrogen induced strength reduction in shear.
Determination Of Hazardous Zones For A Generic Hydrogen Station – A Case Study
Sep 2007
Publication
A method for determination of hazardous zones for hydrogen installations has been studied. This work has been carried out within the NoE HySafe. The method is based on the Italian Method outlined in Guide 31-30(2004) Guide 31–35(2001) Guide 31-35/A(2001) and Guide 31-35/A; V1(2003). Hazardous zones for a “generic hydrogen refuelling station”(HRS) are assessed based on this method. The method is consistent with the EU directive 1999/92/EC “Safety and Health Protection of Workers potentially at risk from explosive atmospheres” which is the basis for determination of hazardous zones in Europe. This regulation is focused on protection of workers and is relevant for hydrogen installations such as hydrogen refuelling stations repair shops and other stationary installations where some type of work operations will be involved. The method is also based on the IEC standard and European norm IEC/EN60079-10 “Electrical apparatus for explosive gas atmospheres. Part 10 Classification of hazardous areas”. This is a widely acknowledged international standard/norm and it is accepted/approved by Fire and Safety Authorities in Europe and also internationally. Results from the HySafe work and other studies relevant for hydrogen and hydrogen installations have been included in the case study. Sensitivity studies have been carried out to examine the effect of varying equipment failure frequencies and leak sizes as well as environmental condition (ventilation obstacles etc.). The discharge and gas dispersion calculations in the Italian Method are based on simple mathematical formulas. However in this work also CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamics) and other simpler numerical tools have been used to quantitatively estimate the effect of ventilation and of different release locations on the size of the flammable gas cloud. Concentration limits for hydrogen to be used as basis for the extent of the hazardous zones in different situations are discussed.
Development of Tools for Risk Assessment and Risk Communication for Hydrogen Applications
Sep 2005
Publication
For decades risk assessment has been an important tool in risk management of activities in several industries world wide. It provides among others authorities and stakeholders with a sound basis for creating awareness about existing and potential hazards and risks and making decisions related to how they can prioritise and plan expenditures on risk reduction. The overall goal of the ongoing HySafe project is to contribute to the safe transition to a more sustainable development in Europe by facilitating the safe introduction of hydrogen technologies and applications. An essential element in this is the demonstration of safety: that all safety aspects related to production transportation and public use are controlled to avoid that introducing hydrogen as energy carrier should pose unacceptable risk to the society.<br/>History has proven that introducing risk analysis to new industries is beneficial e.g. in transportation and power production and distribution. However this will require existing methods and standards to be adapted to the specific applications. Furthermore when trying to quantify risk it is of utmost importance to have access to relevant accident and incident information. Such data may in many cases not be readily available and the utilisation of them will then require specific and long lasting data collection initiatives.<br/>In this paper we will present the work that has been undertaken in the HySafe project in developing methodologies and collecting data for risk management of hydrogen infrastructure. Focus is laid on the development of risk acceptance criteria and on the demonstration of safety and benefits to the public. A trustworthy demonstration of safety will have to be based on facts especially on facts widely known and emphasis will thus be put on the efforts taken to establish and operate a database containing hydrogen accident and incident information which can be utilised in risk assessment of hydrogen applications. A demonstration of safety will also have to include a demonstration of risk control measures and the paper will also present work carried out on safety distances and ignition source control.
Ia-HySafe Standard Benchmark Exercise Sbep-V21- Hydrogen Release and Accumulation within a Non-Ventilated Ambient Pressure Garage at Low Release Rates
Sep 2011
Publication
The successful Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) benchmarking activity originally started within the EC-funded Network of Excellence HySafe (2004-2009) continues within the research topics of the recently established “International Association of Hydrogen Safety” (IA-HySafe). The present contribution reports the results of the standard benchmark problem SBEP-V21. Focus is given to hydrogen dispersion and accumulation within a non-ventilated ambient pressure garage both during the release and post-release periods but for very low release rates as compared to earlier work (SBEP-V3). The current experiments were performed by CEA at the GARAGE facility under highly controlled conditions. Helium was vertically released from the centre of the 5.76 m (length) x 2.96 m (width) x 2.42 m (height) facility 22 cm from the floor from a 29.7 mm diameter opening at a volumetric rate of 18 L/min (0.027 g/s equivalent hydrogen release rate compared to 1 g/s for SBEP-V3) and for a period of 3740 seconds. Helium concentrations were measured with 57 catharometric sensors at various locations for a period up to 1.1 days. The simulations were performed using a variety of CFD codes and turbulence models. The paper compares the results predicted by the participating partners and attempts to identify the reasons for any observed disagreements.
Hydrogen as an Energy Carrier: An Evaluation of Emerging Hydrogen Value Chains
Nov 2018
Publication
Some 3% of global energy consumption today is used to produce hydrogen. Only 0.002% of this hydrogen about 1000 tonnes per annum(i) is used as an energy carrier. Yet as this timely position paper from DNV GL indicates hydrogen can become a major clean energy carrier in a world struggling to limit global warming.<br/>The company’s recently published 2018 Energy Transition Outlook(1) projects moderate uptake of hydrogen in this role towards 2050 then significant growth towards 2100. Building on that this position paper provides a more granular analysis of hydrogen as an energy carrier.
The Influence of H2 Safety Research on Relevant Risk Assessment
Sep 2019
Publication
Hydrogen is a valuable option of clean fuel to keep the global temperature rise below 2°C. However one of the main barriers in its transport and use is to ensure safety levels that are comparable with traditional fuels. In particular liquid hydrogen accidents may not be fully understood (yet) and excluded by relevant risk assessment. For instance as hydrogen is cryogenically liquefied to increase its energy density during transport Boiling Liquid Expanding Vapor Explosions (BLEVE) is a potential and critical event that is important addressing in the hazard identification phase. Two past BLEVE accidents involving liquid hydrogen support such thesis. For this reason results from consequence analysis of hydrogen BLEVE will not only improve the understanding of the related physical phenomenon but also influence future risk assessment studies. This study aims to show the extent of consequence analysis influence on overall quantitative risk assessment of hydrogen technologies and propose a systematic approach for integration of overall results. The Dynamic Procedure for Atypical Scenario Identification (DyPASI) is used for this purpose. The work specifically focuses on consequence models that are originally developed for other substances and adapted for liquid hydrogen. Particular attention is given to the parameters affecting the magnitude of the accident as currently investigated by a number of research projects on hydrogen safety worldwide. A representative example of consequence analysis for liquid hydrogen release is employed in this study. Critical conditions detected by the numerical simulation models are accurately identified and considered for subsequent update of the overall system risk assessment.
Assessment and Evaluation of 3rd Party Risk for Planned Hydrogen Demonstration Facility
Sep 2007
Publication
Potential risk exposure of 3rd parties i.e. people not involved in the actual operation of a plant is often a critical factor to gain authority approval and public acceptance for a development project. This is also highly relevant for development of demonstration facilities for hydrogen production and refuelling infrastructure. This paper presents and discusses results for risk exposure of 3rd parties based on risk assessment studies performed for the planned Hydrogen Technology Research Centre Hytrec in Trondheim. The methodology applied is outlined. Key assumptions and study uncertainties are identified and how these might affect the results are discussed.<br/>The purpose of Hytrec is to build a centre for research development and demonstration of hydrogen as an energy carrier. Hydrogen will be produced both by reforming of natural gas with CO2 capture and by electrolysis of water. The plant also includes a SOFC that will run on natural gas or hydrogen and produce heat and electricity for the Hytrec visitor centre. Hytrec will be located in a populated area without access control. Most of the units will be located within cabinets and modules.<br/>The authors acknowledge the Hytrec project and the Hytrec project partners Statoil Statkraft and DNV for their support and for allowing utilisation of results from the Hytrec QRA in this paper.
Thermal Efficiency of On-site, Small-scale Hydrogen Production Technologies using Liquid Hydrocarbon Fuels in Comparison to Electrolysis a Case Study in Norway
Oct 2018
Publication
The main goal of this study was to assess the energy efficiency of a small-scale on-site hydrogen production and dispensing plant for transport applications. The selected location was the city of Narvik in northern Norway where the hydrogen demand is expected to be 100 kg/day. The investigated technologies for on-site hydrogen generation starting from common liquid fossil fuels such as heavy naphtha and diesel were based on steam reforming and partial oxidation. Water electrolysis derived by renewable energy was also included in the comparison. The overall thermal efficiency of the hydrogen station was computed including compression and miscellaneous power consumption.
Risk Modelling of a Hydrogen Refuelling Station Using a Bayesian Network
Sep 2009
Publication
Fault trees and event trees have for decades been the most commonly applied modelling tools in both risk analysis in general and the risk analysis of hydrogen applications including infrastructure in particular. It is sometimes found challenging to make traditional Quantitative Risk Analyses sufficiently transparent and it is frequently challenging for outsiders to verify the probabilistic modelling. Bayesian Networks (BN) are a graphical representation of uncertain quantities and decisions that explicitly reveal the probabilistic dependence between the variables and the related information flow. It has been suggested that BN represent a modelling tool that is superior to both fault trees and event trees with respect to the structuring and modelling of large complex systems. This paper gives an introduction to BN and utilises a case study as a basis for discussing and demonstrating the suitability of BN for modelling the risks associated with the introduction of hydrogen as an energy carrier. In this study we explore the benefits of modelling a hydrogen refuelling station using BN. The study takes its point of departure in input from a traditional detailed Quantitative Risk Analysis conducted by DNV during the HyApproval project. We compare and discuss the two analyses with respect to their advantages and disadvantages. We especially focus on a comparison of transparency and the results that may be extracted from the two alternative procedures.
Enhancing the Efficiency of Power- and Biomass-to-liquid Fuel Processes Using Fuel-assisted Solid Oxide Electrolysis Cells
Apr 2022
Publication
Power- and biomass-to-liquid fuel processes (PBtL) can utilize renewable energy and residual forestry waste to produce liquid synthetic fuels which have the potential to mitigate the climate impacts of the current transportation infrastructure including the long-haul aviation sector. In a previous study we demonstrated that implementing a solid oxide electrolysis cell (SOEC) in the PBtL process can significantly increase the energy efficiency of fuel production by supplying the produced hydrogen to a reverse water gas shift (RWGS) reactor to generate syngas which is then fed downstream to a Fischer–Tropsch (FT) reactor. The tail gas emitted from the FT reactor consists primarily of a mixture of hydrogen carbon monoxide and methane and is often recycled to the entrained flow gasifier located at the beginning of the process. In this analysis we investigate the efficiency gains of the PBtL process as a result of redirecting the tail gas of the FT reactor to the anode of an SOEC to serve as fuel. Supplying fuel to an SOEC can lower the electrical work input required to facilitate steam electrolysis when reacting electrochemically with oxide ions in the anode which in turn can reduce oxygen partial pressures and thus alleviate material degradation. Accordingly we develop a thermodynamic framework to reveal the performance limits of fuel-assisted SOECs (FASOECs) and provide strategies to minimize oxygen partial pressures in the SOEC anode. Additionally we elucidate how much fuel is required to match the heating demands of a cell when steam is supplied to the cathode over a broad range of inlet temperatures and demonstrate the influence of a set of reaction pathways of the supplied fuel on the operating potential of an FASOEC and the corresponding efficiency gain of the PBtL process. Based on preliminary calculations we estimate that implementing an FASOEC in the PBtL process can increase the energy efficiency of fuel production to more than 90% depending on the amount of FT tail gas available to the system.
Integration of Experimental Facilities: A Joint Effort for Establishing a Common Knowledge Base in Experimental Work on Hydrogen Safety
Sep 2009
Publication
With regard to the goals of the European HySafe Network research facilities are essential for the experimental investigation of relevant phenomena for testing devices and safety concepts as well as for the generation of validation data for the various numerical codes and models. The integrating activity ‘Integration of Experimental Facilities (IEF)’ has provided basic support for jointly performed experimental work within HySafe. Even beyond the funding period of the NoE HySafe in the 6th Framework Programme IEF represents a long lasting effort for reaching sustainable integration of the experimental research capacities and expertise of the partners from different research fields. In order to achieve a high standard in the quality of experimental data provided by the partners emphasis was put on the know-how transfer between the partners. The strategy for reaching the objectives consisted of two parts. On the one hand a documentation of the experimental capacities has been prepared and analysed. On the other hand a communication base has been established by means of biannual workshops on experimental issues. A total of 8 well received workshops has been organised covering topics from measurement technologies to safety issues. Based on the information presented by the partners a working document on best practice including the joint experimental knowledge of all partners with regard to experiments and instrumentation was created. Preserving the character of a working document it was implemented in the IEF wiki website which was set up in order to provide a central communication platform. The paper gives an overview of the IEF network activities over the last 5 years.
HIAD – Hydrogen Incident and Accident Database
Sep 2011
Publication
The Hydrogen Incident and Accident Database (HIAD) is being developed as a repository of systematic data describing in detail hydrogen-related undesired events (incidents or accidents). It is an open web-based information system serving various purposes such as a data source for lessons learnt risk communication and partly risk assessment. The paper describes the features of the three HIAD modules – the Data Entry Module (DEM) the Data Retrieval Module (DRM) and the Data Analysis Module (DAM) – and the potential impact the database may have on hydrogen safety. The importance of data quality assurance process is also addressed.
3D Risk Management for Hydrogen Installations (HY3DRM)
Oct 2015
Publication
This paper introduces the 3D risk management (3DRM) concept with particular emphasis on hydrogen installations (Hy3DRM). The 3DRM framework entails an integrated solution for risk management that combines a detailed site-specific 3D geometry model a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) tool for simulating flow-related accident scenarios methodology for frequency analysis and quantitative risk assessment (QRA) and state-of-the-art visualization techniques for risk communication and decision support. In order to reduce calculation time and to cover escalating accident scenarios involving structural collapse and projectiles the CFD-based consequence analysis can be complemented with empirical engineering models reduced order models or finite element analysis (FEA). The paper outlines the background for 3DRM and presents a proof-of-concept risk assessment for a hypothetical hydrogen filling station. The prototype focuses on dispersion fire and explosion scenarios resulting from loss of containment of gaseous hydrogen. The approach adopted here combines consequence assessments obtained with the CFD tool FLACS-Hydrogen from Gexcon and event frequencies estimated with the Hydrogen Risk Assessment Models (HyRAM) tool from Sandia to generate 3D risk contours for explosion pressure and radiation loads. For a given population density and set of harm criteria it is straightforward to extend the analysis to include personnel risk as well as risk-based design such as detector optimization. The discussion outlines main challenges and inherent limitations of the 3DRM concept as well as prospects for further development towards a fully integrated framework for risk management in organizations.
Accidental Hydrogen Release in Gc-laboratory: A Case Study
Oct 2015
Publication
A 50-litre standard hydrogen gas cylinder was temporarily placed in a laboratory to supply hydrogen gas to a flame ionization detector (FID) for use in gas chromatography (GC). On 20 January 2015 the safety relief valve on the pressure regulator failed and released about 0.34 kg of hydrogen into the laboratory. The gas cloud did not ignite so there was no injury or damage. The results of a full investigation with a complete course of action and reconstruction are presented that verify the cause of the leakage and estimate the gas concentration of the dispersion and gas cloud. A preliminary simulation of the likely explosion is provided. If the gas cloud had ignited the explosion would most likely have caused significant structural damage to doors windows and possibly the walls.
Hydrogen Explosions in 20’ ISO Container
Oct 2015
Publication
This paper describes a series of explosion experiments in inhomogeneous hydrogen air clouds in a standard 20′ ISO container. Test parameter variations included nozzle configuration jet direction reservoir back pressure time of ignition after release and degree of obstacles. The paper presents the experimental setup resulting pressure records and high speed videos. The explosion pressures from the experiments without obstacles were in the range of 0.4–7 kPa. In the experiments with obstacles the gas exploded more violently producing pressures in order of 100 kPa.
Status, Gaps and Recommendations Regarding Standardisation and the Use of Hydrogen in Sustainable Buildings
Sep 2013
Publication
The use of and interpretation of Regulations Codes and Standards is important input when developing hydrogen systems and applications. This paper presents the work related to standardisation undertaken by DNV as part of the EU supported project H2SusBuild. During the H2SusBuild project a renewable (solar and wind) based full scale energy system with components for hydrogen storage hydrogen production by electrolysis and hydrogen consumption by fuel cell and burner was built and integrated into an existing office building in Lavrion Greece. The relevant standards identified and applied the standardisation gaps identified and the recommendations made for further standardisation activities are presented.
The New Oil? The Geopolitics and International Governance of Hydrogen
Jun 2020
Publication
While most hydrogen research focuses on the technical and cost hurdles to a full-scale hydrogen economy little consideration has been given to the geopolitical drivers and consequences of hydrogen developments. The technologies and infrastructures underpinning a hydrogen economy can take markedly different forms and the choice over which pathway to take is the object of competition between different stakeholders and countries. Over time cross-border maritime trade in hydrogen has the potential to fundamentally redraw the geography of global energy trade create a new class of energy exporters and reshape geopolitical relations and alliances between countries. International governance and investments to scale up hydrogen value chains could reduce the risk of market fragmentation carbon lock-in and intensified geo-economic rivalry.
Benchmark Exercise on Risk Assessment Methods Applied to a Virtual Hydrogen Refuelling Station
Sep 2009
Publication
A benchmarking exercise on quantitative risk assessment (QRA) methodologies has been conducted within the project HyQRA under the framework of the European Network of Excellence (NoE) HySafe. The aim of the exercise was basically twofold: (i) to identify the differences and similarities in approaches in a QRA and their results for a hydrogen installation between nine participating partners representing a broad spectrum of background in QRA culture and history and (ii) to identify knowledge gaps in the various steps and parameters underlying the risk quantification. In the first step a reference case was defined: a virtual hydrogen refuelling station (HRS) in virtual surroundings comprising housing school shops and other vulnerable objects. All partners were requested to conduct a QRA according to their usual approach and experience. Basically participants were free to define representative release cases to apply models and frequency assessments according their own methodology and to present risk according to their usual format. To enable inter-comparison a required set of results data was prescribed like distances to specific thermal radiation levels from fires and distances to specific overpressure levels. Moreover complete documentation of assumptions base data and references was to be reported. It was not surprising that a wide range of results was obtained both in the applied approaches as well as in the quantitative outcomes and conclusions. This made it difficult to identify exactly which assumptions and parameters were responsible for the differences in results as the paper will show. A second phase was defined in which the QRA was determined by a more limited number of release cases (scenarios). The partners in the project agreed to assess specific scenarios in order to identify the differences in consequence assessment approaches. The results of this phase provide a better understanding of the influence of modelling assumptions and limitations on the eventual conclusions with regard to risk to on-site people and to the off-site public. This paper presents the results and conclusions of both stages of the exercise.
Hazard Distance Nomograms for a Blast Wave from a Compressed Hydrogen Tank Rupture in a Fire
Sep 2017
Publication
Nomograms for assessment of hazard distances from a blast wave generated by a catastrophic rupture of stand-alone (stationary) and onboard compressed hydrogen cylinder in a fire are presented. The nomograms are easy to use hydrogen safety engineering tools. They were built using the validated and recently published analytical model. Two types of nomograms were developed – one for use by first responders and another for hydrogen safety engineers. The paper underlines the importance of an international effort to unify harm and damage criteria across different countries as the discrepancies identified by the authors gave the expected results of different hazard distances for different criteria.
Modelling and Numerical Simulation of Hydrogen Jet Fires for Industrial Safety Analyses – Comparison with Large-scale Experiments
Sep 2019
Publication
Reliable predictive tools for hydrogen safety engineering are needed to meet increased and more widespread use of hydrogen in the society. Industrial models and methods used to establish thermal radiation hazard safety distances from hydrogen jet fires are often based on models previously developed for hydrocarbon jet fires. Their capability of predicting radiative heat fluxes from hydrogen jet fires has often only been validated against small-scale or medium-scale jet flame experiments. However large-scale hydrogen jet fire experiments have shown that thermal radiation levels can be significantly higher than one might expect from extrapolation of experience on smaller hydrogen flames. Here two large-scale horizontal hydrogen jet fires (from a 20.9 mm and a 52.5 mm diameter release respectively) have been modelled and simulated with the advanced industrial CFD code KAMELEON FIREEX KFX® based on the Eddy Dissipation Concept by Magnussen for turbulent combustion modelling. The modelling of the high-pressure hydrogen gas releases is based on a pseudo-source concept using real-gas thermodynamic data for hydrogen. The discrete transport method of Lockwood and Shah is used to calculate the radiative heat transfer and radiative properties of water vapour are modelled according to Leckner. The predicted thermal radiation is compared to data from large-scale hydrogen jet fire experiments and discussed. This work was conducted as part of a KFX-H2 R&D project supported by the Research Council of Norway.
Modelling of Hydrogen Jet Fires Using CFD
Sep 2011
Publication
The computational fluid dynamics (CFD) software FLACS has primarily been developed to model dispersion and explosion phenomena; however models for the simulation of jet fires are under development. The aim is to be able to predict industrial fires efficiently and with good precision. Newly developed models include e.g. flame models for non-premixed flames discrete transfer radiation model as well as soot models. Since the time scales for fire simulations are longer than for explosions the computational speed is important. The recent development of non-compressible and parallel solvers in FLACS may therefore be important to ensure efficiency. Hydrogen flames may be invisible will generate no soot and tend to radiate less than hydrocarbon fuels. Due to high pressure storage the flame lengths can be significant. Simpler jet flame relations can not predict the jet flame interaction with objects and barriers and thus the heat loads on impacted objects. The development of efficient and precise CFD-tools for hydrogen fires is therefore important. In this paper the new models for the simulation of fire are described. These models are currently under development and this manuscript describes the current status of the work. Jet fire experiments performed by Health and Safety Laboratories (HSL) both free jets and impinging jets will also be simulated to evaluate the applicability and validity of the new fire models.
The Effect of Hydrogen on the Nanoindentation Behavior of Heat Treated 718 Alloy
Oct 2020
Publication
In this study the effect of precipitates on the surface mechanical properties in the presence of hydrogen (H) is investigated by in situ electrochemical nanoindentation. The nickel superalloy 718 is subjected to three different heat treatments leading to different sizes of the precipitates: (i) solution annealing (SA) to eliminate all precipitates (ii) the as-received (AR) sample with fine dispersed precipitates and (iii) the over-aged (OA) specimen with coarser precipitates. The nanoindentation is performed using a conical tip and a new method of reverse imaging is employed to calculate the nano-hardness. The results show that the hardness of the SA sample is significantly affected by H diffusion. However it could be recovered by removing the H from its matrix by applying an anodic potential. Since the precipitates in the OA and AR samples are different they are influenced by H differently. The hardness increase for the OA sample is more significant in −1200mV while for the AR specimen the H is more effective in −1500mV. In addition the pop-in load is reduced when the samples are exposed to cathodic charging and it cannot be fully recovered by switching to an anodic potential.
Application of Hydrides in Hydrogen Storage and Compression: Achievements, Outlook and Perspectives
Feb 2019
Publication
José Bellosta von Colbe,
Jose-Ramón Ares,
Jussara Barale,
Marcello Baricco,
Craig Buckley,
Giovanni Capurso,
Noris Gallandat,
David M. Grant,
Matylda N. Guzik,
Isaac Jacob,
Emil H. Jensen,
Julian Jepsen,
Thomas Klassen,
Mykhaylo V. Lototskyy,
Kandavel Manickam,
Amelia Montone,
Julian Puszkiel,
Martin Dornheim,
Sabrina Sartori,
Drew Sheppard,
Alastair D. Stuart,
Gavin Walker,
Colin Webb,
Heena Yang,
Volodymyr A. Yartys,
Andreas Züttel and
Torben R. Jensen
Metal hydrides are known as a potential efficient low-risk option for high-density hydrogen storage since the late 1970s. In this paper the present status and the future perspectives of the use of metal hydrides for hydrogen storage are discussed. Since the early 1990s interstitial metal hydrides are known as base materials for Ni – metal hydride rechargeable batteries. For hydrogen storage metal hydride systems have been developed in the 2010s [1] for use in emergency or backup power units i. e. for stationary applications.<br/>With the development and completion of the first submarines of the U212 A series by HDW (now Thyssen Krupp Marine Systems) in 2003 and its export class U214 in 2004 the use of metal hydrides for hydrogen storage in mobile applications has been established with new application fields coming into focus.<br/>In the last decades a huge number of new intermetallic and partially covalent hydrogen absorbing compounds has been identified and partly more partly less extensively characterized.<br/>In addition based on the thermodynamic properties of metal hydrides this class of materials gives the opportunity to develop a new hydrogen compression technology. They allow the direct conversion from thermal energy into the compression of hydrogen gas without the need of any moving parts. Such compressors have been developed and are nowadays commercially available for pressures up to 200 bar. Metal hydride based compressors for higher pressures are under development. Moreover storage systems consisting of the combination of metal hydrides and high-pressure vessels have been proposed as a realistic solution for on-board hydrogen storage on fuel cell vehicles.<br/>In the frame of the “Hydrogen Storage Systems for Mobile and Stationary Applications” Group in the International Energy Agency (IEA) Hydrogen Task 32 “Hydrogen-based energy storage” different compounds have been and will be scaled-up in the near future and tested in the range of 500 g to several hundred kg for use in hydrogen storage applications.
Residual Performance of Composite Pressure Vessels Submitted to Mechanical Impacts
Sep 2017
Publication
Type IV pressure vessels are commonly used for hydrogen on-board stationary or bulk storages. During their lifetime they can be submitted to mechanical impacts creating damage within the composite structure not necessarily correlated to what is visible from the outside. When an impact is suspected or when a cylinder is periodically inspected it is necessary to determine whether it can safely stay in service or not. The FCH JU project Hypactor aims at creating a large database of impacts characterized by various non destructive testing (NDT) methods in order to provide reliable pass-fail criteria for damaged cylinders. This paper presents some of the tests results investigating short term burst) and long term (cycling) performance of impacted cylinders and the recommendations that can be made for impact testing and NDT criteria calibration.
Blind-prediction: Estimating the Consequences of Vented Hydrogen Deflagrations for Homogeneous Mixtures in a 20-foot ISO Container
Sep 2017
Publication
Trygve Skjold,
Helene Hisken,
Sunil Lakshmipathy,
Gordon Atanga,
Marco Carcassi,
Martino Schiavetti,
James R. Stewart,
A. Newton,
James R. Hoyes,
Ilias C. Tolias,
Alexandros G. Venetsanos,
Olav Roald Hansen,
J. Geng,
Asmund Huser,
Sjur Helland,
Romain Jambut,
Ke Ren,
Alexei Kotchourko,
Thomas Jordan,
Jérome Daubech,
Guillaume Lecocq,
Arve Grønsund Hanssen,
Chenthil Kumar,
Laurent Krumenacker,
Simon Jallais,
D. Miller and
Carl Regis Bauwens
This paper summarises the results from a blind-prediction study for models developed for estimating the consequences of vented hydrogen deflagrations. The work is part of the project Improving hydrogen safety for energy applications through pre-normative research on vented deflagrations (HySEA). The scenarios selected for the blind-prediction entailed vented explosions with homogeneous hydrogen-air mixtures in a 20-foot ISO container. The test program included two configurations and six experiments i.e. three repeated tests for each scenario. The comparison between experimental results and model predictions reveals reasonable agreement for some of the models and significant discrepancies for others. It is foreseen that the first blind-prediction study in the HySEA project will motivate developers to improve their models and to update guidelines for users of the models.
A Barrier Analysis of a Generic Hydrogen Refuelling Station
Sep 2009
Publication
Any technical installation need appropriate safety barriers installed to prevent or mitigate any adverse effects concerning people property and environment. In this context a safety barrier is a series of elements each consisting of a technical system or human action that implement a planned barrier function to prevent control or mitigate the propagation of a condition or event into an undesired condition or event. This is also important for new technologies as hydrogen refuelling stations being operated at very high pressures up to 900bar. In order to establish the needed barriers a hazard identification of the installation has to be carried out to identify the possible hazardous events. In this study this identification was done using the generic layout of a future large hydrogen refuelling station that has been developed by the EU NoE HySafe. This was based on experiences with smaller scale refuelling stations that has been in operation for several years e.g. being used in the former CUTE and ECTOS projects. Using this approach the object of the study is to support activities to further improve the safety performance of future larger refuelling stations. This will again help to inform the authorities and the public to achieve a proper public awareness and to support building up a realistic risk and safety perception of the safety on such future refuelling stations. In the second step the hazardous events that may take place and the barriers installed to stop hazards and their escalation are analysed also using in-house developed software to model the barriers and to quantify their performance. The paper will present an overview and discuss the state-of-the-art of the barriers established in the generic refuelling station.
Experimental Study of Light Gas Dispersion in a Channel
Sep 2019
Publication
Usage of hydrogen as fuel gives rise to possible accidental risks due to leakage and dispersion. A risk from hydrogen leak is the formation of a large volume of the hydrogen-air mixture which could be ignited and leading up to a severe explosion. Prevention and control of formation and ignition of combustible hydrogen cloud necessitate sufficient knowledge of mechanisms of the hydrogen leak dispersion ignition and over-pressures generated during combustion. This paper aims to investigate the momentum-controlled jet the buoyancy-controlled wave and the parameters influencing hydrogen concentration distribution in an elongated space. It demonstrates experimental results and analysis from helium and hydrogen dispersion in a channel. A set of experiments were carried out for the release of helium and hydrogen jets in a 3 m long channel to record their concentrations in the cloud by concentration sensors at different horizontal and vertical positions. Flow visualization technique was applied using shadowgraph to image the mixing process next to the release point and the helium- hydrogen-air cloud shape at the middle of the channel. Moreover results were used for comparison of helium and hydrogen concentration gradients. The results of the experiments show that swift mixing occurs at higher flow rates smaller nozzle sizes and downward release direction. Higher concentration recorded in the channel with negative inclination. Results also confirmed that hydrogen/helium behavior pattern in the channel accords with mutual intrusion theory about gravity currents.
Minimum Entropy Generation in a Heat Exchanger in the Cryogenic Part of the Hydrogen Liquefaction Process: On the Validity of Equipartition and Disappearance of the Highway
May 2019
Publication
Liquefaction of hydrogen is a promising technology for transporting large quantities of hydrogen across long distances. A key challenge is the high power consumption. In this work we discuss refrigeration strategies that give minimum entropy production/exergy destruction in a plate-fin heat exchanger that cools the hydrogen from 47.8 K to 29.3 K. Two reference cases are studied; one where the feed stream enters at 20 bar and one where it enters at 80 bar. Catalyst in the hot layers speeds up the conversion of ortho-to para-hydrogen. Optimal control theory is used to formulate a minimization problem where the objective function is the total entropy production the control variable is the temperature of the refrigerant and the constrains are the balance equations for energy mass and momentum in the hot layers. The optimal refrigeration strategies give a reduction of the total entropy production of 8.7% in the 20-bar case and 4.3% in the 80-bar case. The overall heat transfer coefficient and duty is higher in the 20 bar case which compensates for the increase in entropy production due to a thermal mismatch that is avoided in the 80 bar case. This leads the second law efficiency of the 20 bar case (91%) to be similar to the 80 bar case (89%). We demonstrate that equipartition of the entropy production and equipartition of the thermal driving force are both excellent design principles for the process unit considered with total entropy productions deviating only 0.2% and 0.5% from the state of minimum entropy production. Equipartition of the thermal driving force i.e. a constant difference between the inverse temperatures of the hot and cold layers represents a particularly simple guideline that works remarkably well. We find that both heat transfer and the spin-isomer reaction contribute significantly to the entropy production throughout the length of the process unit. Unlike previous examples in the literature the process unit considered in this work is not characterized by a “reaction mode” at the inlet followed by a “heat transfer mode”. Therefore it does not follow a highway in state space i.e. a band that is particularly dense with energy efficient solutions. By artificially increasing the spin-isomer conversion rate the highway appears when the conversion rate becomes sufficiently high.
Numerical Simulations of a Large Hydrogen Release in a Process Plant
Sep 2009
Publication
This paper describes a series of numerical simulations with release and ignition of hydrogen. The objective of this work was to re-investigate the accidental explosion in an ammonia plant which happened in Norway in 1985 with modern CFD tools. The severe hydrogen-air explosion led to two fatalities and complete destruction of the factory building where the explosion occurred. A case history of the accident was presented at the 1.st ICHS in Pisa 2005.<br/>The numerical simulations have been performed with FLACS a commercial CFD simulation tool for gas dispersion and gas explosions. The code has in the recent years been validated in the area of hydrogen dispersion and explosions.<br/>The factory building was 100 m long 10 m wide and 7 m high. A blown-out gasket in a water pump led to release of hydrogen from a large reservoir storing gaseous hydrogen at 3.0 MPa. The accident report estimated a total mass of released hydrogen between 10 and 20 kg. The location of the faulty gasket is known but the direction of the accidental release is not well known and has been one of the topics of our investigations. Several simulations have been performed to investigate the mixing process of hydrogen-air clouds and the development of a flammable gas cloud inside the factory building resulting in a simulation matrix with dispersions in all axis directions. Simulations of ignition of the different gas clouds were carried out and resulting pressure examined. These results have been compared with the damages observed during the accident investigation.<br/>We have also performed FLACS simulations to study the effect of natural venting and level of congestion. The height of the longitudinal walls has been varied leading to different vent openings at floor level at the ceiling and a combination of the two. This was done to investigate the effects of congestion with regards to gas cloud formation.<br/>The base case simulation appears to be in good accordance to the observed damages from the accident. The simulations also show that the build up of the gas cloud strongly depends on the direction of the jet and degree of ventilation. The CFD study has given new insights to the accident and the results are a clear reminder of the importance of natural venting in hydrogen safety.
Decarbonization of the Iron and Steel Industry with Direct Reduction of Iron Ore with Green Hydrogen
Feb 2020
Publication
Production of iron and steel releases seven percent of the global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. Incremental changes in present primary steel production technologies would not be sufficient to meet the emission reduction targets. Replacing coke used in the blast furnaces as a reducing agent with hydrogen produced from water electrolysis has the potential to reduce emissions from iron and steel production substantially. Mass and energy flow model based on an open-source software (Python) has been developed in this work to explore the feasibility of using hydrogen direct reduction of iron ore (HDRI) coupled with electric arc furnace (EAF) for carbon-free steel production. Modeling results show that HDRI-EAF technology could reduce specific emissions from steel production in the EU by more than 35% at present grid emission levels (295 kgCO2/MWh). The energy consumption for 1 ton of liquid steel (tls) production through the HDRI-EAF route was found to be 3.72 MWh which is slightly more than the 3.48 MWh required for steel production through the blast furnace (BF) basic oxygen furnace route (BOF). Pellet making and steel finishing processes have not been considered. Sensitivity analysis revealed that electrolyzer efficiency is the most important factor affecting the system energy consumption while the grid emission factor is strongly correlated with the overall system emissions.
CFD Simulation Study to Investigate the Risk from Hydrogen Vehicles in Tunnels
Sep 2007
Publication
When introducing hydrogen-fuelled vehicles an evaluation of the potential change in risk level should be performed. It is widely accepted that outdoor accidental releases of hydrogen from single vehicles will disperse quickly and not lead to any significant explosion hazard. The situation may be different for more confined situations such as parking garages workshops or tunnels. Experiments and computer modelling are both important for understanding the situation better. This paper reports a simulation study to examine what if any is the explosion risk associated with hydrogen vehicles in tunnels. Its aim was to further our understanding of the phenomena surrounding hydrogen releases and combustion inside road tunnels and furthermore to demonstrate how a risk assessment methodology developed for the offshore industry could be applied to the current task. This work is contributing to the EU Sixth Framework (Network of Excellence) project HySafe aiding the overall understanding that is also being collected from previous studies new experiments and other modelling activities. Releases from hydrogen cars (containing 700 bar gas tanks releasing either upwards or downwards or liquid hydrogen tanks releasing only upwards) and buses (containing 350 bar gas tanks releasing upwards) for two different tunnel layouts and a range of longitudinal ventilation conditions have been studied. The largest release modelled was 20 kg H2 from four cylinders in a bus (via one vent) in 50 seconds with an initial release rate around 1000 g/s. Comparisons with natural gas (CNG) fuelled vehicles have also been performed. The study suggests that for hydrogen vehicles a typical worst-case risk assessment approach assuming the full gas inventory being mixed homogeneously at stoichiometry could lead to severe explosion loads. However a more extensive study with more realistic release scenarios reduced the predicted hazard significantly. The flammable gas cloud sizes were still large for some of the scenarios but if the actual reactivity of the predicted clouds is taken into account very moderate worst-case explosion pressures are predicted. As a final step of the risk assessment approach a probabilistic QRA study is performed in which probabilities are assigned to different scenarios time dependent ignition modelling is applied and equivalent stoichiometric gas clouds are used to translate reactivity of dispersed nonhomogeneous clouds. The probabilistic risk assessment study is based on over 200 dispersion and explosion CFD calculations using the commercially available tool FLACS. The risk assessment suggested a maximum likely pressure level of 0.1-0.3 barg at the pressure sensors that were used in the study. Somewhat higher pressures are seen elsewhere due to reflections (e.g. under the vehicles). Several other interesting observations were found in the study. For example the study suggests that for hydrogen releases the level of longitudinal tunnel ventilation has only a marginal impact on the predicted risk since the momentum of the releases and buoyancy of hydrogen dominates the mixing and dilution processes.
Life Cycle Environmental Analysis of a Hydrogen-based Energy Storage System for Remote Applications
Mar 2022
Publication
Energy storage systems are required to address the fluctuating behaviour of variable renewable energy sources. The environmental sustainability of energy storage technologies should be carefully assessed together with their techno-economic feasibility. In this work an environmental analysis of a renewable hydrogen-based energy storage system has been performed making use of input parameters made available in the framework of the European REMOTE project. The analysis is applied to the case study of the Froan islands (Norway) which are representative of many other insular microgrid sites in northern Europe. The REMOTE solution is compared with other scenarios based on fossil fuels and submarine connections to the mainland grid. The highest climate impacts are found in the dieselbased configuration (1090.9 kgCO2eq/MWh) followed by the REMOTE system (148.2 kgCO2eq/MWh) and by the sea cable scenario (113.7 kgCO2eq/MWh). However the latter is biased by the very low carbon intensity of the Norwegian electricity. A sensitivity analysis is then performed on the length of the sea cable and on the CO2 emission intensity of electricity showing that local conditions have a strong impact on the results. The REMOTE system is also found to be the most cost-effective solution to provide electricity to the insular community. The in-depth and comparative (with reference to possible alternatives) assessment of the renewable hydrogen-based system aims to provide a comprehensive overview about the effectiveness and sustainability of these innovative solutions as a support for off-grid remote areas.
Hydrogen Refuelling Stations for Public Transport Quality and Safety in the User-interface
Sep 2007
Publication
Hydrogen stations and supply systems for public transport have been demonstrated in a number of European cities during the last four years. The first refuelling facility was put into operation in Reykjavik in April 2003. Experience from the four years of operation shows that safety related incidents are more frequent in the user interface than in the other parts of the hydrogen refuelling station (HRS). This might be expected taking into account the fact that the refuelling is manually operated and that according to industrial statistics human failures normally stand for more than 80% of all safety related incidents. On the other hand the HRS experience needs special attention since the refuelling at the existing stations is carried out by well trained personnel and that procedures and systems are followed closely. So far the quality and safety approach to hydrogen refuelling stations has been based on industrial experience. This paper addresses the challenge related to the development of safe robust and easy to operate refuelling systems. Such systems require well adapted components and system solutions as well as user procedures. The challenge to adapt the industrial based quality and safety philosophy and methodologies to new hydrogen applications and customers in the public sector is addressed. Risk based safety management and risk acceptance criteria relevant to users and third party are discussed in this context. Human factors and the use of incident reporting as a tool for continuous improvement are also addressed. The paper is based on internal development programmes for hydrogen refuelling stations in Hydro and on participation in international EU and IPHE projects such as CUTE HyFLEET:CUTE HySafe and HyApproval.
Results of the HySafe CFD Validation Benchmark SBEPV5
Sep 2007
Publication
The different CFD tools used by the NoE HySafe partners are applied to a series of integral complex Standard Benchmark Exercise Problems (SBEPs). All benchmarks cover complementarily physical phenomena addressing application relevant scenarios and refer to associated experiments with an explicit usage of hydrogen. After the blind benchmark SBEPV1 and SBEPV3 with subsonic vertical release in a large vessel and in a garage like facility SBEPV4 with a horizontal under-expanded jet release through a small nozzle SBEPV5 covers the scenario of a subsonic horizontal jet release in a multi-compartment room.<br/>As the associated dispersion experiments conducted by GEXCON Norsk Hydro and STATOIL were disclosed to the participants the whole benchmark was conducted openly. For the purpose of validation only the low momentum test D27 had to be simulated.<br/>The experimental rig consists of a 1.20 m x 0.20 m x 0.90 m (Z vertical) vessel divided into 12 compartments partially even physically by four baffle plates. In each compartment a hydrogen concentration sensor is mounted. There is one vent opening at the wall opposite the release location centrally located about 1 cm above floor with dimensions 0.10 m (Y) times 0.20 m (Z). The first upper baffle plate close to the release point is on a sensitive location as it lies nearly perfectly in the centre of the buoyant jet and thus separates the flow into the two compartments. The actual release was a nominally constant flow of 1.15 norm liters for 60 seconds. With a 12mm nozzle diameter this corresponds to an average exit velocity of 10.17 m/s.<br/>6 CFD packages have been applied by 7 HySafe partners to simulate this experiment: ADREAHF by NCSRD FLACS by GexCon and DNV KFX by DNV FLUENT by UPM and UU CFX by HSE/HSL and GASFLOW by FZK. The results of the different participants are compared against the experimental data. Sensitivity studies were conducted by FZK using GASFLOW and by DNV applying KFX.<br/>Conclusions based on the comparisons and the sensitivity studies related to the performance of the applied turbulence models and discretisation schemes in the release and diffusion phase are proposed. These are compared to the findings of the previous benchmark exercises.
Simulation of Detonation after an Accidental Hydrogen Release in Enclosed Environments
Sep 2007
Publication
An accidental hydrogen release in equipment enclosures may result in the presence of a detonable mixture in a confined environment. Numerical simulation is potentially a useful tool for damage assessment in these situations. To assess the value of CFD techniques numerical simulation of detonation was performed for two realistic scenarios. The first scenario starts with a pipe failure in an electrolyzer resulting in a leak of 42 g of hydrogen. The second scenario deals with a failure in a reformer where 84 g of hydrogen is released. In both cases dispersion patterns were first obtained from separate numerical simulation and were then used as initial condition in a detonation simulation based upon the reactive Euler's equations. Energy was artificially added in a narrow region to simulate detonative ignition. In the electrolyzer ignition was assumed to occur 500 ms after beginning of the release. Results show a detonation failing on the top and bottom side but propagating left and right before eventually failing also. Average impulse was 500 Ns/m². For the reformer three cases were simulated with ignition 1.0 1.4 and 2.0 seconds after the beginning of the release. In two cases the detonation wave failed everywhere except in the direction of the release in which it continued propagating until reaching the side wall. In the third the detonation failed everywhere at first but later a deflagration to detonation transition occurred resulting in a strong wave that propagated rapidly toward the side wall. In all three cases the consequences are more serious than in the electrolyzer.
Experiments with Release and Ignition of Hydrogen Gas in a 3m Long Channel
Sep 2007
Publication
This paper presents results from laboratory experiments with hydrogen dispersions and explosions in a 3 m long channel. Our objective is to get a better understanding of the phenomena and to develop tools that can analyse hydrogen dispersions and explosions. A total of 5 test series were performed with flow rates of hydrogen from 1.8 dm³/min to 75 dm³/min. The propagation of the combustible hydrogen-air cloud in the channel was observed from high-speed video recordings. The hydrogen-air cloud in the channel behaves as a gravity current and the flow appears to be well described by Froude scaling with a length scale corresponding to the height of a layer of 100 % hydrogen. The Froude numbers observed in the experiments are in good agreement with the theory of "light-fluid intrusion" for gravity currents found in the literature. Numerical simulations with the Flacs code correlate well with the experimental results. The flame propagation indicated that approximately half the height of the channel was filled with combustible mixture. We believe that this Froude scaling can be useful as a tool to analyse the consequences of hydrogen release in buildings channels and tunnels.
Concept of Hydrogen Fired Gas Turbine Cycle with Exhaust Gas Recirculation: Assessment of Process Performance
Nov 2019
Publication
High hydrogen content fuels can be used in gas turbine for power generation with CO2 capture IGCC plants or with hydrogen from renewables. The challenge for the engine is the high reactive combustion properties making dilution necessary to mitigate NOx emissions at the expense of a significant energy cost. In the concept analysed in this study high Exhaust Gas Recirculation (EGR) rate is applied to the gas turbine to generate oxygen depleted air. As a result combustion temperature is inherently limited keeping NOx emissions low without the need for dilution or unsafe premixing. The concept is analysed by process simulation based on a reference IGCC plant with CO2 Capture. Results with dry and wet EGR options are presented as a function EGR rate. Efficiency performance is assessed against the reference power cycle with nitrogen dilution. All EGR options are shown to represent an efficiency improvement. Nitrogen dilution is found to have a 1.3% efficiency cost. Although all EGR options investigated offer an improvement dry EGR is considered as the preferred option despite the need for higher EGR rate as compared with the wet EGR. The efficiency gain is calculated to be of 1% compared with the reference case.
Balancing GHG Mitigation and Land-use Conflicts: Alternative Northern European Energy System Scenarios
Jan 2022
Publication
Long-term power market outlooks suggest a rapid increase in renewable energy deployment as a main solution to greenhouse gas mitigation in the Northern European energy system. However the consequential area requirement is a non-techno-economic aspect that currently is omitted by many energy system optimization models. This study applies modeling to generate alternatives (MGA) technique to the Balmorel energy system model to address spatial conflicts related to increased renewable energy deployment. The approach searches for alternative solutions that minimize land-use conflicts while meeting the low-carbon target by allowing a 1% to 15% increase in system costs compared to the least-cost solution. Two alternative objectives are defined to reflect various aspects of spatial impact. The results show that the least-cost solution requires 1.2%–3.6% of the land in the modeled countries in 2040 for onshore wind and solar PV installations. A 10% increase in costs can reduce the required land area by 58% by relying more on offshore wind. Nuclear energy may also be an option if both onshore and offshore areas are to be reduced or in a less flexible system. Both offshore wind and nuclear energy technologies are associated with higher risks and pose uncertainties in terms of reaching the climate targets in time. The changes in costs and required land areas imply significantly higher annual costs ranging from 200 to 750 kEUR/km2 to avoid land use for energy infrastructure. Overall this study confirms that the energy transition strategies prioritizing land savings from energy infrastructure are feasible but high risks and costs of averted land are involved.
H2FC European Infrastructure; Research Opportunities to Focus on Scientific and Technical Bottlenecks
Sep 2013
Publication
The European Strategy Forum on Research Infrastructures (ESFRI) recognizes in its roadmap for Research Infrastructures that ?in the near future hydrogen as an energy carrier derived from various other fuels and fuel cells as energy transformers are expected to come into a major role for mobility but also for different other mobile and stationary applications? |1|. This modern hydrogen driven society lags far behind the reality. Because of that it is conform to question the current situation concerning the belief that already most is comprehensively investigated and developed concerning hydrogen technology is correct and already done. From that it appears the hydrogen technology is market ready only partial and not prepared in a sufficient way to get finally included and adopted in modern hydrogen driven society and especially the acceptance of the society is a critical. Beside this critical view through society several scientific and technical bottlenecks still discoverable. Nevertheless it is possible to foster furthermore science and development on hydrogen technology. The ?Integrating European Infrastructure? was created to support science and development of hydrogen and fuel cell technologies towards European strategy for sustainable competitive and secure energy also while identifying scientific and technical bottlenecks to support solutions based on. Its acronym is H2FC European Infrastructure and was formed to integrate the European R&D community around rare and/or unique infrastructural elements that will facilitate and significantly enhance the research and development of hydrogen and fuel cell technology.
Dissecting the Exergy Balance of a Hydrogen Liquefier: Analysis of a Scaled-up Claude Hydrogen Liquefier with Mixed Refrigerant Pre-cooling
Oct 2020
Publication
For liquid hydrogen (LH2) to become an energy carrier in energy commodity markets at scales comparable to for instance LNG liquefier capacities must be scaled up several orders of magnitude. While state-of-the-art liquefiers can provide specific power requirements down to 10 kWh/kg a long-term target for scaled-up liquefier trains is 6 kWh/kg. High capacity will shift the cost weighting more towards operational expenditures which motivates for measures to improve the efficiency. Detailed exergy analysis is the best means for gaining a clear understanding of all losses occurring in the liquefaction process. This work analyses in detail a hydrogen liquefier that is likely to be realisable without intermediate demonstration phases and all irreversibilities are decomposed to the component level. The overall aim is to identify the most promising routes for improving the process. The overall power requirement is found to be 7.09 kWh/kg with stand-alone exergy efficiencies of the mixed-refrigerant pre-cooling cycle and the cryogenic hydrogen Claude cycle of 42.5% and 38.4% respectively. About 90% of the irreversibilities are attributed to the Claude cycle while the remainder is caused by pre-cooling to 114 K. For a component group subdivision the main contributions to irreversibilities are hydrogen compression and intercooling (39%) cryogenic heat exchangers (21%) hydrogen turbine brakes (15%) and hydrogen turbines (13%). Efficiency improvement measures become increasingly attractive with scale in general and several options exist. An effective modification is to recover shaft power from the cryogenic turbines. 80% shaft-to-shaft power recovery will reduce the power requirement to 6.57 kWh/kg. Another potent modification is to replace the single mixed refrigerant pre-cooling cycle with a more advanced mixed-refrigerant cascade cycle. For substantial scaling-up in the long term promising solutions can be cryogenic refrigeration cycles with refrigerant mixtures of helium/neon/hydrogen enabling the use of efficient and well scalable centrifugal compressors.
Mathematical Modeling and Simulation of Hydrogen-fueled Solid Oxide Fuel Cell System for Micro-grid Applications - Effect of Failure and Degradation on Transient Performance
May 2020
Publication
We use a detailed solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) model for micro-grid applications to analyze the effect of failure and degradation on system performance. Design and operational constraints on a component and system level are presented. A degrees of freedom analysis identifies controlled and manipulated system variables which are important for control. Experimental data are included to model complex degradation phenomena of the SOFC unit. Rather than using a constant value a spatially distributed degradation rate as function of temperature and current density is used that allows to study trajectory based performance deterioration. The SOFC unit is assumed to consist of multiple stacks. The failure scenario studied is the loss of one individual SOFC stack e.g. due to breakage of sealing or a series of fuel cells. Simulations reveal that degradation leads to significant drifts from the design operating point. Moreover failure of individual stacks may bring the still operating power generation unit into a regime where further failures and accelerated degradation is more likely. It is shown that system design dimensioning operation and control are strongly linked. Apart from specific quantitative results perhaps the main practical contribution are the collected constraints and the degrees of freedom analysis.
Hydrogen Venting Under Variable Flow Conditions
Sep 2011
Publication
Safety distances for hydrogen plumes are currently derived using models developed for hydrocarbon releases. It is well known that hydrogen behaves in a significantly different manner to that of hydrocarbons when released to atmosphere. There are two main aspects involved with the development of safety distances for credible hydrogen releases; the intensity of the thermal radiation from such a plume should it be ignited and the distance downwind from the release point to the point where a flammable mixture with air no longer exists. A number of distinct areas of venting behaviour were investigated; Thermal radiation from ignited plumes from vertical open ended vent pipes Far field radiation measurements for direct comparison with models Thermal radiation from ignited plumes from vertical vent pipes terminating in a T-piece Thermal radiation measurements from ignited hydrogen with a 45 vent termination Hydrogen concentration measurements with a T-piece.
The Norwegian Government’s Hydrogen Strategy - Towards a Low Emission Society
Jun 2020
Publication
On Wednesday 3rd of June 2020 Norwegian Minister for Petroleum and Energy Tina Bru and Minister for Climate and Environment Sveinung Rotevatn presented the Norwegian government's hydrogen strategy.<br/>The strategy sets the course for the government's efforts to stimulate development of hydrogen-related technologies. Hydrogen as an energy carrier can contribute to reduction of greenhouse gases and create value for the Norwegian business sector. The government wishes to prioritise efforts in areas where Norway Norwegian enterprises and technology clusters may influence the development of hydrogen related technologies and where there are opportunites for increased value creation and green growth. For hydrogen to be a low-carbon or emission-free energy carrier it must be produced with no or low emissions such as through water electrolysis with renewable electricity or from natural gas with carbon capture and storage.<br/>Today technology maturity and high costs represent barriers for increased use of hydrogen especially in the transport sector and as feedstock in parts of industry. If hydrogen and hydrogen-based solutions such as ammonia are to be used in new areas both the technology and the solutions must become more mature. In this respect further technology development will be vital.
CFD and VR for Risk Communication and Safety Training
Sep 2011
Publication
There are new safety challenges with an increased use of hydrogen e.g. that people may not see dangerous jet flames in case of an incident. Compared to conventional fuels hydrogen has very different characteristics and physical properties and is stored at very high pressure or at very low temperatures. Thus the nature of hazard scenarios will be very different. Consequence modelling of ventilation releases explosions and fires can be used to predict and thus understand hazards. In order to describe the detailed development of a hazard scenario and evaluate ways of mitigation 3D Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) models will be required. Even with accurate modelling the communication of risk can be challenging. For this visualization in virtual reality (VR) may be of good help in which the CFD model predictions are presented in a realistic 3D environment with the possibility to include sounds like noise from a high pressure release explosion or fire. In cooperation with Statoil Christian Michelsen Research (CMR) and GexCon have developed the VRSafety application. VRSafety can visualize simulation results from FLACS (and another CFD-tool KFX) in an immersive VR-lab or on a PC. VRSafety can further be used to interactively control and start new CFD-simulations during the sessions. The combination of accurate CFD-modelling visualization and interactive use through VRSafety represents a powerful toolbox for safety training and risk communication to first-responders employees media and other stakeholders. It can also be used for lessons learned sessions studying incidents and accidents and to demonstrate what went wrong and how mitigation could have prevented accidents from happening. This paper will describe possibilities with VRSafety and give examples of use.
Heading for Hydrogen - The Oil and Gas Industry’s Outlook for Hydrogen, From Ambition to Reality
May 2020
Publication
The future of hydrogen energy is wrapped up with the future of natural gas renewable energy and carbon capture and storage (CCS). This yields useful synergies but also political economic and technical complexity. Nevertheless our survey of more than 1000 senior oil and gas professionals suggests a more certain future for hydrogen and that the time is right to begin scaling the hydrogen economy.
Hysafe SBEP-V20: Numerical Predictions of Release Experiments Inside a Residential Garage With Passive Ventilation
Sep 2009
Publication
This work presents the results of the Standard Benchmark Exercise Problem (SBEP) V20 of Work Package 6 (WP6) of HySafe Network of Excellence (NoE) co-funded by the European Commission in the frame of evaluating the quality and suitability of codes models and user practices by comparative assessments of code results. The benchmark problem SBEP-V20 covers release scenarios that were experimentally investigated in the past using helium as a substitute to hydrogen. The aim of the experimental investigations was to determine the ventilation requirements for parking hydrogen fuelled vehicles in residential garages. Helium was released under the vehicle for 2 h with 7.200 l/h flow rate. The leak rate corresponded to a 20% drop of the peak power of a 50 kW fuel cell vehicle. Three double vent garage door geometries are considered in this numerical investigation. In each case the vents are located at the top and bottom of the garage door. The vents vary only in height. In the first case the height of the vents is 0.063 m in the second 0.241 m and in the third 0.495 m. Four HySafe partners participated in this benchmark. The following CFD packages with the respective models were applied to simulate the experiments: ADREA-HF using k–ɛ model by partner NCSRD FLACS using k–ɛ model by partner DNV FLUENT using k–ɛ model by partner UPM and CFX using laminar and the low-Re number SST model by partner JRC. This study compares the results predicted by the partners to the experimental measurements at four sensor locations inside the garage with an attempt to assess and validate the performance of the different numerical approaches.
Development of Uniform Harm Criteria for Use in Quantitative Risk Analysis of the Hydrogen Infrastructure
Sep 2009
Publication
This paper discusses the preliminary results of the Risk Management subtask efforts within the International Energy Agency (IEA) Hydrogen Implementing Agreement (HIA) Task 19 on Hydrogen Safety to develop uniform harm criteria for use in the Quantitative Risk Assessments (QRAs) of hydrogen facilities. The IEA HIA Task 19 efforts are focused on developing guidelines and criteria for performing QRAs of hydrogen facilities. The performance of QRAs requires that the level of harm that is represented in the risk evaluation be established using deterministic models. The level of harm is a function of the type and level of hazard. The principle hazard associated with hydrogen facilities is uncontrolled accumulation of hydrogen in (semi) confined spaces and consecutive ignition. Another significant hazard is combustion of accidentally released hydrogen gas or liquid which may or may not happen instantaneously. The primary consequences from fire hazards consist of personnel injuries or fatalities or facility and equipment damage due to high air temperatures radiant heat fluxes or direct contact with hydrogen flames. The possible consequences of explosions on humans and structures or equipment include blast wave overpressure effects impact from fragments generated by the explosion the collapse of buildings and the heat effects from subsequent fire balls. A harm criterion is used to translate the consequences of an accident evaluated from deterministic models to a probability of harm to people structures or components. Different methods can be used to establish harm criteria including the use of threshold consequence levels and continuous functions that relate the level of a hazard to a probability of damage. This paper presents a survey of harm criteria that can be utilized in QRAs and makes recommendations on the criteria that should be utilized for hydrogen-related hazards.
Production of Sustainable Hydrogen and Carbon for the Metallurgical Industry
Dec 2021
Publication
Hydrogen will presumably become an important substitute for carbon as a reductant in the metallurgical industry for processes such as steel production. However the challenge to supply enough CO2 -free hydrogen for metallurgical processes has not been resolved yet. This paper reviews different production technologies for hydrogen and their advantages and drawbacks. Additionally it will highlight the development of plasma technology to produce hydrogen and carbon black which has been taking place at SINTEF during the last 30 years.
Technical and Economic Analysis of One-Stop Charging Stations for Battery and Fuel Cell EV with Renewable Energy Sources
Jun 2020
Publication
Currently most of the vehicles make use of fossil fuels for operations resulting in one of the largest sources of carbon dioxide emissions. The need to cut our dependency on these fossil fuels has led to an increased use of renewable energy sources (RESs) for mobility purposes. A technical and economic analysis of a one-stop charging station for battery electric vehicles (BEV) and fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEV) is investigated in this paper. The hybrid optimization model for electric renewables (HOMER) software and the heavy-duty refueling station analysis model (HDRSAM) are used to conduct the case study for a one-stop charging station at Technical University of Denmark (DTU)-Risø campus. Using HOMER a total of 42 charging station scenarios are analyzed by considering two systems (a grid-connected system and an off-grid connected system). For each system three different charging station designs (design A-hydrogen load; design B-an electrical load and design C-an integrated system consisting of both hydrogen and electrical load) are set up for analysis. Furthermore seven potential wind turbines with different capacity are selected from HOMER database for each system. Using HDRSAM a total 18 scenarios are analyzed with variation in hydrogen delivery option production volume hydrogen dispensing option and hydrogen dispensing option. The optimal solution from HOMER for a lifespan of twenty-five years is integrated into design C with the grid-connected system whose cost was $986065. For HDRSAM the optimal solution design consists of tube trailer as hydrogen delivery with cascade dispensing option at 350 bar together with high production volume and the cost of the system was $452148. The results from the two simulation tools are integrated and the overall cost of the one-stop charging station is achieved which was $2833465. The analysis demonstrated that the one-stop charging station with a grid connection is able to fulfil the charging demand cost-effectively and environmentally friendly for an integrated energy system with RESs in the investigated locations.
Explosion and Fire Risk Analyses of Maritime Fuel Cell Rooms with Hydrogen
Sep 2017
Publication
A methodology for explosion and fire risk analyses in enclosed rooms is presented. The objectives of this analysis are to accurately predict the risks associated with hydrogen leaks in maritime applications and to use the approach to provide decision support regarding design and risk-prevention and risk mitigating measures. The methodology uses CFD tools and simpler consequence models for ventilation dispersion and explosion scenarios as well as updated frequency for leaks and ignition. Risk is then efficiently calculated with a Monte Carlo routine capturing the transient behavior of the leak. This makes it possible to efficiently obtain effects of sensitivities and design options maintaining safety and reducing costs.
Simulation of DDT in Hydrogen-Air Behind a Single Obstacle
Sep 2011
Publication
Two-dimensional numerical simulations of deflagration-to-detonation transition (DDT) in hydrogen–air mixtures are presented and compared with experiments. The investigated geometry was a 3 m long square channel. One end was closed and had a single obstacle placed 1 m from the end and the other end was open to the atmosphere. The mixture was ignited at the closed end. Experiments and simulations showed that DDT occurred within 1 m behind the obstacle. The onset of detonation followed a series of local explosions occurring far behind the leading edge of the flame in a layer of unburned reactants between the flame and the walls. A local explosion was also seen in the experiments and the pressure records indicated that there may have been more. Furthermore local explosions were observed in the experiments and simulations which did not detonate. The explosions should have sufficient strength and should explode in a layer of sufficient height to result in a detonation. The numerical resolution was 0.5 mm per square cell and further details of the combustion model used are provided in the paper.
Metal Hydride Hydrogen Compressors
Feb 2014
Publication
Metal hydride (MH) thermal sorption compression is an efficient and reliable method allowing a conversion of energy from heat into a compressed hydrogen gas. The most important component of such a thermal engine – the metal hydride material itself – should possess several material features in order to achieve an efficient performance in the hydrogen compression. Apart from the hydrogen storage characteristics important for every solid H storage material (e.g. gravimetric and volumetric efficiency of H storage hydrogen sorption kinetics and effective thermal conductivity) the thermodynamics of the metal–hydrogen systems is of primary importance resulting in a temperature dependence of the absorption/desorption pressures). Several specific features should be optimised to govern the performance of the MH-compressors including synchronisation of the pressure plateaus for multi-stage compressors reduction of slope of the isotherms and hysteresis increase of cycling stability and life time together with challenges in system design associated with volume expansion of the metal matrix during the hydrogenation.<br/>The present review summarises numerous papers and patent literature dealing with MH hydrogen compression technology. The review considers (a) fundamental aspects of materials development with a focus on structure and phase equilibria in the metal–hydrogen systems suitable for the hydrogen compression; and (b) applied aspects including their consideration from the applied thermodynamic viewpoint system design features and performances of the metal hydride compressors and major applications.
On the Use of Hydrogen in Confined Spaces: Results from the Internal Project InsHyde
Sep 2009
Publication
Alexandros G. Venetsanos,
Paul Adams,
Inaki Azkarate,
A. Bengaouer,
Marco Carcassi,
Angunn Engebø,
E. Gallego,
Olav Roald Hansen,
Stuart J. Hawksworth,
Thomas Jordan,
Armin Keßler,
Sanjay Kumar,
Vladimir V. Molkov,
Sandra Nilsen,
Ernst Arndt Reinecke,
M. Stöcklin,
Ulrich Schmidtchen,
Andrzej Teodorczyk,
D. Tigreat,
N. H. A. Versloot and
L. Boon-Brett
The paper presents an overview of the main achievements of the internal project InsHyde of the HySafe NoE. The scope of InsHyde was to investigate realistic small-medium indoor hydrogen leaks and provide recommendations for the safe use/storage of indoor hydrogen systems. Additionally InsHyde served to integrate proposals from HySafe work packages and existing external research projects towards a common effort. Following a state of the art review InsHyde activities expanded into experimental and simulation work. Dispersion experiments were performed using hydrogen and helium at the INERIS gallery facility to evaluate short and long term dispersion patterns in garage like settings. A new facility (GARAGE) was built at CEA and dispersion experiments were performed there using helium to evaluate hydrogen dispersion under highly controlled conditions. In parallel combustion experiments were performed by FZK to evaluate the maximum amount of hydrogen that could be safely ignited indoors. The combustion experiments were extended later on by KI at their test site by considering the ignition of larger amounts of hydrogen in obstructed environments outdoors. An evaluation of the performance of commercial hydrogen detectors as well as inter-lab calibration work was jointly performed by JRC INERIS and BAM. Simulation work was as intensive as the experimental work with participation from most of the partners. It included pre-test simulations validation of the available CFD codes against previously performed experiments with significant CFD code inter-comparisons as well as CFD application to investigate specific realistic scenarios. Additionally an evaluation of permeation issues was performed by VOLVO CEA NCSRD and UU by combining theoretical computational and experimental approaches with the results being presented to key automotive regulations and standards groups. Finally the InsHyde project concluded with a public document providing initial guidance on the use of hydrogen in confined spaces.
An Intercomparison Exercise on the Capabilities of CFD Models to Predict Distribution and Mixing of H2 in a Closed Vessel.
Sep 2005
Publication
This paper presents a compilation and discussion of the results supplied by HySafe partners participating in the Standard Benchmark Exercise Problem (SBEP) V1 which is based on an experiment on hydrogen release mixing and distribution inside a vessel. Each partner has his own point of view of the problem and uses a different approach to the solution. The main characteristics of the models employed for the calculations are compared. The comparison between results together with the experimental data when available is made. Relative deviations of each model from the experimental values are also included. Explanations and interpretations of the results are presented together with some useful conclusions for future work.
An Inter-Comparison Exercise on the Capabilities of CFD Models to Predict the Short and Long Term Distribution and Mixing of Hydrogen in a Garage
Sep 2007
Publication
Alexandros G. Venetsanos,
E. Papanikolaou,
J. García,
Olav Roald Hansen,
Matthias Heitsch,
Asmund Huser,
Wilfried Jahn,
Jean-Marc Lacome,
Thomas Jordan,
H. S. Ledin,
Dmitry Makarov,
Prankul Middha,
Etienne Studer,
Andrei V. Tchouvelev,
Franck Verbecke,
M. M. Voort,
Andrzej Teodorczyk and
M. A. Delichatsios
The paper presents the results of the CFD inter-comparison exercise SBEP-V3 performed within the activity InsHyde internal project of the HYSAFE network of excellence in the framework of evaluating the capability of various CFD tools and modelling approaches in predicting the physical phenomena associated to the short and long term mixing and distribution of hydrogen releases in confined spaces. The experiment simulated was INERIS-TEST-6C performed within the InsHyde project by INERIS consisting of a 1 g/s vertical hydrogen release for 240 s from an orifice of 20 mm diameter into a rectangular room (garage) of dimensions 3.78x7.2x2.88 m in width length and height respectively. Two small openings at the front and bottom side of the room assured constant pressure conditions. During the test hydrogen concentration time histories were measured at 12 positions in the room for a period up to 5160 s after the end of release covering both the release and the subsequent diffusion phases. The benchmark was organized in two phases. The first phase consisted of blind simulations performed prior to the execution of the tests. The second phase consisted of post calculations performed after the tests were concluded and the experimental results made available. The participation in the benchmark was high: 12 different organizations (2 non-HYSAFE partners) 10 different CFD codes and 8 different turbulence models. Large variation in predicted results was found in the first phase of the benchmark between the various modelling approaches. This was attributed mainly to differences in turbulence models and numerical accuracy options (time/space resolution and discretization schemes). During the second phase of the benchmark the variation between predicted results was reduced.
Safety Distances- Definition and Values
Sep 2005
Publication
In order to facilitate the introduction of a new technology as it is the utilization of hydrogen as an energy carrier development of safety codes and standards besides the conduction of demonstrative projects becomes a very important action to be realized. Useful tools of work could be the existing gaseous fuel codes (natural gas and propane) regulating the stationary and automotive applications. Some safety codes have been updated to include hydrogen but they have been based on criteria and/or data applicable for large industrial facilities making the realization of public hydrogen infrastructures prohibitive in terms of space. In order to solve the above mentioned problems others questions come out: how these safety distances have been defined? Which hazard events have been taken as reference for calculation? Is it possible to reduce the safety distances through an appropriate design of systems and components or through the predisposition of adequate mitigation measures? This paper presents an analysis of the definitions of “safety distances” and “hazardous locations” as well as a synoptic analysis of the different values in force in several States for hydrogen and natural gas. The above mentioned synoptic table will highlight the lacks and so some fields that need to be investigated in order to produce a suitable hydrogen standard.
Simulation of Flame Acceleration and DDT in H2-air Mixture with a Flux Limiter Centred Method
Sep 2005
Publication
Flame acceleration and deflagration to detonation transition (DDT) is simulated with a numerical code based on a flux limiter centred method for hyperbolic differential equations. The energy source term is calculated by a Riemann solver for the in homogeneous Euler equations for the turbulent combustion and a two-step reaction model for hydrogen-air. The transport equations are filtered for large eddy simulation (LES) and the sub filter turbulence is modelled by a transport equation for the the turbulent kinetic energy. The flame tracking is handled by the G-equation for turbulent flames. Numerical results are compared to pressure histories from physical experiments. These experiments are performed in a closed circular 4m long tube with inner diameter of 0.107m. The tube is filled with hydrogen-air mixture at 1atm which is at rest when ignited. The ignition is located at one end of the tube. The tube is fitted with an obstruction with circular opening 1m down the tube from the ignition point. The obstruction has a blockage ratio of 0.92 and a thickness of 0.01m. The obstruction creates high pressures in the ignition end of the tube and very high gas velocities in and behind the obstruction opening. The flame experiences a detonation to deflagration transition (DDT) in the super sonic jet created by the obstruction. Pressure build-up in the ignition end of the tube is simulated with some discrepancies. The DDT in the supersonic jet is simulated but the position of the DDT is strongly dependent on the simulated pressure in the ignition end.
Stress Corrosion Cracking Of Stainless Steels In High Pressure Alkaline Electrolysers
Sep 2005
Publication
Hydrogen-producing high-pressure electrolysers operating with 40% potassium hydroxide solution and an applied oxygen pressure up to 30 barg have been developed. Austenitic stainless steels of type AISI316L are deemed resistant to stress corrosion cracking (SCC) in concentrated KOH solutions. However SCC has on some occasions been observed on the oxygen side of the high-pressure electrolysers thereby representing a safety risk in the operation. Several materials have been tested for resistance to SCC using C-ring specimens in autoclaves under conditions similar to the high-pressure electrolysers and at temperatures up to 120°C. The tests confirmed the observed susceptibility of austenitic stainless steels to SCC in concentrated KOH solutions. Higher alloyed austenitic stainless steels also showed SCC. Duplex stainless steel and nickel based Alloy 28 showed good resistance to SCC in the given environment. Further tests are needed to define the optimum weld procedure.
Features of the Hydrogen-Assisted Cracking Mechanism in the Low-Carbon Steel at Ex- and In-situ Hydrogen Charging
Dec 2018
Publication
Hydrogen embrittlement has been intensively studied in the past. However its governing mechanism is still under debate. Particularly the details of the formation of specific cleavage-like or quasi-cleavage fracture surfaces related to hydrogen embrittled steels are unclear yet. Recently it has been found that the fracture surface of the hydrogen charged and tensile tested low-carbon steel exhibits quasi-cleavage facets having specific smoothly curved surface which is completely different from common flat cleavage facets. In the present contribution we endeavor to shed light on the origin of such facets. For this purpose the notched flat specimens of the commercial low carbon steel were tensile tested using ex- and in-situ hydrogen charging. It is found that in the ex-situ hydrogen charged specimens the cracks originate primarily inside the specimen bulk and expand radially form the origin to the specimen surface. This process results in formation of “fisheyes” – the round-shape areas with the surface composed of curved quasi-cleavage facets. In contrast during tensile testing with in-situ hydrogen charging the cracks initiate from the surface and propagate to the bulk. This process results in the formation of the completely brittle fracture surface with the quasi-cleavage morphology - the same as that in fisheyes. The examination of the side surface of the in-situ hydrogen charged specimens revealed the straight and S-shaped sharp cracks which path is visually independent of the microstructure and crystallography but is strongly affected by the local stress fields. Nano-voids are readily found at the tips of these cracks. It is concluded that the growth of such cracks occurs by the nano-void coalescence mechanism and is responsible for the formation of fisheyes and smoothly curved quasi-cleavage facets in hydrogen charged low-carbon steel.
An Innovative and Comprehensive Approach for the Consequence Analysis of Liquid Hydrogen Vessel Explosions
Oct 2020
Publication
Hydrogen is one of the most suitable solutions to replace hydrocarbons in the future. Hydrogen consumption is expected to grow in the next years. Hydrogen liquefaction is one of the processes that allows for increase of hydrogen density and it is suggested when a large amount of substance must be stored or transported. Despite being a clean fuel its chemical and physical properties often arise concerns about the safety of the hydrogen technologies. A potentially critical scenario for the liquid hydrogen (LH2) tanks is the catastrophic rupture causing a consequent boiling liquid expanding vapour explosion (BLEVE) with consequent overpressure fragments projection and eventually a fireball. In this work all the BLEVE consequence typologies are evaluated through theoretical and analytical models. These models are validated with the experimental results provided by the BMW care manufacturer safety tests conducted during the 1990’s. After the validation the most suitable methods are selected to perform a blind prediction study of the forthcoming LH2 BLEVE experiments of the Safe Hydrogen fuel handling and Use for Efficient Implementation (SH2IFT) project. The models drawbacks together with the uncertainties and the knowledge gap in LH2 physical explosions are highlighted. Finally future works on the modelling activity of the LH2 BLEVE are suggested.
Scaling Factors for Channel Width Variations in Tree-like Flow Field Patterns for Polymer Electrolyte Membrane Fuel Cells - An Experimental Study
Apr 2021
Publication
To have a uniform distribution of reactants is an advantage to a fuel cell. We report results for such a distributor with tree-like flow field plates (FFP). Numerical simulations have shown that the width scaling parameters of tree-like patterns in FFPs used in polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cells (PEMFC) reduces the viscous dissipation in the channels. In this study experimental investigations were conducted on a 2-layer FF plate possessing a tree-like FF pattern which was CNC milled on high-quality graphite. Three FF designs of different width scaling parameters were employed. I–V curves power curves and impedance spectra were generated at 70% 60% and 50% relative humidity (25 cm2 active area) and compared to those obtained from a conventional 1-channel serpentine FF. It was found that the FF design with a width scaling factor of 0.917 in the inlet and 0.925 in the outlet pattern exhibited the best peak power out of the three designs (only 11% - 0.08 W/cm2 lower than reference serpentine FF). Results showed that a reduction of the viscous dissipation in the flow pattern was not directly linked to a PEMFC performance increase. It was found that water accumulation together with a slight increase in single PEMFC resistance were the main reasons for the reduced power density. As further improvements a reduction of the number of branching generation levels and width scaling factor were recommended.
Hydrogen Enhanced Fatigue Crack Growth Rates in a Ferritic Fe-3wt%Si Alloy
Dec 2018
Publication
It is well known that ferrous materials can be damaged by absorption of hydrogen. If a sufficient quantity of hydrogen penetrates into the material static fracture and the material's fatigue performances can be affected negatively in particular causing an increase in the material crack growth rates. The latter is often referred as Hydrogen Affected-Fatigue Crack Growth Rate (HA-FCGR). It is therefore of paramount importance to quantify the impact in terms of hydrogen induce fatigue crack growth acceleration in order to determine the life of components exposed to hydrogen and avoid unexpected catastrophic failures. In this study in-situ fatigue crack growth rate testing on Compact Tension (CT) specimens were carried out to determine the fatigue crack growth behaviour for a Fe-3 wt%Si alloy and X70 pipeline steel. Tests were carried out in two environmental conditions i.e. laboratory air and in-situ electrochemically charged hydrogen and different mechanical conditions in terms of load ratio (R = 0.1 and R = 0.5 for the Fe-3 wt%Si R = 0.1 for the X70 steel) and test frequency (f = 0.1 Hz 1 Hz and 10 Hz) were adopted under electrochemically charged hydrogen conditions. The results show a clear detrimental effect of H for the specimens tested in hydrogen when compared to the specimens tested in air for both materials and that the impact of hydrogen is test frequency-dependent: the hydrogen induced acceleration is more prominent as the frequency is decreased. Post-mortem surface investigations consistently relate the global crack growth acceleration to a shift from transgranular to Quasi-cleavage fracture mechanism. Despite such consistency the acceleration factor strongly depends on the material: Fe-3wt%Si features acceleration up to 1000 times while X70 accelerates up to 76 times when compare to the material fatigue crack growth rate recorded in air. Observation of the deformation activities in the crack wake in relation to the transition into hydrogen accelerated regime in fatigue crack growth show a tendency toward restricted plastic activity in presence of hydrogen.
Recent Progress and Approaches on Transition Metal Chalcogenides for Hydrogen Production
Dec 2021
Publication
Development of efficient and affordable photocatalysts is of great significance for energy production and environmental sustainability. Transition metal chalcogenides (TMCs) with particle sizes in the 1–100 nm have been used for various applications such as photocatalysis photovoltaic and energy storage due to their quantum confinement effect optoelectronic behavior and their stability. In particular TMCs and their heterostructures have great potential as an emerging inexpensive and sustainable alternative to metal-based catalysts for hydrogen evolution. Herein the methods used for the fabrication of TMCs characterization techniques employed and the different methods of solar hydrogen production by using different TMCs as photocatalyst are reviewed. This review provides a summary of TMC photocatalysts for hydrogen production.
Hydrogen Fuelling Station, CEP-Berlin – Safety Risk Assessment and Authority Approval Experience and Lessons Learned
Sep 2005
Publication
The CEP (Clean Energy Partnership) – Berlin is one of the most diversified hydrogen demonstration projects at present. The first hydrogen fuelling station serving 16 cars is fully integrated in an ordinary highly frequented Aral service station centrally located at Messedamm in Berlin. Hydro has supplied and is the owner of the electrolyser with ancillary systems. This unit produces gaseous hydrogen at 12 bar with use of renewable energy presently serving 13 of the cars involved. The CEP project is planned to run for a period of five years and is supported by the German Federal Government and is part of the German sustainability strategy. During the planning and design phase there have been done several safety related assessments and analyses:
- Hydro has carried out a HAZOP (HAZard and OPerability) analysis of the electrolyser and ancillary systems delivered by Hydro Electrolysers.
- Hydro arranged with support from the partners a HAZOP analysis of the interface between the electrolyser and the compressor an interface with two different suppliers on each side.
- A QRA (Quantitative Risk Assessment) of the entire fuelling station has been carried out.
- Hydro has carried out a quantitative explosion risk analysis of the electrolyser container supplied by Hydro Electrolysers.
Dynamic Load Analysis of Explosion in Inhomogeneous Hydrogen-air Mixtures
Sep 2017
Publication
This paper presents results from experiments on gas explosions in inhomogeneous hydrogen-air mixtures. The experimental channel is 3 m with a cross section of 100 mm by 100 mm and a 0.25 mm ID nozzle for hydrogen release into the channel. The channel is open in one end. Spectral analysis of the pressure in the channel is used to determine dynamic load factors for SDOF structures. The explosion pressures in the channel will fluctuate with several frequencies or modes and a theoretical high DLF is seen when the pressure frequencies and eigen frequencies of the structure matches.
PIV-measurements of Reactant Flow in Hydrogen-air Explosions
Sep 2017
Publication
The paper present the work on PIV-measurements of reactant flow velocity in front of propagating flames in hydrogen-air explosions. The experiments was performed with hydrogen-air mixture at atmospheric pressure and room temperature. The experimental rig was a square channel with 45 × 20 mm2 cross section 300 mm long with a single cylindrical obstacle of blockage ratio 1/3. The equipment used for the PIV-measurements was a Firefly diode laser from Oxford lasers Photron SA-Z high-speed camera and a particle seeder producing 1 μm droplets of water. The gas concentrations used in the experiments was 14 and 17 vol% hydrogen in air. The resulting explosion can be characterized as slow since the maximum flow velocity of the reactants was 13 m/s in the 14% mixture and 23 m/s in the 17% mixture. The maximum flow velocities was measured during the flame-vortex interaction and at two obstacle diameters behind the obstacle. The flame-vortex interaction contributed to the flame acceleration by increasing the overall reaction rate and the flow velocity. The flame area as a function of position is the same for both concentrations as the flame passes the obstacle.
A Study of Hydrogen Flame Length with Complex Nozzle Geometry
Sep 2017
Publication
The growing number of hydrogen fillings stations and cars increases the need for accurate models to determine risk. The effect on hydrogen flame length was measured by varying the diameter of the spouting nozzle downstream from the chocked nozzle upstream. The results was compared with an existing model for flame length estimations. The experimental rig was setup with sensors that measured accurately temperature mass flow heat radiation and the pressure range from 0.1 to 11 MPa. The flame length was determined with an in-house developed image-processing tool which analyzed a high-speed film of the each experiment. Results show that the nozzle geometry can cause a deviation as high as 50% compared to estimated flame lengths by the model if wrong assumptions are made. Discharge coefficients for different nozzles has been calculated and presented.
Fire Tests Carried Out in FCH JU FIRECOMP Project, Recommendations and Application to Safety of Gas Storage Systems
Sep 2017
Publication
In the event of a fire composite pressure vessels behave very differently from metallic ones: the material is degraded potentially leading to a burst without significant pressure increase. Hence such objects are when necessary protected from fire by using thermally-activated devices (TPRD) and standards require testing cylinder and TPRD together. The pre-normative research project FireComp aimed at understanding better the conditions which may lead to burst through testing and simulation and proposed an alternative way of assessing the fire performance of composite cylinders. This approach is currently used by Air Liquide for the safety of composite bundles carrying large amounts of hydrogen gas.
Implementing Maritime Battery-electric and Hydrogen Solutions: A Technological Innovation Systems Analysis
Sep 2020
Publication
Maritime transport faces increasing pressure to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions to be in accordance with the Paris Agreement. For this to happen low- and zero-carbon energy solutions need to be developed. In this paper we draw on sustainability transition literature and introduce the technological innovation system (TIS) framework to the field of maritime transportation research. The TIS approach analytically distinguishes between different innovation system functions that are important for new technologies to develop and diffuse beyond an early phase of experimentation. This provides a basis for technology-specific policy recommendations. We apply the TIS framework to the case of battery-electric and hydrogen energy solutions for coastal maritime transport in Norway. Whereas both battery-electric and hydrogen solutions have developed rapidly the former is more mature and has a strong momentum. Public procurement and other policy instruments have been crucial for developments to date and will be important for these technologies to become viable options for shipping more generally.
Pressure Peaking Phenomena: Unignited Hydrogen Releases in Confined Spaces – Large-scale Experiments
Sep 2020
Publication
The aim of this study was to validate a model for predicting overpressure arising from accidental hydrogen releases in areas with limited ventilation. Experiments were performed in a large-scale setup that included a steel-reinforced container of volume 14.9 m3 and variable ventilation areas and mass flow rates. The pressure peaking phenomenon characterized as transient overpressure with a characteristic peak in a vented enclosure was observed during all the experiments. The model description presented the relationship between the ventilation area mass flow rate enclosure volume and discharge coefficient. The experimental results were compared with two prediction models representing a perfect mix and the real mix. The perfect mix assumed that all the released hydrogen was well stirred inside the enclosure during the releases. The real mix prediction s used the hydrogen concentration and temperature data measured during experiments. The prediction results with both perfect mix and real mix showed possible hazards during unignited hydrogen releases.
No more items...