France
Comparison of Battery Electric Vehicles and Fuel Cell Vehicles
Sep 2023
Publication
In the current context of the ban on fossil fuel vehicles (diesel and petrol) adopted by several European cities the question arises of the development of the infrastructure for the distribution of alternative energies namely hydrogen (for fuel cell electric vehicles) and electricity (for battery electric vehicles). First we compare the main advantages/constraints of the two alternative propulsion modes for the user. The main advantages of hydrogen vehicles are autonomy and fast recharging. The main advantages of battery-powered vehicles are the lower price and the wide availability of the electricity grid. We then review the existing studies on the deployment of new hydrogen distribution networks and compare the deployment costs of hydrogen and electricity distribution networks. Finally we conclude with some personal conclusions on the benefits of developing both modes and ideas for future studies on the subject.
Experimental Characterization of the Operational Behavior of a Catalytic Recombiner for Hydrogen Mitigation
Sep 2023
Publication
One of the significant safety concerns in large-scale storage and transportation of liquefied (cryogenic) hydrogen (LH2) is the formation of flammable hydrogen/air mixtures after leakages during storage or transportation. Especially in maritime transportation hydrogen accumulations could occur within large and congested geometries. The installation of passive auto-catalytic recombiners (PARs) is a suitable mitigation measure for local areas where venting is insufficient or even impossible. Numerical models describing the operational behavior of PARs are required to allow for optimizing the location and assessing the efficiency of the mitigation measure. In the present study the operational behavior of a PAR with a compact design has been experimentally investigated. In order to obtain data for model validation an experimental program has been performed in the REKO-4 facility a 5.5 m³ vessel. The test procedure includes two phases steady-state and dynamic. The results provide insights into the hydrogen recombination rates and catalyst temperatures under different boundary conditions.
Simulations of Hydrogen Dispersion from Fuel Cell Vehicles' Leakages Inside Full-scale Tunnel
Sep 2023
Publication
In this work real scale experiments involving hydrogen dispersion inside a road tunnel have been modelled using the Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) methodology. The aim is to assess the performance of the ADREA-HF CFD tool against full-scale tunnel dispersion data resulting from high-pressure hydrogen leakage through Thermal Pressure Relief Device (TPRD) of a vehicle. The assessment was performed with the help of experiments conducted by the French Alternative Energies and Atomic Energy Commission (CEA) in a real inclined tunnel in France. In the experiments helium as hydrogen surrogate has been released from 200 bar storage pressure. Several tests were carried out examining different TPRD sizes and release directions (upwards and downwards). For the CFD evaluation two tests were considered: one with downwards and one with upwards release both through a TPRD with a diameter of 2 mm. The comparison between the CFD results and the experiments shows the good predictive capabilities of the ADREA-HF code that can be used as a safety tool in hydrogen dispersion studies. The comparison reveals some of the strengths and weaknesses of both the CFD and the experiments. It is made clear that CFD can contribute to the design of the experiments and to the interpretation of the experimental results.
Instances of Safety-Related Advances in Hydrogen as Regards Its Gaseous Transport and Buffer Storage and Its Solid-State Storage
Jul 2024
Publication
As part of the ongoing transition from fossil fuels to renewable energies advances are particularly expected in terms of safe and cost-effective solutions. Publicising instances of such advances and emphasising global safety considerations constitute the rationale for this communication. Knowing that high-strength steels can prove economically relevant in the foreseeable future for transporting hydrogen in pipelines by limiting the pipe wall thickness required to withstand high pressure one advance relates to a bench designed to assess the safe transport or renewableenergy-related buffer storage of hydrogen gas. That bench has been implemented at the technology readiness level TRL 6 to test initially intact damaged or pre-notched 500 mm-long pipe sections with nominal diameters ranging from 300 to 900 mm in order to appropriately validate or question the use of reputedly satisfactory predictive models in terms of hydrogen embrittlement and potential corollary failure. The other advance discussed herein relates to the reactivation of a previously fruitful applied research into safe mass solid-state hydrogen storage by magnesium hydride through a new public–private partnership. This latest development comes at a time when markets have started driving the hydrogen economy bearing in mind that phase-change materials make it possible to level out heat transfers during the absorption/melting and solidification/desorption cycles and to attain an overall energy efficiency of up to 80% for MgH2 -based compacts doped with expanded natural graphite.
Risk Management in a Containerized Metal Hydride Storage System
Sep 2023
Publication
HyCARE project supported by the Clean Hydrogen Partnership of the European Union deals with a prototype of hydrogen storage tank using a solid-state hydrogen carrier. Up to 40 kilograms of hydrogen are stored in twelve tanks at less than 50 barg and less than 100 °C. The innovative design is based on a standard twenty-foot container including twelve TiFe-based metal hydride (MH) hydrogen storage tanks coupled with a thermal energy storage in phase change materials (PCM). This article aims at showing the main risks related to hydrogen storage in a MH system and the safety barriers considered based on HyCARE’s specific risk analysis.<br/>Regarding the TiFe MH material used to store hydrogen experimental tests showed that the exposure of the MH to air or water did not cause spontaneous ignition. Furthermore an explosion within the solid MH cannot propagate due to internal pore size. Additionally in case of leakage the speed of hydrogen desorption from the MH is self-limited which is an important safety characteristic since it reduces the potential consequences from the hydrogen release scenario.<br/>Regarding the integrated system the critical scenarios identified during the risk analysis were: explosion due to release of hydrogen inside or outside the container internal explosion inside MH tanks due to accidental mix of hydrogen and air and asphyxiation due to inert gas accumulation in the container. This identification phase of the risk analysis allowed to pinpoint the most relevant safety barriers already in place and recommend additional ones if needed to further reduce the risk that were later implemented.<br/>The main safety barriers identified were: material and component selection (including the MH selected) safety interlocks safety valves ventilation gas detection and safety distances.<br/>The risk management process based on risk identification and assessment contributed to coherently integrate inherently safe design features and safety barriers.
Decarbonization with Induced Technical Change: Exploring the Niche Potential of Hydrogen in Heavy Transportation
Jan 2024
Publication
Fuel cells and electric batteries are competing technologies for the energy transition in heavy transportation. We explore the conditions for the survival of a unique technology in the long term. Learning by doing suggests focusing on a single technology while differentiation and decreasing return to scale (cost convexity) favor diversification. Exogenous technical change also plays a role. The interaction between these factors is analyzed in a general model. It is proved that in absence of convexity and exogenous technical change only one technology is used for the whole transition. We then apply this framework to analyze the competition between fuel-cell electric buses (FCEBs) and battery electric buses (BEB) in the European bus sector. There are both learning by doing and exogenous technical change. The model is calibrated and solved. It is shown that the existence of a niche for FCEBs critically depends on the speed at which cost reductions are achieved. The speed depends both on the size of the niche and the rate of learning by doing for FCEBs. Public policies to decentralize the socially optimal trajectory in terms of taxes (carbon) and subsidies (learning by doing) are derived.
Experimental Investigation of Fluid-structure Interaction in the Case of Hydrogen/Air Detonation Impacting a Thin Plate
Sep 2023
Publication
In recent years the use and development of hydrogen as a carbon-free energy carrier have grown. However as hydrogen is flammable with air safety issues are raised. In the case of ignition especially in confined space the flame can accelerate and reach the detonation regime causing severe structural damage [1].<br/>To assess these safety issues it is required to understand the fluid-structure interaction in the case of a detonation impacting a deformable structure and to quantify and model this interaction [2]. At the CEA (Commissariat à l’énergie atomique et aux energies alternatives) a combustion tube experimental facility [3] for studying the fluid-structure interaction in the case of hydrogen combustion has been developed. Several Photomultipliers and Pressure sensors are placed along the tube to monitor the flame acceleration and the detonation location. A fluid-structure interaction (FSI) module or a non-deformable flange can be placed at the end of the tube. Post-processing of the sensor’s signal will provide insight into the occurring phenomena inside the tube.<br/>Several experimental campaigns have been conducted with various initial conditions and configurations at the end of the tube. In this contribution the experiments resulting in a detonation are presented. First the recorded pressure and velocities will be compared to theoretical values coming from combustion models [4] [5]. Secondly the impulse before and after reflection for thin plate and non-deformable flange will be compared to quantify the energy transmitted to the plate and the influence of the fluid-structure interaction on the reflected shock.
The Regulatory Framework of Geological Storage of Hydrogen in Salt Caverns
Sep 2023
Publication
A growing share of renewable energy production in the energy supply systems is key to reaching the European political goal of zero CO2 emission in 2050 highlighted in the green deal. Linked to the irregular production of solar and wind energies which have the highest potential for development in Europe massive energy storage solutions are needed as energy buffers. The European project HyPSTER [1] (Hydrogen Pilot STorage for large Ecosystem Replication) granted by the Clean Hydrogen Partnership addresses this topic by demonstrating a cyclic test in an experimental salt cavern filled with hydrogen up to 3 tons using hydrogen that is produced onsite by a 1 MW electrolyser. One specific objective of the project is the assessment of the risks and environmental impacts of cyclic hydrogen storage in salt caverns and providing guidelines for safety regulations and standards. This paper highlights the first outcome of the task WP5.5 of the HyPSTER project addressing the regulatory and normative frameworks for the safety of hydrogen storage in salt caverns from some selected European Countries which is dedicated to defining recommendations for promoting the safe development of this industry within Europe.
Safety Margin on the Ductile to Brittle Transition Temperature after Hydrogen Embrittlement on X65 Steel
Jan 2022
Publication
Hydrogen embrittlement is a phenomenon that affects the mechanical properties of steels intended for hydrogen transportation. One affected by this embrittlement is the Ductile to Brittle Transition Temperature (DBTT) which characterizes the change in the failure mode of the steel from ductile to brittle. This temperature is conventionally defined and compared to the operating temperature as an acceptability criterion for codes. Transition temperature does not depend only on the material but also on specimen geometry particularly the thickness. Generally the transition temperature is defined for the conservative reason by Charpy impact test. Standard Charpy specimens are straight beams with a thickness of 10 mm. For thin pipes it is impossible to extract these standard specimens. One uses in this case Mini-Charpy specimens with a reduced thickness due to pipe curvature. This paper aims to quantify the effect of hydrogen embrittlement on the transition temperature of pipe steel (API 5L X65) using two types of Charpy specimens.
Hydrogen and ICEs: Validation of a 3D-CFD Approach for In-cylinder Combustion Simulations of Ultra-lean Mixture with a focus on the combustion regime
Sep 2025
Publication
This paper proposes a numerical setup for 3D-CFD in-cylinder simulations of H2-fuelled internal combustion engines. The flamelet G-equation model based on Verhelst and Damkohler-like ¨ correlations for laminar and turbulent flame speeds respectively is used to reproduce the flame propagation. The validation against experimental data from a homogeneous-mixture port-injection engine enables a focus on combustion simulation by minimising stratification uncertainties. Accurate flame propagation modelling is identified as the main challenge. The results on different operating conditions confirm the predictive capabilities of the framework thanks to the agreement with the experimental pressure traces combustion indicators and flame imaging. Notably combustion rate predictions remain accurate even without considering the flame thermo-diffusive instability as the turbulence effect dominates at the investigated conditions. The combustion regime is analysed by a modified Borghi-Peters diagram and it ranges from flamelet to thin reaction zones. This highlights the numerical setup flexibility which accurately simulates combustion across different regimes.
Risk Management in a Containerized Metal Hydride Storage System
Sep 2024
Publication
HyCARE project supported by the Clean Hydrogen Partnership of the European Union deals with a prototype hydrogen storage tank using a solid-state hydrogen carrier. Up to 40 kilograms of hydrogen are stored in 12 tanks at less than 50 barg and less than 100°C. The innovative design is based on a standard 20-foot container including 12 TiFe-based metal hydride (MH) hydrogen storage tanks coupled with a thermal energy storage in phase change materials (PCM). This article aims at showing the main risks related to hydrogen storage in a MH system and the safety barriers considered based on HyCARE’s specific risk analysis. Regarding the TiFe MH material used to store hydrogen experimental tests showed that the exposure of the MH to air or water did not cause spontaneous ignition. Furthermore an explosion within the solid MH cannot propagate due to internal pore size. Additionally in case of leakage the speed of hydrogen desorption from the MH is self-limited which is an important safety characteristic since it reduces the potential consequences from the hydrogen release. Regarding the integrated system the critical scenarios identified during the risk analysis were explosion due to release of hydrogen inside or outside the container internal explosion inside MH tanks due to accidental mix of hydrogen and air and asphyxiation due to inert gas accumulation in the container. The identification phase of risk analysis identified the most relevant safety barriers already in place and recommended additional ones if needed which were later implemented to further reduce the risk. The main safety barriers identified were material and component selection (including the MH selected) safety interlocks safety valves ventilation gas detection and safety distances. The risk management process based on risk identification and assessment contributed to coherently integrate inherently safe design features and safety barriers.
Review on Ammonia as a Potential Fuel: From Synthesis to Economics
Feb 2021
Publication
Ammonia a molecule that is gaining more interest as a fueling vector has been considered as a candidate to power transport produce energy and support heating applications for decades. However the particular characteristics of the molecule always made it a chemical with low if any benefit once compared to conventional fossil fuels. Still the current need to decarbonize our economy makes the search of new methods crucial to use chemicals such as ammonia that can be produced and employed without incurring in the emission of carbon oxides. Therefore current efforts in this field are leading scientists industries and governments to seriously invest efforts in the development of holistic solutions capable of making ammonia a viable fuel for the transition toward a clean future. On that basis this review has approached the subject gathering inputs from scientists actively working on the topic. The review starts from the importance of ammonia as an energy vector moving through all of the steps in the production distribution utilization safety legal considerations and economic aspects of the use of such a molecule to support the future energy mix. Fundamentals of combustion and practical cases for the recovery of energy of ammonia are also addressed thus providing a complete view of what potentially could become a vector of crucial importance to the mitigation of carbon emissions. Different from other works this review seeks to provide a holistic perspective of ammonia as a chemical that presents benefits and constraints for storing energy from sustainable sources. State-of-the-art knowledge provided by academics actively engaged with the topic at various fronts also enables a clear vision of the progress in each of the branches of ammonia as an energy carrier. Further the fundamental boundaries of the use of the molecule are expanded to real technical issues for all potential technologies capable of using it for energy purposes legal barriers that will be faced to achieve its deployment safety and environmental considerations that impose a critical aspect for acceptance and wellbeing and economic implications for the use of ammonia across all aspects approached for the production and implementation of this chemical as a fueling source. Herein this work sets the principles research practicalities and future views of a transition toward a future where ammonia will be a major energy player.
Fuzzy Logic-Based Energy Management Strategy for Hybrid Fuel Cell Electric Ship Power and Propulsion System
Oct 2024
Publication
The growing use of proton-exchange membrane fuel cells (PEMFCs) in hybrid propulsion systems is aimed at replacing traditional internal combustion engines and reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Effective power distribution between the fuel cell and the energy storage system (ESS) is crucial and has led to a growing emphasis on developing energy management systems (EMSs) to efficiently implement this integration. To address this goal this study examines the performance of a fuzzy logic rule-based strategy for a hybrid fuel cell propulsion system in a small hydrogenpowered passenger vessel. The primary objective is to optimize fuel efficiency with particular attention on reducing hydrogen consumption. The analysis is carried out under typical operating conditions encountered during a river trip. Comparisons between the proposed strategy with other approaches—control based optimization based and deterministic rule based—are conducted to verify the effectiveness of the proposed strategy. Simulation results indicated that the EMS based on fuzzy logic mechanisms was the most successful in reducing fuel consumption. The superior performance of this method stems from its ability to adaptively manage power distribution between the fuel cell and energy storage systems.
Hydrogen Refuelling Station Calibration with a Traceable Gravimetric Standard
Apr 2020
Publication
Of all the alternatives to hydrocarbon fuels hydrogen offers the greatest long-term potential to radically reduce the many problems inherent in fuel used for transportation. Hydrogen vehicles have zero tailpipe emissions and are very efficient. If the hydrogen is made from renewable sources such as nuclear power or fossil sources with carbon emissions captured and sequestered hydrogen use on a global scale would produce almost zero greenhouse gas emissions and greatly reduce air pollutant emissions. The aim of this work is to realise a traceability chain for hydrogen flow metering in the range typical for fuelling applications in a wide pressure range with pressures up to 875 bar (for Hydrogen Refuelling Station - HRS with Nominal Working Pressure of 700 bar) and temperature changes from −40 °C (pre-cooling) to 85 °C (maximum allowed vehicle tank temperature) in accordance with the worldwide accepted standard SAE J2601. Several HRS have been tested in Europe (France Netherlands and Germany) and the results show a good repeatability for all tests. This demonstrates that the testing equipment works well in real conditions. Depending on the installation configuration some systematic errors have been detected and explained. Errors observed for Configuration 1 stations can be explained by pressure differences at the beginning and end of fueling in the piping between the Coriolis Flow Meter (CFM) and the dispenser: the longer the distance the bigger the errors. For Configuration 2 where this distance is very short the error is negligible.
Green Hydrogen Cooperation between Egypt and Europe: The Perspective of Locals in Suez and Port Said
Jun 2024
Publication
Hydrogen produced by renewable energy sources (green hydrogen) is at the centrepiece of European decarbonization strategies necessitating large imports from third countries. Egypt potentially stands out as major production hub. While technical and economic viability are broadly discussed in literature analyses of local acceptance are absent. This study closes this gap by surveying 505 locals in the Suez Canal Economic Zone (Port Said and Suez) regarding their attitudes towards renewable energy development and green hydrogen production. We find overall support for both national deployment and export to Europe. Respondents see a key benefit in rising income thereby strongly underlying the economic argument. Improved trade relationships or improved political relationships are seen as potential benefits of export but as less relevant for engaging in cooperation putting a spotlight on local benefits. Our study suggests that the local population is more positive than negative towards the development and scaling up of green hydrogen projects in Egypt.
Identification of Safety Critical Scenarios of Hydrogen Refueling Stations in a Multifuel Context
Sep 2023
Publication
The MultHyFuel Project funded by the Clean Hydrogen Partnership aims to achieve the effective and safe deployment of hydrogen as a carbon-neutral fuel by developing a common strategy for implementing Hydrogen Refueling Stations (HRS) in a multifuel context. The project hopes to contribute to the harmonisation of existing regulations codes and standards (RCS) by generating practical theoretical and experimental data related to HRS.<br/>This paper presents how a set of safety critical scenarios have been identified from the initial preliminary as well as detailed risk analysis of three different hydrogen refueling station configurations. To achieve this a detailed examination of each potential hazardous phenomenon (DPh) or major accident event at or near the hydrogen dispenser was carried out. Particular attention is paid to the scenarios which could affect third parties external to the refueling station.<br/>The paper presents a methodology subdivided into the following steps:<br/>♦ determination of the consequence level and likelihood of each hazardous phenomenon<br/>♦ the classification of major hazard scenarios for the 3 HRS configurations specifically those arising on the dispensing forecourt;<br/>♦ proposal of example preventative control and/or mitigation barriers that could potentially reduce the probability of occurrence and/ or consequences of safety critical scenarios and hence reducing risks to a tolerable level or to as low as reasonably practicable.
Techno-Economic Potential of Wind-Based Green Hydrogen Production in Djibouti: Literature Review and Case Studies
Aug 2023
Publication
Disputed supply chains inappropriate weather and low investment followed by the Russian invasion of Ukraine has led to a phenomenal energy crisis especially in the Horn of Africa. Accordingly proposing eco-friendly and sustainable solutions to diversify the access of electricity in the Republic of Djibouti which has no conventional energy resources and is completely energy dependent on its neighboring countries has become a must. Therefore the implementation of sustainable renewable and energy storage systems is nationally prioritized. This paper deals for the first time with the exploitation of such an affordable and carbon-free resource to produce hydrogen from wind energy in the rural areas of Nagad and Bara Wein in Djibouti. The production of hydrogen and the relevant CO2 emission reduction using different De Wind D6 Vestas and Nordex wind turbines are displayed while using Alkaline and Proton Exchange Membrane (PEM) electrolyzers. The Bara Wein and Nagad sites had a monthly wind speed above 7 m/s. From the results the Nordex turbine accompanied with the alkaline electrolyzer provides the most affordable electricity production approximately 0.0032 $/kWh for both sites; this cost is about one per hundred the actual imported hydroelectric energy price. Through the ecological analysis the Nordex turbine is the most suitable wind turbine with a CO2 emission reduction of 363.58 tons for Bara Wein compared to 228.76 tons for Nagad. While integrating the initial cost of wind turbine implementation in the capital investment the mass and the levelized cost of the produced green hydrogen are estimated as (29.68 tons and 11.48 $/kg) for Bara Wein with corresponding values of (18.68 tons and 18.25 $/kg) for Nagad.
The Evolution of Green Hydrogen in Renewable Energy Research: Insights from a Bibliometric Perspective
Dec 2024
Publication
Green hydrogen generated from water through renewable energies like solar and wind is a key player in sus tainable energy. It only produces water when used making it a clean energy source. However the inconsistent nature of solar and wind energy highlights the need for storage solutions where green hydrogen is promising. This study uniquely combines green hydrogen (GH) and renewable energy (RE) domains using a comprehensive bibliometric approach covering 2018–2022. It identifies emerging trends collaboration networks and key contributors that shape the global landscape of GH research. Our findings show a significant yearly growth in this research field averaging 93.56 %. The study also identifies China Germany India and Italy as leaders among 76 countries involved in this area. Research trends have shifted from technical details to social and economic factors. Given the increasing global commitment to achieving carbon neutrality understanding the evolution and integration of GH within RE systems is essential for guiding future research policy-making and technology development. The analysis categorizes the research into seven main themes focusing on green hydrogen’s role in energy transition and storage. Other vital topics include improving hydrogen production methods assessing its climate impact examining its environmental benefits and exploring various production techniques like water electrolysis and photocatalysis. Our analysis reveals a 93.56 % annual growth rate in GH research highlighting key challenges in storage integration and policy development and offering a roadmap for future studies. The study highlights areas needing more exploration such as better storage methods integration with existing energy infrastructures risk management and policy development. The advancement of green hydrogen as a sustainable energy solution depends on innovative research international collaboration and supportive policy frameworks.
Engineering Models for Refueling Protocol Development: Validation and Recommendations
Sep 2023
Publication
Fouad Ammouri,
Nicola Benvenuti,
Elena Vyazmina,
Vincent Ren,
Guillaume Lodier,
Quentin Nouvelot,
Thomas Guewouo,
Dorine Crouslé,
Rony Tawk,
Nicholas Hart,
Steve Mathison,
Taichi Kuroki,
Spencer Quong,
Antonio Ruiz,
Alexander Grab,
Alexander Kvasnicka,
Benoit Poulet,
Christopher Kutz and
Martin Zerta
The PRHYDE project (PRotocol for heavy duty HYDrogEn refueling) funded by the Clean Hydrogen partnership aims at developing recommendations for heavy-duty refueling protocols used for future standardization activities for trucks and other heavy duty transport systems applying hydrogen technologies. Development of a protocol requires a validated approach. Due to the limited time and budget the experimental data cannot cover the whole possible ranges of protocol parameters such as initial vehicle pressure and temperature ambient and precooling temperatures pressure ramp refueling time hardware specifications etc. Hence a validated numerical tool is essential for a safe and efficient protocol development. For this purpose engineering tools are used. They give good results in a very reasonable computation time of several seconds or minutes. These tools provide the heat parameters estimation in the gas (volume average temperature) and 1D temperature distribution in the tank wall. The following models were used SOFIL (Air Liquide tool) HyFill (by ENGIE) and H2Fills (open access code by NREL). The comparison of modelling results and experimental data demonstrated a good capability of codes to predict the evolution of average gas temperature in function of time. Some recommendations on model validation for the future protocol development are given.
LES of Turbulent Under-expanded Hydrogen Jet Flames
Sep 2023
Publication
In the frame of hydrogen-powered aircraft Airbus wants to understand all the H2 physics and explore every scenario in order to develop and manufacture safe products operated in a safe environment. Within the framework of a Large Eddy Simulation (LES) methodology for modeling turbulence a comparative numerical study of free under-expanded jet H2/AIR flame is conducted. The investigated geometry consists of straight nozzles with a millimetric diameter fed with pure H2 at upstream pressures ranging from 2 to 10 bar. Numerical results are compared with available experimental measurements such as; temperature signals using thermocouples. LES confirms its prediction capability in terms of shock jet structure and flame length. A particular attention is paid for capturing experimental unstable flame when upstream pressure decreases. Furthermore flame stabilization and flame anchoring are analyzed. Mechanisms of flame stabilization are highlighted for case 1 and stabilization criteria are tested. Finally an ignition map to reach flame stabilization is proposed for each case regarding the literature.
No more items...