France
Overview of International Activities in Hydrogen System Safety in IEA Hydrogen TCP Task 43
Sep 2023
Publication
Safety and reliability have long been recognized as key issues for the development commercialization and implementation of new technologies and infrastructure and hydrogen systems are no exception to this rule. Reliability engineering quantitative risk assessment (QRA) and knowledge exchange each play a key role in proactive addressing safety – before problems happen – and help us learn from problems if they happen. Many international research activities are focusing on both reliability and risk assessment for hydrogen systems. However the element of knowledge exchange is sometimes less visible. To support international collaboration and knowledge exchange the International Energy Agency (IEA) convened a new Technology Collaboration Program “Task 43: Safety and Regulatory Aspects of Emerging Large Scale Hydrogen Energy Applications” started in June 2022. Within Task 43 Subtask E focuses on Hydrogen Systems Safety. This paper discusses the structure of the Hydrogen Systems Safety subtask and the aligned activities and introduces opportunities for future work.
A New Dimensionless Number for Type IV Composite Pressure Vessel Designer to Increase Efficiency and Reduce Cost
Sep 2023
Publication
A new dimensionless number (DN) is proposed in order to evaluate the performance of a high-pressure vessel composite structure. It shows that very few composite part is used at its maximum loading potential during bursting. Today for 70 MPa on-board type IV composite tanks DN values close to 20%. The suggested DN will be a useful indicator for an industrial application. By maximizing the DN at the design phase it is possible to minimize the mass of the composite structure of a CPV to reduce the manufacturing time and cost. To increase the DN as close as possible to 100% it is necessary to succeed in increasing the overall loading of the composite structure to have better oriented fibre. For this it seems necessary to find new processes which make it possible to better orient the fibre.
Simulation of DDT in Obstructed Channels: Wavy Channels vs. Fence-type Obstacles
Sep 2023
Publication
The capabilities of an OpenFOAM solver to reproduce the transition of stoichiometric H2-air mixtures to detonation in obstructed 2-D channels were tested. The process is challenging numerically as it involves the ignition of a flame kernel its subsequent propagation and acceleration interaction with obstacles formation of shock waves ahead and detonation onset (DO). Two different obstacle configurations were considered in 10-mm high × 1-m long channels: (i) wavy walls (WW) that mimic the behavior of fencetype obstacles but prevent abrupt area changes. In this case flame acceleration (FA) is strongly affected by shock-flame interactions and DO often results from the compression of the gas present between the accelerating flame front and a converging section of the channel. (ii) Fence-type (FT) obstacles. In this case FA is driven by the increase in flame surface area as a result of the interaction of the flame front with the unburned gas flow field ahead particularly downstream of obstacles; shock-flame interactions play a role at the later stages of FA and DO takes place upon reflection of precursor shocks from obstacles. The effect of initial pressure p0 = 25 50 and 100 kPa at constant blockage ratio (BR = 0.6) was investigated and compared for both configurations. Results show that for the same initial pressure (p0 = 50 kPa) the obstacle configurations could lead to different final propagation regimes: a quasi-detonation for WW and a choked-flame for FT due to the increased losses for the latter. At p0 = 25 kPa however while both configurations result in choked flames WW seem to exhibit larger velocity deficits than FT due to longer flame-precursor shock distances during quasi-steady propagation and to the increased presence of unburnt mixture downstream of the tip of the flame that homogeneously explodes providing additional support to the propagation of the flame.
Designing an Inherently Safe H2 Infrastructure: Combining Analytical, Experimental, and Numerical Investigations to Optimize H2 Refuelling Stations Safety by Passive Mitigation
Sep 2023
Publication
Natural ventilation is a well-known passive mitigation method to limit hydrogen build-up in confined spaces in case of accidental release [1-3]. In most cases a basic design of H2 infrastructure is adopted and vents installed for natural ventilation are adjusted according to safety targets and constraints of the considered structure. With the growing H2 mobility market the demand for H2 refueling infrastructure in our urban environment is on the rise. In order to meet both safety requirements and societal acceptance the design of such infrastructure is becoming more important. In this study a novel design concept is proposed for the hydrogen refueling station (HRS) by modifying physical structure while keeping safety consideration as the top priority of the concept. In this collaborative project between Air Liquide and the University of Delaware an extensive evaluation was performed on new structures of the processing container and dispenser of HRS by integrating safety protocols via passive means. Through a SWOT analysis combined with the most relevant approaches including analytical engineering models numerical simulations [4] and dedicated experimental trials an optimized design was obtained and its safety enhancement was fully evaluated. A small-scale processing container and an almost full-scale dispenser were built and tested to validate the design concepts by simulating accidental H2 release scenarios and assessing the associated consequences in terms of accumulation and potential flammable volumes formation. A conical dispenser and a V-shaped roof-top processing container which were easy to build and implement were designed and tested for this proof-of-concept study. This unique methodology from conception fundamental analysis investigation and validation through experimental design execution and evaluation is fully described in this study.
Safety Challenges Related to the Use of Hydrogen-Natural Gas Blends in Gas Turbines
Sep 2023
Publication
In a context of the decarbonization of the power sector the gas turbine manufacturers are expected tohandle and burn hydrogen or hydrogen/natural gas mixtures. This evolution is conceptually simple in order to displace CO2 emissions by H2O in the combustion exhaust but raises potential engineering andsafety related questions. Concerning the safety aspect the flammability domain is wider and the laminar flame speed is higher for hydrogen than for natural gas. As a result handling fuels with increased hydrogen concentration should a priori lead to an increased the risk of flammable cloud formation with air and also increase the potential explosion violence.<br/>A central topic for the gas turbine manufacturer is the quantification of the hydrogen fuel content from which the explosion risk increases significantly when compared with the use of natural gas. This work will be focused on a risk study of the fuel supply piping of a gas turbine in a scenario where mixing between fuel and air would occur. The pipes are a few dozens of meters long and show singularities: elbows connections with other lines … They are operated at high temperature and atmospheric or high pressure.<br/>The paper will first highlight through CFD modelling the impact of increasing hydrogen content in the fuel on the explosion risk based on a geometry representative of a realistic system. Second the quantification of the explosion effects will be addressed. Some elements of the bibliography relative to flame propagation in pipes will be recalled and put in sight of the characteristics of the industrial case. Finally a CFD model proposed recently for accounting for methane or hydrogen flames propagating in long open steel tubes was used to assess a hydrogen fuel content from which the flame can strongly accelerate and generate significative pressure effects for a flammable mixture initially at atmospheric conditions.
Design of Gravimetric Primary Standards for Field-testing of Hydrogen Refuelling Stations
Apr 2020
Publication
The Federal Institute of Metrology METAS developed a Hydrogen Field Test Standard (HFTS) that can be used for field verification and calibration of hydrogen refuelling stations. The testing method is based on the gravimetric principle. The experimental design of the HFTS as well as the description of the method are presented here.
A Comparative Study on Energy Efficiency of the Maritime Supply Chains for Liquefied Hydrogen, Ammonia, Methanol and Natural Gas
Jun 2023
Publication
To cope with climate change emerging fuels- hydrogen ammonia and methanol- have been proposed as promising energy carriers that will replace part of the liquefied natural gas (LNG) in future maritime scenarios. Energy efficiency is an important indicator for evaluating the system but the maritime supply system for emerging fuels has yet to be revealed. In this study the energy efficiency of the maritime supply chain of hydrogen ammonia methanol and natural gas is investigated considering processes including production storage loading transport and unloading. A sensitivity analysis of parameters such as ambient temperature storage time pipeline length and sailing time is also carried out. The results show that hydrogen (2.366%) has the highest daily boil-off gas (BOG) rate and wastes more energy than LNG (0.413%) with ammonia and methanol both being lower than LNG. The recycling of BOG is of great importance to the hydrogen supply chain. When produced from renewable energy sources methanol (98.02%) is the most energy efficient followed by ammonia with hydrogen being the least (89.10%). This assessment shows from an energy efficiency perspective that ammonia and methanol have the potential to replace LNG as the energy carrier of the future and that hydrogen requires efficient BOG handling systems to increase competitiveness. This study provides some inspirations for the design of global maritime supply systems for emerging fuels.
Experiments and Simulations of Large Scale Hydrogen-Nitrogen-Air Gas Explosions for Nuclear and Hydrogen Safety Applications
Sep 2023
Publication
Hydrogen safety is a general concern because of the high reactivity compared to hydrocarbon-based fuels. The strength of knowledge in risk assessments related to the physical phenomena and the ability of models to predict the consequence of accidental releases is a key aspect for the safe implementation of new technologies. Nuclear safety considers the possibility of accidental leakages of hydrogen gas and subsequent explosion events in risk analysis. In many configurations the considered gaseous streams involve a large fraction of nitrogen gas mixed with hydrogen. This work presents the results of a large scale explosion experimental campaign for hydrogen-nitrogen-air mixtures. The experiments were performed in a 50 m3 vessel at Gexcon’s test site in Bergen Norway. The nitrogen fraction the equivalence ratio and the congestion level were investigated. The experiments are simulated in the FLACS-CFD software to inform about the current level of conservatism of the predictions for engineering application purposes. The study shows the reduced overpressure with nitrogen added to hydrogen mixtures and supports the use of FLACS-CFD-based risk analysis for hydrogen-nitrogen scenarios.
Knowledge Production in Technological Innovation System: A Comprehensive Evaluation using a Multi-criteria Framework based on Patent Data - A Case Study on Hydrogen Storage
Jan 2025
Publication
Knowledge production activity is central within a technological innovation system. The number of patent ap plications is commonly used to evaluate this activity. However it is subject to bias and inaccurate evaluations can occur. This article proposes a multi-criteria framework based on seven complementary patent indicators taking into account the persistence commitment and coherence of knowledge production activities for a more comprehensive evaluation. We demonstrate the value of our proposal through a case study on hydrogen storage comparing patent data since 2000 about three technological solutions: physical chemical and adsorption technologies. Our framework clearly shows that physical hydrogen storage is the most advanced in terms of knowledge production despite not having the highest number of patent applications.
The Impact of Methane Leakage on the Role of Natural Gas in the European Energy Transition
Sep 2023
Publication
Decarbonising energy systems is a prevalent topic in the current literature on climate change mitigation but the additional climate burden caused by methane emissions along the natural gas value chain is rarely discussed at the system level. Considering a two-basket greenhouse gas neutrality objective (both CO2 and methane) we model cost-optimal European energy transition pathways towards 2050. Our analysis shows that adoption of best available methane abatement technologies can entail an 80% reduction in methane leakage limiting the additional environmental burden to 8% of direct CO2 emissions (vs. 35% today). We show that while renewable energy sources are key drivers of climate neutrality the role of natural gas strongly depends on actions to abate both associated CO2 and methane emissions. Moreover clean hydrogen (produced mainly from renewables) can replace natural gas in a substantial proportion of its end-uses satisfying nearly a quarter of final energy demand in a climate-neutral Europe.
IEA TCP Task 43 - Subtask Safety Distances: State of the Art
Sep 2023
Publication
The large deployment of hydrogen technologies for new applications such as heat power mobility and other emerging industrial utilizations is essential to meet targets for CO2 reduction. This will lead to an increase in the number of hydrogen installations nearby local populations that will handle hydrogen technologies. Local regulations differ and provide different safety and/or separation distances in different geographies. The purpose of this work is to give an insight on different methodologies and recommendations developed for hydrogen (mainly) risk management and consequences assessment of accidental scenarios. The first objective is to review available methodologies and to identify the divergent points on the methodology. For this purpose a survey has been launched to obtain the needed inputs from the subtask participants. The current work presents the outcomes of this survey highlighting the gaps and suggesting the prioritization of the actions to take to bridge these gaps.
Detailed Assessment of Dispersion for High-pressure H2 in Multi-fuel Environment
Sep 2023
Publication
The MultHyFuel project notably aims to produce the data missing for usable risk analysis and mitigation activity for Hydrogen Refuelling Stations (HRS) in a multi-fuel context. In this framework realistic releases of hydrogen that could occur in representative multi-fuel forecourts were studied. These releases can occur inside or outside fuel dispensers and they can interact with a complex environment notably made of parked cars and trucks. This paper is focused on the most critical scenarios that were addressed by a sub-group through the use of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) modelling. Once the corresponding source terms for hydrogen releases were known two stages are followed:<br/>♦ Model Validation – to evaluate the CFD models selected by the task partners and to evaluate their performance through comparison to experimental data.<br/>♦ Realistic Release Modelling – to perform demonstration simulations of a range of critical scenarios.<br/>The CFD models selected for the Model Validation have been tested against measured data for a set of experiments involving hydrogen releases. Each experiment accounts for physical features that are encountered in the realistic cases. The selected experiments include an under-expanded hydrogen jet discharging into the open atmosphere with no obstacles or through an array of obstacles. Additionally a very different set-up was studied with buoyancy-driven releases inside a naturally ventilated enclosure. The results of the Model Validation exercise show that the models produce acceptable solutions when compared to measured data and give confidence in the ability of the models and the modellers to capture the behaviour of the realistic releases adequately. The Realistic Release Modelling phase will provide estimation of the flammable gas cloud volume for a set of critical scenarios and will be described at the second stage.
Hydrogen Energy Storage: New Techno-economic Emergence Solution Analysis
Aug 2015
Publication
The integration of various renewable energy sources as well as the liberalization of electricity markets are established facts in modern electrical power systems. The increased share of renewable sources within power systems intensifies the supply variability and intermittency. Therefore energy storage is deemed as one of the solutions for stabilizing the supply of electricity to maintain generation-demand balance and to guarantee uninterrupted supply of energy to users. In the context of sustainable development and energy resources depletion the question of the growth of renewable energy electricity production is highly linked to the ability to propose new and adapted energy storage solutions. The purpose of this multidisciplinary paper is to highlight the new hydrogen production and storage technology its efficiency and the impact of the policy context on its development. A comprehensive techno/socio/economic study of long term hydrogen based storage systems in electrical networks is addressed. The European policy concerning the different energy storage systems and hydrogen production is explicitly discussed. The state of the art of the techno-economic features of the hydrogen production and storage is introduced. Using Matlab-Simulink for a power system of rated 70 kW generator the excess produced hydrogen during high generation periods or low demand can be sold either directly to the grid owners or as filled hydrogen bottles. The affordable use of Hydrogen-based technologies for long term electricity storage is verified.
A New Method to Quantify the Leakage Scenarios (Frequencies and Flowrates) on Hydrogen High Pressure Components
Sep 2023
Publication
This work is part of the MULTHYFUEL E.U. research program [1] aiming at enabling the implementation of hydrogen dispersers in refuelling stations. One important challenge is the severity of accidents due to a leakage of hydrogen from a dispenser in the forecourt. The work presented in this paper deals with the quantification of the leakage scenarios in terms of frequencies and severities. The risk analysis exercise although performed by experts showed very large discrepancies between the frequencies of leakages of the same categories and even between the consequences. A large part of the disagreement comes from the failure databases chosen as shown in the paper. The mismatch between the components on which the databases have been settled and the actual hydrogen components may be responsible for this situation. However as it stands limited confidence can be laid on the outcome of the risk analysis.<br/>A new method is being developed to calculate the frequencies of the leakage and the flowrate based on an accurate description of each component and of each hazardous situation. For instance the possibility for a fitting to become untight due to pressure cycling is modelled based on the contact mechanics. Human errors can also be introduced by describing the tasks. In addition of the description of the method the application to a disperser is proposed with some comparison to experiments. One of the outcomes is that leakage cross sections can be much larger than expected.
Assessing the Impacts of Net Zero Transport Scenarios in France on Biomass Resources, Hydrogen and Electricity Consumption
May 2025
Publication
The transport sector in France accounts for 30% of national emissions and will require significant decarbonization effort to achieve carbon neutrality in 2050. Various technological solutions from electric vehicles to renewable fuel such as biofuels and e-fuels as well as changes in demand are envisioned to reach this target. We build three technological foresight scenarios and two sufficiency variants mainly based on different readings of the European regulations banning the sale of internalcombustion-engine vehicles and setting Sustainable Aviation Fuel incorporation rates. The transport hydrogen and biomass sectors are modeled in system dynamics to assess the detail impacts of these scenarios on biomass resources and energy consumption. In all scenarios the total electricity demand increases drastically regardless of the technological choices made for the vehicle fleets mainly due to the production of e-fuels for aviation. None of the technological scenarios studied suggest that biomass supply is unfeasible. However in a scenario with low electrification there is a potentially increased dependence on imports for waste oils and fats and competing uses or tensions with other demand sectors may arise over some biomass for anaerobic digestion and lignocellulosic resources. To reduce these potential tensions and the demand for electricity sufficiency measures seem necessary in addition to technological advancements.
A Thermodynamically Consistent Methodology to Develop Predictive Simplified Kinetics for Detonation Simulations
Sep 2023
Publication
The number of species and elementary reactions needed for describing the oxidation of fuels increases with the size of the molecule and in turn the complexity of detailed mechanisms. Although the kinetics for conventional fuels (H2 CH4 C3H8...) are somewhat well-established chemical integration in detonation applications remains a major challenge. Significant efforts have been made to develop reduction techniques that aim to keep the predictive capabilities of detailed mechanisms intact while minimizing the number of species and reactions required. However as their starting point of development is based on homogeneous reactors or ZND profiles reduced mechanisms comprising a few species and reactions are not predictive. The methodology presented here relies on defining virtual chemical species such that the thermodynamic equilibrium of the ZND structure is properly recovered thereby circumventing the need to account for minor intermediate species. A classical asymptotic expression relating the ignition delay time with the reaction rate constant is then used to fit the Arrhenius coefficients targeting computations carried out with detailed kinetics. The methodology was extended to develop a three-step mechanism in which the Arrhenius coefficients were optimized to accurately reproduce the one-dimensional laminar ZND structure and the D−κ curves for slightly-curved quasi-steady detonation waves. Two-dimensional simulations performed with the three-step mechanism successfully reproduce the spectrum of length scales present in soot foils computed with detailed kinetics (i.e. cell regularity and size). Results attest for the robustness of the proposed methodology/approximation and its flexibility to be adapted to different configurations.
Experimental Study of the Mitigation of Hydrogen-Air Explosions by Inhibiting Powder
Sep 2023
Publication
The development of hydrogen production technologies and new uses represents an opportunity to accelerate the ecological transition and create a new industrial sector. However the risks associated with the use of hydrogen must be considered. Mitigation of a hydrogen explosion in an enclosure is partly based on prevention strategies such as detection and ventilation and protection strategies such as explosion venting. Even if applications involving hydrogen probably are most interesting for vented explosions in weak structures the extreme reactivity of hydrogen-air mixtures often excludes the use of regular venting devices such as in highly constrained urban environments. Thus having alternative mitigation solutions can make the effects of the explosion acceptable by reducing the flame speed and the overpressure loading or suppressing the secondary explosion. The objective of this paper is to present experimental studies of the mitigation of hydrogen-air deflagration in a 4 m3 vented enclosure by injection of inhibiting powder (NaHCO₃). After describing the experimental set-up the main experimental results are presented for several trial configurations showing the influence of inhibiting powder in the flammable cloud on flame propagation. An interpretation of the mitigating effect of inhibiting powder on the explosion effects is proposed based on the work of Proust et al.
Performance Comparison of Hydrogen Dispersion Models in Enclosure Adapted to Forced Ventilation
Sep 2023
Publication
In confined spaces hydrogen released with low momentum tends to accumulate in a layer below the ceiling; the concentration in this layer rises and can rapidly enter the flammability range. In this context ventilation is a key safety equipment to prevent the formation of such flammable volumes. To ensure its well-sizing to each specific industrial context it is necessary to dispose of reliable engineering models. Currently the existing engineering models dealing with the buoyancy-driven H2 dispersion in a ventilated enclosure mainly focus on the natural-ventilation phenomenon. However forced ventilation is in some situations more adapted to the industrial context as the wind direction and intensity remains constant and under control. Therefore two existing wind-assisted ventilation models elaborated by Hunt and Linden [1] and Lowesmith et al. [2] were tested on forced ventilation applications. The main assumption consists in assuming a blowing ventilation system rather than a suction system as the composition and velocity of the entering air are known. The fresh air enters the down opening and airhydrogen mixture escapes through the upper one. The adapted models are then validated with experimental data releasing helium rather than hydrogen. Experiments are conducted on a 1-m3 ventilated box controlling the release and ventilation rates. The agreement between both analytical and experimental results is discussed from the different comparisons performed.
Power and Green Hydrogen Trade Potential between North African and European Countries: Conditions, Challenges, and Sustainability Prospects
Dec 2024
Publication
This study investigates the implications of hydrogen demand and trade between Europe and North Africa emphasizing how renewable energy system (RES) capacity limitations impact both regions. Growing hydrogen demand for decarbonization has fueled interest in North Africa’s potential to export green hydrogen to Europe. Using the eTIMES-EUNA model this study examines how demand trade and RES development challenges shape the energy landscapes of both regions. The findings indicate that hydrogen demand amplifies renewable electricity requirements in both regions with Europe particularly benefiting from importing hydrogen to alleviate additional RES capacity installation. Hydrogen trade reduces overall costs by 1 % yet it shifts a considerable financial burden onto North Africa demanding a rapid RES capacity expansion at a rate significantly higher than the current pace. Slower RES development in North Africa could hinder the region’s ability to meet both domestic and export targets thereby complicating Europe’s hydrogen sourcing strategies which are also challenged by social acceptance issues that limit RES deployment. These constraints in Europe necessitate adjustments to the technological mix and place additional pressure on North Africa to increase production. Furthermore the varying implications and stakes at the national level highlight the need for further analysis as individual countries may prioritize their own interests potentially leading to conflicts with neighboring nations under different development schemes. Consequently the results underscore the importance of coordinated financial and policy support to ensure equitable trade that aligns with both regions’ sustainability goals.
Hydrogen Production by Catalytic Supercritical Water Gasification of Black Liquor-Based Wastewater
Apr 2025
Publication
In this work the wastewater obtained from the hydrothermal liquefaction of black liquor was treated and valorized for hydrogen production by supercritical water gasification (SCWG). The influence of the main process parameters on the conversion yield was studied. The experiments were conducted at three different temperatures (below and above the critical point of water): 350 ◦C 450 ◦C and 600 ◦C. The results showed that by increasing the temperature from 350 ◦C to 600 ◦C the total gas yield was highly improved (from 1.9 mol gas/kg of dried feedstock to 13.1 mol gas/kg of dried feedstock). The H2 composition was higher than that of CH4 and CO2 at 600 ◦C and the HHV of the obtained gas was 61.2 MJ/kg. The total organic carbon (TOC) removal efficiency was also improved by increasing the temperature indicating that the SCWG process could be used for both applications: (i) for wastewater treatment; (ii) for producing a high calorific gas. The experiments with the Raney-nickel catalyst were performed in order to study the catalyst’s influence on the conversion yield. The results indicated that the catalyst enhances carbon conversion and gas production from mild to higher temperatures. The maximum total gas yield obtained with this catalyst was 32.4 mol gas/kg of dried feedstock at 600 ◦C which is 2.5 times higher than that obtained at the same operating conditions without a catalyst. The H2 yield and the HHV of the obtained gas with the catalyst were 20.98 mol gas/kg dried feedstock and 80.2 MJ/kg respectively. However the major contribution of the catalytic SCWG process was the improvement of the total gas yield at mild operating temperatures (450 ◦C) and the obtained performance was even higher than that obtained at 600 ◦C without catalyst (17.81 mol gas/kg dried feedstock and 13.1 mol gas/kg dried feedstock respectively). This is a sustainable approach for treating wastewater at mild temperatures by catalytic SCWG.
No more items...