Germany
A Coupled Transient Gas Flow Calculation with a Simultaneous Calorific-value-gradient Improved Hydrogen Tracking
Apr 2022
Publication
Gas systems can provide considerable flexibility in integrated energy systems to accommodate hydrogen produced from Power-to-Hydrogen units using excess volatile renewable energy generation. To use the flexibility in integrated energy systems while ensuring a secure and reliable system operation gas system operators need to accurately and easily analyze the effects of varying hydrogen levels on the dynamic gas behavior and vice versa. Existing methods for hydrogen tracking however either solve the hydrogen propagation and dynamic gas behavior separately or must cope with a large inaccuracy. Hence existing methods do not allow an accurate and coupled analysis of gas systems in integrated energy systems considering varying hydrogen levels. This paper proposes a calorific-value-gradient method which can accurately track the propagation of varying hydrogen levels in a gas system even with large simulation time increments of up to one hour. The new method is joined and simultaneously solved with an implicit finite difference scheme describing the transient gas behavior in a single equation system in a coupled Newton–Raphson gas flow calculation. As larger simulation time increments can be chosen without reducing the accuracy the computation time can be strongly reduced compared to existing Euler-based methods. With its high accuracy and its coupled approach this paper provides gas system operators a method to accurately analyze how the propagation of hydrogen affects the entire gas system. With its coupled approach the presented method can enhance the investigation of integrated energy systems as the transient gas behavior and varying hydrogen propagation of the gas system can be easily included in such analyses.
Explosion Characteristics of Hydrogen-air and Hydrogen-Oxygen Mixtures at Elevated Pressures
Sep 2005
Publication
An essential problem for the operation of high pressure water electrolyzers and fuel cells is the permissible contamination of hydrogen and oxygen. This contamination can create malfunction and in the worst case explosions in the apparatus and gas cylinders. In order to avoid dangerous conditions the exact knowledge of the explosion characteristics of hydrogen/air and hydrogen/oxygen mixtures is necessary. The common databases e.g. the CHEMSAFE® database published by DECHEMA BAM and PTB contains even a large number of evaluated safety related properties among other things explosion limits which however are mainly measured according to standard procedures under atmospheric conditions.<br/>Within the framework of the European research project “SAFEKINEX” and other research projects the explosion limits explosion pressures and rates of pressure rise (KG values) of H2/air and H2/O2 mixtures were measured at elevated conditions of initial pressures and temperatures by the Federal Institute of Materials Research and Testing (BAM). Empirical equations of the temperature influence could be deduced from the experimental values. An anomaly was found at the pressure influence on the upper explosion limits of H2/O2 and H2/air mixtures in the range of 20 bars. In addition explosion pressures and also rates of pressure rises have been measured for different hydrogen concentrations inside the explosion range. Such data are important for constructive explosion protection measures. Furthermore the mainly used standards for the determination of explosion limits have been compared. Therefore it was interesting to have a look at the systematic differences between the new EN 1839 tube and bomb method ASTM E 681-01 and German DIN 51649-1.
Measuring and Modelling Unsteady Radiation of Hydrogen Combustion
Sep 2005
Publication
Burning hydrogen emits thermal radiation in UV NIR and IR spectral range. Especially in the case of large cloud explosion the risk of heat radiation is commonly underestimated due to the non-visible flame of hydrogen-air combustion. In the case of a real explosion accident organic substances or inert dust might be entrained from outer sources to produce soot or heated solids to substantially increase the heat release by continuum radiation. To investigate the corresponding combustion phenomena different hydrogen-air mixtures were ignited in a closed vessel and the combustion was observed with fast scanning spectrometers using a sampling rate up to 1000 spectra/s. In some experiments to take into account the influence of organic co-combustion a spray of a liquid glycol-ester and milk powder was added to the mixture. The spectra evaluation uses the BAM code of ICT to model bands of reaction products and thus to get the temperatures. The code calculates NIR/IR-spectra (1 - 10 μm) of non-homogenous gas mixtures of H2O CO2 CO NO and HCl taking into consideration also emission of soot particles. It is based on a single line group model and makes also use of tabulated data of H2O and CO2 and a Least Squares Fit of calculated spectra to experimental ones enables the estimation of flame temperatures. During hydrogen combustion OH emits an intense spectrum at 306 nm. This intermediary radical allows monitoring the reaction progress. Intense water band systems between 1.2 and 3 μm emit remarkable amounts of heat radiation according to a measured flame temperature of 2000 K. At this temperature broad optically-thick water bands between 4.5 μm and 10 μm contribute only scarcely to the total heat output. In case of co-combustion of organic materials additional emission bands of CO and CO2 as well as a continuum radiation of soot and other particles occur and particularly increase the total thermal output drastically.
Analysis Methodology for Hydrogen Behaviour in Accident Scenarios
Sep 2005
Publication
Hydrogen is not more dangerous than current fossil energy carriers but it behaves differently. Therefore hydrogen specific analyses and countermeasures will be needed to support the development of safe hydrogen technologies. A systematic step-by-step procedure for the mechanistic analysis of hydrogen behaviour and mitigation in accidents is presented. The procedure can be subdivided into four main parts:<br/>1) 3D modelling of the H2-air mixture generation<br/>2) hazard evaluation for this mixture based on specifically developed criteria for flammability flame acceleration and detonation on-set<br/>3) numerical simulation of the appropriate combustion regime using verified 3D-CFD codes and<br/>4) consequence analysis based on the calculated pressure and temperature loads.
Hydrogen Embrittlement at Cleavage Planes and Grain Boundaries in Bcc Iron—Revisiting the First-Principles Cohesive Zone Model
Dec 2020
Publication
Hydrogen embrittlement which severely affects structural materials such as steel comprises several mechanisms at the atomic level. One of them is hydrogen enhanced decohesion (HEDE) the phenomenon of H accumulation between cleavage planes where it reduces the interplanar cohesion. Grain boundaries are expected to play a significant role for HEDE since they act as trapping sites for hydrogen. To elucidate this mechanism we present the results of first-principles studies of the H effect on the cohesive strength of α-Fe single crystal (001) and (111) cleavage planes as well as on the Σ5(310)[001] and Σ3(112)[11¯0] symmetrical tilt grain boundaries. The calculated results show that within the studied range of concentrations the single crystal cleavage planes are much more sensitive to a change in H concentration than the grain boundaries. Since there are two main types of procedures to perform ab initio tensile tests different in whether or not to allow the relaxation of atomic positions which can affect the quantitative and qualitative results these methods are revisited to determine their effect on the predicted cohesive strength of segregated interfaces
Large Scale Experiments- Deflagration and Deflagration to Detonation within a Partial Confinement Similar to a Lane
Sep 2005
Publication
About 20 years ago Fraunhofer ICT has performed large scale experiments with premixed hydrogen air mixtures [1]. A special feature has been the investigation of the combustion of the mixture within a partial confinement simulating some sort of a “lane” which may exist in reality within a hydrogen production or storage plant for example. Essentially three different types of tests have been performed: combustion of quiescent mixtures combustion of mixtures with artificially generated turbulence by means of a fan and combustion of mixtures with high speed flame jet ignition. The observed phenomena will be discussed on the basis of measured turbulence levels flame speeds and overpressures. Conditions for DDT concerning critical turbulence levels and flame speeds as well as a scaling rule for DDT related to the detonation cell size of the mixture can be derived from the experiments for this special test setup. The relevance of the results with respect to safety aspects of future hydrogen technology is assessed. Combustion phenomena will be highlighted by the presentation of impressive high speed film videos.
Hydrogen Onboard Storage: An Insertion of the Probabilistic Approach Into Standards & Regulations?
Sep 2005
Publication
The growing attention being paid by car manufacturers and the general public to hydrogen as a middle and long term energy carrier for automotive purpose is giving rise to lively discussions on the advantages and disadvantages of this technology – also with respect to safety. In this connection the focus is increasingly and justifiably so on the possibilities offered by a probabilistic approach to loads and component characteristics: a lower weight obliged with a higher safety level basics for an open minded risk communication the possibility of a provident risk management the conservation of resources and a better and not misleading understanding of deterministic results. But in the case of adequate measures of standards or regulations completion there is a high potential of additional degrees of freedom for the designers obliged with a further increasing safety level. For this purpose what follows deals briefly with the terminological basis and the aspects of acceptance control conservation of resources misinterpretation of deterministic results and the application of regulations/standards.<br/>This leads into the initial steps of standards improvement which can be taken with relatively simple means in the direction of comprehensively risk-oriented protection goal specifications. By this it’s not focused on to provide to much technical details. It’s focused on the context of different views on probabilistic risk assessment. As main result some aspects of the motivation and necessity for the currently running pre-normative research studies within the 6th frame-work program of the EU will be shown.
The Structure and Flame Propagation Regimes in Turbulent Hydrogen Jets
Sep 2009
Publication
Experiments on flame propagation regimes in a turbulent hydrogen jet with velocity and hydrogen concentration gradients have been performed at the FZK hydrogen test site HYKA. Horizontal stationary hydrogen jets released at normal and cryogenic temperatures of 290K and 80 and 35K with different nozzle diameters and mass flow rates in the range from 0.3 to 6.5 g/s have been investigated. Sampling probe method and laser PIV technique have been used to evaluate distribution of hydrogen concentration and flow velocity along and across the jet axis. High-speed photography (1000 fps) combined with a Background Oriented Schlieren (BOS) system was used for the visual observation of the turbulent flame propagation. In order to investigate different flame propagation regimes the ignition position was changed along the jet axis. It was found that the maximum flame velocity and pressure loads can only occur if the hydrogen concentration at the ignition point exceeds 11% of hydrogen in air. In this case the flame propagates in both directions up- and downstream the jet flow whereas in the opposite case the flame propagates only downstream. Such a behavior is consistent with previous experiments according to that the flame is able to accelerate effectively only if the expansion rate σ of the H2-air mixture is higher than a critical value σ* = 3.75 (like for the 11% hydrogen-air mixture). The measured data allow conservative estimates of the safety distance and risk assessment for realistic hydrogen leaks.
Complex Hydrides as Solid Storage Materials- First Safety Tests
Sep 2007
Publication
Hydrogen technology requires efficient and safe hydrogen storage systems. For this purpose storage in solid materials such as high capacity complex hydrides is studied intensely. Independent from the actual material to be used eventually any tank design will combine nanoscale powders of highly reactive material with pressurized hydrogen gas and so far little is known about the behaviour of these mixtures in case of incidents. For a first evaluation of a complex hydride in case of a tank failure NaAlH4 (doped with Ti) was investigated in a small scale tank failure tests. 80-100 ml of the material were filled into a heat exchanger tube and sealed under argon atmosphere with a burst disk. Subsequently the NaAlH4 was partially desorbed by heating. When the powder temperature reached 130 °C and the burst disk ruptured at 9 bar hydrogen overpressure the behaviour of the expelled powder was monitored using a high speed camera an IR camera as well as sound level meters. Expulsion of the hydrogen storage material into (dry) ambient atmosphere yields a dust cloud of finely dispersed powder which does not ignite spontaneously. Similar experiments including an external source of ignition (spark / water reacting with NaAlH4) yield a flame of reacting powder. The intensity will be compared to the reaction of an equivalent amount of pure hydrogen.
Polymer Composites for Tribological Applications in Hydrogen Environment
Sep 2007
Publication
In the development of hydrogen technology special attention is paid to the technical problems of hydrogen storage. One possible way is cryogenic storage in liquid form. Generally cryo-technical machines need components with interacting surfaces in relative motion such as bearings seals or valves which are subjected to extreme conditions. Materials of such systems have to be resistant to friction-caused mechanical deformation at the surface low temperatures and hydrogen environment. Since materials failure can cause uncontrolled escape of hydrogen new material requirements are involved for these tribo-systems in particular regarding operability and reliability. In the past few years several projects dealing with the influence of hydrogen on the tribological properties of friction couples were conducted at the Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing (BAM) Berlin. This paper reports some investigations carried out with polymer composites. Friction and wear were measured for continuous sliding and analyses of the worn surfaces were performed after the experiments. Tests were performed at room temperature in hydrogen as well as in liquid hydrogen.
An Intercomparison Exercise on the Capabilities of CFD Models to Predict Deflagration of a Large-Scale H2-Air Mixture in Open Atmosphere
Sep 2005
Publication
This paper presents a compilation of the results supplied by HySafe partners participating in the Standard Benchmark Exercise Problem (SBEP) V2 which is based on an experiment on hydrogen combustion that is first described. A list of the results requested from participants is also included. The main characteristics of the models used for the calculations are compared in a very succinct way by using tables. The comparison between results together with the experimental data when available is made through a series of graphs. The results show quite good agreement with the experimental data. The calculations have demonstrated to be sensitive to computational domain size and far field boundary condition.
Thermal Loading Cases of Hydrogen High Pressure Storage Cylinders
Sep 2007
Publication
Composite cylinders with metal liner are used for the storage of compressed hydrogen in automotive application. These hybrid pressure cylinders are designed for a nominal working pressure of up to 70 MPa. They also have to withstand a temperature range between -40°C and +85°C according GRPE draft [1] and for short periods up to a maximum temperature of 140°C during filling (fast filling) [2]. In order to exploit the material properties efficiently with a high degree of lightweight optimization and a high level of safety on the same time a better understanding of the structural behavior of hybrid designs is necessary. Work on this topic has been carried out in the frame of a work package on safety aspects and regulation (Subproject SAR) of the European IP StorHy (www.storhy.net). The temperature influence on the composite layers is distinctive due to there typical polymer material behavior. The stiffness of the composite layer is a function of temperature which influences global strains and stress levels (residual stresses) in operation. In order to do an accurate fatigue assessment of composite hybrid cylinders a realistic modeling of a representative temperature load is needed. For this climate data has been evaluated which were collected in Europe over a period of 30 years [3]. Assuming that the temperature follows a Gaussian (normal) distribution within the assessed period of 30 years it is possible to generate a frequency distribution for different temperature classes for the cold extreme and the hot extreme. Combining these distributions leads to the overall temperature range distribution (frequency over temperature classes). The climatic temperature influence the filling temperature and the pressure load have to be considered in combination with the operation profile of the storage cylinder to derive a complete load vector for an accurate assessment of the lifetime and safety level.
Impact of Hydrogen Admixture on Combustion Processes – Part I: Theory
Jun 2020
Publication
Climate change is one of today’s most pressing global challenges. Since the emission of greenhouse gases is often closely related to the use and supply of energy the goal to avoid emissions requires a fundamental restructuring of the energy system including all parts of the technology chains from production to end-use. Natural gas is today one of the most important primary energy sources in Europe with utilization ranging from power generation and industry to appliances in the residential and commercial sector as well as mobility. As natural gas is a fossil fuel gas utilization is thus responsible for significant emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2 ) a greenhouse gas. However the transformation of the gas sector with its broad variety of technologies and end-use applications is a challenge as a fuel switch is related to changing physical properties. Today the residential and commercial sector is the biggest end user sector for natural gas in the EU both in terms of consumption and in the number of installed appliances. Natural gas is used to provide space heating as well as hot water and is used in cooking and catering appliances with in total about 200 million gas-fired residential and commercial end user appliances installed. More than 40 % of the EU gas consumption is accounted for by the residential and commercial sector. The most promising substitutes for natural gas are biogases and hydrogen. The carbon-free fuel gas hydrogen may be produced e.g. from water and renewable electricity; therefore it can be produced with a greatly lowered carbon footprint and on a very large scale. As a gaseous fuel it can be transported stored and utilised in all end-use sectors that are served by natural gas today: Power plants industry commercial appliances households and mobility. Technologies and materials however need to be suitable for the new fuel. The injection of hydrogen into existing gas distribution for example will impact all gas-using equipment in the grids since these devices are designed and optimized to operate safely efficiently and with low pollutant emissions with natural gas as fuel. The THyGA project1 focusses on all technical aspects and the regulatory framework concerning the potential operation of domestic and commercial end user appliances with hydrogen / natural gas blends. The THyGA deliverables start with theoretical background from material science (D2.4) and combustion theory (this report) and extend to the project’s experimental campaign on hydrogen tolerance tests as well as reports on the status quo and potential future developments on rules and standards as well as mitigation strategies for coping with high levels of hydrogen admixture. By this approach the project aims at investigating which levels of hydrogen blending impact the various appliance technologies to which extent and to identify the regime in which a safe efficient and low-polluting operation is possible. As this is in many ways a question of combustion this report focuses on theoretical considerations about the impact of hydrogen admixture on combustion processes. The effects of hydrogen admixture on main gas quality properties as well as combustion temperatures laminar combustion velocities pollutant formation (CO NOx) safety-related aspects and the impact of combustion control are discussed. This overview provides a basis for subsequent steps of the project e.g. for establishing the testing program. A profound understanding of the impact on hydrogen on natural gas combustion is also essential for the development of mitigation strategies to reduce potential negative consequences of hydrogen admixture on appliances.
This is part one. Part two of this project can be found at this link
This is part one. Part two of this project can be found at this link
Validation of CFD Calculations Against Ignited Impinging Jet Experiments
Sep 2007
Publication
Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) tools have been increasingly employed for carrying out quantitative risk assessment (QRA) calculations in the process industry. However these tools must be validated against representative experimental data in order to have a real predictive capability. As any typical accident scenario is quite complex it is important that the CFD tool is able to predict combined release and ignition scenarios reasonably well. However this kind of validation is not performed frequently primarily due to absence of good quality data. For that reason the recent experiments performed by FZK under the HySafe internal project InsHyde (http://www.hysafe.org) are important. These involved vertically upwards hydrogen releases with different release rates and velocities impinging on a plate in two different geometrical configurations. The dispersed cloud was subsequently ignited and pressures recorded. These experiments are important not only for corroborating the underlying physics of any large-scale safety study but also for validating the important assumptions used in QRA. Blind CFD simulations of the release and ignition scenarios were carried out prior to the experiments to predict the results (and possibly assist in planning) of the experiments. The simulated dispersion results are found to correlate reasonably well with experimental data in terms of the gas concentrations. The overpressures subsequent to ignition obtained in the blind predictions could not be compared directly with the experiments as the ignition points were somewhat different but the pressure levels were found to be similar. Simulations carried out after the experiments with the same ignition position as those in the experiments compared reasonably well with the measurements in terms of the pressure level. This agreement points to the ability of the CFD tool FLACS to model such complex scenarios well. Nevertheless the experimental set-up can be considered to be small-scale and less severe than many accidents and real-life situations. Future large-scale data of this type will be valuable to confirm ability to predict large-scale accident scenarios.
Characterization of Materials in Pressurized Hydrogen Under Cyclic Loading at Service Conditions in Hydrogen Powered Engines
Sep 2005
Publication
A new testing device for cyclic loading of specimens with a novel shape design is presented. The device was applied for investigations of fatigue of metallic specimens under pressurized hydrogen up to 300 bar at temperatures up to 200 °C. Main advantage of the specimen design is the very small amount of medium here hydrogen used for testing. This allows experiments with hazardous substances at lower safety level. Additionally no gasket for the load transmission is required. Woehler curves which show the influence of hydrogen on the fatigue behaviour of austenitic steel specimens at relevant service conditions in hydrogen powered engines are presented. Material and test conditions are in agreement with the cooperating industry.
Methodology of CFD Safety Analysis for Large-Scale Industrial Structures
Sep 2005
Publication
The current work is devoted to problems connected with application of CFD tools for safety analysis of large-scale industrial structures. With the aim to preserve conservatism of overall process of multistage procedure of such analysis special efforts are required. A strategy which has to lead to obtaining of reliable results in CFD analysis is discussed. Different aspects of proposed strategy including: adequate choice of physical and numerical models procedure of validation simulations and problem of ‘under-resolved’ simulations are considered. For physical phenomena which could cause significant uncertainties in the course of scenario simulation an approach which complements CFD simulations by application of auxiliary criteria is presented. Physical basis and applicability of strong flame acceleration and detonation-to-deflagration transition criteria are discussed. In concluding part two examples of application of presented approach for nuclear power plant and workshop cell for hydrogen driven vehicles are presented.
An Intercomparison Exercise on the Capabilities of CFD Models to Predict Distribution and Mixing of H2 in a Closed Vessel.
Sep 2005
Publication
This paper presents a compilation and discussion of the results supplied by HySafe partners participating in the Standard Benchmark Exercise Problem (SBEP) V1 which is based on an experiment on hydrogen release mixing and distribution inside a vessel. Each partner has his own point of view of the problem and uses a different approach to the solution. The main characteristics of the models employed for the calculations are compared. The comparison between results together with the experimental data when available is made. Relative deviations of each model from the experimental values are also included. Explanations and interpretations of the results are presented together with some useful conclusions for future work.
Pool Spreading and Vaporization of Liquid Hydrogen
Sep 2005
Publication
An essential part of a safety analysis to evaluate the risks of a liquid hydrogen (LH2) containing system is the understanding of cryogenic pool spreading and its vaporization. It represents the initial step in an accident sequence with the inadvertent spillage of LH2 e.g. after failure of a transport container tank or the rupture of a pipeline. This stage of an accident scenario provides pertinent information as a source term for the subsequent analysis steps of atmospheric dispersion and at presence of an ignition source the combustion of the hydrogen-air vapor cloud. A computer model LAUV has been developed at the Research Center Juelich which is able to simulate the spreading and vaporization of a cryogenic liquid under various conditions such as different grounds (solid water). It is based on the so-called shallow-layer differential equations taking into account physical phenomena such as ice formation if the cryogen is spilled on a water surface. The presentation will give a description of the computer model and its validation against existing experimental data. Furthermore calculational results will be analyzed describing the prediction and quantification of the consequences of an LH2 spill for different cases. They also include the comparison of an LH2 spillage versus the corresponding release of other cryogens such as liquid natural gas liquid oxygen and liquid nitrogen.
Experimental Study of Jet-formed Hydrogen-air Mixtures and Pressure Loads from their Deflagrations in Low Confined Surroundings
Sep 2007
Publication
To provide more practical data for safety assessments a systematic study of explosion and combustion processes which can take place in mixtures produced by jet releases in realistic environmental conditions is required. The presented work is aimed to make step forward in this direction binding three inter-connected tasks: (i) study of horizontal and vertical jets (ii) study of the burnable clouds formed by jets in different geometry configurations and (iii) examination of combustion and explosion processes initiated in such mixtures. Test matrix for the jet experiments included variation of the release pressure and nozzle diameter with the aim to study details of the resulting hydrogen concentration and velocity profiles depending on the release conditions. In this study the following parameters were varied: mass flow rate jet nozzle diameter (to alter gas speed) and geometry of the hood located on top of the jet. The carried out experiments provided data on detailed structure for under-expanded horizontal and buoyant vertical jets and data on pressure loads resulted from deflagration of various mixtures formed by jet releases. The data on pressures waves generated in the conditions under consideration provides conservative estimation of pressure loads for realistic leaks.
Design of Catalytic Recombiners for Safe Removal of Hydrogen from Flammable Gas Mixtures
Sep 2007
Publication
Several today’s and future applications in energy technology bear the risk of the formation of flammable hydrogen/air mixtures either due to the direct use of hydrogen or due to hydrogen appearing as a by-product. If there’s the possibility of hydrogen being released accidentally into closed areas countermeasures have to be implemented in order to mitigate the threat of an explosion. In the field of nuclear safety passive auto-catalytic recombiners (PAR) are well-known devices for reducing the risk of a hydrogen detonation in a nuclear power plant in the course of a severe accident. Hydrogen and oxygen react on catalyst materials like platinum or palladium already far below conventional flammability limits. The most important concern with regard to the utilization of hydrogen recombiners is the adequate removal of the reaction heat. Already low hydrogen concentrations may increase the system temperature beyond the self-ignition limit of hydrogen/air mixtures and may lead to an unintended ignition on hot parts of the PAR.<br/>Starting from the nuclear application since several years IEF-6 and LRST perform joint research in the field of passive auto-catalytic recombiners including experimental studies modelling and development of new design concepts. Recently approaches on specifically designed catalysts and on passive cooling devices have been successfully tested. In a design study both approaches are combined in order to provide means for efficient and safe removal of hydrogen. The paper summarizes results achieved so far and possible designs for future applications.
No more items...