Safety
Feasibility of Hydrogen Detection by the Use of Uncoated Silicon Microcantilever-based Sensors
Sep 2013
Publication
Hydrogen is a key parameter to monitor radioactive disposal facility such as the envisioned French geological repository for nuclear wastes. The use of microcantilevers as chemical sensors usually involves a sensitive layer whose purpose is to selectively sorb the analyte of interest. The sorbed substance can then be detected by monitoring either the resonant frequency shift (dynamic mode) or the quasi-static deflection (static mode). The objective of this paper is to demonstrate the feasibility of eliminating the need for the sensitive layer in the dynamic mode thereby increasing the long-term reliability. The microcantilever resonant frequency allows probing the mechanical properties (mass density and viscosity) of the surrounding fluid and thus to determine the concentration of a species in a binary gaseous. Promising preliminary work has allowed detecting concentration of 200 ppm of hydrogen in air with non-optimized geometry of silicon microcantilever with integrated actuation and read-out.
Effects of Surface on the Flammable Extent of Hydrogen Jets
Sep 2009
Publication
The effect of surfaces on the extent of high pressure horizontal unignited jets of hydrogen and methane is studied using CFD numerical simulations performed with FLACS Hydrogen. Results for constant flow rate through a 6.35 mm PRD from 100 barg and 700 barg storage units are presented for horizontal hydrogen and methane jets. To quantify the effect of a horizontal surface on the jet the jet exit is positioned at various heights above the ground ranging from 0.1 m to 10 m. Free jet simulations are performed for comparison purposes.
Polymer Behaviour in High Pressure Hydrogen, Helium and Argon Environments as Applicable to the Hydrogen Infrastructure
Sep 2017
Publication
Polymers for O-rings valve seats gaskets and other sealing applications in the hydrogen infrastructure face extreme conditions of high-pressure H2 (0.1 to 100 MPa) during normal operation. To fill current knowledge gaps and to establish standard test methods for polymers in H2 environments these materials can be tested in laboratory scale H2 manifolds mimicking end use pressure and temperature conditions. Beyond the influence of high pressure H2 the selection of gases used for leak detection in the H2 test manifold their pressures and times of exposure gas types relative diffusion and permeation rates are all important influences on the polymers being tested. These effects can be studied ex-situ with post-exposure characterization. In a previous study four polymers (Viton A Buna N High Density Polyethylene (HDPE) and Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE)) commonly used in the H2 infrastructure were exposed to high-pressure H2 (100 MPa). The observed effects of H2 were consistent with typical polymer property-structure relationships; in particular H2 affected elastomers more than thermoplastics. However since high pressure He was used for purging and leak detection prior to filling with H2 a study of the influence of the purge gas on these polymers was considered necessary to isolate the effects of H2 from those of the purge gas. Therefore in this study Viton A Buna N and PTFE were exposed to the He purge procedure without the subsequent H2 exposure. Additionally six polymers Viton A Buna N PTFE Polyoxymethylene (POM) Polyamide 11 (Nylon) and Ethylenepropylenediene monomer rubber (EPDM) were subjected to high pressure Ar (100 MPa) followed by high pressure H2 (100 MPa) under the same static isothermal conditions to identify the effect of a purge gas with a significantly larger molecular size than He. Viton A and Buna N elastomers are more prone to irreversible changes as a result of H2 exposure from both Ar and He leak tests as indicated by influences on storage modulus extent of swelling and increased compression set. EPDM even though it is an elastomer is not as prone to high-pressure gas influences. The thermoplastics are generally less influenced by high pressure regardless of the gas type. Conclusions from these experiments will provide insight into the influence of purging processes and purge gases on the subsequent testing in high pressure gaseous H2. Control for the influence of purging on testing results is essential for the development of robust test methods for evaluating the effects of H2 and other high-pressure gases on the properties of polymers.
Advancing the Hydrogen Safety Knowledge Base
Sep 2013
Publication
The International Energy Agency's Hydrogen Implementing Agreement (IEA HIA) was established in 1977 to pursue collaborative hydrogen research and development and information exchange among its member countries. Information and knowledge dissemination is a key aspect of the work within IEA HIA tasks and case studies technical reports and presentations/publications often result from the collaborative efforts. The work conducted in hydrogen safety under Task 31 and its predecessor Task 19 can positively impact the objectives of national programs even in cases for which a specific task report is not published. The interactions within Task 31 illustrate how technology information and knowledge exchange among participating hydrogen safety experts serve the objectives intended by the IEA HIA.
Application of Risk Assessment Approach on a Hydrogen Station
Sep 2013
Publication
An accident modelling approach is used to assess the safety of a hydrogen station as part of a ground transportation network. The method incorporates prevention barriers associated to human factors management and organizational failures in a risk assessment framework. Failure probabilities of these barriers and end-states events are predicted using Fault Tree Analysis and Event Tree Analysis respectively. Results from the case study considered revealed the capability of the proposed method in estimating the likelihood of various outcomes as well as predicting the future probability. In addition the scheme offers opportunity to provide dynamic adjustment by updating the failure probability with actual plant data. Results from the analysis can be used to plan maintenance and management of change as required by the plant condition.
Hydrogen Bubble Dispersion and Surface Bursting Behaviour
Sep 2013
Publication
In many processes where hydrogen may be released from below a liquid surface there has been concern regarding how such releases might ultimately disperse in an ullage space. Knowledge of the extent and persistence of any flammable volume formed is needed for hazardous area classification as well as for validation of explosion modelling or experiments. Following an initial release of hydrogen the overall process can be subdivided into three stages (i) rise and possible break-up of a bubble in the liquid (ii) formation and bursting of a thin gas-liquid-gas interface at the liquid surface and (iii) dispersion of the released gas. An apparatus based on a large glass sided water tank has been constructed which employs two synchronised high-speed imaging systems to record the behaviour of hydrogen bubble release and dispersion. A high-speed digital video system records the rising of the bubbles and the formation and bursting of the gas-liquid-gas interface at the liquid surface. An additional schlieren system is used to visualise the hydrogen release as bubbles burst at the liquid surface. The bubble burst mechanism can clearly be described from the results obtained. Following the nucleation of a hole surface tension causes the liquid film to peel back rapidly forming a ring/torus of liquid around the enlarging hole. This process lasts only a few milliseconds. Although some hydrogen can be seen to be expelled from the bubble much seems to remain in place as the film peels away. To assess the extent of the flammable plume following a bubble burst the apparatus was modified to include an electric-arc igniter. In order to identify plumes coincident in space with the igniter a schlieren system was built capable of recording simultaneously in two orthogonal directions. This confirmed that clouds undetected by the schlerien imaging could not be ignited with the electric arc igniter.
CO2-Free Hydrogen Supply Chain Project and Risk Assessment for the Safety Design
Sep 2013
Publication
We at Kawasaki Heavy Industries have proposed a "CO2-Free H2 supply chain" using abundant brown coal of Australian origin as the energy source. This chain will store CO2 generated during the process for producing hydrogen from brown coal in a project (Carbon Net) that the Australia Government is promoting. Thus Japan can import CO2-free hydrogen. The supply chain consists of the hydrogen production system the hydrogen transport/storage system and the hydrogen use system. Related to their designs we have to consider their hazards polluted scenarios and safety measures via a safety assessment process that is compliant with international risk assessment standards. To verify safety designs related experiments and analyses will be conducted. This paper describes the approach to safety design for especially the related liquid hydrogen facilities.
Assessment of a CFD Model for Simulations of Fast Filling of Hydrogen Tanks with Pre-cooling
Sep 2013
Publication
High gas temperatures can be reached inside a hydrogen tank during the filling process because of the large pressure increase (up to 70-80 MPa) and because of the short time (~3 minutes) of the process. High temperatures can potentially jeopardize the structural integrity of the storage system and one of the strategies to reduce the temperature increase is to pre-cool the hydrogen before injecting it into the tank. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) tools have the capabilities of capturing the flow field and the temperature rise in the tank. The results of CFD simulations of fast filling with pre-cooling are shown and compared with experimental data to assess the accuracy of the CFD model
High Pressure Hydrogen Tank Rupture: Blast Wave and Fireball
Oct 2015
Publication
In the present study the phenomena of blast wave and fireball generated by high pressure (35 MPa) hydrogen tank (72 l) rupture have been investigated numerically. The realizable k-ε turbulence model was applied. The simulation of the combustion process is based on the eddy dissipation model coupled with the one step chemical reaction mechanism. Simulation results are compared with experimental data from a stand-alone hydrogen fuel tank rapture following a bonfire test. The model allows the study of the interaction between combustion process and blast wave propagation. Simulation results (blast wave overpressure fireball shape and size) follow the trends observed in the experiment.
Effect of Initial Turbulence on Vented Explosion Over Pressures from Lean Hydrogen-air Deflagrations
Sep 2013
Publication
To examine the effect of initial turbulence on vented explosions experiments were performed for lean hydrogen–air mixtures with hydrogen concentrations ranging from 12 to 15% vol. at elevated initial turbulence. As expected it was found that an increase in initial turbulence increased the overall flame propagation speed and this increased flame propagation speed translated into higher peak overpressures during the external explosion. The peak pressures generated by flame–acoustic interactions however did not vary significantly with initial turbulence. When flame speeds measurements were examined it was found that the burning velocity increased with flame radius as a power function of radius with a relatively constant exponent over the range of weak initial turbulence studied and did not vary systematically with initial turbulence. Instead the elevated initial turbulence increased the initial flame propagation velocities of the various mixtures. The initial turbulence thus appears to act primarily by generating higher initial flame wrinkling while having a minimal effect on the growth rate of the wrinkles. For practical purposes of modelling flame propagation and pressure generation in vented explosions the increase in burning velocity due to turbulence is suggested to be approximated by a single constant factor that increases the effective burning velocity of the mixture. When this approach is applied to a previously developed vent sizing correlation the correlation performs well for almost all of the peaks. It was found however that in certain situations this approach significantly under predicts the flame–acoustic peak. This suggests that further research may be necessary to better understand the influence of initial turbulence on the development of flame–acoustic peaks in vented explosions.
Review of Methods For Estimating the Overpressure and Impulse Resulting From a Hydrogen Explosion in a Confined/Obstructed Volume
Sep 2009
Publication
This study deals with the TNO Multi-Energy and Baker-Strehlow-Tang (BST) methods for estimating the positive overpressures and positive impulses resulting from hydrogen-air explosions. With these two methods positive overpressure and positive impulse results depend greatly on the choice of the class number for the TNO Multi-Energy method or the Mach number for the BST methods. These two factors permit the user to read the reduced parameters of the blast wave from the appropriate monographs for each of these methods i.e. positive overpressure and positive duration phase for the TNO Multi-Energy method and positive overpressure and positive impulse for the BST methods. However for the TNO Multi-Energy method the determination of the class number is not objective because it is the user who makes the final decision in choosing the class number whereas with the BST methods the user is strongly guided in their choice of an appropriate Mach number. These differences in the choice of these factors can lead to very different results in terms of positive overpressure and positive impulse. Therefore the objective of this work was to compare the positive overpressures and positive impulses predicted with the TNO Multi-Energy and BST methods with data available from large-scale experiments.
Numerical investigation of hydrogen leakage from a high pressure tank and pipeline
Sep 2017
Publication
We numerically investigated high-pressure hydrogen leakage from facilities in storage and transportation phases. In storage phase assuming a tank placed in a hydrogen station we examined unsteady diffusion distance up to 100 ms after leakage. A series of simulations led us to develop an equation of unsteady hydrogen diffusion distance as a function of mass flow rate leakage opening diameter and tank pressure. These results helped us develop a safety standard for unsteady hydrogen diffusion. In transportation phase we simulated (in three dimensions) the dominant factor of steady mass flow rate from a square opening of a rectangular pipeline and the pressure distribution in the pipeline after leakage. The mass flow rate was smaller than the maximum mass flow rate and the pressure distribution converged to a steady state that was 16% higher than the pressure after the passage of expansion waves in a shock tube model. We introduced a theoretical model by dividing the flow with the leakage opening into two phases of the unsteady expansion waves’ propagation and acceleration. The simulation results showed good agreement with the modeling equation when the shrink coefficient was set to 0.8. When the leakage opening was rectangular the simulation results again showed good agreement with the modelling equation suggesting that our simulated results are independent of the leakage opening shape.
Comparisons of Helium and Hydrogen Releases in 1 M3 and 2 M3 Two Vents Enclosures: Concentration Measurements at Different Flow Rates and for Two Diameters of Injection Nozzle
Oct 2015
Publication
This work presents a parametric study on the similitude between hydrogen and helium distribution when released in the air by a source located inside of a naturally ventilated enclosure with two vents. Several configurations were experimentally addressed in order to improve knowledge on dispersion. Parameters were chosen to mimic operating conditions of hydrogen energy systems. Thus the varying parameters of the study were mainly the source diameter the releasing flow rate the volume and the geometry of the enclosure. Two different experimental set-ups were used in order to vary the enclosure's height between 1 and 2 m. Experimental results obtained with helium and hydrogen were compared at equivalent flow rates determined with existing similitude laws. It appears for the plume release case that helium can suitably be used for predicting hydrogen dispersion in these operating designs. On the other hand – when the flow turns into a jet – non negligible differences between hydrogen and helium dispersion appear. In this case helium – used as a direct substitute to hydrogen – will over predict concentrations we would get with hydrogen. Therefore helium concentration read-outs should be converted to obtain correct predictions for hydrogen. However such a converting law is not available yet.
In Situ X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy Study on Water Formation Reaction of Palladium Metal Nanoparticle Catalysts
Oct 2015
Publication
Proper management of hydrogen gas is very important for safety security of nuclear power plants. Hydrogen removal by water formation reaction on a catalyst is one of the candidates for creating hydrogen free system. We observed in situ and time-resolved structure change of palladium metal nanoparticle catalyst during the water formation reaction by using X-ray absorption spectroscopy technique. A poisoning effect by carbon monoxide on catalytic activity was also studied. We have found that the creation of oxidized surface layer on palladium metal nanoparticles plays an important role for the water formation reaction process.
Compatibility and Suitability of Existing Steel Pipelines for Transport of Hydrogen and Hydrogen-natural Gas Blends
Sep 2017
Publication
Hydrogen is being considered as a pathway to decarbonize large energy systems and for utility-scale energy storage. As these applications grow transportation infrastructure that can accommodate large quantities of hydrogen will be needed. Many millions of tons of hydrogen are already consumed annually some of which is transported in dedicated hydrogen pipelines. The materials and operation of these hydrogen pipeline systems however are managed with more constraints than a conventional natural gas pipeline. Transitional strategies for deep decarbonization of energy systems include blending hydrogen into existing natural gas systems where the materials and operations may not have the same controls. This study explores the hydrogen compatibility of existing pipeline steels and the suitability of these steels in hydrogen pipeline systems. Representative fracture and fatigue properties of pipeline grade steels in gaseous hydrogen are summarized from the literature. These properties are then considered in idealized design life calculations to inform materials performance for a typical gas pipeline.
Numerical Simulations of a Large Hydrogen Release in a Process Plant
Sep 2009
Publication
This paper describes a series of numerical simulations with release and ignition of hydrogen. The objective of this work was to re-investigate the accidental explosion in an ammonia plant which happened in Norway in 1985 with modern CFD tools. The severe hydrogen-air explosion led to two fatalities and complete destruction of the factory building where the explosion occurred. A case history of the accident was presented at the 1.st ICHS in Pisa 2005.<br/>The numerical simulations have been performed with FLACS a commercial CFD simulation tool for gas dispersion and gas explosions. The code has in the recent years been validated in the area of hydrogen dispersion and explosions.<br/>The factory building was 100 m long 10 m wide and 7 m high. A blown-out gasket in a water pump led to release of hydrogen from a large reservoir storing gaseous hydrogen at 3.0 MPa. The accident report estimated a total mass of released hydrogen between 10 and 20 kg. The location of the faulty gasket is known but the direction of the accidental release is not well known and has been one of the topics of our investigations. Several simulations have been performed to investigate the mixing process of hydrogen-air clouds and the development of a flammable gas cloud inside the factory building resulting in a simulation matrix with dispersions in all axis directions. Simulations of ignition of the different gas clouds were carried out and resulting pressure examined. These results have been compared with the damages observed during the accident investigation.<br/>We have also performed FLACS simulations to study the effect of natural venting and level of congestion. The height of the longitudinal walls has been varied leading to different vent openings at floor level at the ceiling and a combination of the two. This was done to investigate the effects of congestion with regards to gas cloud formation.<br/>The base case simulation appears to be in good accordance to the observed damages from the accident. The simulations also show that the build up of the gas cloud strongly depends on the direction of the jet and degree of ventilation. The CFD study has given new insights to the accident and the results are a clear reminder of the importance of natural venting in hydrogen safety.
Safety and Regulatory Challenges of Using Hydrogen/Natural Gas Blends in the UK
Sep 2019
Publication
The addition of hydrogen to natural gas for heating and cooking is being considered as a route to reducing carbon emissions in the United Kingdom (UK). The HyDeploy programme (hereafter referred to as HyDeploy) aims to demonstrate that hydrogen can be added to the natural gas supply without compromising public safety or appliance performance. This paper relates to the preparatory work for hydrogen injection on a live site at Keele University closed network comprising domestic premises multi-occupancy buildings and light commercial premises. The project is based around the injection of up to 20 %mol/mol hydrogen into mains natural gas at pressures below 2 barg. Work streams addressed during the pre-trial preparation included; assessment of material interaction with hydrogen blends for all distribution system components and appliances; understanding of gas appliance behaviour; review of: gas detection systems fire and explosion considerations routine and emergency procedural considerations; and the design of a new hydrogen injection grid entry unit. This paper describes the safety and regulatory challenges that were encountered during preparation of the project including obtaining the necessary regulatory permissions to blend hydrogen gas.
Numerical Investigation of Hydrogen Dispersion into Air
Sep 2009
Publication
Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) is used to numerically solve the sudden release of hydrogen from a high pressure tank (up to 70MPa) into air. High pressure tanks increase the risk of failure of the joints and pipes connected to the tank which results in release of Hydrogen. The supersonic flow caused by high pressure ratio of reservoir to ambient generates a strong Mach disk. A three dimensional in-house code is developed to simulate the flow. High pressure Hydrogen requires a real gas law because it deviates from ideal gas law. Firstly Beattie-Bridgeman and Abel-Noble real gas equation of states are applied to simulate the release of hydrogen in hydrogen. Then Abel-Noble is implied to simulate the release of hydrogen in air. Beattie-Bridgeman has stability problems in the case of hydrogen in air. A transport equation is used to solve the concentration of Hydrogen-air mixture. The code is second order accurate in space and first order in time and uses a modified Van Leer limiter. The fast release of Hydrogen from a small rupture needs a very small mesh therefore parallel computation is applied to overcome memory problems and to decrease the solution time. The high pressure ratio of the reservoir to ambient causes a very fast release which is accurately modelled by the code and all the shocks and Mach disk happening are observed in the results. The results show that the difference between real gas and ideal gas models cannot be ignored.
Effect of Hydrogen Concentration on Vented Explosion Overpressures from Lean Hydrogen–air Deflagrations
Sep 2011
Publication
Experimental data from vented explosion tests using lean hydrogen–air mixtures with concentrations from 12 to 19% vol. are presented. A 63.7-m3 chamber was used for the tests with a vent size of either 2.7 or 5.4 m2. The tests were focused on the effect of hydrogen concentration ignition location vent size and obstacles on the pressure development of a propagating flame in a vented enclosure. The dependence of the maximum pressure generated on the experimental parameters was analyzed. It was confirmed that the pressure maxima are caused by pressure transients controlled by the interplay of the maximum flame area the burning velocity and the overpressure generated outside of the chamber by an external explosion. A model proposed earlier to estimate the maximum pressure for each of the main pressure transients was evaluated for the various hydrogen concentrations. The effect of the Lewis number on the vented explosion overpressure is discussed.
High-pressure PEM Water Electrolysis and Corresponding Safety Issues
Sep 2009
Publication
In this paper safety considerations related to the operation of proton-exchange membrane (PEM) water electrolysers (hydrogen production capacity up to 1 Nm3/h and operating pressure up to 130 bars) are presented. These results were obtained in the course of the GenHyPEM project a research program on high-pressure PEM water electrolysis supported by the European Commission. Experiments were made using a high-pressure electrolysis stack designed for operation in the 0–130 bars pressure range at temperatures up to 90 °C. Besides hazards related to the pressure itself hydrogen concentration in the oxygen gas production and vice-versa (resulting from membrane crossover permeation effects) have been identified as the most significant risks. Results show that the oxygen concentration in hydrogen at 130 bars can be as high as 2.66 vol %. This is a value still outside the flammability limit for hydrogen–oxygen mixtures (3.9–95.8 vol %) but safety measures are required to prevent explosion hazards. A simple model based on the diffusion of dissolved gases is proposed to account for gas cross-permeation effects. To reduce contamination levels different solutions are proposed. First thicker membranes can be used. Second modified or composite membranes with lower gas permeabilities can be used. Third as reported earlier external catalytic gas recombiners can be used to promote H2/O2 recombination and reduce contamination levels in the gas production. Finally other considerations related to cell and stack design are also discussed to further reduce operation risks.
No more items...