Transmission, Distribution & Storage
Advances in Hydrogen Storage Technologies
Jan 2025
Publication
Gaseous hydrogen storage is the most mature technology for fuel cell vehicles. The main safety concern is the catastrophic consequences of tank rupture in a fire i.e. blast waves fireballs and projectiles. This paper sum marises research on the development and validation of the breakthrough microleaks-no-burst (μLNB) safety technology of explosion-free in any fire self-venting Type IV tanks that do not require a thermally-activate pressure relief device (TPRD). The invention implies the melting of the hydrogen-tight liner of the Type IV tank before the hydrogen-leaky double-composite wall loses load-bearing ability. Hydrogen then flows through the natural microchannels in the composites and burns in microflames or together with resin. The unattainable to competitive products feature of the technology is the ability to withstand any fire from smouldering to extreme impinging hydrogen jet fires. Innovative 70 MPa tanks made of carbon-carbon carbon-glass and carbon-basalt composites were tested in characteristic for gasoline/diesel spill fires with a specific heat release rate of HRR/A = 1 MW/m2 . Standard unprotected Type III and IV tanks will explode in such intensity fire. The technology excludes hydrogen accumulation in naturally ventilated enclosures. It reduces the risk of hydrogen vehicles to an acceptable level below that of fossil fuel cars including underground parking tunnels etc. The performance of self-venting tanks is studied for fire intervention scenarios: removal from fire and fire extinction by water. It is concluded that novel tanks allow standard fire intervention strategies and tactics. Self-venting operation of the 70 MPa tank is demonstrated in extreme jet fire conditions under impinging hydrogen jet fire (70 MPa) with huge HRR/A = 19.5 MW/m2 . This technology excludes tank rupture in fires onboard trains ships and planes where hazard distances cannot be implemented i.e. provides an unprecedented level of life safety and property protection.
Optimization of the Design of Underground Hydrogen Storage in Salt Caverns in Southern Ontario, Canada
Jan 2025
Publication
With the issue of energy shortages becoming increasingly serious the need to shift to sustainable and clean energy sources has become urgent. However due to the intermittent nature of most renewable energy sources developing underground hydrogen storage (UHS) systems as backup energy solutions offers a promising solution. The thick and regionally extensive salt deposits in Unit B of Southern Ontario Canada have demonstrated significant potential for supporting such storage systems. Based on the stratigraphy statistics of unit B this study investigates the feasibility and stability of underground hydrogen storage (UHS) in salt caverns focusing on the effects of cavern shape geometric parameters and operating pressures. Three cavern shapes—cylindrical cone-shaped and ellipsoid-shaped—were analyzed using numerical simulations. Results indicate that cylindrical caverns with a diameter-to-height ratio of 1.5 provide the best balance between storage capacity and structural stability while ellipsoid-shaped caverns offer reduced stress concentration but have less storage space posing practical challenges during leaching. The results also indicate that the optimal pressure range for maintaining stability and minimizing leakage lies between 0.4 and 0.7 times the vertical in situ stress. Higher pressures increase storage capacity but lead to greater stress displacements and potential leakage risks while lower pressure leads to internal extrusion tendency for cavern walls. Additionally hydrogen leakage rate drops with the maximum working pressure yet total leakage mass keeps a growing trend.
Numerical Study of the Filling Process of a Liquid Hydrogen Storage Tank under Different Sloshing Conditions
Aug 2020
Publication
Cryogenic vessels are widely used in many areas such as liquefied natural gas (LNG) aerospace and medical fields. A suitable filling method is one of the prerequisites for the effective use of cryogenic containers. In this study the filling process for the sloshing condition of a liquid hydrogen storage tank is numerically simulated and analyzed by coupling the sloshing model and the phase-change model. The effects of different sloshing conditions during the filling process are investigated by changing the amplitude and frequency of the sloshing. Within the scope of this study there is a critical value for the effect of sloshing conditions on the pressure curve during the filling process. The critical value corresponds to a frequency f equal to 3 Hz and an amplitude A equal to 0.03 m. According to the simulation results when the sloshing exceeds the critical value the internal pressure curve of the storage tank increases significantly. Under microgravity conditions within the scope of this study the pressure curve changes less than the normal gravity even if the amplitude and frequency increase. The sloshing makes it easier for the liquid to spread along the wall during the filling process. This also further weakens the temperature stratification in the storage tank.
Influence of Capillary Threshold Pressure and Injection Well Location on the Dynamic CO2 and H2 Storage Capacity for the Deep Geological Structure
Jul 2021
Publication
The subject of this study is the analysis of influence of capillary threshold pressure and injection well location on the dynamic CO2 and H2 storage capacity for the Lower Jurassic reservoir of the Sierpc structure from central Poland. The results of injection modeling allowed us to compare the amount of CO2 and H2 that the considered structure can store safely over a given time interval. The modeling was performed using a single well for 30 different locations considering that the minimum capillary pressure of the cap rock and the fracturing pressure should not be exceeded for each gas separately. Other values of capillary threshold pressure for CO2 and H2 significantly affect the amount of a given gas that can be injected into the reservoir. The structure under consideration can store approximately 1 Mt CO2 in 31 years while in the case of H2 it is slightly above 4000 tons. The determined CO2 storage capacity is limited; the structure seems to be more prospective for underground H2 storage. The CO2 and H2 dynamic storage capacity maps are an important element of the analysis of the use of gas storage structures. A much higher fingering effect was observed for H2 than for CO2 which may affect the withdrawal of hydrogen. It is recommended to determine the optimum storage depth particularly for hydrogen. The presented results important for the assessment of the capacity of geological structures also relate to the safety of use of CO2 and H2 underground storage space.
Subsurface Renewable Energy Storage Capcity for Hydrogen, Methane and Compress Air - A Performance Assessment Study from the North German Basin
Jul 2021
Publication
The transition to renewable energy sources to mitigate climate change will require large-scale energy storage to dampen the fluctuating availability of renewable sources and to ensure a stable energy supply. Energy storage in the geological subsurface can provide capacity and support the cycle times required. This study investigates hydrogen storage methane storage and compressed air energy storage in subsurface porous formations and quantifies potential storage capacities as well as storage rates on a site-specific basis. For part of the North German Basin used as the study area potential storage sites are identified employing a newly developed structural geological model. Energy storage capacities estimated from a volume-based approach are 6510 TWh and 24544 TWh for hydrogen and methane respectively. For a consistent comparison of storage capacities including compressed air energy storage the stored exergy is calculated as 6735 TWh 25795 TWh and 358 TWh for hydrogen methane and compressed air energy storage respectively. Evaluation of storage deliverability indicates that high deliverability rates are found mainly in two of the three storage formations considered. Even accounting for the uncertainty in geological parameters the storage potential for the three considered storage technologies is significantly larger than the predicted demand and suitable storage rates are achievable in all storage formations.
Hydrogen Quality in Used Natual Gas Pipelines: An Experimental Investigation of Contaminants According to ISO 14687:2019 Standard
Sep 2023
Publication
The transport of hydrogen in used natural gas pipelines is a strategic key element of a pan-European hydrogen infrastructure. At the same time accurate knowledge of the hydrogen quality is essential in order to be able to address a wide application range. Therefore an experimental investigation was carried out to find out which contaminants enter into the hydrogen from the used natural gas pipelines. Pipeline elements from the high pressure gas grid of Austria were exposed to hydrogen. Steel pipelines built between 1960 and 2018 which were operated with odorised and pure natural gas were examined. The hydrogen was analysed according to requirements of ISO14687: 2019 Grade D measurement standard. The results show that based on age odorization and sediments different contimenants are introduced. Odorants hydrocarbons but also sulphur compounds ammonia and halogenated hydrogen compounds were identified. Sediments are identified as the main source of impurities. However the concentrations of the introduced contaminants were low (6 nmol/mol to 10 μmol/mol). Quality monitoring with a wide range of detection options for different components (sulphur halogenated compounds hydrocarbons ammonia and atmospheric components) is crucial for real operation. The authors deduce that a Grade A hydrogen quality can be safely achieved in real operation.
Technical and Economic Viability of Underground Hydrogen Storage
Nov 2023
Publication
Considering the mismatch between the renewable source availability and energy demand energy storage is increasingly vital for achieving a net-zero future. The daily/seasonal disparities produce a surplus of energy at specific moments. The question is how can this “excess” energy be stored? One promising solution is hydrogen. Conventional hydrogen storage relies on manufactured vessels. However scaling the technology requires larger volumes to satisfy peak demands enhance the reliability of renewable energies and increase hydrogen reserves for future technology and infrastructure development. The optimal solution may involve leveraging the large volumes of underground reservoirs like salt caverns and aquifers while minimizing the surface area usage and avoiding the manufacturing and safety issues inherent to traditional methods. There is a clear literature gap regarding the critical aspects of underground hydrogen storage (UHS) technology. Thus a comprehensive review of the latest developments is needed to identify these gaps and guide further R&D on the topic. This work provides a better understanding of the current situation of UHS and its future challenges. It reviews the literature published on UHS evaluates the progress in the last decades and discusses ongoing and carried-out projects suggesting that the technology is technically and economically ready for today’s needs.
Key Technologies of Pure Hydrogen and Hydrogen-mixed Natural Gas Pipeline Transportation
May 2023
Publication
Thanks to the advantages of cleanliness high efficiency extensive sources and renewable energy hydrogen energy has gradually become the focus of energy development in the world’s major economies. At present the natural gas transportation pipeline network is relatively complete while hydrogen transportation technology faces many challenges such as the lack of technical specifications high safety risks and high investment costs which are the key factors that hinder the development of hydrogen pipeline transportation. This paper provides a comprehensive overview and summary of the current status and development prospects of pure hydrogen and hydrogen-mixed natural gas pipeline transportation. Analysts believe that basic studies and case studies for hydrogen infrastructure transformation and system optimization have received extensive attention and related technical studies are mainly focused on pipeline transportation processes pipe evaluation and safe operation guarantees. There are still technical challenges in hydrogen-mixed natural gas pipelines in terms of the doping ratio and hydrogen separation and purification. To promote the industrial application of hydrogen energy it is necessary to develop more efficient low-cost and low-energy-consumption hydrogen storage materials.
Comprehensive Review of Geomechanics of Underground Hydrogen Storage in Depleted Reservoirs and Salt Caverns
Sep 2023
Publication
Hydrogen is a promising energy carrier for a low-carbon future energy system as it can be stored on a megaton scale (equivalent to TWh of energy) in subsurface reservoirs. However safe and efficient underground hydrogen storage requires a thorough understanding of the geomechanics of the host rock under fluid pressure fluctuations. In this context we summarize the current state of knowledge regarding geomechanics relevant to carbon dioxide and natural gas storage in salt caverns and depleted reservoirs. We further elaborate on how this knowledge can be applied to underground hydrogen storage. The primary focus lies on the mechanical response of rocks under cyclic hydrogen injection and production fault reactivation the impact of hydrogen on rock properties and other associated risks and challenges. In addition we discuss wellbore integrity from the perspective of underground hydrogen storage. The paper provides insights into the history of energy storage laboratory scale experiments and analytical and simulation studies at the field scale. We also emphasize the current knowledge gaps and the necessity to enhance our understanding of the geomechanical aspects of hydrogen storage. This involves developing predictive models coupled with laboratory scale and field-scale testing along with benchmarking methodologies.
A COMSOL Framework for Predicting Hydrogen Embrittlement - Part 1: Coupled Hydrogen Transport
Mar 2025
Publication
Hydrogen threatens the structural integrity of metals and thus predicting hydrogen-material interactions is key to unlocking the role of hydrogen in the energy transition. Quantifying the interplay between material deformation and hydrogen diffusion ahead of cracks and other stress concentrators is key to the prediction and prevention of hydrogen-assisted failures. In this work a generalised theoretical and computational framework is presented that for the first time encompasses: (i) stress-assisted diffusion (ii) hydrogen trapping due to multiple trap types rigorously accounting for the rate of creation of dislocation trap sites (iii) hydrogen transport through dislocations (iv) equilibrium (Oriani) and non-equilibrium (McNabb-Foster) trapping kinetics (v) hydrogen-induced softening and (vi) hydrogen uptake considering the role of hydrostatic stresses and local electrochemistry. Particular emphasis is placed on the numerical implementation in COMSOL Multiphysics releasing the relevant models and discussing stability discretisation and solver details. Each of the elements of the framework is independently benchmarked against results from the literature and implications for the prediction of hydrogen-assisted fractures are discussed. The second part of this work (Part II) shows how these crack tip predictions can be combined with crack growth simulations.
Optimal Design of Hydrogen Delivery Infrastructure for Multi-sector End Uses at Regional Scale
Jul 2024
Publication
Hydrogen is a promising solution for the decarbonisation of several hard-to-abate end uses which are mainly in the industrial and transport sectors. The development of an extensive hydrogen delivery infrastructure is essential to effectively activate and deploy a hydrogen economy connecting production storage and demand. This work adopts a mixed-integer linear programming model to study the cost-optimal design of a future hydrogen infrastructure in presence of cross-sectoral hydrogen uses taking into account spatial and temporal variations multiple production technologies and optimised multi-mode transport and storage. The model is applied to a case study in the region of Sicily in Italy aiming to assess the infrastructural needs to supply the regional demand from transport and industrial sectors and to transfer hydrogen imported from North Africa towards Europe thus accounting for the region’s role as transit point. The analysis integrates multiple production technologies (electrolysis supplied by wind and solar energy steam reforming with carbon capture) and transport options (compressed hydrogen trucks liquid hydrogen trucks pipelines). Results show that the average cost of hydrogen delivered to demand points decreases from 3.75 €/kgH2 to 3.49 €/kgH2 when shifting from mobilityonly to cross-sectoral end uses indicating that the integrated supply chain exploits more efficiently the infrastructural investments. Although pipeline transport emerges as the dominant modality delivery via compressed hydrogen trucks and liquid hydrogen trucks remains relevant even in scenarios characterised by large hydrogen flows as resulting from cross-sectoral demand demonstrating that the system competitiveness is maximised through multi-mode integration.
Optimizing Underground Hydrogen Storage in Aquifers: The Impact of Cushion Gas Type
Aug 2023
Publication
This study investigated the impact of cushion gas type and presence on the performance of underground hydrogen storage (UHS) in an offshore North Sea aquifer. Using numerical simulation the relationship between cushion gas type and UHS performance was comprehensively evaluated providing valuable insights for designing an efficient UHS project delivery. Results indicated that cushion gas type can significantly impact the process's recovery efficiency and hydrogen purity. CO2 was found to have the highest storage capacity while lighter gases like N2 and CH4 exhibited better recovery efficiency. Utilising CH4 as a cushion gas can lead to a higher recovery efficiency of 80%. It was also determined that utilising either of these cushion gases was always more beneficial than hydrogen storage alone leading to an incremental hydrogen recovery up to 7%. Additionally hydrogen purity degraded as each cycle progressed but improved over time. This study contributes to a better understanding of factors affecting UHS performance and can inform the selection of cushion gas type and optimal operational strategies.
Current and Future Role of Natural Gas Supply Chains in the Transition to a Low-Carbon Hydrogen Economy: A Comprehensive Review on Integrated Natural Gas Supply Chain Optimisation Models
Nov 2023
Publication
Natural gas is the most growing fossil fuel due to its environmental advantages. For the economical transportation of natural gas to distant markets physical (i.e. liquefaction and compression) or chemical (i.e. direct and indirect) monetisation options must be considered to reduce volume and meet the demand of different markets. Planning natural gas supply chains is a complex problem in today’s turbulent markets especially considering the uncertainties associated with final market demand and competition with emerging renewable and hydrogen energies. This review study evaluates the latest research on mathematical programming (i.e. MILP and MINLP) as a decisionmaking tool for designing and planning natural gas supply chains under different planning horizons. The first part of this study assesses the status of existing natural gas infrastructures by addressing readily available natural monetisation options quantitative tools for selecting monetisation options and single-state and multistate natural gas supply chain optimisation models. The second part investigates hydrogen as a potential energy carrier for integration with natural gas supply chains carbon capture utilisation and storage technologies. This integration is foreseen to decarbonise systems diversify the product portfolio and fill the gap between current supply chains and the future market need of cleaner energy commodities. Since natural gas markets are turbulent and hydrogen energy has the potential to replace fossil fuels in the future addressing stochastic conditions and demand uncertainty is vital to hedge against risks through designing a responsive supply chain in the project’s early design stages. Hence hydrogen supply chain optimisation studies and the latest works on hydrogen–natural gas supply chain optimisation were reviewed under deterministic and stochastic conditions. Only quantitative mathematical models for supply chain optimisation including linear and nonlinear programming models were considered in this study to evaluate the effectiveness of each proposed approach.
Optimizing the Operational Efficiency of the Underground Hydrogen Storage Scheme in a Deep North Sea Aquifer through Compositional Simulations
Aug 2023
Publication
In this study we evaluate the technical viability of storing hydrogen in a deep UKCS aquifer formation through a series of numerical simulations utilising the compositional simulator CMG-GEM. Effects of various operational parameters such as injection and production rates number and length of storage cycles and shut-in periods on the performance of the underground hydrogen storage (UHS) process are investigated in this study. Results indicate that higher H2 operational rates degrade both the aquifer's working capacity and H2 recovery during the withdrawal phase. This can be attributed to the dominant viscous forces at higher rates which lead to H2 viscous fingering and gas gravity override of the native aquifer water resulting in an unstable displacement of water by the H2 gas. Furthermore analysis of simulation results shows that longer and less frequent storage cycles lead to higher storage capacity and decreased H2 retrieval. We conclude that UHS in the studied aquifer is technically feasible however a thorough evaluation of the operational parameters is necessary to optimise both storage capacity and H2 recovery efficiency.
The Potential of Hydrogen-battery Storage Systems for a Sustainable Renewable-based Electrification of Remote Islands in Norway
Oct 2023
Publication
Remote locations and off-grid regions still rely mainly on diesel generators despite the high operating costs and greenhouse gas emissions. The exploitation of local renewable energy sources (RES) in combination with energy storage technologies can be a promising solution for the sustainable electrification of these areas. The aim of this work is to investigate the potential for decarbonizing remote islands in Norway by installing RES-based energy systems with hydrogen-battery storage. A national scale assessment is presented: first Norwegian islands are characterized and classified according to geographical location number of inhabitants key services and current electrification system. Then 138 suitable installation sites are pinpointed through a multiple-step sorting procedure and finally 10 reference islands are identified as representative case studies. A site-specific methodology is applied to estimate the electrical load profiles of all the selected reference islands. An optimization framework is then developed to determine the optimal system configuration that minimizes the levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) while ensuring a reliable 100% renewable power supply. The LCOE of the RES-based energy systems range from 0.21 to 0.63 €/kWh and a clear linear correlation with the wind farm capacity factor is observed (R2 equal to 0.87). Hydrogen is found to be crucial to prevent the oversizing of the RES generators and batteries and ensure long-term storage capacity. The techno-economic feasibility of alternative electrification strategies is also investigated: the use of diesel generators is not economically viable (0.87–1.04 €/kWh) while the profitability of submarine cable connections is highly dependent on the cable length and the annual electricity consumption (0.14–1.47 €/kWh). Overall the cost-effectiveness of RES-based energy systems for off-grid locations in Northern Europe can be easily assessed using the correlations derived in this analysis.
A Novel Sustainable Approach for Site Selection of Underground Hydrogen Storage in Poland Using Deep Learning
Jul 2024
Publication
This research investigates the potential of using bedded salt formations for underground hydrogen storage. We present a novel artificial intelligence framework that employs spatial data analysis and multi-criteria decision-making to pinpoint the most appropriate sites for hydrogen storage in salt caverns. This methodology incorporates a comprehensive platform enhanced by a deep learning algorithm specifically a convolutional neural network (CNN) to generate suitability maps for rock salt deposits for hydrogen storage. The efficacy of the CNN algorithm was assessed using metrics such as Mean Absolute Error (MAE) Mean Squared Error (MSE) Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) and the Correlation Coefficient (R2 ) with comparisons made to a real-world dataset. The CNN model showed outstanding performance with an R2 of 0.96 MSE of 1.97 MAE of 1.003 and RMSE of 1.4. This novel approach leverages advanced deep learning techniques to offer a unique framework for assessing the viability of underground hydrogen storage. It presents a significant advancement in the field offering valuable insights for a wide range of stakeholders and facilitating the identification of ideal sites for hydrogen storage facilities thereby supporting informed decisionmaking and sustainable energy infrastructure development.
The Role of Underground Salt Caverns in Renewable Energy Peaking: A Review
Nov 2024
Publication
To address the inherent intermittency and instability of renewable energy the construction of large-scale energy storage facilities is imperative. Salt caverns are internationally recognized as excellent sites for large-scale energy storage. They have been widely used to store substances such as natural gas oil air and hydrogen. With the global transition in energy structures and the increasing demand for renewable energy load balancing there is broad market potential for the development of salt cavern energy storage technologies. There are three types of energy storage in salt caverns that can be coupled with renewable energy sources namely salt cavern compressed air energy storage (SCCAES) salt cavern hydrogen storage (SCHS) and salt cavern flow battery (SCFB). The innovation of this paper is to comprehensively review the current status and future development trends of these three energy storage methods. Firstly the development status of these three energy storage methods both domestically and internationally is reviewed. Secondly according to the characteristics of these three types of energy storage methods some key technical challenges are proposed to be focused on. The key technical challenge for SCCAES is the need to further reduce the cost of the ground equipment; the key technical challenge for SCHS is to prevent the risk of hydrogen leakage; and the key technical challenge for SCFB is the need to further increase the concentration of the active substance in the huge salt cavern. Finally some potential solutions are proposed based on these key technical challenges. This work is of great significance in accelerating the development of salt cavern energy storage technologies in coupled renewable energy.
A Review of Gas Phase Inhibition of Gaseous Hydrogen Embrittlement in Pipeline Steels
Feb 2024
Publication
The addition of small amounts of certain gases such as O2 CO and SO2 may mitigate hydrogen embrittlement in high-pressure gas transmission pipelines that transport hydrogen. To practically implement such inhibition in gas transmission pipelines a comprehensive understanding and quantification of this effect are essential. This review examines the impact of various added gases to hydrogen including typical odorants on gaseous hydrogen embrittlement of steels and evaluates their inhibition effectiveness. O2 CO and SO2 were found to be effective inhibitors of hydrogen embrittlement. Yet the results in the literature have not always been consistent partly because of the diverse range of mechanical tests and their parameters. The absence of systematic studies hinders the evaluation of the feasibility of using gas phase inhibitors for controlling gaseous hydrogen embrittlement. A method to quantify the effectiveness of gas phase inhibition is proposed using gas phase permeation studies.
Thermal Sprayed Protective Coatings for Bipolar Plates of Hydrogen Fuel Cells and Water Electrolysis Cells
Mar 2024
Publication
As one core component in hydrogen fuel cells and water electrolysis cells bipolar plates (BPs) perform multiple important functions such as separating the fuel and oxidant flow providing mechanical support conducting electricity and heat connecting the cell units into a stack etc. On the path toward commercialization the manufacturing costs of bipolar plates have to be substantially reduced by adopting low-cost and easy-to-process metallic materials (e.g. stainless steel aluminum or copper). However these materials are susceptible to electrochemical corrosion under harsh operating conditions resulting in long-term performance degradation. By means of advanced thermal spraying technologies protective coatings can be prepared on bipolar plates so as to inhibit oxidation and corrosion. This paper reviews several typical thermal spraying technologies including atmospheric plasma spraying (APS) vacuum plasma spraying (VPS) and high-velocity oxygen fuel (HVOF) spraying for preparing coatings of bipolar plates particularly emphasizing the effect of spraying processes on coating effectiveness. The performance of coatings relies not only on the materials as selected or designed but also on the composition and microstructure practically obtained in the spraying process. The temperature and velocity of in-flight particles have a significant impact on coating quality; therefore precise control over these factors is demanded.
Economic and Environmental Potential of Green Hydrogen Carriers (GHCs) Produced via Reduction of Amine-capture CO2
Jun 2023
Publication
Hydrogen is deemed as a crucial component in the transition to a carbon-free energy system and researchers are actively working to realize the hydrogen economy. While hydrogen derived from renewable energy sources is a promising means of providing clean energy to households and industries its practical usage is currently hindered by difficulties in transportation and storage. Due to the extreme operating conditions required for liquefying hydrogen various hydrogen carriers are being considered which can be transported and stored at mild operating conditions and provide hydrogen at the site of usage. Among various candidates green hydrogen carriers obtained via carbon dioxide utilization have been proposed as an economically and environmentally feasible option. Herein the potential of using methanol and formic acid as green hydrogen carriers are evaluated regarding various production and dehydrogenation pathways within a hydrogen distribution system including the recycle of carbon dioxide. Recent progress in carbon dioxide utilization processes especially conversion of carbon dioxide captured in amine solutions have demonstrated promising results for methanol and formic acid production. This study analyzes seven scenarios that consider carbon dioxide utilization-based thermocatalytic and electrochemical methanol and formic acid production as well as different dehydrogenation pathways and compares them to the scenario of delivering liquefied hydrogen. The scenarios are thoroughly analyzed via techno-economic analysis and life cycle assessment methods. The results of the study indicate that methanol-based options are economically viable reducing the cost up to 43% compared to liquefied hydrogen delivery. As for formic acid only the electrochemical production method is profitable retaining 10% less cost compared to liquefied hydrogen delivery. In terms of environmental impact all of the scenarios show higher global warming impact values than liquefied hydrogen distribution. However results show that in an optimistic case where wind electricity is widely used electrochemical formic acid production is competitive with liquefied hydrogen distribution retaining 39% less global warming impact values. This is because high conversion can be achieved at mild operating conditions for the production and dehydrogenation reactions of formic acid reducing the input of utilities other than electricity. This study suggests that while methanol can be a shortterm solution for hydrogen distribution electrochemical formic acid production may be a viable long-term option.
No more items...