Transmission, Distribution & Storage
A Techno-economic Study of the Strategy for Hydrogen Transport by Pipelines in Canada
Jan 2023
Publication
Hydrogen as a clean zero-emission energy fuel will play a critical role in energy transition and achievement of the net-zero target in 2050. Hydrogen delivery is integral to the entire value chain of a full-scale hydrogen economy. This work conducted a systematic review and analysis of various hydrogen transportation methods including truck tankers for liquid hydrogen tube trailers for gaseous hydrogen and pipelines by identifying and ranking the main properties and affecting factors associated with each method. It is found that pipelines especially the existing natural gas pipelines provide a more efficient and cheaper means to transport hydrogen over long distances. Analysis was further conducted on Canadian natural gas pipeline network which has been operating for safe effective and efficient energy transport over six decades. The established infrastructure along with the developed operating and management experiences and skillful manpower makes the existing pipelines the best option for transport of hydrogen in either blended or pure form in the country. The technical challenges in repurposing the existing natural gas pipelines for hydrogen service were discussed and further work was analyzed.
Linking Geological and Infrastructural Requirements for Large-scale Underground Hydrogen Storage in Germany
Jun 2023
Publication
Hydrogen storage might be key to the success of the hydrogen economy and hence the energy transition in Germany. One option for cost-effective storage of large quantities of hydrogen is the geological subsurface. However previous experience with underground hydrogen storage is restricted to salt caverns which are limited in size and space. In contrast pore storage facilities in aquifers -and/or depleted hydrocarbon reservoirs- could play a vital role in meeting base load needs due to their wide availability and large storage capacity but experiences are limited to past operations with hydrogen-bearing town gas. To overcome this barrier here we investigate hydrogen storage in porous storage systems in a two-step process: 1) First we investigate positive and cautionary indicators for safe operations of hydrogen storage in pore storage systems. 2) Second we estimate hydrogen storage capacities of pore storage systems in (current and decommissioned) underground natural gas storage systems and saline aquifers. Our systematic review highlights that optimal storage conditions in terms of energy content and hydrogen quality are found in sandstone reservoirs in absence of carbonate and iron bearing accessory minerals at a depth of approx. 1100 m and a temperature of at least 40°C. Porosity and permeability of the reservoir formation should be at least 20% and 5 × 10−13 m2 (~500 mD) respectively. In addition the pH of the brine should fall below 6 and the salinity should exceed 100 mg/L. Based on these estimates the total hydrogen storage capacity in underground natural gas storages is estimated to be up to 8 billion cubic meters or (0.72 Mt at STP) corresponding to 29 TWh of energy equivalent of hydrogen. Saline aquifers may offer additional storage capacities of 81.6–691.8 Mt of hydrogen which amounts to 3.2 to 27.3 PWh of energy equivalent of hydrogen the majority of which is located in the North German basin. Pore storage systems could therefore become a crucial element of the future German hydrogen infrastructure especially in regions with large industrial hydrogen (storage) demand and likely hydrogen imports via pipelines and ships.
A Review on Metal Hydride Materials for Hydrogen Storage
Jul 2023
Publication
To achieve the shift to renewable energies efficient energy storage is of the upmost importance. Hydrogen as a chemical energy storage represents a promising technology due to its high gravimetric energy density. However the most efficient form of hydrogen storage still remains an open question. Absorption-based storage of hydrogen in metal hydrides offers high volumetric energy densities as well as safety advantages. In this work technical economic and environmental aspects of different metal hydride materials are investigated. An overview of the material properties production methods as well as possibilities for enhancement of properties are presented. Furthermore impacts on material costs abundance of raw materials and dependency on imports are discussed. Advantages and disadvantages of selected materials are derived and may serve as a decision basis for material selection based on application. Further research on enhancement of material properties as well as on the system level is required for widespread application of metal hydrides.
Perspectives and Prospects of Underground Hydrogen Storage and Natural Hydrogen
Jun 2022
Publication
Hydrogen is considered the fuel of the future due to its cleaner nature compared to methane and gasoline. Therefore renewable hydrogen production technologies and long-term affordable and safe storage have recently attracted significant research interest. However natural underground hydrogen production and storage have received scant attention in the literature despite its great potential. As such the associated formation mechanisms geological locations and future applications remain relatively under-explored thereby requiring further investigation. In this review the global natural hydrogen formation along with reaction mechanisms (i.e. metamorphic processes pyritization and serpentinization reactions) as well as the suitable geological locations (i.e. ophiolites organic-rich sediments fault zones igneous rocks crystalline basements salt bearing strata and hydrocarbon-bearing basins) are discussed. Moreover the underground hydrogen storage mechanisms are detailed and compared with underground natural gas and CO2 storage. Techno-economic analyses of large-scale underground hydrogen storage are presented along with the current challenges and future directions.
A Comparative Study on Energy Efficiency of the Maritime Supply Chains for Liquefied Hydrogen, Ammonia, Methanol and Natural Gas
Jun 2023
Publication
To cope with climate change emerging fuels- hydrogen ammonia and methanol- have been proposed as promising energy carriers that will replace part of the liquefied natural gas (LNG) in future maritime scenarios. Energy efficiency is an important indicator for evaluating the system but the maritime supply system for emerging fuels has yet to be revealed. In this study the energy efficiency of the maritime supply chain of hydrogen ammonia methanol and natural gas is investigated considering processes including production storage loading transport and unloading. A sensitivity analysis of parameters such as ambient temperature storage time pipeline length and sailing time is also carried out. The results show that hydrogen (2.366%) has the highest daily boil-off gas (BOG) rate and wastes more energy than LNG (0.413%) with ammonia and methanol both being lower than LNG. The recycling of BOG is of great importance to the hydrogen supply chain. When produced from renewable energy sources methanol (98.02%) is the most energy efficient followed by ammonia with hydrogen being the least (89.10%). This assessment shows from an energy efficiency perspective that ammonia and methanol have the potential to replace LNG as the energy carrier of the future and that hydrogen requires efficient BOG handling systems to increase competitiveness. This study provides some inspirations for the design of global maritime supply systems for emerging fuels.
Assessing and Modelling Hydrogen Reactivity in Underground Hydrogen Storage: A Review and Models Simulating the Lobodice Town Gas Storage
Apr 2023
Publication
Underground Hydrogen storage (UHS) is a promising technology for safe storage of large quantities of hydrogen in daily to seasonal cycles depending on the consumption requirements. The development of UHS requires anticipating hydrogen behavior to prevent any unexpected economic or environmental impact. An open question is the hydrogen reactivity in underground porous media storages. Indeed there is no consensus on the effects or lack of geochemical reactions in UHS operations because of the strong coupling with the activity of microbes using hydrogen as electron donor during anaerobic reduction reactions. In this work we apply different geochemical models to abiotic conditions or including the catalytic effect of bacterial activity in methanogenesis acetogenesis and sulfate-reduction reactions. The models are applied to Lobodice town gas storage (Czech Republic) where a conversion of hydrogen to methane was measured during seasonal gas storage. Under abiotic conditions no reaction is simulated. When the classical thermodynamic approach for aqueous redox reactions is applied the simulated reactivity of hydrogen is too high. The proper way to simulate hydrogen reactivity must include a description of the kinetics of the aqueous redox reactions. Two models are applied to simulate the reactions of hydrogen observed at Lobodice gas storage. One modeling the microbial activity by applying energy threshold limitations and another where microbial activity follows a Monod-type rate law. After successfully calibrating the bio-geochemical models for hydrogen reactivity on existing gas storage data and constraining the conditions where microbial activity will inhibit or enhance hydrogen reactivity we now have a higher confidence in assessing the hydrogen reactivity in future UHS in aquifers or depleted reservoirs.
Research on Multi-market Strategies for Virtual Power Plants with Hydrogen Energy Storage
Oct 2023
Publication
As the main body of resource aggregation Virtual Power Plant (VPP) not only needs to participate in the external energy market but also needs to optimize the management of internal resources. Different from other energy storage hydrogen energy storage systems can participate in the hydrogen market in addition to assuming the backup supplementary function of electric energy. For the Virtual Power Plant Operator (VPPO) it needs to optimize the scheduling of internal resources and formulate bidding strategies for the electric-hydrogen market based on external market information. In this study a two-stage model is constructed considering the internal and external interaction mechanism. The first stage model optimizes the operation of renewable energy flexible load extraction storage and hydrogen energy storage system based on the complementary characteristics of internal resources; the second stage model optimizes the bidding strategy to maximize the total revenue of the electricity energy market auxiliary service market and hydrogen market. Finally a typical scenario is constructed and the rationality and effectiveness of the strategy are verified. The results show that the hybrid VPP with hydrogen storage has better economic benefits resource benefits and reliability.
Can Africa Serve Europe with Hydrogen Energy from Its Renewables?—Assessing the Economics of Shipping Hydrogen and Hydrogen Carriers to Europe from Different Parts of the Continent
Apr 2023
Publication
There exists no single optimal way for transporting hydrogen and other hydrogen carriers from one port to the other globally. Its delivery depends on several factors such as the quantity distance economics and the availability of the required infrastructure for its transportation. Europe has a strategy to invest in the production of green hydrogen in Africa to meet its needs. This study assessed the economic viability of shipping liquefied hydrogen (LH2 ) and hydrogen carriers to Germany from six African countries that have been identified as countries with great potential in the production of hydrogen. The results obtained suggest that the shipping of LH2 to Europe (Germany) will cost between 0.47 and 1.55 USD/kg H2 depending on the distance of travel for the ship. Similarly the transportation of hydrogen carriers could range from 0.19 to 0.55 USD/kg H2 for ammonia 0.25 to 0.77 USD/kg H2 for LNG 0.24 to 0.73 USD/kg H2 for methanol and 0.43 to 1.28 USD/kg H2 for liquid organic hydrogen carriers (LOHCs). Ammonia was found to be the ideal hydrogen carrier since it recorded the least transportation cost. A sensitivity analysis conducted indicates that an increase in the economic life by 5 years could averagely decrease the cost of LNG by some 13.9% NH3 by 13.2% methanol by 7.9% LOHC by 8.03% and LH2 by 12.41% under a constant distance of 6470 nautical miles. The study concludes with a suggestion that if both foreign and local participation in the development of the hydrogen market is increased in Africa the continent could supply LH2 and other hydrogen carriers to Europe at a cheaper price using clean fuel.
Recent Advances of Metal Borohydrides for Hydrogen Storage
Aug 2022
Publication
Hydrogen energy is an excellent carrier for connecting various renewable energy sources and has many advantages. However hydrogen is flammable and explosive and its density is low and easy to escape which brings inconvenience to the storage and transportation of hydrogen. Therefore hydrogen storage technology has become one of the key steps in the application of hydrogen energy. Solid-state hydrogen storage method has a very high volumetric hydrogen density compared to the traditional compressed hydrogen method. The main issue of solid-state hydrogen storage method is the development of advanced hydrogen storage materials. Metal borohydrides have very high hydrogen density and have received much attention over the past two decades. However high hydrogen sorption temperature slow kinetics and poor reversibility still severely restrict its practical applications. This paper mainly discusses the research progress and problems to be solved of metal borohydride hydrogen storage materials for solid-state hydrogen storage.
Underground Hydrogen Storage to Balance Seasonal Variations in Energy Demand: Impact of Well Configuration on Storage Performance in Deep Saline Aquifers
Mar 2023
Publication
Grid-scale underground hydrogen storage (UHS) is essential for the decarbonization of energy supply systems on the path towards a zero-emissions future. This study presents the feasibility of UHS in an actual saline aquifer with a typical dome-shaped anticline structure to balance the potential seasonal mismatches between energy supply and demand in the UK domestic heating sector. As a main requirement for UHS in saline aquifers we investigate the role of well configuration design in enhancing storage performance in the selected site via numerical simulation. The results demonstrate that the efficiency of cyclic hydrogen recovery can reach around 70% in the short term without the need for upfront cushion gas injection. Storage capacity and deliverability increase in successive storage cycles for all scenarios with the co-production of water from the aquifer having a minimal impact on the efficiency of hydrogen recovery. Storage capacity and deliverability also increase when additional wells are added to the storage site; however the distance between wells can strongly influence this effect. For optimum well spacing in a multi-well storage scenario within a dome-shaped anticline structure it is essential to attain an efficient balance between well pressure interference effects at short well distances and the gas uprising phenomenon at large distances. Overall the findings obtained and the approach described can provide effective technical guidelines pertaining to the design and optimization of hydrogen storage operations in deep saline aquifers.
Mineral Reactions in the Geological Underground Induced by H2 and CO2 Injections
Dec 2014
Publication
The R&D project H2STORE is part of the German program to reduce environmental pollution by energy production and in saving fossil natural resources. Thereby physico-chemical processes in the CO2-H2 system by organic and inorganic reactions receive increasing attention. In H2STORE siliciclastic reservoirs and their caprocks from 25 well sites in Germany and Austria are investigated by different analytical methods before and after H2/CO2 batch experiments under sample specific reservoir conditions (p T XFluid). Mineral dissolution precipitation and their impact on reservoir quality (poro-perm fluid pathways) and on the generation of methane by microbial metabolism triggered by CO2/H2 exposure are studied.
Model to Inform the Expansion of Hydrogen Distribution Infrastructure
Jul 2023
Publication
A growing hydrogen economy requires new hydrogen distribution infrastructure to link geographically distributed hubs of supply and demand. The Hydrogen Optimization with Deployment of Infrastructure (HOwDI) Model helps meet this requirement. The model is a spatially resolved optimization framework that determines location-specific hydrogen production and distribution infrastructure to cost-optimally meet a specified location-based demand. While these results are useful in understanding hydrogen infrastructure development there is uncertainty in some costs that the model uses for inputs. Thus the project team took the modeling effort a step further and developed a Monte Carlo methodology to help manage uncertainties. Seven scenarios were run using existing infrastructure and new demand in Texas exploring different policy and tax approaches. The inclusion of tax credits increased the percentage of runs that could deliver hydrogen at <$4/kg from 31% to 77% and decreased the average dispensed cost from $4.35/kg to $3.55/kg. However even with tax credits there are still some runs where unabated SMR is deployed to meet new demand as the low-carbon production options are not competitive. Every scenario except for the zero-carbon scenario (without tax credits) resulted in at least 20% of the runs meeting the $4/kg dispensed fuel cost target. This indicates that multiple pathways exist to deliver $4/kg hydrogen.
Hydrogen Quality in Used Natual Gas Pipelines: An Experimental Investigation of Contaminants According to ISO 14687:2019 Standard
Sep 2023
Publication
The transport of hydrogen in used natural gas pipelines is a strategic key element of a pan-European hydrogen infrastructure. At the same time accurate knowledge of the hydrogen quality is essential in order to be able to address a wide application range. Therefore an experimental investigation was carried out to find out which contaminants enter into the hydrogen from the used natural gas pipelines. Pipeline elements from the high pressure gas grid of Austria were exposed to hydrogen. Steel pipelines built between 1960 and 2018 which were operated with odorised and pure natural gas were examined. The hydrogen was analysed according to requirements of ISO14687: 2019 Grade D measurement standard. The results show that based on age odorization and sediments different contimenants are introduced. Odorants hydrocarbons but also sulphur compounds ammonia and halogenated hydrogen compounds were identified. Sediments are identified as the main source of impurities. However the concentrations of the introduced contaminants were low (6 nmol/mol to 10 μmol/mol). Quality monitoring with a wide range of detection options for different components (sulphur halogenated compounds hydrocarbons ammonia and atmospheric components) is crucial for real operation. The authors deduce that a Grade A hydrogen quality can be safely achieved in real operation.
Battery and Hydrogen Energy Storage Control in a Smart Energy Network with Flexible Energy Demand Using Deep Reinforcement Learning
Sep 2023
Publication
Smart energy networks provide an effective means to accommodate high penetrations of variable renewable energy sources like solar and wind which are key for the deep decarbonisation of energy production. However given the variability of the renewables as well as the energy demand it is imperative to develop effective control and energy storage schemes to manage the variable energy generation and achieve desired system economics and environmental goals. In this paper we introduce a hybrid energy storage system composed of battery and hydrogen energy storage to handle the uncertainties related to electricity prices renewable energy production and consumption. We aim to improve renewable energy utilisation and minimise energy costs and carbon emissions while ensuring energy reliability and stability within the network. To achieve this we propose a multi-agent deep deterministic policy gradient approach which is a deep reinforcement learning-based control strategy to optimise the scheduling of the hybrid energy storage system and energy demand in real time. The proposed approach is model-free and does not require explicit knowledge and rigorous mathematical models of the smart energy network environment. Simulation results based on real-world data show that (i) integration and optimised operation of the hybrid energy storage system and energy demand reduce carbon emissions by 78.69% improve cost savings by 23.5% and improve renewable energy utilisation by over 13.2% compared to other baseline models; and (ii) the proposed algorithm outperforms the state-of-the-art self-learning algorithms like the deep-Q network.
Assessing the Pressure Losses during Hydrogen Transport in the Current Natural Gas Infrastructure Using Numerical Modelling
May 2023
Publication
The UK government aims to transition its modern natural gas infrastructure towards Hydrogen by 2035. Since hydrogen is a much lighter gas than methane it is important to understand the change in parameters when transporting it. While most modern work in this topic looks at the transport of hydrogen-methane mixtures this work focuses on pure hydrogen transport. The aim of this paper is to highlight the change in gas distribution parameters when natural gas is replaced by hydrogen in the existing infrastructure. This study uses analytical models and computational models to compare the flow of hydrogen and methane in a pipe based on pressure loss. The Darcy-Weisbach and Colebrook-White equations were used for the analytical models and the k- ε model was used for the computational approach. The variables considered in the comparison were the pipe material (X52 Steel and MDPE) and pipe diameters (0.01m–1m). It was observed that hydrogen had to be transported 250–270% the velocity of methane to replicate flow for a fixed length of pipe. Furthermore it was noted that MDPE pipes has 2–31% lower pressure losses compared to X52 steel for all diameters when transporting hydrogen at a high velocity. Lastly it was noted that the analytical model and computational model were in agreement with 1–5% error in their findings.
Large-scale Underground Hydrogen Storage: Integrated Modeling of a Reservoir-wellbore System
Jan 2023
Publication
Underground Hydrogen Storage (UHS) has received significant attention over the past few years as hydrogen seems well-suited for adjusting seasonal energy gaps. We present an integrated reservoir-well model for “Viking A00 the depleted gas field in the North Sea as a potential site for UHS. Our findings show that utilizing the integrated model results in more reasonable predictions as the gas composition changes over time. Sensitivity analyses show that the lighter the cushion gas the more production can be obtained. However the purity of the produced hydrogen will be affected to some extent which can be enhanced by increasing the fill-up period and the injection rate. The results also show that even though hydrogen diffuses into the reservoir and mixes up with the native fluids (mainly methane) the impact of hydrogen diffusion is marginal. All these factors will potentially influence the project's economics.
Benchmark of J55 and X56 Steels on Cracking and Corrosion Effects Under Hydrogen Salt Cavern Boundary Conditions
Feb 2024
Publication
Salt caverns have great potential to store relevant amounts of hydrogen as part of the energy transition. However the durability and suitability of commonly used steels for piping in hydrogen salt caverns is still under research. In this work aging effects focusing on corrosion and cracking patterns of casing steel API 5CT J55 and “H2ready” pipeline steel API 5L X56 were investigated with scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy after accelerated stress tests with pressure/temperature cycling under hydrogen salt cavern-like conditions. Compared to dry conditions significant more corrosion by presence of salt ions was detected. However compared to X56 only for J55 an intensification of corrosion and cracking at the surface due to hydrogen atmosphere was revealed. Pronounced surface cracks were observed for J55 over the entire samples. Overall the results strongly suggest that X56 is more resistant than J55 under the conditions of a hydrogen salt cavern.
Hydrogen Storage for a Net-zero Carbon Future
Apr 2023
Publication
If a hydrogen economy is to become a reality along with efficient and decarbonized production and adequate transportation infrastructure deployment of suitable hydrogen storage facilities will be crucial. This is because due to various technical and economic reasons there is a serious possibility of an imbalance between hydrogen supply and demand. Hydrogen storage could also be pivotal in promoting renewable energy sources and facilitating the decarbonization process by providing long duration storage options which other forms of energy storage such as batteries with capacity limitations or pumped hydro with geographical limitations cannot meet. However hydrogen is not the easiest substance to store and handle. Under ambient conditions the extremely low volumetric energy density of hydrogen does not allow for its efficient and economic storage which means it needs to be compressed liquefied or converted into other substances that are easier to handle and store. Currently there are different hydrogen storage solutions at varying levels of technology market and commercial readiness with different applications depending on the circumstances. This paper evaluates the relative merits and techno-economic features of major types of hydrogen storage options: (i) pure hydrogen storage (ii) synthetic hydrocarbons (iii) chemical hydrides (iv) liquid organic hydrogen carriers (v) metal hydrides and (vi) porous materials. The paper also discusses the main barriers to investment in hydrogen storage and highlights key features of a viable business model in particular the policy and regulatory framework needed to address the primary risks to which potential hydrogen storage investors are exposed.
A Review on the Factors of Liner Collapse in Type IV Hydrogen Storage Vessels
Sep 2023
Publication
The on-board hydrogen storage of mobile applications is a key area of global industrial transformation to hydrogen technology. The research work provides an overview about the principle of hydrogen fuel cell vehicles with a focus on the widespread on-board hydrogen storage technologies. In this work type IV composite pressure vessels in particular are reviewed. The key challenges of polymeric liners are deeply investigated and liner collapse was identified as a critical failure of type IV vessels. Different factors of liner collapse were categorized and relevant material properties - such as permeability physical characteristics and surface properties - were explained in more detail to lay the foundation for further research on high barrier durable polymeric liner materials.
Hydrogen Embrittlement Characteristics in Cold-drawn High-strength Stainless Steel Wires
Mar 2023
Publication
Hydrogen uptake and embrittlement characteristics of a cold-drawn austenitic stainless steel wire were investigated. Slow strain rate testing and fracture surface analysis were applied to determine the hydrogen embrittlement resistance providing an apparent decrease in resistance to hydrogen embrittlement for a 50% degree of cold deformation. The hydrogen content was assessed by thermal desorption and laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy establishing a correlation between the total absorbed hydrogen and the intensity of near-surface hydrogen. The sub-surface hydrogen content of the hot-rolled specimen was determined to be 791 wt.ppm.
No more items...