Transmission, Distribution & Storage
Prospects for the Implementation of Underground Hydrogen Storage in the EU
Dec 2022
Publication
The hydrogen economy is one of the possible directions of development for the European Union economy which in the perspective of 2050 can ensure climate neutrality for the member states. The use of hydrogen in the economy on a larger scale requires the creation of a storage system. Due to the necessary volumes the best sites for storage are geological structures (salt caverns oil and gas deposits or aquifers). This article presents an analysis of prospects for large-scale underground hydrogen storage in geological structures. The political conditions for the implementation of the hydrogen economy in the EU Member States were analysed. The European Commission in its documents (e.g. Green Deal) indicates hydrogen as one of the important elements enabling the implementation of a climate-neutral economy. From the perspective of 2050 the analysis of changes and the forecast of energy consumption in the EU indicate an increase in electricity consumption. The expected increase in the production of energy from renewable sources may contribute to an increase in the production of hydrogen and its role in the economy. From the perspective of 2050 discussed gas should replace natural gas in the chemical metallurgical and transport industries. In the longer term the same process will also be observed in the aviation and maritime sectors. Growing charges for CO2 emissions will also contribute to the development of underground hydrogen storage technology. Geological conditions especially wide-spread aquifers and salt deposits allow the development of underground hydrogen storage in Europe.
Potential of Salt Caverns for Hydrogen Storage in Southern Ontario, Canada
Jul 2023
Publication
Salt caverns produced by solution mining in Southern Ontario provide ideal spaces for gas storage due to their low permeability. Underground hydrogen storage (UHS) is an important part of the future renewable energy market in Ontario in order to achieve global carbon neutrality and to fill the gap left by retiring nuclear power plants. However large-scale hydrogen storage is still restricted by limited storage space on the ground’s surface. In this study hydrogen’s physical and chemical properties are first introduced and characterized by low molecular weight high diffusivity low solubility and low density. Then the geological conditions of the underground reservoirs are analyzed especially salt caverns. Salt caverns with their inert cavity environments and stable physical properties offer the most promising options for future hydrogen storage. The scales heights and thicknesses of the roof and floor salt layers and the internal temperatures and pressures conditions of salt caverns can affect stabilities and storage capacities. Finally several potential problems that may affect the safe storage of hydrogen in salt caverns are discussed. Through the comprehensive analysis of the influencing factors of hydrogen storage in salt caverns this study puts forward the most appropriate development strategy for salt caverns which provides theoretical guidance for UHS in the future and helps to reduce the risk of large-scale storage design.
The Necessity and Feasibility of Hydrogen Storage for Large-Scale, Long-Term Energy Storage in the New Power System in China
Jun 2023
Publication
In the process of building a new power system with new energy sources as the mainstay wind power and photovoltaic energy enter the multiplication stage with randomness and uncertainty and the foundation and support role of large-scale long-time energy storage is highlighted. Considering the advantages of hydrogen energy storage in large-scale cross-seasonal and cross-regional aspects the necessity feasibility and economy of hydrogen energy participation in long-time energy storage under the new power system are discussed. Firstly power supply and demand production simulations were carried out based on the characteristics of new energy generation in China. When the penetration of new energy sources in the new power system reaches 45% long-term energy storage becomes an essential regulation tool. Secondly by comparing the storage duration storage scale and application scenarios of various energy storage technologies it was determined that hydrogen storage is the most preferable choice to participate in large-scale and long-term energy storage. Three long-time hydrogen storage methods are screened out from numerous hydrogen storage technologies including salt-cavern hydrogen storage natural gas blending and solid-state hydrogen storage. Finally by analyzing the development status and economy of the above three types of hydrogen storage technologies and based on the geographical characteristics and resource endowment of China it is pointed out that China will form a hydrogen storage system of “solid state hydrogen storage above ground and salt cavern storage underground” in the future.
Storage Integrity During Underground Hydrogen Storage in Depleted Gas Reservoirs
Nov 2023
Publication
The transition from fossil fuels to renewable energy sources particularly hydrogen has emerged as a central strategy for decarbonization and the pursuit of net-zero carbon emissions. Meeting the demand for large-scale hydrogen storage a crucial component of the hydrogen supply chain has led to the exploration of underground hydrogen storage as an economically viable solution to global energy needs. In contrast to other subsurface storage options such as salt caverns and aquifers which are geographically limited depleted gas reservoirs have garnered increasing attention due to their broader distribution and higher storage capacity. However the safe storage and cycling of hydrogen in depleted gas reservoirs require the preservation of high stability and integrity in the caprock reservoir and wellbore. Nevertheless there exists a significant gap in the current research concerning storage integrity in underground hydrogen storage within depleted gas reservoirs and a systematic approach is lacking. This paper aims to address this gap by reviewing the primary challenges associated with storage integrity including geochemical reactions microbial activities faults and fractures and perspectives on hydrogen cycling. The study comprehensively reviews the processes and impacts such as abiotic and biotic mineral dissolution/precipitation reactivation and propagation of faults and fractures in caprock and host-rock wellbore instability due to cement degradation and casing corrosion and stress changes during hydrogen cycling. To provide a practical solution a technical screening tool has been developed considering controlling variables risks and consequences affecting storage integrity. Finally this paper highlights knowledge gaps and suggests feasible methods and pathways to mitigate these risks facilitating the development of large-scale underground hydrogen storage in depleted gas reservoirs.
How a Grid Company Could Enter the Hydrogen Industry through a New Business Model: A Case Study in China
Mar 2023
Publication
The increasing penetration of renewable and distributed resources signals a global boom in energy transition but traditional grid utilities have yet to share in much of the triumph at the current stage. Higher grid management costs lower electricity prices fewer customers and other challenges have emerged along the path toward renewable energy but many more opportunities await to be seized. Most importantly there are insufficient studies on how grid utilities can thrive within the hydrogen economy. Through a case study on the State Grid Corporation of China we identify the strengths weaknesses opportunities and threats (SWOT) of grid utilities within the hydrogen economy. Based on these factors we recommend that grids integrate hydrogen into the energy-as-a-service model and deliver it to industrial customers who are under decarbonization pressure. We also recommend that grid utilities fund a joint venture with pipeline companies to optimize electricity and hydrogen transmissions simultaneously.
The Potential Role of Ammonia for Hydrogen Storage and Transport: A Critical Review of Challenges and Opportunities
Aug 2023
Publication
Hydrogen is being included in several decarbonization strategies as a potential contributor in some hard-to-abate applications. Among other challenges hydrogen storage represents a critical aspect to be addressed either for stationary storage or for transporting hydrogen over long distances. Ammonia is being proposed as a potential solution for hydrogen storage as it allows storing hydrogen as a liquid chemical component at mild conditions. Nevertheless the use of ammonia instead of pure hydrogen faces some challenges including the health and environmental issues of handling ammonia and the competition with other markets such as the fertilizer market. In addition the technical and economic efficiency of single steps such as ammonia production by means of the Haber–Bosch process ammonia distribution and storage and possibly the ammonia cracking process to hydrogen affects the overall supply chain. The main purpose of this review paper is to shed light on the main aspects related to the use of ammonia as a hydrogen energy carrier discussing technical economic and environmental perspectives with the aim of supporting the international debate on the potential role of ammonia in supporting the development of hydrogen pathways. The analysis also compares ammonia with alternative solutions for the long-distance transport of hydrogen including liquefied hydrogen and other liquid organic carriers such as methanol.
Underground Hydrogen Storage Safety: Experimental Study of Hydrogen Diffusion through Caprocks
Jan 2024
Publication
Underground Hydrogen Storage (UHS) provides a large-scale and safe solution to balance the fluctuations in energy production from renewable sources and energy consumption but requires a proper and detailed characterization of the candidate reservoirs. The scope of this study was to estimate the hydrogen diffusion coefficient for real caprock samples from two natural gas storage reservoirs that are candidates for underground hydrogen storage. A significant number of adsorption/desorption tests were carried out using a Dynamic Gravimetric Vapor/Gas Sorption System. A total of 15 samples were tested at the reservoir temperature of 45 °C and using both hydrogen and methane. For each sample two tests were performed with the same gas. Each test included four partial pressure steps of sorption alternated with desorption. After applying overshooting and buoyancy corrections the data were then interpreted using the early time approximation of the solution to the diffusion equation. Each interpretable partial pressure step provided a value of the diffusion coefficient. In total more than 90 estimations of the diffusion coefficient out of 120 partial pressure steps were available allowing a thorough comparison between the diffusion of hydrogen and methane: hydrogen in the range of 1 × 10−10 m2 /s to 6 × 10−8 m2 /s and methane in the range of 9 × 10−10 m2 /s to 2 × 10−8 m2 /s. The diffusion coefficients measured on wet samples are 2 times lower compared to those measured on dry samples. Hysteresis in hydrogen adsorption/desorption was also observed.
Modelling Hydrogen Storage and Filling Systems: A Dynamic and Customizable Toolkit
Aug 2023
Publication
Hydrogen plays a vital role in decarbonizing the mobility sector. With the number of hydrogen vehicles expected to drastically increase a network of refuelling stations needs to be built to keep up with the hydrogen demand. However further research and development on hydrogen refuelling infrastructure storage and standardization is required to overcome technical and economic barriers. Simulation tools can reduce time and costs during the design phase but existing models do not fully support calculations of complete and arbitrary system layouts. Therefore a flexible simulation toolbox for rapid investigations of hydrogen refuelling and extraction processes as well as development of refuelling infrastructure vehicle tank systems and refuelling protocols for non-standardized applications was developed. Our model library H2VPATT comprises of typical components found in refuelling infrastructure. The key component is the hydrogen tank model. The simulation model was successfully validated with measurement data from refuelling tests of a 320 l type III tank.
Impact of Experimentally Measured Relative Permeability Hysteresis on Reservoir-scale Performance of Undergound Hydrogen Storage (UHS)
Jan 2024
Publication
Underground Hydrogen Storage (UHS) is an emerging large-scale energy storage technology. Researchers are investigating its feasibility and performance including its injectivity productivity and storage capacity through numerical simulations. However several ad-hoc relative permeability and capillary pressure functions have been used in the literature with no direct link to the underlying physics of the hydrogen storage and production process. Recent relative permeability measurements for the hydrogen-brine system show very low hydrogen relative permeability and strong liquid phase hysteresis very different to what has been observed for other fluid systems for the same rock type. This raises the concern as to what extend the existing studies in the literature are able to reliably quantify the feasibility of the potential storage projects. In this study we investigate how experimentally measured hydrogen-brine relative permeability hysteresis affects the performance of UHS projects through numerical reservoir simulations. Relative permeability data measured during a hydrogen-water core-flooding experiment within ADMIRE project is used to design a relative permeability hysteresis model. Next numerical simulation for a UHS project in a generic braided-fluvial water-gas reservoir is performed using this hysteresis model. A performance assessment is carried out for several UHS scenarios with different drainage relative permeability curves hysteresis model coefficients and injection/production rates. Our results show that both gas and liquid relative permeability hysteresis play an important role in UHS irrespective of injection/production rate. Ignoring gas hysteresis may cause up to 338% of uncertainty on cumulative hydrogen production as it has negative effects on injectivity and productivity due to the resulting limited variation range of gas saturation and pressure during cyclic operations. In contrast hysteresis in the liquid phase relative permeability resolves this issue to some extent by improving the displacement of the liquid phase. Finally implementing relative permeability curves from other fluid systems during UHS performance assessment will cause uncertainty in terms of gas saturation and up to 141% underestimation on cumulative hydrogen production. These observations illustrate the importance of using relative permeability curves characteristic of hydrogen-brine system for assessing the UHS performances.
Underground Hydrogen Storage: Integrated Surface Facilities and Fluid Flow Modelling for Depleted Gas Reservoirs
Aug 2023
Publication
We report a new techno-economic model to assess performance and capital costs for large-scale underground hydrogen storage in depleted gas reservoirs. A simulation toolbox is developed to model surface facilities and to simulate the hydrogen flow in geological formations in an integrated fashion.<br/>Integrated modelling revealed the following key insights: 1) A buffer system is highly desirable to absorb inherent variability in upstream hydrogen production; 2) hydrogen mixing with existing gases in the reservoir together with gravity segregation and diffusion results in a decline in hydrogen purity at the wellhead over time and can require increased purification; 3) the capital cost is dominated by the cost of cushion gas (hydrogen) and the compression system where about 9% of the total energy content of the hydrogen is consumed for compression. The scenarios modelled in our study result in a levelized cost of storage in Australia ranging from 2.3 to 4.29 A$/(kg).
Evaluation of Hydrogen Transportation Networks - A Case Study on the German Energy System
May 2023
Publication
Not only due to the energy crisis European policymakers are exploring options to substitute natural gas with renewable hydrogen. A condition for the application of hydrogen is a functioning transportation infrastructure. However the most efficient transport of large hydrogen quantities is still unclear and deeper analyses are missing. A promising option is converting the existing gas infrastructure. This study presents a novel approach to develop hydrogen networks by applying the Steiner tree algorithm to derive candidates and evaluate their costs. This method uses the existing grid (brownfield) and is compared to a newly built grid (Greenfield). The goal is the technical and economic evaluation and comparison of hydrogen network candidates. The methodology is applied to the German gas grid and demand and supply scenarios covering the industry heavy-duty transport power and heating sector imports and domestic production. Five brownfield candidates are compared to a greenfield candidate. The candidates differ by network length and pipeline diameters to consider the transported volume of hydrogen. The economic evaluation concludes that most brownfield candidates’ cost is significantly lower than those of the greenfield candidate. The candidates can serve as starting points for flow simulations and policymakers can estimate the cost based on the results.
Hydrogen Liquefaction: A Review of the Fundamental Physics, Engineering Practice and Future Opportunities
Apr 2022
Publication
Hydrogen is emerging as one of the most promising energy carriers for a decarbonised global energy system. Transportation and storage of hydrogen are critical to its large-scale adoption and to these ends liquid hydrogen is being widely considered. The liquefaction and storage processes must however be both safe and efficient for liquid hydrogen to be viable as an energy carrier. Identifying the most promising liquefaction processes and associated transport and storage technologies is therefore crucial; these need to be considered in terms of a range of interconnected parameters ranging from energy consumption and appropriate materials usage to considerations of unique liquid-hydrogen physics (in the form of ortho–para hydrogen conversion) and boil-off gas handling. This study presents the current state of liquid hydrogen technology across the entire value chain whilst detailing both the relevant underpinning science (e.g. the quantum behaviour of hydrogen at cryogenic temperatures) and current liquefaction process routes including relevant unit operation design and efficiency. Cognisant of the challenges associated with a projected hydrogen liquefaction plant capacity scale-up from the current 32 tonnes per day to greater than 100 tonnes per day to meet projected hydrogen demand this study also reflects on the next-generation of liquid-hydrogen technologies and the scientific research and development priorities needed to enable them.
A Review of Gas Phase Inhibition of Gaseous Hydrogen Embrittlement in Pipeline Steels
Feb 2024
Publication
The addition of small amounts of certain gases such as O2 CO and SO2 may mitigate hydrogen embrittlement in high-pressure gas transmission pipelines that transport hydrogen. To practically implement such inhibition in gas transmission pipelines a comprehensive understanding and quantification of this effect are essential. This review examines the impact of various added gases to hydrogen including typical odorants on gaseous hydrogen embrittlement of steels and evaluates their inhibition effectiveness. O2 CO and SO2 were found to be effective inhibitors of hydrogen embrittlement. Yet the results in the literature have not always been consistent partly because of the diverse range of mechanical tests and their parameters. The absence of systematic studies hinders the evaluation of the feasibility of using gas phase inhibitors for controlling gaseous hydrogen embrittlement. A method to quantify the effectiveness of gas phase inhibition is proposed using gas phase permeation studies.
Liquefied Hydrogen Value Chain: A Detailed Techno-economic Evaluation for its Application in the Industrial and Mobility Sectors
Oct 2023
Publication
Green hydrogen can be efficiently produced in regions rich in renewable sources far from the European largeproduction sites and delivered to the continent for utilization in the industrial and mobility sectors. In this work the transportation of hydrogen from North Africa to North Italy in its liquefied form is considered. A technoeconomic assessment is performed on its value chain which includes liquefaction storage maritime transport distribution regasification and compression. The calculated transport cost for the industrial application (delivery to a hydrogen valley) ranges from 6.14 to 9.16 €/kg while for the mobility application (delivery to refueling stations) the range is 10.96–17.71 €/kg. In the latter case the most cost-effective configuration involves the distribution of liquefied hydrogen and regasification at the refueling stations. The liquefaction process is the cost driver of the value chain in all the investigated cases suggesting the importance of its optimization to minimize the overall transport cost.
Preventing Hydrogen Embrittlement: The Role of Barrier Coatings for the Hydrogen Economy
May 2023
Publication
Hydrogen barrier coatings are protective layers consisting of materials with a low intrinsic hydrogen diffusivity and solubility showing the potential to delay reduce or hinder hydrogen permeation. Hydrogen barrier coatings are expected to enable steels which are susceptible to hydrogen embrittlement specifically cost-effective low alloy-steels or light-weight high-strength steels for applications in a hydrogen economy. Predominantly ceramic coating materials have been investigated for this purpose including oxides nitrides and carbides. In this review the state of the art with respect to hydrogen permeation is discussed for a variety of coatings. Al2O3 TiAlN and TiC appear to be the most promising candidates from a large pool of ceramic materials. Coating methods are compared with respect to their ability to produce layers with suitable quality and their potential for scaling up for industrial use. Different setups for the characterisation of hydrogen permeability are discussed using both gaseous hydrogen and hydrogen originating from an electrochemical reaction. Finally possible pathways for improvement and optimisation of hydrogen barrier coatings are outlined.
Subsurface Renewable Energy Storage Capcity for Hydrogen, Methane and Compress Air - A Performance Assessment Study from the North German Basin
Jul 2021
Publication
The transition to renewable energy sources to mitigate climate change will require large-scale energy storage to dampen the fluctuating availability of renewable sources and to ensure a stable energy supply. Energy storage in the geological subsurface can provide capacity and support the cycle times required. This study investigates hydrogen storage methane storage and compressed air energy storage in subsurface porous formations and quantifies potential storage capacities as well as storage rates on a site-specific basis. For part of the North German Basin used as the study area potential storage sites are identified employing a newly developed structural geological model. Energy storage capacities estimated from a volume-based approach are 6510 TWh and 24544 TWh for hydrogen and methane respectively. For a consistent comparison of storage capacities including compressed air energy storage the stored exergy is calculated as 6735 TWh 25795 TWh and 358 TWh for hydrogen methane and compressed air energy storage respectively. Evaluation of storage deliverability indicates that high deliverability rates are found mainly in two of the three storage formations considered. Even accounting for the uncertainty in geological parameters the storage potential for the three considered storage technologies is significantly larger than the predicted demand and suitable storage rates are achievable in all storage formations.
Modelling Underground Hydrogen Storage: A State-of-the-art Review of Fundamental Approaches and Findings
Dec 2023
Publication
This review presents a state-of-the-art of geochemical geomechanical and hydrodynamic modelling studies in the Underground Hydrogen Storage (UHS) domain. Geochemical modelling assessed the reactivity of hydrogen and res pective fluctuations in hydrogen losses using kinetic reaction rates rock mineralogy brine salinity and the integration of hydrogen redox reactions. Existing geomechanics studies offer an array of coupled hydromechanical models suggesting a decline in rock failure during the withdrawal phase in aquifers compared to injection phase. Hydrodynamic modelling evaluations indicate the critical importance of relative permeability hysteresis in determining the UHS performance. Solubility and diffusion of hydrogen gas appear to have minimal impact on UHS. Injection and production rates cushion gas deployment and reservoir heterogeneity however significantly affect the UHS performance stressing the need for thorough modelling and experimental studies. Most of the current UHS modelling efforts focus on assessing the hydrodynamic aspects which are crucial for understanding the viability and safety of UHS. In contrast the lesser-explored geochemical and geomechanical considerations point to potential research gaps. A variety of modelling software tools such as CMG Eclipse COMSOL and PHREEQC evaluated those UHS underlying effects along with a few recent applications of datadriven-based Machine Learning (ML) techniques for enhanced accuracy. This review identified several unresolved challenges in UHS modelling: pronounced lack of expansive datasets leading to a gap between model predictions and their practical reliability; need robust methodologies capable of capturing natural subsurface heterogeneity while upscaling from precise laboratory data to field-scale conditions; demanding intensive computational resources and novel strategies to enhance simulation efficiency; and a gap in addressing geological uncertainties in subsurface environments suggesting that methodologies from oil reservoir simulations could be adapted for UHS. This comprehensive review offers a critical synthesis of the prevailing approaches challenges and research gaps in the domain of UHS thus providing a valuable reference document for further modelling efforts facilitating the informed advancements in this critical domain towards the realization of sustainable energy solutions.
On the Bulk Transport of Green Hydrogen at Sea: Comparison Between Submarine Pipeline and Compressed and Liquefied Transport by Ship
Jan 2023
Publication
This paper compares six (6) alternatives for green hydrogen transport at sea. Two (2) alternatives of liquid hydrogen (LH2) by ship two (2) alternatives of compressed hydrogen (cH2) by ship and two (2) alternatives of hydrogen by pipeline. The ship alternatives study having hydrogen storage media at both end terminals to reduce the ships’ time at port or prescinding of them and reduce the immobilized capital. In the case of the pipeline new models are proposed by considering pressure costs. One scenario considers that there are compression stations every 500 km and the other one considers that there are none along the way. These alternatives are assessed under nine different scenarios that combine three distances: 100 km 2500 km and 5000 km; and three export rates of hydrogen 100 kt/y 1 Mt/y and 10 Mt/y. The results show including uncertainty bands that for the 100 km of distance the best alternative is the pipeline. For 2500 km and 100 kt/y the top alternative is cH2 shipping without storage facilities at the port terminals. For 2500 km and 1 Mt/y and for 5000 km and 100 kt/y the best alternatives are cH2 or LH2 shipping. For the remaining scenarios the best alternative is LH2 shipping.
Benchmark Study for the Simulation of Underground Hydrogen Storage Operations
Aug 2022
Publication
While the share of renewable energy sources increased within the last years with an ongoing upward trend the energy sector is facing the problem of storing large amounts of electrical energy properly. To compensate daily and seasonal fluctuations a sufficient storage system has to be developed. The storage of hydrogen in the subsurface referred to as Underground Hydrogen Storage (UHS) shows potential to be a solution for this problem. Hydrogen produced from excess energy via electrolysis is injected into a subsurface reservoir and withdrawn when required. As hydrogen possesses unique thermodynamic properties many commonly used correlations can not be simply transferred to a system with a high hydrogen content. Mixing processes with the present fluids are essential to be understood to achieve high storage efficiencies. Additionally in the past microbial activity e.g. by methanogenic archaea was observed leading to a changing fluid composition over time. To evaluate the capability of reservoir simulators to cover these processes the present study establishes a benchmark scenario of an exemplary underground hydrogen storage scenario. The benchmark comprises of a generic sandstone gas reservoir and a typical gas storage schedule is defined. Based on this benchmark the present study assesses the capabilities of the commercial simulator Schlumberger ECLIPSE and the open-source simulator DuMux to mimic UHS related processes such as hydrodynamics but also microbial activity. While ECLIPSE offers a reasonable mix of user-friendliness and computation time DuMux allows for a better adjustment of correlations and the implementation of biochemical reactions. The corresponding input data (ECLIPSE format) and relevant results are provided in a repository to allow this simulation study’s reproduction and extension.
Hydrogen Export Competitiveness Index for a Sustainable Hydrogen Economy
May 2023
Publication
The transition to cleaner energy sources including renewables introduces the need for versatile and transportable energy carriers such as hydrogen. This paper aims to quantify the hydrogen export competitiveness of all countries using a newly developed comprehensive index. The developed competitiveness index includes 21 indicators under four main categories: resource availability and potential economic and financial potential political and regulatory status and industrial knowledge. Expert interviews and surveys are conducted to properly identify choose and modify the categories and indicators and to calculate the appropriate weight for each. Top-ranking countries include the United States Australia Canada United Kingdom China Norway India Russia Netherlands and Germany and they are poised to be significant players in the hydrogen market. Policy recommendations for growing the hydrogen production and export sector are given based on each category.
No more items...