France
Safety Cost of a Large Scale Hydrogen System for Photovoltaic Energy Regulation
Sep 2011
Publication
Hydrogen can be used as a buffer for storing intermittent electricity produced by solar plants and/or wind farms. The MYRTE project in Corsica France aims to operate and test a large scale hydrogen facility for regulating the electricity produced by a 560 kWp photovoltaic plant.
Due to the large quantity of hydrogen and oxygen produced and stored (respectively 333 kg and 2654 kg) this installation faces safety issues and safety regulations constraints that can lead to extra costs. These extra costs may concern detectors monitoring barrier equipments that have to be taken into account for evaluating the system‘s total cost.
Relying on the MYRTE example that is an R&D platform the present work consists in listing the whole environmental and safety regulations to be applied in France on both Hydrogen and Oxygen production and storage. A methodology has been developed [1] [2] for evaluating safety extra costs. This methodology takes into account various hydrogen storage technologies (gaseous and solid state) and is applicable to other ways of storage (batteries etc.) to compare them. Results of this work based on a forecast of the operating platform over 20 years can be used to extrapolate and/or optimize future safety costs of next large scale hydrogen systems for further PV or wind energy storage applications.
Due to the large quantity of hydrogen and oxygen produced and stored (respectively 333 kg and 2654 kg) this installation faces safety issues and safety regulations constraints that can lead to extra costs. These extra costs may concern detectors monitoring barrier equipments that have to be taken into account for evaluating the system‘s total cost.
Relying on the MYRTE example that is an R&D platform the present work consists in listing the whole environmental and safety regulations to be applied in France on both Hydrogen and Oxygen production and storage. A methodology has been developed [1] [2] for evaluating safety extra costs. This methodology takes into account various hydrogen storage technologies (gaseous and solid state) and is applicable to other ways of storage (batteries etc.) to compare them. Results of this work based on a forecast of the operating platform over 20 years can be used to extrapolate and/or optimize future safety costs of next large scale hydrogen systems for further PV or wind energy storage applications.
Fire Risk on High-pressure Full Composite Cylinders for Automotive Applications
Sep 2011
Publication
In the event of a fire the TPRD (Thermally activated Pressure Relief Device) prevents the high-pressure full composite cylinder from bursting by detecting high temperatures and releasing the pressurized gas. The current safety performance of both the vessel and the TPRD is demonstrated by an engulfing bonfire test. However there is no requirement concerning the effect of the TPRD release which may produce a hazardous hydrogen flame due to the high flow-rate of the TPRD. It is necessary to understand better the behavior of an unprotected composite cylinder exposed to fire in order to design appropriate protection for it and to be able to reduce the length of any potential hydrogen flame. For that purpose a test campaign was performed on a 36 L cylinder with a design pressure of 70 MPa. The time from fire exposure to the bursting of this cylinder (the burst delay) was measured. The influence of the fire type (partial or global) and the influence of the pressure in the cylinder during the exposure were studied. It was found that the TPRD orifice diameter should be significantly reduced compared to current practice.
Numerical Investigation of a Mechanical Device Subjected to a Deflagration-to-detonation Transition
Sep 2011
Publication
In this work we evaluate the consequences of the combustion of a stoichiometric mixture of hydrogen-air on a mechanical device which can be considered as a long tube. In order to choose the most dangerous combustion regime for the mechanical device we devote a particular attention to the investigation of the 1D deflagration-to-detonation transition. Then once established the most dangerous combustion regime we compute the reacting flow and the stress and strain in the mechanical device. Analyses are performed using both semi-analytical solutions and Europlexus a computer program for the simulation of fluid-structure systems under transient dynamic loading.
Quantifying the Hydrogen Embrittlement of Pipeline Steels for Safety Considerations
Sep 2011
Publication
In a near future with an increasing use of hydrogen as an energy vector gaseous hydrogen transport as well as high capacity storage may imply the use of high strength steel pipelines for economical reasons. However such materials are well known to be sensitive to hydrogen embrittlement (HE). For safety reasons it is thus necessary to improve and clarify the means of quantifying embrittlement. The present paper exposes the changes in mechanical properties of a grade API X80 steel through numerous mechanical tests i.e. tensile tests disk pressure test fracture toughness and fatigue crack growth measurements WOL tests performed either in neutral atmosphere or in high-pressure of hydrogen gas. The observed results are then discussed in front of safety considerations for the redaction of standards for the qualification of materials dedicating to hydrogen transport.
Delayed Explosion of Hydrogen High Pressure Jets in a Highly Obstructed Geometry
Sep 2017
Publication
Delayed explosions of accidental high pressure hydrogen releases are an important risk scenario in safety studies of production plants transportation pipelines and fuel cell vehicles charging stations. Such explosions were widely explored in multiple experimental and numerical investigations. Explosion of high pressure releases in highly obstructed geometries with high blockage ratio is a much more complicated phenomenon. This paper is dedicated to the experimental investigation of the influence of obstacles on a delayed deflagration of hydrogen jets. The computational fluid dynamics (CFD) code FLACS is used to reproduce experimental data. In the current study the computed overpressure signals are compared to the experimentally measured ones at different monitoring points. Simulations are in close agreement with experimental results and can be used to predict overpressure where experimental pressure detectors were saturated. For homogenous stationary clouds a new approach of equivalent mixture of H2/air (~16.5%) to stoichiometric mixture of CH4/air is suggested. This approach is validated versus experimental data from the literature in terms of overpressure maxima. A parametric study is performed using FLACS for various concentrations in the same geometry in order to identify a possible transition from deflagration to detonation.
Numerical and Experimental Investigation of H2-air and H2-O2 Detonation Parameters in a 9 m Long Tube, Introduction of a New Detonation Model
Sep 2017
Publication
Experimental and numerical investigation of hydrogen-air and hydrogen-oxygen detonation parameters was performed. A new detonation model was introduced and validated against the experimental data. Experimental set-up consisted of 9 m long tube with 0.17 m in diameter where pressure was measured with piezoelectric transducers located along the channel. Numerical simulations were performed within OpenFoam code based on progress variable equation where the detonative source term accounts for autoignition effects. Autoignition delay times were computed at a simulation run-time with the use of a multivariate regression model where independent variables were: pressure temperature and fuel concentration. The dependent variable was the autoignition delay time. Range of the analyzed gaseous mixture composition varied between 20% and 50% of hydrogen-air and 50%–66% of hydrogen in oxygen. Simulations were performed using LES one-equation eddy viscosity turbulence model in 2D and 3D. Calculations were validated against experimental data.
Effects of Oxidants on Hydrogen Spontaneous Ignition: Experiments and Modelling
Sep 2017
Publication
Experiments were performed on the influence of oxidants (air pure oxygen O2 and pure nitrous oxide N2O at atmospheric pressure) in the straight expansion tube after the burst disk on the hydrogen spontaneous ignition. The lowest pressure at which the spontaneous ignition is observed has been researched for a 4 mm diameter tube with a length of 10 cm for the two oxidant gases. The ignition phenomenon is observed with a high speed camera and the external overpressures are measured. Numerical simulations have also been conducted with the high resolution CFD approach detailed chemistry formerly developed by Wen and co-workers. Comparison is made between the predictions and the experimental data.
Prevention of Hydrogen Accumulation Inside the Vacuum Vessel Pressure Suppression System of the ITER Facility by Means of Passive Auto-catalytic Recombiners
Sep 2017
Publication
Hydrogen safety is a relevant topic for both nuclear fission and fusion power plants. Hydrogen generated in the course of a severe accident may endanger the integrity of safety barriers and may result in radioactive releases. In the case of the ITER fusion facility accident scenarios with water ingress consider the release of hydrogen into the suppression tank (ST) of the vacuum vessel pressure suppression system (VVPSS). Under the assumption of additional air ingress the formation of flammable gas mixtures may lead to explosions and safety component failure.<br/>The installation of passive auto-catalytic recombiners (PARs) inside the ST which are presently used as safety devices inside the containments of nuclear fission reactors is one option under consideration to mitigate such a scenario. PARs convert hydrogen into water vapor by means of passive mechanisms and have been qualified for operation under the conditions of a nuclear power plant accident since the 1990s.<br/>In order to support on-going hydrogen safety considerations simulations of accident scenarios using the CFD code ANSYS-CFX are foreseen. In this context the in-house code REKO-DIREKT is coupled to CFX to simulate PAR operation. However the operational boundary conditions for hydrogen recombination (e.g. temperature pressure gas mixture) of a fusion reactor scenario differ significantly from those of a fission reactor. In order to enhance the code towards realistic PAR operation a series of experiments has been performed in the REKO-4 facility with specific focus on ITER conditions. These specifically include operation under sub-atmospheric pressure (0.2–1.0 bar) gas compositions ranging from lean to rich H2/O2 mixtures and superposed flow conditions.<br/>The paper gives an overview of the experimental program presents results achieved and gives an outlook on the modelling approach towards accident scenario simulation.
Experimental Determination of Minimum Ignition Current (MIC) for Hydrogen & Methane Mixtures for the Determination of the Explosion Group Corresponding to IEC 60079-20-1
Sep 2017
Publication
Power to gas could get an important issue in future permitting the valorisation of green electric excess energy by producing hydrogen mixing it with natural gas (NG) and use the NG grid as temporary storage. NG grid stakeholders expect that blends up to 20% seem to be a realistic scenario. The knowledge of the explosion group for these hydrogen/NG (H2NG) mixtures is a necessary information for the choice of equipment and protective systems intended for the use in potentially explosive atmospheres of these mixtures. Therefore we determined experimentally the minimum ignition current (MIC) the MIC ratios referenced on MIC of pure methane corresponding to IEC 60079-20-1 standard. The results are compared to those obtained by maximum experimental safe gap (MESG) the second standardized method. The tested gas mixtures started from 2 vol.% volume admixture in methane rising in 2% steps up to 20 vol.% of hydrogen. The interpretation of these results could conduct to consider methane/hydrogen mixtures containing more than 14 vol.% of hydrogen as Group IIB gases.
Delayed Explosion of Hydrogen High Pressure Jets: An Inter Comparison Benchmark Study
Sep 2017
Publication
Delayed explosions of accidental high pressure hydrogen releases are an important risk scenario for safety studies of production plants transportation pipelines and fuel cell vehicles charging stations. As a consequence the assessment of the associated consequences requires accurate and validated prediction based on modelling and experimental approaches. In the frame of the French working group dedicated to the evaluation of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) codes for the modelling of explosion phenomena this study is dedicated to delayed explosions of high pressure releases. Two participants using two different codes have evaluated the capacity of CFD codes to reproduce explosions of high pressure hydrogen releases. In the first step the jet dispersion is modelled and simulation results are compared with experimental data in terms of axial and radial concentration dilution velocity decay and turbulent characteristics of jets. In the second step a delayed explosion is modelled and compared to experimental data in terms of overpressure at different monitor points. Based on this investigation several recommendations for CFD modelling of high pressure jets explosions are suggested.
European Hydrogen Safety Training Programme for First Responders: Hyresponse Outcomes and Perspectives
Sep 2017
Publication
The paper presents the outcomes of the HyResponse project i.e. the European Hydrogen Safety Training Programme for first responders. The threefold training is described: the content of the educational training is presented the operational training platform and its mock-up real scale transport and hydrogen stationary installations are detailed and the innovative virtual tools and training exercises are highlighted. The paper underlines the outcomes the three pilot sessions as well as the Emergency Response Guide available on the HyResponse’s public website. The next steps for widespread dissemination into the community are discussed.
Vented Hydrogen-air Deflagration in a Small Enclosed Volume
Sep 2013
Publication
Since the rapid development of hydrogen stationary and vehicle fuel cells the last decade it is of importance to improve the prediction of overpressure generated during an accidental explosion which could occur in a confined part of the system. To this end small-scale vented hydrogen–air explosions were performed in a transparent cubic enclosure with a volume of 3375 cm3. The flame propagation was followed with a high speed camera and the overpressure inside the enclosure was recorded using high frequency piezoelectric transmitters. The effects of vent area and ignition location on the amplitude of pressure peaks in the enclosed volume were investigated. Indeed vented deflagration generates several pressures peaks according to the configuration and each peak can be the dominating pressure. The parametric study concerned three ignition locations and five square vent sizes.
Experimental Study of the Concentration Build-Up Regimes in an Enclosure Without Ventilation
Sep 2011
Publication
We present an experimental investigation of the different concentration build-up regimes encountered during a release of helium/air mixture in an empty enclosure without ventilation. The release is a vertical jet issuing from a nozzle located near the floor. The nozzle diameter the flow rate and the composition of the injected mixture have been varied such that the injection Richardson number ranges from 6 × 10−6 to 190. The volume Richardson number which gives the ability of the release to mix the enclosure content ranges from 2 × 10−3 to 2 × 104. This wide range allowed reaching three distinct regimes: stratified stratified with a homogeneous upper layer and homogenous.
Failure of PEM Water Electrolysis Cells: Case Study Involving Anode Dissolution and Membrane Thinning
Sep 2013
Publication
Polymer electrolyte membrane (PEM) water electrolysis is an efficient and environmental friendly method that can be used for the production of molecular hydrogen of electrolytic grade using zero-carbon power sources such as renewable and nuclear. However market applications are asking for cost reduction and performances improvement. This can be achieved by increasing operating current density and lifetime of operation. Concerning performance safety reliability and durability issues the membrane-electrode assembly (MEA) is the weakest cell component. Most performance losses and most accidents occurring during PEM water electrolysis are usually due to the MEA. The purpose of this communication is to report on some specific degradation mechanisms that have been identified as a potential source of performance loss and membrane failure. An accelerated degradation test has been performed on a MEA by applying galvanostatic pulses. Platinum has been used as electrocatalyst at both anode and cathode in order to accelerate degradation rate by maintaining higher cell voltage and higher anodic potential that otherwise would have occurred if conventional Ir/IrOx catalysts had been used. Experimental evidence of degradation mechanisms have been obtained by post-mortem analysis of the MEA using microscopy and chemical analysis. Details of these degradation processes are presented and discussed.
Mixed E-learning and Virtual Reality Pedagogical Approach for Innovative Hydrogen Safety Training for First Responders
Oct 2015
Publication
Within the scope of the HyResponse project the development of a specialised training programme is currently underway. Utilizing an andragogy approach to teaching distance learning is mixed with classroom instructors-led activities while hands-on training on a full-scale simulator is coupled with an innovative virtual reality based experience. Although the course is dedicated mainly to first responders provision has been made to incorporate not only simple table-top and drill exercises but also full-scale training involving all functional emergency response organisations at multi-agency cooperation level. The developed curriculum includes basics of hydrogen safety first responders' procedures and incident management expectations
Best Practice in Numerical Simulation and CFD Benchmarking. Results from the SUSANA Project
Sep 2017
Publication
Correct use of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) tools is essential in order to have confidence in the results. A comprehensive set of Best Practice Guidelines (BPG) in numerical simulations for Fuel Cells and Hydrogen applications has been one of the main outputs of the SUSANA project. These BPG focus on the practical needs of engineers in consultancies and industry undertaking CFD simulations or evaluating CFD simulation results in support of hazard/risk assessments of hydrogen facilities as well as on the needs of regulatory authorities. This contribution presents a summary of the BPG document. All crucial aspects of numerical simulations are addressed such as selection of the physical models domain design meshing boundary conditions and selection of numerical parameters. BPG cover all hydrogen safety relative phenomena i.e. release and dispersion ignition jet fire deflagration and detonation. A series of CFD benchmarking exercises are also presented serving as examples of appropriate modelling strategies.
Hydrogen Storage – Industrial Prospectives
Sep 2011
Publication
The topic of this paper is to give an historical and technical overview of hydrogen storage vessels and to detail the specific issues and constraints of hydrogen energy uses. Hydrogen as an industrial gas is stored either as a compressed or as a refrigerated liquefied gas. Since the beginning of the last century hydrogen is stored in seamless steel cylinders. At the end of the 60 s tubes also made of seamless steels were used; specific attention was paid to hydrogen embrittlement in the 70 s. Aluminum cylinders were also used for hydrogen storage since the end of the 60 s but their cost was higher compared to steel cylinders and smaller water capacity. To further increase the service pressure of hydrogen tanks or to slightly decrease the weight metallic cylinders can be hoop-wrapped. Then with specific developments for space or military applications fully-wrapped tanks started to be developed in the 80 s. Because of their low weight they started to be used in for portable applications: for vehicles (on-board storages of natural gas) for leisure applications (paint-ball) etc… These fully-wrapped composite tanks named types III and IV are now developed for hydrogen energy storage; the requested pressure is very high (from 700 to 850 bar) leads to specific issues which are discussed. Each technology is described in term of materials manufacturing technologies and approval tests. The specific issues due to very high pressure are depicted. Hydrogen can also be stored in liquid form (refrigerated liquefied gases). The first cryogenic vessels were used in the 60s. In the following the main characteristics of this type of storage will be indicated.
Explosion and Fire Risk Analyses of Maritime Fuel Cell Rooms with Hydrogen
Sep 2017
Publication
A methodology for explosion and fire risk analyses in enclosed rooms is presented. The objectives of this analysis are to accurately predict the risks associated with hydrogen leaks in maritime applications and to use the approach to provide decision support regarding design and risk-prevention and risk mitigating measures. The methodology uses CFD tools and simpler consequence models for ventilation dispersion and explosion scenarios as well as updated frequency for leaks and ignition. Risk is then efficiently calculated with a Monte Carlo routine capturing the transient behavior of the leak. This makes it possible to efficiently obtain effects of sensitivities and design options maintaining safety and reducing costs.
Threshold Stress Intensity Factor for Hydrogen Assisted Cracking of Cr-Mo Steel Used as Stationary Storage Buffer of a Hydrogen Refueling Station
Oct 2015
Publication
In order to determine appropriate value for threshold stress intensity factor for hydrogen-assisted cracking (KIH) constant-displacement and rising-load tests were conducted in high-pressure hydrogen gas for JIS-SCM435 low alloy steel (Cr-Mo steel) used as stationary storage buffer of a hydrogen refuelling station with 0.2% proof strength and ultimate tensile strength equal to 772 MPa and 948 MPa respectively. Thresholds for crack arrest under constant displacement and for crack initiation under rising load were identified. The crack arrest threshold under constant displacement was 44.3 MPa m1/2 to 44.5 MPa m1/2 when small-scale yielding and plane-strain criteria were satisfied and the crack initiation threshold under rising load was 33.1 MPa m1/2 to 41.1 MPa m1/2 in 115 MPa hydrogen gas. The crack arrest threshold was roughly equivalent to the crack initiation threshold although the crack initiation threshold showed slightly more conservative values. It was considered that both test methods could be suitable to determine appropriate value for KIH for this material.
Residual Performance of Composite Pressure Vessels Submitted to Mechanical Impacts
Sep 2017
Publication
Type IV pressure vessels are commonly used for hydrogen on-board stationary or bulk storages. During their lifetime they can be submitted to mechanical impacts creating damage within the composite structure not necessarily correlated to what is visible from the outside. When an impact is suspected or when a cylinder is periodically inspected it is necessary to determine whether it can safely stay in service or not. The FCH JU project Hypactor aims at creating a large database of impacts characterized by various non destructive testing (NDT) methods in order to provide reliable pass-fail criteria for damaged cylinders. This paper presents some of the tests results investigating short term burst) and long term (cycling) performance of impacted cylinders and the recommendations that can be made for impact testing and NDT criteria calibration.
No more items...