France
Ammonia Production from Clean Hydrogen and the Implications for Global Natural Gas Demand
Jan 2023
Publication
Non-energy use of natural gas is gaining importance. Gas used for 183 million tons annual ammonia production represents 4% of total global gas supply. 1.5-degree pathways estimate an ammonia demand growth of 3–4-fold until 2050 as new markets in hydrogen transport shipping and power generation emerge. Ammonia production from hydrogen produced via water electrolysis with renewable power (green ammonia) and from natural gas with CO2 storage (blue ammonia) is gaining attention due to the potential role of ammonia in decarbonizing energy value chains and aiding nations in achieving their net-zero targets. This study assesses the technical and economic viability of different routes of ammonia production with an emphasis on a systems level perspective and related process integration. Additional cost reductions may be driven by optimum sizing of renewable power capacity reducing losses in the value chain technology learning and scale-up reducing risk and a lower cost of capital. Developing certification and standards will be necessary to ascertain the extent of greenhouse gas emissions throughout the supply chain as well as improving the enabling conditions including innovative finance and de-risking for facilitating international trade market creation and large-scale project development.
Relevance of Optimized Low-Scale Green H2 Systems in a French Context: Two Case Studies
May 2022
Publication
Hydrogen has been identified as a very promising vector for energy storage especially for heavy mobility applications. For this reason France is making significant investments in this field and use cases need to be evaluated as they are sprouting. In this paper the relevance of H2 in two storage applications is studied: a domestic renewable electricity production system connected to the grid and a collective hydrogen production for the daily bus refill. The investigation consists of the sizing of the system and then the evaluation of its performance according to several criteria depending on case. Optimizations are made using Bayesian and gradient-based methods. Several variations around a central case are explored for both cases to give insights on the impact of the different parameters (location pricing objective etc.) on the performance of the system.Our results show that domestic power-to-power applications (case 1) do not seem to be competitive with electrochemical storage. Meanwhile without any subsidies or incentives such configuration does not allow prosumers to save money (+16% spendings compared to non-equipped dwelling). It remains interesting when self-sufficiency is the main objective (up to 68% of energy is not exchanged). The power-to-gas application (case 2 central case) with a direct use of hydrogen for mobility seems to be more relevant according to our case study we could reach a production cost of green H2 around 5 €/kg similar to the 3–10 $/kg found in literature for 182 houses involved. In both cases H2 follows a yearly cycle charging in summer and discharging in winter (long term storage) due to low conversion efficiency.
Ignition of Hydrogen-air Mixtures Under Volumetric Expansion Conditions
Sep 2017
Publication
A better understanding of chemical kinetics under volumetric expansion is important for a number of situations relevant to industrial safety including detonation diffraction and direct initiation reflected shock-ignition at obstacles ignition behind a decaying shock among others. The ignition of stoichiometric hydrogen-air mixtures was studied using 0D numerical simulations with time-dependent specific volume variations. The competition between chemical energy release and expansion-induced cooling was characterized for different cooling rates and mathematical forms describing the shock decay rate. The critical conditions for reaction quenching were systematically determined and the thermo-chemistry dynamics were analyzed near the critical conditions.
A Simple and Low-cost Integrative Sensor System for Methane and Hydrogen Measurement
Sep 2020
Publication
Energy production by methanization or gasification of biomass is dependant on the chemical composition of the gas generated. The resistive sensors based on semiconductor metal oxides like the MQ series sensors are inexpensive and frequently used in gas detection. These sensors initially dedicated to detecting gas leaks in safety systems have relatively small measurement ranges (i.e. limited to concentrations below 10000 ppm). It is therefore necessary to find solutions to adapt these categories of sensors for gas measurements in the energy sector where the gas concentration is much more significant. In this article we propose a protocol using an adaptable capsule for MQ-4 and MQ-8 sensors to measure high concentrations of CH4 and H2 respectively. The technique consists of diluting the gas to be studied in a known volume of air. Three methods are proposed and compared regarding the linearity and the repeatability of the measurements. The first method was done in an airtight enclosed chamber the second method consists of directly injecting the gas on the sensor placed in an open environment and the final method was accomplished by direct injection of the gas on the sensor placed in a partially closed capsule. Comparisons show that the first technique provides the best repeatability with a maximum standard deviation of 13.88% for CH4 measurement and 5.1% for H2. However its linearity is weak (i.e. R2 ¼ 0.8637 for CH4 and R2 ¼ 0.5756 for H2). The second technique has better linearity but bad repeatability. The third technique presents the best results with R2 values of 0.9973 for the CH4 measurement and 0.9472 for H2. The use of the partially closed capsule resulted in an acceptable linear response of the sensors by up to 20% concentration of CH4 and until 13.33% concentration of H2 in the studied gas. The use of this simple and low-cost technique facilitates the characterization of combustible gases in isolated areas. It allows local operators of biomass valorization systems to control and improve their installations while avoiding the high costs of conventional measurement devices. This study hence contributes to the development of rural electrification projects in remote areas.
Effects of Hydrogen Addition on Design, Maintenance and Surveillance of Gas Networks
Jul 2021
Publication
Hydrogen when is blended with natural gas over time degrades the materials used for pipe transport. Degradation is dependent on the proportion of hydrogen added to the natural gas. The assessment is made according to hydrogen permeation risk to the integrity of structures adaptation of surveillance and maintenance of equipment. The paper gives a survey of HE and its consequence on the design and maintenance. It is presented in a logical sequence: the design before use; the hydrogen embrittlement (HE) effects on Maximum Allowable Operating Pressure (MAOP); maintenance and surveillance during use of smooth and damaged pipes; and particularly for crack-like defects corrosion defects and dents.
Discharge Modeling of Large Scale LH2 Experiments with an Engineering Tool
Sep 2021
Publication
Accurate estimation of mass flow rate and release conditions is important for the design of dispersion and combustion experiments for the subsequent validation of CFD codes/models for consequence assessment analysis within related risk assessment studies and for associated Regulation Codes and Standards development. This work focuses on the modelling of the discharge phase of the recent large scale LH2 release and dispersion experiments performed by HSE within the framework of PRESLHY project. The experimental conditions covered sub-cooled liquid stagnation conditions at two pressures (2 and 6 bara) and 3 release nozzle diameters (1 ½ and ¼ inches). The simulations were performed using a 1d engineering tool which accounts for discharge line effects due to friction extra resistance due to fittings and area change. The engineering tool uses the Possible Impossible Flow (PIF) algorithm for choked flow calculations and the Helmholtz Free Energy (HFE) EoS formulation. Three different phase distribution models were applied. The predictions are compared against measured and derived data from the experiments and recommendations are given both regarding engineering tool applicability and future experimental design.
The Challenges of Hydrogen Storage on a Large Scale
Sep 2021
Publication
With the growing success of green hydrogen the general trend is for increased hydrogen production and large quantities of storage. Engie’s projects have grown from a few kilos of hydrogen to the quest for large scale production and associated storage – e.g. several tons or tens of tons. Although a positive sign for Engie’s projects it does inevitably result in challenges in new storage methods and in risks management related to such facilities; particularly with hydrogen facilities being increasingly placed in the vicinity of general public sites. For example a leak on hydrogen storage can generate significant thermal and overpressure effects on surrounding people/facilities in the event of ignition. Firewalls can be installed to protect individuals / infrastructure from thermal effects but the adverse result is that this solution can increase the violence of an explosion in case of delayed ignition or confinement. The manner of emergency intervention on a pool fire of hydrogen is also totally different from intervention on compressed gaseous hydrogen. The first part of this presentation will explain different means to store hydrogen in large quantities. The second part will present for each storage the specific risks generated. The third and final part will explain how these risks can be addressed on a technical point of view by safety devices or by other solutions (separation distance passive/active means …).
Proton Exchange Membrane Electrolyzer Emulator for Power Electronics Testing Applications
Mar 2021
Publication
This article aims to develop a proton exchange membrane (PEM) electrolyzer emulator. This emulator is realized through an equivalent electrical scheme. It allows taking into consideration the dynamic operation of PEM electrolyzers which is generally neglected in the literature. PEM electrolyzer dynamics are reproduced by the use of supercapacitors due to the high value of the equivalent double-layer capacitance value. Steady-state and dynamics operations are investigated in this work. The design criteria are addressed. The PEM electrolyzer emulator is validated by using a 400-W commercial PEM electrolyzer. This emulator is conceived to test new DC-DC converters to supply the PEM ELs and their control as well avoiding the risk to damage a real electrolyzer for experiment purposes. The proposed approach is valid both for a single cell and for the whole stack emulation.
Numerical Modeling of a Moderate Hydrogen Leakage in a Typical Two-vented Fuel Cell Configuration
Sep 2021
Publication
Numerical results are presented from two direct numerical simulations (DNS) where a moderate hydrogen leakage is modeled in a typical two-vented fuel cell configuration. The study mimics one of the experimental investigations carried out on the 1 m3 enclosure with a leak flow rate of 10.4 Nl.min−1 [1]. The injection dimensionless Richardson number is at the order of unity and thus characterizes a plume flow which becomes turbulent due to gravitational accelerations. Two large exterior regions are added to the computational domain to model correctly the exchange between the in/out flows at both vents and the outer environment. Two meshes are used in this study; a first consisting of 250 million cells while the second has 2 billion cells to ensure the fine DNS resolution at the level of Kolmogorov and Batchelor length scales. The high performance computation (HPC) platform TRUST is employed where the computational domain is distributed up to 5.104 central processing unit (CPU) cores. A detailed description of the flow structure and the hydrogen dispersion is provided where the sharp effect of the cross-flow on the plume is analyzed. Comparisons versus the experimental measurements show a very good agreement where both the bi-layer Linden regime and the maximal concentration in the top homogeneous layer are correctly reproduced by the DNS. This result is extremely important and breaks the limitations shown previously with statistical RANS approaches and LES models. This study can be considered as a good candidate for any further improvements of the theoretical industrial plume models in general and for the estimation of the non-constant entrainment coefficient in particular.
Energy Efficiency Based Control Strategy of a Three-Level Interleaved DC-DC Buck Converter Supplying a Proton Exchange Membrane Electrolyzer
Aug 2019
Publication
To face the intensive use of natural gas and other fossil fuels to generate hydrogen water electrolysis based on renewable energy sources (RES) seems to be a viable solution. Due to their fast response times and high efficiency proton exchange membrane electrolyzer (PEM EL) is the most suitable technology for long-term energy storage combined with RES. Like fuel cells the development of fit DC-DC converters is mandatory to interface the EL to the DC grid. Given that PEM EL operating voltages are quite low and to meet requirements in terms of output current ripples new emerging interleaved DC-DC converter topologies seem to be the best candidates. In this work a three-level interleaved DC-DC buck converter has been chosen to supply a PEM EL from a DC grid. Therefore the main objective of this paper is to develop a suitable control strategy of this interleaved topology connected to a PEM EL emulator. To design the control strategy investigations have been carried out on energy efficiency hydrogen flow rate and specific energy consumption. The obtained experimental results validate the performance of the converter in protecting the PEM EL during transient operations while guaranteeing correct specific energy consumption.
Far Off-shore Wind Energy-based Hydrogen Production: Technological Assessment and Market Valuation Designs
Jan 2020
Publication
This article provides a techno-economic study on coupled offshore wind farm and green hydrogen production via sea water electrolysis (OWF-H2). Offshore wind energy wind farms (OWF) and water electrolysis (WE) technologies are described. MHyWind (the tool used to perform simulations and optimisations of such plants) is presented as well as the models of the main components in the study. Three case studies focus on offshore wind farms either stand-alone or connected to the grid via export cables coupled with a battery and electrolysis systems either offshore or onshore. Exhaustive searches and optimisations performed allowed for rules of thumb to be derived on the sizing of coupled OWF-H2 plants that minimize costs of hydrogen production (LCoH2 in €/kgH2): Non-connected OWF-H2 coupled to a battery offers the lowest LCoH2 without the costs of H2 transportation when compared to cases where the WE is installed onshore and connected to the OWF. Using a simple power distribution heuristic increasing the number of installed WE allows the system to take advantage of more OWF energy but doesn’t improve plant efficiency whereas a battery always does. Finally within the scope of this study it is observed that power ratios of optimized plant architectures (leading to the lowest LCoH2) are between 0.8-0.9 for PWE/POWF and 0.3-0.35 for PBattery/POWF.
Preliminary Risk Assessment (PRA) for Tests Planned in a Pilot Salt Cavern Hydrogen Storage in the Frame of the French Project STOPIL-H2
Sep 2021
Publication
The STOPIL-H2 project supported by the French Geodenergies research consortium aims to design a demonstrator for underground hydrogen storage in cavern EZ53 of the Etrez gas storage (France) operated by Storengy. Two types of tests are planned in this cavern: a tightness test with nitrogen and hydrogen then a cycling test during which the upper part of the cavern (approximately 200 m3) will be filled with hydrogen during 6 to 9 months. In this paper the PRA for the cycling test is presented comprising the identification of the major hazards and the proposed prevention and protection measures. The implemented methodology involves the following steps: data mining from the description of the project; analysis of lessons learned from accidents that occurred in underground gas storage and subface facilities; identification of the potential hazards pertaining to the storage process; analysis of external potential aggressors. Resulting as one of the outcomes of the PRA major accidental scenarios are presented and classified according to concerned storage operation phases as well as determined preventive or protective barriers able to prevent their occurrence of mitigate their consequences.
Detection of Contaminants in Hydrogen Fuel for Fuel Cell Electrical Vehicles with Sensors—Available Technology, Testing Protocols and Implementation Challenges
Dec 2021
Publication
Europe’s low-carbon energy policy favors a greater use of fuel cells and technologies based on hydrogen used as a fuel. Hydrogen delivered at the hydrogen refueling station must be compliant with requirements stated in different standards. Currently the quality control process is performed by offline analysis of the hydrogen fuel. It is however beneficial to continuously monitor at least some of the contaminants onsite using chemical sensors. For hydrogen quality control with regard to contaminants high sensitivity integration parameters and low cost are the most important requirements. In this study we have reviewed the existing sensor technologies to detect contaminants in hydrogen then discussed the implementation of sensors at a hydrogen refueling stations described the state-of-art in protocols to perform assessment of these sensor technologies and finally identified the gaps and needs in these areas. It was clear that sensors are not yet commercially available for all gaseous contaminants mentioned in ISO14687:2019. The development of standardized testing protocols is required to go hand in hand with the development of chemical sensors for this application following a similar approach to the one undertaken for air sensors.
Hydrogen Projects Database – Analysis
Jun 2020
Publication
The IEA produced this dataset as part of efforts to track advances in low-carbon hydrogen technology. It covers all projects commissioned worldwide since 2000 to produce hydrogen for energy or climate-change-mitigation purposes. It includes projects which their objective is either to reduce emissions associated with producing hydrogen for existing applications or to use hydrogen as an energy carrier or industrial feedstock in new applications that have the potential to be a low-carbon technology. Projects in planning or construction are also covered.
Link to Download Database from IEA Website
Link to Download Database from IEA Website
Combustion Regimes of Hydrogen-air-steam Mixtures
Sep 2021
Publication
In the case of a severe nuclear power plant accident hydrogen gas formation may occur from the core degradation and cooling water evaporation and subsequent oxidation of zircaloy. These phenomena increase the risk of hazardous combustion events in the reactor especially when combined with an ignition source. If not handled carefully these types of accidents can cause severe damage to the reactor building with potential radioactive effects on the environment. Although hydrogen-air combustion has been investigated before hydrogen-air-steam mixtures remain unstudied under reactor-like conditions. Thus this study investigated such mixtures’ combustion regimes. A closed tube of 318 liters (7.65m tall and 0.23m inner diameter) measures the flame speed flame propagation and shock wave behaviors for 11-15 %vol hydrogen mixtures combined with 0 20 or 30 %vol steam and air. Thus both the effect of steam and hydrogen content was investigated and compared. The experimental setup combined photomultiplier tubes pressure sensors and shock detectors to give a full view of the different combustion regimes. A number of obstacles changed the in-chamber turbulence during flame propagation to provide further reactor-like environments. This changed turbulence affected the combustion regimes and enhanced the flame speed for some cases. The results showed varying combustion behaviors depending on the water vapor concentration where a higher concentration meant a lower flame speed reduced pressure load and sometimes combustion extinction. At 0 %vol steam dilution the flame speed remained supersonic for all H2 concentrations while at 30 %vol steam dilution the flame speed remained subsonic for all H2 concentrations. Thus with high levels of steam dilution the risk for shock waves leading to potential reactor building destruction decreases."
Mathematical Modeling of Unstable Transport in Underground Hydrogen Storage
Apr 2015
Publication
Within the framework of energy transition hydrogen has a great potential as a clean energy carrier. The conversion of electricity into hydrogen for storage and transport is an efficient technological solution capable of significantly reducing the problem of energy shortage. Underground hydrogen storage (UHS) is the best solution to store the large amount of excess electrical energy arising from the excessive over-production of electricity with the objective of balancing the irregular and intermittent energy production typical of renewable sources such as windmills or solar. Earlier studies have demonstrated that UHS should be qualitatively identical to the underground storage of natural gas. Much later however it was revealed that UHS is bound to incur peculiar difficulties as the stored hydrogen is likely to be used by the microorganisms present in the rocks for their metabolism which may cause significant losses of hydrogen. This paper demonstrates that besides microbial activities the hydrodynamic behavior of UHS is very unique and different from that of a natural gas storage.
Global Hydrogen Review 2021
Oct 2021
Publication
The Global Hydrogen Review is a new annual publication by the International Energy Agency to track progress in hydrogen production and demand as well as in other critical areas such as policy regulation investments innovation and infrastructure development.
The report is an output of the Clean Energy Ministerial Hydrogen Initiative (CEM H2I) and is intended to inform energy sector stakeholders on the status and future prospects of hydrogen while serving as an input to the discussions at the Hydrogen Energy Ministerial Meeting (HEM) organised by Japan. It examines what international progress on hydrogen is needed to help address climate change – and compares real-world developments with the stated ambitions of government and industry and with key actions under the Global Action Agenda launched at the HEM in 2019.
Focusing on hydrogen’s usefulness for meeting climate goals this Review aims to help decision makers fine-tune strategies to attract investment and facilitate deployment of hydrogen technologies while also creating demand for hydrogen and hydrogen-based fuels.
Link to International Energy Agency website
The report is an output of the Clean Energy Ministerial Hydrogen Initiative (CEM H2I) and is intended to inform energy sector stakeholders on the status and future prospects of hydrogen while serving as an input to the discussions at the Hydrogen Energy Ministerial Meeting (HEM) organised by Japan. It examines what international progress on hydrogen is needed to help address climate change – and compares real-world developments with the stated ambitions of government and industry and with key actions under the Global Action Agenda launched at the HEM in 2019.
Focusing on hydrogen’s usefulness for meeting climate goals this Review aims to help decision makers fine-tune strategies to attract investment and facilitate deployment of hydrogen technologies while also creating demand for hydrogen and hydrogen-based fuels.
Link to International Energy Agency website
Numerical Simulations of Atmospheric Dispersion of Large-scale Liquid Hydrogen Releases
Sep 2021
Publication
Numerical simulations have been conducted for LH2 massive releases and the subsequent atmospheric dispersion using an in-house modified version of the open source computational fluid dynamics (CFD) code OpenFOAM. A conjugate heat transfer model has been added for heat transfer between the released LH2 and the ground. Appropriate interface boundary conditions are applied to ensure the continuities of temperature and heat fluxes. The significant temperature difference between the cryogenic hydrogen and the ground means that the released LH2 will instantly enter in a boiling state resulting in a hydrogen- air gaseous cloud which will initially behave like a dense gas. Numerical predictions have been conducted for the subsequent atmospheric dispersion of the vaporized LH2 for a series of release scenarios - with and without retention pits - to limit the horizontal spread of the LH2 on the ground. The considered cases included the instantaneous release of 1 10 and 50 tons of LH2 under neutral (D) and stable (F) weather conditions. More specifically 3F and 5D conditions were simulated with the former representing stable weather conditions under wind speed of 3 m/s at 10 m above the ground and the later corresponding to neutral weather conditions under 5 m/s wind speed (10 m above the ground). Specific numerical tests have also been conducted for selected scenarios under different ambient temperatures from 233 up to 313 K. According to the current study although the retention pit can extend the dispersion time it can significantly reduce the extent of hazards due to much smaller cloud size within both the flammability and explosion limits. While the former has negative impact on safety the later is beneficial. The use of retention pit should hence be considered with caution in practical applications.
Main Hydrogen Production Processes: An Overview
May 2021
Publication
Due to its characteristics hydrogen is considered the energy carrier of the future. Its use as a fuel generates reduced pollution as if burned it almost exclusively produces water vapor. Hydrogen can be produced from numerous sources both of fossil and renewable origin and with as many production processes which can use renewable or non-renewable energy sources. To achieve carbon neutrality the sources must necessarily be renewable and the production processes themselves must use renewable energy sources. In this review article the main characteristics of the most used hydrogen production methods are summarized mainly focusing on renewable feedstocks furthermore a series of relevant articles published in the last year are reviewed. The production methods are grouped according to the type of energy they use; and at the end of each section the strengths and limitations of the processes are highlighted. The conclusions compare the main characteristics of the production processes studied and contextualize their possible use.
Hydrogen Recovery from Waste Gas Streams to Feed (High-Temperature PEM) Fuel Cells: Environmental Performance under a Life-Cycle Thinking Approach
Oct 2020
Publication
Fossil fuels are being progressively substituted by a cleaner and more environmentally friendly form of energy where hydrogen fuel cells stand out. However the implementation of a competitive hydrogen economy still presents several challenges related to economic costs required infrastructures and environmental performance. In this context the objective of this work is to determine the environmental performance of the recovery of hydrogen from industrial waste gas streams to feed high-temperature proton exchange membrane fuel cells for stationary applications. The life-cycle assessment (LCA) analyzed alternative scenarios with different process configurations considering as functional unit 1 kg of hydrogen produced 1 kWh of energy obtained and 1 kg of inlet flow. The results make the recovery of hydrogen from waste streams environmentally preferable over alternative processes like methane reforming or coal gasification. The production of the fuel cell device resulted in high contributions in the abiotic depletion potential and acidification potential mainly due to the presence of platinum metal in the anode and cathode. The design and operation conditions that defined a more favorable scenario are the availability of a pressurized waste gas stream the use of photovoltaic electricity and the implementation of an energy recovery system for the residual methane stream.
No more items...