Italy
Electric Load Influence on Performances of a Composite Plant for Hydrogen Production from RES and its Conversion in Electricity
Nov 2019
Publication
The analysis here presented investigates the influence of electrical load on the operational performances of a plant for hydrogen production from solar energy and its conversion in electricity via a fuel cell. The plant is an actual one currently under construction in Reggio Calabria (Italy) at the site of the Mediterranean university campus; it is composed of a Renewable Energy Source (RES) section (photovoltaic panels) a hydrogen production section and a fuel cell power section feeding the electrical energy demand of the load. Two different load configurations have been analysed and simulations have been carried out through HomerTM simulation code. Results allow interesting conclusions regarding the plant operation to be drawn. The study could have a remarkable role in supporting further research activities aimed at the assessment of the optimal configuration of this type of pioneering plants designed for feeding electrical loads possibly in a self-sufficient way.
Performance Assessment of an Integrated Environmental Control System of Civil Hypersonic Vehicles
Apr 2022
Publication
This paper discloses the architecture and related performance of an environment control system designed to be integrated within a complex multi-functional thermal and energy management system that manages the heat loads and generation of electric power in a hypersonic vehicle by benefitting from the presence of cryogenic liquid hydrogen onboard. A bleed-less architecture implementing an open-loop cycle with a boot-strap sub-freezing air cycle machine is suggested. Hydrogen boil-off reveals to be a viable cold source for the heat exchangers of the system as well as for the convective insulation layer designed around the cabin walls. Including a 2 mm boil-off convective layer into the cabin cross-section proves to be far more effective than a more traditional air convective layer of approximately 60 mm. The application to STRATOFLY MR3 a Mach 8 waverider cruiser using liquid hydrogen as propellant confirmed that presence of cryogenic tanks provides up to a 70% reduction in heat fluxes entering the cabin generated outside of it but inside the vehicle by the propulsive system and other onboard systems. The effectiveness of the architecture was confirmed for all Mach numbers (from 0.3 to 8) and all flight altitudes (from sea level to 35 km).
Optimal Design of Stand-alone Solutions Based on RES + Hydrogen Storage Feeding Off-grid Communities
Apr 2021
Publication
Concerning off-grid areas diesel engines still dominate the scene of local electricity generation despite the related pollution concerns and high operating costs. There is thus a huge global potential in remote areas for exploiting local renewable energy sources (RES) in place of fossil generation. Energy storage systems become hence essential for off-grid communities to cope with the issue of RES intermittency allowing them to rely on locally harvested RES. In this work we analysed different typologies of off-grid renewable power systems involving batteries and hydrogen as means to store energy to find out which is the most cost-effective configuration in remote areas. Both Li-ion and lead-acid batteries were included in the analysis and both alkaline and PEM electrolysis technologies were considered for the production of hydrogen. Starting from single cell electrochemical models the performance curves of the electrolyser and fuel cell devices were derived for a more detailed techno-economic assessment. Lifetimes of batteries and H2-based components were also computed based on how the power-to-power (P2P) system operates along the reference year. The particle swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm was employed to find the component sizes that allow minimizing the levelized cost of energy (LCOE) while keeping the off-grid area energy autonomous. As a case study the Ginostra village on the island of Stromboli (North of Sicily Southern Italy) was analysed since it is well representative of small insular locations in the Mediterranean area. The renewable P2P solution (0.51 €/kWh for the cheapest configuration) was found to be economically preferable than the current existing power system relying on diesel generators (0.86 €/kWh). Hydrogen in particular can prevent the oversizing of both battery and PV systems thus reducing the final cost of electricity delivered by the P2P system. Moreover unlike diesel generators the RES-based configuration allows avoiding the production of local air pollutants and GHG emissions during its operation.
Aqueous Phase Reforming of the Residual Waters Derived from Lignin-rich Hydrothermal Liquefaction: Investigation of Representative Organic Compounds and Actual Biorefinery Streams
Sep 2019
Publication
Secondary streams in biorefineries need to be valorized to improve the economic and environmental sustainability of the plants. Representative model compounds of the water fraction from the hydrothermal liquefaction (HTL) of biomass were subjected to aqueous phase reforming (APR) to produce hydrogen. Carboxylic and bicarboxylic acids hydroxyacids alcohols cycloketones and aromatics were identified as model compounds and tested for APR. The tests were performed with a Pt/C catalyst and the influence of the carbon concentration (0.3–1.8 wt. C%) was investigated. Typically the increase of the concentration negatively affected the conversion of the feed toward gaseous products without influencing the selectivity toward hydrogen production. A synthetic ternary mixture (glycolic acid acetic acid lactic acid) was subjected to APR to evaluate any differences in performance compared to the tests with single compounds. Indeed glycolic acid reacted faster in the mixture than in the corresponding single compound test while acetic acid remained almost unconverted. The influence of the reaction time temperature and carbon concentration was also evaluated. Finally residual water resulting from the HTL of a lignin-rich stream originating from an industrial-scale lignocellulosic ethanol process was tested for the first time after a thorough characterization. In this framework the stability of the catalyst was studied and found to be correlated to the presence of aromatics in the aqueous feedstock. For this reason the influence of an extraction procedure for the selective removal of these compounds was explored leading to an improvement in the APR performance.
Modelling and Analyzing the Impact of Hydrogen Enriched Natural Gas on Domestic Gas Boilers in a Decarbonization Perspective
Aug 2020
Publication
Decarbonization of energy economy is nowadays a topical theme and several pathways are under discussion. Gaseous fuels have a fundamental role for this transition and the production of low carbon-impact fuels is necessary to deal with this challenge. The generation of renewable hydrogen is a trusted solution since this energy vector can be promptly produced from electricity and injected into the existing natural gas infrastructure granting storage capacity and easy transportation. This scenario will lead in the near future to hydrogen enrichment of natural gas whose impact on the infrastructures is being actively studied. The effect on end-user devices such as domestic gas boilers instead is still little analyzed and tested but is fundamental to be assessed. The aim of this research is to generate knowledge on the effect of hydrogen enrichment on the widely used premixed boilers: the investigations include pollutant emissions efficiency flashback and explosion hazard control system and materials selection. A model for calculating several parameters related to combustion of hydrogen enriched natural gas is presented. Guidelines for the design of new components are provided and an insight is given on the maximum hydrogen blending bearable by the current boilers.
Electrification and Sustainable Fuels: Competing for Wind and Sun (complement to the Policy brief)
May 2021
Publication
This study seeks to answer a simple question: will we have enough renewable electricity to meet all of the EU's decarbonisation objectives and if not what should be the priorities and how to address the remaining needs for energy towards carbon neutrality? Indeed if not the policy push for green hydrogen would not be covered by enough green electricity to match the “energy efficiency and electrification first” approach outlined in the system integration communication and a prioritization of green electricity uses complemented by other solutions (import of green electricity or sustainable fuels CCS...) would be advisable [1]. On one hand we show that the principle “Energy efficiency and electrification first” results in an electricity demand which will be very difficult to satisfy domestically with renewable energy. On the other hand green hydrogen and other sustainable fuels will be needed for a carbon neutral industry for the replacement of the fuel for aviation and navigation and as strategic green energy reserves. The detailed modelling of these interactions is challenging given the large uncertainties on technology and infrastructure development. Therefore we offer a “15 minutes” decarbonization scenario based on general and transparent technical considerations and very straightforward “back-of-envelope” calculations. This working paper contains the calculations and assumptions in support of the accompanying policy brief with the same title which focuses instead on the main take-aways.
Economic Analysis of Hydrogen Household Energy Systems Including Incentives on Energy Communities and Externalities: A Case Study in Italy
Sep 2021
Publication
The building sector is one of the key energy consumers worldwide. Fuel cell micro-Cogeneration Heat and Power systems for residential and small commercial applications are proposed as one of the most promising innovations contributing to the transition towards a sustainable energy infrastructure. For the application and the diffusion of these systems in addition to their environmental performance it is necessary however to evaluate their economic feasibility. In this paper a life cycle assessment of a fuel cell/photovoltaic hybrid micro-cogeneration heat and power system for a residential building is integrated with a detailed economic analysis. Financial indicators (net present cost and payback time are used for studying two different investments: reversible-Solid Oxide Fuel Cell and natural gas SOFC in comparison to a base scenario using a homeowner perspective approach. Moreover two alternative incentives scenarios are analysed and applied: net metering and self-consumers’ groups (or energy communities). Results show that both systems obtain annual savings but their high capital costs still would make the investments not profitable. However the natural gas Solide Oxide Fuel Cell with the net metering incentive is the best scenario among all. On the contrary the reversible-Solid Oxide Fuel Cell maximizes its economic performance only when the self-consumers’ groups incentive is applied. For a complete life cycle cost analysis environmental impacts are monetized using three different monetization methods with the aim to internalize (considering them into direct cost) the externalities (environmental costs). If externalities are considered as an effective cost the natural gas Solide Oxide Fuel Cell system increases its saving because its environmental impact is lower than in the base case one while the reversible-Solid Oxide Fuel Cell system reduces it.
Hybrid PEM Fuel Cell Power Plants Fuelled by Hydrogen for Improving Sustainability in Shipping: State of the Art and Review on Active Projects
Feb 2023
Publication
The interest in hybrid polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cells (PEMFC) fuelled by hydrogen in shipping has seen an unprecedented growth in the last years as it could allow zero-emission navigation. However technical safety and regulatory barriers in PEMFC ship design and operation are hampering the use of such systems on a large scale. While several studies analyse these aspects a comprehensive and up-to-date overview on hydrogen PEMFCs for shipping is missing. Starting from the survey of past/ongoing projects on FCs in shipping this paper presents an extensive review on maritime hydrogen PEMFCs outlining the state of the art and future trends for hydrogen storage and bunkering powertrain and regulations. In addition to the need for a clear regulatory framework future studies should investigate the development of an efficient fuel supply chain and bunkering facilities ashore. As for the onboard power system health-conscious energy management low-temperature heat recovery and advancements in fuel processing have emerged as hot research topics.
Flexible Power & Biomass-to-Methanol Plants: Design Optimization and Economic Viability of the Electrolysis Integration
Nov 2021
Publication
This paper assesses the optimal design criteria of a flexible power and biomass to methanol (PBtM) plant conceived to operate both without green hydrogen addition (baseline mode) and with hydrogen addition (enhanced mode) following an intermittent use of the electrolysis system which is turned on when the electricity price allows an economically viable hydrogen production. The assessed plant includes a gasification section syngas cleaning and compression methanol synthesis and purification and heat recovery steam cycle to be flexibly operated. A sorption-enhanced gasification technology allows to produce a tailored syngas for the downstream synthesis in both the baseline and enhanced operating conditions by controlling the in-situ CO2 separation rate. Two designs are assessed for the methanol synthesis unit with two different reactor sizes: (i) a larger reactor designed on the enhanced operation mode (enhanced reactor design – ERD) and (ii) a smaller reactor designed on the baseline operation mode (baseline reactor design – BRD). The ERD design resulted to be preferable from the techno economic perspectives resulting in 20% lower cost of the e-MeOH (30.80 vs. 37.76 €/ GJLHV) with the baseline assumptions (i.e. 80% of electrolyzer capacity factor and 2019 Denmark day-ahead market electricity price). Other important outcomes are: (i) high electrolysis capacity factor is needed to obtain competitive cost of e-MeOH and (ii) advantages of flexibly operated PBtM plants with respect to inflexible PBtM plants are significant in scenarios with high penetration of intermittent renewables leading to low average prices of electricity but also longer periods of high peak prices.
A Parametric Approach for Conceptual Integration and Performance Studies of Liquid Hydrogen Short–Medium Range Aircraft
Jul 2022
Publication
The present paper deals with the investigation at conceptual level of the performance of short–medium-range aircraft with hydrogen propulsion. The attention is focused on the relationship between figures of merit related to transport capability such as passenger capacity and flight range and the parameters which drive the design of liquid hydrogen tanks and their integration with a given aircraft geometry. The reference aircraft chosen for such purpose is a box-wing short–mediumrange airplane the object of study within a previous European research project called PARSIFAL capable of cutting the fuel consumption per passenger-kilometre up to 22%. By adopting a retrofitting approach non-integral pressure vessels are sized to fit into the fuselage of the reference aircraft under the assumption that the main aerodynamic flight mechanic and structural characteristics are not affected. A parametric model is introduced to generate a wide variety of fuselage-tank cross-section layouts from a single tank with the maximum diameter compatible with a catwalk corridor to multiple tanks located in the cargo deck and an assessment workflow is implemented to perform the structural sizing of the tanks and analyse their thermodynamic behaviour during the mission. This latter is simulated with a time-marching approach that couples the fuel request from engines with the thermodynamics of the hydrogen in the tanks which is constantly subject to evaporation and depending on the internal pressure vented-out in gas form. Each model is presented in detail in the paper and results are provided through sensitivity analyses to both the technologic parameters of the tanks and the geometric parameters influencing their integration. The guidelines resulting from the analyses indicate that light materials such as the aluminium alloy AA2219 for tanks’ structures and polystyrene foam for the insulation should be selected. Preferred values are also indicted for the aspect ratios of the vessel components i.e. central tube and endcaps as well as suggestions for the integration layout to be adopted depending on the desired trade-off between passenger capacity as for the case of multiple tanks in the cargo deck and achievable flight ranges as for the single tank in the section.
True Cost of Solar Hydrogen
Sep 2021
Publication
Green hydrogen will be an essential part of the future 100% sustainable energy and industry system. Up to one-third of the required solar and wind electricity would eventually be used for water electrolysis to produce hydrogen increasing the cumulative electrolyzer capacity to about 17 TWel by 2050. The key method applied in this research is a learning curve approach for the key technologies i.e. solar photovoltaics (PV) and water electrolyzers and levelized cost of hydrogen (LCOH). Sensitivities for the hydrogen demand and various input parameters are considered. Electrolyzer capital expenditure (CAPEX) for a large utility-scale system is expected to decrease from the current 400 €/kWel to 240 €/kWel by 2030 and to 80 €/kWel by 2050. With the continuing solar PV cost decrease this will lead to an LCOH decrease from the current 31–81 €/ MWhH2LHV (1.0–2.7 €/kgH2) to 20–54 €/MWhH2LHV (0.7–1.8 €/kgH2) by 2030 and 10–27 €/MWhH2LHV (0.3–0.9 €/kgH2) by 2050 depending on the location. The share of PV electricity cost in the LCOH will increase from the current 63% to 74% by 2050.
Value of Green Hydrogen When Curtailed to Provide Grid Balancing Services
Aug 2022
Publication
This paper evaluates the potential of grid services in France Italy Norway and Spain to provide an alternative income for electrolysers producing hydrogen from wind power. Grid services are simulated with each country's data for 2017 for energy prices grid services and wind power profiles from relevant wind parks. A novel metric is presented the value of curtailed hydrogen which is independent from several highly uncertain parameters such as electrolyser cost or hydrogen market price. Results indicate that grid services can monetise the unused spare capacity of electrolyser plants improving their economy in the critical deployment phase. For most countries up-regulation yields a value of curtailed hydrogen above 6 V/kg over 3 times higher than the EU's 2030 price target (without incentives). However countries with large hydro power resources such as Norway yield far lower results below 2 V/kg. The value of curtailed hydrogen also decreases with hydrogen production corresponding to the cases of symmetric and down-regulation.
Health-Conscious Optimization of Long-Term Operation for Hybrid PEMFC Ship Propulsion Systems
Jun 2021
Publication
The need to decarbonize the shipping sector is leading to a growing interest in fuel cell-based propulsion systems. While Polymer Electrolyte Membrane Fuel Cells (PEMFC) represent one of the most promising and mature technologies for onboard implementation they are still prone to remarkable degradation. The same problem is also affecting Lithium-ion batteries (LIB) which are usually coupled with PEMFC in hybrid powertrains. By including the combined degradation effects in an optimization strategy the best compromise between costs and PEMFC/LIB lifetime could be determined. However this is still a challenging yet crucial aspect rarely addressed in the literature and rarely yet explored. To fill this gap a health-conscious optimization is here proposed for the long-term minimization of costs and PEMFC/LIB degradation. Results show that a holistic multi-objective optimization allows a 185% increase of PEMFC/LIB lifetime with respect to a fuel-consumption-minimization-only approach. With the progressive ageing of PEMFC/LIB the hybrid propulsion system modifies the energy management strategy to limit the increase of the daily operation cost. Comparing the optimization results at the beginning and the end of the plant lifetime daily operation costs are increased by 73% and hydrogen consumption by 29%. The proposed methodology is believed to be a useful tool able to give insights into the effective costs involved in the long-term operation of this new type of propulsion system.
Electric Mobility in Portugal: Current Situation and Forecasts for Fuel Cell Vehicles
Nov 2021
Publication
In recent years the growing concern for air quality has led to the development of sustainable vehicles to replace conventional internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles. Currently the most widespread technology in Europe and Portugal is that of Battery Electric Vehicles (BEV) or plug‐in HEV (PHEV) electric cars but hydrogen‐based transport has also shown significant growth in the commercialization of Fuel Cell Electric Vehicles (FCEV) and in the development of new infrastructural schemes. In the current panorama of EV particular attention should be paid to hydrogen technology i.e. FCEVs which is potentially a valid alternative to BEVs and can also be hybrid (FCHEV) and plug‐in hybrid (FCPHEV). Several sources cited show a positive trend of hydrogen in the transport sector identifying a growing trend in the expansion of hydrogen infrastructure although at this time it is still at an early stage of development. At the moment the cost of building the infrastructure is still high but on the basis of medium/long‐term scenarios it is clear that investments in hydrogen refueling stations will be profitable if the number of Fuel Cell vehicles increases. Conversely the Fuel Cell vehicle market is hampered if there is no adequate infrastructure for hydrogen development. The opportunity to use Fuel Cells to store electrical energy is quite fascinating and bypasses some obstacles encountered with BEVs. The advantages are clear since the charging times are reduced compared to charging from an electric charging post and the long‐distance voyage is made easier as the autonomy is much larger i.e. the psycho‐ sociological anxiety is avoided. Therefore the first part of the paper provides an overview of the current state of electric mobility in Portugal and the strategies adopted by the country. This is necessary to have a clear vision of how a new technology is accepted by the population and develops on the territory that is the propensity of citizens to technological change. Subsequently using current data on EV development and comparing information from recent years this work aims to investigate the future prospects of FCEVs in Portugal by adopting a dynamic model called SERA (Scenario Evaluation and Regionalization Analysis) with which it is possible to identify the Portuguese districts and cities where an FC charging infrastructure is expected to be most beneficial. From the results obtained the districts of Lisbon Porto and Aveiro seem to be the most interested in adopting FC technology. This analysis aims to ensure a measured view of the credible development of this market segment.
The Route from Green H2 Production through Bioethanol Reforming to CO2 Catalytic Conversion: A Review
Mar 2022
Publication
Currently a progressively different approach to the generation of power and the production of fuels for the automotive sector as well as for domestic applications is being taken. As a result research on the feasibility of applying renewable energy sources to the present energy scenario has been progressively growing aiming to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Following more than one approach the integration of renewables mainly involves the utilization of biomass-derived raw material and the combination of power generated via clean sources with conventional power generation systems. The aim of this review article is to provide a satisfactory overview of the most recent progress in the catalysis of hydrogen production through sustainable reforming and CO2 utilization. In particular attention is focused on the route that starting from bioethanol reforming for H2 production leads to the use of the produced CO2 for different purposes and by means of different catalytic processes passing through the water–gas shift stage. The newest approaches reported in the literature are reviewed showing that it is possible to successfully produce “green” and sustainable hydrogen which can represent a power storage technology and its utilization is a strategy for the integration of renewables into the power generation scenario. Moreover this hydrogen may be used for CO2 catalytic conversion to hydrocarbons thus giving CO2 added value.
Different Scenarios of Electric Mobility: Current Situation and Possible Future Developments of Fuel Cell Vehicles in Italy
Jan 2020
Publication
The diffusion of electric vehicles in Italy has started but some complications weight its spread. At present hybrid technology is the most followed by users due particularly to socioeconomic factors such as cost of investment and range anxiety. After a deep discussion of the Italian scenario the aim of the paper is to recognize whether fuel cell technology may be an enabling solution to overcome pollution problems and respect for the environment. The opportunity to use fuel cells to store electric energy is quite fascinating—the charging times will be shortened and heavy passenger transport should be effortless challenged. On the basis of the present history and by investigating the available information this work reports the current e-mobility state in Italy and forecasts the cities in which a fuel cell charging infrastructure should be more profitable with the intention of granting a measured outlook on the plausible development of this actual niche market.
Analysis of the Existing Barriers for the Market Development of Power to Hydrogen (P2H) in Italy
Sep 2020
Publication
New technological solutions are required to control the impact of the increasing presence of renewable energy sources connected to the electric grid that are characterized by unpredictable production (i.e. wind and solar energy). Energy storage is becoming essential to stabilize the grid when a mismatch between production and demand occurs. Among the available solutions Power to Hydrogen (P2H) is one of the most attractive options. However despite the potential many barriers currently hinder P2H market development. The literature reports general barriers and strategies to overcome them but a specific analysis is fundamental to identifying how these barriers concretely arise in national and regional frameworks since tailored solutions are needed to foster the development of P2H local market. The paper aims to identify and to analyze the existing barriers for P2H market uptake in Italy. The paper shows how several technical regulatory and economic issues are still unsolved resulting in a source of uncertainty for P2H investment. The paper also suggests possible approaches and solutions to address the Italian barriers and to support politics and decision-makers in the definition and implementation of the national hydrogen strategy.
Domestic Gas Meter Durability in Hydrogen and Natural Gas Mixtures
Nov 2021
Publication
Blending hydrogen into the natural gas infrastructure is becoming a very promising practice to increase the exploitation of renewable energy sources which can be used to produce “green” hydrogen. Several research projects and field experiments are currently aimed at evaluating the risks associated with utilization of the gas blend in end-use devices such as the gas meters. In this paper the authors present the results of experiments aimed at assessing the effect of hydrogen injection in terms of the durability of domestic gas meters. To this end 105 gas meters of different measurement capabilities and manufacturers both brand-new and withdrawn from service were investigated in terms of accuracy drift after durability cycles of 5000 and 10000 h with H2NG mixtures and H2 concentrations of 10% and 15%. The obtained results show that there is no metrologically significant or statistically significant influence of hydrogen content on changes in gas meter indication errors after subjecting the meters to durability testing with a maximum of 15% H2 content over 10000 h. A metrologically significant influence of the long-term operation of the gas meters was confirmed but it should not be made dependent on the hydrogen content in the gas. No safety problems related to the loss of external tightness were observed for either the new or 10-year-old gas meters.
The Role of Research and Innovation in Europe for the Decarbonisation of Waterborne Transport
Sep 2021
Publication
Waterborne transport contributes to around 14% of the overall greenhouse gas emissions of transport in the European Union and it is among the most efficient modes of transport. Nonetheless considering the aim of making the European Union carbon-neutral by 2050 and the fundamental role of waterborne transport within the European economy effort is needed to reduce its environmental impact. This paper provides an assessment of research and innovation measures aiming at decreasing waterborne transport’s CO2 emissions by assessing European projects based on the European Commission’s Transport Research and Innovation Monitoring and Information System (TRIMIS). Additionally it provides an outlook of the evolution of scientific publications and intellectual property activity in the area. The review of project findings suggests that there is no single measure which can be considered as a problem solver in the area of the reduction of waterborne CO2 emissions and only the combination of different innovations should enable reaching this goal. The highlighted potential innovations include further development of lightweight composite materials innovative hull repair methods wind assisted propulsion engine efficiency waste heat electrification hydrogen and alternative fuels. The assessment shows prevalence of funding allocated to technological measures; however non-technological ones like improved vessel navigation and allocation systems also show a great potential for the reduction of CO2 emissions and reduction of negative environmental impacts of waterborne transport.
Analysis of Standard and Innovative Methods for Allocating Upstream and Refinery GHG Emissions to Oil Products
Sep 2017
Publication
Alternative fuel policies need accurate and transparent methods to find the embedded carbon intensity of individual refinery products. This study investigates different ways of allocating greenhouse gases emissions deriving from refining and upstream crude oil supply. Allocation methods based on mass energy content economic value and innovatively added-value are compared with the marginal refining emissions calculated by CONCAWE’s linear-programming model to the average EU refinery which has been adopted as reference in EU legislation. Beside the most important transportation fuels (gasoline diesel kerosene/jet fuel and heavy fuel oil) the analysis extends to petroleum coke and refinery hydrogen. Moreover novel criteria based on the implications due to hydrogen usage by each fuel pathway have been introduced to test the consistency of the analyzed approaches. It is found that only two economic-based allocation methods are consistent with the introduced criteria. These two methods also give negative refinery emissions for heavy products which is coherent with the marginal emissions calculated through the CONCAWE refinery model. The recommended allocation methods are transparent and use only publicly available statistical data so they may be useful not only for future EU legislation but also in jurisdictions where a representative refinery model is not available.
No more items...