Institution of Gas Engineers & Managers
Comparative Techno-economic Analysis of Large-scale Renewable Energy Storage Technologies
Jun 2023
Publication
Energy storage is an effective way to address the instability of renewable energy generation modes such as wind and solar which are projected to play an important role in the sustainable and low-carbon society. Economics and carbon emissions are important indicators that should be thoroughly considered for evaluating the feasibility of energy storage technologies (ESTs). In this study we study two promising routes for large-scale renewable energy storage electrochemical energy storage (EES) and hydrogen energy storage (HES) via technical analysis of the ESTs. The levelized cost of storage (LCOS) carbon emissions and uncertainty assessments for EESs and HESs over the life cycle are conducted with full consideration of the critical links for these routes. In order to reduce the evaluation error we use the Monte Carlo method to derive a large number of data for estimating the economy and carbon emission level of ESTs based on the collected data. The results show that lithium ion (Li-ion) batteries show the lowest LCOS and carbon emissions at 0.314 US$ kWh-1 and 72.76 gCO2e kWh-1 compared with other batteries for EES. Different HES routes meaning different combinations of hydrogen production delivery and refueling methods show substantial differences in economics and the lowest LCOS and carbon emissions at 0.227 US$ kWh-1 and 61.63 gCO2e kWh-1 are achieved using HES routes that involve hydrogen production by alkaline electrolyzer (AE) delivery by hydrogen pipeline and corresponding refueling. The findings of this study suggest that HES and EES have comparable levels of economics and carbon emissions that should be both considered for large-scale renewable energy storage to achieve future decarbonization goals.
An Analysis of Renewable Energy Sources for Developing a Sustainable and Low-Carbon Hydrogen Economy in China
Apr 2023
Publication
A significant effort is required to reduce China’s dependency on fossil fuels while also supporting worldwide efforts to reduce climate change and develop hydrogen energy systems. A hydrogen economy must include renewable energy sources (RESs) which can offer a clean and sustainable energy source for producing hydrogen. This study uses an integrated fuzzy AHP–fuzzy TOPSIS method to evaluate and rank renewable energy sources for developing a hydrogen economy in China. This is a novel approach because it can capture the uncertainty and vagueness in the decision-making process and provide a comprehensive and robust evaluation of the alternatives. Moreover it considers multiple criteria and sub-criteria that reflect the environmental economic technical social and political aspects of RESs from the perspective of a hydrogen economy. This study identified five major criteria fifteen sub-criteria and six RES alternatives for hydrogen production. This integrated approach uses fuzzy AHP to evaluate and rank the criteria and sub-criteria and fuzzy TOPSIS to identify the most suitable and feasible RES. The results show that environmental economic and technical criteria are the most important criteria. Solar wind and hydropower are the top three RES alternatives that are most suitable and feasible. Furthermore biomass geo-thermal and tidal energy were ranked lower which might be due to the limitations and challenges in their adoption and performance in the context of the criteria and sub-criteria used for the analysis. This study’s findings add to the literature on guidelines to strategize for renewable energy adoption for the hydrogen economy in China.
Optimal Energy Management in a Standalone Microgrid, with Photovoltaic Generation, Short-Term Storage, and Hydrogen Production
Mar 2020
Publication
This paper addresses the energy management of a standalone renewable energy system. The system is configured as a microgrid including photovoltaic generation a lead-acid battery as a short term energy storage system hydrogen production and several loads. In this microgrid an energy management strategy has been incorporated that pursues several objectives. On the one hand it aims to minimize the amount of energy cycled in the battery in order to reduce the associated losses and battery size. On the other hand it seeks to take advantage of the long-term surplus energy producing hydrogen and extracting it from the system to be used in a fuel cell hybrid electric vehicle. A crucial factor in this approach is to accommodate the energy consumption to the energy demand and to achieve this a model predictive control (MPC) scheme is proposed. In this context proper models for solar estimation hydrogen production and battery energy storage will be presented. Moreover the controller is capable of advancing or delaying the deferrable loads from its prescheduled time. As a result a stable and efficient supply with a relatively small battery is obtained. Finally the proposed control scheme has been validated on a real case scenario.
Optimal Scheduling of Power Systems with High Proportions of Renewable Energy Accounting for Operational Flexibility
Jul 2023
Publication
Yi Lin,
Wei Lin,
Wei Wu and
Zhenshan Zhu
The volatility and uncertainty of high-penetration renewable energy pose significant challenges to the stability of the power system. Current research often fails to consider the insufficient system flexibility during real-time scheduling. To address this issue this paper proposes a flexibility scheduling method for high-penetration renewable energy power systems that considers flexibility index constraints. Firstly a quantification method for flexibility resources and demands is introduced. Then considering the constraint of the flexibility margin index optimization scheduling strategies for different time scales including day-ahead scheduling and intra-day scheduling are developed with the objective of minimizing total operational costs. The intra-day optimization is divided into 15 min and 1 min time scales to meet the flexibility requirements of different time scales in the power system. Finally through simulation studies the proposed strategy is validated to enhance the system’s flexibility and economic performance. The daily operating costs are reduced by 3.1% and the wind curtailment rate is reduced by 4.7%. The proposed strategy not only considers the economic efficiency of day-ahead scheduling but also ensures a sufficient margin to cope with the uncertainty of intra-day renewable energy fluctuations.
Enhancing Energy Transition through Sector Coupling: A Review of Technologies and Models
Jul 2023
Publication
In order to effectively combat the effects of global warming all sectors must actively reduce greenhouse gas emissions in a sustainable and substantial manner. Sector coupling has emerged as a critical technology that can integrate energy systems and address the temporal imbalances created by intermittent renewable energy sources. Despite its potential current sector coupling capabilities remain underutilized and energy modeling approaches face challenges in understanding the intricacies of sector coupling and in selecting appropriate modeling tools. This paper presents a comprehensive review of sector coupling technologies and their role in the energy transition with a specific focus on the integration of electricity heat/cooling and transportation as well as the importance of hydrogen in sector coupling. Additionally we conducted an analysis of 27 sector coupling models based on renewable energy sources with the goal of aiding deciders in identifying the most appropriate model for their specific modeling needs. Finally the paper highlights the importance of sector coupling in achieving climate protection goals while emphasizing the need for technological openness and market-driven conditions to ensure economically efficient implementation.
Leakage and Diffusion Characteristics of Underground Hydrogen Pipeline
Jun 2023
Publication
Soil corrosion and hydrogen embrittlement are the main factors of hydrogen pipeline failure. The gas escapes diffuses and accumulating in the soil and entering the atmosphere when leak occurs. The mechanism of gas diffusion in buried pipelines is very complicated. Mastering the evolution law of hydrogen leakage diffusion is conducive to quickly locating the leakage point and reducing the loss. The leakage model of the underground hydrogen pipeline is established in this paper. Effect of leakage hole soil type pipeline pressure pipeline diameter on hydrogen leakage diffusion were investigated. The results show that when the hydrogen pipeline leaks the hydrogen concentration increases with the increase of leakage time showing a symmetrical distribution trend. With the pipeline pressure increase hydrogen leakage speed is accelerated and longitudinal diffusion gradually becomes the dominant direction. With the leakage diameter increases hydrogen leakage per unit of time increases sharply. Hydrogen diffuses more easily in sandy soil and diffusion speed concentration and range are higher than that in clay soil. The research content provides a reference and basis for the detection and evaluation of buried hydrogen pipeline leakage.
Optimization of a Hydrogen-based Hybrid Propulsion System Under Aircraft Performance Constraints
Aug 2021
Publication
This paper addresses the topic of the conceptual design of a regional aircraft with hybrid electric propulsion based on hydrogen fuel cells. It aims at providing an optimization-based method to design a hybrid propulsive system comprising two power sources (jet fuel and hydrogen) for the generation of the required propulsive power and at studying the impact of fuel cell technologies on the aircraft performances. Indeed by performing optimizations for two hybrid propulsive systems using either low temperature or high temperature Proton-exchange membrane fuel cells this study provides a preliminary assessment of the impact of the fuel cell operating temperature on the system design and the overall aircraft performance. First this paper gives a description of the baseline turboprop regional aircraft with a focus on its high speed and low speed flight performances which will serve as requirements for the design of the hybrid aircraft. Then the hybrid electric architecture and the sizing models of the propulsion system are presented. Finally optimizations are performed to design two parallel hybrid propulsive systems based on different fuel cells technologies and aimed at minimizing the block fuel per passenger over a mission of 200 nm. Results show how the proposed methodology and models lead to design two propulsive systems capable of reducing the fuel consumption per passenger by more than 30% compared to the baseline aircraft. The study also shows that the choice of fuel cell operating temperature has a first-order impact on the total mass of the propulsive system due to the higher cooling requirement of the low temperature fuel cells.
Investigation of the Hydrogen Production of the PACER Fusion Blanket Integrated with Fe-Cl Thermochemical Water Splitting Cycle
Aug 2023
Publication
In order to meet the energy demand energy production must be done continuously. Hydrogen seems to be the best alternative for this energy production because it is both an environmentally friendly and renewable energy source. In this study the hydrogen fuel production of the peaceful nuclear explosives (PACER) fusion blanket as the energy source integrated with Fe–Cl thermochemical water splitting cycle have been investigated. Firstly neutronic analyzes of the PACER fusion blanket were performed. Necessary neutronic studies were performed in the Monte Carlo calculation method. Molten salt fuel has been considered mole-fractions of heavy metal salt (ThF4 UF4 and ThF4+UF4) by 2 6 and 12 mol. % with Flibe as the main constituent. Secondly potential of the hydrogen fuel production as a result of the neutronic evaluations of the PACER fusion blanket integrated with Fe–Cl thermochemical cycle have been performed. In these calculations tritium breeding (TBR) energy multi plication factor (M) thermal power ratio (1 − ψ) total thermal power (Phpf) and mass flow rate of hydrogen (m˙ H2 ) have been computed. As a results the amount of the hydrogen production (m˙ H2 ) have been obtained in the range of 232.24x106 kg/year and 345.79 x106 kg/year for the all mole-fractions of heavy metal salts using in the blanket.
First Solar Hydrogen Storage in a Private Building in Western Switzerland: Building energy Analysis and Schematic Design
Sep 2019
Publication
Self-sufficiency of buildings with carbon emission reduction can be obtained thanks to the introduction of Photovoltaics systems coupled with Hydrogen seasonal storage. To be self-sufficient over the year the electricity converted to hydrogen by electrolysis during the sunny season can be re-used with the help of fuel cells during the winter season. This article is dealing with the dimensioning methodology of a solar PV hydrogen-electrochemical system for self-sufficient buildings. We introduce the case study of the first private building in western Switzerland that will be equipped with solar hydrogen storage. Calculation results of the dimensioning of the PV system with storage will be presented. The life cycle assessment and the calculations of the environmental indicators GWP and CED will be introduced.
The Economics and the Environmental Benignity of Different Colors of Hydrogen
Feb 2022
Publication
Due to the increasing greenhouse gas emissions as well as due to the rapidly increasing use of renewable energy sources in the electricity generation over the last years interest in hydrogen is rising again. Hydrogen can be used as a storage for renewable energy balancing the whole energy systems and contributing to the decarbonization of the energy system especially of the industry and the transport sector. The major objective of this paper is to discuss various ways of hydrogen production depending on the primary energy sources used. Moreover the economic and environmental performance of three major hydrogen colors as well as major barriers for faster deployment in fuel cell vehicles are analyzed. The major conclusion is that the full environmental benefits of hydrogen use are highly dependent on the hydrogen production methods and primary sources used. Only green hydrogen with electricity from wind PV and hydro has truly low emissions. All other sources like blue hydrogen with CCUS or electrolysis using the electricity grid have substantially higher emissions coming close to grey hydrogen production. Another conclusion is that it is important to introduce an international market for hydrogen to lower costs and to produce hydrogen where conditions are best. Finally the major open question remaining is whether e including all external costs of all energy carriers hydrogen of any color may become economically competitive in any sector of the energy system. The future success of hydrogen is very dependent on technological development and resulting cost reductions as well as on future priorities and the corresponding policy framework. The policy framework should support the shift from grey to green hydrogen.
Techno-economic Assessment of a Chemical Looping Splitting System for H2 and CO Co-generation
Feb 2022
Publication
The natural gas (NG) reforming is currently one of the low-cost methods for hydrogen production. However the mixture of H2 and CO2 in the produced gas inevitably includes CO2 and necessitates the costly CO2 separation. In this work a novel double chemical looping involving both combustion (CLC) and sorption-enhanced reforming (SE-CLR) was proposed towards the co-production of H2 and CO (CLC-SECLRHC) in two separated streams. CLC provides reactant CO2 and energy to feed SECLRHC which generates hydrogen in a higher purity as well as the calcium cycle to generate CO in a higher purity. Techno-economic assessment of the proposed system was conducted to evaluate its efficiency and economic competitiveness. Studies revealed that the optimal molar ratios of oxygen carrier (OC)/NG and steam/NG for reforming were recommended to be 1.7 and 1.0 respectively. The heat integration within CLC and SECLRHC units can be achieved by circulating hot OCs. The desired temperatures of fuel reactor (FR) and reforming reactor (RR) should be 850 °C and 600 °C respectively. The heat coupling between CLC and SECLRHC units can be realized via a jacket-type reactor and the NG split ratio for reforming and combustion was 0.53:0.47. Under the optimal conditions the H2 purity the H2 yield and the CH4 conversion efficiency were 98.76% 2.31 mol mol-1 and 97.96% respectively. The carbon and hydrogen utilization efficiency respectively were 58.60% and 72.45% in terms of the total hydrogen in both steam and NG. The exergy efficiency of the overall process reached 70.28%. In terms of the conventional plant capacity (75×103 t y-1 ) and current raw materials price (2500 $ t-1 ) the payback period can be 6.2 years and the IRR would be 11.5 demonstrating an economically feasible and risk resistant capability.
Double Compression-Expansion Engine (DCEE) Fueled with Hydrogen: Preliminary Computational Assessment
Jan 2022
Publication
Hydrogen (H2 ) is currently a highly attractive fuel for internal combustion engines (ICEs) owing to the prospects of potentially near-zero emissions. However the production emissions and cost of H2 fuel necessitate substantial improvements in ICE thermal efficiency. This work aims to investigate a potential implementation of H2 combustion in a highly efficient double compression-expansion engine (DCEE). DICI nonpremixed H2 combustion mode is used for its superior characteristics as concluded in previous studies. The analysis is performed using a 1D GT-Power software package where different variants of the DICI H2 and diesel combustion cycles obtained experimentally and numerically (3D CFD) are imposed in the combustion cylinder of the DCEE. The results show that the low jet momentum free jet mixing dominated variants of the DICI H2 combustion concept are preferred owing to the lower heat transfer losses and relaxed requirements on the fuel injection system. Insulation of the expander and removal of the intercooling improve the engine efficiency by 1.3 and 0.5 %-points respectively but the latter leads to elevated temperatures in the high-pressure tank which makes the selection of its materials harder but allows the use of cheaper oxidation catalysts. The results also show that the DCEE performance is insensitive to combustion cylinder temperatures making it potentially suitable for other high-octane fuels such as methane methanol ammonia etc. Finally a brake thermal efficiency of 56 % is achieved with H2 combustion around 1 %-point higher than with diesel. Further efficiency improvements are also possible with a fully optimized H2 combustion system.
Sensing Hydrogen Seeps in the Subsurface for Natural Hydrogen Exploration
Jun 2022
Publication
The recent detection of natural hydrogen seeps in sedimentary basin settings has triggered significant interest in the exploration of this promising resource. If large economical resources exist and can be extracted from the sub-surface this would provide an opportunity for natural hydrogen to contribute to the non-carbon-based energy mix. The detection and exploration of hydrogen gas in the sub-surface is a significant challenge that requires costly drilling sophisticated instrumentation and reliable analytical/sampling methods. Here we propose the application of a commercial-based sensor that can be used to detect and monitor low levels of hydrogen gas emissions from geological environments. The sensitivity selectivity (K > 1000) and stability (<1 ppm/day) of the sensor was evaluated under various conditions to determine its suitability for geological field monitoring. Calibration tests showed that the hydrogen readings from the sensor were within ±20% of the expected values. We propose that chemical sensing is a simple and feasible method for understanding natural hydrogen seeps that emanate from geological systems and formations. However we recommend using this sensor as part of a complete geological survey that incorporates an understanding of the geology along with complementary techniques that provide information on the rock properties.
Complex Metal Borohydrides: From Laboratory Oddities to Prime Candidates in Energy Storage Applications
Mar 2022
Publication
Despite being the lightest element in the periodic table hydrogen poses many risks regarding its production storage and transport but it is also the one element promising pollutionfree energy for the planet energy reliability and sustainability. Development of such novel materials conveying a hydrogen source face stringent scrutiny from both a scientific and a safety point of view: they are required to have a high hydrogen wt.% storage capacity must store hydrogen in a safe manner (i.e. by chemically binding it) and should exhibit controlled and preferably rapid absorption–desorption kinetics. Even the most advanced composites today face the difficult task of overcoming the harsh re-hydrogenation conditions (elevated temperature high hydrogen pressure). Traditionally the most utilized materials have been RMH (reactive metal hydrides) and complex metal borohydrides M(BH4 )x (M: main group or transition metal; x: valence of M) often along with metal amides or various additives serving as catalysts (Pd2+ Ti4+ etc.). Through destabilization (kinetic or thermodynamic) M(BH4 )x can effectively lower their dehydrogenation enthalpy providing for a faster reaction occurring at a lower temperature onset. The present review summarizes the recent scientific results on various metal borohydrides aiming to present the current state-of-the-art on such hydrogen storage materials while trying to analyze the pros and cons of each material regarding its thermodynamic and kinetic behavior in hydrogenation studies.
Everything About Hydrogen Podcast: Scaling Clean Hydrogen Production
Dec 2021
Publication
Today we are joined by our good friends from Enapter. The company is a leader in the clean hydrogen sector focused on AEM electrolyzer technology and innovative software solutions that make it possible to rapidly deploy and scale hydrogen production assets. For those who follow the hydrogen sector regularly it’s been hard not to hear Enapter-related news in 2021 and its impressive trajectory as they have gone public announced the plans for a brand new production facility in Germany (on which they have now begun construction) and most recently the announcement that Enapter was selected as the winner of the prestigious Earthshot prize. To do that we are absolutely delighted to have with us all the way from his home base in Thailand Thomas Chrometzka Chief Strategy Officer at Enapter and one of the people that we enjoy having on the show so much that we have brought him back again to fill us in on what he and Enapter are up to and what they have planned for the future of hydrogen.
The podcast can be found on their website
The podcast can be found on their website
Effect of Ignition Energy and Hydrogen Addition on Laminar Flame Speed, Ignition Delay Time, and Flame Rising Time of Lean Methane/Air Mixtures
Mar 2022
Publication
A series of experiments were performed to investigate the effect of ignition energy (Eig) and hydrogen addition on the laminar burning velocity (Su 0 ) ignition delay time (tdelay) and flame rising time (trising) of lean methane−air mixtures. The mixtures at three different equivalence ratios (φ) of 0.6 0.7 and 0.8 with varying hydrogen volume fractions from 0 to 50% were centrally ignited in a constant volume combustion chamber by a pair of pin-to-pin electrodes at a spark gap of 2.0 mm. In situ ignition energy (Eig ∼2.4 mJ ÷ 58 mJ) was calculated by integration of the product of current and voltage between positive and negative electrodes. The result revealed that the Su 0 value increases non-linearly with increasing hydrogen fraction at three equivalence ratios of 0.6 0.7 and 0.8 by which the increasing slope of Su 0 changes from gradual to drastic when the hydrogen fraction is greater than 20%. tdelay and trising decrease quickly with increasing hydrogen fraction; however trising drops faster than tdelay at φ = 0.6 and 0.7 and the reverse is true at φ = 0.8. Furthermore tdelay transition is observed when Eig > Eigcritical by which tdelay drastically drops in the pre-transition and gradually decreases in the post-transition. These results may be relevant to spark ignition engines operated under lean-burn conditions.
Fabrication of Highly Textured 2D SnSe Layers with Tunable Electronic Properties for Hydrogen Evolution
Jun 2021
Publication
Hydrogen is regarded to be one of the most promising renewable and clean energy sources. Finding a highly efficient and cost-effective catalyst to generate hydrogen via water splitting has become a research hotspot. Two-dimensional materials with exotic structural and electronic properties have been considered as economical alternatives. In this work 2D SnSe films with high quality of crystallinity were grown on a mica substrate via molecular beam epitaxy. The electronic property of the prepared SnSe thin films can be easily and accurately tuned in situ by three orders of magnitude through the controllable compensation of Sn atoms. The prepared film normally exhibited p-type conduction due to the deficiency of Sn in the film during its growth. First-principle calculations explained that Sn vacancies can introduce additional reactive sites for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and enhance the HER performance by accelerating electron migration and promoting continuous hydrogen generation which was mirrored by the reduced Gibbs free energy by a factor of 2.3 as compared with the pure SnSe film. The results pave the way for synthesized 2D SnSe thin films in the applications of hydrogen production.
Techno-Economic Evaluation of Deploying CCS in SMR Based Merchant H2 Production with NG as Feedstock and Fuel
Aug 2017
Publication
Hydrogen is a crucial raw materials to other industries. Globally nearly 90% of the hydrogen or HyCO gas produced is consumed by the ammonia methanol and oil refining industries. In the future hydrogen could play an important role in the decarbonisation of transport fuel (i.e. use of fuel cell vehicles) and space heating (i.e. industrial commercial building and residential heating). This paper summarizes the results of the feasibility study carried out by Amec Foster Wheeler for the IEA Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme (IEA GHG) with the purpose of evaluating the performance and costs of a modern steam methane reforming without and with CCS producing 100000 Nm3 /h H2 and operating as a merchant plant. This study focuses on the economic evaluation of five different alternatives to capture CO2 from SMR. This paper provides an up-to-date assessment of the performance and cost of producing hydrogen without and with CCS based on technologies that could be erected today. This study demonstrates that CO2 could be captured from an SMR plant with an overall capture rate ranging between 53 to 90%. The integration of CO2 capture plant could increase the NG consumption by -0.03 to 1.41 GJ per Nm3 /h of H2. The amount of electricity exported to the grid by the SMR plant is reduced. The levelised cost of H2 production could increase by 2.1 to 5.1 € cent per Nm3 H2 (depending on capture rate and technology selected). This translates to a CO2 avoidance cost of 47 to 70 €/t.
Hydrogen Deep Ocean Link: A Global Sustainable Interconnected Energy Grid
Mar 2022
Publication
The world is undergoing a substantial energy transition with an increasing share of intermittent sources of energy on the grid which is increasing the challenges to operate the power grid reliably. An option that has been receiving much focus after the COVID pandemic is the development of a hydrogen economy. Challenges for a hydrogen economy are the high investment costs involved in compression storage and long-distance transportation. This paper analyses an innovative proposal for the creation of hydrogen ocean links. It intends to fill existing gaps in the creation of a hydrogen economy with the increase in flexibility and viability for hydrogen production consumption compression storage and transportation. The main concept behind the proposals presented in this paper consists of using the fact that the pressure in the deep sea is very high which allows a thin and cheap HDPE tank to store and transport large amounts of pressurized hydrogen in the deep sea. This is performed by replacing seawater with pressurized hydrogen and maintaining the pressure in the pipes similar to the outside pressure. Hydrogen Deep Ocean Link has the potential of increasing the interconnectivity of different regional energy grids into a global sustainable interconnected energy system.
An Experimental Study of Propagating Spherical Flames in Unconfined Hydrogen-oxygen Explosions
Sep 2021
Publication
The study to understand the flame propagation behaviors of hydrogen-oxygen explosions is required to make a precise risk assessment. Moreover although research has investigated the propagating spherical flames in unconfined hydrogen-air explosions no study to date has examined the hydrogen-oxygen explosions. The spherical flame propagation in unconfined hydrogen-oxygen explosions have been investigated using a soap bubble method. In the present experiments hydrogen-oxygen mixtures were filled in a 10 cm diameter soap bubble and ignited by an electric spark at the center. The flame propagation behaviors were measured by a high-speed Schlieren photography. The laminar burning velocities and critical flame radii for the onset of flame acceleration in unconfined hydrogen-oxygen explosions were estimated. Results demonstrated that the laminar burning velocities of hydrogenoxygen mixtures were much faster than those of hydrogen-air mixtures. In addition the shift value of maximum laminar burning velocity for hydrogen-oxygen mixtures towards a leaner equivalence ratio is observed. The experimental flame speeds for all experiments were increased owing to diffusionalthermal and Darrieus-Landau instabilities although the measured flame radii were small. The critical flame radius corresponding to the onset of flame acceleration decreased with the decrease in equivalence ratio.
No more items...