Transmission, Distribution & Storage
Blowout Prediction on a Salt Cavern Selected for a Hydrogen Storage Pilot
Oct 2022
Publication
To prevent climate change Europe and the world must shift to low-carbon and renewable energies. Hydrogen as an energy vector provides viable solutions for replacing polluting and carbon-emitting fossil fuels. Gaseous hydrogen can be stored underground and coupled with existing natural gas pipe networks. Salt cavern storage is the best suited technology to meet the challenges of new energy systems. Hydrogen storage caverns are currently operated in the UK and Texas. A preliminary risk analysis dedicated to underground hydrogen salt caverns highlighted the importance of containment losses (leaks) and the formation of gas clouds following blowouts whose ignition may generate dangerous phenomena such as jet fires unconfined vapor cloud explosions (UVCEs) or flashfires. A blowout is not a frequent accident in gas storage caverns. A safety valve is often set at a 30 m depth below ground level; it is automatically triggered following a pressure drop at the wellhead. Nevertheless a blowout remains to be one of the significant accidental scenarios likely to occur during hydrogen underground storage in salt caverns. In this paper we present modelling the subterraneous and aerial parts of a blowout on an EZ53 salt cavern fully filled with hydrogen.
Estimation of the Influence of Compressed Hydrogen on the Mechanical Properties of Pipeline Steels
Sep 2021
Publication
Consideration of the possibility of transporting compressed hydrogen through existing gas pipelines leads to the need to study the regularities of the effect of hydrogen on the mechanical properties of steels in relation to the conditions of their operation in pipelines (operating pressure range stress state of the pipe metal etc.). This article provides an overview of the types of influence of hydrogen on the mechanical properties of steels including those used for the manufacture of pipelines. The effect of elastic and plastic deformations on the intensity of hydrogen saturation of steels and changes in their strength and plastic deformations is analyzed. An assessment of the potential losses of transported hydrogen through the pipeline wall as a result of diffusion has been made. The main issues that need to be solved for the development of a scientifically grounded conclusion on the possibility of using existing gas pipelines for the transportation of compressed hydrogen are outlined.
NewGasMet - Flow Metering of Renewable Gases (Biogas, Biomethane, Hydrogen, Syngas and Mixtures with Natural Gas): Report on the Usable Technologies for Calibrating Gas Meters with Renewable Gases and Currently Available Flow Standards Suitable for Use with Methane, Crude Biogas, Hydrogen and Mixtures of these gases
Mar 2021
Publication
The main goal stated at the Paris agreement is to limit the global temperature rise well below 2 °C above pre-industrial levels. Limiting the increase of global average temperature to 1.5 °C is striven since risks and impacts of the climate change would be reduced drastically. To face these challenges the European Green Deal was invented by the European Commission. The “Green Deal” is a growth strategy which aims to transform the economy of the EU into a resource-efficient modern and competitive one [1-1 1-2]. Figure 1: The key elements of the European Green Deal [1-2] In this context the European Commission proposed that the amount of renewable energy within the EU’s overall energy mix should reach 20 % by 2020 and therefore producing energy by solar and wind plants become even more important. For example the cumulative installed wind farm capacity increased from 117.3 GW in 2013 to a total capacity of 182.163 GW in 2018 within the EU [1-4-1-6]. Due to the fluctuations in energy produced by wind farms storage of electricity is crucial. One possibility for storage is the production of hydrogen via electrolysis using renewable energy sources like wind farms. The hydrogen is then either directly added to the gas distribution grid or is converted to methane with external CO or CO2 which is then added to the gas distribution grid as a substitute [1-4]. Increasing the knowledge about the impact of renewable gases on available gas meters in terms of accuracy and durability is the main object of the EMPIR NEWGASMET project. Therefore in activity A3.1.1 a literature study was performed to provide information on which technologies can be used to calibrate gas meters when using renewable gases.
A Review of the MSCA ITN ECOSTORE—Novel Complex Metal Hydrides for Efficient and Compact Storage of Renewable Energy as Hydrogen and Electricity
Mar 2020
Publication
Hydrogen as an energy carrier is very versatile in energy storage applications. Developments in novel sustainable technologies towards a CO2-free society are needed and the exploration of all-solid-state batteries (ASSBs) as well as solid-state hydrogen storage applications based on metal hydrides can provide solutions for such technologies. However there are still many technical challenges for both hydrogen storage material and ASSBs related to designing low-cost materials with low-environmental impact. The current materials considered for all-solid-state batteries should have high conductivities for Na+ Mg2+ and Ca2+ while Al3+-based compounds are often marginalised due to the lack of suitable electrode and electrolyte materials. In hydrogen storage materials the sluggish kinetic behaviour of solid-state hydride materials is one of the key constraints that limit their practical uses. Therefore it is necessary to overcome the kinetic issues of hydride materials before discussing and considering them on the system level. This review summarizes the achievements of the Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions (MSCA) innovative training network (ITN) ECOSTORE the aim of which was the investigation of different aspects of (complex) metal hydride materials. Advances in battery and hydrogen storage materials for the efficient and compact storage of renewable energy production are discussed.
Hybrid Hydrogen–PV–e-Mobility Industrial Energy Community Concept—A Technology Feasibility Study
Sep 2021
Publication
As renewable energy sources are spreading the problems of energy usage transport and storage arise more frequently. In order that the performance of energy producing units from renewable sources which have a relatively low efficiency should not be decreased further and to promote sustainable energy consumption solutions a living lab conception was elaborated in this project. At the pilot site the produced energy (by PV panels gas turbines/engines) is stored in numerous ways including hydrogen production. The following uses of hydrogen are explored: (i) feeding it into the national natural gas network; (ii) selling it at a H-CNG (compressed natural gas) filling station; (iii) using it in fuel cells to produce electricity. This article introduces the overall implementation plan which can serve as a model for the hybrid energy communities to be established in the future.
A Review of Factors Affecting SCC Initiation and Propagation in Pipeline Carbon Steels
Aug 2022
Publication
Pipelines have been installed and operated around the globe to transport oil and gas for decades. They are considered to be an effective economic and safe means of transportation. The major concern in their operation is corrosion. Among the different forms of corrosion stress corrosion cracking (SCC) which is caused by stresses induced by internal fluid flow or other external forces during the pipeline’s operation in combined action with the presence of a corrosive medium can lead to pipeline failure. In this paper an extensive review of different factors affecting SCC of pipeline steels in various environmental conditions is carried out to understand their impact. Several factors such as temperature presence of oxidizers (O2 CO2 H2S etc.) composition and concentration of medium pH applied stress and microstructure of the metal/alloy have been established to affect the SCC of pipeline steels. SCC susceptibility of a steel at a particular temperature strongly depends on the type and composition of the corrosive medium and microstructure. It was observed that pipeline steels with water quenched and quenched and tempered heat treatments such as those that consist of acicular ferrite or bainitic ferrite grains are more susceptible to SCC irrespective of solution type and composition. Applied stress stress concentration and fluctuating stress facilitates SCC initiation and propagation. In general the mechanisms for crack initiation and propagation in near-neutral solutions are anodic dissolution and hydrogen embrittlement.
NewGasMet - Flow Metering of Renewable Gases (Biogas, Biomethane, Hydrogen, Syngas and Mixtures with Natural Gas): Criteria and Proposals for EMC Tests on Ultrasonic Meters with Non-conventional Gases
Oct 2022
Publication
The NEWGASMET project has the overall objective to increase knowledge about the accuracy and durability of commercially available gas meters after exposure to renewable gases. This should lead to the improvement of existing meter designs and flow calibration standards. One of the recently released results is a proposal for a set of test gases to represent the range of non-conventional gases in the scope of the revision of the gas meter standards. In details these were proposed to be used in the CEN/TC237 standards and the OIML-R137:2014. During the project meetings concerns have been raised regarding the applicability of such test gases to EMC tests for static meters. Today such tests are performed in air but there is a clear agreement that the behaviour of the meter during EMC tests can be influenced by the renewable gas type. At least this agreement exists for the ultrasonic measurement technology while further discussion might be needed for the mass flow. However it is not simply possible to redesign the current EMC tests by replacing air with the defined gas mixtures as this would be quite impractical especially considering the explosive nature of the test gases.
Assessment of Hydrogen Delivery Options: Feasibility of Transport of Green Hydrogen within Europe
Oct 2022
Publication
The RePowerEU plan [1] and the European Hydrogen Strategy [2] recognise the important role that the transport of hydrogen will play in enabling the penetration of renewable hydrogen in Europe. To implement the European Hydrogen Strategy it is important to understand whether the transport of hydrogen is cost effective or whether hydrogen should be produced where it is used. If transporting hydrogen makes sense a second open question is how long the transport route should be for the cost of the hydrogen to still be competitive with locally produced hydrogen. JRC has performed a comprehensive study regarding the transport of hydrogen. To investigate which renewable hydrogen delivery pathways are favourable in terms of energy demand and costs JRC has developed a database and an analytical tool to assess each step of the pathways and used it to assess two case studies. The study reveals that there is no single optimal hydrogen delivery solution across every transport scenario. The most cost effective way to deliver renewable hydrogen depends on distance amount final use and whether there is infrastructure already available. For distances compatible with the European territory compressed and liquefied hydrogen solutions and especially compressed hydrogen pipelines offer lower costs than chemical carriers do. The repurposing of existing natural gas pipelines for hydrogen use is expected to significantly lower the delivery cost making the pipeline option even more competitive in the future. By contrast chemical carriers become more competitive the longer the delivery distance (due to their lower transport costs) and open up import options from suppliers located for example in Chile or Australia.
Hydrogen Supply Chain Scenarios for the Decarbonisation of a German Multi-modal Energy System
Sep 2021
Publication
Analysing hydrogen supply chains is of utmost importance to adequately understand future energy systems with a high degree of sector coupling. Here a multi-modal energy system model is set up as linear programme incorporating electricity natural gas as well as hydrogen transportation options for Germany in 2050. Further different hydrogen import routes and optimised inland electrolysis are included. In a sensitivity analysis hydrogen demands are varied to cover uncertainties and to provide scenarios for future requirements of a hydrogen supply and transportation infrastructure. 80% of the overall hydrogen demand of 150 TWh/a emerge in Northern Germany due to optimised electrolyser locations and imports which subsequently need to be transported southwards. Therefore a central hydrogen pipeline connection from Schleswig-Holstein to the region of Darmstadt evolves already for moderate demands and appears to be a no-regret investment. Furthermore a natural gas pipeline reassignment potential of 46% is identified.
Numerical Simulation on Heating Effects during Hydrogen Absorption in Metal Hydride Systems for Hydrogen Storage
Apr 2022
Publication
A 2-D numerical simulation model was established based on a small-sized metal hydride storage tank and the model was validated by the existing experiments. An external cooling bath was equipped to simulate the heating effects of hydrogen absorption reactions. Furthermore both the type and the flow rate of the cooling fluids in the cooling bath were altered so that changes in temperature and hydrogen storage capacity in the hydrogen storage model could be analyzed. It is demonstrated that the reaction rate in the center of the hydrogen storage tank gradually becomes lower than that at the wall surface. When the flow rate of the fluid is small significant differences can be found in the cooling liquid temperature at the inlet and the outlet cooling bath. In areas adjacent to its inlet the reaction rate is higher than that at the outlet and a better cooling effect is produced by water. As the flow rate increases the total time consumed by hydrogen adsorption reaction is gradually reduced to a constant value. At the same flow rate the wall surface of the tank shows a reaction rate insignificantly different from that in its center provided that cooling water or oil coolant is replaced with air.
Optimizing Renewable Injection in Integrated Natural Gas Pipeline Networks Using a Multi-Period Programming Approach
Mar 2023
Publication
In this paper we propose an optimization model that considers two pathways for injecting renewable content into natural gas pipeline networks. The pathways include (1) power-to-hydrogen or PtH where off-peak electricity is converted to hydrogen via electrolysis and (2) power-to-methane or PtM where carbon dioxide from different source locations is converted into renewable methane (also known as synthetic natural gas SNG). The above pathways result in green hydrogen and methane which can be injected into an existing natural gas pipeline network. Based on these pathways a multi-period network optimization model that integrates the design and operation of hydrogen from PtH and renewable methane is proposed. The multi-period model is a mixed-integer non-linear programming (MINLP) model that determines (1) the optimal concentration of hydrogen and carbon dioxide in the natural gas pipelines (2) the optimal location of PtH and carbon dioxide units while minimizing the overall system cost. We show using a case study in Ontario the optimal network structure for injecting renewable hydrogen and methane within an integrated natural gas network system provides a $12M cost reduction. The optimal concentration of hydrogen ranges from 0.2 vol % to a maximum limit of 15.1 vol % across the network while reaching a 2.5 vol % at the distribution point. This is well below the maximum limit of 5 vol % specification. Furthermore the optimizer realized a CO2 concentration ranging from 0.2 vol % to 0.7 vol %. This is well below the target of 1% specified in the model. The study is essential to understanding the practical implication of hydrogen penetration in natural gas systems in terms of constraints on hydrogen concentration and network system costs.
NewGasMet - Flow Metering of Renewable Gases (Biogas, Biomethane, Hydrogen, Syngas and Mixtures with Natural Gas): Effect of Hydrogen Admixture on the Accuracy of a Rotary Flow Meter
Aug 2021
Publication
With the rise of hydrogen use in the natural gas grid a need exists for reliable measurements of the amount of energy being transported and traded for hydrogen admixtures. Using VSL’s high-pressure Gas Oil Piston Prover (GOPP) primary standard the effect of mixing hydrogen with natural gas on the performance of a high-pressure gas flow meter was investigated. The error of a rotary flow meter was determined using the best possible uncertainty by calibration with the primary standard for high-pressure natural gas flow. The rotary flow meter was calibrated using both natural gas and hydrogen enriched natural gas (nominally 15% hydrogen) at two different pressures: 9 and 16 bar. Results indicate that for the rotary flow meter and hydrogen admixtures used the differences in the meter errors between high-pressure hydrogen-enriched natural gas calibration and high-pressure natural gas calibration are smaller than the corresponding differences between atmospheric pressure air calibration and high-pressure natural gas calibration.
Feasibility of Hydrogen Storage in Depleted Hydrocarbon Chalk Reservoirs: Assessment of Biochemical and Chemical Effects
Jul 2022
Publication
Hydrogen storage is one of the energy storage methods that can help realization of an emission free future by saving surplus renewable energy for energy deficit periods. Utilization of depleted hydrocarbon reservoirs for large-scale hydrogen storage may be associated with the risk of chemical/biochemical reactions. In the specific case of chalk reservoirs the principal reactions are abiotic calcite dissolution acetogenesis methanogenesis and biological souring. Here we use PHREEQC to evaluate the dynamics and the extent of hydrogen loss by each of these reactions in hydrogen storage scenarios for various Danish North Sea chalk hydrocarbon reservoirs. We find that: (i) Abiotic calcite dissolution does not occur in the temperature range of 40-180◦ C. (ii) If methanogens and acetogens grow as slow as the slowest growing methanogens and acetogens reported in the literature methanogenesis and acetogenesis cannot cause a hydrogen loss more than 0.6% per year. However (iii) if they proceed as fast as the fastest growing methanogens and acetogens reported in the literature a complete loss of all injected hydrogen in less than five years is possible. (iv) Co-injection of CO2 can be employed to inhibit calcite dissolution and keep the produced methane due to methanogenesis carbon neutral. (v) Biological sulfate reduction does not cause significant hydrogen loss during 10 years but it can lead to high hydrogen sulfide concentrations (1015 ppm). Biological sulfate reduction is expected to impact hydrogen storage only in early stages if the only source of sulfur substrates are the dissolved species in the brine and not rock minerals. Considering these findings we suggest that depleted chalk reservoirs may not possess chemical/biochemical risks and be good candidates for large-scale underground hydrogen storage.
Seasonal Hydrogen Storage for Sustainable Renewable Energy Integration in the Electricity Sector: A Case Study of Finland
Nov 2021
Publication
Wind power is rapidly growing in the Finnish grid and Finland’s electricity consumption is low in the summer compared to the winter. Hence there is a need for storage that can absorb a large amount of energy during summer and discharge it during winter. This study examines one such storage technology geological hydrogen storage which has the potential to store energy on a GWh scale and also over longer periods of time. Finland’s electricity generation system was modelled with and without hydrogen storage using the LEAP-NEMO modeling toolkit. The results showed about 69% decline in carbon dioxide emissions as well as a decline in the fossil fuel-based power accompanied with a higher capability to meet demand with less imports in both scenarios. Finally a critical analysis of the Finnish electricity mix with and without hydrogen storage is presented.
Comparative Study on Ammonia and Liquid Hydrogen Transportation Costs in Comparison to LNG
Feb 2023
Publication
Since ammonia and liquid hydrogen are the optional future shipping cargo and fuels the applicability was crucial using the current technologies and expectations. Existing studies for the economic feasibility of the energies had limitations: empirical evaluation with assumptions and insufficiency related to causality. A distorted estimation can result in failure of decision-making or policy in terms of future energy. The present study aimed to evaluate the transportation costs of future energy including ammonia and liquid hydrogen in comparison to LNG for overcoming the limitations. An integrated mathematical model was applied to the investigation for economic feasibility. The transportation costs of the chosen energies were evaluated for the given transportation plan considering key factors: ship speed BOR and transportation plan. The transportation costs at the design speed for LNG and liquid hydrogen were approximately 55 % and 80 % of that for ammonia without considering the social cost due to CO2 emission. Although ammonia was the most expensive energy for transportation ammonia could be an effective alternative due to insensitivity to the transportation plan. If the social cost was taken into account liquid hydrogen already gained competitiveness in comparison to LNG. The advantage of liquid hydrogen was maximized for higher speed where more BOG was injected into main engines.
Briefing on the EU Innovation Fund and the Implications for CCUS Projects- First Report on the Thematic Working Group on Policy, Regulation and Public Perception
Jan 2020
Publication
This report outlines the key modalities and procedures for the Innovation Fund and focuses on the potential funding implications for CCUS projects. The assessment of the suitability of the Innovation Fund for CCS projects has been completed based on discussion during a workshop hosted by the EU CCUS Projects Network in October 2019. This session was part of the Network’s Thematic Group on Policy Regulation and Public Perception. The session was held according to Chatham House rules to allow the projects present to exchange viewpoints and ideas freely.<br/>Broadly speaking it is hoped that the Innovation Fund Call for Proposal documents expected in mid-2020 will provide more information on how applicants should approach some of the key evaluation criteria namely calculating emissions avoidance for part-chain CCS and CCU projects demonstrating project maturity as well as project innovativeness. Furthermore there remains a concern that the costs for developing sufficient contingent storage sites could be overlooked by the Innovation Fund and EU policies directed towards CCS in general. Finally whereas there does not seem to be any regulatory barriers to blending Innovation Fund financing with Member State subsidies the asynchronous timing between the planned final investment decisions (FIDs) of some of the more advanced projects and the outcomes of the Innovation Fund (expected in 2022) means that certain projects may not be able to benefit from this.
A Review of Hydrogen Production and Supply Chain Modeling and Optmization
Jan 2023
Publication
This paper reviews recent optimization models for hydrogen supply chains and production. Optimization is a central component of systematic methodologies to support hydrogen expansion. Hydrogen production is expected to evolve in the coming years to help replace fossil fuels; these high expectations arise from the potential to produce low-carbon hydrogen via electrolysis using electricity generated by renewable sources. However hydrogen is currently mainly used in refinery and industrial operations; therefore physical infrastructures for transmission distribution integration with other energy systems and efficient hydrogen production processes are lacking. Given the potential of hydrogen the greenfield state of infrastructures and the variability of renewable sources systematic methodologies are needed to reach competitive hydrogen prices and design hydrogen supply chains. Future research topics are identified: 1) improved hydrogen demand projections 2) integrated sector modeling 3) improving temporal and spatial resolutions 4) accounting for climate change 5) new methods to address sophisticated models.
Experimental Study of Hydrogen Embrittlement in Maraging Steels
Feb 2018
Publication
This research activity aims at investigating the hydrogen embrittlement of Maraging steels in connection to real sudden failures of some of the suspension blades of the Virgo Project experimental apparatus. Some of them failed after 15 years of service in working conditions. Typically in the Virgo detector blades are loaded up to 50-60% of the material yield strength. For a deeper understanding of the failure the relationship between hydrogen concentration and mechanical properties of the material have been investigated with specimens prepared in order to simulate blade working conditions. A mechanical characterization of the material has been carried out by standard tensile testing in order to establish the effect of hydrogen content on the material strength. Further experimental activity was executed in order to characterize the fracture surface and to measure the hydrogen content. Finally some of the failed blades have been analyzed in DICI-UNIPI laboratory. The experimental results show that the blades failure can be related with the hydrogen embrittlement phenomenon.
Material-based Hydrogen Storage Projection
Sep 2021
Publication
Massive consumption of fossil fuel leads to shortage problems as well as various global environmental issues. Due to the global climatic problem in the world techniques to supply energy demand change from conventional methods that use fossil fuel as the energy source to clean and renewable sources such as solar and wind. However these renewable energy sources are not permanent. Energy storage methods can ensure to supply the energy demand in need if the energy is stored when the renewable source is available. Hydrogen is considered a promising alternative feedstock owing to has unique properties such as clean energy high energy density absence of toxic materials and carbon-free nature. Hydrogen is used main fuel source in fuel cells and hydrogen can be produced with various methods such as wind or electrolysis of water systems that supply electricity from renewable sources. However the safe effective and economical storage of hydrogen is still a challenge that limits the spread of the usage of hydrogen energy. High pressed hydrogen gas and cryogenic hydrogen liquid are two applied storage pathways although they do not meet the above-mentioned requirement. To overcome these drawbacks materials-based hydrogen storage materials have been mostly investigated research field recently. The aim of the study is that exhibiting various material-based hydrogen storage systems and development of these techniques worldwide. Additionally past and current status of the technology are explained and future perspective is discussed.
A Comprehensive Review on the Recent Development of Ammonia as a Renewable Energy Carrier
Jun 2021
Publication
Global energy sources are being transformed from hydrocarbon-based energy sources to renewable and carbon-free energy sources such as wind solar and hydrogen. The biggest challenge with hydrogen as a renewable energy carrier is the storage and delivery system’s complexity. Therefore other media such as ammonia for indirect storage are now being considered. Research has shown that at reasonable pressures ammonia is easily contained as a liquid. In this form energy density is approximately half of that of gasoline and ten times more than batteries. Ammonia can provide effective storage of renewable energy through its existing storage and distribution network. In this article we aimed to analyse the previous studies and the current research on the preparation of ammonia as a next-generation renewable energy carrier. The study focuses on technical advances emerging in ammonia synthesis technologies such as photocatalysis electrocatalysis and plasmacatalysis. Ammonia is now also strongly regarded as fuel in the transport industrial and power sectors and is relatively more versatile in reducing CO2 emissions. Therefore the utilisation of ammonia as a renewable energy carrier plays a significant role in reducing GHG emissions. Finally the simplicity of ammonia processing transport and use makes it an appealing choice for the link between the development of renewable energy and demand.
No more items...