Safety
Simulation of Hydrogen Dispersion under Cryogenic Release Conditions
Sep 2013
Publication
The use of hydrogen as fuel should always be accompanied by a safety assessment in case of an accidental release. To evaluate the potential hazards in a spill accident both experiments and simulations are performed. In the present work the CFD code ADREA-HF is used to simulate the liquefied hydrogen (LH2) spill experiments (test 5 6 7) conducted by the Health and Safety Laboratory (HSL). In these tests LH2 was spilled at a fixed rate of 60lt/min in several directions and for several durations. The factors that influence the vapor dispersion under cryogenic release conditions that were examined in this study are: the air humidity the wind direction and the slip effect of droplets formed by both the cryogenic liquid and the condensation of air humidity. The numerical results were compared with the experimental measurements and the effect of each abovementioned factors in the vapor dispersion is being discussed.
Safe Hydrogen Fuel Handling and Use for Efficient Implementation – SH2IFT
Sep 2019
Publication
The SH2IFT project combines social and technical scientific methods to address knowledge gaps regarding safe handling and use of gaseous and liquid hydrogen. Theoretical approaches will be complemented by fire and explosion experiments with emphasis on topics of strategic importance to Norway such as tunnel safety maritime applications etc. Experiments include Rapid Phase Transition Boiling Liquid Expanding Vapour Explosion and jet fires. This paper gives an overview of the project and preliminary results.
Delivering a Safe, Viable Hydrogen Economy in Australia
Sep 2019
Publication
At Woodside Energy Ltd (Woodside) safety is built into everything we do and progressing hydrogen opportunities is no exception. This paper will present information from the macro level of process safety for hydrogen at a plant level through to the consumer experience. Examples of the benefits of an integrated process safety approach will be used from Woodside’s experience pioneering the liquefied natural gas industry in Australia.<br/>This paper will underscore the reasons why Australia needs to adopt robust safety standards for hydrogen as quickly as possible in order to advance the hydrogen economy across all sectors. Focus areas requiring attention during development of standards and potential mechanisms to close will be proposed. Establishing a hydrogen economy in Australia could lower carbon emissions stabilise power grids increase renewable energy penetration and create jobs. Developing Australian standards that are fully aligned with international standards will facilitate Australia taking a leading role in the global hydrogen economy.
Homogeneous and Inhomogeneous Hydrogen Deflagrations in 25 m3 Enclosure
Sep 2019
Publication
Explosion venting is a frequently used measure to mitigate the consequence of gas deflagrations in closed environments. Despite the effort to predict the vent area needed to achieved the protection through engineering formulas and CFD tools work has still to be done to reliably predict the outcome of a vented gas explosion. Most of available data derived from experimental campaigns performed in the past involved homogeneous conditions while especially in the case of a very buoyant gas such as hydrogen the most probable scenario that can follow and unintended release in a closed environment foresee the ignition of a stratified inhomogeneous mixture. University of Pisa performed experimental tests in a 25 m3 facility in homogeneous and inhomogeneous conditions. The present paper is aimed to share the results of hydrogen dispersion and deflagration tests and discuss the comparison of maximum peak overpressure generated in the two scenarios. Description of the experimental set-up includes all the details deemed necessary to reproduce the phenomenon with a CFD tool.
Dependency of Equivalence Ratio on Hydrogen Cylindrical Detonation Induced by Direct Initiation
Sep 2011
Publication
A hydrogen fuel is expected to expand its demand in the future. However hydrogen has to be treated with enough caution because of wide combustible conditions and easiness to ignite. Detonation accidents are caused in hydrogen gas such as the explosion accident in Fukushima first nuclear plant (2011). Therefore it is necessary to comprehend initiation conditions of detonation to prevent its detonation explosion. In the present study cylindrical detonation induced by direct initiation is simulated to understand the dependency of equivalence ratios in hydrogen-oxygen mixture. The several detailed kinetic models are compared to select the most appropriate model for detonation in a wide range of equivalence ratios. The Petersen-Hanson model is used in the present study due to the best agreement among the other models. In the numerical results of cylindrical detonation induced by direct initiation a cellular structure which is similar to the experimental smoked foil record is observed. The local pressure is up to 12 MPa under the condition at the standard state. The ignition process of cylindrical detonation has two stages. At the first stage the normalized cell width /L1/2 at each equivalence ratio increases linearly. At the second stage cell bifurcations appear due to a generation of new transverse waves. It is observed that a transverse wave transforms to a transverse detonation at the end of the first stage and after that some disturbance is developed to be a new transverse wave at the beginning of the second stage.
Experimental Results on The Dispersion of Buoyant Gas in a Full Scale Garage from a Complex Source
Sep 2009
Publication
The lack of experimental data on hydrogen dispersion led to the experimental project DRIVE (Experimental Data for Hydrogen Automotive Risks Assessment for the validation of numerical tools and for the Edition of guidelines) that involves the CEA (French Atomic Energy Commission) the National Institute of Industrial Environment and Risks (INERIS) the French car manufacturer PSA PEUGEOT CITROËN and the Research Institute on Out of Equilibrium Phenomena (IRPHE). The CEA has developed an experimental setup named GARAGE in order to analyze the condition of formation of an explosive atmosphere in an enclosure. This is a full scale facility in which a real car can be parked. Hydrogen releases were simulated with helium which volume fraction was measured with mini-katharometers. These thermal conductivity probes allow spatial and time volume fraction variations measurements. We present experimental results on the dispersion of helium in the enclosure due to releases in a typical car. The tested parameters are the location of the source (engine bottom of the car storage) and the flow rate. Emphasis is put on the influence of these parameters on the time evolution of the volume fraction in the enclosure as well as on the vertical distribution of helium.
Experiments on the Distribution of Concentration Due to Buoyant Gas Low Flow Rate Release in an Enclosure.
Sep 2009
Publication
Hydrogen energy based vehicles or power generators are expected to come into widespread use in the near future. Safety information is of major importance to support the successful public acceptance of hydrogen as an energy carrier. One of the most important issues in terms of safety is the use of such system in closed area such as a private garage in which a fuel cell car may be parked. This kind of situation leads to the fundamental problem of the dispersion of hydrogen due to a simple vertical source in an enclosure. Many numerical and experimental studies have already been conducted on this problem showing the formation of a stably stratified distribution of concentration. Most of them consider the cases of accidental situation in which the flow rate is relatively important (of the order of 10Nl/min to 100Nl/min). We present a set of experiments conducted on a full scale facility of the size of a typical private garage with helium as a model gas for hydrogen. In this study we focus on the low flow rates that can be characteristic of chronic leaks that may not be detected by security devices of the system (of the order of 0.1Nl/min to 10Nl/min). The facility allows changing natural ventilation conditions and experiments have been conducted from the tightest which is less than 0.01ACH to that typical of a real garage say of the order of 0.1ACH.
Numerical Modelling of Hydrogen Deflagration Dynamics in Enclosed Space
Sep 2009
Publication
A three-dimensional mathematical model of gaseous hydrogen deflagration in the enclosed space is developed. The process is described by the system of gas dynamics differential equations. Thermodynamic parameters of the mixture and its components are defined as functions of the local temperature and mixture composition. The concentration changes of the fuel and combustion products are determined using conservation laws taking into account rates of component disappearance and formation and turbulent diffusion. It is assumed that the chemical reaction takes place only in the volume where the fuel concentration is within the limits of inflammability. The mathematical model is validated during an intercomparison test to predict deflagration of a large-scale hydrogen-air mixture in open atmosphere. An algorithm of numerical solution based on the Godunov method is developed. A computer system of engineering analysis of gas-dynamic processes of hydrogen-air mixture formation and combustion in enclosed space with natural ventilation is created. It allows predicting the history of the changes of overpressure temperature concentrations of hydrogen and combustion products and other thermogasdynamic parameters of the mixture in space. This prognosis can be used to estimate dangerous zones of destruction and recommend some safety measures.
Determination of Distribution Function Used in Monte Carlo Simulation on Safety Analysis of Hydrogen Vessels
Sep 2019
Publication
The test data of static burst strength and load cycle strength of composite pressure vessels are often described by GAUSSian normal or WEIBULL distribution function to perform safety analyses. The goodness of assumed distribution function plays a significant role in the inferential statistics to predict the population properties by using limited test data. Often GAUSSian and WEIBULL probability nets are empirical methods used to validate the distribution function; Anderson-Darling and Kolmogorov-Smirnov tests are the mostly favorable approaches for Goodness of Fit. However the different approaches used to determine the parameters of distribution function lead mostly to different conclusions for safety assessments.<br/>In this study six different methods are investigated to show the variations on the rates for accepting the composite pressure vessels according to GTR No. 13 life test procedure. The six methods are: a) Norm- Log based method b) Least squares regression c) Weighted least squares regression d) A linear approach based on good linear unbiased estimators e) Maximum likelihood estimation and f) The method of moments estimation. In addition various approaches of ranking function are considered. In the study Monte Carlo simulations are conducted to generate basic populations based on the distribution functions which are determined using different methods. Then the samples are extracted randomly from a population and evaluated to obtain acceptance rate. Here the “populations” and “samples” are corresponding to the burst strength or load cycle strength of the pressure vessels made from composite material and a plastic liner (type 4) for the storage of hydrogen. To the end the results are discussed and the best reliable methods are proposed.
Mesh-Independent Large-Eddy Simulation with Anisotropic Adaptive Mesh Refinement for Hydrogen Deflagration Prediction in Closed Vessels
Sep 2019
Publication
The use of high-fidelity simulation methods based on large-eddy simulation (LES) are proving useful for understanding and mitigating the safety hazards associated with hydrogen releases from nuclear power plants. However accurate modelling of turbulent premixed hydrogen flames via LES can require very high resolution to capture both the large-scale turbulence and its interaction with the flame fronts. Standard meshing strategies can result in impractically high computational costs especially for the thin fronts of hydrogen flames. For these reasons the use of a recently formulated integral length scale approximation (ILSA) subfilter-scale model in combination with an efficient anisotropic block-based adaptive mesh refinement (AMR) technique is proposed and examined herein for performing LES of turbulent premixed hydrogen flames. The anisotropic AMR method allows dynamic and solution-dependent resolution of flame fronts and the grid-independent properties of the ILSA model ensure that numerical errors associated with implicitly-filtered LES techniques in regions with varying resolution are avoided. The combined approach has the potential to allow formally converged LES solutions (direct numerical simulation results are typically reached in the limit of very fine meshes with standard subgrid models). The proposed LES methodology is applied to combustion simulations of lean premixed hydrogen-air mixtures within closed vessels: a problem relevant to hydrogen safety applications in nuclear facilities. A progress variable-based method with a multi-phenomena burning velocity model is used as the combustion model. The present simulation results are compared to the available experiment data for several previously studied THAI vessel cases and the capabilities of the proposed LES approach are assessed.
Hytunnel Project to Investigate the Use of Hydrogen Vehicles in Road Tunnels
Sep 2009
Publication
Hydrogen vehicles may emerge as a leading contender to replace today’s internal combustion engine powered vehicles. A Phenomena Identification and Ranking Table exercise conducted as part of the European Network of Excellence on Hydrogen Safety (HySafe) identified the use of hydrogen vehicles in road tunnels as a topic of important concern. An internal project called HyTunnel was duly established within HySafe to review identify and analyse the issues involved and to contribute to the wider activity to establish the true nature of the hazards posed by hydrogen vehicles in the confined space of a tunnel and their relative severity compared to those posed by vehicles powered by conventional fuels including compressed natural gas (CNG). In addition to reviewing current hydrogen vehicle designs tunnel design practice and previous research a programme of experiments and CFD modelling activities was performed for selected scenarios to examine the dispersion and explosion hazards potentially posed by hydrogen vehicles. Releases from compressed gaseous hydrogen (CGH2) and liquid hydrogen (LH2) powered vehicles have been studied under various tunnel geometries and ventilation regimes. The findings drawn from the limited work done so far indicate that under normal circumstances hydrogen powered vehicles do not pose a significantly higher risk than those powered by petrol diesel or CNG but this needs to be confirmed by further research. In particular obstructions at tunnel ceiling level have been identified as a potential hazard in respect to fast deflagration or even detonation in some circumstances which warrants further investigation. The shape of the tunnel tunnel ventilation and vehicle pressure relief device (PRD) operation are potentially important parameters in determining explosion risks and the appropriate mitigation measures.
Experimental Investigation of Nonideality and Nonadiabatic Effects Under High Pressure Releases
Sep 2013
Publication
Due to the nonideality of a high pressure hydrogen release the possibility of a two-phase flow and its effect on the dynamics of the discharge process was experimentally investigated. A small-scale facility was designed and constructed to simulate the transient blow-down of a cryogenic fluid through a small break. Gaseous and liquid nitrogen were planned to were used as a surrogate for GH2 and LH2. The results will complement the quasi-stationary safety regulation tests and will provide time-dependent data for verification of the theoretical models. Different orifice sizes (0.5 1 2 4 mm) and initial N2 pressures (30 – 200 bar) were used in the tests. The measured time-dependent data for vessel discharge pressure thrust discharge mass flow rate and gas temperatures were compared against a theoretical model for high pressure nitrogen release. This verification for nitrogen also assures the equation of state for hydrogen which is based on the same methodology.
A Turbulent Combustion Model for Ignition of Rapidly Expanding Hydrogen Jets
Mar 2013
Publication
A turbulent combustion model based on the Linear Eddy Model for Large Eddy Simulation (LEM- LES) is currently proposed to study self-ignition events of rapidly expanding hydrogen jets. The model is a one-dimensional treatment of a diffusion-reaction system within each multi-dimensional LES cell. This reduces the expense of solving a complete multi-dimensional problem while preserving micro-scale hotspots and their effects on ignition. The current approach features a Lagrangian description of fluid particles on the sub-grid for increased accuracy. Also Adaptive Mesh Refinement (AMR) is implemented for increased computational efficiency. In this paper the model is validated for various inviscid laminar 1-D mixing and ignition problems shock tube problems flames and detonations.
Accumulation of Hydrogen Released into a Vented Enclosure - Experimental Results
Sep 2013
Publication
This paper reports experimental results from a series of experiments in which gaseous hydrogen was released into a 31 m3 enclosure and the hydrogen concentrations at a number of points within the enclosure were monitored to assess whether hydrogen accumulation occurred and whether a homogeneous or stratified mixture was formed. The enclosure was located in the open air and therefore subject to realistic and therefore variable wind conditions. The hydrogen release rate and the passive vent arrangements were varied. The experiments were carried out as part of the EU Hyindoor Project.
Numerical Investigation of Vented Hydrogen-air Deflagration in a Chamber
Oct 2015
Publication
This paper shows numerical investigation related to hydrogen-air deflagration venting. The aim of this study is to clarify the influence of concentration gradient on the pressure histories and peak pressures in a chamber. The numerical analysis target is a 27 m3 cubic chamber which has 2.6 m2 vent area on the sidewall. The vent opening pressure is set to be gauge 10 kPa. Two different conditions of the hydrogen concentration are assumed which are uniform and gradient. In the uniform case 15 20 25 30 and 35 vol.% concentrations are assumed. In the gradient case the concentration linearly increases from 0 vol.% (at the ground) to 30 40 50 60 70 vol.% (at the ceiling). The initial total mass of hydrogen inside the chamber is the same as the uniform case. Moreover three different ignition points are assumed: on the rear center and the front of the chamber relative to the vent. The deflagrations are initiated by a single ignition source. In most gradient cases the highest peak is lower than in the uniform case though the initial total mass of hydrogen inside the chamber is the same as in the uniform case. This is because the generated burned gas per time is smaller in the gradient case than in the uniform case. In 15 vol.% gradient case however the peak pressure gets higher than in the uniform case. This is because in 15 vol.% gradient case the burning velocity around the ignition point gets faster and the flame surface gets larger which induces larger amount of burned gas per time.
Experimental Investigation of Nozzle Aspect Ratio Effects on Under Expanded Hydrogen Jet Release Characteristics
Sep 2013
Publication
Most experimental investigations of underexpanded hydrogen jets have been limited to circular nozzles in an attempt to better understand the fundamental jet-exit flow physics and model this behaviour with pseudo source models. However realistic compressed storage leak exit geometries are not always expected to be circular. In the present study jet dispersion characteristics from rectangular slot nozzles with aspect ratios from 2 to 8 were investigated and compared with an equivalent circular nozzle. Schlieren imaging was used to observe the jet-exit shock structure while quantitative Planar Laser Rayleigh Scattering was used to measure downstream dispersion characteristics. These results provide physical insight and much needed model validation data for model development.
An Assessment on the Quantification of Hydrogen Releases Through Oxygen Displacement Using Oxygen
Sep 2013
Publication
Contrary to several reports in the recent literature the use of oxygen sensors for indirectly monitoring ambient hydrogen concentration has serious drawbacks. This method is based on the assumption that a hydrogen release will displace oxygen which is quantified using oxygen sensors. Despite its shortcomings the draft Hydrogen Vehicle Global Technical Regulation lists this method as a means to monitor hydrogen leaks to verify vehicle fuel system integrity. Experimental evaluations that were designed to impartially compare the ability of commercial oxygen and hydrogen sensors to reliably measure and report hydrogen concentration changes are presented. Numerous drawbacks are identified and discussed.
IPHE Regulations Codes and Standards Working Group-type IV COPV Round Robin Testing
Oct 2015
Publication
This manuscript presents the results of a multi-lateral international activity intended to understand how to execute a cycle stress test as specified in a chosen standard (GTR SAE ISO EIHP …). The purpose of this work was to establish a harmonized test method protocol to ensure that the same results would be achieved regardless of the testing facility. It was found that accurate temperature measurement of the working fluid is necessary to ensure the test conditions remain within the tolerances specified. Continuous operation is possible with adequate cooling of the working fluid but this becomes more demanding if the cycle frequency increases. Recommendations for future test system design and operation are presented.
Numerical Investigation of Hydrogen Leakage from a High Pressure Tank and its Explosion
Oct 2015
Publication
We numerically investigated the initial behaviour of leakage and diffusion from high-pressure hydrogen storage tank assumed in hydrogen station. First calculations are carried out to validate the present numerical approach and compare with the theoretical distribution of hydrogen mass fraction to the direction which is vertical to the jet direction in the case of hydrogen leaking out from the circular injection port whose diameter is 0.25 mm. Then performing calculations about hydrogen leakage and diffusion behaviour on different tank pressures the effects are examined to reduce damage by gas explosion assumed in the hydrogen station. There is no significant difference in the diffusion distance to the jet direction from a start to 0.2 ms. After 0.2 ms it is seen the difference in the diffusion distance to the jet direction in different pressure. As tank pressures become large the hydrogen diffusion not only to the jet direction but also to the direction which is vertical to the jet direction is remarkably seen. Then according to histories of the percentage of the flammable mass to total one in the space it drastically increases up to 30%2between 0 and 0.05 ms. After 0.05 ms it uniformly increases so it is shown that the explosion risk becomes high over time. The place where mass within flammability range distributes at a certain time is shown. Hydrogen widely diffuses to jet direction and distributes in each case and time. Therefore it is found that when it is assumed that ignition occurs by some sources in place where high-pressure hydrogen is leaked and diffused the magnitude of the explosion damage can be predicted when and where ignition occurs.
Time Response of Hydrogen Sensors
Sep 2013
Publication
The efficiency of gas sensor application for facilitating the safe use of hydrogen depends to a considerable extent on the response time of the sensor to change in hydrogen concentration. The response and recovery times have been measured for five different hydrogen sensors three commercially available and two promising prototypes which operate at room temperature. Experiments according to ISO 26142 show that most of the sensors surpass much for a concentration change from clean to hydrogen containing air the demands of the standard for the response times t(90) and values of 2 to 16 s were estimated. For an opposite shift to clean air the recovery times t(10) are from 7 to 70 s. Results of transient behaviour can be fitted with an exponential approach. It can be demonstrated that results on transient behaviour depend not only from investigation method and the experimental conditions like gas changing rate and concentration jump as well as from operating parameters of sensors. In comparison to commercial MOS and MIS-FET hydrogen sensors new sensor prototypes operating at room temperature possesses in particular longer recovery times.
No more items...