Safety
Compliance Measurements of Fuel Cell Electric Vehicle Exhaust
Sep 2019
Publication
The NREL Sensor Laboratory has been developing an analyzer that can verify compliance to the international United Nations Global Technical Regulation number 13 (GTR 13--Global Technical Regulation on Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Vehicles) prescriptive requirements pertaining to allowable hydrogen levels in the exhaust of fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEV) [1]. GTR 13 prescribes that the FCEV exhaust shall remain below 4 vol% H2 over a 3-second moving average and shall not at any time exceed 8 vol% H2 as verified with an analyzer with a response time (t90) of 300 ms or faster. GTR 13 has been implemented and is to serve as the basis for national regulations pertaining to hydrogen powered vehicle safety in the United States Canada Japan and the European Union. In the U.S. vehicle safety is overseen by the Department of Transportation (DOT) through the Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards (FMVSS) and in Canada by Transport Canada through the Canadian Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (CMVSS). The NREL FCEV exhaust analyzer is based upon a low-cost commercial hydrogen sensor with a response time (t90) of less than 250 ms. A prototype analyzer and gas probe assembly have been constructed and tested that can interface to the gas sampling system used by Environment and Climate Change Canada’s (ECCC) Emission Research and Measurement Section (ERMS) for the exhaust gas analysis. Through a partnership with Transport Canada ECCC will analyze the hydrogen level in the exhaust of a commercial FCEV. ECCC will use the NREL FCEV Exhaust Gas analyzer to perform these measurements. The analyzer was demonstrated on a FCEV operating under simulated road conditions using a chassis dynamometer at a private facility.
Effect of the Time Dependent Loading of Type IV Cylinders Using a Multi-scalemodel
Sep 2019
Publication
The current requirements for composite cylinders are still based on an arbitrary approach derived from the behaviour of metal structures that the designed burst pressure should be at least 2.5 times the maximum in-service pressure. This could lead to an over-designed composite cylinder for which the weight saving would be less than optimum. Moreover predicting the lifetime of composite cylinders is a challenging task due to their anisotropic characteristics. A federal research institute in Germany (BAM) has proposed a minimum load-cycle requirement that mitigates this issue by using a MonteCarlo analysis of the burst test results. To enrich this study more experiments are required however they are normally limited by the necessity of long duration testing times (loading rate and number of cylinders) and the design (stacking sequence of the composite layer). A multi-scale model incorporating the micromechanical behaviour of composite structures has been developed at Mines ParisTech. The model has shown similar behaviour to that of composite cylinders under different loading rates. This indicates that the model could assist the Monte-Carlo analysis study. An evaluation of the multi-scale model therefore has been carried out to determine its limitations in predicting lifetimes of composite cylinders. The evaluation starts with the comparison of burst pressures with type IV composite cylinders under different loading rates. A μCT-Scan of a type IV cylinder has been carried out at the University of Southampton. The produced images were analysed using the Fast-Fourier Transform (FFT) technique to determine the configuration of the composite layers which is required by the model. Finally the time dependent effect studied by using the multi scale model has been described. In the long-term this study can be used to conduct a parametric study for creating more efficient design of type IV cylinders.
Numerical Analysis for Hydrogen Flame Acceleration during a Severe Accident in the APR1400 Containment Using a Multi-Dimensional Hydrogen Analysis System
Nov 2020
Publication
Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute (KAERI) established a multi-dimensional hydrogen analysis system to evaluate hydrogen release distribution and combustion in the containment of a Nuclear Power Plant (NPP) using MAAP GASFLOW and COM3D. In particular KAERI developed an analysis methodology for a hydrogen flame acceleration on the basis of the COM3D validation results against measured data of the hydrogen combustion tests in the ENACCEF and THAI facilities. The proposed analysis methodology accurately predicted the peak overpressure with an error range of approximately ±10% using the Kawanabe model used for a turbulent flame speed in the COM3D. KAERI performed a hydrogen flame acceleration analysis using the multi-dimensional hydrogen analysis system for a severe accident initiated by a station blackout (SBO) under the assumption of 100% metal–water reaction in the Reactor Pressure Vessel (RPV) to evaluate an overpressure buildup in the containment of the Advanced Power Reactor 1400 MWe (APR1400). The magnitude of the overpressure buildup in the APR1400 containment might be used as a criterion to judge whether the containment integrity is maintained or not when the hydrogen combustion occurs during a severe accident. The COM3D calculation results using the established analysis methodology showed that the calculated peak pressure in the containment was lower than the fracture pressure of the APR1400 containment. This calculation result might have resulted from a large air volume of the containment a reduced hydrogen concentration owing to passive auto-catalytic recombiners installed in the containment during the hydrogen release from the RPV and a lot of stem presence during the hydrogen combustion period in the containment. Therefore we found that the current design of the APR1400 containment maintained its integrity when the flame acceleration occurred during the severe accident initiated by the SBO accident.
Vented Hydrogen-air Deflagrations in Low Strength Equipment and Buildings
Sep 2013
Publication
This paper aims to improve prediction capability of the vent sizing correlation presented in the form of functional dependence of the dimensionless deflagration overpressure on the turbulent Bradley number similar to our previous studies. The correlation is essentially upgraded based on recent advancements in understanding and modelling of combustion phenomena relevant to hydrogen-air vented deflagrations and unique large-scale tests carried out by different research groups. The focus is on hydrogen-air deflagrations in low-strength equipment and buildings when the reduced pressure is accepted to be below 0.1 MPa. The combustion phenomena accounted for by the correlation include: turbulence generated by the flame front itself; leading point mechanism stemming from the preferential diffusion of hydrogen in air in stretched flames; growth of the fractal area of the turbulent flame surface; initial turbulence in the flammable mixture; as well as effects of enclosure aspect ratio and presence of obstacles. The correlation is validated against the widest range of experimental conditions available to date (76 experimental points). The validation covers a wide range of test conditions: different shape enclosures of volume up to 120 m3; initially quiescent and turbulent hydrogen-air mixtures; hydrogen concentration in air from 6% to 30% by volume; ignition source location at enclosure centre near and far from a vent; empty enclosures and enclosures with obstacles.
Highly Resolve Large Eddy Simulations of a Transitional Air-helium Buoyant Jet in a Two Vented Enclosure: Validation Against Particle Image Velocimetry Experiments
Sep 2017
Publication
The article deals with LES simulations of an air-helium buoyant jet in a two vented enclosure and their validation against particle image velocimetry experiments. The main objective is to test the ability of LES models to simulate such scenarios. These types of scenarios are of first interest considering safety studies for new hydrogen systems. Three main challenges are identified. The two first are the ability of the LES model to account for a rapid laminar-to-turbulence transition mainly due to the buoyancy accelerations and the Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities that can develop due to sharp density gradients. The third one is the outlet boundary conditions to be imposed on the vent surfaces. The influence of the classical pressure boundary condition is studied by comparing the simulations results when an exterior region is added in the simulations. The comparisons against particle image velocimetry experiments show that the use of an exterior domain gives more accurate results than the classical pressure boundary condition. This result and the description of the phenomena involved are the main outlets of the article.
Hydrogen Venting Under Variable Flow Conditions
Sep 2011
Publication
Safety distances for hydrogen plumes are currently derived using models developed for hydrocarbon releases. It is well known that hydrogen behaves in a significantly different manner to that of hydrocarbons when released to atmosphere. There are two main aspects involved with the development of safety distances for credible hydrogen releases; the intensity of the thermal radiation from such a plume should it be ignited and the distance downwind from the release point to the point where a flammable mixture with air no longer exists. A number of distinct areas of venting behaviour were investigated; Thermal radiation from ignited plumes from vertical open ended vent pipes Far field radiation measurements for direct comparison with models Thermal radiation from ignited plumes from vertical vent pipes terminating in a T-piece Thermal radiation measurements from ignited hydrogen with a 45 vent termination Hydrogen concentration measurements with a T-piece.
High-Order Perturbation Solutions to a Lh2 Spreading Model With Continuous Spill
Sep 2011
Publication
High-order perturbation solutions have been obtained for the simple physical model describing the LH2 spreading with a continuous spill and are shown to improve over the first-order perturbation solutions. The non-dimensional governing equations for the model are derived to obtain more general solutions. Non-dimensional parameters are sought as the governing parameters for the non-dimensional equations and the non-dimensional evaporation rate is used as the perturbation parameter. The results show that the second-order solutions exhibit an improvement over the first-order solutions with respect to the pool volume; however there is still a difference between numerical solutions and second-order solutions in the late stage of spread. Finally it is revealed that the third-order solutions almost agree with numerical solutions.
Hydrogen Risk Assessment in Sao Paulo State, Brazil
Sep 2011
Publication
Sao Paulo State Environmental Protection Agency CETESB Brazil adopts a so called Reference Distance (RD) from hazardous substances storage facilities to populated places as a decision making tool for the application of a simplified or a full Risk Analysis (RA). As for hydrogen RD was set up based on instantaneous release scenarios where consequences reaching off-site population were estimated for delayed ignition ending up in vapor cloud explosion (VCE) with a 0.1 bar blast wave overpressure as a chosen endpoint corresponding to a 1%2of death probability range. Procedures for RD evaluation and further adoption by CETESB are presented in this paper.
Analysis of Acoustic Pressure Oscillation During Vented Deflagration
Oct 2015
Publication
In industrial buildings explosion relief panels or doors are often used to reduce damages caused by gas explosion. Decades of research produced a significant contribution to the understanding of the phenomena involved nevertheless among the aspects that need further research interaction between acoustic oscillation and the flame front is one of the more important. Interaction between the flame front and acoustic oscillation has raised technical problem in lots of combustion applications as well and had been studied theoretically and experimentally in such cases. Pressure oscillation had been observed in vented deflagration and in certain cases they are responsible for the highest pressure peak generated during the event. At Scalbatraio laboratory of Pisa University CVE test facility was built in order to investigate vented hydrogen deflagration. This paper is aimed to present an overview of the results obtained during several experimental campaigns which tests are analysed with the focus on the investigation of flame acoustic interaction phenomenon. Qualitative and quantitative analysis is presented and the possible physic generating the phenomenon investigated.
Risk Informed Separation Distances For Hydrogen Refuelling Stations
Sep 2011
Publication
The lay-out requirements developed for hydrogen systems operated in industrial environment are not suitable for the operating conditions specific to hydrogen refuelling stations (service pressure of up to 95 MPa facility for public use). A risk informed rationale has been developed to define and substantiate separation distance requirements in ISO 20100 Gaseous hydrogen – refuelling stations [1]. In this approach priority is given to preventing escalation of small incidents into majors ones with a focus on critical exposures such as places of occupancy (fuelling station retail shop) while optimizing use of the available space from a risk perspective a key objective for being able to retrofit hydrogen refuelling in existing stations.
A Study of Hydrogen Flame Length with Complex Nozzle Geometry
Sep 2017
Publication
The growing number of hydrogen fillings stations and cars increases the need for accurate models to determine risk. The effect on hydrogen flame length was measured by varying the diameter of the spouting nozzle downstream from the chocked nozzle upstream. The results was compared with an existing model for flame length estimations. The experimental rig was setup with sensors that measured accurately temperature mass flow heat radiation and the pressure range from 0.1 to 11 MPa. The flame length was determined with an in-house developed image-processing tool which analyzed a high-speed film of the each experiment. Results show that the nozzle geometry can cause a deviation as high as 50% compared to estimated flame lengths by the model if wrong assumptions are made. Discharge coefficients for different nozzles has been calculated and presented.
Numerical and Experimental Investigation of H2-air and H2-O2 Detonation Parameters in a 9 m Long Tube, Introduction of a New Detonation Model
Sep 2017
Publication
Experimental and numerical investigation of hydrogen-air and hydrogen-oxygen detonation parameters was performed. A new detonation model was introduced and validated against the experimental data. Experimental set-up consisted of 9 m long tube with 0.17 m in diameter where pressure was measured with piezoelectric transducers located along the channel. Numerical simulations were performed within OpenFoam code based on progress variable equation where the detonative source term accounts for autoignition effects. Autoignition delay times were computed at a simulation run-time with the use of a multivariate regression model where independent variables were: pressure temperature and fuel concentration. The dependent variable was the autoignition delay time. Range of the analyzed gaseous mixture composition varied between 20% and 50% of hydrogen-air and 50%–66% of hydrogen in oxygen. Simulations were performed using LES one-equation eddy viscosity turbulence model in 2D and 3D. Calculations were validated against experimental data.
Safety Concept of Nuclear Cogeneration of Hydrogen and Electricity
Oct 2015
Publication
There is a significant potential for nuclear combined heat and power (CHP) in quite a number of industries. The reactor concepts of the next generation would be capable to open up in particular the high temperature heat market where nuclear energy is applicable to the production processes of hydrogen (or liquid fuels) by steam reforming or water splitting. Due to the need to locate a nuclear facility near the hydrogen plant an overall safety concept has to deal with the question of safety of the combined nuclear/industrial system by taking into account a qualitatively new class of events characterized by interacting influences. Specific requirements will be determined by such factors as the reactor type the nature of the industrial process the separation distances of the industrial facility and population centers from the nuclear plant and prevailing public attitudes. Based on the Japanese concept of the GTHTR300C nuclear reactor for electricity and hydrogen cogeneration theoretical studies were conducted on the release dispersive transport and explosion of a hydrogen cloud in the atmosphere for the sake of assessing the required minimum separation distance to avoid any risk to the nuclear plant's safety systems. In the case of sulfur-iodine water splitting the accidental release of process intermediates including large amounts of sulfur dioxide sulfur trioxide and sulfuric acid need to be investigated as well to estimate the potential risk to nuclear installations like the operators' room and estimate appropriate separation distances against toxic gas propagation. Results of respective simulation studies will be presented.
Effect of Initial Turbulence on Vented Explosion Over Pressures from Lean Hydrogen-air Deflagrations
Sep 2013
Publication
To examine the effect of initial turbulence on vented explosions experiments were performed for lean hydrogen–air mixtures with hydrogen concentrations ranging from 12 to 15% vol. at elevated initial turbulence. As expected it was found that an increase in initial turbulence increased the overall flame propagation speed and this increased flame propagation speed translated into higher peak overpressures during the external explosion. The peak pressures generated by flame–acoustic interactions however did not vary significantly with initial turbulence. When flame speeds measurements were examined it was found that the burning velocity increased with flame radius as a power function of radius with a relatively constant exponent over the range of weak initial turbulence studied and did not vary systematically with initial turbulence. Instead the elevated initial turbulence increased the initial flame propagation velocities of the various mixtures. The initial turbulence thus appears to act primarily by generating higher initial flame wrinkling while having a minimal effect on the growth rate of the wrinkles. For practical purposes of modelling flame propagation and pressure generation in vented explosions the increase in burning velocity due to turbulence is suggested to be approximated by a single constant factor that increases the effective burning velocity of the mixture. When this approach is applied to a previously developed vent sizing correlation the correlation performs well for almost all of the peaks. It was found however that in certain situations this approach significantly under predicts the flame–acoustic peak. This suggests that further research may be necessary to better understand the influence of initial turbulence on the development of flame–acoustic peaks in vented explosions.
Leakage-type-based Analysis of Accidents Involving Hydrogen Fueling Stations in Japan and USA
Aug 2016
Publication
To identify the safety issues associated with hydrogen fuelling stations incidents at such stations in Japan and the USA were analyzed considering the regulations in these countries. Leakage due to the damage and fracture of main bodies of apparatuses and pipes in Japan and the USA is mainly caused by design error that is poorly planned fatigue. Considering the present incidents in these countries adequate consideration of the usage environment in the design is very important. Leakage from flanges valves and seals in Japan is mainly caused by screw joints. If welded joints are to be used in hydrogen fuelling stations in Japan strength data for welded parts should be obtained and pipe thicknesses should be reduced. Leakage due to other factors e.g. external impact in Japan and the USA is mainly caused by human error. To realize self-serviced hydrogen fuelling stations safety measures should be developed to prevent human error by fuel cell vehicle users.
Measurements of Effective Diffusion Coefficient of Helium and Hydrogen Through Gypsum
Sep 2011
Publication
An experimental apparatus which was based on the ¼-scale garage previously used for studying helium release and dispersion in our laboratory was used to obtain effective diffusion coefficients of helium and hydrogen (released as forming gas for safety reasons) through gypsum panel. Two types of gypsum panel were used in the experiments. Helium or forming gas was released into the enclosure from a Fischer burner1 located near the enclosure floor for a fixed duration and then terminated. Eight thermal-conductivity sensors mounted at different vertical locations above the enclosure floor were used to monitor the temporal and spatial gas concentrations. An electric fan was used inside the enclosure to mix the released gas to ensure a spatially uniform gas concentration to minimize stratification. The temporal variations of the pressure difference between the enclosure interior and the ambience were also measured. An analytical model was developed to extract the effective diffusion coefficients from the experimental data.
Non-steady Characteristics of Dispersion and Ignitability for High-pressurized Hydrogen Jet Discharged From a Pinhole
Sep 2017
Publication
Hydrogen gas concentrations and jet velocities were measured downstream by a high response speed flame ionization detector and PIV (Particle Image Velocimetry) in order to investigate the characteristics of dispersion and ignitability for 40–82 MPa high-pressurized hydrogen jet discharged from a nozzle with 0.2 mm diameter. The light emitted from both OH radical and water vapor species yielded from hydrogen combustion ignited by an electric spark were recorded by two high speed cameras. From the results the empirical formula concerning the relationships for time-averaged concentrations concentration fluctuations and ignition probability were obtained to suggest that they would be independent of hydrogen discharge pressure.
Closing the Regulatory Gaps and Advancing Hydrogen Infrastructure Deployment in Australia
Sep 2019
Publication
With downward trends in Australian equipment manufacturing there are increased numbers of overseas designed manufactured and certified hydrogen systems being introduced into Australia. In parallel there are also opportunities for hydrogen and its carriers to be exported to overseas. Certainty of reputable codes and standards is important to meet regulatory requirements and community safety expectations locally and overseas.
This paper is a progress report of Hydrogen Mobility Australia’s (HMA) Technical Committee on mapping the regulatory codes and standards (RCS) gaps in Australia and establishing a pathway together with Standards Australia and Commonwealth and State Governments. This paper will discuss the benefits of the pathway covering the areas of:
This paper is a progress report of Hydrogen Mobility Australia’s (HMA) Technical Committee on mapping the regulatory codes and standards (RCS) gaps in Australia and establishing a pathway together with Standards Australia and Commonwealth and State Governments. This paper will discuss the benefits of the pathway covering the areas of:
- Safety – Enable Australia to implement consensual rules to minimise avoidable risks to persons and goods to an acceptable level
- Environment – Ensure protection of the environment from unacceptable damage due to the operation and effects of products processes and services linked to hydrogen
- Elimination of barriers to trade – Provide consistency between international jurisdictions enabling streamlined entry of hydrogen related equipment from overseas
- Upskilling of Australian industry participants – Gain useful learnings from countries more advanced in their progress in implementing ISO standards and hydrogen sector development
Helios- A New Method for Hydrogen Permeation Test
Sep 2013
Publication
Hydrogen induced cracking is still a severe and current threat for several industrial applications. With the aim of providing a simple and versatile device for hydrogen detection a new instrument was designed based on solid state sensor technology. New detection technique allows to execute hydrogen permeation measurement in short time and without material surface preparation. Thanks to this innovation HELIOS offers a concrete alternative to traditional experimental methods for laboratory permeability tests. In addition it is proposed as a new system for Non Destructive Testing of components in service in hydrogenating environment. Hydrogen flux monitoring is particularly relevant for risk mitigation of elements involved in hydrogen storage and transportation. Hydrogen permeation tests were performed by means of HELIOS instruments both on a plane membrane and on the wall of a gas cylinder. Results confirmed the extreme sensitivity of the detection system and its suitability to perform measurements even on non metallic materials by means of an easy-to-handle instrument.
A Study on the Continuous Spill with Limited Period of Release
Sep 2013
Publication
In this study the spread of cryogenic liquid due to a limited period of release is investigated for the first time to clarify the unclear conventional concept regarding two release types continuous and instantaneous release. In describing instantaneous release a discharge time has been assumed to be infinitesimally small; however such an assumption is unreal because there exists a finite period of release no matter how rapid it is. If the discharge time is less than the entire time domain the instantaneous release model should be added to the continuous model from the end of the time. This combined release that consists of the initial continuous model and subsequent instantaneous model is more realistic than the instantaneous release. The physical phenomenon is governed by three parameters: the evaporation rate per unit area release time and spill quantity. Third-order perturbation solutions are obtained and compared with a numerical solution to verify the perturbation solution. For the same spill quantity the combined model that consists of continuous and subsequent instantaneous model is necessary for small release times whereas the continuous model is only required for large release times. Additionally the combined release model is necessary for a small spill quantity at a fixed release time. These two release models are clearly distinguished using the perturbation solution.
No more items...