Germany
Analyzing the Future Potential of Defossilizing Industrial Specialty Glass Production with Hydrogen by LCA
Mar 2022
Publication
The glass industry is part of the energy-intensive industry with most of the energy needed to melt the raw materials. To produce glass temperatures between 1000 and 1600 °C are necessary. Presently mostly fossil natural gas is the dominant energy source. As direct electrification is not always possible in this paper a Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) for specialty glass production is conducted where the conventional fossil-based reference process is compared to a hydrogen-fired furnace. This hydrogen can be produced on-site in an water electrolyzer using not only the hydrogen for the combustion but also the produced oxygen. Hydrogen can be produced alternatively off-site in a large scale electrolyzer to facilitate economy of scale. For the transport and distribution of this hydrogen different options are available. A rather new option are liquid organic hydrogen carriers (LOHC) which bind the hydrogen in a chemical substance. However temperatures around 300 °C are necessary to separate the hydrogen from the LOHC after transport. At the glass trough waste heat is available at the required temperature level to facilitate the dehydrogenation. The comparison is completed by the production of off-site hydrogen transported to the glass trough as conventional liquefied hydrogen in cooling tanks by truck or in hydrogen pipelines. In this assessment to power the electrolyzers the national grid mix of Germany is used. A time frame from 2020 till 2050 and its changing energy system towards defossilisation is analyzed. Regarding climate change on-site hydrogen production causes the least impact for specialty glass production in 2050. However negative trade-offs for other environmental impact categories e.g. Metal depletion are recorded.
The Sector Coupling Concept: A Critical Review
Jun 2020
Publication
Pursued climate goals require reduced greenhouse gas emissions by substituting fossil fuels with energy from renewable sources in all energy-consuming processes. On a large-scale this can mainly be achieved through electricity from wind and sun which are subject to intermittency. To efficiently integrate this variable energy a coupling of the power sector to the residential transport industry and commercial/trade sector is often promoted called sector coupling (SC). Nevertheless our literature review indicates that SC is frequently misinterpreted and its scope varies among available research from exclusively considering the use of excess renewable electricity to a rather holistic view of integrated energy systems including excess heat or even biomass sources. The core objective of this article is to provide a thorough understanding of the SC concept through an analysis of its origin and its main purpose as described in the current literature. We provide a structured categorization of SC derived from our findings and critically discuss its remaining challenges as well as its value for renewable energy systems. We find that SC is rooted in the increasing use of variable renewable energy sources and its main assets are the flexibility it provides for renewable energy systems decarbonization potential for fossil-fuel-based end-consumption sectors and consequently reduced dependency on oil and gas extracting countries. However the enabling technologies face great challenges in their economic feasibility because of the uncertain future development of competing solutions.
Efficiency and Optimal Load Capacity of E-Fuel-Based Energy Storage Systems
Apr 2023
Publication
This work evaluates the effectiveness of chemical-based solutions for storing large amounts of renewable electricity. Four “Power-to-X-to-Power” pathways are examined comprising hydrogen methane methanol and ammonia as energy carriers. The pathways are assessed using a model scenario where they are produced with electricity from an onshore wind farm stored in suitable facilities and then reconverted to electricity to meet the energy demand of a chemical site. An energy management and storage capacity estimation tool is used to calculate the annual load coverage resulting from each pathway. All four pathways offer a significant increase in load coverage compared to a scenario without storage solution (56.19%). The hydrogen-based pathway has the highest load coverage (71.88%) and round-trip efficiency (36.93%) followed by the ammonia-based (69.62% 31.37%) methanol-based (67.85% 27.00%) and methane-based (67.64% 26.47% respectively) pathways. The substantially larger storage capacity required for gaseous energy carriers to ensure a steady supply to the consumer could be a decisive factor. The hydrogen pathway requires a storage volume up to 10.93 times larger than ammonia and 16.87 times larger than methanol. Notably ammonia and methanol whose load coverages are only 2.26 and 4.03 percentage points lower than that of hydrogen offer the possibility of implementing site-specific storage solutions avoiding potential bottlenecks due to limited pipeline and cavern capacities.
THyGA - Test Report on Mitigation Solutions for Residential Natural Gas Appliances Not Designed for Hydrogen Admixture
Apr 2023
Publication
This report from the WP5 “Mitigation” provides information and test results regarding perturbations that hydrogen could cause to gas appliances when blended to natural gas especially on anatural draught for exhaust fumes or acidity for the condensates. The important topic of on-site adjustment is also studied with test results on alternative technologies and proposals of mitigation approaches.
The Potential Role of a Hydrogen Network in Europe
Jul 2023
Publication
Europe’s electricity transmission expansion suffers many delays despite its significance for integrating renewable electricity. A hydrogen network reusing the existing gas network could not only help to supply the demand for low-emission fuels but could also balance variations in wind and solar energies across the continent and thus avoid power grid expansion. Our investigation varies the allowed expansion of electricity and hydrogen grids in net-zero CO2 scenarios for a sector-coupled European energy system capturing transmission bottlenecks renewable supply and demand variability and pipeline retrofitting and geological storage potentials. We find that a hydrogen network connecting regions with low-cost and abundant renewable potentials to demand centers electrofuel production and cavern storage sites reduces system costs by up to 26 bnV/a (3.4%). Although expanding both networks together can achieve the largest cost reductions by 9.9% the expansion of neither is essential for a net-zero system as long as higher costs can be accepted and flexibility options allow managing transmission bottlenecks.
Evaluation of Surplus Hydroelectricity Potential in Nepal until 2040 and its Use for Hydrogen Production Via Electrolysis
May 2023
Publication
The abundant hydro resources in Nepal have resulted in the generation of electricity almost exclusively from hydropower plants. Several hydropower plants are also currently under construction. There is no doubt that the surplus electricity will be significantly high in the coming years. Given the previous trend in electricity consumption it will be a challenge to maximize the use of surplus electricity. In this work the potential solutions to maximize the use of this surplus electricity have been analysed. Three approached are proposed: (i) increasing domestic electricity consumption by shifting the other energy use sectors to electricity (ii) cross-border export of electricity and (iii) conversion of electricity to hydrogen via electrolysis. The current state of energy demand and supply patterns in the country are presented. Future monthly demand forecasts and surplus electricity projections have been made. The hydrogen that can be produced with the surplus electricity via electrolysis is determined and an economic assessment is carried out for the produced hydrogen. The analysis of levelized cost of hydrogen (LCOH) under different scenarios resulted values ranging from 3.8 €/kg to 4.5 €/kg.
Energy Management of Hydrogen Hybrid Electric Vehicles—Online-Capable Control
May 2024
Publication
The results shown in this paper extend our research group’s previous work which presents the theoretically achievable hydrogen engine-out NOeo x (H2-NOeo x ) Pareto front of a hydrogen hybrid electric vehicle (H2-HEV). While the Pareto front is calculated offline which requires significant computing power and time this work presents an online-capable algorithm to tackle the energy management of a H2-HEV with explicit consideration of the H2-NOeo x trade-off. Through the inclusion of realistic predictive data on the upcoming driving mission a model predictive control algorithm (MPC) is utilized to effectively tackle the conflicting goal of achieving low hydrogen consumption while simultaneously minimizing NOeo x . In a case study it is shown that MPC is able to satisfy user-defined NOeo x limits over the course of various driving missions. Moreover a comparison with the optimal Pareto front highlights MPC’s ability to achieve close-to-optimal fuel performance for any desired cumulated NOeo x target on four realistic routes for passenger cars.
Techno-Economic Evaluation of Hydrogen-Based Cooking Solutions in Remote African Communities—The Case of Kenya
Apr 2023
Publication
Hydrogen has recently been proposed as a versatile energy carrier to contribute to archiving universal access to clean cooking. In hard-to-reach rural settings decentralized produced hydrogen may be utilized (i) as a clean fuel via direct combustion in pure gaseous form or blended with Liquid Petroleum Gas (LPG) or (ii) via power-to-hydrogen-to-power (P2H2P) to serve electric cooking (e-cooking) appliances. Here we present the first techno-economic evaluation of hydrogen-based cooking solutions. We apply mathematical optimization via energy system modeling to assess the minimal cost configuration of each respective energy system on technical and economic measures under present and future parameters. We further compare the potential costs of cooking for the end user with the costs of cooking with traditional fuels. Today P2H2P-based e-cooking and production of hydrogen for utilization via combustion integrated into the electricity supply system have almost equal energy system costs to simultaneously satisfy the cooking and electricity needs of the isolated rural Kenyan village studied. P2H2P-based e-cooking might become advantageous in the near future when improving the energy efficiency of e-cooking appliances. The economic efficiency of producing hydrogen for utilization by end users via combustion benefits from integrating the water electrolysis into the electricity supply system. More efficient and cheaper hydrogen technologies expected by 2050 may improve the economic performance of integrated hydrogen production and utilization via combustion to be competitive with P2H2P-based e-cooking. The monthly costs of cooking per household may be lower than the traditional use of firewood and charcoal even today when applying the current life-line tariff for the electricity consumed or utilizing hydrogen via combustion. Driven by likely future technological improvements and the expected increase in traditional and fossil fuel prices any hydrogen-based cooking pathway may be cheaper for end users than using charcoal and firewood by 2030 and LPG by 2040. The results suggest that providing clean cooking in rural villages could economically and environmentally benefit from utilizing hydrogen. However facing the complexity of clean cooking projects we emphasize the importance of embedding the results of our techno-economic analysis in holistic energy delivery models. We propose useful starting points for future aspects to be investigated in the discussion section including business and financing models.
Investigation of Different Load Characteristics, Component Dimensioning, and System Scaling for the Optimized Design of a Hybrid Hydrogen-Based PV Energy System
Jul 2023
Publication
The realization of a carbon-neutral civilization which has been set as a goal for the coming decades goes directly hand-in-hand with the need for an energy system based on renewable energies (REs). Due to the strong weather-related daily and seasonal fluctuations in supply of REs suitable energy storage devices must be included for such energy systems. For this purpose an energy system model featuring hybrid energy storage consisting of a hydrogen unit (for long-term storage) and a lithium-ion storage device (for short-term storage) was developed. With a proper design such a system can ensure a year-round energy supply by using electricity generated by photovoltaics (PVs). In the energy system that was investigated hydrogen (H2) was produced by using an electrolyser (ELY) with a PV surplus during the summer months and then stored in an H2 tank. During the winter due to the lack of PV power the H2 is converted back into electricity and heat by a fuel cell (FC). While the components of such a system are expensive a resource- and cost-efficient layout is important. For this purpose a Matlab/Simulink model that enabled an energy balance analysis and a component lifetime forecast was developed. With this model the results of extensive parameter studies allowed an optimized system layout to be created for specific applications. The parameter studies covered different focal points. Several ELY and FC layouts different load characteristics different system scales different weather conditions and different load levels—especially in winter with variations in heating demand—were investigated.
THyGA - Long Term Effect of H2 on Appliances Tested
May 2023
Publication
The goals of the long-term tests were to see the impact of blends of hydrogen and natural gas on the technical condition of the appliances and their performance after several hours of operation. To do so they were run through an accelerated test program amounting to more than 3000 testing hours for the boilers and more than 2500 testing hours for the cookers. The percentage of hydrogen in the test gas was 30% by volume. Three boilers and two cookers were tested by DGC and two boilers by GWI. This report describes the test protocol the results and analysis on the seven appliances tested.
Implications of Hydrogen Import Prices for the German Energy System in a Model-comparison Experiment
Mar 2024
Publication
With its ability to store and transport energy without releasing greenhouse gases hydrogen is considered an important driver for the decarbonisation of energy systems. As future hydrogen import prices from global markets are subject to large uncertainties it is unclear what impact different hydrogen and derivative import prices will have on the future German energy system. To answer that research question this paper explores the impact of three different import price scenarios for hydrogen and its derivatives on the German energy system in a climate-neutral setting for Europe in 2045 using three different energy system models. The analysis shows that the quantities of electricity generated as well as the installed capacities for electricity generation and electrolysis increase as the hydrogen import price rises. However the resulting differences between the import price scenarios vary across the models. The results further indicate that domestic German (and European) hydrogen production is often cost-efficient.
Derivation and Validation of a Reference Data-based Real Gas Model for Hydrogen
Mar 2023
Publication
Hydrogen plays an important role for the decarbonization of the energy sector. In its gaseous form it is stored at pressures of up to 1000 bar at which real gas effects become relevant. To capture these effects in numerical simulations accurate real gas models are required. In this work new correlation equations for relevant hydrogen properties are developed based on the Reference Fluid Thermodynamic and Transport Properties Database (REFPROP). Within the regarded temperature (150e400 K) and pressure (0.1e1000 bar) range this approach yields a substantially improved accuracy compared to other databased correlations. Furthermore the developed equations are validated in a numerical simulation of a critical flow Venturi nozzle. The results are in much better accordance with experimental data compared to a cubic equation of state model. In addition the simulation is even slightly faster.
Highly Efficient Solar Hydrogen Production through the Use of Bifacial Photovoltaics and Membrane Electrolysis
Jul 2020
Publication
T The large-scale implementation of solar hydrogen production requires an optimal combination of photovoltaic systems with suitably-designed electrochemical cells possibly avoiding power electronics for DC-DC conversion to decrease costs. Here a stable solar-driven water splitting system is presented obtained through the direct connection of a state-of-the-art proton exchange membrane (PEM) electrolyzer to a bifacial silicon hetero junction (SHJ) solar module of three cells in series with total area of 730 cm2 . The bifaciality of the solar module has been optimized through modeling in terms of the number of cells module height and inclination. During outdoor operation in the standard monofacial configuration the system is able to produce 3.7 gr of H2 h 1 m 2 with an irradiation of 1000 W m 2 and a solar-to-hydrogen efficiency (STH) of 11.55%. The same system operating in bifacial mode gives rise to a higher H2 flux and STH efficiency reaching values of 4.2 gr of H2 h 1 m 2 and STH of 13.5%. Such a noticeable difference is achieved through the collection of albedo radiation from the ground by the bifacial PV system. The system has been tested outdoors for more than 55 h exhibiting very good endurance with no appreciable change in production and eff
Underground Hydrogen Storage to Balance Seasonal Variations in Energy Demand: Impact of Well Configuration on Storage Performance in Deep Saline Aquifers
Mar 2023
Publication
Grid-scale underground hydrogen storage (UHS) is essential for the decarbonization of energy supply systems on the path towards a zero-emissions future. This study presents the feasibility of UHS in an actual saline aquifer with a typical dome-shaped anticline structure to balance the potential seasonal mismatches between energy supply and demand in the UK domestic heating sector. As a main requirement for UHS in saline aquifers we investigate the role of well configuration design in enhancing storage performance in the selected site via numerical simulation. The results demonstrate that the efficiency of cyclic hydrogen recovery can reach around 70% in the short term without the need for upfront cushion gas injection. Storage capacity and deliverability increase in successive storage cycles for all scenarios with the co-production of water from the aquifer having a minimal impact on the efficiency of hydrogen recovery. Storage capacity and deliverability also increase when additional wells are added to the storage site; however the distance between wells can strongly influence this effect. For optimum well spacing in a multi-well storage scenario within a dome-shaped anticline structure it is essential to attain an efficient balance between well pressure interference effects at short well distances and the gas uprising phenomenon at large distances. Overall the findings obtained and the approach described can provide effective technical guidelines pertaining to the design and optimization of hydrogen storage operations in deep saline aquifers.
Evaluating Partners for Renewable Energy Trading: A Multidimensional Framework and Tool
Apr 2024
Publication
The worsening climate crisis has increased the urgency of transitioning energy systems from fossil fuels to renewable sources. However many industrialized countries are struggling to meet their growing demand for renewable energy (RE) through domestic production alone and therefore seek to import additional RE using carriers such as hydrogen ammonia or metals. The pressing question for RE importers is therefore how to select trading partners i.e. RE exporting countries. Recent research has identified a plethora of different selection criteria reflecting the complexity of energy systems and international cooperation. However there is little guidance on how to reduce this complexity to more manageable levels as well as a lack of tools for effective partner evaluation. This article aims to fill these gaps. It proposes a new multidimensional framework for evaluating and comparing potential RE trading partners based on four dimensions: economy and technology environment and development regulation and governance and innovation and cooperation. Focusing on Germany as an RE importer an exploratory factor analysis is used to identify a consolidated set of composite selection criteria across these dimensions. The results suggest that Germany’s neighboring developed countries and current net energy exporters such as Canada and Australia are among the most attractive RE trading partners for Germany. A dashboard tool has been developed to provide the framework and composite criteria including adjustable weights to reflect the varying preferences of decision-makers and stakeholders. The framework and the dashboard can provide helpful guidance and transparency for partner selection processes facilitating the creation of RE trade networks that are essential for a successful energy transition.
How to Make Climate-neutral Aviation Fly
Jul 2023
Publication
The European aviation sector must substantially reduce climate impacts to reach net-zero goals. This reduction however must not be limited to flight CO2 emissions since such a narrow focus leaves up to 80% of climate impacts unaccounted for. Based on rigorous life-cycle assessment and a time-dependent quantification of non-CO2 climate impacts here we show that from a technological standpoint using electricity-based synthetic jet fuels and compensating climate impacts via direct air carbon capture and storage (DACCS) can enable climate-neutral aviation. However with a continuous increase in air traffic synthetic jet fuel produced with electricity from renewables would exert excessive pressure on economic and natural resources. Alternatively compensating climate impacts of fossil jet fuel via DACCS would require massive CO2 storage volumes and prolong dependence on fossil fuels. Here we demonstrate that a European climate-neutral aviation will fly if air traffic is reduced to limit the scale of the climate impacts to mitigate.
Industrial Decarbonization Pathways: The Example of the German Glass Industry
Nov 2022
Publication
Mitigating anthropogenic climate change and achieving the Paris climate goals is one of the greatest challenges of the twenty-first century. To meet the Paris climate goals sector-specific transformation pathways need to be defined. The different transformation pathways are used to hypothetically quantify whether a defined climate target is achievable or not. For this reason a bottom-up model was developed to assess the extent of selected industrial decarbonization options compared to conventionally used technologies from an emissions perspective. Thereby the bottom-up model is used to analyze the German container and flat glass industries as an example. The results show that no transformation pathway can be compatible with the 1.5 °C based strict carbon dioxide budget target. Even the best case scenario exceeds the 1.5 °C based target by approximately +200%. The 2 °C based loose carbon dioxide budget target is only achievable via fuel switching the complete phase-out from natural gas to renewable energy carriers. Furthermore the results of hydrogen for flat glass production demonstrate that missing investments in renewable energy carriers may lead to the non-compliance with actually achievable 2 °C based carbon dioxide budget targets. In conclusion the phase-out from natural gas to renewable energies should be executed at the end of the life of any existing furnace and process emissions should be avoided in the long term to contribute to 1.5 °C based strict carbon dioxide budget target.
Economic Evaluation of Renewable Hydrogen Integration into Steelworks for the Production of Methanol and Methane
Jun 2022
Publication
This work investigates the cost-efficient integration of renewable hydrogen into steelworks for the production of methane and methanol as an efficient way to decarbonize the steel industry. Three case studies that utilize a mixture of steelworks off-gases (blast furnace gas coke oven gas and basic oxygen furnace gas) which differ on the amount of used off-gases as well as on the end product (methane and/or methanol) are analyzed and evaluated in terms of their economic performance. The most influential cost factors are identified and sensitivity analyses are conducted for different operating and economic parameters. Renewable hydrogen produced by PEM electrolysis is the most expensive component in this scheme and responsible for over 80% of the total costs. Progress in the hydrogen economy (lower electrolyzer capital costs improved electrolyzer efficiency and lower electricity prices) is necessary to establish this technology in the future.
H2-powered Aviation at Airports – Design and Economics of LH2 Refueling Systems
Feb 2022
Publication
In this paper the broader perspective of green hydrogen (H2) supply and refueling systems for aircraft is provided as an enabling technology brick for more climate friendly H2-powered aviation. For this two H2 demand scenarios at exemplary airports are determined for 2050. Then general requirements for liquid hydrogen (LH2) refueling setups in an airport environment are derived and techno-economic models for LH2 storage liquefaction and transportation to the aircraft are designed. Finally a cost tradeoff study is undertaken for the design of the LH2 setup including LH2 refueling trucks and a LH2 pipeline and hydrant system. It is found that for airports with less than 125 ktLH2 annual demand a LH2 refueling truck setup is the more economic choice. At airports with higher annual LH2 demands a LH2 pipeline & hydrant system can lead to slight cost reductions and enable safer and faster refueling. However in all demand scenarios the refueling system costs only mark 3 to 4% of the total supply costs of LH2. The latter are dominated by the costs for green H2 produced offsite followed by the costs for liquefaction of H2 at an airport. While cost reducing scaling effects are likely to be achieved for H2 liquefaction plants other component capacities would already be designed at maximum capacities for medium-sized airports. Furthermore with annual LH2 demands of 100 ktLH2 and more medium and larger airports could take a special H2 hub role by 2050 dominating regional H2 consumption. Finally technology demonstrators are required to reduce uncertainty around major techno-economic parameters such as the investment costs for LH2 pipeline & hydrant systems.
Improving the Efficiency of PEM Electrolyzers through Membrane-Specific Pressure Optimization
Feb 2020
Publication
Hydrogen produced in a polymer electrolyte membrane (PEM) electrolyzer must be stored under high pressure. It is discussed whether the gas should be compressed in subsequent gas compressors or by the electrolyzer. While gas compressor stages can be reduced in the case of electrochemical compression safety problems arise for thin membranes due to the undesired permeation of hydrogen across the membrane to the oxygen side forming an explosive gas. In this study a PEM system is modeled to evaluate the membrane-specific total system efficiency. The optimum efficiency is given depending on the external heat requirement permeation cell pressure current density and membrane thickness. It shows that the heat requirement and hydrogen permeation dominate the maximum efficiency below 1.6 V while above the cell polarization is decisive. In addition a pressure-optimized cell operation is introduced by which the optimum cathode pressure is set as a function of current density and membrane thickness. This approach indicates that thin membranes do not provide increased safety issues compared to thick membranes. However operating an N212-based system instead of an N117-based one can generate twice the amount of hydrogen at the same system efficiency while only one compressor stage must be added.
Hydrogen-Assisted Cracking in GMA Welding of High-Strength Structural Steel—A New Look into This Issue at Narrow Groove
Jun 2021
Publication
Modern arc processes such as the modified spray arc (Mod. SA) have been developed for gas metal arc welding of high-strength structural steels with which even narrow weld seams can be welded. High-strength joints are subjected to increasingly stringent requirements in terms of welding processing and the resulting component performance. In the present work this challenge is to be met by clarifying the influences on hydrogen-assisted cracking (HAC) in a high-strength structural steel S960QL. Adapted samples analogous to the self-restraint TEKKEN test are used and analyzed with respect to crack formation microstructure diffusible hydrogen concentration and residual stresses. The variation of the seam opening angle of the test seams is between 30° and 60°. To prevent HAC the effectiveness of a dehydrogenation heat treatment (DHT) from the welding heat is investigated. As a result the weld metals produced at reduced weld opening angle show slightly higher hydrogen concentrations on average. In addition increased micro- as well as macro-crack formation can be observed on these weld metal samples. On all samples without DHT cracks in the root notch occur due to HAC which can be prevented by DHT immediately after welding.
Hydrogen Technology Towards the Solution of Environment-Friendly New Energy Vehicles
Aug 2021
Publication
The popularity of climate neutral new energy vehicles for reduced emissions and improved air quality has been raising great attention for many years. World-wide a strong commitment continues to drive the demand for zero-emission through alternative energy sources and propulsion systems. Despite the fact that 71.27% of hydrogen is produced from natural gas green hydrogen is a promising clean way to contribute to and maintain a climate neutral ecosystem. Thereby reaching CO2 targets for 2030 and beyond requires cross-sectoral changes. However the strong motivation of governments for climate neutrality is challenging many sectors. One of them is the transport sector as it is challenged to find viable all-in solutions that satisfy social economic and sustainable requirements. Currently the use of new energy vehicles operating on green sustainable hydrogen technologies such as batteries or fuel cells has been the focus for reducing the mobility induced emissions. In Europe 50% of the total emissions result from mobility. The following article reviews the background ongoing challenges and potentials of new energy vehicles towards the development of an environmentally friendly hydrogen economy. A change management process mindset has been adapted to discuss the key scientific and commercial challenges for a successful transition.
Decarbonizing the German Industrial Thermal Energy Use with Solar, Hydrogen, and Other Options - Recommendations for the World
Nov 2022
Publication
This paper is based on a position paper of the German Industry Association Concentrated Solar Power e.V. to the German government and discusses options on how to decarbonize the heat demand of the domestic industry. Among other option concentration solar collectors are a suitable option in Germany which has not been expected by many experts. The paper derives requirements that are needed to ensure a quick and sustainable way to decarbonize industrial heat demand. They are considered to also be relevant for many other countries that follow the same ambition to become climate neutral in the next decades. They major statements are: A mix of different renewable energy technologies in conjunction with efficiency measures is needed to ensure a secure climate-friendly and cost-efficient heat supply for the industry; The different technology options for the provision of heat from renewable sources through electrification and through hydrogen can and must be combined and integrated with each other. In this context concentrating solar thermal represents an important part of the hybrid supply portfolio of a decarbonized industry This requires: The definition of an expansion target for process heat and the flanking measures; Ensuring the equivalence of renewable heat renewable electricity and green hydrogen - also as hybrid solutions; The promotion of concentrating solar thermal reference projects as an impetus for market ramp-up in Germany; The launch of an information campaign for heat consumers and the establishment of a pool of consultants.
Setting Thresholds to Define Indifferences and Preferences in PROMETHEE for Life Cycle Sustainability Assessment of European Hydrogen Production
Jun 2021
Publication
The Life Cycle Sustainability Assessment (LCSA) is a proven method for sustainability assessment. However the interpretation phase of an LCSA is challenging because many different single results are obtained. Additionally performing a Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) is one way—not only for LCSA—to gain clarity about how to interpret the results. One common form of MCDAs are outranking methods. For these type of methods it becomes of utmost importance to clarify when results become preferable. Thus thresholds are commonly used to prevent decisions based on results that are actually indifferent between the analyzed options. In this paper a new approach is presented to identify and quantify such thresholds for Preference Ranking Organization METHod for Enrichment Evaluation (PROMETHEE) based on uncertainty of Life Cycle Impact Assessment (LCIA) methods. Common thresholds and this new approach are discussed using a case study on finding a preferred location for sustainable industrial hydrogen production comparing three locations in European countries. The single LCSA results indicated different preferences for the environmental economic and social assessment. The application of PROMETHEE helped to find a clear solution. The comparison of the newly-specified thresholds based on LCIA uncertainty with default thresholds provided important insights of how to interpret the LCSA results regarding industrial hydrogen production.
Development of a Flashback Correlation for Burner-stabilized Hydrogen-air Premixed Flames
Feb 2022
Publication
With a growing need for replacing fossil fuels with cleaner alternatives hydrogen has emerged as a viable candidate for providing heat and power. However stable and safe combustion of hydrogen is not simple and as such a number of key issues have been identified that need to be understood for a safe design of combustion chambers. One such issue is the higher propensity of hydrogen flames to flashback compared to that for methane flames. The flashback problem is coupled with higher burner temperatures that could cause strong thermal stresses in burners and could hinder their performance. In order to systematically investigate flashback in premixed hydrogen-air flames for finding a global flashback criteria in this study we use numerical simulations as a basic tool to study flashback limits of slit burners. Flashback limits are found for varying geometrical parameters and equivalence ratios and the sensitivity of each parameter on the flashback limit and burner temperatures are identified and analyzed. It is shown that the conventional flashback correlation with critical velocity gradient does not collapse the flashback data as it does not take into account stretch induced preferential diffusion effects. A new Karlovitz number definition is introduced with physical insights that collapses the flashback data at all tested conditions in an excellent manner.
AI Agents Envisioning the Future: Forecast-based Operation of Renewable Energy Storage Systems Using Hydrogen with Deep Reinforcement Learning
Feb 2022
Publication
Hydrogen-based energy storage has the potential to compensate for the volatility of renewable power generation in energy systems with a high renewable penetration. The operation of these storage facilities can be optimized using automated energy management systems. This work presents a Reinforcement Learning-based energy management approach in the context of CO2-neutral hydrogen production and storage for an industrial combined heat and power application. The economic performance of the presented approach is compared to a rule-based energy management strategy as a lower benchmark and a Dynamic Programming-based unit commitment as an upper benchmark. The comparative analysis highlights both the potential benefits and drawbacks of the implemented Reinforcement Learning approach. The simulation results indicate a promising potential of Reinforcement Learning-based algorithms for hydrogen production planning outperforming the lower benchmark. Furthermore a novel approach in the scientific literature demonstrates that including energy and price forecasts in the Reinforcement Learning observation space significantly improves optimization results and allows the algorithm to take variable prices into account. An unresolved challenge however is balancing multiple conflicting objectives in a setting with few degrees of freedom. As a result no parameterization of the reward function could be found that fully satisfied all predefined targets highlighting one of the major challenges for Reinforcement Learning -based energy management algorithms to overcome.
Strategies for the Sampling of Hydrogen at Refuelling Stations for Purity Assessment
Aug 2021
Publication
Hydrogen delivered at hydrogen refuelling station must be compliant with requirements stated in different standards which require specialized sampling device and personnel to operate it. Currently different strategies are implemented in different parts of the world and these strategies have already been used to perform 100s of hydrogen fuel sampling in USA EU and Japan. However these strategies have never been compared on a large systematic study. The purpose of this paper is to describe and compare the different strategies for sampling hydrogen at the nozzle and summarize the key aspects of all the existing hydrogen fuel sampling including discussion on material compatibility with the impurities that must be assessed. This review highlights the fact it is currently difficult to evaluate the impact or the difference these strategies would have on the hydrogen fuel quality assessment. Therefore comparative sampling studies are required to evaluate the equivalence between the different sampling strategies. This is the first step to support the standardization of hydrogen fuel sampling and to identify future research and development area for hydrogen fuel sampling.
Is Iridium Demand a Potential Bottleneck in the Realization of Large-Scale PEM Water Electrolysis?
Jul 2021
Publication
Proton exchange membrane water electrolysis (PEMWE) is a key technology for future sustainable energy systems. Proton exchange membrane (PEM) electrolysis cells use iridium one of the scarcest elements on earth as catalyst for the oxygen evolution reaction. In the present study the expected iridium demand and potential bottlenecks in the realization of PEMWE for hydrogen production in the targeted GW a−1 scale are assessed in a model built on three pillars: (i) an in-depth analysis of iridium reserves and mine production (ii) technical prospects for the optimization of PEM water electrolyzers and (iii) PEMWE installation rates for a market ramp-up and maturation model covering 50 years. As a main result two necessary preconditions have been identified to meet the immense future iridium demand: first the dramatic reduction of iridium catalyst loading in PEM electrolysis cells and second the development of a recycling infrastructure for iridium catalysts with technical end-of-life recycling rates of at least 90%.
Hydrogen Supply Chains for Mobility—Environmental and Economic Assessment
May 2018
Publication
Hydrogen mobility is one option for reducing local emissions avoiding greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and moving away from a mainly oil-based transport system towards a diversification of energy sources. As hydrogen production can be based on a broad variety of technologies already existing or under development a comprehensive assessment of the different supply chains is necessary regarding not only costs but also diverse environmental impacts. Therefore in this paper a broad variety of hydrogen production technologies using different energy sources renewable and fossil are exemplarily assessed with the help of a Life Cycle Assessment and a cost assessment for Germany. As environmental impacts along with the impact category Climate change five more advanced impact categories are assessed. The results show that from an environmental point of view PEM and alkaline electrolysis are characterized by the lowest results in five out of six impact categories. Supply chains using fossil fuels in contrast have the lowest supply costs; this is true e.g. for steam methane reforming. Solar powered hydrogen production shows low impacts during hydrogen production but high impacts for transport and distribution to Germany. There is no single supply chain that is the most promising for every aspect assessed here. Either costs have to be lowered further or supply chains with selected environmental impacts have to be modified.
Nested Decomposition Approach for Dispatch Optimization of Large-Scale, Integrated Electricity, Methane and Hydrogen Infrastructures
Apr 2022
Publication
Energy system integration enables raising operational synergies by coupling the energy infrastructures for electricity methane and hydrogen. However this coupling reinforces the infrastructure interdependencies increasing the need for integrated modeling of these infrastructures. To analyze the cost-efficient sustainable and secure dispatch of applied large-scale energy infrastructures an extensive and non-linear optimization problem needs to be solved. This paper introduces a nested decomposition approach with three stages. The method enables an integrated and full-year consideration of large-scale multi-energy systems in hourly resolution taking into account physical laws of power flows in electricity and gas transmission systems as boundary conditions. For this purpose a zooming technique successively reduces the temporal scope while first increasing the spatial and last the technical resolution. A use case proves the applicability of the presented approach to large-scale energy systems. To this end the model is applied to an integrated European energy system model with a detailed focus on Germany in a challenging transport situation. The use case demonstrates the temporal regional and cross-sectoral interdependencies in the dispatch of integrated energy infrastructures and thus the benefits of the introduced approach.
Sector Coupling and Business Models Towards Sustainability: The Case of the Hydrogen Vehicle Industry
Mar 2022
Publication
The concept of sector coupling has been gaining increased momentum in political discourses during 18 the past few years but it has only recently received the attention of international academics. The 19 private sector is particularly relevant to foster sector coupling through entrepreneurial action – 20 specifically innovative business models for more sustainable technologies are needed to promote a 21 transition towards more sustainability. So far however the literature on business models from a 22 sector coupling perspective is scarce yet strongly emerging. To address the identified research gaps 23 and enhance the current knowledge on the emerging hydrogen vehicle industry and sector coupling 24 this study adopts a qualitative and exploratory research approach and builds on information gained 25 in 103 semi-structured interviews to discuss emerging business models in Germany. In particular 33 26 business cases have been analyzed. Anchoring business model theory to the concept of sector 27 coupling this study identifies 12 business model archetypes in the emerging hydrogen vehicle 28 industry and its value chain. It can be shown that while the market is still emerging and the market 29 players are not defined and are evolving companies are currently engaged in finding their position 30 along the value chain fostering vertical integration and promoting cooperation between the 31 different sectors. While this study is relevant for both the academia and the industry it is particularly 2 32 interesting for policy makers shaping the future of sustainable development specifically considering 33 integrated energy systems.
Cost-effective Technology Choice in a Decarbonized and Diversified Long-haul Truck Transportation Sector: A U.S. Case Study
Dec 2021
Publication
Achieving net-zero emissions by 2050 will require accelerated efforts that include decarbonizing long-haul truck transportation. In this difficult-to-decarbonize low-margin industry economic transparency on technology options is vital for decision makers seeking to eliminate emissions. Battery electric (BET) and hydrogen fuel cell electric trucks (FCET) can represent emission-free alternatives to diesel-powered trucks (DT). Previous studies focus on cost competitiveness in weight-constrained transportation even though logistics research shows that significant shares of transportation are constrained by volume and analyze cost only for selected technologies hence impeding a differentiated market segmentation of future emission-free trucks. In this study the perspective of a rational investor is taken and it is shown that under current conditions in the U.S. BETs outperform FCETs in various long-haul use cases despite charging times and cargo deficits and will further increase their technological competitiveness to DTs. While future energy and fueling prices are decisive for BET competitiveness the analysis reveals that autonomous driving may change the picture in favor of FCETs.
Hydrogen-powered Aviation and its Reliance on Green Hydrogen Infrastructure - Review and Research Gaps
Oct 2021
Publication
Aircraft powered by green hydrogen (H2) are a lever for the aviation sector to reduce the climate impact. Previous research already focused on evaluations of H2 aircraft technology but analyses on infrastructure related cost factors are rarely undertaken. Therefore this paper aims to provide a holistic overview of previous efforts and introduces an approach to assess the importance of a H2 infrastructure for aviation. A short and a medium-range aircraft are modelled and modified for H2 propulsion. Based on these a detailed cost analysis is used to compare both aircraft and infrastructure related direct operating costs (DOC). Overall it is shown that the economy of H2 aviation highly depends on the availability of low-cost green liquid hydrogen (LH2) supply infrastructure. While total DOC might even slightly decrease in a best LH2 cost case total DOC could also increase between 10 and 70% (short-range) and 15e102% (medium-range) due to LH2 costs alone.
An Overview of Promising Alternative Fuels for Road, Rail, Air, and Inland Waterway Transport in Germany
Feb 2022
Publication
To solve the challenge of decarbonizing the transport sector a broad variety of alternative fuels based on different concepts including Power-to-Gas and Power-to-Liquid and propulsion systems have been developed. The current research landscape is investigating either a selection of fuel options or a selection of criteria a comprehensive overview is missing so far. This study aims to close this gap by providing a holistic analysis of existing fuel and drivetrain options spanning production to utilization. For this purpose a case study for Germany is performed considering different vehicle classes in road rail inland waterway and air transport. The evaluated criteria on the production side include technical maturity costs as well as environmental impacts whereas on the utilization side possible blending with existing fossil fuels and the satisfaction of the required mission ranges are evaluated. Overall the fuels and propulsion systems Methanol-to-Gasoline Fischer–Tropsch diesel and kerosene hydrogen battery-electric propulsion HVO DME and natural gas are identified as promising future options. All of these promising fuels could reach near-zero greenhouse gas emissions bounded to some mandatory preconditions. However the current research landscape is characterized by high insecurity with regard to fuel costs depending on the predicted range and length of value chains.
The Evolution and Structure of Ignited High-pressure Cryogenic Hydrogen Jets
Jun 2022
Publication
The anticipated upscaling of hydrogen energy applications will involve the storage and transport of hydrogen at cryogenic conditions. Understanding the potential hazard arising from leaks in high-pressure cryogenic storage is needed to improve hydrogen safety. The manuscript reports a series of numerical simulations with detailed chemistry for the transient evolution of ignited high-pressure cryogenic hydrogen jets. The study aims to gain insight of the ignition processes flame structures and dynamics associated with the transient flame evolution. Numerical simulations were firstly conducted for an unignited jet released under the same cryogenic temperature of 80 K and pressure of 200 bar as the considered ignited jets. The predicted hydrogen concentrations were found to be in good agreement with the experimental measurements. The results informed the subsequent simulations of the ignited jets involving four different ignition locations. The predicted time series snapshots of temperature hydrogen mass fraction and the flame index are analyzed to study the transient evolution and structure of the flame. The results show that a diffusion combustion layer is developed along the outer boundary of the jet and a side diffusion flame is formed for the near-field ignition. For the far-field ignition an envelope flame is observed. The flame structure contains a diffusion flame on the outer edge and a premixed flame inside the jet. Due to the complex interactions between turbulence fuel-air mixing at cryogenic temperature and chemical reactions localized spontaneous ignition and transient flame extinguishment are observed. The predictions also captured the experimentally observed deflagration waves in the far-field ignited jets.
Building the Green Hydrogen Market - Current State and Outlook on Green Hydrogen Demand and Electrolyzer Manufacturing
Jul 2022
Publication
Over the past two years requirements to meet climate targets have been intensified. In addition to the tightening of the climate targets and the demand for net-zero achievement by as early as 2045 there have been discussions on implementing and realizing these goals. Hydrogen has emerged as a promising climate-neutral energy carrier. Thus over the last 1.5 years more than 25 countries have published hydrogen roadmaps. Furthermore various studies by different authorities have been released to support the development of a hydrogen economy. This paper examines published studies and hydrogen country roadmaps as part of a meta-analysis. Furthermore a market analysis of electrolyzer manufacturers is conducted. The prospected demand for green hydrogen from various studies is compared to electrolyzer manufacturing capacities and selected green hydrogen projects to identify potential market ramp-up scenarios and to evaluate if green hydrogen demand forecasts can be filled.
The Role of Renewable Energies, Storage and Sector-Coupling Technologies in the German Energy Sector under Different CO2 Emission Restrictions
Aug 2022
Publication
This study aimed to simulate the sector-coupled energy system of Germany in 2030 with the restriction on CO2 emission levels and to observe how the system evolves with decreasing emissions. Moreover the study presented an analysis of the interconnection between electricity heat and hydrogen and how technologies providing flexibility will react when restricting CO2 emissions levels. This investigation has not yet been carried out with the technologies under consideration in this study. It shows how the energy system behaves under different set boundaries of CO2 emissions and how the costs and technologies change with different emission levels. The study results show that the installed capacities of renewable technologies constantly increase with higher limitations on emissions. However their usage rates decreases with low CO2 emission levels in response to higher curtailed energy. The sector-coupled technologies behave differently in this regard. Heat pumps show similar behaviour while the electrolysers usage rate increases with more renewable energy penetration. The system flexibility is not primarily driven by the hydrogen sector but in low CO2 emission level scenarios the flexibility shifts towards the heating sector and electrical batteries.
Underground Bio-methanation: Concept and Potential
Feb 2020
Publication
As a major part of the energy turn around the European Union and other countries are supporting the development of renewable energy technologies to decrease nuclear and fossil energy production. Therefore efficient use of renewable energy resources is one challenge as they are influenced by environmental conditions and hence the intensity of resources such as wind or solar power fluctuates. To secure constant energy supply suitable energy storage and conversion techniques are required. An upcoming solution is the utilization and storage of hydrogen or hydrogen-rich natural gas in porous formations in the underground. In the past microbial methanation was observed as a side effect during these gas storage operations. The concept of underground bio-methanation arised which uses the microbial metabolism to convert hydrogen and carbon dioxide into methane. The concept consists of injecting gaseous hydrogen and carbon dioxide into an underground structure during energy production peaks which are subsequently partly converted into methane. The resulting methane-rich gas mixture is withdrawn during high energy demand. The concept is comparable to engineered bio-reactors which are already locally integrated into the gas infrastructure. In both technologies the conversion process of hydrogen into methane is driven by hydrogenotrophic methanogenic archaea present in the aqueous phase of the natural underground or above-ground engineered reactor. Nevertheless the porous medium in the underground provides compared to the engineered bio-reactors a larger interface between the gas and aqueous phase caused by the enormous volume in the underground porous media. The following article summarizes the potential and concept of underground methanation and the current state of the art in terms of laboratory investigations and pilot tests. A short system potential analysis shows that an underground bio-reactor with a storage capacity of 850 Mio. Sm3 could deliver methane to more than 600000 households based on a hydrogen production from renewable energies.
The More the Merrier? Actors and Ideas in the Evolution of Germany Hydrogen Policy Discourse
Feb 2023
Publication
Hydrogen has set high hopes for decarbonization due to its flexibility and ability to decarbonize sectors of the economy where direct electrification appears unviable. Broad hydrogen policies have therefore started to emerge. Nevertheless it is still a rather niche technology not integrated or adopted at scale and not regulated through particular policy provisions. The involved stakeholders are thus still rushing to set the agenda over the issue. All this plays out publicly and shapes the public discourse. This paper explores how the composition of stakeholders their positions and the overall discourse structure have developed and accompanied the political agenda-setting in the early public debate on hydrogen in Germany. We use discourse network analysis of media where stakeholders' claims-making is documented and their positions can be tracked over time. The public discourse on hydrogen in Germany shows the expected evolution of statements in connection with the two milestones chosen for the analyses the initiation of the Gas 2030 Dialogue and the publication of the National Hydrogen Strategy. Interestingly the discourse was comparatively feeble in the immediate aftermath of the respective milestones but intensified in a consolidation phase around half a year later. Sequencing the discourse and contextualizing its content relative to political societal and economic conditions in a diachronic way is essential because it helps to avoid misinterpreting the development of stakeholders' standpoints as conflict-driven rather than mere repositioning. Thus we observed no discourse “polarization” even though potentially polarizing issues were already present in the debate.
Green Hydrogen Production and Use in Low- and Middle-income Countries: A Least-cost Geospatial Modelling Approach Applied to Kenya
May 2023
Publication
With the rising threat of climate change green hydrogen is increasingly seen as the high-capacity energy storage and transport medium of the future. This creates an opportunity for low- and middle-income countries to leverage their high renewable energy potential to produce use and export low-cost green hydrogen creating environmental and economic development benefits. While identifying ideal locations for green hydrogen production is critical for countries when defining their green hydrogen strategies there has been a paucity of adequate geospatial planning approaches suitable to low- and middle-income countries. It is essential for these countries to identify green hydrogen production sites which match demand to expected use cases such that their strategies are economically sustainable. This paper therefore develops a novel geospatial cost modelling method to optimize the location of green hydrogen production across different use cases with a focus on suitability to low- and middle-income countries. This method is applied in Kenya to investigate the potential hydrogen supply chain for three use cases: ammonia-based fertilizer freight transport and export. We find hydrogen production costs of e3.7–9.9/kgH2 are currently achievable across Kenya depending on the production location chosen. The cheapest production locations are identified to the south and south-east of Lake Turkana. We show that ammonia produced in Kenya can be cost-competitive given the current energy crisis and that Kenya could export hydrogen to Rotterdam with costs of e7/kgH2 undercutting current market prices regardless of the carrier medium. With expected techno-economic improvements hydrogen production costs across Kenya could drop to e1.8–3.0/kgH2 by 2030.
Storage Batteries in Photovoltaic-electrochemical Device for Solar Hydrogen Production
Aug 2021
Publication
Hydrogen produced by water electrolysis and electrochemical batteries are widely considered as primary routes for the long- and short-term storage of photovoltaic (PV) energy. At the same time fast power ramps and idle periods in PV power generation may cause degradation of water splitting electrochemical (EC) cells. Implementation of batteries in PV-EC systems is a viable option for smoothening out intermittence of PV power. Notably the spreading of PV energy over the diurnal cycle reduces power of the EC cell and thus its overpotential loss. We study these potential advantages theoretically and experimentally for a simple parallel connected combination of PV EC and battery cells (PV-EC-B) operated without power management electronics. We show feasibility of the unaided operation of PV-EC-B device in a relevant duty cycle and explore how PV-EC-B system can operate at higher solar-to-hydrogen efficiency than the equivalent reference PV-EC system despite the losses caused by the battery.
Fostering Macroeconomic Research on Hydrogen-Powered Aviation: A Systematic Literature Review on General Equilibrium Models
Feb 2023
Publication
Hydrogen is a promising fuel to decarbonize aviation but macroeconomic studies are currently missing. Computable general equilibrium (CGE) models are suitable to conduct macroeconomic analyses and are frequently employed in hydrogen and aviation research. The main objective of this paper is to investigate existing CGE studies related to (a) hydrogen and (b) aviation to derive a macroeconomic research agenda for hydrogen-powered aviation. Therefore the well-established method of systematic literature review is conducted. First we provide an overview of 18 hydrogen-related and 27 aviation-related CGE studies and analyze the literature with respect to appropriate categories. Second we highlight key insights and identify research gaps for both the hydrogen and aviation-related CGE literature. Our findings comprise inter alia hydrogen’s current lack of cost competitiveness and the macroeconomic relevance of air transportation. Research gaps include among others a stronger focus on sustainable hydrogen and a more holistic perspective on the air transportation system. Third we derive implications for macroeconomic research on hydrogen-powered aviation including (I) the consideration of existing modeling approaches (II) the utilization of interdisciplinary data and scenarios (III) geographical suitability (IV) the application of diverse policy tools and (V) a holistic perspective. Our work contributes a meaningful foundation for macroeconomic studies on hydrogen-powered aviation. Moreover we recommend policymakers to address the macroeconomic perspectives of hydrogen use in air transportation.
Technical Evaluation of the Flexibility of Water Electrolysis Systems to Increase Energy Flexibility: A Review
Jan 2023
Publication
The goal of achieving water electrolysis on a gigawatt scale faces numerous challenges regarding technological feasibility and market application. Here the flexibility of operation scenarios such as load changes and capacity of electrolysis plays a key role. This raises the question of how flexible electrolysis systems currently are and what possibilities there are to increase flexibility. In order to be able to answer this question in the following a systematic literature research was carried out with the aim to show the current technical possibilities to adapt load and capacity of electrolysis technologies and to determine limits. The result of the systematic literature research is an overview matrix of the electrolysis types AEL PEMEL HTEL and AEMEL already applied in the market. Technical data on the operation of the respective electrolysis stacks as well as details and materials for the respective stack structure (cathode anode electrolyte) were summarized. The flexibility of the individual technologies is addressed by expressing it in values such as load flexibility and startup-times. The overview matrix contains values from various sour1ces in order to make electrolysis comparable at the stack level and to be able to make statements about flexibility. The result of the overview article shows the still open need for research and development to make electrolysis more flexible.
Impacts of Greenhouse Gas Neutrality Strategies on Gas Infrastructure and Costs: Implications from Case Studies Based on French and German GHG-neutral Scenarios
Sep 2022
Publication
The European Union’s target to reach greenhouse gas neutrality by 2050 calls for a sharp decrease in the consumption of natural gas. This study assesses impacts of greenhouse gas neutrality on the gas system taking France and Germany as two case studies which illustrate a wide range of potential developments within the European Union. Based on a review of French and German GHG-neutral scenarios it explores impacts on gas infrastructure and estimates the changes in end-user methane price considering a business-as-usual and an optimised infrastructure pathway. Our results show that gas supply and demand radically change by mid-century across various scenarios. Moreover the analysis suggests that deep transformations of the gas infrastructure are required and that according to the existing pricing mechanisms the end-user price of methane will increase driven by the switch to low-carbon gases and intensified by infrastructure costs.
Strategic Policy Targets and the Contribution of Hydrogen in a 100% Renewable European Power System
Jul 2021
Publication
The goal of the European energy policy is to achieve climate neutrality. The long-term energy strategies of various European countries include additional targets such as the diversification of energy sources maintenance of security of supply and reduction of import dependency. When optimizing energy systems these strategic policy targets are often only considered in a rudimentary manner and thus the understanding of the corresponding interdependencies is lacking. Moreover hydrogen is considered as a key component of a fully decarbonized energy system but its role in the power sector remains unclear due to the low round-trip efficiencies. This study reveals how fully decarbonized European power systems can benefit from hydrogen in terms of overall system costs and the achievement of strategic policy targets. We analyzed a broad spectrum of scenarios using an energy system optimization model and varied model constraints that reflect strategic policy targets. Our results are threefold. First compared to power systems without hydrogen systems using hydrogen realize savings of 14–16% in terms of the total system costs. Second the implementation of a hydrogen infrastructure reduces the number of infeasible scenarios when structural policy targets are considered within the power system. Third the role of hydrogen is highly diverse at a national level. Particularly in countries with low renewable energy potential hydrogen plays a crucial role. Here high levels of self-sufficiency and security of supply are achieved by deploying hydrogen-based power generation of up to 46% of their annual electricity demand realized via imports of green hydrogen.
Blast Wave Generated by Delayed Ignition of Under-Expanded Hydrogen Free Jet at Ambient and Cryogenic Temperatures
Nov 2022
Publication
An under-expanded hydrogen jet from high-pressure equipment or storage tank is a potential incident scenario. Experiments demonstrated that the delayed ignition of a highly turbulent under-expanded hydrogen jet generates a blast wave able to harm people and damage property. There is a need for engineering tools to predict the pressure effects during such incidents to define hazard distances. The similitude analysis is applied to build a correlation using available experimental data. The dimensionless blast wave overpressure generated by delayed ignition and the follow-up deflagration or detonation of hydrogen jets at an any location from the jet ∆Pexp/P0 is correlated to the original dimensionless parameter composed of the product of the dimensionless ratio of storage pressure to atmospheric pressure Ps/P0 and the ratio of the jet release nozzle diameter to the distance from the centre of location of the fast-burning near-stoichiometric mixture on the jet axis (30% of hydrogen in the air by volume) to the location of a target (personnel or property) d/Rw. The correlation is built using the analysis of 78 experiments regarding this phenomenon in the wide range of hydrogen storage pressure of 0.5–65.0 MPa and release diameter of 0.5–52.5 mm. The correlation is applicable to hydrogen free jets at ambient and cryogenic temperatures. It is found that the generated blast wave decays inversely proportional to the square of the distance from the fast-burning portion of the jet. The correlation is used to calculate the hazard distances by harm thresholds for five typical hydrogen applications. It is observed that in the case of a vehicle with onboard storage tank at pressure 70 MPa the “no-harm” distance for humans reduces from 10.5 m to 2.6 m when a thermally activated pressure relief device (TPRD) diameter decreases from 2 mm to a diameter of 0.5 mm.
On the Road to Sustainable Transport: Acceptance and Preferences for Renewable Fuel Production Infrastructure
Sep 2022
Publication
To abate climate change and ameliorate the air quality in urban areas innovative solutions are required to reduce CO2 and pollutant emissions from traffic. Alternative fuels made from biomass or CO2 and hydrogen can contribute to these goals by substituting fossil gasoline or diesel in combustion engines. Using a conjoint analysis approach the current study investigates preferences of laypeople (n = 303) for fuel production facilities in terms of siting location plant size raw material used in the production and raw material transport. The location was most decision-relevant followed by raw material transport whereas plant size and type of raw material played a less prominent role for the preference choice. The best-case scenario from the point of view of acceptance would be the installation of a rather small bio-hybrid fuel production plant in an industrial area (instead of an agricultural or pristine environment). No transport or transport via underground pipeline were preferred over truck/tank car or overground pipeline. The findings can be used as a basis for planning and decision-making for designing production networks for new fuel types.
Underground Storage of Green Hydrogen—Boundary Conditions for Compressor Systems
Aug 2022
Publication
The large-scale storage of hydrogen in salt caverns modelled on today’s natural gas storage is a promising approach to storing renewable energy over a large power range and for the required time period. An essential subsystem of the overall gas storage is the surface facility and in particular the compressor system. The future design of compressor systems for hydrogen storage strongly depends on the respective boundary conditions. Therefore this work analyses the requirements of compressor systems for cavern storage facilities for the storage of green hydrogen i.e. hydrogen produced from renewable energy sources using the example of Lower Saxony in Germany. In this course a hydrogen storage demand profile of one year is developed in hourly resolution from feed-in time series of renewable energy sources. The injection profile relevant for compressor operation is compared with current natural gas injection operation modes
Is Blue Hydrogen a Bridging Technology? - The Limits of a CO2 Price and the Role of State-induced Price Components for Green Hydrogen Production in Germany
Jun 2022
Publication
The European Commission aims to establish green hydrogen produced through electrolysis using renewable electricity and in a transition phase hydrogen produced in a low-carbon process or blue hydrogen. In an extensive cost analysis for Germany up to 2050 based on scenario data and a component-based learning rate approach we find that blue hydrogen is likely to establish itself as the most cost-effective option and not only as a medium-term low-carbon alternative. We find that expected CO2 prices below €480/tCO2 have a limited impact on the economic feasibility of electrolysis and show that substantial increases in excise tax on natural gas could lead blue hydrogen to reach a sufficient cost level for electrolysed hydrogen. Unless alternatives for green hydrogen supply through infrastructure and imports become available at lower cost electrolysed hydrogen may require long-term subsidies. As blue hydrogen comprises fugitive methane emissions and financing needs for green hydrogen support have implications for society and competition in the internal market we suggest that policymakers rely on hydrogen for decarbonising only essential energy applications. We recommend further investigations into the cost of hydrogen infrastructure and import options as well as efficient subsidy frameworks.
The Role of Hydrogen in a Greenhouse Gas-neutral Energy Supply System in Germany
Sep 2022
Publication
Hydrogen is widely considered to play a pivotal role in successfully transforming the German energy system but the German government’s current “National Hydrogen Strategy” does not specify how hydrogen utilization production storage or distribution will be implemented. Addressing key uncertainties for the German energy system’s path to greenhouse gas-neutrality this paper examines hydrogen in different scenarios. This analysis aims to support the concretization of the German hydrogen strategy. Applying a European energy supply model with strong interactions between the conversion sector and the hydrogen system the analysis focuses on the requirements for geological hydrogen storages and their utilization over the course of a year the positioning of electrolyzers within Germany and the contributions of hydrogen transport networks to balancing supply and demand. Regarding seasonal hydrogen storages the results show that hydrogen storage facilities in the range of 42 TWhH2 to 104 TWhH2 are beneficial to shift high electricity generation volumes from onshore wind in spring and fall to winter periods with lower renewable supply and increased electricity and heat demands. In 2050 the scenario results show electrolyzer capacities between 41 GWel and 75 GWel in Germany. Electrolyzer sites were found to follow the low-cost renewable energy potential and are concentrated on the North Sea and Baltic Sea coasts with their high wind yields. With respect to a hydrogen transport infrastructure there were two robust findings: One a domestic German hydrogen transport network connecting electrolytic hydrogen production sites in northern Germany with hydrogen demand hubs in western and southern Germany is economically efficient. Two connecting Germany to a European hydrogen transport network with interconnection capacities between 18 GWH2 and 58 GWH2 is cost-efficient to meet Germany’s substantial hydrogen demand.
Design of Fuel Cell Systems for Aviation: Representative Mission Profiles and Sensitivity Analyses
Apr 2019
Publication
The global transition to a clean and sustainable energy infrastructure does not stop at aviation. The European Commission defined a set of environmental goals for the “Flight Path 2050”: 75% CO2 reduction 90% NOx reduction and 65% perceived noise reduction. Hydrogen as an energy carrier fulfills these needs while it would also offer a tenable and flexible solution for intermittent large-scale energy storage for renewable energy networks. If hydrogen is used as an energy carrier there is no better device than a fuel cell to convert its stored chemical energy. In order to design fuel cell systems for passenger aircraft it is necessary to specify the requirements that the system has to fulfill. In this paper a statistical approach to analyze these requirements is presented which accounts for variations in the flight mission profile. Starting from a subset of flight data within the desired class (e.g. mid-range inter-European flights) a stochastic model of the random mission profile is inferred. This model allows for subsequent predictions under uncertainty as part of the aircraft design process. By using Monte Carlo-based sampling of flight mission profiles the range of necessary component sizes as well as optimal degrees of hybridization with a battery is explored and design options are evaluated. Furthermore Monte Carlo-based sensitivity analysis of performance parameters explores the potential of future technological developments. Results suggest that the improvement of the specific power of the fuel cell is the deciding factor for lowering the energy system mass. The specific energy of the battery has a low influence but acts in conjunction with the specific power of the fuel cell.
Electrofuels from Excess Renewable Electricity at High Variable Renewable Shares: Cost, Greenhouse Gas Abatement, Carbon Use and Competition
Nov 2020
Publication
Increasing shares of variable renewable electricity (VRE) generation are necessary for achieving high renewable shares in all energy sectors. This results in increased excess renewable electricity (ERE) at times when supply exceeds demand. ERE can be utilized as a low-emission energy source for sector coupling through hydrogen production via electrolysis which can be used directly or combined with a carbon source to produce electrofuels. Such fuels are crucial for the transport sector where renewable alternatives are scarce. However while ERE increases with raising VRE shares carbon emissions decrease and may become a limited resource with several usage options including carbon storage (CCS). Here we perform a model based analysis for the German case until 2050 with a general analysis for regions with a high VRE reliance. Results indicate that ERE-based electrofuels could achieve a greenhouse gas (GHG) abatement of 74 MtCO2eq yearly (46% of current German transport emissions) by displacing fossil fuels at high fuel-cell electric vehicle (FCEV) shares at a cost of 250–320 V per tCO2eq. The capital expenditure of electrolysers was found not to be crucial for the cost despite low capacity factors due to variable ERE patterns. Carbon will likely become a limiting factor when aiming for stringent climate targets and renewable electricity-based hydrocarbon electrofuels replacing fossil fuels achieve up to 70% more GHG abatement than CCS. Given (1) an unsaturated demand for renewable hydrocarbon fuels (2) a saturated renewable hydrogen demand and (3) unused ERE capacities which would otherwise be curtailed we find that carbon is better used for renewable fuel production than being stored in terms of overall GHG abatement.
Aboveground Hydrogen Storage - Assessment of the Potential Market Releveance in a Carbon-Neutral European Energy System
Mar 2024
Publication
Hydrogen storage is expected to play a crucial role in the comprehensive defossilization of energy systems. In this context the focus is typically on underground hydrogen storage (e.g. in salt caverns). However aboveground storage which is independent of geological conditions and might offer other technical advantages could provide systemic benefits and thereby gain shares in the hydrogen storage market. Against this background this paper examines the market relevance of aboveground compared to underground hydrogen storage. Using the opensource energy system model and optimization framework of Europe PyPSA-Eur the influence of geological independence storage cost relations and technical storage characteristics (i.e. efficiencies) on mentioned market relevance of aboveground hydrogen storage are investigated. Further the expectable market relevance based on current cost projections for the future is assessed. The studies show that in terms of hydrogen capacities aboveground hydrogen storage plays a considerably smaller role compared to underground hydrogen storage. Even when assuming comparatively low aboveground storage cost it will not exceed 1.7% (1.9 TWhH2LHV) of total hydrogen storage capacities in a cost-optimal European energy system. Regarding the amounts of annually stored hydrogen aboveground storage could play a larger role reaching a maximum share of 32.5% (168 TWhH2 LHV a-1) of total stored hydrogen throughout Europe. However these shares are only achievable for low cost storage in particularly suited energy system supply configurations. For higher aboveground storage costs or lower efficiencies shares drop below 10% sharply. The analysis identifies some especially influential factors for achieving higher market relevance. Besides storage costs the demand-orientation of a particular aboveground storage system (e.g. hydrogen storage at demand pressure levels) plays an essential role in market relevance. Further overall efficiency can be a beneficial factor. Still current projections of future techno-economic characteristics show that aboveground hydrogen storage is too expensive or too inefficient compared to underground storage. Therefore to achieve notable market relevance rather drastic cost reductions beyond current expectations would be needed for all assessed aboveground hydrogen storage technologies.
Artificial Intelligence/Machine Learning in Energy Management Systems, Control, and Optimization of Hydrogen Fuel Cell Vehicles
Mar 2023
Publication
Environmental emissions global warming and energy-related concerns have accelerated the advancements in conventional vehicles that primarily use internal combustion engines. Among the existing technologies hydrogen fuel cell electric vehicles and fuel cell hybrid electric vehicles may have minimal contributions to greenhouse gas emissions and thus are the prime choices for environmental concerns. However energy management in fuel cell electric vehicles and fuel cell hybrid electric vehicles is a major challenge. Appropriate control strategies should be used for effective energy management in these vehicles. On the other hand there has been significant progress in artificial intelligence machine learning and designing data-driven intelligent controllers. These techniques have found much attention within the community and state-of-the-art energy management technologies have been developed based on them. This manuscript reviews the application of machine learning and intelligent controllers for prediction control energy management and vehicle to everything (V2X) in hydrogen fuel cell vehicles. The effectiveness of data-driven control and optimization systems are investigated to evolve classify and compare and future trends and directions for sustainability are discussed.
Carbon Footprint Assessment of Hydrogen and Steel
Dec 2022
Publication
Hydrogen has the potential to decarbonize a variety of energy-intensive sectors including steel production. Using the life cycle assessment (LCA) methodology the state of the art is given for current hydrogen production with a focus on the hydrogen carbon footprint. Beside the state of the art the outlook on different European scenarios up to the year 2040 is presented. A case study of the transformation of steel production from coal-based towards hydrogen- and electricity-based metallurgy is presented. Direct reduction plants with integrated electric arc furnaces enable steel production which is almost exclusively based on hydrogen and electricity or rather on electricity alone if hydrogen stems from electrolysis. Thus an integrated steel site has a demand of 4.9 kWh of electric energy per kilogram of steel. The carbon footprint of steel considering a European sustainable development scenario concerning the electricity mix is 0.75 kg CO2eq/kg steel in 2040. From a novel perspective a break-even analysis is given comparing the use of natural gas and hydrogen using different electricity mixes. The results concerning hydrogen production presented in this paper can also be transferred to application fields other than steel.
Solar Hydrogen Fuel Generation from Wastewater—Beyond Photoelectrochemical Water Splitting: A Perspective
Oct 2022
Publication
Green hydrogen—a carbon-free renewable fuel—has the capability to decarbonise a variety of sectors. The generation of green hydrogen is currently restricted to water electrolysers. The use of freshwater resources and critical raw materials however limits their use. Alternative water splitting methods for green hydrogen generation via photocatalysis and photoelectrocatalysis (PEC) have been explored in the past few decades; however their commercial potential still remains unexploited due to the high hydrogen generation costs. Novel PEC-based simultaneous generation of green hydrogen and wastewater treatment/high-value product production is therefore seen as an alternative to conventional water splitting. Interestingly the organic/inorganic pollutants in wastewater and biomass favourably act as electron donors and facilitate the dual-functional process of recovering green hydrogen while oxidising the organic matter. The generation of green hydrogen through the dual-functional PEC process opens up opportunities for a “circular economy”. It further enables the end-of-life commodities to be reused recycled and resourced for a better life-cycle design while being economically viable for commercialisation. This review brings together and critically analyses the recent trends towards simultaneous wastewater treatment/biomass reforming while generating hydrogen gas by employing the PEC technology. We have briefly discussed the technical challenges associated with the tandem PEC process new avenues techno-economic feasibility and future directions towards achieving net neutrality.
Decentral Production of Green Hydrogen for Energy Systems: An Economically and Environmentally Viable Solution for Surplus Self-Generated Energy in Manufacturing Companies?
Feb 2023
Publication
Power-to-X processes where renewable energy is converted into storable liquids or gases are considered to be one of the key approaches for decarbonizing energy systems and compensating for the volatility involved in generating electricity from renewable sources. In this context the production of “green” hydrogen and hydrogen-based derivatives is being discussed and tested as a possible solution for the energy-intensive industry sector in particular. Given the sharp ongoing increases in electricity and gas prices and the need for sustainable energy supplies in production systems non-energy-intensive companies should also be taken into account when considering possible utilization paths for hydrogen. This work focuses on the following three utilization paths: “hydrogen as an energy storage system that can be reconverted into electricity” “hydrogen mobility” for company vehicles and “direct hydrogen use”. These three paths are developed modeled simulated and subsequently evaluated in terms of economic and environmental viability. Different photovoltaic system configurations are set up for the tests with nominal power ratings ranging from 300 kWp to 1000 kWp. Each system is assigned an electrolyzer with a power output ranging between 200 kW and 700 kW and a fuel cell with a power output ranging between 5 kW and 75 kW. There are also additional variations in relation to the battery storage systems within these basic configurations. Furthermore a reference variant without battery storage and hydrogen technologies is simulated for each photovoltaic system size. This means that there are ultimately 16 variants to be simulated for each utilization path. The results show that these utilization paths already constitute a reasonable alternative to fossil fuels in terms of costs in variants with a suitable energy system design. For the “hydrogen as an energy storage system” path electricity production costs of between 43 and 79 ct/kWh can be achieved with the 750 kWp photovoltaic system. The “hydrogen mobility” is associated with costs of 12 to 15 ct/km while the “direct hydrogen use” path resulted in costs of 8.2 €/kg. Environmental benefits are achieved in all three paths by replacing the German electricity mix with renewable energy sources produced on site or by substituting hydrogen for fossil fuels. The results confirm that using hydrogen as a storage medium in manufacturing companies could be economically and environmentally viable. These results also form the basis for further studies e.g. on detailed operating strategies for hydrogen technologies in scenarios involving a combination of multiple utilization paths. The work also presents the simulation-based method developed in this project which can be transferred to comparable applications in further studies.
Integration of Water Electrolysis Facilities in Power Grids: A Case Study in Northern Germany
Mar 2022
Publication
This work presents a study of the effects that integration of electrolysis facilities for Power-to-X processes have on the power grid. The novel simulation setup combines a high-resolution grid optimization model and a detailed scheduling model for alkaline water electrolysis. The utilization and congestion of power lines in northern Germany is investigated by setting different installed capacities and production strategies of the electrolysis facility. For electrolysis capacities up to 300 MW (~50 ktH2/a) local impacts on the grid are observed while higher capacities cause supra-regional impacts. Thereby impacts are defined as deviations from the average line utilization greater than 5%. In addition the minimum line congestion is determined to coincide with the dailyconstrained production strategy of the electrolysis facility. Our result show a good compromise for the integrated grid-facility operation with minimum production cost and reduced impact on the grid.
System Analysis and Requirements Derivation of a Hydrogen-electric Aircraft Powertrain
Sep 2022
Publication
In contrast to sustainable aviation fuels for use in conventional combustion engines hydrogen-electric powertrains constitute a fundamentally novel approach that requires extensive effort from various engineering disciplines. A transient system analysis has been applied to a 500 kW shaft-power-class powertrain. The model was fed with high-level system requirements to gain a fundamental understanding of the interaction between sub-systems and components. Transient effects such as delays in pressure build up heat transfer and valve operation substantially impact the safe and continuous operation of the propulsion system throughout a typical mission profile which is based on the Daher TBM850. The lumped-parameters network solver provides results quickly which are used to derive requirements for subsystems and components which support their in-depth future development. E.g. heat exchanger transfer rates and pressure drop of the motor's novel hydrogen cooling system are established. Furthermore improvements to the system architecture such as a compartmentalization of the tank are identified.
Biological CO2-Methanation: An Approach to Standardization
May 2019
Publication
Power-to-Methane as one part of Power-to-Gas has been recognized globally as one of the key elements for the transition towards a sustainable energy system. While plants that produce methane catalytically have been in operation for a long time biological methanation has just reached industrial pilot scale and near-term commercial application. The growing importance of the biological method is reflected by an increasing number of scientific articles describing novel approaches to improve this technology. However these studies are difficult to compare because they lack a coherent nomenclature. In this article we present a comprehensive set of parameters allowing the characterization and comparison of various biological methanation processes. To identify relevant parameters needed for a proper description of this technology we summarized existing literature and defined system boundaries for Power-to-Methane process steps. On this basis we derive system parameters providing information on the methanation system its performance the biology and cost aspects. As a result three different standards are provided as a blueprint matrix for use in academia and industry applicable to both biological and catalytic methanation. Hence this review attempts to set the standards for a comprehensive description of biological and chemical methanation processes.
Methane Pyrolysis for CO2-Free H2 Production: A Green Process to Overcome Renewable Energies Unsteadiness
Aug 2020
Publication
The Carbon2Chem project aims to convert exhaust gases from the steel industry into chemicals such as methanol to reduce CO2 emissions. Here H2 is required for the conversion of CO2 into methanol. Although much effort is put to produce H2 from renewables the use of fossil fuels especially natural gas seems to be fundamental in the short term. For this reason the development of clean technologies for the processing of natural gas with a low environmental impact has become a topic of utmost importance. In this context methane pyrolysis has received special attention to produce CO2-free H2.
Review of Power-to-X Demonstration Projects in Europe
Sep 2020
Publication
At the heart of most Power-to-X (PtX) concepts is the utilization of renewable electricity to produce hydrogen through the electrolysis of water. This hydrogen can be used directly as a final energy carrier or it can be converted into for example methane synthesis gas liquid fuels electricity or chemicals. Technical demonstration and systems integration are of major importance for integrating PtX into energy systems. As of June 2020 a total of 220 PtX research and demonstration projects in Europe have either been realized completed or are currently being planned. The central aim of this review is to identify and assess relevant projects in terms of their year of commissioning location electricity and carbon dioxide sources applied technologies for electrolysis capacity type of hydrogen post-processing and the targeted field of application. The latter aspect has changed over the years. At first the targeted field of application was fuel production for example for hydrogen buses combined heat and power generation and subsequent injection into the natural gas grid. Today alongside fuel production industrial applications are also important. Synthetic gaseous fuels are the focus of fuel production while liquid fuel production is severely under-represented. Solid oxide electrolyzer cells (SOECs) represent a very small proportion of projects compared to polymer electrolyte membranes (PEMs) and alkaline electrolyzers. This is also reflected by the difference in installed capacities. While alkaline electrolyzers are installed with capacities between 50 and 5000 kW (2019/20) and PEM electrolyzers between 100 and 6000 kW SOECs have a capacity of 150 kW. France and Germany are undertaking the biggest efforts to develop PtX technologies compared to other European countries. On the whole however activities have progressed at a considerably faster rate than had been predicted just a couple of years ago.
Assessing the Social Acceptance of Key Technologies for the German Energy Transition
Jan 2022
Publication
Background: The widespread use of sustainable energy technologies is a key element in the transformation of the energy system from fossil-based to zero-carbon. In line with this technology acceptance is of great importance as resistance from the public can slow down or hinder the construction of energy technology projects. The current study assesses the social acceptance of three energy technologies relevant for the German energy transition: stationary battery storage biofuel production plants and hydrogen fuel station. Methods: An online survey was conducted to examine the public’s general and local acceptance of energy technologies. Explored factors included general and local acceptance public concerns trust in relevant stakeholders and attitudes towards financial support. Results: The results indicate that general acceptance for all technologies is slightly higher than local acceptance. In addition we discuss which public concerns exist with regard to the respective technologies and how they are more strongly associated with local than general acceptance. Further we show that trust in stakeholders and attitudes towards fnancial support is relatively high across the technologies discussed. Conclusions: Taken together the study provides evidence for the existence of a “general–local” gap despite measuring general and local acceptance at the same level of specifcity using a public sample. In addition the collected data can provide stakeholders with an overview of worries that might need to be addressed when planning to implement a certain energy project.
Review and Harmonization of the Life-Cycle Global Warming Impact of PV-Powered Hydrogen Production by Electrolysis
Sep 2021
Publication
This work presents a review of life-cycle assessment (LCA) studies of hydrogen electrolysis using power from photovoltaic (PV) systems. The paper discusses the assumptions strengths and weaknesses of 13 LCA studies and identifies the causes of the environmental impact. Differences in assumptions of system boundaries system sizes evaluation methods and functional units make it challenging to directly compare the Global Warming Potential (GWP) resulting from different studies. To simplify this process 13 selected LCA studies on PV-powered hydrogen production have been harmonized following a consistent framework described by this paper. The harmonized GWP values vary from 0.7 to 6.6 kg CO2-eq/kg H2 which can be considered a wide range. The maximum absolute difference between the original and harmonized GWP results of a study is 1.5 kg CO2-eq/kg H2. Yet even the highest GWP of this study is over four times lower than the GWP of grid-powered electrolysis in Germany. Due to the lack of transparency of most LCAs included in this review full identification of the sources of discrepancies (methods applied assumed production conditions) is not possible. Overall it can be concluded that the environmental impact of the electrolytic hydrogen production process is mainly caused by the GWP of the electricity supply. For future environmental impact studies on hydrogen production systems it is highly recommended to 1) divide the whole system into well-defined subsystems using compression as the final stage of the LCA and 2) to provide energy inputs/GWP results for the different subsystems.
Methanol as a Renewable Energy Carrier: An Assessment of Production and Transportation Costs for Selected Global Locations
Jun 2021
Publication
The importing of renewable energy will be one part of the process of defossilizing the energy systems of countries and regions which are currently heavily dependent on the import of fossil-based energy carriers. This study investigates the possibility of importing renewable methanol comprised of hydrogen and carbon dioxide. Based on a methanol synthesis simulation model the net production costs of methanol are derived as a function of hydrogen and carbon dioxide expenses. These findings enable a comparison of the import costs of methanol and hydrogen. For this the hydrogen production and distribution costs for 2030 as reported in a recent study for four different origin/destination country combinations are considered. With the predicted hydrogen production costs of 1.35–2 €/kg and additional shipping costs methanol can be imported for 370–600 €/t if renewable or process-related carbon dioxide is available at costs of 100 €/t or below in the hydrogen-producing country. Compared to the current fossil market price of approximately 400 €/t renewable methanol could therefore become cost-competitive. Within the range of carbon dioxide prices of 30–100 €/t both hydrogen and methanol exhibit comparable energy-specific import costs of 18–30 €/GJ. Hence the additional costs for upgrading hydrogen to methanol are balanced out by the lower shipping costs of methanol compared to hydrogen. Lastly a comparison for producing methanol in the hydrogen’s origin or destination country indicates that carbon dioxide in the destination country must be 181–228 €/t less expensive than that in the origin country to balance out the more expensive shipping costs for hydrogen.
Determination of the Optimal Power Ratio between Electrolysis and Renewable Energy to Investigate the Effects on the Hydrogen Production Costs
Sep 2022
Publication
Green hydrogen via renewable powered electrolysis has a high relevance in decarbonization and supply security. Achieving economically competitive hydrogen production costs is a major challenge in times of an energy price crisis. Our objective is to show the economically optimal installed capacity of electrolysers in relation to wind and solar power so swift and credible statements can be made regarding the system design. The ratio between renewable generation and electrolysis power as well as scaling effects operating behaviour and development of costs are considered. Hydrogen production costs are calculated for four exemplary real PV and wind sites and different ratios of electrolysis to renewable power for the year 2020. The ideal ratio for PV systems is between 14% and 73% and for wind between 3.3% and 143% for low and high full load hours. The lowest hydrogen production costs are identified at 2.53 €/kg for 50 MW wind power and 72 MW electrolysis power. The results provide plant constructors the possibility to create a cost-optimized design via an optimum ratio of electrolysis to renewable capacity. Therefore the procedures for planning and dimensioning of selected systems can be drastically simplified.
Study of Attenuation Effect of Water Droplets on Shockwaves from Hydrogen Explosion
Sep 2021
Publication
The increasing demand for renewable energy storage may position hydrogen as one of the major players in the future energy system. However to introduce such technology high level of safety must be offered. In particular for the accident scenarios with combustion or explosion of the unintendedly released hydrogen in partially or fully confined volumes such as e.g. road tunnel the effective countermeasures preventing or reducing the risk of equipment damages and person injuries should be established. A mitigation strategy could be the use of existing fire suppression system which can inject water as a spray. The shock waves resulted from hydrogen explosion could be weakened by the water droplets met on the shock path. In the presented work an attenuation effect of water droplets presence on the strength of the passing shock was studied. The analysis of the different attenuation mechanisms was performed and estimation of the effect of spray parameters such as droplet size and spray density on the shock wave was carried out. For the quantitative evaluation of the attenuation potential a numerical model for the COM3D combustion code was developed. The novel model for the droplet behavior accounting for the realistic correlations for the fluid (water) particle drag force linked with the corresponding droplet breakup model describing droplet atomization is presented. The model was validated against literature experimental data and was used for the blind simulations of the hydrogen test facility in KIT.
Seasonal Hydrogen Storage for Residential On- and Off-grid Solar Photovoltaics Prosumer Applications: Revolutionary Solution or Niche Market for the Energy Transition until 2050?
Apr 2023
Publication
Appropriate climate change mitigation requires solutions for all actors of the energy system. The residential sector is a major part of the energy system and solutions for the implementation of a seasonal hydrogen storage system in residential houses has been increasingly discussed. A global analysis of prosumer systems including seasonal hydrogen storage with water electrolyser hydrogen compressor storage tank and a fuel cell studying the role of such a seasonal household storage in the upcoming decades is not available. This study aims to close this research gap via the improved LUT-PROSUME model which models a fully micro sector coupled residential photovoltaic prosumer system with linear optimisation for 145 regions globally. The modelling of the cost development of hydrogen storage components allows for the simulation of a residential system from 2020 until 2050 in 5-year steps in hourly resolution. The systems are cost-optimised for either on– or off-grid operation in eight scenarios including battery electric vehicles which can act as an additional vehicle-to-home electricity storage for the system. Results show that implementation of seasonal hydrogen systems only occurs in least cost solutions in high latitude countries when the system is forced to run in off-grid mode. In general a solar photovoltaic plus battery system including technologies that can cover the heat demand is the most economic choice and can even achieve lower cost than a full grid supply in off-grid operation for most regions until 2050. Additional parameters including the self-consumption ratio the demand cover ratio and the heat cover ratio can therefore not be improved by seasonal storage systems if economics is the main deciding factor for a respective system. Further research opportunities and possible limitations of the system are then identified.
Evaluation of Sourcing Decision for Hydrogen Supply Chain Using an Integrated Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) Tool
Apr 2023
Publication
The use of fossil fuels has caused many environmental issues including greenhouse gas emissions and associated climate change. Several studies have focused on mitigating this problem. One dynamic direction for emerging sources of future renewable energy is the use of hydrogen energy. In this research we evaluate the sourcing decision for a hydrogen supply chain in the context of a case study in Thailand using group decision making analysis for policy implications. We use an integrative multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) tool which includes an analytic hierarchy process (AHP) fuzzy AHP (FAHP) and data envelopment analysis (DEA) to analyze weighted criteria and sourcing alternatives using data collected from a group of selected experts. A list of criteria related to sustainability paradigms and sourcing decisions for possible use of hydrogen energy including natural gas coal biomass and water are evaluated. Our results reveal that political acceptance is considered the most important criterion with a global weight of 0.514 in the context of Thailand. Additionally natural gas is found to be the foreseeable source for hydrogen production in Thailand with a global weight of 0.313. We also note that the analysis is based on specific data inputs and that an alternative with a lower score does not imply that the source is not worth exploring.
A Review of the Role of Hydrogen in the Heat Decarbonization of Future Energy Systems: Insights and Perspectives
Apr 2024
Publication
Hydrogen is an emerging technology changing the context of heating with cleaner combustion than traditional fossil fuels. Studies indicate the potential to repurpose the existing natural gas infrastructure offering consumers a sustainable economically viable option in the future. The integration of hydrogen in combined heat and power systems could provide residential energy demand and reduce environmental emissions. However the widespread adoption of hydrogen will face several challenges such as carbon dioxide emissions from the current production methods and the need for infrastructure modification for transport and safety. Researchers indicated the viability of hydrogen in decarbonizing heat while some studies also challenged its long-term role in the future of heating. In this paper a comprehensive literature review is carried out by identifying the following key aspects which could impact the conclusion on the overall role of hydrogen in heat decarbonization: (i) a holistic view of the energy system considering factors such as renewable integration and system balancing; (ii) consumer-oriented approaches often overlook the broader benefits of hydrogen in emission reduction and grid stability; (iii) carbon capture and storage scalability is a key factor for large-scale production of low-emission blue hydrogen; (iv) technological improvements could increase the cost-effectiveness of hydrogen; (v) the role of hydrogen in enhancing resilience especially during extreme weather conditions raises the potential of hydrogen as a flexible asset in the energy infrastructure for future energy supply; and finally when considering the UK as a basis case (vi) incorporating factors such as the extensive gas network and unique climate conditions necessitates specific strategies.
Refueling of LH2 Aircraft—Assessment of Turnaround Procedures and Aircraft Design Implication
Mar 2022
Publication
Green liquid hydrogen (LH2) could play an essential role as a zero-carbon aircraft fuel to reach long-term sustainable aviation. Excluding challenges such as electrolysis transportation and use of renewable energy in setting up hydrogen (H2) fuel infrastructure this paper investigates the interface between refueling systems and aircraft and the impacts on fuel distribution at the airport. Furthermore it provides an overview of key technology design decisions for LH2 refueling procedures and their effects on the turnaround times as well as on aircraft design. Based on a comparison to Jet A-1 refueling new LH2 refueling procedures are described and evaluated. Process steps under consideration are connecting/disconnecting purging chill-down and refueling. The actual refueling flow of LH2 is limited to a simplified Reynolds term of v · d = 2.35 m2/s. A mass flow rate of 20 kg/s is reached with an inner hose diameter of 152.4 mm. The previous and subsequent processes (without refueling) require 9 min with purging and 6 min without purging. For the assessment of impacts on LH2 aircraft operation process changes on the level of ground support equipment are compared to current procedures with Jet A-1. The technical challenges at the airport for refueling trucks as well as pipeline systems and dispensers are presented. In addition to the technological solutions explosion protection as applicable safety regulations are analyzed and the overall refueling process is validated. The thermodynamic properties of LH2 as a real compressible fluid are considered to derive implications for airport-side infrastructure. The advantages and disadvantages of a subcooled liquid are evaluated and cost impacts are elaborated. Behind the airport storage tank LH2 must be cooled to at least 19 K to prevent two-phase phenomena and a mass flow reduction during distribution. Implications on LH2 aircraft design are investigated by understanding the thermodynamic properties including calculation methods for the aircraft tank volume and problems such as cavitation and two-phase flows. In conclusion the work presented shows that LH2 refueling procedure is feasible compliant with the applicable explosion protection standards and hence does not impact the turnaround procedure. A turnaround time comparison shows that refueling with LH2 in most cases takes less time than with Jet A-1. The turnaround at the airport can be performed by a fuel truck or a pipeline dispenser system without generating direct losses i.e. venting to the atmosphere.
Aluminium Redox Cycle in Comparison to Pressurized Hydrogen for the Energy Supply of Multi-family Houses
Nov 2022
Publication
Power-to-X technologies that convert renewable electricity to chemically stored energy in “X” may provide a gaseous liquid or solid fuel that can be used in winter to provide both heat and electricity and thus replace fossil fuels that are currently used in many countries with cold winters. This contribution compares two options for power-to-X technologies for providing heat and electricity supply of buildings with high solar photovoltaic coverage at times of low solar availability. The option “compressed hydrogen” is based on water electrolysis that produces hydrogen on-site. This hydrogen is subsequently compressed and stored at high pressure (350 bar) for use in winter by a fuel cell. The option “aluminium redox-cycle” includes an inert electrode high temperature electrolysis process that is carried out at industrial scale. Produced aluminium is subseqeuntly transported to the site of use and converted to hydrogen and heat – and finally to electricity and heat - by aluminium-water reaction in combination with a fuel cell. Results of cost and LCA analysis show that the overall energetic efficiency of the compressed hydrogen process is slightly higher than for the aluminium redox cycle. However the aluminium redox-cycles needs far less on-site storage volume and is likely to become available at lower investment cost for the end user. Total annual cost of ownership and global warming potential of the two options are quite similar.
International Experience of Carbon Neutrality and Prospects of Key Technologies: Lessons for China
Feb 2023
Publication
Carbon neutrality (or climate neutrality) has been a global consensus and international experience exchange is essential. Given the differences in the degree of social development resource endowment and technological level each country should build a carbon-neutral plan based on its national conditions. Compared with other major developed countries (e.g. Germany the United States and Japan) China's carbon neutrality has much bigger challenges including a heavy and time-pressured carbon reduction task and the current energy structure that is over-dependent on fossil fuels. Here we provide a comprehensive review of the status and prospects of the key technologies for low-carbon near-zero carbon and negative carbon emissions. Technological innovations associated with coal oil-gas and hydrogen industries and their future potential in reducing carbon emissions are particularly explained and assessed. Based on integrated analysis of international experience from the world's major developed countries in-depth knowledge of the current and future technologies and China's energy and ecological resources potential five lessons for the implementation of China's carbon neutrality are proposed: (1) transformation of energy production pattern from a coal-dominated pattern to a diversified renewable energy pattern; (2) renewable power-to-X and large-scale underground energy storage; (3) integration of green hydrogen production storage transport and utilization; (4) construction of clean energy systems based on smart sector coupling (ENSYSCO); (5) improvement of ecosystem carbon sinks both in nationwide forest land and potential desert in Northwest China. This paper provides an international perspective for a better understanding of the challenges and opportunities of carbon neutrality in China and can serve as a theoretical foundation for medium-long term carbon neutral policy formulation.
Risk Assessment and Mitigation Evaluation for Hydrogen Vehicles in Private Garages. Experiments and Modelling
Sep 2021
Publication
Governments and local authorities introduce new incentives and regulations for cleaner mobility as part of their environmental strategies to address energy challenges. Fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEVs) are becoming increasingly important and will extend beyond captive fleets reaching private users. Research on hydrogen safety issues is currently led in several projects in order to highlight and manage risks of FCEVs in confined spaces such as tunnels underground parkings repair garages etc. But what about private garages - that involve specific geometries volumes congestion ventilation? This study has been carried out in the framework of PRHyVATE JIP project which aims at better understanding hydrogen build-up and distribution in a private garage. The investigation went through different rates and modes of ventilation. As first step an HAZID (Hazard Identification) has been realized for a generic FCEV. This preliminary work allowed to select and prioritize accidental release scenarios to be explored experimentally with helium in a 40-m3 garage. Several configurations of release ventilation modes and congestion – in transient regime and at steady state – have been tested. Then analytical and numerical calculation approaches have been applied and adjusted to develop a simplified methodology. This methodology takes into account natural ventilation for assessment of hydrogen accumulation and mitigation means optimization. Finally a global risk evaluation – including ignition of a flammable hydrogen-air mixture – has been performed to account for the mostly feared events and to evaluate their consequences in a private garage. Thus preliminary recommendations good practices and safety features for safely parking FCEVs in private garages can be proposed.
Just Energy Transition: Learning from the Past for a More Just and Sustainable Hydrogen Transition in West Africa
Dec 2022
Publication
The rising demand for energy and the aim of moving away from fossil fuels and to low-carbon power have led many countries to move to alternative sources including solar energy wind geothermal energy biomass and hydrogen. Hydrogen is often considered a “missing link” in guaranteeing the energy transition providing storage and covering the volatility and intermittency of renewable energy generation. However due to potential injustice with regard to the distribution of risks benefits and costs (i.e. in regard to competing for land use) the large-scale deployment of hydrogen is a contested policy issue. This paper draws from a historical analysis of past energy projects to contribute to a more informed policy-making process toward a more just transition to the hydrogen economy. We perform a systematic literature review to identify relevant conflict factors that can influence the outcome of hydrogen energy transition projects in selected Economic Community of West African States countries namely Nigeria and Mali. To better address potential challenges policymakers must not only facilitate technology development access and market structures for hydrogen energy policies but also focus on energy access to affected communities. Further research should monitor hydrogen implementation with a special focus on societal impacts in producing countries.
Simulation of Hydrogen Mixing and Par Operation During Accidental Release in an LH2 Carrier Engine Room
Sep 2021
Publication
Next-generation LH2 carriers may use the boil-off gas from the cargo tanks as additional fuel for the engine. As a consequence hydrogen pipes will enter the room of the ship’s propulsion system and transport hydrogen to the main engine. The hydrogen distribution resulting from a postulated hydrogen leak inside the room of the propulsion system has been analyzed by means of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). In a subsequent step simulations with passive auto-catalytic recombiners (PARs) were carried out in order to investigate if the recombiners can increase the safety margins during such accident scenarios. CFD enables a 3D prediction of the transient distribution with a high resolution allowing to identify local accumulation of hydrogen and consequently to identify optimal PAR positions as well as to demonstrate the efficiency of the PARs. The simulation of the unmitigated reference case reveals a strong natural circulation driven by the density difference of hydrogen and the incoming cold air from the ventilation system. Globally this natural circulation dilutes the hydrogen and removes a considerable amount from the room of the ship’s propulsion system via the ventilation ducts. However a hydrogen accumulation beyond the flammability limit is identified below the first ceiling above the leak position and the back-side wall of the engine room. Based on these findings suitable positions for recombiners were identified. The design objectives of the PAR system were on the one hand to provide both high instantaneous and integral removal rate and on the other hand to limit build-up of flammable clouds by means of depletion and PAR induced mixing processes. The simulations performed with three different PAR arrangements (variation of large and<br/>small PAR units at different positions) confirm that the PARs reduce efficiently the hydrogen<br/>accumulations.
Effect of Heat Transfer through the Release of Pipe on Simulations of Cryogenic Hydrogen Jet Fires and Hazard Distances
Sep 2021
Publication
Jet flames originated by cryo-compressed ignited hydrogen releases can cause life-threatening conditions in their surroundings. Validated models are needed to accurately predict thermal hazards from a jet fire. Numerical simulations of cryogenic hydrogen flow in the release pipe are performed to assess the effect of heat transfer through the pipe walls on jet parameters. Notional nozzle exit diameter is calculated based on the simulated real nozzle parameters and used in CFD simulations as a boundary condition to model jet fires. The CFD model was previously validated against experiments with vertical cryogenic hydrogen jet fires with release pressures up to 0.5 MPa (abs) release diameter 1.25 mm and temperatures as low as 50 K. This study validates the CFD model in a wider domain of experimental release conditions - horizontal cryogenic jets at exhaust pipe temperature 80 K pressure up to 2 MPa abs and release diameters up to 4 mm. Simulation results are compared against experimentally measured parameters as hydrogen mass flow rate flame length and radiative heat flux at several locations from the jet fire. The CFD model reproduces well experiments with reasonable engineering accuracy. Jet fire hazard distances established using three different criteria - temperature thermal radiation and thermal dose - are compared and discussed based on CFD simulation results.
Hydrogen Research: Technology First, Society Second?
Jul 2021
Publication
Hydrogen futures are in the making right in front of our eyes and will determine socio-ecological path dependencies for decades to come. However expertise on the societal effects of the hydrogen transition is in its infancy. Future energy research needs to include the social sciences humanities and interdisciplinary studies: energy cultures have to be examined as well as power relations and anticipation processes since the need for (green) hydrogen is likely to require a massive expansion of renewable energy plants.
Economically Viable Large-scale Hydrogen Liquefaction
Mar 2016
Publication
The liquid hydrogen demand particularly driven by clean energy applications will rise in the near future. As industrial large scale liquefiers will play a major role within the hydrogen supply chain production capacity will have to increase by a multiple of today’s typical sizes. The main goal is to reduce the total cost of ownership for these plants by increasing energy efficiency with innovative and simple process designs optimized in capital expenditure. New concepts must ensure a manageable plant complexity and flexible operability. In the phase of process development and selection a dimensioning of key equipment for large scale liquefiers such as turbines and compressors as well as heat exchangers must be performed iteratively to ensure technological feasibility and maturity. Further critical aspects related to hydrogen liquefaction e.g. fluid properties ortho-para hydrogen conversion and coldbox configuration must be analysed in detail. This paper provides an overview on the approach challenges and preliminary results in the development of efficient as well as economically viable concepts for large-scale hydrogen liquefaction.
On Capital Utilization in the Hydrogen Economy: The Quest to Minimize Idle Capacity in Renewables-rich Energy Systems
Oct 2020
Publication
The hydrogen economy is currently experiencing a surge in attention partly due to the possibility of absorbing variable renewable energy (VRE) production peaks through electrolysis. A fundamental challenge with this approach is low utilization rates of various parts of the integrated electricity-hydrogen system. To assess the importance of capacity utilization this paper introduces a novel stylized numerical energy system model incorporating the major elements of electricity and hydrogen generation transmission and storage including both “green” hydrogen from electrolysis and “blue” hydrogen from natural gas reforming with CO2 capture and storage (CCS). Concurrent optimization of all major system elements revealed that balancing VRE with electrolysis involves substantial additional costs beyond reduced electrolyzer capacity factors. Depending on the location of electrolyzers greater capital expenditures are also required for hydrogen pipelines and storage infrastructure (to handle intermittent hydrogen production) or electricity transmission networks (to transmit VRE peaks to electrolyzers). Blue hydrogen scenarios face similar constraints. High VRE shares impose low utilization rates of CO2 capture transport and storage infrastructure for conventional CCS and of hydrogen transmission and storage infrastructure for a novel process (gas switching reforming) that enables flexible power and hydrogen production. In conclusion all major system elements must be considered to accurately reflect the costs of using hydrogen to integrate higher VRE shares.
A Study on Electrofuels in Aviation
Feb 2018
Publication
With the growth of aviation traffic and the demand for emission reduction alternative fuels like the so-called electrofuels could comprise a sustainable solution. Electrofuels are understood as those that use renewable energy for fuel synthesis and that are carbon-neutral with respect to greenhouse gas emission. In this study five potential electrofuels are discussed with respect to the potential application as aviation fuels being n-octane methanol methane hydrogen and ammonia and compared to conventional Jet A-1 fuel. Three important aspects are illuminated. Firstly the synthesis process of the electrofuel is described with its technological paths its energy efficiency and the maturity or research need of the production. Secondly the physico-chemical properties are compared with respect to specific energy energy density as well as those properties relevant to the combustion of the fuels i.e. autoignition delay time adiabatic flame temperature laminar flame speed and extinction strain rate. Results show that the physical and combustion properties significantly differ from jet fuel except for n-octane. The results describe how the different electrofuels perform with respect to important aspects such as fuel and air mass flow rates. In addition the results help determine mixture properties of the exhaust gas for each electrofuel. Thirdly a turbine configuration is investigated at a constant operating point to further analyze the drop-in potential of electrofuels in aircraft engines. It is found that electrofuels can generally substitute conventional kerosene-based fuels but have some downsides in the form of higher structural loads and potentially lower efficiencies. Finally a preliminary comparative evaluation matrix is developed. It contains specifically those fields for the different proposed electrofuels where special challenges and problematic points are seen that need more research for potential application. Synthetically-produced n-octane is seen as a potential candidate for a future electrofuel where even a drop-in capability is given. For the other fuels more issues need further research to allow the application as electrofuels in aviation. Specifically interesting could be the combination of hydrogen with ammonia in the far future; however the research is just at the beginning stage.
A Novel Emergency Gas-to-Power System Based on an Efficient and Long-Lasting Solid-State Hydride Storage System: Modeling and Experimental Validation
Jan 2022
Publication
In this paper a gas-to-power (GtoP) system for power outages is digitally modeled and experimentally developed. The design includes a solid-state hydrogen storage system composed of TiFeMn as a hydride forming alloy (6.7 kg of alloy in five tanks) and an air-cooled fuel cell (maximum power: 1.6 kW). The hydrogen storage system is charged under room temperature and 40 bar of hydrogen pressure reaching about 110 g of hydrogen capacity. In an emergency use case of the system hydrogen is supplied to the fuel cell and the waste heat coming from the exhaust air of the fuel cell is used for the endothermic dehydrogenation reaction of the metal hydride. This GtoP system demonstrates fast stable and reliable responses providing from 149 W to 596 W under different constant as well as dynamic conditions. A comprehensive and novel simulation approach based on a network model is also applied. The developed model is validated under static and dynamic power load scenarios demonstrating excellent agreement with the experimental results.
Guidelines and Recommendations for Indoor Use of Fuel Cells and Hydrogen Systems
Oct 2015
Publication
Deborah Houssin-Agbomson,
Simon Jallais,
Elena Vyazmina,
Guy Dang-Nhu,
Gilles Bernard-Michel,
Mike Kuznetsov,
Vladimir V. Molkov,
Boris Chernyavsky,
Volodymyr V. Shentsov,
Dmitry Makarov,
Randy Dey,
Philip Hooker,
Daniele Baraldi,
Evelyn Weidner,
Daniele Melideo,
Valerio Palmisano,
Alexandros G. Venetsanos,
Jan Der Kinderen and
Béatrice L’Hostis
Hydrogen energy applications often require that systems are used indoors (e.g. industrial trucks for materials handling in a warehouse facility fuel cells located in a room or hydrogen stored and distributed from a gas cabinet). It may also be necessary or desirable to locate some hydrogen system components/equipment inside indoor or outdoor enclosures for security or safety reasons to isolate them from the end-user and the public or from weather conditions.<br/>Using of hydrogen in confined environments requires detailed assessments of hazards and associated risks including potential risk prevention and mitigation features. The release of hydrogen can potentially lead to the accumulation of hydrogen and the formation of a flammable hydrogen-air mixture or can result in jet-fires. Within Hyindoor European Project carried out for the EU Fuel Cells and Hydrogen Joint Undertaking safety design guidelines and engineering tools have been developed to prevent and mitigate hazardous consequences of hydrogen release in confined environments. Three main areas are considered: Hydrogen release conditions and accumulation vented deflagrations jet fires and including under-ventilated flame regimes (e.g. extinguishment or oscillating flames and steady burns). Potential RCS recommendations are also identified.
Venting Deflagrations of Local Hydrogen-air Mixture
Oct 2015
Publication
The paper describes a lumped-parameter model for vented deflagrations of localised and layered fuel air mixtures. Theoretical model background is described to allow insight into the model development with focus on lean mixtures and overpressures significantly below 0.1 MPa for protection of low strength equipment and buildings. Phenomena leading to combustion augmentation was accounted based on conclusions of recent CFD studies. Technique to treat layered mixtures with concentration gradient is demonstrated. The model is validated against 25 vented deflagration experiments with lean non-uniform and layered hydrogen-air mixtures performed in Health and Safety Laboratory (UK) and Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (Germany).
Results of the Pre-normative Research Project PRESLHY for the Safe Use of Liquid Hydrogen
Sep 2021
Publication
Liquid hydrogen (LH2) compared to compressed gaseous hydrogen offers advantages for large-scale transport and storage of hydrogen with higher densities. Although the gas industry has good experience with LH2 only little experience is available for the new applications of LH2 as an energy carrier. Therefore the European FCH JU funded project PRESLHY conducted pre-normative research for the safe use of cryogenic LH2 in non-industrial settings. The central research consisted of a broad experimental program combined with analytical work modelling and simulations belonging to the three key phenomena of the accident chain: release and mixing ignition and combustion. The presented results improve the general understanding of the behavior of LH2 in accidents and provide some design guidelines and engineering tools for safer use of LH2. Recommendations for improvement of current international standards are derived.
Ab Initio Study of the Combined Effects of Alloying Elements and H on Grain Boundary Cohesion in Ferritic Steels
Mar 2019
Publication
Hydrogen enhanced decohesion is expected to play a major role in ferritic steels especially at grain boundaries. Here we address the effects of some common alloying elements C V Cr and Mn on the H segregation behaviour and the decohesion mechanism at a Σ5(310)[001] 36.9∘ grain boundary in bcc Fe using spin polarized density functional theory calculations. We find that V Cr and Mn enhance grain boundary cohesion. Furthermore all elements have an influence on the segregation energies of the interstitial elements as well as on these elements’ impact on grain boundary cohesion. V slightly promotes segregation of the cohesion enhancing element C. However none of the elements increase the cohesion enhancing effect of C and reduce the detrimental effect of H on interfacial cohesion at the same time. At an interface which is co-segregated with C H and a substitutional element C and H show only weak interaction and the highest work of separation is obtained when the substitute is Mn.
The Merit and the Context of Hydrogen Production from Water and Its Effect on Global CO2 Emission
Feb 2022
Publication
For a green economy to be possible in the near future hydrogen production from water is a sought-after alternative to fossil fuels. It is however important to put things into context with respect to global CO2 emission and the role of hydrogen in curbing it. The present world annual production of hydrogen is about 70 million metric tons of which almost 50% is used to make ammonia NH3 (that is mostly used for fertilizers) and about 15% is used for other chemicals [1]. The hydrogen produced worldwide is largely made by steam CH4 reforming (SMR) which is one of the most energy-intensive processes in the chemical industry [2]. It releases based on reaction stoichiometry 5.5 kg of CO2 per 1 kg of H2 (CH4+ 2 H2O → CO2 + 4 H2). When the process itself is taken into account in addition the production [3] becomes about 9 kg of CO2 per kg of H2 and this ratio can be as high as 12 [4]. This results in the production of about one billion tons/year of CO2. The world annual CO2 emission from fossil fuels is however much larger: it is about 36 billion tons of which roughly 25% is emitted while generating electricity and heat 20% due to transport activity and 20% from other industrial processes. Because of the link between global warming and CO2 emissions there is an increasing move towards finding alternative approaches for energy vectors and their applications.
Synthesis and Characterisation of Platinum-cobalt-manganese Ternary Alloy Catalysts Supported on Carbon Nanofibers: An Alternative Catalyst for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction
Mar 2020
Publication
A systematic method for obtaining a novel electrode structure based on PtCoMn ternary alloy catalyst supported on graphitic carbon nanofibers (CNF) for hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) in acidic media is proposed. Ternary alloy nanoparticles (Co0.6Mn0.4 Pt) with a mean crystallite diameter under 10 nm were electrodeposited onto a graphitic support material using a two-step pulsed deposition technique. Initially a surface functionalisation of the carbon nanofibers is performed with the aid of oxygen plasma. Subsequently a short galvanostatic pulse electrodeposition technique is applied. It has been demonstrated that if pulsing current is employed compositionally controlled PtCoMn catalysts can be achieved. Variations of metal concentration ratios in the electrolyte and main deposition parameters such as current density and pulse shape led to electrodes with relevant catalytic activity towards HER. The samples were further characterised using several physico-chemical methods to reveal their morphology structure chemical and electrochemical properties. X-ray diffraction confirms the PtCoMn alloy formation on the graphitic support and energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy highlights the presence of the three metallic components from the alloy structure. The preliminary tests regarding the electrocatalytic activity of the developed electrodes display promising results compared to commercial Pt/C catalysts. The PtCoMn/CNF electrode exhibits a decrease in hydrogen evolution overpotential of about 250 mV at 40 mA cm−2 in acidic solution (0.5 M H2SO4) when compared to similar platinum based electrodes (Pt/CNF) and a Tafel slope of around 120 mV dec−1 indicating that HER takes place under the Volmer-Heyrovsky mechanismm
Role of Hydrogen in a Low-Carbon Electric Power System: A Case Study
Jan 2021
Publication
The European Union set a 2050 decarbonization target in the Paris Agreement to reduce carbon emissions by 90–95% relative to 1990 emission levels. The path toward achieving those deep decarbonization targets can take various shapes but will surely include a portfolio of economy-wide low-carbon energy technologies/options. The growth of the intermittent renewable power sources in the grid mix has helped reduce the carbon footprint of the electric power sector. Under the need for decarbonizing the electric power sector we simulated a low-carbon power system. We investigated the role of hydrogen for future electric power systems under current cost projections. The model optimizes the power generation mix economically for a given carbon constraint. The generation mix consists of intermittent renewable power sources (solar and wind) and dispatchable gas turbine and combined cycle units fuelled by natural gas with carbon capture and sequestration as well as hydrogen. We created several scenarios with battery storage options pumped hydro hydrogen storage and demand-side response (DSR). The results show that energy storage replaces power generation and pumped hydro entirely replaces battery storage under given conditions. The availability of pumped hydro storage and demand-side response reduced the total cost as well as the combination of solar photovoltaic and pumped hydro storage. Demand-side response reduces relatively costly dispatchable power generation reduces annual power generation halves the shadow carbon price and is a viable alternative to energy storage. The carbon constrain defines the generation mix and initializes the integration of hydrogen (H2). Although the model rates power to gas with hydrogen as not economically viable in this power system under the given conditions and assumptions hydrogen is important for hard-to-abate sectors and enables sector coupling in a real energy system. This study discusses the potential for hydrogen beyond this model approach and shows the differences between cost optimization models and real-world feasibility.
The Impact of Hydrogen on Mechanical Properties; A New In Situ Nanoindentation Testing Method
Feb 2019
Publication
We have designed a new method for electrochemical hydrogen charging which allows us to charge very thin coarse-grained specimens from the bottom and perform nanomechanical testing on the top. As the average grain diameter is larger than the thickness of the sample this setup allows us to efficiently evaluate the mechanical properties of multiple single crystals with similar electrochemical conditions. Another important advantage is that the top surface is not affected by corrosion by the electrolyte. The nanoindentation results show that hydrogen reduces the activation energy for homogenous dislocation nucleation by approximately 15–20% in a (001) grain. The elastic modulus also was observed to be reduced by the same amount. The hardness increased by approximately 4% as determined by load-displacement curves and residual imprint analysis.
Hydrogen-assisted Cracking of GMA Welded 960 & A Grade High-strength Steels
Jan 2020
Publication
High-strength steels with yield strength of 960 MPa are susceptible to hydrogen-assisted cracking (HAC) during welding processing. In the present paper the implant test is used to study HAC in a quenched and tempered steel S960QL and a high-strength steel produced by thermo-mechanical controlled process S960MC. Welding is performed using the gas-metal arc welding process. Furthermore diffusible hydrogen concentration (HD) in arc weld metal is determined. Based on the implant test results lower critical stress (LCS) for complete fracture critical implant stress (σkrit) for crack initiation and embrittlement index (EI) are determined. At HD of 1.66 ml/100 g LCS is 605 MPa and 817 MPa for S960QL and S960MC respectively. EI is 0.30 and 0.46 for S960QL and S960MC respectively. Fracture surfaces of S960QL show higher degradation with reduced deformation. Both higher EI of S960MC and fractography show better resistance to HAC in the HAZ of S960MC compared to S960QL.
Economic Optima for Buffers in Direct Reduction Steelmaking Under Increasing Shares of Renewable Hydrogen
Oct 2021
Publication
While current climate targets demand substantial reductions in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions the potentials to further reduce carbon dioxide emissions in traditional primary steel-making are limited. One possible solution that is receiving increasing attention is the direct reduction (DR) technology operated either with renewable hydrogen (H2) from electrolysis or with conventional natural gas (NG). DR technology makes it possible to decouple steel and hydrogen production by temporarily using overcapacities to produce and store intermediary products during periods of low renewable electricity prices or by switching between H2 and NG. This paper aims to explore the impact of this decoupling on overall costs and the corresponding dimensioning of production and storage capacities. An optimization model is developed to determine the least-cost operation based on perfect-foresight. This model can determine the minimum costs for optimal production and storage capacities under various assumptions considering fluctuating H2 and NG prices and increasing H2 shares. The model is applied to a case study for Germany and covers the current situation the medium term until 2030 and the long term until 2050. Under the assumptions made the role of using direct reduced iron (DRI) storage as a buffer seems less relevant. DRI mainly serves as long-term storage for several weeks similar to usual balancing storage capacities. Storing H2 on the contrary is used for short-term fluctuations and could balance H2 demand in the hourly range until 2050. From an economic perspective DRI production using NG tends to be cheaper than using H2 in the short term and potential savings from the flexible operation with storages are small at first. However in the long term until 2050 NG and H2 could achieve similar total costs if buffers are used. Otherwise temporarily occurring electricity price spikes imply substantial increases in total costs if high shares of H2 need to be achieved.
Technologies and Policies to Decarbonize Global Industry: Review and Assessment of Mitigation Drivers Through 2070
Mar 2020
Publication
Jeffrey Rissman,
Chris Bataille,
Eric Masanet,
Nate Aden,
William R. Morrow III,
Nan Zhou,
Neal Elliott,
Rebecca Dell,
Niko Heeren,
Brigitta Huckestein,
Joe Cresko,
Sabbie A. Miller,
Joyashree Roy,
Paul Fennell,
Betty Cremmins,
Thomas Koch Blank,
David Hone,
Ellen D. Williams,
Stephane de la Rue du Can,
Bill Sisson,
Mike Williams,
John Katzenberger,
Dallas Burtraw,
Girish Sethi,
He Ping,
David Danielson,
Hongyou Lu,
Tom Lorber,
Jens Dinkel and
Jonas Helseth
Fully decarbonizing global industry is essential to achieving climate stabilization and reaching net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050–2070 is necessary to limit global warming to 2 °C. This paper assembles and evaluates technical and policy interventions both on the supply side and on the demand side. It identifies measures that employed together can achieve net zero industrial emissions in the required timeframe. Key supply-side technologies include energy efficiency (especially at the system level) carbon capture electrification and zero-carbon hydrogen as a heat source and chemical feedstock. There are also promising technologies specific to each of the three top-emitting industries: cement iron & steel and chemicals & plastics. These include cement admixtures and alternative chemistries several technological routes for zero-carbon steelmaking and novel chemical catalysts and separation technologies. Crucial demand-side approaches include material-efficient design reductions in material waste substituting low-carbon for high-carbon materials and circular economy interventions (such as improving product longevity reusability ease of refurbishment and recyclability). Strategic well-designed policy can accelerate innovation and provide incentives for technology deployment. High-value policies include carbon pricing with border adjustments or other price signals; robust government support for research development and deployment; and energy efficiency or emissions standards. These core policies should be supported by labeling and government procurement of low-carbon products data collection and disclosure requirements and recycling incentives. In implementing these policies care must be taken to ensure a just transition for displaced workers and affected communities. Similarly decarbonization must complement the human and economic development of low- and middle-income countries.
Life Cycle Assessments on Battery Electric Vehicles and Electrolytic Hydrogen: The Need for Calculation Rules and Better Databases on Electricity
May 2021
Publication
LCAs of electric cars and electrolytic hydrogen production are governed by the consumption of electricity. Therefore LCA benchmarking is prone to choices on electricity data. There are four issues: (1) leading Life Cycle Impact (LCI) databases suffer from inconvenient uncertainties and inaccuracies (2) electricity mix in countries is rapidly changing year after year (3) the electricity mix is strongly fluctuating on an hourly and daily basis which requires time-based allocation approaches and (4) how to deal with nuclear power in benchmarking. This analysis shows that: (a) the differences of the GHG emissions of the country production mix in leading databases are rather high (30%) (b) in LCA a distinction must be made between bundled and unbundled registered electricity certificates (RECs) and guarantees of origin (GOs); the residual mix should not be applied in LCA because of its huge inaccuracy (c) time-based allocation rules for renewables are required to cope with periods of overproduction (d) benchmarking of electricity is highly affected by the choice of midpoints and/or endpoint systems and (e) there is an urgent need for a new LCI database based on measured emission data continuously kept up-to-date transparent and open access.
Transient Reversible Solid Oxide Cell Reactor Operation – Experimentally Validated Modeling and Analysis
Oct 2018
Publication
A reversible solid oxide cell (rSOC) reactor can operate efficiently in both electrolysis mode and in fuel cell mode. The bidirectional operability enables rSOC reactors to play a central role as an efficient energy conversion system for energy storage and sector coupling for a renewable energy driven society. A combined system for electrolysis and fuel cell operation can result in complex system configurations that should be able to switch between the two modes as quickly as possible. This can lead to temperature profiles within the reactor that can potentially lead to the failure of the reactor and eventually the system. Hence the behavior of the reactor during the mode switch should be analyzed and optimal transition strategies should be taken into account during the process system design stage. In this paper a one dimensional transient reversible solid oxide cell model was built and experimentally validated using a commercially available reactor. A simple hydrogen based system model was built employing the validated reactor model to study reactor behavior during the mode switch. The simple design leads to a system efficiency of 49% in fuel cell operation and 87% in electrolysis operation where the electrolysis process is slightly endothermic. Three transient operation strategies were studied. It is shown that the voltage response to transient operation is very fast provided the reactant flows are changed equally fast. A possible solution to ensure a safe mode switch by controlling the reactant inlet temperatures is presented. By keeping the rate of change of reactant inlet temperatures five to ten times slower than the mode switch a safe transition can be ensured.
Future Costs of Hydrogen: A Quantitative Review
Mar 2024
Publication
Hydrogen is the key energy carrier of the future. Numerous industrial processes incorporate hydrogen in their transformation towards climate neutrality. To date the high cost of producing hydrogen from renewable sources has been a major barrier to its widespread adoption. Inspired by these two aspects many researchers have published cost predictions for hydrogen. This review provides an overview of the extant literature of more than 7000 publications in the last two decades concerned with the topic. After removing articles that do not provide explicit hydrogen production cost projections for the 2020 to 2050 time horizon 89 articles remain and are analyzed in detail. The review identifies 832 cost forecast data points among these studies and categorizes the data points according to various parameters such as production region production process and publication year of the study. Through a linear regression a main trajectory for the development of hydrogen production costs can be derived. The costs of hydrogen from electrolysis are reduced on the basis of this trajectory starting from the reference 5.3 V per kg in 2020 to 4.4 V per kg in 2030 and to 2.7 V per kg in 2050. The costs for natural gas-based hydrogen are almost constant on a globally aggregated basis. There are also major regional and processrelated differences. In 2050 Asia has the lowest average costs of the regions analyzed at 1.8 V per kg and production by alkaline electrolysis with average costs of 2.0 V per kg appears to be the most costeffective electrolysis technology. Although studies show a high degree of variation it is evident from this review that the trend within certain investigation parameters is well defined. Therefore researchers and practitioners can use this review to set up further analyses that depend on future hydrogen costs.
Linking the Power and Transport Sectors—Part 2: Modelling a Sector Coupling Scenario for Germany
Jul 2017
Publication
“Linking the power and transport sectors—Part 1” describes the general principle of “sector coupling” (SC) develops a working definition intended of the concept to be of utility to the international scientific community contains a literature review that provides an overview of relevant scientific papers on this topic and conducts a rudimentary analysis of the linking of the power and transport sectors on a worldwide EU and German level. The aim of this follow-on paper is to outline an approach to the modelling of SC. Therefore a study of Germany as a case study was conducted. This study assumes a high share of renewable energy sources (RES) contributing to the grid and significant proportion of fuel cell vehicles (FCVs) in the year 2050 along with a dedicated hydrogen pipeline grid to meet hydrogen demand. To construct a model of this nature the model environment “METIS” (models for energy transformation and integration systems) we developed will be described in more detail in this paper. Within this framework a detailed model of the power and transport sector in Germany will be presented in this paper and the rationale behind its assumptions described. Furthermore an intensive result analysis for the power surplus utilization of electrolysis hydrogen pipeline and economic considerations has been conducted to show the potential outcomes of modelling SC. It is hoped that this will serve as a basis for researchers to apply this framework in future to models and analysis with an international focus.
Monte-Carlo-Analysis of Minimum Burst Requirements for Composite Cylinders for Hydrogen Service
Sep 2021
Publication
For achieving Net Zero-aims hydrogen is an indispensable component probably the main component. For the usage of hydrogen a wide acceptance is necessary which requires trust in hydrogen based on absence of major incidents resulting from a high safety level. Burst tests stand for a type of testing that is used in every test standard and regulation as one of the key issues for ensuring safety in use. The central role of burst and proof test is grown to historical reasons for steam engines and steel vessels but - with respect for composite pressure vessels (CPVs) - not due an extraordinary depth of outcomes. Its importance results from the relatively simple test process with relatively low costs and gets its importance by running of the different test variations in parallel. In relevant test und production standards (as e. g. ECE R134) the burst test is used in at least 4 different meanings. There is the burst test on a) new CPVs and some others b) for determining the residual strength subsequent to various simulations of ageing effects. Both are performed during the approval process on a pre-series. Then there is c) the batch testing during the CPVs production and finally d) the 100% proof testing which means to stop the burst test at a certain pressure level. These different aspects of burst tests are analysed and compared with respect to its importance for the resulting safety of the populations of CPVs in service based on experienced test results and Monte-Carlo simulations. As main criterial for this the expected failure rate in a probabilistic meaning is used. This finally ends up with recommendations for relevant RC&S especially with respect to GTR 13."
Cost-optimized Design Point and Operating Strategy of Polymer Electrolyte Membrane Electrolyzers
Nov 2022
Publication
Green hydrogen is a key solution for reducing CO2 emissions in various industrial applications but high production costs continue to hinder its market penetration today. Better competitiveness is linked to lower investment costs and higher efficiency of the conversion technologies among which polymer electrolyte membrane electrolysis seems to be attractive. Although new manufacturing techniques and materials can help achieve these goals a less frequently investigated approach is the optimization of the design point and operating strategy of electrolyzers. This means in particular that the questions of how often a system should be operated and which cell voltage should be applied must be answered. As existing techno-economic models feature gaps which means that these questions cannot be adequately answered a modified model is introduced here. In this model different technical parameters are implemented and correlated to each other in order to simulate the lowest possible levelized cost of hydrogen and extract the required designs and strategies from this. In each case investigated the recommended cost-based cell voltage that should be applied to the system is surprisingly low compared to the assumptions made in previous publications. Depending on the case the cell voltage is in a range between 1.6 V and 1.8 V with an annual operation of 2000e8000 h. The wide range of results clearly indicate how individual the design and operation must be but with efficiency gains of several percent the effect of optimization will be indispensable in the future.
Thermodynamic and Ecological Preselection of Synthetic Fuel Intermediates from Biogas at Farm Sites
Jan 2020
Publication
Background: Synthetic fuels based on renewable hydrogen and CO2 are a currently highly discussed piece of the puzzle to defossilize the transport sector. In this regard CO2 can play a positive role in shaping a sustainable future. Large potentials are available as a product of biogas production however occurring in small scales and in thin spatial distributions. This work aims to evaluate suitable synthetic fuel products to be produced at farm sites.<br/>Methods: A thermodynamic analysis to assess the energetic efficiency of synthesis pathways and a qualitative assessment of product handling issues is carried out.<br/>Results: Regarding the technical and safety-related advantages in storage liquid products are the superior option for fuel production at decentralized sites. Due to the economy of scale multi-stage synthesis processes lose economic performance with rising complexity. A method was shown which covers a principle sketch of all necessary reaction separation steps and all compression and heat exchanger units. The figures showed that methanol and butanol are the most suitable candidates in contrast to OME3-5 for implementation in existing transportation and fuel systems. These results were underpin by a Gibbs energy analysis.<br/>Conclusions: As long as safety regulations are met and the farm can guarantee safe storage and transport farm-site production for all intermediates can be realized technically. Ultimately this work points out that the process must be kept as simple as possible favoring methanol production at farm site and its further processing to more complicated fuels in large units for several fuel pathways.
No more items...