Safety
Risk Sensitivity Study as the Basis for Risk-informed Consequence-based Setback Distances for Liquid Hydrogen Storage Systems
Sep 2023
Publication
A quantitative risk assessment on a representative liquid hydrogen storage system was performed to identify the main drivers of individual risk and provide a technical basis for revised separation distances for bulk liquid hydrogen storage systems in regulations codes and standards requirements. The framework in the Hydrogen Plus Other Alternative Fuels Risk Assessment Models (HyRAM+) toolkit was used and multiple relevant inputs to the risk assessment (e.g. system pipe size ignition probabilities) were individually varied. For each set of risk assessment inputs the individual risk as a function of the distance away from the release point was determined and the risk-based separation distance was determined from an acceptable risk criterion. These risk-based distances were then converted to equivalent leak size using consequence models that would result in the same distance to selected hazard criteria (i.e. extent of flammable cloud heat flux and peak overpressure). The leak sizes were normalized to a fraction of the flow area of the source piping. The resulting equivalent fractional hole sizes for each sensitivity case were then used to inform selection of a conservative fractional flow area leak size of 5% that serves as the basis for consequence-based separation distance calculations. This work demonstrates a method for using a quantitative risk assessment sensitivity study to inform the selection of a basis for determining consequence-based separation distances.
Towards the Simulation of Hydrogen Leakage Scenarios in Closed Buildings Using ContainmentFOAM
Sep 2023
Publication
The increase of using hydrogen as a replacement for fossil fuels in power generation and mobility is expected to witness a huge leap in the next decades. However several safety issues arise due to the physical and chemical properties of hydrogen especially its wide range of flammability. In case of Hydrogen leakage in confined areas Hydrogen clouds can accumulate in the space and their concentration can build up quickly to reach the lower flammability limit (LFL) in case of not applying a proper ventilation system. As a part of the Living Lab Energy Campus (LLEC) project at Jülich Research Centre the use of hydrogen mixed with natural gas as a fuel for the central heating system of the campus is being studied. The current research aims to investigate the release dispersion and formation and the spread of a hydrogen cloud inside the central utility building at the campus of Jülich Research Centre in case of hypothetical accidental leakage. Such a leakage is simulated using the opensource containmentFoam package base on OpenFOAM CFD code to numerically simulate the behavior of the air-hydrogen mixture. The critical locations where hydrogen concentrations can reach the LFL values are shown.
A Review on Hydrogen Embrittlement and Risk-based Inspection of Hydrogen Technologies
May 2023
Publication
Hydrogen could gradually replace fossil fuels mitigating the human impact on the environment. However equipment exposed to hydrogen is subjected to damaging effects due to H2 absorption and permeation through metals. Hence inspection activities are necessary to preserve the physical integrity of the containment systems and the risk-based (RBI) methodology is considered the most beneficial approach. This review aims to provide relevant information regarding hydrogen embrittlement its effect on materials’ properties and the synergistic interplay of the factors influencing its occurrence. Moreover an overview of predictive maintenance strategies is presented focusing on the RBI methodology. A systematic review was carried out to identify examples of the application of RBI to equipment exposed to hydrogenated environments and to identify the most active research groups. In conclusion a significant lack of knowledge has been highlighted along with difficulties in applying the RBI methodology for equipment operating in a pure hydrogen environment.
A Computational Study of Hydrogen Dispersion and Explosion after Large-Scale Leakage of Liquid Hydrogen
Nov 2023
Publication
This study employs the FLACS code to analyze hydrogen leakage vapor dispersion and subsequent explosions. Utilizing pseudo-source models a liquid pool model and a hybrid model combining both we investigate dispersion processes for varying leak mass flow rates (0.225 kg/s and 0.73 kg/s) in a large open space. We also evaluate explosion hazards based on overpressure and impulse effects on humans. The computational results compared with experimental data demonstrated reasonable hydrogen vapor cloud concentration predictions especially aligned with the wind direction. For higher mass flow rate of 0.73 kg/s the pseudo-source model exhibited the most reasonable predictive performance for locations near the leak source despite the hybrid model yielded similar results to the pseudo-source model while the liquid pool model was more suitable for lower mass flow rate of 0.225 kg/s. Regarding explosion analyses using overpressure-impulse diagram higher mass flow rates leaded to potentially fatal overpressure and impulse effects on humans. However lower mass flow rates may cause severe eardrum damage at the maximum overpressure point.
Perspective on the Development and Integration of Hydrogen Sensors for Fuel Cell Control
Oct 2024
Publication
The measurement of hydrogen concentration in fuel cell systems is an important prerequisite for the development of a control strategy to enhance system performance reduce purge losses and minimize fuel cell aging effects. In this perspective paper the working principles of hydrogen sensors are analyzed and their requirements for hydrogen control in fuel cell systems are critically discussed. The wide measurement range absence of oxygen high humidity and limited space turn out to be most limiting. A perspective on the development of hydrogen sensors based on palladium as a gas-sensitive metal and based on the organic magnetic field effect in organic lightemitting devices is presented. The design of a test chamber where the sensor response can easily be analyzed under fuel cell-like conditions is proposed. This allows the generation of practical knowledge for further sensor development. The presented sensors could be integrated into the end plate to measure the hydrogen concentration at the anode in- and outlet. Further miniaturization is necessary to integrate them into the flow field of the fuel cell to avoid fuel starvation in each single cell. Compressed sensing methods are used for more efficient data analysis. By using a dynamical sensor model control algorithms are applied with high frequency to control the hydrogen concentration the purge process and the recirculation pump.
Flame Acceleration, Detonation Limit and Heat Loss for Hydrogen-Oxygen Mixture at Cryogenic Temperature of 77 K
Sep 2023
Publication
Experiments are performed in hydrogen-oxygen mixtures at the cryogenic temperature of 77 K with the equivalence ratio of 1.5 and 2.0. The optical fibers pressure sensors and the smoked foils are used to record the flame velocity overpressure evolution curve and detonation cells respectively. The 1st and 2nd shock waves are captured and they finally merge to form a stronger precursor shock wave prior to the onset of detonation. The cryogenic temperature will cause the larger expansion ratio which results in the occurrence of strong flame acceleration. The stuttering mode the galloping mode and the deflagration mode are observed when the initial pressure decreases from 0.50 atm to 0.20 atm with the equivalence ratio of 1.5 and the detonation limit is within 0.25-0.30 atm. The heat loss effect on the detonation limit is analysed. In addition the regularity of detonation cell is investigated and the larger post-shock specific heat ratio !"" and the lower normalized activation energy # at lower initial pressure will cause the more regular detonation cell. Also the detonation cell width is predicted by a model of = ($) ⋅ Δ# and the prediction results are mainly consistent with the experimental results.
Analytical Model of Cryogenic Hydrogen Releases
Sep 2023
Publication
Hydrogen is one of the most promising alternative sources to relieve the energy crisis and environmental pollution. Hydrogen can be stored as cryogenic compressed hydrogen (CcH2) to achieve high volumetric energy densities. Reliable safety codes and standards are needed for hydrogen production delivery and storage to promote hydrogen commercialization. Unintended hydrogen releases from cryogenic storage systems are potential accident scenarios that are of great interest for updating safety codes and standards. This study investigated the behavior of CcH2 releases and dispersion. The extremely low-temperature CcH2 jets can cause condensation of the air components including water vapor nitrogen and oxygen. An integral model considering the condensation effects was developed to predict the CcH2 jet trajectories and concentration distributions. The thermophysical properties were obtained from the COOLPROP database. The model divides the CcH2 jet into the underexpanded initial entrainment and heating flow establishment and established flow zones. The condensation effects on the heat transfer and flow were included in the initial entrainment and heating zones. The empirical coefficients in the integral model were then modified based on measured concentration results. Finally the analytical model predictions are shown to compare well with measured data to verify the model accuracy. The present study can be used to develop quantitative risk assessment models and update safety codes and standards for cryogenic hydrogen facilities.
Numerical Study of Highly Turbulent Under-expanded Hydrogen Jet Flames Impinging Walls
Sep 2023
Publication
Heat flux on walls from under-expanded H2/AIR jet flames have been numerically investigated. The thermal behaviour of a plate close to different under-expanded jet flames has been compared with rear-face plate temperature measurements. In this study two straight nozzles with millimetric diameter were selected with H2 reservoir pressure in a range from 2 to 10 bar. The CFD study of these two quite different horizontal jet flames employs the Large Eddy Simulation (LES) formalism to capture the turbulent flame-wall interaction. The results demonstrated a good agreement with experimental wall heat fluxes computed from plate temperature measurements. The present study assesses the prediction capability of LES for flame-wall heat transfer.
Optimization of Emergency Alternatives for Hydrogen Leakage and Explosion Accidents Based on Improved VIKOR
Nov 2023
Publication
Hydrogen leakage and explosion accidents have obvious dangers ambiguity of accident information and urgency of decision-making time. These characteristics bring challenges to the optimization of emergency alternatives for such accidents. Effective emergency decision making is crucial to mitigating the consequences of accidents and minimizing losses and can provide a vital reference for emergency management in the field of hydrogen energy. An improved VIKOR emergency alternatives optimization method is proposed based on the combination of hesitant triangular fuzzy set (HTFS) and the cumulative prospect theory (CPT) termed the HTFS-CPT-VIKOR method. This method adopts the hesitant triangular fuzzy number to represent the decision information on the alternatives under the influence of multi-attributes constructs alternatives evaluation indicators and solves the indicator weights by using the deviation method. Based on CPT positive and negative ideal points were used as reference points to construct the prospect matrix which then utilized the VIKOR method to optimize the emergency alternatives for hydrogen leakage and explosion accidents. Taking an accident at a hydrogen refueling station as an example the effectiveness and rationality of the HTFS-CPT-VIKOR method were verified by comparing with the existing three methods and conducting parameter sensitivity analysis. Research results show that the HTFS-CPT-VIKOR method effectively captures the limited psychological behavior characteristics of decision makers and enhances their ability to identify filter and judge ambiguous information making the decisionmaking alternatives more in line with the actual environment which provided strong support for the optimization of emergency alternatives for hydrogen leakage and explosion accidents.
Validation of a Hydrogen Jet Fire Model in FDS
Sep 2023
Publication
Hydrogen jet fire occurs with high probability when hydrogen leaks from high-pressure equipment. The hydrogen jet fire is characterized by its high velocity and energy. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) numerical analysis is a prominent way to predict the potential hazards associated with hydrogen jet fire. Validation of the CFD model is essential to ensure and quantify the accuracy of numerical results. This study focuses on the validation of the hydrogen jet fire model using Fire Dynamic Simulation (FDS). Hydrogen release is modeled using high-speed Lagrangian particles released from a virtual nozzle thus avoiding the modeling of the actual nozzle. The mesh size sensitivity analysis of the model is carried out in a container-size domain with 0.04m – 0.08m resolution of the jet. The model is validated by comparing gas temperatures and heat fluxes with test data. The promising results demonstrated that the model could predict the hazardous influence of the jet fire.
Safety Risk and Strategy Analysis of On-Board Hydrogen System of Hydrogen Fuel Cell Vehicles in China
Nov 2023
Publication
Hydrogen fuel cell vehicles (HFCVs) represent an important breakthrough in the hydrogen energy industry. The safe utilization of hydrogen is critical for the sustainable and healthy development of hydrogen fuel cell vehicles. In this study risk factors and preventive measures are proposed for on-board hydrogen systems during the process of transportation storage and use of fuel cell vehicles. The relevant hydrogen safety standards in China are also analyzed and suggestions involving four safety strategies and three safety standards are proposed.
Artificial Intelligence-Driven Innovations in Hydrogen Safety
Jun 2024
Publication
This review explores recent advancements in hydrogen gas (H2 ) safety through the lens of artificial intelligence (AI) techniques. As hydrogen gains prominence as a clean energy source ensuring its safe handling becomes paramount. The paper critically evaluates the implementation of AI methodologies including artificial neural networks (ANN) machine learning algorithms computer vision (CV) and data fusion techniques in enhancing hydrogen safety measures. By examining the integration of wireless sensor networks and AI for real-time monitoring and leveraging CV for interpreting visual indicators related to hydrogen leakage issues this review highlights the transformative potential of AI in revolutionizing safety frameworks. Moreover it addresses key challenges such as the scarcity of standardized datasets the optimization of AI models for diverse environmental conditions etc. while also identifying opportunities for further research and development. This review foresees faster response times reduced false alarms and overall improved safety for hydrogen-related applications. This paper serves as a valuable resource for researchers engineers and practitioners seeking to leverage state-of-the-art AI technologies for enhanced hydrogen safety systems.
Experimental Characterization of the Operational Behavior of a Catalytic Recombiner for Hydrogen Mitigation
Sep 2023
Publication
One of the significant safety concerns in large-scale storage and transportation of liquefied (cryogenic) hydrogen (LH2) is the formation of flammable hydrogen/air mixtures after leakages during storage or transportation. Especially in maritime transportation hydrogen accumulations could occur within large and congested geometries. The installation of passive auto-catalytic recombiners (PARs) is a suitable mitigation measure for local areas where venting is insufficient or even impossible. Numerical models describing the operational behavior of PARs are required to allow for optimizing the location and assessing the efficiency of the mitigation measure. In the present study the operational behavior of a PAR with a compact design has been experimentally investigated. In order to obtain data for model validation an experimental program has been performed in the REKO-4 facility a 5.5 m³ vessel. The test procedure includes two phases steady-state and dynamic. The results provide insights into the hydrogen recombination rates and catalyst temperatures under different boundary conditions.
Simulations of Hydrogen Dispersion from Fuel Cell Vehicles' Leakages Inside Full-scale Tunnel
Sep 2023
Publication
In this work real scale experiments involving hydrogen dispersion inside a road tunnel have been modelled using the Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) methodology. The aim is to assess the performance of the ADREA-HF CFD tool against full-scale tunnel dispersion data resulting from high-pressure hydrogen leakage through Thermal Pressure Relief Device (TPRD) of a vehicle. The assessment was performed with the help of experiments conducted by the French Alternative Energies and Atomic Energy Commission (CEA) in a real inclined tunnel in France. In the experiments helium as hydrogen surrogate has been released from 200 bar storage pressure. Several tests were carried out examining different TPRD sizes and release directions (upwards and downwards). For the CFD evaluation two tests were considered: one with downwards and one with upwards release both through a TPRD with a diameter of 2 mm. The comparison between the CFD results and the experiments shows the good predictive capabilities of the ADREA-HF code that can be used as a safety tool in hydrogen dispersion studies. The comparison reveals some of the strengths and weaknesses of both the CFD and the experiments. It is made clear that CFD can contribute to the design of the experiments and to the interpretation of the experimental results.
CFD Analysis of Delayed Ignition Hydrogen Releases from a Train Inside a Tunnel
Sep 2023
Publication
In the present work we present the results of numerical simulations involving the dispersion and combustion of a hydrogen cloud released in an empty tunnel. The simulations were conducted with the use of ADREA-HF CFD code and the results are compared with measurements from experiments conducted by HSE in a tunnel with the exact same geometry. The length of the tunnel is equal to 70 m and the maximum height from the floor is equal to 3.25 m. Hydrogen release is considered to occur from a train containing pressurized hydrogen stored at 580 bars. The release diameter is equal to 4.7 mm and the release direction is upwards. Initially dispersion simulation was performed in order to define the initial conditions for the deflagration simulations. The effect of the initial wind speed and the effect of the ignition delay time were investigated. An extensive grid sensitivity study was conducted in order to achieve grid independent results. The CFD model takes into account the flame instabilities that are developed as the flame propagates inside the tunnel and turbulence that exists in front of the flame front. Pressure predictions are compared against experimental measurements revealing a very good performance of the CFD model.
Instances of Safety-Related Advances in Hydrogen as Regards Its Gaseous Transport and Buffer Storage and Its Solid-State Storage
Jul 2024
Publication
As part of the ongoing transition from fossil fuels to renewable energies advances are particularly expected in terms of safe and cost-effective solutions. Publicising instances of such advances and emphasising global safety considerations constitute the rationale for this communication. Knowing that high-strength steels can prove economically relevant in the foreseeable future for transporting hydrogen in pipelines by limiting the pipe wall thickness required to withstand high pressure one advance relates to a bench designed to assess the safe transport or renewableenergy-related buffer storage of hydrogen gas. That bench has been implemented at the technology readiness level TRL 6 to test initially intact damaged or pre-notched 500 mm-long pipe sections with nominal diameters ranging from 300 to 900 mm in order to appropriately validate or question the use of reputedly satisfactory predictive models in terms of hydrogen embrittlement and potential corollary failure. The other advance discussed herein relates to the reactivation of a previously fruitful applied research into safe mass solid-state hydrogen storage by magnesium hydride through a new public–private partnership. This latest development comes at a time when markets have started driving the hydrogen economy bearing in mind that phase-change materials make it possible to level out heat transfers during the absorption/melting and solidification/desorption cycles and to attain an overall energy efficiency of up to 80% for MgH2 -based compacts doped with expanded natural graphite.
Proactive Emergency Response Strategies for First Responders to Hydrogen Gas Leakages in Vehicles
Feb 2024
Publication
The widespread use of fossil fuels in automobiles has become a concern particularly in light of recent frequent natural disasters prompting a shift towards eco-friendly vehicles to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions. This shift is evident in the rapidly increasing registration rates of hydrogen vehicles. However with the growing presence of hydrogen vehicles on roads a corresponding rise in related accidents is anticipated posing new challenges for first responders. In this study computational fluid dynamics analysis was performed to develop effective response strategies for first responders dealing with high-pressure hydrogen gas leaks in vehicle accidents. The analysis revealed that in the absence of blower intervention a vapor cloud explosion from leaked hydrogen gas could generate overpressure exceeding 13.8 kPa potentially causing direct harm to first responders. In the event of a hydrogen vehicle accident requiring urgent rescue activities the appropriate response strategy must be selected. The use of blowers can aid in developing a variety of strategies by reducing the risk of a vapor cloud explosion. Consequently this study offers a tailored response strategy for first responders in hydrogen vehicle leak scenarios emphasizing the importance of situational assessment at the incident site.
Safety Calculations for Emerging Technologies
Sep 2023
Publication
As part of executing 25 hydrogen-based Power to X (PtX) projects our team of Safety consultants has completed safety and risk assessments for a number of hydrogen production developments. Drawing on this experience we will present the importance of making comparisons between hydrogen specific data sources such as HyRAM and conventional oil and gas data sets and calculation methods to ensure that project design is carried out to the most appropriate data and provides a robust solution to demonstrate risks are managed. This presentation will be based on case studies where Fire and Explosion Risk Assessments (FERA) and Quantitative Risk Assessments (QRA) were conducted. The frequency calculations for these assessments used the release frequencies and ignition probabilities provided in HyRAM. However it is noted that the HyRAM ignition probabilities are derived from a correlation from oil and gas assessments in the 1990s. The oil and gas approach has moved on from this data source and now derives ignition probabilities based on the type of facility and fluid characteristics. To address this evolution a comparison was made between the leak frequencies for equipment in hydrogen service and established oil and gas release frequencies from IOGP. In addition a comparison between the HyRAM recommended ignition probabilities and the correlations used for oil and gas (from OEUK formerly UKOOA) was conducted. By taking this approach it was confirmed that the UKOOA data was more conservative and sensitivity calculations were carried out. It was also noted that as hydrogen technologies are emerging there is a level of uncertainty around the data and comparisons must be regularly made to ensure the most appropriate basis for calculations is used.
Visualisation and Quantification of Wind-induced Variability in Hydrogen Clouds Following Releases of Liquid Hydrogen
Sep 2023
Publication
Well characterized experimental data for consequence model validation is important in progressing the use of liquid hydrogen as an energy carrier. In 2019 the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) undertook a series of liquid hydrogen dispersion and combustion experiments as a part of the Pre-normative Research for Safe Use of Liquid Hydrogen (PRESLHY) project. In partnership between the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) and HSE time and spatially varying hydrogen concentration measurements were made in 25 dispersion experiments and 23 congested ignition experiments associated with PRESLHY WP3 and WP5 respectively. These measurements were undertaken using the hydrogen wide area monitoring system developed by NREL. During the 23 congested ignition experiments high variability was observed in the measured explosion severity during experiments with similar initial conditions. This led to the conclusion that wind including localized gusts had a large influence on the dispersion of the hydrogen and therefore the quantity of hydrogen that was present in the congested region of the explosions. Using the hydrogen concentration measurements taken immediately prior to ignition the hydrogen clouds were visualized in an attempt to rationalize the variability in overpressure between the tests. Gaussian process regression was applied to quantify the variability of the measured hydrogen concentrations. This analysis could also be used to guide modifications in experimental designs for future research on hydrogen combustion behavior.
Modelling of Hydrogen Dispersion with Effects
Sep 2023
Publication
The paper shows the latest developments of Gexcon’s consequence modelling software EFFECTS with validation based on hydrogen experimental data for different storage conditions and scenarios including liquid hydrogen two-phase jet releases. The effect of atmospheric turbulence on the dispersion and potential worst-case scenarios of hydrogen which are very different from heavy gas releases are discussed. Beside validation for gaseous hydrogen releases a validation study for pressurised liquid hydrogen jet releases including a sensitivity analysis is performed and the results are compared with experimental data.
Strength of Knowledge and Uncertainties in Safety Regulation of Hydrogen as an Energy Carrier
Sep 2023
Publication
Ahead of a potential large-scale implementation of hydrogen as an energy carrier in society safety regulation systems should be in place to provide a systematic consideration of safety related concerns. Knowledge is essential for regulatory activities. At the same time it is challenging to obtain sufficient information when regulating emerging technologies – it may be difficult to address informational shortcomings in regulatory matters as analysts can be prone to under-communicate the significance of uncertainties. Furthermore Strength of Knowledge (SoK) has been developed to address the quality of background knowledge in risk analyses. An example of a SoK framework is based on the following four conditions that is used to assess whether knowledge can be considered weak or strong: the issue of simplifications availability and reliability of data consensus among experts and general understanding of the phenomena in question. In theory this concept seems relevant for the introduction of hydrogen as an energy carrier mainly because there is little historical data to develop sound analyses creating uncertainties. However there are no clear-cut guidelines as to how knowledge gaps should be handled in the development of regulatory requirements. In this paper we consider the relevance of a specific approach for SoK assessment in the context of safety and security regulation of hydrogen as an energy carrier in society. We conclude that there are some challenges with the proposed framework and argue that further research should be conducted to identify or develop a method for handling uncertainties in regulatory processes regarding hydrogen systems as energy carriers in societies.
Lessons Learned and Recommendations from Analysis of Hydrogen Incidents and Accidents to Support Risk Assessment for the Hydrogen Economy
Feb 2024
Publication
This study addresses challenges associated with hydrogen’s physio-chemical characteristics and the need for safety and public acceptance as a precursor to the emerging hydrogen economy. It highlights the gap in existing literature regarding lessons learned from events in the green hydrogen production value chain. The study aims to use the documented lessons learned from previous hydrogen-related events to assist in enhancing safety measures and to guide stakeholders on how to avoid and mitigate future hydrogen-related events. Given the potential catastrophic consequences robust safety systems are essential for hydrogen economy development. The work underscores the importance of human and operational factors as root causes of these events. The paper recommends establishing a specialized hydrogen-related event database to support risk assessment and risk mitigation thus catering to the growing hydrogen industry’s needs and facilitating quick access to critical information for stakeholders in the private and public sectors.
Case Study: Quantitative Risk Assessment of Hydrogen Blended Natural Gas for an Existing Distribution Network and End-use Equipment in Fort Saskatchewan, Alberta
Sep 2023
Publication
In a first-of-its-kind project for Alberta ATCO Gas and Pipelines Ltd. (ATCO) began delivering a 5% blend of hydrogen (H2) in natural gas into a subsection of the existing Fort Saskatchewan natural gas distribution system (approximately 2100 customers). The project was commissioned in October 2022 with the intention of increasing the blend to 20% H₂ in 2023. As part of project due diligence ATCO in partnership with DNV undertook Quantitative Risk Assessments (QRAs) to understand any risks associated with the introduction of blended gas into its existing distribution system and to its customers. This paper describes key findings from the QRAs through the comparison of risks associated with H2 blended natural gas at concentrations of 5% and 20% H₂ and the current natural gas configuration. The impact of operating pressure and hydrogen blend composition formed a sensitivity study completed as part of this work. To provide context and to help interpret the results an individual risk (IR) level of 1 × 10-6 per year was utilised as a reference threshold for the limit of the ‘broadly acceptable’ risk level and juxtaposed against comparable risk scenarios. Although adding hydrogen increases the IR of ignited releases from mains services meters regulators and end user appliances the ignited release IR was always well below the broadly acceptable reference criterion for all operating pressures and blend cases considered as part of the project. The IR associated with carbon monoxide poisoning dominates the overall IR and the results demonstrate that the reduction in carbon monoxide poisoning associated with the introduction of H₂ blended natural gas negates any incremental risk associated with ignited releases due to H₂ blended gas. The paper also explains how the results of the QRA were incorporated into Engineering Assessments as per the requirements of CSA Z662:19 [1] to justify the conversion of existing natural gas infrastructure to H₂ blended gas infrastructure.
Numerical Simulation of Liquid Hydrogen Evaporation in the Pressurized Tank During Venting
Sep 2023
Publication
CFD modelling of liquified hydrogen boiling and evaporation during the pressurised tank venting is presented. The model is based on the volume-of-fluid method for tracking liquid and gas phases and Lee’s model for phase change. The simulation results are compared against the liquid hydrogen evaporation experiment performed by Tani et al. (2021) in a large-scale pressurised storage tank using experimental pressure dynamics and temperatures measured in gas and liquid phases. The study focuses on tank pressure decrease and recovery phenomena during the first 15 s of the venting process. The model sensitivity have been studied applying different Lee’s model evaporisation-condensation coefficients. The CFD model provided reasonable agreement with the observed pressure and gas phase temperature dynamics during the liquid hydrogen storage depressurisation using Lee’s model coefficient =0.05 s-1. Experimentalists’ hypothesis about particularly intensive boiling in the proximity of thermocouples was supported by close agreement between simulated and experimental saturation temperatures obtained from pressure dynamics.
Developing a Generalized Framework for Assessing Safety of Hydrogen Vehicles in Tunnels
Sep 2023
Publication
For widespread adoption of hydrogen fuel cell powered vehicles such vehicles need to be able to provide similar transportation capabilities as their gasoline/diesel powered counterparts. Meeting this requirement in many regions will necessitate access to tunnels. Previous work completed at Sandia National Laboratories provided high-fidelity consequence modeling of hydrogen vehicle tunnel crashes for a specific fire scenario in selected Massachusetts tunnels. To consider additional tunnels a generalized tunnel safety analysis framework is being developed. This framework aims to be broader than specific fire scenarios in specific tunnels allowing it to be applied to a range of tunnel geometries vehicle types and crash scenarios. Initial steps in the development of the generalized framework are reported within this work. Representative tunnel characteristics are derived based on data for tunnels in the U.S. Tunnel dimensions shapes and traffic levels are among the many characteristics reported within the data that can be used to inform crash scenario specification. Various crash scenario parameters are varied using lower-fidelity consequence modeling to quantify the impact on resulting safety hazards for time-dependent releases. These lower-fidelity models consider the unignited dispersion of hydrogen gas the thermal effects of jet fires and potential impacts of overpressures. Different sizes/classes of vehicles are considered as the total amount of hydrogen onboard may greatly affect scenario-specific consequences. The generalized framework will allow safety assessments to be both more agile and consistent when applied to different types of tunnels.
Explosion Replication Test of FCEV Hydrogen Tank
Sep 2023
Publication
Due to the increased interest in alternative energy sources hydrogen device safety has become paramount. In this study we induced the explosion of a hydrogen tank from a fuel cell electric vehicle (FCEV) by igniting a fire beneath it and disabling the built-in temperature pressure relief device. Three Type 4 tanks were injected gaseous hydrogen at pressures of 700 350 and 10 bar respectively. The incident pressure generated by the tank explosion was measured by pressure transducers positioned at various points around the tank. A protective barrier was installed to examine its effect on the resulting damage and the reflected pressure was measured along the barrier. The internal pressure and external temperature of the tanks were measured in multiple locations. The 700- and 350-bar hydrogen tanks exploded approximately 10 and 16 min after burner ignition respectively. The 10-bar hydrogen tank did not explode but ruptured approximately 29 min after burner ignition The explosions generated blast waves fireballs and fragments. The impact on the surrounding area was evaluated and we verified that the blast pressure fireballs and fragments were almost completely blocked by the protective barrier. The results of this study are expected to improve safety on an FCEV accident scene.
Hydrogen in the Natural Gas Network—Relevance for Existing Fire Precautions
Jun 2024
Publication
Power-to-gas technology can be used to convert excess power from renewable energies to hydrogen by means of water electrolysis. This hydrogen can serve as “chemical energy storage” and be converted back to electricity or fed into the natural gas grid. In the presented study a leak in a household pipe in a single-family house with a 13 KW heating device was experimentally investigated. An admixture of up to 40% hydrogen was set up to produce a scenario of burning leakage. Due to the outflow and mixing conditions a lifted turbulent diffusion flame was formed. This led to an additional examination point and expanded the aim and novelty of the experimental investigation. In addition to the fire safety experimental simulation of a burning leakage the resulting complex properties of the flame namely the lift-off height flame length shape and thermal radiation have also been investigated. The obtained results of this show clearly that as a consequence of the hydrogen addition the main properties of the flame such as lifting height flame temperature thermal radiation and total heat flux densities along the flame have been changed. To supplement the measurements with thermocouples imaging methods based on the Sobel gradient were used to determine the lifting height and the flame length. In order to analyze the determined values a probability density function was created.
Flame Visibility in Hydrogen Appliances
Sep 2023
Publication
One of the benefits of the direct use of hydrogen is its ability to be burned in a similar way to natural gas using appliances with which the community is already familiar. This is particularly true for applications where electrification is neither practicable nor desirable. One common example is domestic cooking stoves where the open flame offers numerous real and perceived benefits to the chef. Similarly many commercial and industrial appliances rely on the unique properties of combustion to achieve a desired purpose that cannot readily be replaced by an alternative to an open flame. Despite the enormous decarbonisation potential of the direct replacement of natural gas with hydrogen there are some operational constraints due to the different burning characteristics of hydrogen. One of the challenges is the low visible light emission from hydrogen flames. The change in visible radiation from the combustion of hydrogen compared with natural gas is a safety concern whereby visual observation of a flame may be difficult. This paper aims to provide clarity on the visual appearance of hydrogen flames via a series of measurements of flame visibility and emission spectra accompanied by the assessment of strategies to improve the safe use of hydrogen.
CFD Modelling of Large Scale Liquid Hydrogen Experiments Indoors and Outdoors
Sep 2023
Publication
The use of liquid hydrogen in maritime applications is expected to grow in the coming years in order to meet the decarbonisation goals that EU countries and countries worldwide have set for 2050. In this context The Norwegian Public Roads Administration commissioned large-scale LH2 dispersion and explosion experiments both indoors and outdoors which were conducted by DNG GL in 2019 to better understand safety aspects of LH2 in the maritime sector. In this work the DNV unignited outdoor and indoor tests have been simulated and compared with the experiments with the aim to validate the ADREA-HF Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) code in maritime applications. Three tests two outdoors and one indoors were chosen for the validation. The outdoor tests (test 5 and 6) involved liquid hydrogen release vertically downwards and horizontal to simulate an accidental leakage during bunkering. The indoor test (test 9) involved liquid hydrogen release inside a closed room to simulate an accident inside a tank connection space (TCS) connected to a ventilation mast.
Risk Management in a Containerized Metal Hydride Storage System
Sep 2023
Publication
HyCARE project supported by the Clean Hydrogen Partnership of the European Union deals with a prototype of hydrogen storage tank using a solid-state hydrogen carrier. Up to 40 kilograms of hydrogen are stored in twelve tanks at less than 50 barg and less than 100 °C. The innovative design is based on a standard twenty-foot container including twelve TiFe-based metal hydride (MH) hydrogen storage tanks coupled with a thermal energy storage in phase change materials (PCM). This article aims at showing the main risks related to hydrogen storage in a MH system and the safety barriers considered based on HyCARE’s specific risk analysis.<br/>Regarding the TiFe MH material used to store hydrogen experimental tests showed that the exposure of the MH to air or water did not cause spontaneous ignition. Furthermore an explosion within the solid MH cannot propagate due to internal pore size. Additionally in case of leakage the speed of hydrogen desorption from the MH is self-limited which is an important safety characteristic since it reduces the potential consequences from the hydrogen release scenario.<br/>Regarding the integrated system the critical scenarios identified during the risk analysis were: explosion due to release of hydrogen inside or outside the container internal explosion inside MH tanks due to accidental mix of hydrogen and air and asphyxiation due to inert gas accumulation in the container. This identification phase of the risk analysis allowed to pinpoint the most relevant safety barriers already in place and recommend additional ones if needed to further reduce the risk that were later implemented.<br/>The main safety barriers identified were: material and component selection (including the MH selected) safety interlocks safety valves ventilation gas detection and safety distances.<br/>The risk management process based on risk identification and assessment contributed to coherently integrate inherently safe design features and safety barriers.
Explosion Mitigation Techniques in Tunnels and their Applicability to Scenarios of Hydrogen Tank Rupture in a Fire
Sep 2023
Publication
This paper presents a comprehensive review of existing explosion mitigation techniques for tunnels and evaluates their applicability in scenarios of hydrogen tank rupture in a fire. The study provides an overview of the current state of the art in tunnel explosion mitigation and discusses the challenges associated with hydrogen explosions in the context of fire incidents. The review shows that there are several approaches available to decrease the effects of explosions including wrapping the tunnel with a flexible and compressible barrier and introducing energy-absorbing flexible honeycomb elements. However these methods are limited to the mitigation of the action and do not consider either the mitigation of the structural response or the effects on the occupants. The study highlights how the structural response is affected by the duration of the action and the natural period of the structural elements and how an accurate design of the element stiffness can be used in order to mitigate the structural vulnerability to the explosion. The review also presents various passive and active mitigation techniques aimed at mitigating the explosion effects on the occupants. Such techniques include tunnel branching ventilation openings evacuation lanes right-angled bends drop-down perforated plates or high-performance fibre-reinforced cementitious composite (HPFRCC) panels for blast shielding. While some of these techniques can be introduced during the tunnel's construction phase others require changes to the already working tunnels. To simulate the effect of blast wave propagation and evaluate the effectiveness of these mitigation techniques a CFD-FEM study is proposed for future analysis. The study also highlights the importance of considering these mitigation techniques to ensure the safety of the public and first responders. Finally the study identifies the need for more research to understand blast wave mitigation by existing structural elements in the application for potential accidents associated with hydrogen tank rupture in a tunnel.
Jet Flame Risk Analysis for Safe Response to Hydrogen Vehicle Accidents
Jun 2023
Publication
With an increase in the use of eco-friendly vehicles such as hybrid electric and hydrogen vehicles in response to the global climate crisis accidents related to these vehicles have also increased. Numerical analysis was performed to optimize the safety of first responders responding to hydrogen vehicle accidents wherein hydrogen jet flames occur. The influence range of the jet flame generated through a 1.8-mm-diameter nozzle was analyzed based on five discharge angles (90 75 60 45 and 30◦ ) between the road surface and the downward vertical. As the discharge angle decreases toward the road surface the risk area that could cause damage moves from the center of the vehicle to the rear; at a discharge angle of 90◦ the range above 9.5 kW/m2 was 1.59 m and 4.09 m to the front and rear of the vehicle respectively. However at a discharge angle of 30◦ it was not generated at the front but was 10.39 m to the rear. In response to a hydrogen vehicle accident first responders should perform rescue activities approaching from a diagonal direction to the vehicle front to minimize injury risk. This study can be used in future hydrogen vehicle design to develop the response strategy of the first responders.
Ignition and Flow Stopping Considerations for the Transmission of Hydrogen in the Existing Natural Gas Network
Sep 2023
Publication
This work formed part of the H21 programme whose objective is to reach the point whereby it is feasible to convert the existing natural gas (NG) distribution network to 100% hydrogen (H2) and provide a contribution to decarbonising the UK’s heat and power sectors with the focus on decarbonised fuel at point of use. Hydrogen has an ATEX Gas Group of IIC compared to IIA for natural gas which means further precautions are necessary to prevent the ignition of hydrogen during network operations. Both electrostatic and friction ignition risks were considered. Network operations considered include electrostatic precautions for polyethylene (PE) pipe and cutting and drilling of metallic pipes. As a result of the updated basis of safety from ignition considerations existing flow stopping methods were reviewed to see if they were compatible. Commonly used flow stopping methods were tested under laboratory conditions with hydrogen following the methodologies specified in the Gas Industry Standards (GIS). A new basis of safety for flow stopping has been proposed that looks at the flow past the secondary stop as double isolations are recommended for use with hydrogen.
Experimental Investigation of Fluid-structure Interaction in the Case of Hydrogen/Air Detonation Impacting a Thin Plate
Sep 2023
Publication
In recent years the use and development of hydrogen as a carbon-free energy carrier have grown. However as hydrogen is flammable with air safety issues are raised. In the case of ignition especially in confined space the flame can accelerate and reach the detonation regime causing severe structural damage [1].<br/>To assess these safety issues it is required to understand the fluid-structure interaction in the case of a detonation impacting a deformable structure and to quantify and model this interaction [2]. At the CEA (Commissariat à l’énergie atomique et aux energies alternatives) a combustion tube experimental facility [3] for studying the fluid-structure interaction in the case of hydrogen combustion has been developed. Several Photomultipliers and Pressure sensors are placed along the tube to monitor the flame acceleration and the detonation location. A fluid-structure interaction (FSI) module or a non-deformable flange can be placed at the end of the tube. Post-processing of the sensor’s signal will provide insight into the occurring phenomena inside the tube.<br/>Several experimental campaigns have been conducted with various initial conditions and configurations at the end of the tube. In this contribution the experiments resulting in a detonation are presented. First the recorded pressure and velocities will be compared to theoretical values coming from combustion models [4] [5]. Secondly the impulse before and after reflection for thin plate and non-deformable flange will be compared to quantify the energy transmitted to the plate and the influence of the fluid-structure interaction on the reflected shock.
Flame Acceleration in Stoichiometric Methane/Hydrogen/Air Mixtures in an Obstructed Channel: Effect of Hydrogen Blend Ratio
Sep 2023
Publication
Experiments and numerical simulations were conducted to study the flame acceleration (FA) in stoichiometric CH4/H2/air mixtures with various hydrogen blend ratios (i.e. Hbr = 0% 20% 50% 80% and 100%). In the experiments high-speed photography was used to record the FA process. In the calculations the two-dimensional fully-compressible reactive Navier-Stokes equations were solved using a high-order algorithm on a dynamically adapting mesh. The chemical reaction and diffusive transport of the mixtures were described by a calibrated chemical-diffusive model. The numerical predictions are in good agreement with the experimental measurements. The results show that the mechanism of FA is similar in all cases that is the flame is accelerated by the thermal expansion effects various fluid-dynamic instabilities flame-vortex interactions and the interactions of flame with pressure waves. The hydrogen blend ratio has a significant impact on the propagation speed and the morphological evolution of the flame during FA. A larger hydrogen blend ratio leads to a faster FA and the difference in FA mainly depends on the increase of flame surface area and the interactions between flame and pressure waves. In addition as the hydrogen blend ratio increases there are fewer pockets of the unburned funnels in the combustion products when the flame propagates to the end of the channel.
Numerical Investigation of Hydrogen Jet Dispersion Below and Around a Car in a Tunnel
Sep 2023
Publication
Accidental release from a hydrogen car tank in a confined space like a tunnel poses safety concerns. This Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) study focuses on the first seconds of such a release which are the most critical. Hydrogen leaks through a Thermal Pressure Relief Device (TPRD) forms a high-speed jet that impinges on the street spreads horizontally recirculates under the chassis and fills the area below it in about one second. The “fresh-air entrainment effect” at the back of the car changes the concentrations under the chassis and results in the creation of two “tongues” of hydrogen at the rear corners of the car. Two other tongues are formed near the front sides of the vehicle. In general after a few seconds hydrogen starts moving upwards around the car mainly in the form of buoyant blister-like structures. The average hydrogen volume concentrations below the car have a maximum of 71% which occurs at 2 s. The largest “equivalent stoichiometric flammable gas cloud size Q9” is 20.2 m3 at 2.7 s. Smaller TPRDs result in smaller hydrogen flow rates and smaller buoyant structures that are closer to the car. The investigation of the hydrogen dispersion during the initial stages of the leak and the identification of the physical phenomena that occur can be useful for the design of experiments for the determination of the TPRD characteristics for potential safety measures and for understanding the further distribution of the hydrogen cloud in the tunnel.
The Regulatory Framework of Geological Storage of Hydrogen in Salt Caverns
Sep 2023
Publication
A growing share of renewable energy production in the energy supply systems is key to reaching the European political goal of zero CO2 emission in 2050 highlighted in the green deal. Linked to the irregular production of solar and wind energies which have the highest potential for development in Europe massive energy storage solutions are needed as energy buffers. The European project HyPSTER [1] (Hydrogen Pilot STorage for large Ecosystem Replication) granted by the Clean Hydrogen Partnership addresses this topic by demonstrating a cyclic test in an experimental salt cavern filled with hydrogen up to 3 tons using hydrogen that is produced onsite by a 1 MW electrolyser. One specific objective of the project is the assessment of the risks and environmental impacts of cyclic hydrogen storage in salt caverns and providing guidelines for safety regulations and standards. This paper highlights the first outcome of the task WP5.5 of the HyPSTER project addressing the regulatory and normative frameworks for the safety of hydrogen storage in salt caverns from some selected European Countries which is dedicated to defining recommendations for promoting the safe development of this industry within Europe.
QRA of Hydrogen Vehicles in a Road Tunnel
Sep 2023
Publication
Hydrogen energy is recognized by many European governments as an important part of the development to achieve a more sustainable energy infrastructure. Great efforts are spent to build up a hydrogen supply chain to support the increasing number of hydrogen-powered vehicles. Naturally these vehicles will use the common traffic infrastructure. Thus it has to be ensured these infrastructures are capable to withstand the hazards and associated risks that may arise from these new technologies. In order to have an appropriate assessment tool for hydrogen vehicles transport through tunnels a new QRA methodology is developed and presented here. In Europe the PIARC is a very common approach. It is therefore chosen as a starting point for the new methodology. It provides data on traffic statistics accident frequencies tunnel geometries including certain prevention and protection measures. This approach is enhanced by allowing better identification of hazards and their respective sources for hydrogen vehicles. A detailed analysis of the accident scenarios that are unique for hydrogen vehicles hereunder the initiating events severity of collision types that may result in a release of hydrogen gas in a tunnel and the location of such an accident are included. QRA enables the assessment and evaluation of scenarios involving external fires or vehicles that burst into fire because of an accident or other fire sources. Event Tree Analysis is the technique used to estimate the event frequencies. The consequence analysis includes the hazards from blast waves hydrogen jet fires DDT.
Modelling of Refuelling though the Entire Equipment of HRS: Use of Dynamic Mesh to Simulate Heat and Mass Transfer during Throttling at PCV
Sep 2024
Publication
Hydrogen refuelling is imperative for the emerging market of hydrogen vehicles. The pressure control valve (PCV) at the hydrogen refuelling station (HRS) plays a major role in ensuring that hydrogen delivery to the vehicle follows the prescribed refuelling protocols. A three-dimensional CFD model with a detailed resolution of PCV motion affecting heat and mass transfer is developed. The PCV motion controlling the mass flow rate is simulated using dynamic mesh. The CFD model captures refuelling from high-pressure tanks through entire HRS equipment to onboard tanks capturing pressure and temperature changes upstream and downstream of the PCV. The Joule-Thomson effect resulting in a hydrogen temperature increase at PCV is captured using the NIST real gas database. The model is validated against Test No.1 of NREL on refuelling through the entire equipment of HRS. The CFD model can be used to design HRS equipment parameters including PCV and develop efficient refuelling protocols.
A Theoretical Assessment of the On-site Monitoring of Hydrogen-enriched Natural Gas by its Thermodynamic Properties
Mar 2025
Publication
A real-time on-site monitoring of the concentration of hydrogen and the heating value of a blend of hydrogen and natural gas is of key importance for its safe distribution in existing pipelines as proposed by the ‘Power-toGas’ concept. Although current gas chromatography (PGC) methods deliver this information accurately they are unsuitable for a quick and pipelineintegrated measurement. We analyse the possibility to monitor this blend with a combination of sensors of thermodynamic properties—thermal conductivity speed of sound and density—as a potential substitute for PGC. We propose a numerical method for this multi-sensor detection based on the assumption of ideal gas (i.e. low-pressure) behaviour treating natural gas as a ‘mixture of mixtures’ depending on how many geographical sources are drawn upon for its distribution. By performing a Monte-Carlo simulation with known concentrations of natural gas proceeding from different European sources we conclude that the combined measurement of thermal conductivity together with either speed of sound or density can yield a good estimation of both variables of interest (hydrogen concentration and heating value) even under variability in the composition of natural gas.
Experimental Investigation of Hydrogen-Air Flame Propagation in Fire Extinguishing Foam
Sep 2024
Publication
An important element of modern firefighting is sometimes the use of foam. After the use of extinguishing foam on vehicles or machinery operated by compressed gases it is conceivable that masses of foam were enriched by escaping fuel gas. Furthermore new foam creation enriched with a high level of fuel gas from the deposed foam solution becomes theoretically possible. The aim of this study was to carry out basic experimental investigations on the combustion of water-based H2/air foam. Ignition tests were carried out in a transparent and vertically oriented cylindrical tube (d = 0.09 m; 1.5 m length) and a rectangular thin layer channel (0.02 m × 0.2 m; 2 m length). Additionally results from larger scale tests performed inside a pool (0.30 m × 1 m × 2 m) are presented. All ducts are semi-confined and a foam generator fills the ducts from below with the defined foam. The foams vary in type and concentration of the foaming agent and hydrogen concentration. The expansion ratio of the combustible foam is in the range of 20 to 50 and the investigated H2-concentrations vary from 8 to 70% H2 in air. High-speed imaging is used to observe the combustion and determine flame velocities. The study shows that foam is flammable over a wide range of H2-concentrations from 9 to 65% H2 in air. For certain H2/air-mixtures an abrupt flame acceleration is observed. The velocity of combustion increases rapidly by an order of magnitude and reaches velocities of up to 80 m/s.
Numerical Investigation for Hazardous Gas Cloud Form and Dissipation of Hydrogen-blended Natural Gas in a Confined Space
Jan 2025
Publication
The safety of hydrogen-blended natural gas (HBNG) in a confined space is an issue especially for ventilation processes. In this study leakage and ventilation processes of low-pressure HBNG with different hydrogen-blended ratio (HBR) in a confined space are simulated and validated by experiment based on similarity criteria. For the leakage process the leak direction and HBR do not significantly affect gas accumulation behaviour. The required time for a gas cloud to fill space decreases slightly with HBR rising and they generally show a linear relationship. For the ventilation process the main influences on the leakage process are the total leakage mass and the ventilation conditions. The required time for hazardous gas cloud dissipation increases with total leakage mass and decreases with HBR. For different ventilation conditions the ranking of required time to exhaust leaked gas is low > centre > high > mix. Through the analysis of pressure distribution it is found time difference is produced by different airflow patterns. With the asymmetric layout outside air rushes into the confined space from the high side and then flows out from the low side carrying the leaked HBNG. These findings inform the design of ventilation for HBNG utilization scenarios like restaurant facing the street.
Risk Management in a Containerized Metal Hydride Storage System
Sep 2024
Publication
HyCARE project supported by the Clean Hydrogen Partnership of the European Union deals with a prototype hydrogen storage tank using a solid-state hydrogen carrier. Up to 40 kilograms of hydrogen are stored in 12 tanks at less than 50 barg and less than 100°C. The innovative design is based on a standard 20-foot container including 12 TiFe-based metal hydride (MH) hydrogen storage tanks coupled with a thermal energy storage in phase change materials (PCM). This article aims at showing the main risks related to hydrogen storage in a MH system and the safety barriers considered based on HyCARE’s specific risk analysis. Regarding the TiFe MH material used to store hydrogen experimental tests showed that the exposure of the MH to air or water did not cause spontaneous ignition. Furthermore an explosion within the solid MH cannot propagate due to internal pore size. Additionally in case of leakage the speed of hydrogen desorption from the MH is self-limited which is an important safety characteristic since it reduces the potential consequences from the hydrogen release. Regarding the integrated system the critical scenarios identified during the risk analysis were explosion due to release of hydrogen inside or outside the container internal explosion inside MH tanks due to accidental mix of hydrogen and air and asphyxiation due to inert gas accumulation in the container. The identification phase of risk analysis identified the most relevant safety barriers already in place and recommended additional ones if needed which were later implemented to further reduce the risk. The main safety barriers identified were material and component selection (including the MH selected) safety interlocks safety valves ventilation gas detection and safety distances. The risk management process based on risk identification and assessment contributed to coherently integrate inherently safe design features and safety barriers.
Consequence Analysis of Liquid Hydrogen Leakage from Storage Tanks at Urban Hydrogen Refueling Stations: A Case Study
Aug 2025
Publication
Hydrogen energy is considered a crucial clean energy carrier for replacing fossil fuels in the future. Liquid hydrogen (LH2) with its economic advantages and high purity is central to the development of future hydrogen refueling stations (HRSs). However leakage poses significant fire and explosion risks challenging its safe industrial use. In this study a numerical model of LH2 leakage at an HRS in Chongqing was established using Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) software. The diffusion law of a flammable gas cloud (FGC) was examined under the synergistic effect of the leakage direction rate and wind speed of an LH2 storage tank in an HRS. The phase transition of LH2 presents dual risks of combustion and frostbite owing to the spatial overlap between low-temperature areas and FGCs. The findings revealed that the equivalent stoichiometric gas cloud volume (Q9) reached 685 m3 in the case of crosswind leakage with the superimposed effect of reflected waves from the LH2 transport vehicle resulting in a peak explosion overpressure of 0.61 bar. The low-temperature hazard area and the FGC (with a concentration of 30–75%) show significant spatial overlap. These research outcomes offer crucial theoretical underpinning for enhancing equipment layout optimization and safety protection strategies at HRSs.
A Model for Assessing the Risk of Liquid Hydrogen Transport through Road Tunnels
Sep 2023
Publication
Among the new energy carriers aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions the use of hydrogen is expected to grow significantly in various applications and sectors (i.e. industrial commercial transportation etc.) due to its high energy content by weight and zero carbon emissions. The increasingly widespread use of hydrogen will require massive distribution from production sites to final consumers and the delivery by means of liquid hydrogen road tankers may be a suitable cost-effective option for market penetration in the short-medium term. Liquid hydrogen (LH2) presents different hazards compared to gaseous hydrogen and an accidental release in confined spaces such as road tunnels might lead to the formation of a flammable hydrogen cloud that might deflagrate or even detonate. Nevertheless the potential negative effects on users in the event of accidental leakage of liquid hydrogen from a tanker in road tunnels so far have not been sufficiently investigated. Therefore a 3D Computational Fluid Dynamics model for the release of LH2 and its dispersion within a road tunnel was developed in this study. The proposed model was validated by a comparison with certain experimental and numerical studies found in the literature. Such modeling is demanding for long tunnels. Therefore the results of the simulations (e.g. the amount of hydrogen contained within the cloud) were combined with established simplified consequence methods to estimate the overpressures generated from a potential hydrogen deflagration. This was then used to evaluate the effects on users while evacuating from the tunnel. The findings showed that the worst scenario is when the release is in the middle of the tunnel length and the ignition occurs 90 s after the leakage.
Laminar Burning Velocities of Hydrogen-Blended Methane–Air and Natural Gas–Air Mixtures, Calculated from the Early Stage of p(t) Records in a Spherical Vessel
Nov 2021
Publication
The flammable hydrogen-blended methane–air and natural gas–air mixtures raise specific safety and environmental issues in the industry and transportation; therefore their explosion characteristics such as the explosion limits explosion pressures and rates of pressure rise have significant importance from a safety point of view. At the same time the laminar burning velocities are the most useful parameters for practical applications and in basic studies for the validation of reaction mechanisms and modeling turbulent combustion. In the present study an experimental and numerical study of the effect of hydrogen addition on the laminar burning velocity (LBV) of methane–air and natural gas–air mixtures was conducted using mixtures with equivalence ratios within 0.90 and 1.30 and various hydrogen fractions rH within 0.0 and 0.5. The experiments were performed in a 14 L spherical vessel with central ignition at ambient initial conditions. The LBVs were calculated from p(t) data determined in accordance with EN 15967 by using only the early stage of flame propagation. The results show that hydrogen addition determines an increase in LBV for all examined binary flammable mixtures. The LBV variation versus the fraction of added hydrogen rH follows a linear trend only at moderate hydrogen fractions. The further increase in rH results in a stronger variation in LBV as shown by both experimental and computed LBVs. Hydrogen addition significantly changes the thermal diffusivity of flammable CH4–air or NG–air mixtures the rate of heat release and the concentration of active radical species in the flame front and contribute thus to LBV variation.
Flame Stabilization and Blow-off of Ultra-Lean H2-Air Premixed Flames
Apr 2021
Publication
The manner in which an ultra-lean hydrogen flame stabilizes and blows off is crucial for the understanding and design of safe and efficient combustion devices. In this study we use experiments and numerical simulations for pure H2-air flames stabilized behind a cylindrical bluff body to reveal the underlying physics that make such flames stable and eventually blow-off. Results from CFD simulations are used to investigate the role of stretch and preferential diffusion after a qualitative validation with experiments. It is found that the flame displacement speed of flames stabilized beyond the lean flammability limit of a flat stretchless flame (φ = 0.3) can be scaled with a relevant tubular flame displacement speed. This result is crucial as no scaling reference is available for such flames. We also confirm our previous hypothesis regarding lean limit blow-off for flames with a neck formation that such flames are quenched due to excessive local stretching. After extinction at the flame neck flames with closed flame fronts are found to be stabilized inside a recirculation zone.
Safety of Hydrogen Storage Technologies
Oct 2024
Publication
While hydrogen is regularly discussed as a possible option for storing regenerative energies its low minimum ignition energy and broad range of explosive concentrations pose safety challenges regarding hydrogen storage and there are also challenges related to hydrogen production and transport and at the point of use. A risk assessment of the whole hydrogen energy system is necessary to develop hydrogen utilization further. Here we concentrate on the most important hydrogen storage technologies especially high-pressure storage liquid hydrogen in cryogenic tanks methanol storage and salt cavern storage. This review aims to study the most recent research results related to these storage techniques by describing typical sensors and explosion protection measures thus allowing for a risk assessment of hydrogen storage through these technologies.
Identification of Safety Critical Scenarios of Hydrogen Refueling Stations in a Multifuel Context
Sep 2023
Publication
The MultHyFuel Project funded by the Clean Hydrogen Partnership aims to achieve the effective and safe deployment of hydrogen as a carbon-neutral fuel by developing a common strategy for implementing Hydrogen Refueling Stations (HRS) in a multifuel context. The project hopes to contribute to the harmonisation of existing regulations codes and standards (RCS) by generating practical theoretical and experimental data related to HRS.<br/>This paper presents how a set of safety critical scenarios have been identified from the initial preliminary as well as detailed risk analysis of three different hydrogen refueling station configurations. To achieve this a detailed examination of each potential hazardous phenomenon (DPh) or major accident event at or near the hydrogen dispenser was carried out. Particular attention is paid to the scenarios which could affect third parties external to the refueling station.<br/>The paper presents a methodology subdivided into the following steps:<br/>♦ determination of the consequence level and likelihood of each hazardous phenomenon<br/>♦ the classification of major hazard scenarios for the 3 HRS configurations specifically those arising on the dispensing forecourt;<br/>♦ proposal of example preventative control and/or mitigation barriers that could potentially reduce the probability of occurrence and/ or consequences of safety critical scenarios and hence reducing risks to a tolerable level or to as low as reasonably practicable.
Investigation of the Suitability of Viper: Blast CFD Software for Hydrogen and Vapor Cloud Explosions
Sep 2023
Publication
Many simplified methods for estimating blast loads from a hydrogen or vapor cloud explosion are unable to take into account the accurate geometry of confining spaces obstacles or landscape that may significantly interact with the blast wave and influence the strength of blast loads. Computation fluid dynamics (CFD) software Viper::Blast which was originally developed for the simulation of the detonation of high explosives is able to quickly and easily model geometry for blast analyses however its use for vapor cloud explosions and deflagrations is not well established. This paper describes the results of an investigation into the suitability of Viper::Blast for use in modeling hydrogen deflagration and detonation events from various experiments in literature. Detonation events have been captured with a high degree of detail and relatively little uncertainty in inputs while deflagration events are significantly more complex. An approach is proposed that may allow for a reasonable bounding of uncertainty potentially leading to an approach to CFD-based Monte Carlo analyses that are able to address a problem’s true geometry while remaining reasonably pragmatic in terms of run-time and computational investment. This will allow further exploration of practical CFD application to inform hydrogen safety in the engineering design assessment and management of energy mobility and transport systems infrastructure and operations.
No more items...