Safety
Simulation-based Safety Investigation of a Hydrogen Fueling Station with an On-site Hydrogen Production System Involving Methylcyclohexane
Jan 2017
Publication
Adequate safety measures are crucial for preventing major accidents at hydrogen fuelling stations. In particular risk analysis of the domino effect at hydrogen fuelling stations is essential because knock-on accidents are likely to intensify the consequences of a relatively small incident. Several risk assessment studies have focused on hydrogen fuelling stations but none have investigated accidental scenarios related to the domino effect at such stations. Therefore the purpose of this study is to identify a domino effect scenario analyze the scenario by using simulations and propose safety measures for preventing and mitigating of the scenario. In this hazard identification study we identified the domino effect scenario of a hydrogen fuelling station with an on-site hydrogen production system involving methylcyclohexane and investigated through simulations of the scenario. The simulations revealed that a pool fire of methylcyclohexane or toluene can damage the process equipment and that thermal radiation may cause the pressurized hydrogen tanks to rupture. The rupture-type vent system can serve as a critical safety measure for preventing and mitigating the examined scenario.
Estimation of Final Hydrogen Temperature From Refueling Parameters
Oct 2015
Publication
Compressed hydrogen storage is currently widely used in fuel cell vehicles due to its simplicity in tank structure and refuelling process. For safety reason the final gas temperature in the hydrogen tank during vehicle refuelling must be maintained under a certain limit e.g. 85 °C. Many experiments have been performed to find the relations between the final gas temperature in the hydrogen tank and refueling conditions. The analytical solution of the hydrogen temperature in the tank can be obtained from the simplified thermodynamic model of a compressed hydrogen storage tank and it serves as function formula to fit experimental temperatures. From the analytical solution the final hydrogen temperature can be expressed as a weighted average form of initial temperature inflow temperature and ambient temperature inspired by the rule of mixtures. The weighted factors are related to other refuelling parameters such as initial mass initial pressure refuelling time refuelling mass rate average pressure ramp rate (APRR) final mass final pressure etc. The function formula coming from the analytical solution of the thermodynamic model is more meaningful physically and more efficient mathematically in fitting experimental temperatures. The simple uniform formula inspired by the concept of the rule of mixture and its weighted factors obtained from the analytical solution of lumped parameter thermodynamics model is representatively used to fit the experimental and simulated results in publication. Estimation of final hydrogen temperature from refuelling parameters based on the rule of mixtures is simple and practical for controlling the maximum temperature and for ensuring hydrogen safety during fast filling process.
Evaluating Uncertainty in Accident Rate Estimation at Hydrogen Refueling Station Using Time Correlation Model
Nov 2018
Publication
Hydrogen as a future energy carrier is receiving a significant amount of attention in Japan. From the viewpoint of safety risk evaluation is required in order to increase the number of hydrogen refuelling stations (HRSs) implemented in Japan. Collecting data about accidents in the past will provide a hint to understand the trend in the possibility of accidents occurrence by identifying its operation time However in new technology; accident rate estimation can have a high degree of uncertainty due to absence of major accident direct data in the late operational period. The uncertainty in the estimation is proportional to the data unavailability which increases over long operation period due to decrease in number of stations. In this paper a suitable time correlation model is adopted in the estimation to reflect lack (due to the limited operation period of HRS) or abundance of accident data which is not well supported by conventional approaches. The model adopted in this paper shows that the uncertainty in the estimation increases when the operation time is long owing to the decreasing data.
Hazard Identification Study for Risk Assessment of a Hybrid Gasoline-hydrogen Fueling Station with an Onsite Hydrogen Production System Using Organic Hydride
Oct 2015
Publication
Hydrogen infrastructures are important for the commercialization of fuel cell vehicles. Hydrogen storage and transportation are significant topics because it is difficult to safely and effectively treat large amounts of hydrogen because of hydrogen hazards. An organic chemical hydride method keeps and provides hydrogen using hydrogenation and dehydrogenation chemical reactions with aromatic compounds. This method has advantages in that the conventional petrochemical products are used as a hydrogen carrier and petrochemicals are more easily treated than hydrogen because of low hazards. Hydrogen fueling stations are also crucial infrastructures for hydrogen supply. In Japan hybrid gasoline-hydrogen fuelling stations are needed for effective space utilization in urban areas. It is essential to address the safety issues of hybrid fueling stations for inherently safer station construction. We focused on a hybrid gasoline-hydrogen fuelling station with an on-site hydrogen production system using methylcyclohexane as an organic chemical hydride. The purpose of this study is to reveal unique hybrid risks in the station with a hazard identification study (HAZID study). As a result of the HAZID study we identified 314 accident scenarios involving gasoline and organic chemical hydride systems. In addition we suggested improvement safety measures for uniquely worst-case accident scenarios to prevent and mitigate the scenarios.
Modeling Thermal Response of Polymer Composite Hydrogen Cylinders
Oct 2015
Publication
With the anticipated introduction of hydrogen fuel cell vehicles to the market there is an increasing need to address the fire resistance of hydrogen cylinders for onboard storage. Sufficient fire resistance is essential to ensure safe evacuation in the event of car fire accidents. The authors have developed a Finite Element (FE) model for predicting the thermal response of composite hydrogen cylinders within the frame of the open source FE code Elmer. The model accounts for the decomposition of the polymer matrix and effects of volatile gas transport in the composite. Model comparison with experimental data has been conducted using a classical one-dimensional test case of polymer composite subjected to fire. The validated model was then used to analyze a type-4 hydrogen cylinder subjected to an engulfing external propane fire mimicking a published cylinder fire experiment. The external flame is modelled and simulated using the open source code FireFOAM. A simplified failure criteria based on internal pressure increase is subsequently used to determine the cylinder fire resistance.
Validation of Leading Point Concept in RANS Simulations of Highly Turbulent Lean Syngas-air Flames with Well-pronounced Diffusional-thermal Effects
Jan 2021
Publication
While significant increase in turbulent burning rate in lean premixed flames of hydrogen or hydrogen-containing fuel blends is well documented in various experiments and can be explained by highlighting local diffusional-thermal effects capabilities of the vast majority of available models of turbulent combustion for predicting this increase have not yet been documented in numerical simulations. To fill this knowledge gap a well-validated Turbulent Flame Closure (TFC) model of the influence of turbulence on premixed combustion which however does not address the diffusional-thermal effects is combined with the leading point concept which highlights strongly perturbed leading flame kernels whose local structure and burning rate are significantly affected by the diffusional-thermal effects. More specifically within the framework of the leading point concept local consumption velocity is computed in extremely strained laminar flames by adopting detailed combustion chemistry and subsequently the computed velocity is used as an input parameter of the TFC model. The combined model is tested in RANS simulations of highly turbulent lean syngas-air flames that were experimentally investigated at Georgia Tech. The tests are performed for four different values of the inlet rms turbulent velocities different turbulence length scales normal and elevated (up to 10 atm) pressures various H2/CO ratios ranging from 30/70 to 90/10 and various equivalence ratios ranging from 0.40 to 0.80. All in all the performed 33 tests indicate that the studied combination of the leading point concept and the TFC model can predict well-pronounced diffusional-thermal effects in lean highly turbulent syngas-air flames with these results being obtained using the same value of a single constant of the combined model in all cases. In particular the model well predicts a significant increase in the bulk turbulent consumption velocity when increasing the H2/CO ratio but retaining the same value of the laminar flame speed.
Three-dimensional Structures of N2-Diluted Stoichiometric H2-O2 Flames in Narrow Channels
Sep 2021
Publication
Flame propagation and acceleration in unobstructed channels/tubes is usually assumed as symmetric. A fully optically accessible narrow channel that allows to perform simultaneous high-speed schlieren visualization from two mutually perpendicular directions was built to asses the validity of the aforementioned assumption. Here we provide experimental evidence of the interesting three-dimensional structures and asymmetries that develop during the acceleration phase and show how these may control detonation onset in N2-diluted stoichiometric H2-O2 mixtures.
Development of Technical Regulations for Fuel Cell Motorcycles in Japan—Hydrogen Safety
Jul 2019
Publication
Hydrogen fuel cell vehicles are expected to play an important role in the future and thus have improved significantly over the past years. Hydrogen fuel cell motorcycles with a small container for compressed hydrogen gas have been developed in Japan along with related regulations. As a result national regulations have been established in Japan after discussions with Japanese motorcycle companies stakeholders and experts. The concept of Japanese regulations was proposed internationally and a new international regulation on hydrogen-fueled motorcycles incorporating compressed hydrogen storage systems based on this concept are also established as United Nations Regulation No. 146. In this paper several technical regulations on hydrogen safety specific to fuel cell motorcycles incorporating compressed hydrogen storage systems are summarized. The unique characteristics of these motorcycles e.g. small body light weight and tendency to overturn easily are considered in these regulations.
LES Simulation of Buoyancy Jet From Unintended Hydrogen Release with GASFLOW-MPI
Sep 2017
Publication
Hydrogen leakage is a key safety issue for hydrogen energy application. For hydrogen leakage hydrogen releases with low momentum hence the development of the leakage jet is dominated by both initial momentum and buoyancy. It is important for a computational code to capture the flow characteristics transiting from momentum-dominated jet to buoyancy dominated plume during leakage. GASFLOW-MPI is a parallel computational fluid dynamics (CFD) code which is well validated and widely used for hydrogen safety analysis. In this paper its capability for small scale hydrogen leakage is validated with unintended hydrogen release experiment. In the experiment pure hydrogen is released into surrounding stagnant air through a jet tube on a honeycomb plate with various Froude numbers (Fr). The flow can be fully momentum-dominated at the beginning while the influence of buoyancy increases with the Fr decreases along the streamline. Several quantities of interest including velocity along the centerline radial profiles of the time-averaged H2 mass fraction are obtained to compare with experimental data. The good agreement between the numerical results and the experimental data indicates that GASFLOW-MPI can successfully simulate hydrogen turbulent dispersion driven by both momentum and buoyant force. Different turbulent models i.e. k-ε LES and DES model are analyzed for code performance the result shows that all these three models are adequate for hydrogen leakage simulation k-ε simulation is sufficient for industrial applications while LES model can be adopted for detail analysis for a jet/plume study like entrainment. The DES model possesses both characters of the former two model only the performance of its result depends on the grid refinement.
Modeling of Hydrogen Flame Dynamics in Narrow Gap with Bendable Walls
Sep 2017
Publication
A concept of volume porosity together with model of moving walls were elaborated and implemented into the COM3D code. Additionally to that a support of real-time data exchange with finite-element code ABAQUS - © Dassault Systèmes provided possibility to perform simulations of the gas-dynamic simultaneously with geometrical adaptation of environmental conditions. Based on the data obtained in the KIT combustion experiments in narrow gaps the authors performed a series of the simulation on the combustion in the corresponding conditions. Obtained numerical results demonstrated good agreement with the observed experimental data. These data were also compared with those obtained in the simulation without wall bending where simulation showed considerably different combustion regime. Application of the developed technique allows to obtain results unreachable without accounting on wall displacements which demonstrates massive over-estimation of the pressures observed during flame propagation.
The Hydrogen Economy - Evaluation of the Materials Science and Engineering Issues
Jan 2005
Publication
The main objectives were to identify materials issues relating to the widespread use of hydrogen as a fuel.
MAIN FINDINGS
MAIN FINDINGS
- Hydrogen is seen by many as the answer to the environmental problems of reliance on fossil fuels for energy needs. A great deal of effort is currently being invested in research into all areas of the hydrogen economy such as fuel cells hydrogen generation transportation and storage.
- Fuel cells have the potential to provide power for a very wide range of applications ranging from small portable electronics devices to large stationary electricity production and vehicles covering the whole range of road vehicles and possibly extending to rail marine and even aviation.
- The main obstacles to achieving a viable hydrogen economy are costs of producing hydrogen from renewable sources issues relating to transportation and storage due to the low energy density of hydrogen gas and the cost and reliability of fuel cells.
- The main material considerations relating to the use of hydrogen are hydrogen embrittlement material properties at cryogenic temperatures (due to use of liquid hydrogen) and permeability.
- A number of new materials are likely to come to prominence in a hydrogen economy; high performance composites are likely to be used extensively for high pressure hydrogen cylinders new materials or combinations of materials may be used for hydrogen pipelines and a range of new materials are currently being considered for hydrogen storage such as metal hydrides and carbon nanotubes.
- Due to the effect of hydrogen on materials it is important to test any materials in the environment in which they would be used. Depending on the type of test this could require the use of very specialist expensive equipment.
Vented Explosion of Hydrogen/Air Mixture: An Inter Comparison Benchmark Exercise
Sep 2017
Publication
Explosion venting is a widely used mitigation solution in the process industry to protect indoor equipment or buildings from excessive internal pressure caused by accidental explosions. However vented explosions are very complicated to model using computational fluid dynamics (CFD). In the framework of a French working group the main target of this investigation is to assess the predictive capabilities of five CFD codes used by five different organizations by means of comparison with recent experimental data. On this basis several recommendations for the CFD modelling of vented explosions are suggested.
Modelling and Numerical Simulation of Hydrogen Jet Fires for Industrial Safety Analyses – Comparison with Large-scale Experiments
Sep 2019
Publication
Reliable predictive tools for hydrogen safety engineering are needed to meet increased and more widespread use of hydrogen in the society. Industrial models and methods used to establish thermal radiation hazard safety distances from hydrogen jet fires are often based on models previously developed for hydrocarbon jet fires. Their capability of predicting radiative heat fluxes from hydrogen jet fires has often only been validated against small-scale or medium-scale jet flame experiments. However large-scale hydrogen jet fire experiments have shown that thermal radiation levels can be significantly higher than one might expect from extrapolation of experience on smaller hydrogen flames. Here two large-scale horizontal hydrogen jet fires (from a 20.9 mm and a 52.5 mm diameter release respectively) have been modelled and simulated with the advanced industrial CFD code KAMELEON FIREEX KFX® based on the Eddy Dissipation Concept by Magnussen for turbulent combustion modelling. The modelling of the high-pressure hydrogen gas releases is based on a pseudo-source concept using real-gas thermodynamic data for hydrogen. The discrete transport method of Lockwood and Shah is used to calculate the radiative heat transfer and radiative properties of water vapour are modelled according to Leckner. The predicted thermal radiation is compared to data from large-scale hydrogen jet fire experiments and discussed. This work was conducted as part of a KFX-H2 R&D project supported by the Research Council of Norway.
Non-adiabatic Under-expanded Jet Theory for Blowdown and Fire Resistance Rating of Hydrogen Tank
Sep 2019
Publication
The European Regulations on type-approval of hydrogen vehicles require thermally-activated pressure relief device (TPRD) to be installed on hydrogen onboard storage tanks to release its content in a fire event to prevent its catastrophic rupture. The aim of this study is to develop a model for design of an inherently safer system TPRD-storage tank. Parameters of tank materials and hydrogen external heat flux from the fire to the tank wall TPRD diameter time to initiate TPRD are input parameters of the model. The energy conservation equation and real gas equation of state are employed to describe the dynamic behaviour of the system. The under-expanded jet theory developed previously for adiabatic release from a storage tank is applied here to non-adiabatic blowdown of a tank in a fire. Unsteady heat transfer equation is used to calculate heat conduction through the tank wall. It includes the decomposition of the wall material due to high heat flux. The convective heat transfer between tank wall and hydrogen is modelled through the dimensionless Nusselt number correlations. The model is validated against two types of experiments i.e. realistic (non-adiabatic) blowdown of high-pressure storage tank and failure of a tank without TPRD in a fire. The model is confirmed to be time efficient for computations and accurately predicts the dynamic pressure and temperature of the gas inside the tank temperature profile within the tank wall time to tank rupture in a fire and the blowdown time.
Validation of a 3d Multiphase-multicomponent CFD Model for Accidental Liquid and Gaseous Hydrogen Releases
Sep 2017
Publication
As hydrogen-air mixtures are flammable in a wide range of concentrations and the minimum ignition energy is low compared to hydrocarbon fuels the safe handling of hydrogen is of utmost importance. Additional hazards may arise with the accidental spill of liquid hydrogen. Such a release of LH2 leads to a formation of a cryogenic pool a dynamic vaporization process and consequently a dispersion of gaseous hydrogen into the environment. Several LH2 release experiments as well as modelling approaches address this phenomenology. In contrast to existing approaches a new CFD model capable of simulating liquid and gaseous distribution was developed at Forschungszentrum Jülich. It is validated against existing experiments and yields no substantial lacks in the physical model and reveals a qualitatively consistent prediction. Nevertheless the deviation between experiment and simulation raises questions on the completeness of the database in particular with regard to the boundary conditions and available measurements.
Large Eddy Simulations of Asymmetric Turbulent Hydrogen Jets Issuing from Realistic Pipe Geometries
Sep 2017
Publication
In the current study a Large Eddy Simulation strategy is applied to model the dispersion of compressible turbulent hydrogen jets issuing from realistic pipe geometries. The work is novel as it explores the effect of jet densities and Reynolds numbers on vertical buoyant jets as they emerge from the outer wall of a pipe through a round orifice perpendicular to the mean flow within the pipe. An efficient Godunov solver is used and coupled with Adaptive Mesh Refinement to provide high resolution solutions only in areas of interest. The numerical results are validated against physical experiments of air and helium which allows a degree of confidence in analysing the data obtained for hydrogen releases. The results show that the jets investigated are always asymmetric. Thus significant discrepancies exist when applying conventional round jet assumptions to determine statistical properties associated with gas leaks from pipelines.
Investigation of Turbulent Premixed Methane/Air and Hydrogen-enriched Methane/Air Flames in a Laboratory-scale Gas Turbine Model Combustor
Feb 2021
Publication
Methane and hydrogen-enriched (25 vol% and 50 vol% H2 -enriched CH4) methane/air premixed flames were investigated in a gas turbine model combustor under atmospheric conditions. The flame operability ranges were mapped at different Reynold numbers (Re) showing the dependence on Re and H2 concentrations. The effects of equivalence ratio (Φ) Re and H2 enrichment on flame structure were examined employing OH-PLIF measurement. For CH4/air cases the flame was stabilized with an M shape; while for H2 -enriched cases the flame transitions to a П shape above a specific Φ. This transition was observed to influence significantly the flashback limits. The flame shape transition is most likely a result of H2 enrichment occurring due to the increase in flame speed higher resistance of the flame to the strain rate and change in the inner recirculation zone. Flow fields of CH4/air flames were compared between low and high Re cases employing high-speed PIV. The flashback events led by two mechanisms (combustion-induced vortex breakdown CIVB and boundary-layer flashback BLF) were observed and recorded using high-speed OH chemiluminescence imaging. It was found that the CIVB flashback occurred only for CH4 flames with M shape whereas the BLF occurs for all H2 -enriched flames with П shape.
Moving Gas Turbine Package from Conventional Gas to Hydrogen Blend
Sep 2021
Publication
The current greatest challenge that all gas turbine manufactures and users have in front of them for the years to come is the energy transition while reducing CO2 footprint and to contrast climate change. To this aim the introduction of hydrogen as fuel gas (or its blend) is playing a very important role. The benefit from an environmental point of view is undisputed but the presence of hydrogen introduces a series of safety related aspects to be considered for the design of all systems of a gas turbine package. Most of the design standards developed and adopted in the past are based on conventional natural gas however physical properties of hydrogen require to analyze additional aspects or revise the current ones. In this context the design for safety is paramount as it is strongly impacted by the low energy ignition of hydrogen blend fuels. Baker Hughes has built its experience on several sites different Customers and applications currently installed. These gas turbines run with a variety of hydrogen blends with concentration as high as 100% hydrogen. Baker Hughes has achieved several milestones moving from design to experimental set up leveraging the internal infrastructures consolidating design assumptions. In this work the critical aspects such as material selection instrumentation electrical devices and components are discussed in the framework of package safety with the aim to evolve conventional design minimizing the impacts on package configurations.
On the Evaluation of ALD TiO 2 , ZrO 2 and HfO 2 Coatings on Corrosion and Cytotoxicity Performances
May 2021
Publication
Magnesium alloys have been widely studied as materials for temporary implants but their use has been limited by their corrosion rate. Recently coatings have been proven to provide an effective barrier. Though only little explored in the field Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD) stands out as a coating technology due to the outstanding film conformality and density achievable. Here we provide first insights into the corrosion behavior and the induced biological response of 100 nm thick ALD TiO2 HfO2 and ZrO2 coatings on AZ31 alloy by means of potentiodynamic polarization curves electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) hydrogen evolution and MTS colorimetric assay with L929 cells. All three coatings improve the corrosion behavior and cytotoxicity of the alloy. Particularly HfO2 coatings were characterized by the highest corrosion resistance and cell viability slightly higher than those of ZrO2 coatings. TiO2 was characterized by the lowest corrosion improvements and though generally considered a biocompatible coating was found to not meet the demands for cellular applications (it was characterized by grade 3 cytotoxicity after 5 days of culture). These results reveal a strong link between biocompatibility and corrosion resistance and entail the need of taking the latter into consideration in the choice of a biocompatible coating to protect degradable Mg-based alloys.
On Flame Ball-to-Deflagration Transition in Hydrogen-air Mixtures
Sep 2021
Publication
Ultra-lean hydrogen-air combustion is characterized by two phenomena: the difference in upward and downward flame propagation concentration limits and the incomplete combustion. The clear answers on the two basic questions are still absent: What is a reason and what is a mechanism for their manifestation? Problem statement and the principal research topics of the Flame Ball to Deflagration Transition (FBDT) phenomenon in gaseous hydrogen-air mixtures are presented. The non-empirical concept of the fundamental concentration limits discriminates two basic low-speed laminar combustion patterns - self-propagating locally planar deflagration fronts and drifting locally spherical flame balls. To understand - at what critical conditions and how the baric deflagrations are transforming into iso- baric flame balls? - the photographic studies of the quasi-2-dim flames freely propagating outward radially via thin horizontal channel were performed. For gradual increase of initial hydrogen concentration from 3 to 12 vol.% the three representative morphological types of combustion (star-like dendrite-like and quasi-homogeneous) and two characteristic processes of reaction front bifurcation were revealed. Key elements of the FBDT mechanism both for 2-dim and 3-dim combustion are the following. Locally spherical ""leading centres"" (drifting flame balls) are the ""elementary building blocks"" of all ultra-lean flames. System of the drifting flame balls is formed due to primary bifurcation of the pre-flame kernel just after ignition. Subsequent mutual dynamics and overall morphology of the ultra-lean flames are governed by competitive non-local interactions of the individual drifting flame balls and their secondary/tertiary/etc. bifurcations defined by initial stoichiometry."
No more items...