Safety
Potential Models For Stand-Alone And Multi-Fuel Gaseous Hydrogen Refuelling Stations- Assessment Of Associated Risk
Sep 2005
Publication
Air pollution and traffic congestion are two of the major issues affecting public authorities policy makers and citizens not only in Italy and European Union but worldwide; this is nowadays witnessed by always more frequent limitations to the traffic in most of Italian cities for instance. Hydrogen use in automotive appears to offer a viable solution in medium-long term; this new perspective involves the need to carry out adequate infrastructures for distribution and refuelling and consequently the need to improve knowledge on hydrogen technologies from a safety point of view. In the present work possible different configurations for gaseous hydrogen refuelling station has been compared: “stand-alone” and “multi-fuel”. These two alternative scenarios has been taken into consideration each of one with specific hypotheses: “stand-alone” configuration based on the hypothesis of a potential model consisting of a hydrogen refuelling station composed by on-site hydrogen production via electrolysis a trailer of compressed gas for back-up compressor unit intermediate storage unit and dispenser. In this model it is assumed that no other refuelling equipment and/or dispenser of traditional fuel is present in the same site. “multi-fuel” configuration where it is assumed that the same components for hydrogen refuelling station are placed in the same site beside one or more refuelling equipment and/or dispenser of traditional fuel. Comparisons have been carried out from the point of view of specific risk assessment which have been conducted on both the two alternative scenarios.
Quantitative Risk Analysis Of Gaseous Hydrogen Storage Unit
Sep 2005
Publication
A quantitative risk analysis to a central pressurized storage tank for gaseous hydrogen has been performed to attend requirements of licensing procedures established by the State Environment Agency of São Paulo State Brazil. Gaseous hydrogen is used to feed the reactor to promote hydrogenation at the surfactant unit. HAZOP was the hazard identification technique selected. System components failures were defined by event and fault tree analysis. Quantitative risk analysis was complied to define the acceptability concepts on societal and individual risks required by the State Environmental Agency to approve the installation operation license. Acceptable levels to public society from the analysis were reached. Safety recommendations to the gaseous hydrogen central were proposed to assure minimization of risk to the near-by community operators environment and property.
Experimental Study of Jet-formed Hydrogen-air Mixtures and Pressure Loads from their Deflagrations in Low Confined Surroundings
Sep 2007
Publication
To provide more practical data for safety assessments a systematic study of explosion and combustion processes which can take place in mixtures produced by jet releases in realistic environmental conditions is required. The presented work is aimed to make step forward in this direction binding three inter-connected tasks: (i) study of horizontal and vertical jets (ii) study of the burnable clouds formed by jets in different geometry configurations and (iii) examination of combustion and explosion processes initiated in such mixtures. Test matrix for the jet experiments included variation of the release pressure and nozzle diameter with the aim to study details of the resulting hydrogen concentration and velocity profiles depending on the release conditions. In this study the following parameters were varied: mass flow rate jet nozzle diameter (to alter gas speed) and geometry of the hood located on top of the jet. The carried out experiments provided data on detailed structure for under-expanded horizontal and buoyant vertical jets and data on pressure loads resulted from deflagration of various mixtures formed by jet releases. The data on pressures waves generated in the conditions under consideration provides conservative estimation of pressure loads for realistic leaks.
Analysis of Buoyancy-driven Ventilation of Hydrogen from Buildings
Sep 2007
Publication
When hydrogen gas is used or stored within a building as with a hydrogen-powered vehicle parked in a residential garage any leakage of unignited H2 will mix with indoor air and may form a flammable mixture. One approach to safety engineering relies on buoyancy-driven passive ventilation of H2 from the building through vents to the outside. To discover relationships between design variables we combine two types of analysis: (1) a simplified 1-D steady-state analysis of buoyancy-driven ventilation and (2) CFD modelling using FLUENT 6.3. The simplified model yields a closed-form expression relating the H2 concentration to vent area height and discharge coefficient; leakage rate; and a stratification factor. The CFD modelling includes 3-D geometry; H2 cloud formation; diffusion momentum convection and thermal effects; and transient response. We modelled a typical residential two-car garage with 5 kg of H2 stored in a fuel tank; leakage rates of 5.9 to 82 L/min (tank discharge times of 12 hours to 1 week); a variety of vent sizes and heights; and both isothermal and nonisothermal conditions. This modelling indicates a range of the stratification factor needed to apply the simplified model for vent sizing as well as a more complete understanding of the dynamics of H2 movement within the building. A significant thermal effect occurs when outdoor temperature is higher than indoor temperature so that thermocirculation opposes the buoyancy-driven ventilation of H2. This circumstance leads to higher concentrations of H2 in the building relative to an isothermal case. In an unconditioned space such as a residential garage this effect depends on the thermal coupling of indoor air to outdoor air the ground (under a concrete slab floor) and an adjacent conditioned space in addition to temperatures. We use CFD modelling to explore the magnitude of this effect under rather extreme conditions.
Design of Catalytic Recombiners for Safe Removal of Hydrogen from Flammable Gas Mixtures
Sep 2007
Publication
Several today’s and future applications in energy technology bear the risk of the formation of flammable hydrogen/air mixtures either due to the direct use of hydrogen or due to hydrogen appearing as a by-product. If there’s the possibility of hydrogen being released accidentally into closed areas countermeasures have to be implemented in order to mitigate the threat of an explosion. In the field of nuclear safety passive auto-catalytic recombiners (PAR) are well-known devices for reducing the risk of a hydrogen detonation in a nuclear power plant in the course of a severe accident. Hydrogen and oxygen react on catalyst materials like platinum or palladium already far below conventional flammability limits. The most important concern with regard to the utilization of hydrogen recombiners is the adequate removal of the reaction heat. Already low hydrogen concentrations may increase the system temperature beyond the self-ignition limit of hydrogen/air mixtures and may lead to an unintended ignition on hot parts of the PAR.<br/>Starting from the nuclear application since several years IEF-6 and LRST perform joint research in the field of passive auto-catalytic recombiners including experimental studies modelling and development of new design concepts. Recently approaches on specifically designed catalysts and on passive cooling devices have been successfully tested. In a design study both approaches are combined in order to provide means for efficient and safe removal of hydrogen. The paper summarizes results achieved so far and possible designs for future applications.
Stress Corrosion Cracking Of Stainless Steels In High Pressure Alkaline Electrolysers
Sep 2005
Publication
Hydrogen-producing high-pressure electrolysers operating with 40% potassium hydroxide solution and an applied oxygen pressure up to 30 barg have been developed. Austenitic stainless steels of type AISI316L are deemed resistant to stress corrosion cracking (SCC) in concentrated KOH solutions. However SCC has on some occasions been observed on the oxygen side of the high-pressure electrolysers thereby representing a safety risk in the operation. Several materials have been tested for resistance to SCC using C-ring specimens in autoclaves under conditions similar to the high-pressure electrolysers and at temperatures up to 120°C. The tests confirmed the observed susceptibility of austenitic stainless steels to SCC in concentrated KOH solutions. Higher alloyed austenitic stainless steels also showed SCC. Duplex stainless steel and nickel based Alloy 28 showed good resistance to SCC in the given environment. Further tests are needed to define the optimum weld procedure.
Phenomena of Dispersion and Explosion of High Pressurized Hydrogen
Sep 2005
Publication
To make “Hydrogen vehicles and refuelling station systems” fit for public use research on hydrogen safety and designing mitigative measures are significant. For compact storage it is planned to store under high pressure (40MPa) at the refuelling stations so that the safety for the handling of high-pressurized hydrogen is essential. This paper describes the experimental investigation on the hypothetical dispersion and explosion of high-pressurized hydrogen gas which leaks through a large scale break in piping and blows down to atmosphere. At first we investigated time history of distribution of gas concentration in order to comprehend the behaviour of the dispersion of high-pressurized hydrogen gas before explosion experiments. The explosion experiments were carried out with changing the time of ignition after the start of dispersion. Hydrogen gas with the initial pressure of 40MPa was released through a nozzle of 10mm diameter. Through these experiments it was clarified that the explosion power depends not only on the concentration and volume of hydrogen/air pre-mixture but also on the turbulence characteristics before ignition. To clarify the explosion mechanism the numerical computer simulation about the same experimental conditions was performed. The initial conditions such as hydrogen distribution and turbulent characteristics were given by the results of the atmospheric diffusion simulation. By the verification of these experiments the results of CFD were fully improved.
Analysis of Jet Flames and Unignited Jets from Unintended Releases of Hydrogen
Sep 2007
Publication
A combined experimental and modeling program is being carried out at Sandia National Laboratories to characterize and predict the behavior of unintended hydrogen releases. In the case where the hydrogen leak remains unignited knowledge of the concentration field and flammability envelope is an issue of importance in determining consequence distances for the safe use of hydrogen. In the case where a high-pressure leak of hydrogen is ignited a classic turbulent jet flame forms. Knowledge of the flame length and thermal radiation heat flux distribution is important to safety. Depending on the effective diameter of the leak and the tank source pressure free jet flames can be extensive in length and pose significant radiation and impingement hazard resulting in consequence distances that are unacceptably large. One possible mitigation strategy to potentially reduce the exposure to jet flames is to incorporate barriers around hydrogen storage equipment. The reasoning is that walls will reduce the extent of unacceptable consequences due to jet releases resulting from accidents involving high-pressure equipment. While reducing the jet extent the walls may introduce other hazards if not configured properly. The goal of this work is to provide guidance on configuration and placement of these walls to minimize overall hazards using a quantitative risk assessment approach. Detailed Navier-Stokes calculations of jet flames and unignited jets are used to understand how hydrogen leaks and jet-flames interact with barriers. The effort is complemented by an experimental program that considers the interaction of jet flames and unignited jets with barriers.
Massive H2 Production With Nuclear Heating, Safety Approach For Coupling A VHTR With An Iodine Sulfur Process Cycle
Sep 2005
Publication
In the frame of a sustainable development investigations dealing with massive Hydrogen production by means of nuclear heating are carried out at CEA. For nuclear safety thermodynamic efficiency and waste minimization purposes the technological solution privileged is the coupling of a gas cooled Very High Temperature Reactor (VHTR) with a plant producing Hydrogen from an Iodine/Sulfur (I/S) thermochemical cycle. Each of the aforementioned facilities presents different risks resulting from the operation of a nuclear reactor (VHTR) and from a chemical plant including Hydrogen other flammable and/or explosible substances as well as toxic ones. Due to these various risks the safety approach is an important concern. Therefore this paper deals with the preliminary CEA investigations on the safety issues devoted to the whole plant focusing on the safety questions related to the coupling between the nuclear reactor and the Hydrogen production facility. Actually the H2 production process and the energy distribution network between the plants are currently at a preliminary design stage. A general safety approach is proposed based on a Defence In Depth (DID) principle permitting to analyze all the system configurations successively in normal incidental and accidental expected operating conditions. More precisely the dynamic answer of an installation to a perturbation affecting the other one during the previous conditions as well as the potential aggressions of the chemical plant towards the nuclear reactor have to be considered. The methodology presented in this paper is intended to help the designer to take into account the coupling safety constraints and to provide some recommendations on the global architecture of both plants especially on their coupling system. As a result the design of a VHTR combined to a H2 production process will require an iterative process between design and safety requirements.
A Reappraisal of Containment Safety Under Hydrogen Detonation
Sep 2005
Publication
The response of a typical steel-lined reinforced concrete nuclear reactor containment to postulated internal hydrogen detonations is investigated by detailed axisymetric non-linear dynamic finite element analysis. The wall pressure histories are calculated for hydrogen detonations using a technique that reproduces the sharp discontinuity at the shock front. The pressure results can be applied to geometrically similar vessels. The analysis indicates that the response is more sensitive to the point of initiation than to the strength of the detonation. Approximate solutions based on a pure impulse assumption where the containment is modelled as a single-degree-of freedom (SDOF) system may be seriously unconservative. This work becomes relevant because new nuclear reactors are foreseen as a primary of source of hydrogen supply.<br/><br/>
Development of Hydrogen Sensors and Recombiners
Sep 2005
Publication
Hydrogen energy is very promising as it ensures a high efficiency and ecological cleanliness of energy conversion. The goal of the present work is to provide the analysis of hydrogen safety aspects and to prescribe methods of safety operation with hydrogen. The authors conducted a hazard analysis of hydrogen operation and storage in comparison with other fuels. Good ventilation is the main hydrogen operation requirement. Besides an effective way of protection against propagation of hazards (for instance leaks) is neutralization of dangerous hydrogen-air mixtures by a method of controlled catalytic combustion inside special devices so-called recombiners [1-3]. The basis of these devices is a high porosity cell material (HPCM) activated by platinum deposition. Apart from recombiners HPCM was also applied for development of hydrogen detectors intended for measurement and analysis of hydrogen concentration for hydrogen-driven transport and objects of hydrogen infrastructure (including vapor-air media at high pressure and temperatures). A system of hydrogen safety based on hydrogen detectors and hydrogen catalytic recombiners was developed. Experimental and theoretical studies of hydrogen combustion processes heat- and mass transfer and also gas flows in catalytic-activated HPCM allowed for a design optimization of recombiners and their location. Pilot hydrogen detectors and hydrogen catalytic recombiners were fabricated and their laboratory tests were successfully performed. Thus it was indicated that on condition of following the appropriate passive and active safety measures hydrogen is just as safe as the other fuels. This conclusion represents another incentive for a transition to the hydrogen energy.
Consequence Assessment of the BBC Hydrogen Refuelling Station, Using The Adrea-Hf Code
Sep 2009
Publication
Within the framework of the internal project HyQRA of the HYSAFE Network of Excellence (NoE) funded by the European Commission (EC) the participating partners were requested to apply their Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA) methodologies on a predefined hypothetical gaseous H2 refuelling station named BBC (Benchmark Base Case). The overall aim of the HyQRA project was to perform an inter-comparison of the various QRA approaches and to identify the knowledge gaps on data and information needed in the QRA steps specifically related to H2. Partners NCSRD and UNIPI collaborated on a common QRA. UNIPI identified the hazards on site selected the most critical ones defined the events that could be the primary cause of an accident and provided to NCSRD the scenarios listed in risk order for the evaluation of the consequences. NCSRD performed the quantitative analysis using the ADREA-HF CFD code. The predicted risk assessment parameters (flammable H2 mass and volume time histories and maximum horizontal and vertical distances of the LFL from the source) were provided to UNIPI to analyze the consequences and to evaluate the risk and distances of damage. In total 15 scenarios were simulated. Five of them were H2 releases in confined ventilated spaces (inside the compression and the purification/drying buildings). The remaining 10 scenarios were releases in open/semi-confined spaces (in the storage cabinet storage bank and refuelling hose of one dispenser). This paper presents the CFD methodology applied for the quantitative analysis of the common UNIPI/NCSRD QRA and discusses the results obtained from the performed calculations.
Development of Tools for Risk Assessment and Risk Communication for Hydrogen Applications
Sep 2005
Publication
For decades risk assessment has been an important tool in risk management of activities in several industries world wide. It provides among others authorities and stakeholders with a sound basis for creating awareness about existing and potential hazards and risks and making decisions related to how they can prioritise and plan expenditures on risk reduction. The overall goal of the ongoing HySafe project is to contribute to the safe transition to a more sustainable development in Europe by facilitating the safe introduction of hydrogen technologies and applications. An essential element in this is the demonstration of safety: that all safety aspects related to production transportation and public use are controlled to avoid that introducing hydrogen as energy carrier should pose unacceptable risk to the society.<br/>History has proven that introducing risk analysis to new industries is beneficial e.g. in transportation and power production and distribution. However this will require existing methods and standards to be adapted to the specific applications. Furthermore when trying to quantify risk it is of utmost importance to have access to relevant accident and incident information. Such data may in many cases not be readily available and the utilisation of them will then require specific and long lasting data collection initiatives.<br/>In this paper we will present the work that has been undertaken in the HySafe project in developing methodologies and collecting data for risk management of hydrogen infrastructure. Focus is laid on the development of risk acceptance criteria and on the demonstration of safety and benefits to the public. A trustworthy demonstration of safety will have to be based on facts especially on facts widely known and emphasis will thus be put on the efforts taken to establish and operate a database containing hydrogen accident and incident information which can be utilised in risk assessment of hydrogen applications. A demonstration of safety will also have to include a demonstration of risk control measures and the paper will also present work carried out on safety distances and ignition source control.
A Survey Among Experts of Safety Related to the Use of Hydrogen as an Energy Carrier
Sep 2005
Publication
Based on the increasing need of energy for the future and the related risks to the environments due to burning of fossils fuels hydrogen is seen as an efficient and application related clean energy carrier that may be derived from renewable energy sources. A variety of applications connected with production and use of hydrogen and the related risks have been identified and a survey has been conducted among a number of experts as an internet exercise for unveiling the potential lack of necessary knowledge in order to handle hydrogen in a safe way concerning the various applications. The main results concern hazardous situations related to release and explosions of hydrogen in confined and semi-confined areas tunnels and garages and mitigation of hazardous situations i.e. preventions of accidents and reduction of consequences from accidents happening anyway.
CFD Modeling of Hydrogen Dispersion Experiments for SAE J2578 Test Methods Development
Sep 2007
Publication
This paper discusses the results of validation of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) modelling of hydrogen releases and dispersion inside a metal container imitating a single car garage based on experimental results. The said experiments and modelling were conducted as part of activities to predict fuel cell vehicles discharge flammability and potential build-up of hydrogen for the development of test procedures for the Recommended Practice for General Fuel Cell Vehicle Safety SAE J2578. The experimental setup included 9 hydrogen detectors located in each corner and in the middle of the roof of the container and a fan to ensure uniform mixing of the released hydrogen. The PHOENICS CFD software package was used to solve the continuity momentum and concentration equations with the appropriate boundary conditions buoyancy effect and turbulence models. Obtained modelling results matched experimental data of a high-rate injection of hydrogen with fan-forced dispersion used to create near-uniform mixtures with a high degree of accuracy. This supports the conclusion that CFD modelling will be able to predict potential accumulation of hydrogen beyond the experimental conditions. CFD modelling of hydrogen concentrations has proven to be reliable effective and relatively inexpensive tool to evaluate the effects of hydrogen discharge from hydrogen powered vehicles or other hydrogen containing equipment.
CFD Simulation Study to Investigate the Risk from Hydrogen Vehicles in Tunnels
Sep 2007
Publication
When introducing hydrogen-fuelled vehicles an evaluation of the potential change in risk level should be performed. It is widely accepted that outdoor accidental releases of hydrogen from single vehicles will disperse quickly and not lead to any significant explosion hazard. The situation may be different for more confined situations such as parking garages workshops or tunnels. Experiments and computer modelling are both important for understanding the situation better. This paper reports a simulation study to examine what if any is the explosion risk associated with hydrogen vehicles in tunnels. Its aim was to further our understanding of the phenomena surrounding hydrogen releases and combustion inside road tunnels and furthermore to demonstrate how a risk assessment methodology developed for the offshore industry could be applied to the current task. This work is contributing to the EU Sixth Framework (Network of Excellence) project HySafe aiding the overall understanding that is also being collected from previous studies new experiments and other modelling activities. Releases from hydrogen cars (containing 700 bar gas tanks releasing either upwards or downwards or liquid hydrogen tanks releasing only upwards) and buses (containing 350 bar gas tanks releasing upwards) for two different tunnel layouts and a range of longitudinal ventilation conditions have been studied. The largest release modelled was 20 kg H2 from four cylinders in a bus (via one vent) in 50 seconds with an initial release rate around 1000 g/s. Comparisons with natural gas (CNG) fuelled vehicles have also been performed. The study suggests that for hydrogen vehicles a typical worst-case risk assessment approach assuming the full gas inventory being mixed homogeneously at stoichiometry could lead to severe explosion loads. However a more extensive study with more realistic release scenarios reduced the predicted hazard significantly. The flammable gas cloud sizes were still large for some of the scenarios but if the actual reactivity of the predicted clouds is taken into account very moderate worst-case explosion pressures are predicted. As a final step of the risk assessment approach a probabilistic QRA study is performed in which probabilities are assigned to different scenarios time dependent ignition modelling is applied and equivalent stoichiometric gas clouds are used to translate reactivity of dispersed nonhomogeneous clouds. The probabilistic risk assessment study is based on over 200 dispersion and explosion CFD calculations using the commercially available tool FLACS. The risk assessment suggested a maximum likely pressure level of 0.1-0.3 barg at the pressure sensors that were used in the study. Somewhat higher pressures are seen elsewhere due to reflections (e.g. under the vehicles). Several other interesting observations were found in the study. For example the study suggests that for hydrogen releases the level of longitudinal tunnel ventilation has only a marginal impact on the predicted risk since the momentum of the releases and buoyancy of hydrogen dominates the mixing and dilution processes.
Collaborative Activities On Hydrogen Safety under the International Energy Agency’s Hydrogen Implementing
Sep 2005
Publication
In October 2004 the International Energy Agency Hydrogen Implementing Agreement (www.ieahia.org) approved the initiation of a collaborative task on hydrogen safety. During the past twelve months a work plan has been established and several member countries have committed to participate. Because of the nature of the International Energy Agency which is an international agreement between governments it is hoped that such collaboration will complement other cooperative efforts to help build the technology base around which codes and standards can be developed. In this way the new task on hydrogen safety will further the IEA Hydrogen Agreement in fulfilling its mission to accelerate the commercial introduction of hydrogen energy. This paper describes the specific scope and work plan for the collaboration that has been developed to date.
Determination Of Hazardous Zones For A Generic Hydrogen Station – A Case Study
Sep 2007
Publication
A method for determination of hazardous zones for hydrogen installations has been studied. This work has been carried out within the NoE HySafe. The method is based on the Italian Method outlined in Guide 31-30(2004) Guide 31–35(2001) Guide 31-35/A(2001) and Guide 31-35/A; V1(2003). Hazardous zones for a “generic hydrogen refuelling station”(HRS) are assessed based on this method. The method is consistent with the EU directive 1999/92/EC “Safety and Health Protection of Workers potentially at risk from explosive atmospheres” which is the basis for determination of hazardous zones in Europe. This regulation is focused on protection of workers and is relevant for hydrogen installations such as hydrogen refuelling stations repair shops and other stationary installations where some type of work operations will be involved. The method is also based on the IEC standard and European norm IEC/EN60079-10 “Electrical apparatus for explosive gas atmospheres. Part 10 Classification of hazardous areas”. This is a widely acknowledged international standard/norm and it is accepted/approved by Fire and Safety Authorities in Europe and also internationally. Results from the HySafe work and other studies relevant for hydrogen and hydrogen installations have been included in the case study. Sensitivity studies have been carried out to examine the effect of varying equipment failure frequencies and leak sizes as well as environmental condition (ventilation obstacles etc.). The discharge and gas dispersion calculations in the Italian Method are based on simple mathematical formulas. However in this work also CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamics) and other simpler numerical tools have been used to quantitatively estimate the effect of ventilation and of different release locations on the size of the flammable gas cloud. Concentration limits for hydrogen to be used as basis for the extent of the hazardous zones in different situations are discussed.
Hydrogen Detection- Visualisation of Hydrogen Using Non Invasive Optical Schlieren Technique BOS
Sep 2005
Publication
The detection of hydrogen after its accidental release is not only important for research purposes but will be much more important under safety aspects for future applications when hydrogen should be a standard energy resource. At Fraunhofer ICT two principally different approaches were made: first the new optical background-oriented schlieren method (BOS) is used for the visualization of hydrogen distribution and mixing processes at a rate of up to 1000 frames per second. The results from experiments with small scale injection of hydrogen/air–mixtures into air flows and free jets of hydrogen and hydrogen/air–mixtures emerging from 1” hoses simulating exhaust pipes will be discussed and interpreted with support from selected high speed videos. Finally mixing zones and safety distances can be determined by this powerful method.
Safety Study of Hydrogen Supply Stations for the Review of High Pressure Gas Safety Law in Japan
Sep 2005
Publication
A safety study of gaseous hydrogen supply stations with 40MPa storage system is undertaken through a risk based approach. Accident scenarios are identified based on a generic model of hydrogen station. And risks of identified accident scenarios are estimated and evaluated comparing with risk acceptance criteria. Also safety measures for risk reduction are discussed. Especially for clearance distance it is proposed that the distance from high-pressurized equipment to site borders should be at least 6 meters. As a result of the study it is concluded that risks of accidental scenarios can be mitigated to acceptable level under the proposed safety measures with several exceptions. These exceptional scenarios are very unlikely to occur but expected to have extremely severe consequence once occurred.
HySafe European Network of Excellence on Hydrogen Safety
Sep 2005
Publication
Introduction and commercialisation of hydrogen as an energy carrier of the future make great demands on all aspects of safety. Safety is a critical issue for innovations as it influences the economic attractiveness and public acceptance of any new idea or product. However research and safety expertise related to hydrogen is quite fragmented in Europe. The vision of a significant increased use of hydrogen as an energy carrier in Europe could not go ahead without strengthening and merging this expertise. This was the reason for the European Commission to support the launch on the first of March 2004 of a so-called Network of Excellence (NoE) on hydrogen safety: HySafe.
An Inter-Comparison Exercise on the Capabilities of CFD Models to Predict the Short and Long Term Distribution and Mixing of Hydrogen in a Garage
Sep 2007
Publication
Alexandros G. Venetsanos,
E. Papanikolaou,
J. García,
Olav Roald Hansen,
Matthias Heitsch,
Asmund Huser,
Wilfried Jahn,
Jean-Marc Lacome,
Thomas Jordan,
H. S. Ledin,
Dmitry Makarov,
Prankul Middha,
Etienne Studer,
Andrei V. Tchouvelev,
Franck Verbecke,
M. M. Voort,
Andrzej Teodorczyk and
M. A. Delichatsios
The paper presents the results of the CFD inter-comparison exercise SBEP-V3 performed within the activity InsHyde internal project of the HYSAFE network of excellence in the framework of evaluating the capability of various CFD tools and modelling approaches in predicting the physical phenomena associated to the short and long term mixing and distribution of hydrogen releases in confined spaces. The experiment simulated was INERIS-TEST-6C performed within the InsHyde project by INERIS consisting of a 1 g/s vertical hydrogen release for 240 s from an orifice of 20 mm diameter into a rectangular room (garage) of dimensions 3.78x7.2x2.88 m in width length and height respectively. Two small openings at the front and bottom side of the room assured constant pressure conditions. During the test hydrogen concentration time histories were measured at 12 positions in the room for a period up to 5160 s after the end of release covering both the release and the subsequent diffusion phases. The benchmark was organized in two phases. The first phase consisted of blind simulations performed prior to the execution of the tests. The second phase consisted of post calculations performed after the tests were concluded and the experimental results made available. The participation in the benchmark was high: 12 different organizations (2 non-HYSAFE partners) 10 different CFD codes and 8 different turbulence models. Large variation in predicted results was found in the first phase of the benchmark between the various modelling approaches. This was attributed mainly to differences in turbulence models and numerical accuracy options (time/space resolution and discretization schemes). During the second phase of the benchmark the variation between predicted results was reduced.
Compatibility of Metallic Materials with Hydrogen Review of the Present Knowledge
Sep 2007
Publication
In this document after a review of the accidents/incidents are described the different interactions between hydrogen gas and the most commonly used materials including the influence of "internal" and "external" hydrogen the phenomena occurring in all ranges of temperatures and pressures and Hydrogen Embrittlement (HE) created by gaseous hydrogen. The principle of all the test methods used to investigate this phenomenon are presented and discussed. The advantages and disadvantages of each method will be explained. The document also covers the influence of all the parameters related to HE including the ones related to the material itself the ones related to the design and manufacture of the equipment and the ones related to the hydrogen itself (pressure temperature purity etc). Finally recommendations to avoid repetition of accidents/incidents mentioned before are proposed.
The Safe Use of the Existing Natural Gas System for Hydrogen (Overview of the NATURALHY-Project)
Sep 2005
Publication
The transition period towards the situation in which hydrogen will become an important energy carrier will be lengthy (decades) costly and needs a significant R&D effort. It’s clear therefore that the development of a hydrogen system requires a practical strategy within the context of the existing assets. Examining the potential of the existing extensive natural gas chain (transmission - distribution - end user infrastructures and appliances) is a logical first step towards the widespread delivery of hydrogen.
The project will define the conditions under which hydrogen can be mixed with natural gas for delivery by the existing natural gas system and later withdrawn selectively from the pipeline system by advanced separation technologies. Membranes will be developed to enable this separation. The socio-economic and life cycle consequences of this hydrogen delivery approach will be mapped out. By adding hydrogen to natural gas the physical and chemical properties of the mixture will differ from “pure” natural gas. As this may have a major effect on safety issues and durability issues (which also have a safety component) related to the gas delivery and the performance of end use appliances these issues are particularly addressed in the project.
The project is executed by a European consortium of 39 partners (including 15 from the gas industry). In this project set up under the auspices of GERG The European Gas Research Group there are leading roles for N.V. Nederlandse Gasunie (NL) Gaz de France (F) TNO (NL) ISQ (P) the Universities of Loughborough and Warwick (UK) and Exergia (GR). Guidance will be provided by a Strategic Advisory Committee consisting of representatives from relevant (inter)national organizations.
The project started on 1st May 2004 and will run for 5 years. The European Commission has selected the Integrated Project NATURALHY for financial support within the Sixth Framework Programme.
The project will define the conditions under which hydrogen can be mixed with natural gas for delivery by the existing natural gas system and later withdrawn selectively from the pipeline system by advanced separation technologies. Membranes will be developed to enable this separation. The socio-economic and life cycle consequences of this hydrogen delivery approach will be mapped out. By adding hydrogen to natural gas the physical and chemical properties of the mixture will differ from “pure” natural gas. As this may have a major effect on safety issues and durability issues (which also have a safety component) related to the gas delivery and the performance of end use appliances these issues are particularly addressed in the project.
The project is executed by a European consortium of 39 partners (including 15 from the gas industry). In this project set up under the auspices of GERG The European Gas Research Group there are leading roles for N.V. Nederlandse Gasunie (NL) Gaz de France (F) TNO (NL) ISQ (P) the Universities of Loughborough and Warwick (UK) and Exergia (GR). Guidance will be provided by a Strategic Advisory Committee consisting of representatives from relevant (inter)national organizations.
The project started on 1st May 2004 and will run for 5 years. The European Commission has selected the Integrated Project NATURALHY for financial support within the Sixth Framework Programme.
Hydrogen Transport Safety: Case of Compressed Gaseous Tube Trailer
Sep 2005
Publication
The following paper describes researches to evaluate the behaviour under various accidental conditions of systems of transport compressed hydrogen. Particularly have been considered gaseous tube trailer and the packages cylinders employed for the road transport which have an internal gas pressures up to 200 barg.<br/>Further to a verification of the actual safety conditions this analysis intends to propose a theme that in the next future if confirmed projects around the employment of hydrogen as possible source energetic alternative could become quite important. The general increase of the consumptions of hydrogen and the consequently probable increase of the transports of gaseous hydrogen in pressure they will make the problem of the safety of the gaseous tube trail particularly important. Gaseous tube trailers will also use as components of plant. for versatility easy availability' and inexpensiveness.<br/>The first part of the memory is related to the analysis of the accidents happened in the last year in Italy with compressed hydrogen transports and particularly an accurate study has been made on the behaviour of a gaseous tube trailer involved in fire following a motorway accident in March 2003. In the central part of the job has been done a safety analysis of the described events trying to make to also emerge the most critical elements towards the activities developed by the teams of help intervened.<br/>Finally in the last part you are been listed on the base of the picked data a series of proposals and indications of the possible structural and procedural changes that could be suggested with the purpose to guarantee more elevated safety levels.
Fundamental Safety Testing and Analysis of Solid State Hydrogen Storage Materials and Systems
Sep 2007
Publication
Hydrogen is seen as the future automobile energy storage media due to its inherent cleanliness upon oxidation and its ready utilization in fuel cell applications. Its physical storage in light weight low volume systems is a key technical requirement. In searching for ever higher gravimetric and volumetric density hydrogen storage materials and systems it is inevitable that higher energy density materials will be studied and used. To make safe and commercially acceptable systems it is important to understand quantitatively the risks involved in using and handling these materials and to develop appropriate risk mitigation strategies to handle unforeseen accidental events. To evaluate these materials and systems an IPHE sanctioned program was initiated in 2006 partnering laboratories from Europe North America and Japan. The objective of this international program is to understanding the physical risks involved in synthesis handling and utilization of solid state hydrogen storage materials and to develop methods to mitigate these risks. This understanding will support ultimate acceptance of commercially high density hydrogen storage system designs. An overview of the approaches to be taken to achieve this objective will be given. Initial experimental results will be presented on environmental exposure of NaAlH4 a candidate high density hydrogen storage compound. The tests to be shown are based on United Nations recommendations for the transport of hazardous materials and include air and water exposure of the hydride at three hydrogen charge levels in various physical configurations. Additional tests developed by the American Society for Testing and Materials were used to quantify the dust cloud ignition characteristics of this material which may result from accidental high energy impacts and system breach. Results of these tests are shown along with necessary risk mitigation techniques used in the synthesis and fabrication of a prototype hydrogen storage system.
Fire Prevention Technical Rule for Gaseous Hydrogen Transport in Pipelines
Sep 2007
Publication
This paper presents the current results of the theoretical and experimental activity carried out by the Italian Working Group on the fire prevention safety issues in the field of the hydrogen transport in pipelines. From the theoretical point of view a draft document has been produced beginning from the regulations in force on the natural gas pipelines; these have been reviewed corrected and integrated with the instructions suitable to the use with hydrogen gas. From the experimental point of view a suitable apparatus has been designed and installed at the University of Pisa; this apparatus will allow the simulation of hydrogen releases from a pipeline with or without ignition of the hydrogen-air mixture. The experimental data will help the completion of the above-mentioned draft document with the instructions about the safety distances. However in the opinion of the Group the work on the text contents is concluded and the document is ready to be discussed with the Italian stakeholders involved in the hydrogen applications.
Compatibility of Materials with Hydrogen Particular Case- Hydrogen Assisted Stress Cracking of Titanium Alloys
Sep 2007
Publication
A review of the effect of hydrogen on materials is addressed in this paper. General aspects of the interaction of hydrogen and materials hydrogen embrittlement low temperature effects material suitability for hydrogen service and materials testing are the main subjects considered in the first part of the paper. As a particular case of the effect of hydrogen in materials the hydride formation of titanium alloys is considered. Alpha titanium alloys are considered corrosion resistant materials in a wide range of environments. However hydrogen absorption and the possible associated problems must be taken into account when considering titanium as a candidate material for high responsibility applications. The sensitivity of three different titanium alloys Ti Gr-2 Ti Gr-5 and Ti Gr-12 to the Hydrogen Assisted Stress Cracking phenomena has been studied by means of the Slow Strain Rate Technique (SSRT). The testing media has been sea water and hydrogen has been produced on the specimen surface during the test by cathodic polarization. Tested specimens have been characterized by metallography and scanning electron microscopy. Results obtained show that the microstructure of the materials particularly the β phase content plays an important role on the sensitivity of the studied alloys to the Hydrogen Assisted Stress Cracking Phenomena.
Numerical Analysis for Hydrogen Flame Acceleration during a Severe Accident Initiated by SBLOCA in the APR1400 Containment
Jan 2022
Publication
We performed a hydrogen combustion analysis in the Advanced Power Reactor 1400 MWe (APR1400) containment during a severe accident initiated by a small break loss of coolant accident (SBLOCA) which occurred at a lower part of the cold leg using a multi-dimensional hydrogen analysis system (MHAS) to confirm the integrity of the APR1400 containment. The MHAS was developed by combining MAAP GASFLOW and COM3D to simulate hydrogen release distribution and combustion in the containment of a nuclear power plant during the severe accidents in the containment of a nuclear power reactor. The calculated peak pressure due to the flame acceleration by the COM3D using the GASFLOW results as an initial condition of the hydrogen distribution was approximately 555 kPa which is lower than the fracture pressure 1223 kPa of the APR1400 containment. To induce a higher peak pressure resulted from a strong flame acceleration in the containment we intentionally assumed several things in developing an accident scenario of the SBLOCA. Therefore we may judge that the integrity of the APR1400 containment can be maintained even though the hydrogen combustion occurs during the severe accident initiated by the SBLOCA.
Hydrogen Refueling Stations: Safe Filling Procedures
Sep 2005
Publication
Safety is a high priority for a hydrogen refueling station. Here we propose a method to safely refuel a vehicle at optimised speed of filling with minimum information about it. Actually we identify two major risks during a vehicle refuelling: over filling and overheating. These two risks depend on the temperature increase in the tank during refuelling. But the inside temperature is a difficult information to get from the station point of view. It assumes a temperature sensor in a representative place of the tank and an additional connection between the vehicle and the station for data exchange. The refuelling control may not depend on this parameter only. Therefore out objective was to effectively control the filling particularly to avoid the two identified risks independently of optional and safety redundant information from the vehicle. For that purpose we defined a maximum filling pressure which corresponds to the most severe following conditions: if the maximum temperature is reached in the tank or if the maximum capacity is reached in the tank. This maximum pressure depends on a few filling parameters which are easily available. The method and its practical applications are depicted.
CFD Simulations of Hydrogen Release and Dispersion Inside the Storage Room of a Hydrogen Refuelling Station Using the ADREA-HF Code
Sep 2007
Publication
The paper presents CFD simulations of high pressure hydrogen release and dispersion inside the storage room of realistic hydrogen refuelling station and comparison to experimental data. The experiments were those reported by Tanaka et al. (2005) carried out inside an enclosure 5 m wide 6 m long and 4 m high having 1 m high ventilation opening on all sidewalls (half or fully open) containing an array of 35 x 250 L cylinders. The scenarios investigated were 40 MPa storage pressure horizontal releases from the center of the room from one cylinder with orifices of diameters 0.8 1.6 and 8 mm. The release calculations were performed using GAJET integral code. The CFD dispersion simulations were performed using the ADREA-HF CFD code. The structure of the flow and the mixing patterns were also investigated by presenting the predicted hydrogen concentration field. Finally the effects of release parameters natural ventilation and wind conditions were analyzed too.
Modelling of Lean Uniform and Non-Uniform Hydrogen-Air Mixture Explosions in a Closed Vessel
Sep 2009
Publication
Simulation of hydrogen-air mixture explosions in a closed large-scale vessel with uniform and nonuniform mixture compositions was performed by the group of partners within the EC funded project “Hydrogen Safety as an Energy Carrier” (HySafe). Several experiments were conducted previously by Whitehouse et al. in a 10.7 m3 vertically oriented (5.7-m high) cylindrical facility with different hydrogen-air mixture compositions. Two particular experiments were selected for simulation and comparison as a Standard Benchmark Exercise (SBEP) problem: combustion of uniform 12.8% (vol.) hydrogen-air mixture and combustion of non-uniform hydrogen-air mixture with average 12.6% (vol.) hydrogen concentration across the vessel (vertical stratification 27% vol. hydrogen at the top of the vessel 2.5% vol. hydrogen at the bottom of the vessel); both mixtures were ignited at the top of the vessel. The paper presents modelling approaches used by the partners comparison of simulation results against the experiment data and conclusions regarding the non-uniform mixture combustion modelling in real-life applications.
Agent-Based as an Alternative to Prognostic Modelling of Safety Risks in Hydrogen Energy Scenarios
Sep 2005
Publication
Interest in the future is not new. Economic constraints and acceptability considerations of today compel decision-makers from industry and authorities to speculate on possible safety risks originating from a hydrogen economy developed in the future. Tools that support thinking about the long-term consequences of today's actions and resulting technical systems are usually prognostic based on data from past performance of past or current systems. It has become convention to assume that the performance of future systems in future environments can be accommodated in the uncertainties of such prognostic models resulting from sensitivity studies. This paper presents an alternative approach to modelling future systems based on narratives about the future. Such narratives based on the actions and interactions of individual "agents" are powerful means for addressing anxiety about engaging the imagination in order to prepare for events that are likely to occur detect critical conditions and to thus achieve desirable outcomes. This is the methodological base of Agent-Based Models (ABM) and this paper will present the approach discuss its strengths and weaknesses and present a preliminary application to modelling safety risks related to energy scenarios in a possible future hydrogen economy.
Addressing Hydrogen Embrittlement of Metals in the Sae J2579 Fuel Cell Vehicle Tank Standard
Sep 2013
Publication
The SAE Technical Information Report (TIR) J2579 (Technical Information Report for Fuel Systems in Fuel Cell and Other Hydrogen Vehicles) has been created to address the safety performance of hydrogen storage and handling systems on vehicles. Safety qualification of the compressed hydrogen storage system is demonstrated through performance testing on prototype containment vessels. The two performance tests currently included in the SAE J2579 for evaluating unacceptable leakage and burst do not account for the potential effects of hydrogen embrittlement on structural integrity. This report describes efforts to address hydrogen embrittlement of structural metals in the framework of performance-based safety qualification. New safety qualification pathways that account for hydrogen embrittlement in the SAE J2579 include an additional pneumatic performance test using hydrogen gas or materials tests that demonstrate acceptable hydrogen embrittlement resistance of candidate structural metals.
Safety-Barrier Diagrams for Documenting Safety of Hydrogen Applications
Sep 2007
Publication
Safety-barrier diagrams have proven to be a useful tool in documenting the safety measures taken to prevent incidents and accidents in process industry. In Denmark they are used to inform the authorities and the nonexperts on safety relevant issues as safety-barrier diagrams are less complex compared to fault trees and are easy to understand. Internationally there is a growing interest in this concept with the use of so-called “bowtie” diagrams which are a special case of safety-barrier diagrams. Especially during the on-going introduction of new hydrogen technologies or applications as e.g. hydrogen refueling stations this technique is considered a valuable tool to support the communication with authorities and other stakeholders during the permitting process. Another advantage of safety-barrier diagrams is that there is a direct focus on those system elements that need to be subject to safety management in terms of design and installation operational use inspection and monitoring and maintenance. Safety-barrier diagrams support both quantitative and qualitative or deterministic approaches. The paper will describe the background and syntax of the methodology and thereafter the use of such diagrams for hydrogen technologies are demonstrated.
Experimental and Numerical Investigation of Hydrogen Gas Auto-ignition
Sep 2007
Publication
This paper describes hydrogen self-ignition as a result of the formation of a shock wave in front of a high-pressure hydrogen gas propagating in the tube and the semi-confined space for which the numerical and experimental investigation was done. An increase in the temperature behind the shock wave leads to the ignition on the contact surface of the mixture of combustible gas with air. The required condition of combustible self-ignition is to maintain the high temperature in the mixture for a time long enough for inflammation to take place. Experimental technique was based on a high-pressure chamber inflating with hydrogen burst disk failure and pressurized hydrogen discharge into tube of round or rectangular cross section filled with air. A physicochemical model involving the gas dynamic transport of a viscous gas the detailed kinetics of hydrogen oxidation k-ω differential turbulence model and the heat exchange was used for calculations of the self-ignition of high-pressure hydrogen. The results of our experiments and model calculations show that self-ignition in the emitted jet takes place. The stable development of self-ignition naturally depends on the orifice size and the pressure in the vessel a decrease in which leads to the collapse of the ignition process. The critical conditions are obtained.
The Hydrogen Executive Leadership Panel (HELP) Initiative for Emergency Responder Training
Sep 2007
Publication
In close cooperation with their Canadian counterparts United States public safety authorities are taking the first steps towards creating a proper infrastructure to ensure the safe use of the new hydrogen fuel cells now being introduced commercially. Currently public safety officials are being asked to permit hydrogen fuel cells for stationary power and as emergency power backups for the telecommunications towers that exist everywhere. Consistent application of the safety codes is difficult – in part because it is new – yet it is far more complex to train emergency responders to deal safely with the inevitable hydrogen incidents. The US and Canadian building and fire codes and standards are similar but not identical. The US and Canadian rules are unlikely to be useful to other nations without modification to suit different regulatory systems. However emergency responder safety training is potentially more universal. The risks strategies and tactics are unlikely to differ much by region. The Hydrogen Executive Leadership Panel (HELP) made emergency responder safety training its first priority because the transition to hydrogen depends on keeping incidents small and inoffensive and the public and responders safe from harm. One might think that advising 1.2 million firefighters and 800000 law enforcement officers about hydrogen risks is no more complicated than adding guidance to a website. One would be wrong. The term “training” has specific legal implications which may vary by state. For hazardous materials federal requirements apply. Insurance companies place training requirements on the policies they sell to fire departments including the thousands of small all-volunteer departments which may operate as private corporations. Union contracts may define training and promotions may be based on satisfactorily completed certain levels of training. Emergency responders could no sooner learn how to extinguish a<br/>hydrogen fire by reading a webpage than a person could learn to ride a bicycle by reading a book. Procedures must be learned by listening reading and then doing. Regular practice is necessary. As new hydrogen applications are commercialized additional responder training may be necessary. This highlights another obstacle emergency responders’ ability to travel distances and take the time to undergo training. Historically fire academies established adjunct instructor programs and satellite academies to bring the training to firefighters. The large well-equipped academies are typically used for specialized training. States rarely have enough instructors and instructors often must take the time to create a course outline research each point and produce a program that is informative useful and holds the attention of responders. The challenge of training emergency responders seems next to impossible but public safety authorities are asked to tackle the impossible every day and a model exists to move forward in the U.S. Over the past few years the National Association of State Fire Marshals and U.S. Department of Transportation enlisted the help of emergency responders and industry to create a standardized approach to train emergency responders to deal with pipeline incidents. A curriculum and training materials were created and more than 26000 sets have been distributed for free to public safety agencies nationwide. More than 8000 instructors have been trained to use these materials that are now part of the regular training in 23 states. Using this model HELP intends to ensure that all emergency responders are trained to address hydrogen risks. The model and the rigorous scenario analysis and review used to developing the operational and technical training is addressed in this paper.
Incident Reporting- Learning from Experience
Sep 2007
Publication
Experience makes a superior teacher. Sharing the details surrounding safety events is one of the best ways to help prevent their recurrence elsewhere. This approach requires an open non-punitive environment to achieve broad benefits. The Hydrogen Incident Reporting Tool (www.h2incidents.org) is intended to facilitate the sharing of lessons learned and other relevant information gained from actual experiences using and working with hydrogen and hydrogen systems. Its intended audience includes those involved in virtually any aspect of hydrogen technology systems and use with an emphasis towards energy and transportation applications. The database contains records of safety events both publicly available and/or voluntarily submitted. Typical records contain a general description of the occurrence contributing factors equipment involved and some detailing of consequences and changes that have been subsequently implemented to prevent recurrence of similar events in the future. The voluntary and confidential nature and other characteristics surrounding the database mean that any analysis of apparent trends in its contents cannot be considered statistically valid for a universal population. A large portion of reported incidents have occurred in a laboratory setting due to the typical background of the reporting projects for example. Yet some interesting trends are becoming apparent even at this early stage of the database’s existence and general lessons can already be taken away from these experiences. This paper discusses the database and a few trends that have already become apparent for the reported incidents. Anticipated future uses of this information are also described. This paper is intended to encourage wider participation and usage of the incidents reporting database and to promote the safety benefits offered by its contents.
Risk-Informed Process and Tools for Permitting Hydrogen Fueling Stations
Sep 2007
Publication
The permitting process for hydrogen fueling stations varies from country to country. However a common step in the permitting process is the demonstration that the proposed fueling station meets certain safety requirements. Currently many permitting authorities rely on compliance with well known codes and standards as a means to permit a facility. Current codes and standards for hydrogen facilities require certain safety features specify equipment made of material suitable for hydrogen environment and include separation or safety distances. Thus compliance with the code and standard requirements is widely accepted as evidence of a safe design. However to ensure that a hydrogen facility is indeed safe the code and standard requirements should be identified using a risk-informed process that utilizes an acceptable level of risk. When compliance with one or more code or standard requirements is not possible an evaluation of the risk associated with the exemptions to the requirements should be understood and conveyed to the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ). Establishment of a consistent risk assessment toolset and associated data is essential to performing these risk evaluations. This paper describes an approach for risk-informing the permitting process for hydrogen fueling stations that relies primarily on the establishment of risk-informed codes and standards. The proposed risk-informed process begins with the establishment of acceptable risk criteria associated with the operation of hydrogen fueling stations. Using accepted Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA) techniques and the established risk criteria the minimum code and standard requirements necessary to ensure the safe operation of hydrogen facilities can be identified. Risk informed permitting processes exist in some countries and are being developed in others. To facilitate consistent risk-informed approaches the participants in the International Energy Agency (IEA) Task 19 on hydrogen safety are working to identify acceptable risk criteria QRA models and supporting data.
Processes of the Formation of Large Unconfined Clouds Following a Massive Spillage of Liquid Hydrogen on the Ground
Sep 2007
Publication
Because of hydrogen low volumetric energy content under its gaseous form transport and storage of liquid hydrogen will certainly play a major role in any future hydrogen economy. One of the obstacles to the expected development use of hydrogen is the poor state of knowledge on explosion risks in the event of an extensive spillage. INERIS set up a large-scale experiment to study the mechanisms of the formation of the gas cloud resulting from such a spillage and the associated mixing process and turbulence effects. Dispersion tests have been performed with cryogenic helium presenting similar dispersion characteristics than liquid hydrogen (buoyancy). Flowrates up to 3 kg/s have been investigated and the instrumentation allowed the observation and quantification of bouyancy effects including internal turbulence. Those results constitute an originals et of data which can be used as a basis for the development of dispersion software and reinterpretation of other existing databases ([10 11])
Prediction of the Lift-off, Blow-out and Blow-off Stability Limits of Pure Hydrogen and Hydrogen and Hydrocarbon Mixture Jet Flames
Sep 2007
Publication
The paper presented experimental studies of the liftoff and blowout stability of pure hydrogen hydrogen/propane and hydrogen/methane jet flam es using a 2 mm burner. Carbon dioxide and Argon gas were also used in the study for the comparison with hydrocarbon fuel. Comparisons of the stability of H 2/C3H8 H 2/CH4 H 2/Ar and H 2/CO2 flames showed that H 2/C3H8 produced the highest liftoff height and H 2/CH4 required highest liftoff and blowoff velocities. The non-dimensional analysis of liftoff height approach was used to correlate liftoff data of H 2 H2-C3H8 H 2-CO2 C 3H8 and H2-Ar jet flames tested in the 2 mm burner. The suitability of extending the empirical correlations based on hydrocarbon flames to both hydrogen and hydrogen/ hydrocarbon flames was examined.
Testing Safety of Hydrogen Components
Sep 2007
Publication
Hydrogen as a new and ecologic energy source is tempting though it creates the challenge of ensuring the safe use of hydrogen for all future consumers. Making sure that a hydrogen vehicle can be simply and safely used by anyone while performing as expected requires that the car be light with built-in safety features. This is achieved by combining high pressure composite cylinders with strict test procedures. Composite cylinders of up to 150 L operated to a maximum of 700 bar are required for vehicle applications. Air Liquide has developed test benches to hydraulically cycle such cylinders at 1400 bar and up to 3500 bar for burst tests. These tests are performed under controlled temperature conditions at ambient and extreme temperatures in order to simulate cylinder aging. Components in gas service such as valves hoses and other pressure devices are tested up to 1400 bars with hydrogen to simulate actual usage conditions. Hydrogen is used as a testing gas instead of nitrogen which is commonly used for such tests because hydrogen interacts with materials (e.g. hydrogen embrittlement) and because hydrogen has a special thermodynamic behaviour ( pressure drop velocity heat exchange…)
Hydrogen Safety, Training and Risk Assessment System
Sep 2007
Publication
The rapid evolution of information related to hydrogen safety is multidimensional ranging from developing codes and standards to CFD simulations and experimental studies of hydrogen releases to a variety of risk assessment approaches. This information needs to be transformed into system design risk decision-making and first responder tools for use by hydrogen community stakeholders. The Canadian Transportation Fuel Cell Alliance (CTFCA) has developed HySTARtm an interactive Hydrogen Safety Training And Risk System. The HySTARtm user interacts with a Web-based 3-D graphical user interface to input hydrogen system configurations. The system includes a Codes and Standards Expert System that identifies the applicable codes and standards in a number of national jurisdictions that apply to the facility and its components. A Siting Compliance and Planning Expert System assesses compliance with clearance distance requirements in these jurisdictions. Incorporating the results of other CTFCA projects HySTARtm identifies stand-out hydrogen release scenarios and their corresponding release condition that serves as input to built-in consequence and risk assessment programs that output a variety of risk assessment metrics. The latter include on- and off-site individual risk probability of loss of life and expected number of fatalities. These results are displayed on the graphical user interface used to set up the facility. These content and graphical tools are also used to educate regulatory approval and permitting officials and build a first-responder training guide.
Numerical Study of Spontaneous Ignition of Pressurized Hydrogen Release into Air
Sep 2007
Publication
Numerical simulations have been carried out for spontaneous ignition of pressurized hydrogen release directly into air. Results showed a possible mechanism for spontaneous ignition due to molecular diffusion. To accurately calculate the molecular transport of species momentum and energy in a multi-component gaseous mixture a mixture-averaged multi-component approach was employed in which thermal diffusion is accounted for. To reduce false numerical diffusion extremely fine meshes were used along with the ALE (Arbitrary Lagrangian-Eulerian) method. The ALE method was employed to track the moving contact surface with moving clustered grids. A detailed kinetic scheme with 21 elementary steps and 8 reactive chemical species was implemented for combustion chemistry. The scheme gives due consideration to third body reactions and reaction-rate pressure-dependant “fall-off” behavior. The autoignition of pressurized hydrogen release was previously observed in laboratory tests [2-3] and suspected as possible cause of some accidents. The present numerical study successfully captured this scenario. Autoignition was predicted to first take place at the tip region of the hydrogen-air contact surface due to mass and energy exchange between low temperature hydrogen and shock-heated air at the contact surface through molecular diffusion. The initial flame thickness is extremely thin due to the limiting molecular diffusion. The combustion region extends downward along the contact surface as it moves downstream. As the hydrogen jet developed downstream the front contact surface tends to be distorted by the developed flow of the air. Turbulence plays an important role in mixing at the region of the distorted contact surface. This is thought to be a major factor for the initial laminar flame to turn into a final stable turbulent flame.
Experiments with Release and Ignition of Hydrogen Gas in a 3m Long Channel
Sep 2007
Publication
This paper presents results from laboratory experiments with hydrogen dispersions and explosions in a 3 m long channel. Our objective is to get a better understanding of the phenomena and to develop tools that can analyse hydrogen dispersions and explosions. A total of 5 test series were performed with flow rates of hydrogen from 1.8 dm³/min to 75 dm³/min. The propagation of the combustible hydrogen-air cloud in the channel was observed from high-speed video recordings. The hydrogen-air cloud in the channel behaves as a gravity current and the flow appears to be well described by Froude scaling with a length scale corresponding to the height of a layer of 100 % hydrogen. The Froude numbers observed in the experiments are in good agreement with the theory of "light-fluid intrusion" for gravity currents found in the literature. Numerical simulations with the Flacs code correlate well with the experimental results. The flame propagation indicated that approximately half the height of the channel was filled with combustible mixture. We believe that this Froude scaling can be useful as a tool to analyse the consequences of hydrogen release in buildings channels and tunnels.
Experimental Study of Hydrogen-Air Deflagrations in Flat Layer
Sep 2007
Publication
In the present paper the results of experiments on study of high-speed deflagrations in flat layer of hydrogen-air mixtures unconfined from below are presented. The experiments were performed in two different rectangular channels: small-scale with mixture volume up to 0.4 m3 and large-scale with volume up to 5.5 m3. The main goal of the experiments was to examine the possibility of the layer geometries to maintain high-speed deflagration and detonation. With the aim to study a range of combustion regimes the experiments were performed varying degree of channel obstruction hydrogen concentration and thickness of the layer. Depending on the experimental conditions all major combustion regimes were observed: slow flame fast – ‘choked’ flame and steady-state detonation. It was found that minimum layer layer thickness in the range of 8 to 15 detonation cell widths is required for sustainable detonations.
Hydrogen Refuelling Stations for Public Transport Quality and Safety in the User-interface
Sep 2007
Publication
Hydrogen stations and supply systems for public transport have been demonstrated in a number of European cities during the last four years. The first refuelling facility was put into operation in Reykjavik in April 2003. Experience from the four years of operation shows that safety related incidents are more frequent in the user interface than in the other parts of the hydrogen refuelling station (HRS). This might be expected taking into account the fact that the refuelling is manually operated and that according to industrial statistics human failures normally stand for more than 80% of all safety related incidents. On the other hand the HRS experience needs special attention since the refuelling at the existing stations is carried out by well trained personnel and that procedures and systems are followed closely. So far the quality and safety approach to hydrogen refuelling stations has been based on industrial experience. This paper addresses the challenge related to the development of safe robust and easy to operate refuelling systems. Such systems require well adapted components and system solutions as well as user procedures. The challenge to adapt the industrial based quality and safety philosophy and methodologies to new hydrogen applications and customers in the public sector is addressed. Risk based safety management and risk acceptance criteria relevant to users and third party are discussed in this context. Human factors and the use of incident reporting as a tool for continuous improvement are also addressed. The paper is based on internal development programmes for hydrogen refuelling stations in Hydro and on participation in international EU and IPHE projects such as CUTE HyFLEET:CUTE HySafe and HyApproval.
Explosion Hazard of Hydrogen-Air Mixtures in the Large Volumes
Sep 2007
Publication
The report deals with the investigation of non-stationary combustion of hydrogen-air mixtures extremely relevant to the issues of safety. Considered are the conditions of its formation and development in the tubes in the conic element and in the spherical 12-m diameter chamber. The report shows that at the formation of non-stationary combustion in the conic element in its top the pressure can develop exceeding 1000 atmospheres. It is also shown that in large closed volumes non-stationary combustion can develop from a small energy source in contrast to detonation for whose stimulation in large volumes significant power influences are required. Simultaneously in the volume a pressure can be formed by far exceeding the Chapman-Jouguet pressure in the front of stationary detonation.
Fire Prevention Technical Rule for Gaseous Hydrogen Refuelling Stations
Sep 2005
Publication
In the last years different Italian hydrogen projects provided for gaseous hydrogen motor vehicles refuelling stations. Motivated by the lack of suitable set of rules in the year 2002 Italian National Firecorps (Institute under the Italian Ministry of the Interior) formed an Ad Hoc Working Group asked to regulate the above-said stations as regards fire prevention and protection safety. This Working Group consists of members coming from both Firecorps and academic world (Pisa University). Throughout his work this Group produced a technical rule covering the fire prevention requirements for design construction and operation of gaseous hydrogen refuelling stations. This document has been approved by the Ministry’s Technical Scientific Central Committee for fire prevention (C.C.T.S.) and now it has to carry out the “Community procedure for the provision of information”. This paper describes the main safety contents of the technical rule.
Hydrogen Safety and Permitting Hydrogen Fueling Stations
Sep 2007
Publication
Two key aspects of hydrogen safety are (1) incorporating data and analysis from research development and demonstration (RD&D) into the codes and standards development process; and (2) adopting and enforcing these codes and standards by state and local permitting officials. This paper describes work that the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) is sponsoring to address these aspects of hydrogen safety. For the first DOE is working with the automobile and energy industries to identify and address high priority RD&D to establish a sound scientific basis for requirements that are incorporated in hydrogen codes and standards. The high priority RD&D needs are incorporated and tracked in an RD&D Roadmap adopted by the Codes and Standards Technical Team of the FreedomCAR and Fuel Partnership. DOE and its national laboratories conduct critical RD&D and work with key standards and model code development organizations to help incorporate RD&D results into the codes and standards process. To address the second aspect DOE has launched an initiative to facilitate the permitting process for hydrogen fueling stations (HFS). A key element of this initiative will be a Web-based information repository a toolkit that includes information fact sheets networking charts to encourage information exchange among code officials who have permitted or are in the process of permitting HFS templates to show whether a proposed station footprint conforms to requirements in the jurisdiction and a database of requirements incorporated in key codes and standards. The information repository will be augmented by workshops for code officials and station developers in jurisdictions that are likely to have HFS in the near future.
No more items...