Safety
Monte-Carlo-Analysis of Minimum Burst Requirements for Composite Cylinders for Hydrogen Service
Sep 2021
Publication
For achieving Net Zero-aims hydrogen is an indispensable component probably the main component. For the usage of hydrogen a wide acceptance is necessary which requires trust in hydrogen based on absence of major incidents resulting from a high safety level. Burst tests stand for a type of testing that is used in every test standard and regulation as one of the key issues for ensuring safety in use. The central role of burst and proof test is grown to historical reasons for steam engines and steel vessels but - with respect for composite pressure vessels (CPVs) - not due an extraordinary depth of outcomes. Its importance results from the relatively simple test process with relatively low costs and gets its importance by running of the different test variations in parallel. In relevant test und production standards (as e. g. ECE R134) the burst test is used in at least 4 different meanings. There is the burst test on a) new CPVs and some others b) for determining the residual strength subsequent to various simulations of ageing effects. Both are performed during the approval process on a pre-series. Then there is c) the batch testing during the CPVs production and finally d) the 100% proof testing which means to stop the burst test at a certain pressure level. These different aspects of burst tests are analysed and compared with respect to its importance for the resulting safety of the populations of CPVs in service based on experienced test results and Monte-Carlo simulations. As main criterial for this the expected failure rate in a probabilistic meaning is used. This finally ends up with recommendations for relevant RC&S especially with respect to GTR 13."
Hydrogen Inhibition as Explosion Prevention in Wet Metal Dust Removal Systems
Mar 2022
Publication
Hydrogen energy attracts an amount of attention as an environmentally friendly and sustainable energy source. However hydrogen is also flammable. Hydrogen fires and explosions might occur in wet-dust-removal systems if accumulated aluminum dust reacts with water. Hydrogen inhibition is a safe method to address these issues. For this purpose we used sodium citrate a renewable and nontoxic raw material to inhibit H2 formation. Specifically hydrogen inhibition experiments with sodium citrate were carried out using custom-built equipment developed by our research group. When the concentration of sodium citrate solution was in the range of 0.4–4.0 g/L a protective coating was formed on the surface of the Al particles which prevented them from contacting with water. The inhibitory effect was achieved when the concentration of sodium citrate was in a certain range and too much or too little addition may reduce the inhibitory effect. In this paper we also discuss the economic aspects of H2 inhibition with this method because it offers excellent safety advantages and could be incorporated on a large scale. Such an intrinsic safety design of H2 inhibition to control explosions in wet-dust-removal systems could be applied to ensure the safety of other systems such as nuclear reactors.
Safety Design and Engineering Solution of Fuel Cell Powered Ship in Inland Waterway of China
Oct 2021
Publication
From the perspective of risk control when hydrogen fuel and fuel cells are used on ships there is a possibility of low-flash fuel leakage leading to the risk of explosion. Since the fuel cell space (cabin for fuel cell installations) is an enclosed space any small amount of leakage must be handled properly. In ship design area classification is a method of analyzing and classifying the areas where explosive gas atmospheres may occur. If the fuel cell space is regarded as a hazardous area all the electrical devices inside it must be explosion-proof type which will make the ship’s design very difficult. This paper takes a Chinese fuel cell powered ship as an example to analyze its safety. Firstly the leakage rates of fuel cell modules valves and connectors are calculated. Secondly the IEC60079-10-1 algorithm is used to calculate the risk level of the fuel cell space. Finally the ship and fuel cells are optimized and redesigned and the risk level of the fuel cell space is recalculated and compared. The result shows that the optimized fuel space risk level could be reduced to the level of the non-hazardous zone.
Analysis of the Environmental Degradation Effects on the Cables of “La Arena” Bridge (Spain)
Sep 2017
Publication
After nearly 25 years of service some of the wires of the tendons of “La Arena” bridge (Spain) started to exhibit the effects of environmental degradation processes. “La Arena” is cable-stayed bridge with 6 towers and a reference span between towers of about 100 meters. After a maintenance inspection of the bridge evidences of corrosion were detected in some of the galvanized wires of the cables. A more in-deep analysis of these wires revealed that many of them exhibited loss of section due to the corrosion process. In order to clarify the causes of this degradation event and to suggest some remedial actions an experimental program was designed. This program consisted of tensile and fatigue tests on some strand samples of the bridge together with a fractographic analysis of the fracture surfaces of the wires its galvanized layer thickness and some hydrogen measurements (hydrogen embrittlement could be another effect of the environmental degradation process).Once the type and extension of the flaws in the wires was characterized a structural integrity assessment of the strands was performed with the aim of quantifying the margins until failure and establishing some maintenance recommendations.
Building Hydrogen Competence, a Technology Aligned Skills and Knowledge Approach
Sep 2021
Publication
There is a pressing need for a framework and strategic approach to be taken to workforce safety training requirements of new hydrogen projects. It is apparent that organisations embarking on projects utilizing or producing green hydrogen need to implement a program of training for their workforce in order to ensure that all personnel within their organisation understand not only the environmental benefits of green hydrogen but also the safety considerations that come with either producing or using hydrogen as a fuel. Energy Transition must be safe to be successful. If such an approach is taken by industry and stakeholders it is also possible to use the high level content as a vehicle and basis to offer public audiences which also require a basic level of understanding in order to fully accept the transition to using hydrogen more widely as a fuel. This will be crucial to the success of national hydrogen strategies. Coeus Energy has developed an innovative framework of training following engagement with operators keen to ensure their duty of care responsibilities have been met. Whilst having highly skilled personnel already employed within their organisations specific hydrogen content is still required for workforce competence. This is where the framework need arises as the knowledge is required at all levels of an organisation.
Development of Analysis Program for Direct Containment Heating
Feb 2022
Publication
Direct containment heating (DCH) is one of the potential factors leading to early containment failure. DCH is closely related to safety analysis and containment performance evaluation of nuclear power plants. In this study a DCH prediction program was developed to analyze the DCH loads of containment vessel. The phenomenological model of debris dispersal metal oxidation reaction debris-atmospheric heat transfer and hydrogen jet burn was established. Code assessment was performed by comparing with several separate effect tests and integral effect tests. The comparison between the predicted results and experimental data shows that the program can predict the key parameters such as peak pressure temperature and hydrogen production in containment well and for most comparisons the relative errors can be maintained within 20%. Among them the prediction uncertainty of hydrogen production is slightly larger. The analysis shows that the main sources of the error are the difference of time scale and the oxidation of cavity debris.
Simulation of Possible Fire and Explosion Hazards of Clean Fuel Vehicles in Garages
Nov 2021
Publication
Clean fuel is advocated to be used for sustainability. The number of liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) and hydrogen vehicles is increasing globally. Explosion hazard is a threat. On the other hand the use of hydrogen is under consideration in Hong Kong. Explosion hazards of these clean fuel (LPG and hydrogen) vehicles were studied and are compared in this paper. The computational fluid dynamics (CFD) software Flame Acceleration Simulator (FLACS) was used. A car garage with a rolling shutter as its entrance was selected for study. Dispersion of LPG from the leakage source with ignition at a higher position was studied. The same garage was used with a typical hydrogen vehicle leaking 3.4 pounds (1.5 kg) of hydrogen in 100 s the mass flow rate being equal to 0.015 kgs−1 . The hydrogen vehicle used in the simulation has two hydrogen tanks with a combined capacity of 5 kg. The entire tank would be completely vented out in about 333 s. Two scenarios of CFD simulation were carried out. In the first scenario the rolling shutter was completely closed and the leaked LPG or hydrogen was ignited at 300 s after leakage. The second scenario was conducted with a gap height of 0.3 m under the rolling shutter. Predicted results of explosion pressure and temperature show that appropriate active fire engineering systems are required when servicing these clean fuel vehicles in garages. An appropriate vent in an enclosed space such as the garage is important in reducing explosion hazards.
Overview on Hydrogen Risk Research and Development Activities: Methodology and Open Issues
Jan 2015
Publication
During the course of a severe accident in a light water nuclear reactor large amounts of hydrogen can be generated and released into the containment during reactor core degradation. Additional burnable gases [hydrogen (H2) and carbon monoxide (CO)] may be released into the containment in the corium/concrete interaction. This could subsequently raise a combustion hazard. As the Fukushima accidents revealed hydrogen combustion can cause high pressure spikes that could challenge the reactor buildings and lead to failure of the surrounding buildings. To prevent the gas explosion hazard most mitigation strategies adopted by European countries are based on the implementation of passive autocatalytic recombiners (PARs). Studies of representative accident sequences indicate that despite the installation of PARs it is difficult to prevent at all times and locations the formation of a combustible mixture that potentially leads to local flame acceleration. Complementary research and development (R&D) projects were recently launched to understand better the phenomena associated with the combustion hazard and to address the issues highlighted after the Fukushima Daiichi events such as explosion hazard in the venting system and the potential flammable mixture migration into spaces beyond the primary containment. The expected results will be used to improve the modeling tools and methodology for hydrogen risk assessment and severe accident management guidelines. The present paper aims to present the methodology adopted by Institut de Radioprotection et de Suˆ rete Nucleaire to assess hydrogen risk in nuclear power plants in particular French nuclear power plants the open issues and the ongoing R&D programs related to hydrogen distribution mitigation and combustion.
Condensed Phase Explosions Involving Liquid Hydrogen
Sep 2021
Publication
Liquid hydrogen may have an important role in the storage and transportation of hydrogen energy. It may also provide the best option for some users of hydrogen energy notably the aviation sector. In the 1960’s liquid hydrogen spillages in open uncongested conditions sometimes produced violent condensed phase explosions as well as the familiar gas phase flash and sustained pool fire. Testing showed that burning mixtures of LH2 and solid oxygen/nitrogen readily transitioned to detonation for oxygen concentrations in the solid phase at or above 50%. Such explosive events have been observed in more recent research work on LH2 spillage and the pressure effects could be significant in some accident scenarios. There is a need to understand how solids are produced following spillage and what factors determine the level of oxygen enrichment. This paper describes the physical processes involved in the accumulation of solids during a horizontal discharge at ground level based on observations made in a recent HSE test that led to a condensed phase explosion. Areas where solids accumulated but remained in intimate contact with LH2 are identified. The paper also includes a thermodynamic and fluid mechanical analysis of the condensation process that includes the calculation of densities of mixtures of LH2 and air in different proportions. When the difference in flow speed between air and underlying LH2 is low a stable condensation layer can develop above the liquid where the temperature is just under the initial condensation point of air allowing sustained oxygen enrichment of condensate.
Experimental Study on the Self-ignition of Pressurized Hydrogen Released into Three-way Tubes
Sep 2021
Publication
To explore the effect of bifurcation structures on the spontaneous ignition and shock wave result from the sudden release of pressurized hydrogen. Three-way tubes with different bifurcation angles (90° 120° 150°) were used in the experiments. They are two Y-shape tubes and one T-shape tube. The photoelectric and pressure signals in the tube were recorded by the sensor. The results show that the reflected shock wave will be formed at the bifurcation. In addition the intensity and velocity of the leading shock wave will attenuate sharply when it passes through the bifurcation.The smaller bifurcation angle of tubethe smaller overpressure decay rate of shock wave at bifurcation position.The smaller the bifurcation angle of tubes the weaker the reflected shock wave transmitted downstream and the greater attenuation of shock wave intensity. Experimental results have reference value for the safety of hydrogen storage at high-pressure and are helpful to understand the influence of different tube structures on spontaneous ignition when hydrogen is transported at high pressure.
Critical Morphological Phenomena During Ultra-lean Hydrogen-air Combustion in Closed Horizontal Hele-Shaw Cell
Sep 2021
Publication
Free quasi-two-dimensional outward propagation of the ultra-lean hydrogen-air flames was studied in a horizontal closed flat channel in order to minimize the influences of gravity and natural convection. Experiments were carried out with a sequential change of initial hydrogen concentration in the premixed gaseous hydrogen-air mixtures in the range from 3 to 12 vol. % H2 under normal pressure and temperature conditions. Two types of critical (in term of concentration threshold behavior) morphological phenomena were observed - formation of a pre-flame kernel and primary bifurcation of the pre-flame kernel and the higher order (secondary tertiary etc.) bifurcations of the individual locally spherical and restricted in space flame fronts. For the given initial ambient conditions (channel thickness initial gas mixture pressure and temperature) variation of initial mixture stoichiometry results in a few substantial changes in overall flame shape. These changes were recorded at the specific concentration limits which delineate three characteristic macroscopic morphological forms (morphotypes) of the ultra-lean hydrogen-air flame's ""trails"" - ""ray-like"" ""dendritic"" and ""quasi-uniform"". Transitions between the revealed basic flame morphotypes took place in different ways. The ""pre-flame kernel-to- rays"" and ""rays-to-dendrites"" transitions were abrupt and resembled the first order transitions in physics. -to-quasi-uniform morphology"" were significantly blurred and can be regarded as analogue to the second order transitions.
Fatigue Behavior of AA2198 in Liquid Hydrogen
Aug 2019
Publication
Tensile and fatigue tests were performed on an AA2198 aluminum alloy in the T851 condition in ambient air and liquid hydrogen (LH2). All fatigue tests were performed under load control at a frequency of 20 Hz and a stress ratio of R=0.1. The Gecks-Och-Function [1] was fitted on the measured cyclic lifetimes.<br/><br/>The tensile strength in LH2 was measured to be 46 % higher compared to the value determined at ambient conditions and the fatigue limit was increased by approximately 60 %. Both S-N curves show a distinct S-shape but also significant differences. Under LH2 environment the transition from LCF- to HCF-region as well as the transition to the fatigue limit is shifted to higher cyclic lifetimes compared to ambient test results. The investigation of the crack surfaces showed distinct differences between ambient and LH2 conditions. These observed differences are important factors in the fatigue behavior change.
Observation of the Hydrogen Dispersion by Using Raman Scattering Measurement and Increase of Measurable Distance
Sep 2017
Publication
Preparing for the arrival of the hydrogen society it is necessary to develop suitable sensors to use hydrogen safely. There are many methods to know the hydrogen concentration by using conventional sensors but it is difficult to know the behavior of hydrogen gas from long distance. This study measured hydrogen dispersion by using Raman scattering light. Generally some delays occur when using conventional sensors but there are almost no delays by using the new Raman sensor. In the experiments 6mm & 1mm diameter holes are used as a spout nozzle to change initial velocities. To ensure the result a special sheets are used which turns transparent when it detected hydrogen and visualized the hydrogen behaviour. As a result the behaviour of the hydrogen gas in the small container was observed. In addition measurable distance is increased by the improvement of the device.
Non-steady Characteristics of Dispersion and Ignitability for High-pressurized Hydrogen Jet Discharged From a Pinhole
Sep 2017
Publication
Hydrogen gas concentrations and jet velocities were measured downstream by a high response speed flame ionization detector and PIV (Particle Image Velocimetry) in order to investigate the characteristics of dispersion and ignitability for 40–82 MPa high-pressurized hydrogen jet discharged from a nozzle with 0.2 mm diameter. The light emitted from both OH radical and water vapor species yielded from hydrogen combustion ignited by an electric spark were recorded by two high speed cameras. From the results the empirical formula concerning the relationships for time-averaged concentrations concentration fluctuations and ignition probability were obtained to suggest that they would be independent of hydrogen discharge pressure.
Public Perception on Hydrogen Infrastructure in Japan
Oct 2015
Publication
A public survey was conducted in March 2015 in Japan asking public awareness knowledge perception and acceptance regarding hydrogen hydrogen infrastructure and fuel cell vehicle adopting the same key questions contained in the public surveys conducted six and seven years ago. Changes in answers between two different times of survey implementation were analyzed by comparing results of current survey to those of the previous surveys. Regression analyses were conducted and revealed influence of respondents’ awareness knowledge and perception about hydrogen hydrogen infrastructure and fuel cell vehicle on their acceptance on hydrogen station. We found a large increase in the awareness and relatively a small improvement on knowledge on hydrogen energy hydrogen infrastructure and fuel cell vehicle from the previous surveys. In contrast we did not find much changes in perception of risk and benefit perception on hydrogen society and hydrogen station and public acceptance of hydrogen infrastructure. Through the regression analyses we found large influences of negative risk perception of hydrogen itself and technology of hydrogen station and perception of necessity of hydrogen station on public acceptance of hydrogen station and the small influence of time background on the acceptance. Through the results of analyses implications to public communication in building public infrastructure are presented.
Hydrogen Fast Filling to a Type IV Tank Developed for Motorcycles
Oct 2015
Publication
If Hydrogen is expected to be highly valuable some improvements should be conducted mainly regarding the storage safety. To prevent from high pressure hydrogen composite tanks bursting the comprehension of the thermo-mechanics phenomena in the case of fire should be improved. To understand the kinetic of strength loss the heat flux produced by fire of various intensities should be assessed. This is the objective of this real scale experimental campaign which will allow studying in future works the strength loss of composite high-pressure vessels in similar fire conditions to the ones determined in this study. Fire calibration tests were performed on metallic cylinder vessels. These tests with metallic cylinders are critical in the characterization of the thermal load of various fire sources (pool fire propane gas fire hydrogen gas fire) so as to evaluate differences related to different thermal load. Radiant panels were also used as thermal source for reference of pure radiation heat transfer. The retained thermal load might be representative of accidental situations in worst case scenarios and relevant for a standardized testing protocol. The tests performed show that hydrogen gas fires and heptane pool fire allow reaching the target in terms of absorbed energy regarding the results of risk analysis performed previously. Other considerations can be taken into account that will led to retain an hydrogen gas fire for further works. Firstly hydrogen gas fire is the more realistic scenario: Hydrogen is the combustible that we every time find near an hydrogen storage. Secondly as one of the objectives of the project is to make recommendations for standardization issues it's important to note that gas fires are not too complex to calibrate control and reproduce. Finally due to previous considerations Hydrogen gas fire will be retained for thermal load of composite cylinders in future works.
Leakage-type-based Analysis of Accidents Involving Hydrogen Fueling Stations in Japan and USA
Aug 2016
Publication
To identify the safety issues associated with hydrogen fuelling stations incidents at such stations in Japan and the USA were analyzed considering the regulations in these countries. Leakage due to the damage and fracture of main bodies of apparatuses and pipes in Japan and the USA is mainly caused by design error that is poorly planned fatigue. Considering the present incidents in these countries adequate consideration of the usage environment in the design is very important. Leakage from flanges valves and seals in Japan is mainly caused by screw joints. If welded joints are to be used in hydrogen fuelling stations in Japan strength data for welded parts should be obtained and pipe thicknesses should be reduced. Leakage due to other factors e.g. external impact in Japan and the USA is mainly caused by human error. To realize self-serviced hydrogen fuelling stations safety measures should be developed to prevent human error by fuel cell vehicle users.
Validation and Recommendations for CFD and Engineering Modeling of Hydrogen Vented Explosions: Effects of Concentration, Stratification, Obstruction and Vent Area
Oct 2015
Publication
Explosion venting is commonly used in the process industry as a prevention solution to protect equipment or buildings against excessive internal pressure caused by an explosion. This article is dedicated to the validation of FLACS CFD code for the modelling of vented explosions. Analytical engineering models fail when complex cases are considered for instance in the presence of obstacles or H2 stratified mixtures. CFD is an alternative solution but has to be carefully validated. In this study FLACS simulations are compared to published experimental results and recommendations are suggested for their application.
Flame Acceleration and Deflagration-to-Detonation Transition in Hydrogen-Oxygen Mixture in a Channel with Triangular Obstacles
Sep 2021
Publication
Study of flame acceleration and deflagration-to-detonation transition (DDT) in obstructed channels is an important subject of research for hydrogen safety. Experiments and numerical simulations of DDT in channels equipped with triangular obstacles were conducted in this work. High-speed schlieren photography and pressure records were used to study the flame shape changes flame propagation and pressure build up in the experiments. In the simulations the fully compressible reactive Navier–Stokes equations coupled with a calibrated chemical-diffusion model for stoichiometric hydrogen-oxygen mixture were solved using a high-order numerical method. The simulations were in good agreement with the experiments. The results show that the triangular obstacles significantly promote the flame acceleration and provide conditions for the occurrence of DDT. In the early stages of flame acceleration vortices are generated in the gaps between adjacent obstacles which is the main cause for the flame roll-up and distortion. A positive feedback mechanism between the combustiongenerated flow and flame propagation results in the variations of the size and velocity of vortices. The flame-vortex interactions cause flame fragmentation and consequently rapid growth in flame surface area which further lead to flame acceleration. The initially laminar flame then develops into a turbulent flame with the creation of shocks shock-flame interactions and various flame instabilities. The continuously arranged obstacles interact with shocks and flames and help to create environments in which a detonation can develop. Both flame collision and flame-shock interaction can give rise to detonation in the channels with triangular obstacles.
Direct Numerical Simulation of Hydrogen Combustion at Auto-ignitive Conditions Ignition, Stability and Turbulent Reaction-front Velocity
Mar 2021
Publication
Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) are performed to investigate the process of spontaneous ignition of hydrogen flames at laminar turbulent adiabatic and non-adiabatic conditions. Mixtures of hydrogen and vitiated air at temperatures representing gas-turbine reheat combustion are considered. Adiabatic spontaneous ignition processes are investigated first providing a quantitative characterization of stable and unstable flames. Results indicate that in hydrogen reheat combustion compressibility effects play a key role in flame stability and that unstable ignition and combustion are consistently encountered for reactant temperatures close to the mixture’s characteristic crossover temperature. Furthermore it is also found that the characterization of the adiabatic processes is also valid in the presence of non-adiabaticity due to wall heat-loss. Finally a quantitative characterization of the instantaneous fuel consumption rate within the reaction front is obtained and of its ability at auto-ignitive conditions to advance against the approaching turbulent flow of the reactants for a range of different turbulence intensities temperatures and pressure levels.
Hydrogeochemical Modeling to Identify Potential Risks of Underground Hydrogen Storage in Depleted Gas Fields
Nov 2018
Publication
Underground hydrogen storage is a potential way to balance seasonal fluctuations in energy production from renewable energies. The risks of hydrogen storage in depleted gas fields include the conversion of hydrogen to CH4(g) and H2S(g) due to microbial activity gas–water–rock interactions in the reservoir and cap rock which are connected with porosity changes and the loss of aqueous hydrogen by diffusion through the cap rock brine. These risks lead to loss of hydrogen and thus to a loss of energy. A hydrogeochemical modeling approach is developed to analyze these risks and to understand the basic hydrogeochemical mechanisms of hydrogen storage over storage times at the reservoir scale. The one-dimensional diffusive mass transport model is based on equilibrium reactions for gas–water–rock interactions and kinetic reactions for sulfate reduction and methanogenesis. The modeling code is PHREEQC (pH-REdox-EQuilibrium written in the C programming language). The parameters that influence the hydrogen loss are identified. Crucial parameters are the amount of available electron acceptors the storage time and the kinetic rate constants. Hydrogen storage causes a slight decrease in porosity of the reservoir rock. Loss of aqueous hydrogen by diffusion is minimal. A wide range of conditions for optimized hydrogen storage in depleted gas fields is identified.
Modelling of Ventilated Hydrogen Dispersion in Presence of Co-flow and Counter-flow
Sep 2021
Publication
In the framework of the EU-funded project HyTunnel-CS an inter-comparison among partners CFD simulations has been carried out. The simulations are based on experiments conducted within the project by Pro-Science and involve hydrogen release inside a safety vessel testing different ventilation configurations. The different ventilation configurations that were tested are co-flow counter-flow and cross-flow. In the current study co-flow and counter-flow tests along with the no ventilation test (m' = S g/s d = 4 mm ) are simulated with the aim to validate available and well-known CFD codes against such applications and to provide recommendations on modeling strategies. Special focus is given on modeling the velocity field produced by the fan during the experiments. The computational results are compared with the experimental results and a discussion follows regarding the efficiency of each ventilation configuration.
Velocity Measurements of Hydrogen Jets Using the Optical Flow Method
Sep 2021
Publication
Concentration and velocity measurements are crucial for developing and validating hydrogen jet models which provide scientific bases for hydrogen safety analyses. The concentration fields have been visualized and accurately measured using laser diagnostic methods based on lase Rayleigh and Raman scattering techniques. However the velocity measurements are more challenging. Particle image velocimetry (PIV) has been commonly used for measuring velocities in turbulent flows by seeding tracer particles into the flow and assuming the particles intimately following the flow. However sometimes the particle seeding is difficult or disturbs the flow. Moreover simultaneously concentration and velocity measurements are very difficult when using PIV systems to measure the velocities. Therefore the optical flow velocimetry (OFV) method was used to resolve the velocity fields from the scalar fields or particle images of hydrogen jets. In the present work the velocity field and particle images of hydrogen jets were simulated using FLUENT with the large eddy simulation (LES) model and the particle images were then used to resolve the velocity field by the OFV method. The OFV results were compared with the CFD simulations to verify their accuracy. The results show that the OFC method was an efficient low-cost way to extract the velocity fields from particle images. The OFV method accurately located the large vortices in the flow and the velocity distribution of the high-velocity gradients regions was consistent with the CFD results. The present study lays a foundation for using the OFV method to directly resolve the velocity fields from the concentration fields of hydrogen jets measured by laser diagnostics.
An Investigation into the Volumetric Flow Rate Requirement of Hydrogen Transportation in Existing Natural Gas Pipelines and Its Safety Implications
Oct 2021
Publication
As an alternative to the construction of new infrastructure repurposing existing natural gas pipelines for hydrogen transportation has been identified as a low-cost strategy for substituting natural gas with hydrogen in the wake of the energy transition. In line with that a 342 km 3600 natural gas pipeline was used in this study to simulate some technical implications of delivering the same amount of energy with different blends of natural gas and hydrogen and with 100% hydrogen. Preliminary findings from the study confirmed that a three-fold increase in volumetric flow rate would be required of hydrogen to deliver an equivalent amount of energy as natural gas. The effects of flowing hydrogen at this rate in an existing natural gas pipeline on two flow parameters (the compressibility factor and the velocity gradient) which are crucial to the safety of the pipeline were investigated. The compressibility factor behaviour revealed the presence of a wide range of values as the proportions of hydrogen and natural gas in the blends changed signifying disparate flow behaviours and consequent varying flow challenges. The velocity profiles showed that hydrogen can be transported in natural gas pipelines via blending with natural gas by up to 40% of hydrogen in the blend without exceeding the erosional velocity limits of the pipeline. However when the proportion of hydrogen reached 60% the erosional velocity limit was reached at 290 km so that beyond this distance the pipeline would be subject to internal erosion. The use of compressor stations was shown to be effective in remedying this challenge. This study provides more insights into the volumetric and safety considerations of adopting existing natural gas pipelines for the transportation of hydrogen and blends of hydrogen and natural gas.
Risk Assessment Method Combining Independent Protection Layers (IPL) of Layer of Protection Analysis (LOPA) and RISKCURVES Software: Case Study of Hydrogen Refueling Stations in Urban Areas
Jul 2021
Publication
The commercialization of eco-friendly hydrogen vehicles has elicited attempts to expand hydrogen refueling stations in urban areas; however safety measures to reduce the risk of jet fires have not been established. The RISKCURVES software was used to evaluate the individual and societal risks of hydrogen refueling stations in urban areas and the F–N (Frequency–Number of fatalities) curve was used to compare whether the safety measures satisfied international standards. From the results of the analysis it was found that there is a risk of explosion in the expansion of hydrogen refueling stations in urban areas and safety measures should be considered. To lower the risk of hydrogen refueling stations this study applied the passive and active independent protection layers (IPLs) of LOPA (Layer of Protection Analysis) and confirmed that these measures significantly reduced societal risk as well as individual risk and met international standards. In particular such measures could effectively reduce the impact of jet fire in dispensers and tube trailers that had a high risk. Measures employing both IPL types were efficient in meeting international standard criteria; however passive IPLs were found to have a greater risk reduction effect than active IPLs. The combination of RISKCURVES and LOPA is an appropriate risk assessment method that can reduce work time and mitigate risks through protective measures compared to existing risk assessment methods. This method can be applied to risk assessment and risk mitigation not only for hydrogen facilities but also for hazardous materials with high fire or explosion risk.
Liquid Organic Hydrogen Carriers - A Technology to Overcome Common Risks of Hydrogen Storage
Sep 2021
Publication
In transport and storage of hydrogen the risks are mainly seen in its volatile nature its ability to form explosive mixtures with air and the harsh conditions (high pressure or low temperature) for efficient storage. The concept of Liquid Organic Hydrogen Carriers (LOHC) offers a technology to overcome the above mentioned threats. The present submission describes the basics of the LOHC technology. It contains a comparison of a selection of common LOHC materials with a view on physical properties. The advantages of a low viscosity at low temperatures and a high flash point are expressed. LOHCs are also discussed as a concept to import large amounts of energy/hydrogen. A closer look is taken on the environmental and safety aspects of hydrogen storage in LOHCs since here the main differences to pressurized and cryo-storage of hydrogen can be found. The aim of this paper is to provide an overview of the principles of the LOHC technology the different LOHC materials and their risks and opportunities and an impression of a large scale scenario on the basis of the LOHC technology.
Hydrogen as a Maritime Fuel–Can Experiences with LNG Be Transferred to Hydrogen Systems?
Jul 2021
Publication
As the use of fossil fuels becomes more and more restricted there is a need for alternative fuels also at sea. For short sea distance travel purposes batteries may be a solution. However for longer distances when there is no possibility of recharging at sea batteries do not have sufficient capacity yet. Several projects have demonstrated the use of compressed hydrogen (CH2) as a fuel for road transport. The experience with hydrogen as a maritime fuel is very limited. In this paper the similarities and differences between liquefied hydrogen (LH2) and liquefied natural gas (LNG) as a maritime fuel will be discussed based on literature data of their properties and our system knowledge. The advantages and disadvantages of the two fuels will be examined with respect to use as a maritime fuel. Our objective is to discuss if and how hydrogen could replace fossil fuels on long distance sea voyages. Due to the low temperature of LH2 and wide flammability range in air these systems have more challenges related to storage and processing onboard than LNG. These factors result in higher investment costs. All this may also imply challenges for the LH2 supply chain.
Flammability Reduction in a Pressurised Water Electrolyser Based on a Thin Polymer Electrolyte Membrane through a Pt-alloy Catalytic Approach
Jan 2019
Publication
Various Pt-based materials (unsupported Pt PtRu PtCo) were investigated as catalysts for recombining hydrogen and oxygen back into water. The recombination performance correlated well with the surface Pt metallic state. Alloying cobalt to platinum was observed to produce an electron transfer favouring the occurrence of a large fraction of the Pt metallic state on the catalyst surface. Unsupported PtCo showed both excellent recombination performance and dynamic behaviour. In a packed bed catalytic reactor when hydrogen was fed at 4% vol. in the oxygen stream (flammability limit) 99.5% of the total H2 content was immediately converted to water in the presence of PtCo thus avoiding safety issues. The PtCo catalyst was thus integrated in the anode of the membrane-electrode assembly of a polymer electrolyte membrane electrolysis cell. This catalyst showed good capability to reduce the concentration of hydrogen in the oxygen stream under differential pressure operation (1–20 bar) in the presence of a thin (90 μm) Aquivion® membrane. The modified system showed lower hydrogen concentration in the oxygen flow than electrolysis cells based on state-of-the-art thick polymer electrolyte membranes and allowed to expand the minimum current density load down to 0.15 A cm−2 . This was mainly due to the electrochemical oxidation of permeated H2 to protons that were transported back to the cathode. The electrolysis cell equipped with a dual layer PtCo/IrRuOx oxidation catalyst achieved a high operating current density (3 A cm−2 ) as requested to decrease the system capital costs under high efficiency conditions (about 77% efficiency at 55 °C and 20 bar). Moreover the electrolysis system showed reduced probability to reach the flammability limit under both high differential pressure (20 bar) and partial load operation (5%) as needed to properly address grid-balancing service
Safety Standard for Hydrogen and Hydrogen Systems Guidelines for Hydrogen System Design, Materials Selection, Operations, Storage and Transportation
Jan 1997
Publication
The NASA Safety Standard which establishes a uniform process for hydrogen system design materials selection operation storage and transportation is presented. The guidelines include suggestions for safely storing handling and using hydrogen in gaseous (GH2) liquid (LH2) or slush (SLH2) form whether used as a propellant or non-propellant. The handbook contains 9 chapters detailing properties and hazards facility design design of components materials compatibility detection and transportation. Chapter 10 serves as a reference and the appendices contained therein include: assessment examples; scaling laws explosions blast effects and fragmentation; codes standards and NASA directives; and relief devices along with a list of tables and figures abbreviations a glossary and an index for ease of use. The intent of the handbook is to provide enough information that it can be used alone but at the same time reference data sources that can provide much more detail if required.
CFD Simulations of Large Scale LH2 Dispersion in Open Environment
Sep 2021
Publication
An inter-comparison among partners’ CFD simulations has been carried out within the EU-funded project PRESLHY to investigate the dispersion of the mixture cloud formed from large scale liquid hydrogen release. Rainout experiments performed by Health and Safety Executive (HSE) have been chosen for the work. From the HSE experimental series trial-11 was selected forsimulation due to its conditions where only liquid flow at the nozzle was achieved. During trial-11 liquid hydrogen is spilled horizontally 0.5 m above a concrete pad from a 5 barg tank pressure through a 12 mm (1/2 inch) nozzle. The dispersion takes place outdoors and thus it is imposed to variant wind conditions. Comparison of the CFD results with the measurements at several sensors is presented and useful conclusions are drawn.
Advanced Polymeric/inorganic Nanohybrids: An Integrated Platform for Gas Sensing Applications
Jan 2022
Publication
Rapid industrial development vehicles domestic activities and mishandling of garbage are the main sources of pollutants which are destroying the atmosphere. There is a need to continuously monitor these pollutants for the safety of the environment and human beings. Conventional instruments for monitoring of toxic gases are expensive bigger in size and time-consuming. Hybrid materials containing organic and inorganic components are considered potential candidates for diverse applications including gas sensing. Gas sensors convert the information regarding the analyte into signals. Various polymeric/inorganic nanohybrids have been used for the sensing of toxic gases. Composites of different polymeric materials like polyaniline (PANI) poly (4-styrene sulfonate) (PSS) poly (34-ethylene dioxythiophene) (PEDOT) etc. with various metal/metal oxide nanoparticles have been reported as sensing materials for gas sensors because of their unique redox features conductivity and facile operation at room temperature. Polymeric nanohybrids showed better performance because of the larger surface area of nanohybrids and the synergistic effect between polymeric and inorganic materials. This review article focuses on the recent developments of emerging polymeric/inorganic nanohybrids for sensing various toxic gases including ammonia hydrogen nitrogen dioxide carbon oxides and liquefied petroleum gas. Advantages disadvantages operating conditions and prospects of hybrid composites have also been discussed.
Hy4Heat Annex To Site Specific Safety Case for Hydrogen Community Demonstration - Work Package 7
May 2021
Publication
The Hy4Heat Safety Assessment has focused on assessing the safe use of hydrogen gas in certain types of domestic properties and buildings. The summary reports (the Precis and the Safety Assessment Conclusions Report) bring together all the findings of the work and should be looked to for context by all readers. The technical reports should be read in conjunction with the summary reports. While the summary reports are made as accessible as possible for general readers the technical reports may be most accessible for readers with a degree of technical subject matter understanding. All of the safety assessment reports have now been reviewed by the HSE<br/>Annex prepared to support Site Specific Safety Cases for hydrogen gas community demonstrations based on work undertaken by the Hy4Heat programme. It covers a collection of recommended risk reduction measures for application downstream of the Emergency Control Valve (ECV)
Fundamentals and Principles of Solid-State Electrochemical Sensors for High Temperature Gas Detection
Dec 2021
Publication
The rapid development of science technology and engineering in the 21st century has offered a remarkable rise in our living standards. However at the same time serious environmental issues have emerged such as acid rain and the greenhouse effect which are associated with the ever-increasing need for energy consumption 85% of which comes from fossil fuels combustion. From this combustion process except for energy the main greenhouse gases-carbon dioxide and steam-are produced. Moreover during industrial processes many hazardous gases are emitted. For this reason gas-detecting devices such as electrochemical gas sensors able to analyze the composition of a target atmosphere in real time are important for further improving our living quality. Such devices can help address environmental issues and inform us about the presence of dangerous gases. Furthermore as non-renewable energy sources run out there is a need for energy saving. By analyzing the composition of combustion emissions of automobiles or industries combustion processes can be optimized. This review deals with electrochemical gas sensors based on solid oxide electrolytes which are employed for the detection of hazardous gasses at high temperatures and aggressive environments. The fundamentals the principle of operation and the configuration of potentiometric amperometric combined (amperometric-potentiometric) and mixed-potential gas sensors are presented. Moreover the results of previous studies on carbon oxides (COx) nitrogen oxides (NOx) hydrogen (H2 ) oxygen (O2 ) ammonia (NH3 ) and humidity (steam) electrochemical sensors are reported and discussed. Emphasis is given to sensors based on oxygen ion and proton-conducting electrolytes.
ZnO@ZIF-8 Core-Shell Structure Gas Sensors with Excellent Selectivity to H2
Jun 2021
Publication
As the energy crisis becomes worse hydrogen as a clean energy source is more and more widely used in industrial production and people’s daily life. However there are hidden dangers in hydrogen storage and transportation because of its flammable and explosive features. Gas detection is the key to solving this problem. High quality sensors with more practical and commercial value must be able to accurately detect target gases in the environment. Emerging porous metal-organic framework (MOF) materials can effectively improve the selectivity of sensors as a result of high surface area and coordinated pore structure. The application of MOFs for surface modification to improve the selectivity and sensitivity of metal oxides sensors to hydrogen has been widely investigated. However the influence of MOF modified film thickness on the selectivity of hydrogen sensors is seldom studied. Moreover the mechanism of the selectivity improvement of the sensors with MOF modified film is still unclear. In this paper we prepared nano-sized ZnO particles by a homogeneous precipitation method. ZnO nanoparticle (NP) gas sensors were prepared by screen printing technology. Then a dense ZIF-8 film was grown on the surface of the gas sensor by hydrothermal synthesis. The morphology the composition of the elements and the characters of the product were analyzed by X-ray diffraction analysis (XRD) transmission electron microscope (TEM) scanning electron microscope (SEM) energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS) Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). It is found that the ZIF-8 film grown for 4 h cannot form a dense core-shell structure. The thickness of ZIF-8 reaches 130 nm at 20 h. Through the detection and analysis of hydrogen (1000 ppm) ethanol (100 ppm) and acetone (50 ppm) from 150 °C to 290 °C it is found that the response of the ZnO@ZIF-8 sensors to hydrogen has been significantly improved while the response to ethanol and acetone was decreased. By comparing the change of the response coefficient when the thickness of ZIF-8 is 130 nm the gas sensor has a significantly improved selectivity to hydrogen at 230 °C. The continuous increase of the thickness tends to inhibit selectivity. The mechanism of selectivity improvement of the sensors with different thickness of the ZIF-8 films is discussed.
CFD Model Based Ann Prediction of Flammable Vapor Colour Formed by Liquid Hydrogen Spill
Sep 2021
Publication
Unintended releases can occur during the production storage transportation and filling of liquid hydrogen which may cause devastating consequences. In the present work liquid hydrogen leak is modeled in ANSYS Fluent with the numerical model validated using the liquid hydrogen spill test data. A three-layer artificial neural network (ANN) model is built in which the wind speed ground temperature leakage time and leakage rate are taken as the inputs the horizontal diffusion distance and vertical diffusion distance of combustible gas as the outputs of the ANN. The representative sample data derived from the detailed calculation results of the numerical model are selected via the orthogonal experiment method to train and verify the back propagation (BP) neural network. Comparing the calculation results of the formula fitting with the sample data the results show that the established ANN model can quickly and accurately predict the horizontal and vertical diffusion distance of flammable vapor cloud relatively. The influences of four parameters on the horizontal hazard distance as well as vertical hazard height are predicted and analyzed in the case of continuous overflow of liquid hydrogen using the ANN model.
Hydrogen Tank Rupture in Fire in the Open Atmosphere: Hazard Distance Defined by Fireball
Feb 2021
Publication
The engineering correlations for assessment of hazard distance defined by a size of fireball after either liquid hydrogen spill combustion or high-pressure hydrogen tank rupture in a fire in the open atmosphere (both for stand-alone and under-vehicle tanks) are presented. The term “fireball size” is used for the maximum horizontal size of a fireball that is different from the term “fireball diameter” applied to spherical or semi-spherical shape fireballs. There are different reasons for a fireball to deviate from a spherical shape e.g. in case of tank rupture under a vehicle the non-instantaneous opening of tank walls etc. Two conservative correlations are built using theoretical analysis numerical simulations and experimental data available in the literature. The theoretical model for hydrogen fireball size assumes complete isobaric combustion of hydrogen in air and presumes its hemispherical shape as observed in the experiments and the simulations for tank rupturing at the ground level. The dependence of the fireball size on hydrogen mass and fireball’s diameter-to-height ratio is discussed. The correlation for liquid hydrogen release fireball is based on the experiments by Zabetakis (1964). The correlations can be applied as engineering tools to access hazard distances for scenarios of liquid or gaseous hydrogen storage tank rupture in a fire in the open atmosphere
The Effect of Hydrogen Enrichment, Flame-flame Interaction, Confinement, and Asymmetry on the Acoustic Response of a Model Can Combustor
Apr 2022
Publication
To maximise power density practical gas turbine combustion systems have several injectors which can lead to complex interactions between flames. However our knowledge about the effect of flame-flame interactions on the flame response the essential element to predict the stability of a combustor is still limited. The present study investigates the effect of hydrogen enrichment flame-flame interaction confinement and asymmetries on the linear and non-linear acoustic response of three premixed flames in a simple can combustor. A parametric study of the linear response characterised by the flame transfer function (FTF) is performed for swirling and non-swirling flames. Flame-flame interactions were achieved by changing the injector spacing and the level of hydrogen enrichment by power from 10 to 50%. It was found that the latter had the most significant effect on the flame response. Asymmetry effects were investigated by changing one of the flames by using a different bluff-body to alter both the flame shape and flow field. The global flame response showed that the asymmetric cases can be reconstructed using a superposition of the two symmetric cases where all three bluff-bodies and flames are the same. Overall the linear response characterised by the flame transfer function (FTF) showed that the effect of increasing the level of hydrogen enrichment is more pronounced than the effect of the injector spacing. Increasing hydrogen enrichment results in more compact flames which minimises flame-flame interactions. More compact flames increase the cut-off frequency which can lead to self-excited modes at higher frequencies. Finally the non-linear response was characterised by measuring the flame describing function (FDF) at a frequency close to a self-excited mode of the combustor for different injector spacings and levels of hydrogen enrichment. It is shown that increasing the hydrogen enrichment leads to higher saturation amplitude whereas the effect of injector spacing has a comparably smaller effect.
Recent Progress in Hydrogen Flammability Prediction for the Safe Energy Systems
Nov 2020
Publication
Many countries consider hydrogen as a promising energy source to resolve the energy challenges over the global climate change. However the potential of hydrogen explosions remains a technical issue to embrace hydrogen as an alternate solution since the Hindenburg disaster occurred in 1937. To ascertain safe hydrogen energy systems including production storage and transportation securing the knowledge concerning hydrogen flammability is essential. In this paper we addressed a comprehensive review of the studies related to predicting hydrogen flammability by dividing them into three types: experimental numerical and analytical. While the earlier experimental studies had focused only on measuring limit concentration recent studies clarified the extinction mechanism of a hydrogen flame. In numerical studies the continued advances in computer performance enabled even multi-dimensional stretched flame analysis following one-dimensional planar flame analysis. The different extinction mechanisms depending on the Lewis number of each fuel type could be observed by these advanced simulations. Finally historical attempts to predict the limit concentration by analytical modelling of flammability characteristics were discussed. Developing an accurate model to predict the flammability limit of various hydrogen mixtures is our remaining issue.
Hy4Heat Safety Assessment: Precis - Work Package 7
May 2021
Publication
The Hy4Heat Safety Assessment has focused on assessing the safe use of hydrogen gas in certain types of domestic properties and buildings. The summary reports (the Precis and the Safety Assessment Conclusions Report) bring together all the findings of the work and should be looked to for context by all readers. The technical reports should be read in conjunction with the summary reports. While the summary reports are made as accessible as possible for general readers the technical reports may be most accessible for readers with a degree of technical subject matter understanding. All of the safety assessment reports have now been reviewed by the HSE.<br/><br/>This document is an overview of the Safety Assessment work undertaken as part of the Hy4Heat programme
Effect of Deformation Microstructures on Hydrogen Embrittlement Sensitivity and Failure Mechanism of 304 Austenitic Stainless Steel: The Significant Role of Rolling Temperature
Feb 2022
Publication
Metastable austenitic stainless steels (ASSs) have excellent ductility but low strength so that their usage as load-bearing components is significantly limited. Rolling is an effective method of increasing strength whereas the effect of rolling temperature on microstructural evolution the hydrogen embrittlement (HE) sensitivity and fracture mechanisms is still unclear. In present study the effect of cold/warm rolling on detailed microstructural characteristics of 304 ASS was quantitatively investigated and the corresponding HE sensitivity was evaluated via slow strain rate test. The results suggest that cold-rolling led to high strength but poor plasticity and deteriorated HE sensitivity while warm-rolled samples provided combination of high strength and ductility and also superior HE resistance. Compared with 18% α′-martensite in cold -rolled steel warm-rolled specimens consisted of complete austenite less twins and lower dislocation density,moreover the favorable {112} ND and {110} ND textures replaced the harmful {001} ND texture. Based on in-situ EBSD observation during SSRT the HE sensitivity was governed by the combined effect of pre-deformation microstructures and the dynamic microstructural evolution. Advanced method of time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry was used to observe the distribution of hydrogen and the hydrogen content of specimens was determined by the gas chromatograph thermal desorption analysis method. An exceedingly small amount of hydrogen entered the warm-rolled samples while a large amount of hydrogen was trapped at grain boundaries of cold-rolled sample leading to complete intergranular fracture. Therefore warm rolling is an effective pathway for obtaining high combination of strength and ductility together with excellent HE sensitivity.
H21- Phase 1 Technical Summary Report
May 2021
Publication
The UK Government signed legislation on 27th June 2019 committing the UK to a legally binding target of Net Zero emissions by 2050. Climate change is one of the most significant technical economic social and business challenges facing the world today.
The H21 NIC Phase 1 project delivered an optimally designed experimentation and testing programme supported by the HSE Science Division and DNV GL with the aim to collect quantifiable evidence to support that the UK distribution network of 2032 will be comparably as safe operating on 100% hydrogen as it currently is on
natural gas. This innovative project begins to fill critical safety evidence gaps surrounding the conversion of the UK gas network to 100% hydrogen. This will facilitate progression towards H21 Phase 2 Operational Safety Demonstrations and the H21 Phase 3 Live Trials to promote customer acceptability and ultimately aid progress towards a government policy decision on heat.
DNV GL and HSE Science Division were engaged to undertake the experimentation testing and QRA update programme of work. DNV GL and HSE Science Division also peer reviewed each other’s programme of work at various stages throughout the project undertaking a challenge and review of the experimental data and results to provide confidence in the conclusions.
A strategic set of tests was designed to cover the range of assets represented across the Great Britain gas distribution networks. The assets used in the testing were mostly recovered from the distribution network as part of the ongoing Iron Mains Risk Reduction Replacement Programme. Controlled testing against a well-defined master testing plan with both natural gas and 100% hydrogen was then undertaken to provide the quantitative evidence to forecast any change to background leakage levels in a 100% hydrogen network.
Key Findings from Phase 1a:
The H21 NIC Phase 1 project delivered an optimally designed experimentation and testing programme supported by the HSE Science Division and DNV GL with the aim to collect quantifiable evidence to support that the UK distribution network of 2032 will be comparably as safe operating on 100% hydrogen as it currently is on
natural gas. This innovative project begins to fill critical safety evidence gaps surrounding the conversion of the UK gas network to 100% hydrogen. This will facilitate progression towards H21 Phase 2 Operational Safety Demonstrations and the H21 Phase 3 Live Trials to promote customer acceptability and ultimately aid progress towards a government policy decision on heat.
DNV GL and HSE Science Division were engaged to undertake the experimentation testing and QRA update programme of work. DNV GL and HSE Science Division also peer reviewed each other’s programme of work at various stages throughout the project undertaking a challenge and review of the experimental data and results to provide confidence in the conclusions.
A strategic set of tests was designed to cover the range of assets represented across the Great Britain gas distribution networks. The assets used in the testing were mostly recovered from the distribution network as part of the ongoing Iron Mains Risk Reduction Replacement Programme. Controlled testing against a well-defined master testing plan with both natural gas and 100% hydrogen was then undertaken to provide the quantitative evidence to forecast any change to background leakage levels in a 100% hydrogen network.
Key Findings from Phase 1a:
- Of the 215 assets tested 41 of them were found to leak 19 of them provided sufficient data to be able to compare hydrogen and methane leak rates.
- The tests showed that assets that were gas tight on methane were also gas tight on hydrogen. Assets that leaked on hydrogen also leaked
- on methane including repaired assets.
- The ratio of the hydrogen to methane volumetric leak rates varied between 1.1 and 2.2 which is largely consistent with the bounding values expected for laminar and turbulent (or inertial) flow which gave ratios of 1.2 and 2.8 respectively.
- None of the PE assets leaked; cast ductile and spun iron leaked to a similar degree (around 26-29% of all iron assets leaked) and the proportion of leaking steel assets was slightly less (14%).
- Four types of joint were responsible for most of the leaks on joints: screwed lead yarn bolted gland and hook bolts.
- All of the repairs that sealed methane leaks also were effective when tested with hydrogen.
The Role of the Argon and Helium Bath Gases on the Detonation Structure of H2/)2 Mixture
Sep 2021
Publication
Recent modeling efforts of non-equilibrium effects in detonations have suggested that hydrogen-based detonations may be affected by vibrational non-equilibrium of the hydrogen and oxygen molecules effects which could explain discrepancies of cell sizes measured experimentally and calculated without relaxation effects. The present study addresses the role of vibrational relaxation in 2H2/O2 detonations by considering two-bath gases argon and helium. These two gases have the same thermodynamic and kinetic effects when relaxation is neglected. However due to the bath gases differences in molecular weight and reduced mass differences which affect the molecular collisions relaxation rates can be changed by approximately 50-70%. Experiments were performed in a narrow channel in mixtures of 2H2/O2/7Ar and 2H2/O2/7He to evaluate the role of the bath gas on detonation cellular structures. The experiments showed differences in velocity deficits and cell sizes for experimental conditions keeping the induction zone length constant in each of the mixtures. These differences were negligible in sensitive mixtures but increased with the increase in velocity deficits while the cell sizes approaching the channel dimensions. Near the limits differences of cell size in two mixtures approached a factor of 2. These differences were however reconciled by accounting for the viscous losses to the tube walls evaluated using a modified version of Mirels' laminar boundary layer theory and generalized Chapman-Jouguet theory for eigenvalue detonations. The experiments suggest that there is an influence of relaxation effects on the cellular structure of detonations which is more sensitive to wall boundary conditions. However the previous works showed that the impact of vibrational non-equilibrium in a mixture of H2/Air is more visible due to the effects of N2 in the air slowest to relax. Previous discrepancies suggested to be indicative of relaxation effects should be reevaluated by the inclusion of wall loss effects.
Approaches and Methods to Demonstrate Repurposing of the UK's Local Transmission System (LTS) Pipelines for Transportation of Hydrogen
Sep 2021
Publication
Hydrogen has the potential as an energy solution to contribute to decarbonisation targets as it has the capability to deliver low-carbon energy at the scale required. For this to be realised the suitability of the existing natural gas pipeline networks for transporting hydrogen must be established. The current paper describes a feasibility study that was undertaken to assess the potential for repurposing the UK’s Local Transmission System (LTS) natural gas pipelines for hydrogen service. The analysis focused on SGN’s network which includes 3000 km of LTS pipelines in Scotland and the south of England. The characteristics of the LTS pipelines in terms of materials of construction and operation were first evaluated. This analysis showed that a significant percentage of SGN’s LTS network consists of lower strength grades of steel pipeline that operate at low stresses which are factors conducive to a pipeline’s suitability for hydrogen service. An assessment was also made of where existing approaches in pipeline operation may require modifications for hydrogen. The effects of changes in mechanical properties of steel pipelines on integrity and lifetime as a result of potential hydrogen degradation were demonstrated using fitness-for-purpose analysis. A review of pipeline risk assessment and Land-Use Planning (LUP) zone calculations for hydrogen was undertaken to identify any required changes. Case studies on selected sections of the LTS pipeline were then carried out to illustrate the potential changes to LUP zones. The work concluded with a summary of identified gaps that require addressing to ensure safe pipeline repurposing for hydrogen which cover materials performance inspection risk assessment land use planning and procedures.
Evaluation of Selectivity and Resistance to Poisons of Commercial Hydrogen Sensors
Sep 2013
Publication
The development of reliable hydrogen sensors is crucial for the safe use of hydrogen. One of the main concerns of end-users is sensor reliability in the presence of species other than the target gas which can lead to false alarms or undetected harmful situations. In order to assess the selectivity of commercial of the shelf (COTS) hydrogen sensors a number of sensors of different technology types were exposed to various interferent gas species. Cross-sensitivity tests were performed in accordance to the recommendations of ISO 26142:2010 using the hydrogen sensor testing facilities of NREL and JRC-IET. The results and conclusions arising from this study are presented.
Effects of Renewable Energy Unstable Source to Hydrogen Production: Safety Considerations
Sep 2021
Publication
Hydrogen is considered a promising energy carrier for a sustainable future when it is produced by utilizing renewable energy. Nowadays less than 4% of hydrogen production is based on electrolysis processes. Each component of a hydrogen energy system needs to be optimized to increase the operation time and system efficiency. Only in this way hydrogen produced by electrolysis processes can be competitive with the conventional fossil energy sources. As conventional electrolysers are designed for operation at fixed process conditions the implementation of fluctuating and highly intermittent renewable energy is challenging. Alkaline water electrolysis is a key technology for large-scale hydrogen production powered by renewable energy. At low power availability conventional alkaline water electrolysers show a limited part-load range due to an increased gas impurity. Explosive mixtures of hydrogen and oxygen must be prevented; thus a safety shutdown is performed when reaching specific gas contamination. The University of Pisa is setting up a dedicated laboratory including a 40-kW commercial alkaline electrolyser: the focus of the study is to analyze the safety of the electrolyser together with its performance and the real energy efficiency analyzing its operational data collected under different operating conditions affected by the unstable energy supply.
Analysis to Support Revised Distances between Bulk Liquid Hydrogen Systems and Exposures
Sep 2021
Publication
The minimum distances between exposures and bulk liquid hydrogen listed in the National Fire Protection Agency’s Hydrogen Technology Code NFPA 2 are based on historical consensus without a documented scientific analysis. This work follows a similar analysis as the scientific justification provided in NFPA 2 for exposure distances from bulk gaseous hydrogen storage systems but for liquid hydrogen. Validated physical models from Sandia’s HyRAM software are used to calculate distances to a flammable concentration for an unignited release the distance to critical heat flux values and the visible flame length for an ignited release and the overpressure that would occur for a delayed ignition of a liquid hydrogen leak. Revised exposure distances for bulk liquid hydrogen systems are calculated. These distances are related to the maximum allowable working pressure of the tank and the line size as compared to the current exposure distances which are based on system volume. For most systems the exposure distances calculated are smaller than the current distances for Group 1 they are similar for Group 2 while they increase for some Group 3 exposures. These distances could enable smaller footprints for infrastructure that includes bulk liquid hydrogen storage tanks especially when using firewalls to mitigate Group 3 hazards and exposure distances. This analysis is being refined as additional information on leak frequencies is incorporated and changes have been proposed to the 2023 edition of NFPA 2.
Hydrogen Generation on Orkney: Integrating Established Risk Management Best Practice to Emerging Clean Energy Sector
Sep 2021
Publication
The European Marine Energy Centre’s (EMEC) ITEG project (Integrating Tidal Energy into the European Grid) funded by Interreg NWE combines a tidal energy and hydrogen production solution to address grid constraints on the island of Eday in Orkney. The project will install a 0.5MW electrolyser at EMEC’s existing hydrogen production plant. EMEC and Risktec collaboratively applied best practice risk assessment and management techniques to assess and manage hydrogen safety. Hazard identification (HAZID) workshops were conducted collaboratively with design engineers through which a comprehensive hazard register was developed. Risktec applied bowtie analysis to each major accident hazard identified from the hazard register via virtual workshop with design engineers. The bowties promoted a structured review of each hazard’s threat and consequence identifying and reviewing the controls in place against good practice standards. The process revealed some recommendations for further improvement and risk reduction exemplifying a systematic management of risks associated with hydrogen hazards to as low as reasonably practicable (ALARP). Hardware based barriers preventing or mitigating loss of control of these hazards were logged as safety critical elements (SCE) and procedural barriers as safety critical activities (SCA). To ensure that all SCEs and SCAs identified through the risk assessment process are managed throughout the facility’s operational lifetime a safety management system is created giving assurance of overall safety management system continued effectiveness. The process enables the demonstration that design risks are managed to ALARP during design and throughout operational lifetime. More importantly enabling ITEG to progress to construction and operation in 2021.
Chemical Inhibition of Premixed Hydrogen-air Flames: Experimental Investigation using a 20-litre Vessel
Sep 2021
Publication
Throughout the history of the mining petroleum process and nuclear industries continuous efforts have been made to develop and improve measures to prevent and mitigate accidental explosions. Over the coming decades energy systems are expected to undergo a transition towards sustainable use of conventional hydrocarbons and an increasing share of renewable energy sources in the global energy mix. The variable and intermittent supply of energy from solar and wind points to energy systems based on hydrogen or hydrogen-based fuels as the primary energy carriers. However the safety-related properties of hydrogen imply that it is not straightforward to achieve and document the same level of safety for hydrogen systems compared to similar systems based on established fuels such as petrol diesel and natural gas. Compared to the conventional fuels hydrogen-air mixtures have lower ignition energy higher combustion reactivity and a propensity to undergo deflagration-to-detonation-transition (DDT) under certain conditions. To achieve an acceptable level of safety it is essential to develop effective measures for mitigating the consequences of hydrogen explosions in systems with certain degree of congestion and confinement. Extensive research over the last decade have demonstrated that chemical inhibition or partial suppression can be used for mitigating the consequences of vapour cloud explosions (VCEs) in congested process plants. Total and cooperation partners have demonstrated that solid flame inhibitors injected into flammable hydrocarbon-air clouds represent an effective means of mitigating the consequences of VCEs involving hydrocarbons. For hydrogen-air explosions these same chemicals inhibitors have not proved effective. It is however well-known that hydrocarbons can affect the burning velocity of hydrogen-air mixtures greatly. This paper gives an overview over previous work on chemical inhibitors. In addition experiments in a 20-litre vessel have been performed to investigate the effect of combinations of hydrocarbons and alkali salts on hydrogen/air mixtures.
Minimum Fire Size for Hydrogen Storage Tank Fire Test Protocol for Hydrogen-powered Electric City Bus Determine Via Risk-based Approach
Sep 2021
Publication
As part of the United Nations Global Technical Regulation No. 13 (UN GTR #13 [1]) vehicle fire safety is validated using a localized and engulfing fire test methodology and currently updates are being considered in the on-going Phase 2 development stage. The GTR#13 fire test is designed to verify the performance of a hydrogen storage system of preventing rupture when exposed to service-terminating condition of fire situation. The test is conducted in two stages – localized flame exposure at a location most challenging for thermally-activated pressure relief device(s) (TPRDs) to respond for 10 min. followed by engulfing fire exposure until the system vents and the pressure falls to less than 1 MPa or until “time out” (30min. for light-duty vehicle containers and 60 min. for heavy-duty vehicle containers). The rationale behind this two-stage fire test is to ensure that even when fire sizes are small and TPRDs are not responding the containers have fire resistance to withstand or fire sensitivity to respond to a localized fire to avoid system rupture. In this study appropriate fire sizes for localized and engulfing fire tests in GTR#13 are evaluated by considering actual fire conditions in a hydrogen-powered electric city bus. Quantitative risk analysis is conducted to develop various fire accident scenarios including regular bus fire battery fire and hydrogen leak fire. Frequency and severity analyses are performed to determine the minimum fire size required in GTR#13 fire test to ensure hydrogen storage tank safety in hydrogen-powered electric city buses.
Protocol for Heavy-duty Hydrogen Refueling: A Modelling Benchmark
Sep 2021
Publication
For the successful deployment of the Heavy Duty (HD) hydrogen vehicles an associated infrastructure in particular hydrogen refueling stations (HRS) should be reliable compliant with regulations and optimized to reduce the related costs. FCH JU project PRHYDE aims to develop a sophisticated protocol dedicated to HD applications. The target of the project is to develop protocol and recommendations for an efficient refueling of 350 500 and 700 bar HD tanks of types III and IV. This protocol is based on modeling results as well as experimental data. Different partners of the PRHYDE European project are closely working together on this target. However modeling approaches and corresponding tools must first be compared and validated to ensure the high level of reliability for the modeling results. The current paper presents the benchmark performed in the frame of the project by Air Liquide Engie Wenger Engineering and NREL. The different models used were compared and calibrated to the configurations proposed by the PRHYDE project. In addition several scenarios were investigated to explore different cases with high ambient temperatures.
No more items...