Safety
Modeling of Unintended Hydrogen Releases from a Fuel Cell Tram
Sep 2021
Publication
Hydrogen is a promising alternative energy carrier that has been increasingly used in industry especially the transportation sector to fuel vehicles through fuel cells. Hydrogen fuel cell vehicles usually have high pressure on-board storage tanks which take up large spaces to provide comparable ranges as current fossil fuel vehicles because of the low volumetric energy density of hydrogen. Therefore hydrogen is also appropriate for large heavy-duty vehicles that have more space than passenger vehicles.
Brief Review on High-Temperature Electrochemical Hydrogen Sensors
Dec 2022
Publication
Hydrogen sensors especially those operating at high temperatures are essential tools for the emerging hydrogen economy. Monitoring hydrogen under process conditions to control the reactions for detecting confined species is crucial to the safe widespread use and public acceptance of hydrogen as fuel. Hydrogen sensors must have a sensitivity ranging from traces of hydrogen (parts per million (ppm)) up to levels near the lower explosive limit (LEL = 4% H2 in the air) for safety reasons. Furthermore they need to operate in cryogenic ambient and high-temperature environments. Herein emphasis is given to hydrogen sensors based on solid oxide electrolytes (operating at high temperatures) in particular oxygen ion and proton conductors. The review is devoted to potentiometric amperometric and combined amperometric-potentiometric hydrogen sensors. Experimental results already reported in the international literature are presented and analyzed to reveal the configuration principle of operation and the applied solid electrolytes and electrodes of the high-temperature hydrogen sensors. Additionally an amperometric sensor able to detect hydrogen and steam in atmospheric air through a two-stage procedure is presented and thoroughly discussed. The discussion reveals that high-temperature hydrogen sensors face different challenges in terms of the electrodes and solid electrolytes to be used depending on the operating principle of each sensor type.
Numerical Simulation of Hydrogen Deflagration Using CFD
Sep 2021
Publication
Hydrogen is seen as an important future energy carrier as part of the move away from traditional hydrocarbon sources. Delayed ignition of a hydrogen-air mixture formed from an accidental release of hydrogen in either a confined or congested environment can lead to the generation of overpressure impacting both people and assets. An understanding of the possible overpressures generated is critical in designing facilities and effective mitigation systems against hydrogen explosion hazards. This paper describes the numerical modelling of hydrogen deflagrations using a new application PDRFOAM-R that is part of the wider OpenFOAM open-source CFD package of routines for the solution of systems of partial differential equations. The PDRFOAM-R code solves momentum and continuity equations the combustion model is based on flame area transport and the turbulent burning velocity correlation is based on Markstein and Karlovitz numbers. PDRFOAM-R is derived from publicly available PDRFOAM tool and it resolves small and large obstacles unlike PDRFOAM which is based on the Porosity Distributed Resistance approach. The PDRFOAM-R code is validated against various unconfined-uncongested and semi-confined congested explosion experiments. The flame dynamics and pressure history predicted from the simulation show a reasonable comparison with the experiments.
Numerical Study of the Effects of Tunnel Inclination and Ventilation on the Dispersion of Hydrogen Released from a Car
Sep 2021
Publication
Hydrogen cars are expected to play an important role in a decarbonised clean-transport future. Safety issues arise though in tunnels due to the possibility of accidental release and accumulation of hydrogen. This Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) study focuses on the effect of tunnel inclination and ventilation on hydrogen dispersion. A horseshoe shaped tunnel of 200 m length is considered in all seventeen cases examined. In most cases hydrogen is released from the bottom of a car placed at the center of the tunnel. Various inclinations in-tunnel wind speeds and fuel tank Pressure Relief Device (PRD) diameters were considered in order to assess their influence on safety. It was found that even if the long-term influence of the inclination is positive there is no systematic effect at initial stages nor at the most dangerous ‘nearly-stoichiometric’ cloud volumes (25% - 35% v/v). Adverse effects may also exist like the occasionally higher flammable cloud (4% - 75% v/v). Regarding ventilation it was found that even low wind speeds (e.g. 1 m/s) can reduce the flammable cloud by several times. However no significant effect on the total nearly-stoichiometric volumes was found for most of the cases examined. Ventilation can also cause adverse effects as for example at mid-term of the release duration in some cases. Concerning the PRD diameter a reduction from 4 mm to 2 mm resulted in about five times smaller maximum of the nearly-stoichiometric cloud volume. In addition the effect of release orientation on hydrogen cloud was examined and it was found that the downwards direction presents drawbacks compared to the backwards and upwards release directions.
Three-dimensional Simulations of Lean H2-air Flames Propagating in a Narrow Gap: n the Validity of the Quasi-two-dimensional Appoximation
Sep 2021
Publication
The premixed propagation of lean isobaric H2-air flames (φ = 0.3) in Hele-Shaw cells (i.e. two parallel plates separated by a small distance h on the order of the thickness of the planar adiabatic flame δf ∼ 3 mm) is investigated numerically. Three-dimensional (3D) simulations with detailed chemistry and transport are used to examine the effect of h on the flame dynamics and its overall normalized propagation speed (S T /S L) for a semi-closed system of size 25δf × 25δf × h. To determine the validity of an existing quasi-two-dimensional (quasi-2D) formulation (derived in the limit of h → 0) to capture the 3D dynamics results for h = 0.1δf h = 0.5δf and h = δf are reported. For h = 0.1δf strong cell splitting/merging is observed with associated low frequency/high amplitude oscillations in the temporal evolution of S T /S L (10-17Hz; 6 ≤ S T /S L ≤ 10). Larger values of h exhibit a much smoother evolution. For h = 0.5δf the cell splitting/merging is milder relaxing to a steady propagating speed of S T /S L ∼ 6 after an initial transient; for h = 1δf the flame dynamics along the h direction starts to play an important role showing two distinct phases: (i) initial symmetric propagation with a linear increase in S T /S L (from 5.3 to 6.8) as early signs of asymmetry are visible (ii) followed by a fully non-symmetric propagation resulting in an abrupt increase in S T /S L that quickly relaxes to a constant value thereafter (S T /S L ∼ 10). Our preliminary results suggest that for the lean H2-air mixture considered the quasi-2D approximation breaks down for h > 0.1δf .
Controlling the Pressure of Hydrogen-natural Gas Mixture in an Inclined Pipeline
Feb 2020
Publication
This paper discusses the optimal control of pressure using the zero-gradient control (ZGC) approach. It is applied for the first time in the study to control the optimal pressure of hydrogen natural gas mixture in an inclined pipeline. The solution to the flow problem is first validated with existing results using the Taylor series approximation regression analysis and the Runge-Kutta method combined. The optimal pressure is then determined using ZGC where the optimal set points are calculated without having to solve the non-linear system of equations associated with the standard optimization problem. It is shown that the mass ratio is the more effective parameter compared to the initial pressure in controlling the maximum variation of pressure in a gas pipeline.
Risk Assessment and Mitigation Evaluation for Hydrogen Vehicles in Private Garages. Experiments and Modelling
Sep 2021
Publication
Governments and local authorities introduce new incentives and regulations for cleaner mobility as part of their environmental strategies to address energy challenges. Fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEVs) are becoming increasingly important and will extend beyond captive fleets reaching private users. Research on hydrogen safety issues is currently led in several projects in order to highlight and manage risks of FCEVs in confined spaces such as tunnels underground parkings repair garages etc. But what about private garages - that involve specific geometries volumes congestion ventilation? This study has been carried out in the framework of PRHyVATE JIP project which aims at better understanding hydrogen build-up and distribution in a private garage. The investigation went through different rates and modes of ventilation. As first step an HAZID (Hazard Identification) has been realized for a generic FCEV. This preliminary work allowed to select and prioritize accidental release scenarios to be explored experimentally with helium in a 40-m3 garage. Several configurations of release ventilation modes and congestion – in transient regime and at steady state – have been tested. Then analytical and numerical calculation approaches have been applied and adjusted to develop a simplified methodology. This methodology takes into account natural ventilation for assessment of hydrogen accumulation and mitigation means optimization. Finally a global risk evaluation – including ignition of a flammable hydrogen-air mixture – has been performed to account for the mostly feared events and to evaluate their consequences in a private garage. Thus preliminary recommendations good practices and safety features for safely parking FCEVs in private garages can be proposed.
Assessing Damaged Pipelines Transporting Hydrogen
Jun 2022
Publication
There is worldwide interest in transporting hydrogen using both new pipelines and pipelines converted from natural gas service. Laboratory tests investigating the effect of hydrogen on the mechanical properties of pipeline steels have shown that even low partial pressures of hydrogen can substantially reduce properties such as reduction in area and fracture toughness and increase fatigue crack growth rates. However qualitative arguments suggest that the effects on pipelines may not be as severe as predicted from the small scale tests. If the trends seen in laboratory tests do occur in service there are implications for the assessment of damage such as volumetric corrosion dents and mechanical interference. Most pipeline damage assessment methods are semi-empirical and have been calibrated with data from full scale tests that did not involve hydrogen. Hence the European Pipeline Research Group (EPRG) commissioned a study to investigate damage assessment methods in the presence of hydrogen. Two example pipeline designs were considered both were assessed assuming a modern high performance material and an older material. From these analyses the numerical results show that the high toughness material will tolerate damage even if the properties are degraded by hydrogen exposure. However low toughness materials may not be able to tolerate some types of severe damage. If the predictions are realistic operators may have to repair more damage or reduce operating pressures. Furthermore damage involving cracking may not Page 2 of 22 satisfy the ASME B31.12 requirements for preventing time dependent crack growth. Further work is required to determine if the effects predicted using small scale laboratory test data will occur in practice.
Simulation of Hydrogen Mixing and Par Operation During Accidental Release in an LH2 Carrier Engine Room
Sep 2021
Publication
Next-generation LH2 carriers may use the boil-off gas from the cargo tanks as additional fuel for the engine. As a consequence hydrogen pipes will enter the room of the ship’s propulsion system and transport hydrogen to the main engine. The hydrogen distribution resulting from a postulated hydrogen leak inside the room of the propulsion system has been analyzed by means of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). In a subsequent step simulations with passive auto-catalytic recombiners (PARs) were carried out in order to investigate if the recombiners can increase the safety margins during such accident scenarios. CFD enables a 3D prediction of the transient distribution with a high resolution allowing to identify local accumulation of hydrogen and consequently to identify optimal PAR positions as well as to demonstrate the efficiency of the PARs. The simulation of the unmitigated reference case reveals a strong natural circulation driven by the density difference of hydrogen and the incoming cold air from the ventilation system. Globally this natural circulation dilutes the hydrogen and removes a considerable amount from the room of the ship’s propulsion system via the ventilation ducts. However a hydrogen accumulation beyond the flammability limit is identified below the first ceiling above the leak position and the back-side wall of the engine room. Based on these findings suitable positions for recombiners were identified. The design objectives of the PAR system were on the one hand to provide both high instantaneous and integral removal rate and on the other hand to limit build-up of flammable clouds by means of depletion and PAR induced mixing processes. The simulations performed with three different PAR arrangements (variation of large and<br/>small PAR units at different positions) confirm that the PARs reduce efficiently the hydrogen<br/>accumulations.
Numerical Analysis on the Mechanism of Blast Mitigation by Water Droplets
Sep 2021
Publication
Hydrogen has a high risk of ignition owing to its extremely low ignition energy and wide range of flammability. Therefore acquiring parameters relating to safe usage is of particular interest. The ignition of hydrogen generates combustion processes such as detonation and deflagration which may produce a blast wave. The severity of injuries sustained from a blast wave is determined by its strength. To reduce the physical hazards caused by explosion there is a need for some concepts for attenuating explosions and blast waves. In the present study we used water droplets as a material to reduce the blast wave strength. Numerical analysis of the interaction between blast waves and water droplets in a shock tube was conducted to understand the mitigation mechanism of blast wave. In this report we numerically modelled the experiment conducted by Mataradze et al. [1] to understand the main factor of blast mitigation by water droplets. In order to quantitatively clarify the mitigation effect of water droplets on the blast wave especially by quasi-steady drag here we conducted parameter studies on water droplet sprayed region. From this calculation it was suggested that the location of water droplet sprayed layer did not affect the blast mitigation effect at far side of the high explosives.
Effect of Heat Transfer through the Release of Pipe on Simulations of Cryogenic Hydrogen Jet Fires and Hazard Distances
Sep 2021
Publication
Jet flames originated by cryo-compressed ignited hydrogen releases can cause life-threatening conditions in their surroundings. Validated models are needed to accurately predict thermal hazards from a jet fire. Numerical simulations of cryogenic hydrogen flow in the release pipe are performed to assess the effect of heat transfer through the pipe walls on jet parameters. Notional nozzle exit diameter is calculated based on the simulated real nozzle parameters and used in CFD simulations as a boundary condition to model jet fires. The CFD model was previously validated against experiments with vertical cryogenic hydrogen jet fires with release pressures up to 0.5 MPa (abs) release diameter 1.25 mm and temperatures as low as 50 K. This study validates the CFD model in a wider domain of experimental release conditions - horizontal cryogenic jets at exhaust pipe temperature 80 K pressure up to 2 MPa abs and release diameters up to 4 mm. Simulation results are compared against experimentally measured parameters as hydrogen mass flow rate flame length and radiative heat flux at several locations from the jet fire. The CFD model reproduces well experiments with reasonable engineering accuracy. Jet fire hazard distances established using three different criteria - temperature thermal radiation and thermal dose - are compared and discussed based on CFD simulation results.
Numerical Simulation on Hydrogen Leakage and Dispersion Behavior in Hydrogen Energy Infrastructures
Sep 2021
Publication
Unexpected hydrogen leakage may occur in the production storage transportation and utilization of hydrogen. The lower flammability limit (LFL) for the hydrogen is 4% in air. The combustion and explosion of hydrogen-air mixture poses potential hazards to personnel and property. In this study unintended release of hydrogen from a hydrogen fuel cell forklift vehicle inside a enclosed warehouse is simulated by fireFoam which is an LES Navier-Stokes CFD solver. The simulation results are verified by experimental data. The variation of hydrogen concentration with time and the isosurface of hydrogen concentration of 4% vol. are given. Furthermore the leakage of hydrogen from a storage tanks in a hydrogen refueling station is simulated and the evolution of the isosurface of hydrogen concentration of 4% vol. is given which provides a quantitative guidence for determination the hazardous area after the leakage of hydrogen.
CFD Modeling on Natural and Forced Ventilation During Hydrogen Leaks in a Pressure Regulator Process of a Residential Area
Mar 2022
Publication
Hydrogen fuel cells have been installed in more than 100 facilities and numerous homes in Ulsan hydrogen town in the Republic of Korea. Despite the advantages of hydrogen accidents can still occur near residential areas. Thus appropriate risk mitigation plans should be established. In this study a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) model of natural and forced ventilation is presented as an emergency response to hydrogen leakages in pressure regulator equipment housing. The CFD model is developed and investigated using three vent configurations: UP CROSS and UP-DOWN. The simulation results indicate that the UPDOWN configuration achieves the lowest internal hydrogen concentration out of the three. In addition the relationship between the total vent size and internal hydrogen concentration is determined. A vent size of 12% of the floor area has the lowest hydrogen concentration. The use of nitrogen for forced ventilation during emergencies is proposed to ensure that the hydrogen concentration of the released gas is less than one-fourth of the lower flammability 2 / 25 limit of hydrogen. Compared to natural ventilation the time required to reach safe conditions is decreased when nitrogen forced ventilation is used.
Proposed Approach to Calculate Safety Distances for Hydrogen Fuelling Station in Italy
Sep 2021
Publication
In 2021 only 6 hydrogen fuelling station have been built in Italy of which 3 are not operational and only 1 is open to the public while the rest are built in private or industrial areas. While fuelling station which store more than 5000 kg of hydrogen are subjected to the “Seveso Directive” the permitting procedure for refuelling station which store less than the threshold is supervised by the fire brigade command of the province where the station is built. Recently in the effort to easy the permitting procedure to establish new stations a Ministerial Decree was published in the official gazette of the Italian Republic which lists minimum safety features and safety distances that if respected guarantee the approval by the authority. Nevertheless the imposed distances are such that the land required to build the station constitute a barrier rather than a facilitation. Exploiting the possibility introduced by the Decree to calculate safety distances following a Fire Safety Engineering approach a method is proposed for calculation of safety distances. The present paper presents the Italian regulation and describes an approach to calculate the safety distances including an example applied on the dispenser.
Tactical Depressurization of Hydrogen and CNG Tanks Using Rifles and Other Projectiles
Sep 2021
Publication
After a tank has been exposed to crash violence or an external fire it might in some situations be judged dangerous to move the vessel due to the risk of a sudden tank rupture. Therefore Swedish rescue services have a long history of using rifles to penetrate and therefore depressurize the vessels. In this paper some first steps on providing guidance on the selection of ammunition and required stand back distance are presented. The results indicate that a stand back distance on the order of 100 m is required and that the standard 7.62 Ball should only be used for composite CNG-tanks while stronger ammunitions are needed for steel and composite hydrogen tanks. However more research is required to provide a more solid scientific underpinning of the tactic guidance.
Thermal Radiation Properties of Large Hydrogen Leaks from Gas Distribution Networks
Sep 2019
Publication
Determination of the behaviour of hydrogen when leaking from pipework on gas distribution assets is essential in assessing the comparative risk associated with using pure hydrogen in place of natural gas in existing assets. Experimental work considering the behaviour of gaseous hydrogen when released in large volumes from gas distribution pipework at pressures of up to 7 barg through holes of up to 200mm in diameter in both buried and unburied scenarios is currently underway. The present paper presents and briefly discusses the results from a set of ignited 20mm diameter releases of hydrogen at pressures up to 7 barg vertically upwards from a pipe in an open excavation. Gaseous releases which find a direct route to atmosphere have the potential to create significant volumes of flammable gas and subsequently significant fires in the case of ignition. It is important to understand both the dispersion distances and thermal hazard field to be able to understand the comparative risk posed when compared to natural gas releases in similar situations. Results of current work completed to date are presented alongside comparisons with known properties of natural gas releases and the potential implications to the comparative risk of hydrogen network operation. The work has been conducted at the DNV GL Spadeadam Testing and Research Centre UK as part of the UK Gas Distribution Networks and Ofgem National Innovation Competition funded H21 project.
Pressure Peaking Phenomena: Unignited Hydrogen Releases in Confined Spaces – Large-scale Experiments
Sep 2020
Publication
The aim of this study was to validate a model for predicting overpressure arising from accidental hydrogen releases in areas with limited ventilation. Experiments were performed in a large-scale setup that included a steel-reinforced container of volume 14.9 m3 and variable ventilation areas and mass flow rates. The pressure peaking phenomenon characterized as transient overpressure with a characteristic peak in a vented enclosure was observed during all the experiments. The model description presented the relationship between the ventilation area mass flow rate enclosure volume and discharge coefficient. The experimental results were compared with two prediction models representing a perfect mix and the real mix. The perfect mix assumed that all the released hydrogen was well stirred inside the enclosure during the releases. The real mix prediction s used the hydrogen concentration and temperature data measured during experiments. The prediction results with both perfect mix and real mix showed possible hazards during unignited hydrogen releases.
Hydrogen Storage: Recent Improvements and Industrial Prospective
Oct 2015
Publication
Efficient storage of hydrogen is crucial for the success of hydrogen energy markets (early markets as well as transportation market). Hydrogen can be stored either as a compressed gas a refrigerated liquefied gas a cryo-compressed gas or in hydrides. This paper gives an overview of hydrogen storage technologies and details the specific issues and constraints related to the materials behaviour in hydrogen and conditions representative of hydrogen energy uses. It is indeed essential for the development of applications requiring long-term performance to have good understanding of long-term behaviour of the materials of the storage device and its components under operational loads.
Modelling Heat Transfer in an Intumescent Paint and its Effect on Fire Resistance of On-board Hydrogen Storage
Oct 2015
Publication
This paper describes a 1-D numerical model for the prediction of heat and mass transfer through an intumescent paint that is applied to an on-board high-pressure GH2 storage tank. The intumescent paint is treated as a composite system consisting of three general components decomposing in accordance with independent finite reaction rates. A moving mesh that is employed for a better prediction of the expansion process of the intumescent paint is based on the local changes of heat and mass. The numerical model is validated against experiments by Cagliostro et al. (1975). The overall model results are used to estimate effect of intumescent paint on fire resistance of carbon-fibre reinforced GH2 storage.
Adapted Tube Cleaning Practices to Reduce Particulate Contamination at Hydrogen Fueling Stations
Sep 2017
Publication
The higher rate of component failure and downtime during initial operation in hydrogen stations is not well understood. The National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) has been collecting failed components from retail and research hydrogen fuelling stations in California and Colorado and analyzing them using an optical zoom and scanning electron microscope. The results show stainless steel metal particulate contamination. While it is difficult to definitively know the origin of the contaminants a possible source of the metal particulates is improper tube cleaning practices. To understand the impact of different cleaning procedures NREL performed an experiment to quantify the particulates introduced from newly cut tubes. The process of tube cutting threading and bevelling which is performed most often during station fabrication is shown to introduce metal contaminants and thus is an area that could benefit from improved cleaning practices. This paper shows how these particulates can be reduced which could prevent station downtime and costly repair. These results are from the initial phase of a project in which NREL intends to further investigate the sources of particulate contamination in hydrogen stations.
No more items...