Safety
Effectiveness Evaluation of Facilities Protecting from Hydrogen-air Explosion Overpressure
Sep 2011
Publication
The physical processes of the explosion of the hydrogen cloud which is formed as a result of the instantaneous destruction of high-pressure cylinder in the fuelling station are investigated. To simulate the formation of hydrogen-air mixture and its combustion a three-dimensional model of an instantaneous explosion of the gas mixture based on the Euler equations supplemented by the conservation laws of mixture components solved by Godunov method is used. To reduce the influence of the overpressure effects in the shock wave on the surrounding environment it is proposed to use a number of protective measures. An estimation of the efficiency of safety devices is carried out by monitoring the overpressure changes in several critical points. To reduce the pressure load on the construction of protective devices a range of constructive measures is also offered.
Safety Concept of a self-sustaining PEM Hydrogen Electrolyzer System
Sep 2013
Publication
Sustainable electricity generation is gaining importance across the globe against the backdrop of ever- diminishing resources and to achieve significant reductions in CO2 emissions. One of the challenges is storing excess energy generated from wind and solar power. Siemens developed an electrolysis system based on proton exchange membrane (PEM) technology enabling large volumes of energy to be stored through the conversion of electrical energy into hydrogen. In developing this new product range Siemens worked intensively on safe operation with a special focus on safety measures (primary secondary and tertiary). Indeed hydrogen is not only a rapidly diffusing gas with a wide range of flammability but frequent lack of information leads to insecurity among the public. Siemens PEM water electrolyzer operates at a working pressure of 50 bar / 5 MPa. The current product generation is being used for demonstration purposes and fits into a 30 ft. / 9.14 m container. Further industrialized product lines up to double-digit medium voltage ranges will be available on the market short- and mid-term. The system is designed to operate self-sustaining. Therefore special features such as back-up and fail-safe mode supported by remote monitoring and access have been implemented. This paper includes Siemens' approach to develop and implement a safety concept for the PEM water electrolyzer leading into the approval and certification by a Notified Body as well as the lessons learnt from test stand and field experience in this new application field
IGEM/SR/23 Review of Thermal Radiation and Noise for Hydrogen Venting
Nov 2021
Publication
IGEM/SR/23 (“Venting of natural gas”) provides recommendations for the conceptual design operation and safety aspects of permanent temporary and emergency venting of natural gas. The document was originally developed many years ago and the current edition dates to 1995. The document is due to be reviewed and updated for application to natural gas but the aim of this study is not to review the applicability of the document for natural gas but to assess the possible impact of 100% hydrogen on specific aspects of the existing guidance.<br/>A key element of the guidance concerns the safe dispersion distances for natural gas as vents are intended to provide a means of safely dispersing gas in the atmosphere without ignition. Guidance on safe dispersion distances for venting are provided in Section 6.6 accompanied by graphs showing the relationship between the mass flow rate through the vent and the safe (horizontal) dispersion distance. Details of the model used to predict the dispersion distances are given in Appendix 1. However for dispersion the guidance in IGEM/SR/23 has been superseded by similar guidance on hazard distances for unignited releases in IGEM/SR/25 (“Hazardous area classification of natural gas installations”) [2]. A comprehensive review of the applicability of IGEM/SR/25 to hydrogen is already underway for the LTS Futures project and is not duplicated here.<br/>However IGEM/SR/23 contains guidance on other important aspects relevant to the safe design and operation of vents which are not addressed elsewhere in the IGEM suite of standards; in particular guidance on hazard ranges for thermal radiation (in the event of an unplanned ignition of the venting gas) and noise.<br/>The main aim of this report is to assess the potential impact of replacing natural gas with 100% hydrogen on the guidance in IGEM/SR/23 concerned with thermal hazards with a secondary objective of assessing the available information to comment on the possible influence of hydrogen on noise.
Characterization of the Hazards from Jet Releases of Hydrogen
Sep 2005
Publication
Hydrogen is a convenient energy storage medium; it can be produced from fossil fuels and biomass via chemical conversion processes or from intermittent renewable sources like wind and solar via electrolysis. It is the fuel of choice for the clean fuel-cell vehicles of the future. If the general public are to use hydrogen as a vehicle fuel customers must be able to handle hydrogen with the same degree of confidence and with comparable risk as conventional liquid and gaseous fuels. For the safe design of retail facilities through the development of appropriate codes and standards it is essential to understand all the hazards that could arise following an accidental release of hydrogen. If it is to be stored and used as a high-pressure gas the hazards associated with jet releases from accidental leaks must be considered. This paper describes work by Shell and the Health and Safety Laboratory to characterise the hazards from jet releases of hydrogen. Jet release experiments have been carried out using small leaks (circular holes ranging from 1 mm to 12 mm diameter) at system pressures up to 150 barg. Concentration measurements were made in the unignited free jets to determine the extent of the flammable cloud generated. Ignited jets were observed both in the visible and infrared to determine the flame size and shape. The experimental results for the extent of the flammable cloud and jet flame length were found to be in good agreement with model predictions.
Numerical Characterization of Under-expanded Cryogenic Hydrogen Gas Jets
Sep 2022
Publication
High-resolution direct numerical simulations are conducted for under-expanded cryogenic hydrogen gas jets to characterize the nearfield flow physics. The basic flow features and jet dynamics are analyzed in detail revealing the existence of four stages during early jet development namely (a) initial penetration (b) establishment of near-nozzle expansion (c) formation of downstream compression and (d) wave propagation. Complex acoustic waves are formed around the under-expanded jets. The jet expansion can also lead to conditions for local liquefaction from the pressurized cryogenic hydrogen gas release. A series of simulations are conducted with systematically varied nozzle pressure ratios and systematically changed exit diameters. The acoustic waves around the jets are found to waken with the decrease in the nozzle pressure ratio. The increase in the nozzle pressure ratio is found to accelerate hydrogen dispersion and widen the regions with hydrogen liquefaction potential. The increase in the nozzle exit diameter also widens the region with hydrogen liquefaction potential but slows down the evolution of the flow structures.
Development of Dispensing Hardware for Safe Fueling of Heavy Duty Vehicles
Sep 2021
Publication
The development of safe dispensing equipment for the fueling of heavy duty (HD) vehicles is critical to the expansion of this newly and quickly expanding market. This paper discusses the development of a HD dispenser and nozzles assembly (nozzle hose breakaway) for these new larger vehicles where flow rates are more than double compared to light duty (LD) vehicles. This equipment must operate at nominal pressures of 700 bar -40o C gas temperature and average flow rate of 5-10 kg/min at a high throughput commercial hydrogen fueling station without leaking hydrogen. The project surveyed HD vehicle manufacturers station developers and component suppliers to determine the basic specifications of the dispensing equipment and nozzle assembly. The team also examined existing codes and standards to determine necessary changes to accommodate HD components. From this information the team developed a set of specifications which will be used to design the dispensing equipment. In order to meet these goals the team performed computational fluid dynamic pressure modelling and temperature analysis in order to determine the necessary parameters to meet existing safety standards modified for HD fueling. The team also considered user operational and maintenance requirements such as freeze lock which has been an issue which prevents the removal of the nozzle from LD vehicles. The team also performed a failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA) to identify the possible failures in the design. The dispenser and nozzle assembly will be tested separately and then installed on an innovative HD fueling station which will use a HD vehicle simulator to test the entire system.
Numerical Study of the Effects of Tunnel Inclination and Ventilation on the Dispersion of Hydrogen Released from a Car
Sep 2021
Publication
Hydrogen cars are expected to play an important role in a decarbonised clean-transport future. Safety issues arise though in tunnels due to the possibility of accidental release and accumulation of hydrogen. This Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) study focuses on the effect of tunnel inclination and ventilation on hydrogen dispersion. A horseshoe shaped tunnel of 200 m length is considered in all seventeen cases examined. In most cases hydrogen is released from the bottom of a car placed at the center of the tunnel. Various inclinations in-tunnel wind speeds and fuel tank Pressure Relief Device (PRD) diameters were considered in order to assess their influence on safety. It was found that even if the long-term influence of the inclination is positive there is no systematic effect at initial stages nor at the most dangerous ‘nearly-stoichiometric’ cloud volumes (25% - 35% v/v). Adverse effects may also exist like the occasionally higher flammable cloud (4% - 75% v/v). Regarding ventilation it was found that even low wind speeds (e.g. 1 m/s) can reduce the flammable cloud by several times. However no significant effect on the total nearly-stoichiometric volumes was found for most of the cases examined. Ventilation can also cause adverse effects as for example at mid-term of the release duration in some cases. Concerning the PRD diameter a reduction from 4 mm to 2 mm resulted in about five times smaller maximum of the nearly-stoichiometric cloud volume. In addition the effect of release orientation on hydrogen cloud was examined and it was found that the downwards direction presents drawbacks compared to the backwards and upwards release directions.
The Influence of Grain Boundary and Hydrogen on the Indetation of Bi-crystal Nickel
Sep 2021
Publication
Three different types of symmetrical tilt grain boundaries Ȉ3 Ȉ11 and Ȉ27 were constructed to study the dislocation behavior under the indentation on bi-crystal nickel. After hydrogen charging the number of hydrogen atoms in the Ȉ3 sample is the smallest and gradually increases in Ȉ11 and Ȉ27 samples. The force-displacement curve of indentation shows that the deformation resistance of the Ȉ3 sample is significantly higher than that of Ȉ11 and Ȉ27 samples. With the presence of grain boundaries the deformation resistance of Ȉ11 and Ȉ27 samples is significantly improved while the deformation resistance of the Ȉ3 VDPSOH is weakened. The indentation depth during the formation of dislocations in single crystals is significantly greater than that of bi-crystals. Grain boundaries slow down the dislocation propagation speed. Compared with the bi-crystals without hydrogen the presence of hydrogen reduces the deformation resistance and accelerates the dislocation propagation.
CFD Simulations of the Refueling of Long Horizontal H2 Tanks
Sep 2021
Publication
The understanding of physical phenomena occurring during the refueling of H2 tanks used for hydrogen mobility applications is the key point towards the most optimal refueling protocol. A lot of experimental investigations on tank refueling were performed in the previous years for different types and sizes of tank. Several operating conditions were tested through these experiments. For instance the HyTransfer project gave one of the major outputs on the understanding of the physical phenomena occurring during a tank refueling. From a numerical perspective the availability of accurate numerical tools is another key point. Such tools could be used instead of the experimental set-ups to test various operating conditions or new designs of tanks and injectors. The use of these tools can reduce the cost of the refueling protocol development in the future. However they first need to be validated versus experimental data. This work is dedicated to CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamics) modeling of the hydrogen refueling of a long horizontal 530L type IV tank. As of now the number of available CFD simulations for such a large tank is low as the computational cost is significant which is often considered as a bottleneck for this approach. The simulated operating conditions correspond to one of the experimental campaigns performed in the framework of the HyTransfer project. The 3D CFD model is presented. In a first validation step the CFD results are compared with experimental data. Then a deeper insight into the physics predicted by the CFD is provided. Finally two other methodologies with the aim to reduce the computational cost have been tested.
Study of Attenuation Effect of Water Droplets on Shockwaves from Hydrogen Explosion
Sep 2021
Publication
The increasing demand for renewable energy storage may position hydrogen as one of the major players in the future energy system. However to introduce such technology high level of safety must be offered. In particular for the accident scenarios with combustion or explosion of the unintendedly released hydrogen in partially or fully confined volumes such as e.g. road tunnel the effective countermeasures preventing or reducing the risk of equipment damages and person injuries should be established. A mitigation strategy could be the use of existing fire suppression system which can inject water as a spray. The shock waves resulted from hydrogen explosion could be weakened by the water droplets met on the shock path. In the presented work an attenuation effect of water droplets presence on the strength of the passing shock was studied. The analysis of the different attenuation mechanisms was performed and estimation of the effect of spray parameters such as droplet size and spray density on the shock wave was carried out. For the quantitative evaluation of the attenuation potential a numerical model for the COM3D combustion code was developed. The novel model for the droplet behavior accounting for the realistic correlations for the fluid (water) particle drag force linked with the corresponding droplet breakup model describing droplet atomization is presented. The model was validated against literature experimental data and was used for the blind simulations of the hydrogen test facility in KIT.
Hydrogen Sensing Properties of UV Enhanced Pd-SnO2 Nano-Spherical Composites at Low Temperature
Sep 2021
Publication
Metal oxide semiconductor (MOS) is promising in developing hydrogen detectors. However typical MOS materials usually work between 200-500°C which not only restricts their application in flammable and explosive gases detection but also weakens sensor stability and causes high power consumption. This paper studies the sensing properties of UV enhanced Pd-SnO2 nano-spherical composites at 80-360 ℃. In the experiment Pd of different molar ratios (0.5 2.5 5.0 10.0) was doped into uniform spherical SnO2 nanoparticles by a hydrothermal synthesis method. A xenon lamp with a filter was used as the ultraviolet excitation light source to examine the response of the spherical Pd- SnO2 nanocomposite to 50-1000 ppm H2 gas. The influence of different intensities of ultraviolet light on the gas-sensing properties of composite materials compared with dark condition was analyzed. The experiments show that the conductivity of the composites can be greatly stabilized and the thermal excitation temperature can be reduced to 180 ℃ under the effect of UV enhancement. A rapid response (4.4/ 17.4 s) to 200 ppm of H2 at 330 °C can be achieved by the Pd-SnO2 nanocomposites with UV assistance. The mechanism may be attributed to light motivated electron-hole pairs due to built-in electric fields under UV light illumination which can be captured by target gases and lead to UV controlled gas sensing performance. Catalytic active sites of hydrogen are provided on the surface of the mixed material by Pd. The results in this study can be helpful in reducing the response temperature of MOS materials and improving the performance of hydrogen detectors."
Spontaneous Ignition of Cryo-Compressed Hydrogen in a T-Shaped Channel System
Aug 2022
Publication
Sudden releases of pressurised hydrogen may spontaneously ignite by the so-called “diffusion ignition” mechanism. Several experimental and numerical studies have been performed on spontaneous ignition for compressed hydrogen at ambient temperature. However there is no knowledge of the phenomenon for compressed hydrogen at cryogenic temperatures. The study aims to close this knowledge gap by performing numerical experiments using a computational fluid dynamics model validated previously against experiments at atmospheric temperatures to assess the effect of temperature decrease from ambient 300 K to cryogenic 80 K. The ignition dynamics is analysed for a T-shaped channel system. The cryo-compressed hydrogen is initially separated from the air in the T-shaped channel system by a burst disk (diaphragm). The inertia of the burst disk is accounted for in the simulations. The numerical experiments were carried out to determine the hydrogen storage pressure limit leading to spontaneous ignition in the configuration under investigation. It is found that the pressure limit for spontaneous ignition of the cryo-compressed hydrogen at temperature 80 K is 9.4 MPa. This is more than 3 times larger than pressure limit for spontaneous ignition of 2.9 MPa in the same setup at ambient temperature of 300 K.
Why Ultrasonic Gas Leak Detection?
Sep 2021
Publication
Technologies that have traditionally been used in fixed installations to detect hydrogen gas leaks such as Catalytic and Electrochemical Point Sensors have one limitation: in order for a leak to be detected the gas itself must either be in close proximity to the detector or within a pre-defined area. Unfortunately outdoor environmental conditions such as changing wind directions and quick dispersion of the gas cloud from a leaking outdoor installation often cause that traditional gas detection systems may not alert to the presence of gas simply because the gas never reaches the detector. These traditional gas detection systems need to wait for the gas to form a vapor cloud which may or may not ignite and which may or may not allow loss prevention by enabling shutting down the gas facility in time. Ultrasonic Gas Leak Detectors (UGLD) respond at the speed of sound at gas leak initiation unaffected by changing wind directions and dilution of the gas. Ultrasonic Gas Leak Detectors are based on robust microphone technology; they detect outdoor leaks by sensing the distinct high frequency ultrasound emitted by all high pressure gas leaks. With the ultrasonic sensing technology leaking gas itself does not have to reach the sensor – just the sound of the gas leaking. By adding Ultrasonic Gas Leak Detectors for Hydrogen leak detection faster response times and lower operation costs can be obtained.
Simulation of a Hydrogen-Air Diffusion Flame under Consideration of Component-Specific Diffusivities
Mar 2022
Publication
This work deals with the numerical investigation of a three-dimensional laminar hydrogenair diffusion flame in which a cylindrical fuel jet is surrounded by in-flowing air. To calculate the distribution of gas molecules the model solves the species conservation equation for N-1 components using infinity fast chemistry and irreversible chemical reaction. The consideration of the component-specific diffusion has a strong influence on the position of the high-temperature zone as well as on the concentration distribution of the individual gas molecules. The calculations of the developed model predict the radial and axial species and temperature distribution in the combustion chamber comparable to those from previous publications. Deviations due to a changed burner geometry and air supply narrow the flame structure by up to 50% and the high-temperature zones merge toward the central axis. Due to the reduced inflow velocity of the hydrogen the high-temperature zones develop closer to the nozzle inlet of the combustion chamber. As the power increases the length of the cold hydrogen jet increases. Furthermore the results show that the axial profiles of temperature and mass fractions scale quantitatively with the power input by the fuel.
The Evolution and Structure of Ignited High-pressure Cryogenic Hydrogen Jets
Jun 2022
Publication
The anticipated upscaling of hydrogen energy applications will involve the storage and transport of hydrogen at cryogenic conditions. Understanding the potential hazard arising from leaks in high-pressure cryogenic storage is needed to improve hydrogen safety. The manuscript reports a series of numerical simulations with detailed chemistry for the transient evolution of ignited high-pressure cryogenic hydrogen jets. The study aims to gain insight of the ignition processes flame structures and dynamics associated with the transient flame evolution. Numerical simulations were firstly conducted for an unignited jet released under the same cryogenic temperature of 80 K and pressure of 200 bar as the considered ignited jets. The predicted hydrogen concentrations were found to be in good agreement with the experimental measurements. The results informed the subsequent simulations of the ignited jets involving four different ignition locations. The predicted time series snapshots of temperature hydrogen mass fraction and the flame index are analyzed to study the transient evolution and structure of the flame. The results show that a diffusion combustion layer is developed along the outer boundary of the jet and a side diffusion flame is formed for the near-field ignition. For the far-field ignition an envelope flame is observed. The flame structure contains a diffusion flame on the outer edge and a premixed flame inside the jet. Due to the complex interactions between turbulence fuel-air mixing at cryogenic temperature and chemical reactions localized spontaneous ignition and transient flame extinguishment are observed. The predictions also captured the experimentally observed deflagration waves in the far-field ignited jets.
Hydrogen Stratification in Enclosures in Dependence of the Gas Release Momentum
Sep 2021
Publication
The hydrogen dispersion phenomenon in an enclosure depends on the ratio of the gas buoyancy induced momentum. Random diffusive motions of individual gas particles become dominative when the release momentum is low. Then a uniform hydrogen concentration appears in the enclosure instead of the gas stratification below the ceiling. The paper justifies this hypothesis by demonstrating fullscale experimental results of hydrogen dispersion within a confined space under six different release variations. During the experiments hydrogen was released into the test room of 60 m3 volume in two methods: through a nozzle and through 21 points evenly distributed on the emission box cover (multipoint release). Each release method was tested with three different hydrogen volume flow rates (3.17·10−3 m3/s 1.63·10−3 m3/s 3.34·10−4 m3/s). The tests confirm the increase of hydrogen convective upward flow and its stratification tendency relative to increased volume flow. A tendency of more uniform hydrogen cloud distribution when Mach Reynolds and Froud number values decreased was demonstrated. Because the hydrogen dispersion phenomena impact fire and explosive hazards the presented experimental results could help fire protection systems be in an enclosure designed allowing their effectiveness optimization.
Quantitative Risk Assessment Methodology for Hydrogen Tank Rupture in a Tunnel Fire
Dec 2022
Publication
This study presents a methodology of a quantitative risk assessment for the scenario of an onboard hydrogen storage tank rupture and tunnel fire incident. The application of the methodology is demonstrated on a road tunnel. The consequence analysis is carried out for the rupture of a 70 MPa 62.4-litre hydrogen storage tank in a fire that has a thermally activated pressure relief device (TPRD) failed or blocked during an incident. Scenarios with two states of charge (SoC) of the tank i.e. SoC = 99% and SoC = 59% are investigated. The risks in terms of fatalities per vehicle per year and the cost per incident are assessed. It is found that for the reduction in the risk with the hydrogen-powered vehicle in a road tunnel fire incident to the acceptable level of 10−5 fatality/vehicle/year the fireresistance rating (FRR) of the hydrogen storage tank should exceed 84 min. The FRR increase to this level reduces the societal risk to an acceptable level. The increase in the FRR to 91 min reduces the risk in terms of the cost of the incident to GBP 300 following the threshold cost of minor injury published by the UK Health and Safety Executive. The Frequency–Number (F–N) of the fatalities curve is developed to demonstrate the effect of mitigation measures on the risk reduction to socially acceptable levels. The performed sensitivity study confirms that with the broad range of input parameters including the fire brigade response time the risk of rupture of standard hydrogen tank-TPRD systems inside the road tunnel is unacceptable. One of the solutions enabling an inherently safer use of hydrogen-powered vehicles in tunnels is the implementation of breakthrough safety technology—the explosion free in a fire self-venting (TPRD-less) tanks.
Hydrogen Safety Challenges: A Comprehensive Review on Production, Storage, Transport, Utilization, and CFD-Based Consequence and Risk Assessment
Mar 2024
Publication
This review examines the central role of hydrogen particularly green hydrogen from renewable sources in the global search for energy solutions that are sustainable and safe by design. Using the hydrogen square safety measures across the hydrogen value chain—production storage transport and utilisation—are discussed thereby highlighting the need for a balanced approach to ensure a sustainable and efficient hydrogen economy. The review also underlines the challenges in safety assessments points to past incidents and argues for a comprehensive risk assessment that uses empirical modelling simulation-based computational fluid dynamics (CFDs) for hydrogen dispersion and quantitative risk assessments. It also highlights the activities carried out by our research group SaRAH (Safety Risk Analysis and Hydrogen) relative to a more rigorous risk assessment of hydrogenrelated systems through the use of a combined approach of CFD simulations and the appropriate risk assessment tools. Our research activities are currently focused on underground hydrogen storage and hydrogen transport as hythane.
Tactical Depressurization of Hydrogen and CNG Tanks Using Rifles and Other Projectiles
Sep 2021
Publication
After a tank has been exposed to crash violence or an external fire it might in some situations be judged dangerous to move the vessel due to the risk of a sudden tank rupture. Therefore Swedish rescue services have a long history of using rifles to penetrate and therefore depressurize the vessels. In this paper some first steps on providing guidance on the selection of ammunition and required stand back distance are presented. The results indicate that a stand back distance on the order of 100 m is required and that the standard 7.62 Ball should only be used for composite CNG-tanks while stronger ammunitions are needed for steel and composite hydrogen tanks. However more research is required to provide a more solid scientific underpinning of the tactic guidance.
A CFD Analysis of Liquefied Gas Vessel Explosions
Dec 2021
Publication
Hydrogen is one of the most suitable candidates in replacing fossil fuels. However storage issues due to its very low density under ambient conditions are encountered in many applications. The liquefaction process can overcome such issues by increasing hydrogen’s density and thus enhancing its storage capacity. A boiling liquid expanding vapour explosion (BLEVE) is a phenomenon in liquefied gas storage systems. It is a physical explosion that might occur after the catastrophic rupture of a vessel containing a liquid with a temperature above its boiling point at atmospheric pressure. Even though it is an atypical accident scenario (low probability) it should be always considered due to its high yield consequences. For all the above-mentioned reasons the BLEVE phenomenon for liquid hydrogen (LH2) vessels was studied using the CFD methodology. Firstly the CFD model was validated against a well-documented CO2 BLEVE experiment. Secondly hydrogen BLEVE cases were simulated based on tests that were conducted in the 1990s on LH2 tanks designed for automotive purposes. The parametric CFD analysis examined different filling degrees initial pressures and temperatures of the tank content with the aim of comprehending to what extent the initial conditions influence the blast wave. Good agreement was shown between the simulation outcomes and the LH2 bursting scenario tests results.
No more items...