Safety

Correct use of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) tools is essential in order to have confidence in the results. A comprehensive set of Best Practice Guidelines (BPG) in numerical simulations for Fuel Cells and Hydrogen applications has been one of the main outputs of the SUSANA project. These BPG focus on the practical needs of engineers in consultancies and industry undertaking CFD simulations or evaluating CFD simulation results in support of hazard/risk assessments of hydrogen facilities as well as on the needs of regulatory authorities. This contribution presents a summary of the BPG document. All crucial aspects of numerical simulations are addressed such as selection of the physical models domain design meshing boundary conditions and selection of numerical parameters. BPG cover all hydrogen safety relative phenomena i.e. release and dispersion ignition jet fire deflagration and detonation. A series of CFD benchmarking exercises are also presented serving as examples of appropriate modelling strategies.

The recent growth of the net of hydrogen fuelling stations increases the demands to transport compressed hydrogen on road by battery vehicles or tube-trailers both in composite pressure vessels. As a transport regulation the ADR is applicable in Europe and adjoined regions and is used for national transport in the EU. This regulation provides requirements based on the behaviour of each individual pressure vessel regardless of the pressure of the transported hydrogen and relevant consequences resulting from generally possible worst case scenarios such as sudden rupture. In 2012 the BAM (German Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing) introduced consequence-dependent requirements and established them in national transport requirements concerning the “UN service life checks” etc. to consider the transported volume and pressure of gases. This results in a requirement that becomes more restrictive as the product of pressure and volume increases. In the studies presented here the safety measures for hydrogen road transport are identified and reviewed through a number of safety measures from countries including Japan the USA and China. Subsequently the failure consequences of using trailer vehicles the related risk and the chance are evaluated. A benefit-related risk criterion is suggested to add to regulations and to be defined as a safety goal in standards for hydrogen transport vehicles and for mounted pressure vessels. Finally an idea is given for generating probabilistic safety data and for highly efficient evaluation without a significant increase of effort.

Passive auto-catalytic recombiners (PARs) have the potential to be used in the future for the removal of accidentally released hydrogen inside confined areas. PARs could be operated both as stand-alone or backup safety devices e.g. in case of active ventilation failure.

Recently computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations have been performed in order to demonstrate the principal performance of a PAR during a postulated hydrogen release inside a car garage. This fundamental study has now been extended towards a variation of several boundary conditions including PAR location hydrogen release scenario and active venting operation. The goal of this enhanced study is to investigate the sensitivity of the PAR operational behaviour for changing boundary conditions and to support the identification of a suitable PAR positioning strategy. For the simulation of PAR operation the in-house code REKO-DIREKT has been implemented in the CFD code ANSYS-CFX 15.

In a first step the vertical position of the PAR and the thermal boundary conditions of the garage walls have been modified. In a subsequent step different hydrogen release modes have been simulated which result either in a hydrogen-rich layer underneath the ceiling or in a homogeneous hydrogen distribution inside the garage. Furthermore the interaction of active venting and PAR operation has been investigated.

As a result of this parameter study the optimum PAR location was identified to be close underneath the garage ceiling. In case of active venting failure the PAR efficiently reduces the flammable gas volume (hydrogen concentration > 4 vol.%) for both stratified and homogeneous distribution. However the simulations indicate that the simultaneous operation of active venting and PAR may in some cases reduce the overall efficiency of hydrogen removal. Consequently a well-matched arrangement of both safety systems is required in order to optimize the overall efficiency. The presented CFD-based approach is an appropriate tool to support the assessment of the efficiency of PAR application for plant design and safety considerations with regard to the use of hydrogen in confined areas.

Commercial use of hydrogen on-board fuel cell vehicles necessitates the compression of hydrogen gas up to 700 bar raising unique safety challenges. Potential hazards to be addressed include jet fires from high-pressure hydrogen on-board storage. Previous studies investigated effects of jet fires that occur when pressure relief devices (PRDs) on hydrogen fuel cell vehicles activate. This investigation examines plane jets’ axis switching and flame length accounting for compressibility effects and turbulent combustion near the point of release. Comparison with experimental data and previous plane jet simulation results reveal that combustion process does not affect flow dynamics in compressible region of jet flow. Furthermore a theoretical design of a variable aperture pressure relief device is examined which would enable the blow-down time to be minimized while reducing deterministic separation distances is examined using Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) techniques. Design recommendations are suggested for a novel PRD design.

A methodology for explosion and fire risk analyses in enclosed rooms is presented. The objectives of this analysis are to accurately predict the risks associated with hydrogen leaks in maritime applications and to use the approach to provide decision support regarding design and risk-prevention and risk mitigating measures. The methodology uses CFD tools and simpler consequence models for ventilation dispersion and explosion scenarios as well as updated frequency for leaks and ignition. Risk is then efficiently calculated with a Monte Carlo routine capturing the transient behavior of the leak. This makes it possible to efficiently obtain effects of sensitivities and design options maintaining safety and reducing costs.

The California Fuel Cell Partnership (CaFCP) is currently working with key stakeholders like the US Department of Energy (DOE) and National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) to develop a national template for educating and training first responders about hydrogen fuel cell-powered vehicles (FCV) and hydrogen fuelling infrastructure. Currently there are several existing programs that either have some related FCV/hydrogen material or have plans to incorporate this in the future. To create a robust national emergency responder (ER) program the strongest elements from these existing programs are considered for incorporation into the template. Working with the key stakeholders the national template will be evaluated on a regular basis to ensure accurate and up to date information and resources and effective teaching techniques for the emergency response community. This paper describes the evaluation process discusses elements of the template and reports on the steps and progress to implementation; all in the effort to effectively support the emergency response community as hydrogen infrastructure develops and FCVs are leased or sold.

Risk assessment of hazardous material transport by road is critical in considering the spatial features of the transport route. However previous studies that focused on hydrogen transport were unable to reflect the spatial features in their risk assessments. Hence this study aims to assess the risk of hydrogen transport by road considering the spatial features of the transport route based on a geographic information system (GIS). This risk assessment method is conducted through a case study in Yokohama which is an advanced city for hydrogen economy in Japan. In our assessment the risk determined by multiplying the frequency of accidents with the consequence was estimated by road segments that constitute the entire transport route. The effects of the road structure and traffic volumes were reflected in the estimation of the frequency and consequence for each road segment. All estimations of frequency consequence and risk were conducted on a GIS compiled with the information regarding the road network and population. In the case study in Yokohama the route for the transport of compressed hydrogen was virtually set from the near-term perspectives. Based on the case study results the risks of the target transport route were assessed at an acceptable level under the previous risk criteria. The results indicated that the risks fluctuated according to the road segments. This implies that the spatial features of the transport route significantly affect the corresponding risks. This finding corroborates the importance of considering spatial features in the risk assessment of hydrogen transport by road. Furthermore the discussion of this importance leads to the capability of introducing hydrogen energy careers with high transport efficiency and transport routing to avoid high risk road segments as risk countermeasures.

This paper describes a CFD study of a scenario involving the vertical downward release of hydrogen from a thermally-activated pressure relief device (TPRD) under a fuel cell car. The volumetric source model is applied to simulate hydrogen release dynamics during the tank blowdown process. Simulations are conducted for both unignited and ignited releases from onboard storage at 35 MPa and 70 MPa with TPRD orifice 4.2 mm. Results show that after TPRD opening the hazards associated with the release of hydrogen lasts less than two minutes and the most hazardous timeframe occurs within ten seconds of the initiation of the release. The deterministic separation distances for unignited releases are longer than those for ignited releases indicating that the separation distances are dominated by delayed ignition events rather than immediate ignition events. The deterministic separation distances for both unignited and ignited hydrogen downward releases under the car are significantly shorter than those of free jets. To ensure the safety of people a deterministic separation distance of at least 10 m for 35 MPa releases is required. This distance should be increased to 12 m for the 70 MPa release case. To ensure that the concentration of hydrogen is always less than 4% at the location of the air intake of buildings the deterministic separation distance should be at least 11 m for 35 MPa releases and 13 m for 70 MPa releases.

The U.S. Department of Energy supports the implementation of hydrogen fuel cell technologies by providing hydrogen safety and emergency response training to first responders. A collaboration was formed to develop and deliver a one-day course that uses a mobile fuel cell vehicle (FCV) burn prop designed and built by Kidde Fire Trainers. This paper describes the development of the training curriculum including the design and operation of the FCV prop; describes the successful delivery of this course to over 300 participants at three training centers in California; and discusses feedback and observations received on the course. Photographs and video clips of the training sessions will be presented.

This paper summarizes the current results of the theoretical and experimental activity carried out by the Italian Working Group on the fire prevention safety issues in the field of the hydrogen transport in pipelines. From the theoretical point of view a draft document has been produced beginning from the regulations in force on the natural gas pipelines; these have been reviewed corrected and integrated with the instructions suitable to the use of hydrogen. From the experimental point of view an apparatus has been designed and installed at the University of Pisa; this apparatus has allowed the simulation of hydrogen releases from a pipeline with and without ignition of hydrogen-air mixture. The experimental data have helped the completion of the above-mentioned draft document with the instructions about the safety distances. The document has been improved for example pipelines above ground (not buried) are allowed due to the knowledge acquired by means of the experimental campaign. The safety distances related to this kind of piping has been chosen on the base of risk analysis. The work on the text contents is concluded and the document is currently under discussion with the Italian stakeholders involved in the hydrogen applications.