United Kingdom

This report provides the Committee on Climate Change’s response to the UK Government’s Clean Growth Strategy.

The report finds that:

• The Government has made a strong commitment to achieving the UK’s climate change targets.

• Policies and proposals set out in the Clean Growth Strategy will need to be firmed up.

• Gaps to meeting the fourth and fifth carbon budgets remain. These gaps must be closed.

• Risks of under-delivery must be addressed and carbon budgets met on time.

This report responds to a request from the Governments of the UK Wales and Scotland asking the Committee to reassess the UK’s long-term emissions targets. Our new emissions scenarios draw on ten new research projects three expert advisory groups and reviews of the work of the IPCC and others.<br/>The conclusions are supported by detailed analysis published in the Net Zero Technical Report that has been carried out for each sector of the economy plus consideration of F-gas emissions and greenhouse gas removals.

This spreadsheet contains data for two future UK scenarios: a "baseline" (i.e. no climate action after 2008 the start of the carbon budget system) and the "central" scenario underpinning the CCC's advice on the fifth carbon budget (the limit to domestic emissions during the period 2028-32).<br/>The central scenario is an assessment of the technologies and behaviours that would prepare for the 2050 target cost-effectively while meeting the other criteria in the Climate Change Act (2008) based on central views of technology costs fuel prices carbon prices and feasibility. It is not prescriptive nor is it the only scenario considered for meeting the carbon budgets. For further details on our scenarios and how they were generated see the CCC report Sectoral scenarios for the Fifth Carbon Budget. The scenario was constructed for the CCC's November 2015 report and has not been further updated for example to reflect outturn data for 2015 or changes to Government policy.

The HyDeploy project is the UK’s first practical project to demonstrate that hydrogen can be safely blended into the natural-gas distribution system without requiring changes to appliances and the associated disruption. The project is funded under Ofgem’s Network Innovation Competition and is a collaboration between Cadent Gas Northern Gas Networks Progressive Energy Ltd Keele University (Keele) Health & Safety Laboratory and ITM Power. Cadent and Northern Gas Networks are the Gas Distribution Network sponsors of the project. Keele University is the host site providing the gas-distribution network which will receive the hydrogen blend. Keele University is the largest campus university in the UK. Health & Safety Laboratory provides the scientific laboratories and experimental expertise. ITM Power provides the electrolyser that produces the hydrogen. Progressive Energy Ltd is the project developer and project manager. HyDeploy is structured into three distinct phases. The first is an extensive technical programme to establish the necessary detailed evidence base in support of an application to the Health & Safety Executive for Exemption to Schedule 3 of the Gas Safety (Management) Regulations (GS(M)R) to permit the injection of hydrogen at 20 mol%. This is required to allow hydrogen to be blended into a natural-gas supply above the current British limit of 0.1 mol%.



The second phase comprises the construction of the electrolyser and grid entry unit along with the necessary piping and valves to allow hydrogen to be mixed and injected into the Keele University gas-distribution network and to ensure all necessary training of operatives is conducted before injection. The third phase is the trial itself which is due to start in the summer of 2019 and last around 10 months. The trial phase also provides an opportunity to undertake further experimental activities related to the operational network to support the pathway to full deployment of blended gas. The outcome of HyDeploy is principally developing the initial evidence base that hydrogen can be blended into a UK operational natural-gas network without disruption to customers and without prejudicing the safety of end users. If deployed at scale hydrogen blending at 20 mol% would unlock 29 TWh pa of decarbonized heat and provide a route map for deeper savings. The equivalent carbon savings of a national roll-out of a 20-mol% hydrogen blend would be to remove 2.5 million cars from the road.



HyDeploy is a seminal UK project for the decarbonization of the gas grid via hydrogen deployment and will provide the first stepping stone for setting technical operational and regulatory precedents of the hydrogen vector.

This report sets out scenarios for the UK power sector in 2030 as an input to the Committee’s advice on the fifth carbon budget.<br/>These scenarios are not intended to set out a prescriptive path. Instead they provide a tool for the Committee to verify that its advice can be achieved with manageable impacts in order to meet the criteria set out in the Climate Change Act including competitiveness affordability and energy security.

The Aberdeen Vision Project could deliver CO2 savings of 1.5MtCO2/y compared with natural gas. A dedicated pipeline from St Fergus to Aberdeen would enable the phased transfer of the Aberdeen regional gas distribution system to 20% then 100% hydrogen.

The study has demonstrated that 2% hydrogen can be injected into the National Transmission System (NTS) at St Fergus and its distribution through the system into the gas distribution network. Due to unique regional attributes the Aberdeen region could lead the UK in the conversion to largescale clean hydrogen. A 200MW hydrogen generation plant is planned to suit 2% blend into the NTS followed by a build out to supply the Aberdeen gas networks and to enable low cost hydrogen transport applications.

This report and any attachment is freely available on the ENA Smarter Networks Portal here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.

The EC funded Naturalhy project is assessing the potential for using the existing gas infrastructure for conveying hydrogen as a mixture with natural gas (methane). The hydrogen could then be removed at a point of use or the natural gas/hydrogen mixture could be burned in gas-fired appliances thereby providing reduced carbon emissions compared to natural gas. As part of the project the impact on the safety of the gas system resulting from the addition of hydrogen is being assessed. A release of a natural gas/hydrogen mixture within a vented enclosure (such as an industrial housing of plant and equipment) could result in a flammable mixture being formed and ignited. Due to the different properties of hydrogen the resulting explosion may be more severe for natural gas/hydrogen mixtures compared to natural gas. Therefore a series of large scale explosion experiments involving methane/hydrogen mixtures has been conducted in a 69.3 m3 enclosure in order to assess the effect of different hydrogen concentrations on the resulting explosion overpressures. The results showed that adding up to 20% by volume of hydrogen to the methane resulted in a small increase in explosion flame speeds and overpressures. However a significant increase was observed when 50% hydrogen was added. For the vented confined explosions studied it was also observed that the addition of obstacles within the enclosure representing congestion caused by equipment and pipework etc. increased flame speeds and overpressures above the levels measured in an empty enclosure. Predictions of the explosion overpressure and flame speed were also made using a modified version of the Shell Global Solutions model SCOPE. The modifications included changes to the burning velocity and other physical properties of methane/hydrogen mixtures. Comparisons with the experimental data showed generally good agreement.

The present work is concerned with numerical simulations of large scale hydrogen detonations. Euler equations have been solved along with a single step reaction for the chemistry. Total variation diminishing (TVD) numerical schemes are used for shock capturing. The equations are solved in parallel in a decomposed domain. Predictions were firstly conducted with a small domain to ensure that the reaction scheme has been properly tuned to capture the correct detonation pressure and velocity. On this basis simulations were set up for the detonation tests carried out at the RUT tunnel facilities in Russia. This is one of the standard benchmark test cases selected for HYSAFE [1]. Comparison is made between the predictions and measurements. Reasonably good agreement has been obtained on pressure decay and the propagation speed of detonation. Further simulations were then conducted for a hypothetical hydrogen-air cloud in the open to assess the impulse as well as overpressure. The effects of cloud height width were investigated in the safety context.

The possibility of using a risk based approach for the safe installation and siting of stationary fuel cell systems depends upon the availability of normative data and guidance on potential hazards and the probabilities of their occurrence. Such guidance data is readily available for most common hydrocarbon fuels. For hydrogen however data is still required on the hazards associated with different release scenarios. This data can then be related to the probability of different types of scenarios from historical fault data to allow safety distances to be defined and controlled using different techniques. Some data on releases has started to appear but this data generally relates to hydrogen vehicle refuelling systems that are designed for larger throughput higher pressures and the general use of larger pipe diameters than are likely to be used for small fuel cell systems.

A benchmarking exercise on quantitative risk assessment (QRA) methodologies has been conducted within the project HyQRA under the framework of the European Network of Excellence (NoE) HySafe. The aim of the exercise was basically twofold: (i) to identify the differences and similarities in approaches in a QRA and their results for a hydrogen installation between nine participating partners representing a broad spectrum of background in QRA culture and history and (ii) to identify knowledge gaps in the various steps and parameters underlying the risk quantification. In the first step a reference case was defined: a virtual hydrogen refuelling station (HRS) in virtual surroundings comprising housing school shops and other vulnerable objects. All partners were requested to conduct a QRA according to their usual approach and experience. Basically participants were free to define representative release cases to apply models and frequency assessments according their own methodology and to present risk according to their usual format. To enable inter-comparison a required set of results data was prescribed like distances to specific thermal radiation levels from fires and distances to specific overpressure levels. Moreover complete documentation of assumptions base data and references was to be reported. It was not surprising that a wide range of results was obtained both in the applied approaches as well as in the quantitative outcomes and conclusions. This made it difficult to identify exactly which assumptions and parameters were responsible for the differences in results as the paper will show. A second phase was defined in which the QRA was determined by a more limited number of release cases (scenarios). The partners in the project agreed to assess specific scenarios in order to identify the differences in consequence assessment approaches. The results of this phase provide a better understanding of the influence of modelling assumptions and limitations on the eventual conclusions with regard to risk to on-site people and to the off-site public. This paper presents the results and conclusions of both stages of the exercise.

A possible consequence of pressurized hydrogen release is an under-expanded jet fire. Knowledge of the flame length radiative heat flux and fraction as well as the effects of variations in ground reflectance is important for safety assessment. The present study applies an open source CFD code FireFOAM to study the radiation characteristics of hydrogen and hydrogen/methane jet fires. For combustion the eddy dissipation concept for multi-component fuels recently developed by the authors in the large eddy simulation (LES) framework is used. The radiative heat is computed with the finite volume discrete ordinates model in conjunction with the weighted-sum-of-gray-gases model for the absorption/emission coefficient. The pseudo-diameter approach is used in which the corresponding parameters are calculated using the correlations of Birch et al. [22]. The predicted flame length and radiant fraction are in good agreement with the measurements of Schefer et al. [2] Studer et al. [3] and Ekoto et al. [6]. In order to account for the effects of variation in ground surface reflectance the emissivity of hydrogen flames was modified following Ekoto et al. [6]. Four cases with different ground reflectance are computed. The predictions show that the ground surface reflectance only has minor effect on the surface emissive power of the hydrogen jet fire. The radiant fractions fluctuate from 0.168 to 0.176 close to the suggested value of 0.16 by Ekoto et al.[6] based on the analysis of their measurements.

On October 16-17 2012 the International Association for Hydrogen Safety (HySafe) in cooperation with the Institute for Energy and Transport of the Joint Research Centre of the European Commission (JRC IET Petten) held a two-day workshop dedicated to Hydrogen Safety Research Priorities. The workshop was hosted by Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing (BAM) in Berlin Germany. The main idea of the Workshop was to bring together stakeholders who can address the existing knowledge gaps in the area of the hydrogen safety including identification and prioritization of such gaps from the standpoint of scientific knowledge both experimental and theoretical including numerical. The experience highlighting these gaps which was obtained during both practical applications (industry) and risk assessment should serve as reference point for further analysis. The program included two sections: knowledge gaps as they are addressed by industry and knowledge gaps and state-of-the-art by research. In the current work the main results of the workshop are summarized and analysed.

A project overview of HyDeploy project led by Cadent Gas and supported by Northern Gas Networks Progressive Energy Ltd Keele University HSE – Science Division and ITM Power.

First Phase:

HyDeploy at Keele is the first stage of this three stage programme. In November 2019 the UK Health & Safety Executive gave permission to run a live test of blended hydrogen and natural gas on part of the private gas network at Keele University campus in Staffordshire. HyDeploy is the first project in the UK to inject hydrogen into a natural gas network.

Second and Third Phases;

Once the Keele stage has been completed HyDeploy will move to a larger demonstration on a public network in the North East. After that HyDeploy will have another large demonstration in the North West.  These are designed to test the blend across a range of networks and customers so that the evidence is representative of the UK as a whole. With HSE approval and success at Keele these phases will go ahead in the early 2020s.

The longer term goal:

Once the evidence has been submitted to Government policy makers we very much expect hydrogen to take its place alongside other forms of zero carbon energy in meeting the needs of the UK population.

HyDeploy is a pioneering hydrogen energy project designed to help reduce UK CO2 emissions and reach the Government’s net zero target for 2050.

As the first ever live demonstration of hydrogen in homes HyDeploy aims to prove that blending up to 20% volume of hydrogen with natural gas is a safe and greener alternative to the gas we use now.  It is  providing evidence on how customers don’t have to change their cooking or heating appliances to take the blend which means less disruption and cost for them.  It is also confirming initial findings that customers don’t notice any difference when using the hydrogen blend.

This work is driven by the need to understand the hazards resulting from the rapid ignited release of hydrogen from onboard storage tanks through a thermally activated pressure relief device (TPRD) inside a garage-like enclosure with low natural ventilation i.e. the consequences of a jet fire which has been immediately ignited. The resultant overpressure is of particular interest. Previous work [1] focused on an unignited release in a garage with minimum ventilation. This initial work demonstrated that high flow rates of unignited hydrogen through a thermally activated pressure relief device (TPRD) in ventilated enclosures with low air change per hour can generate overpressures above the limit of 10- 15 kPa which a typical civil structure like a garage could withstand. This is due to the pressure peaking phenomenon. Both numerical and phenomenological models were developed for an unignited release and this has been recently validated experimentally [2]. However it could be expected that the majority of unexpected releases through a TPRD may be ignited; leading to even greater overpressures and to date whilst there has been some work on fires in enclosures the pressure peaking phenomenon for an ignited release has yet to be studied or compared with that for an equivalent unignited release. A numerical model for ignited releases in enclosures has been developed and computational fluid dynamics has then been used to examine the pressure dynamics of an ignited hydrogen release in a real scale garage. The scenario considered involves a high mass flow rate release from an onboard hydrogen storage tank at 700 bar through a 3.34 mm diameter orifice representing the TPRD in a small garage with a single vent equivalent in area to small window. It is shown that whilst this vent size garage volume and TPRD configuration may be considered “safe” from overpressures in the event of an unignited release the overpressure resulting from an ignited release is two orders of magnitude greater and would destroy the structure. Whilst further investigation is needed the results clearly indicate the presence of a highly dangerous situation which should be accounted for in regulations codes and standards. The hazard relates to the volume of hydrogen released in a given timeframe thus the application of this work extends beyond TPRDs and is relevant where there is a rapid ignited release of hydrogen in an enclosure with limited ventilation.

Hydrogen technologies are expected to play a key role in implementing the transition from a fossil fuel- based to a more sustainable lower-carbon energy system. To facilitate their widespread deployment the safe operation and hydrogen systems needs to be ensured together with the evaluation of the associated risk.<br/>HIAD has been designed to be a collaborative and communicative web-based information platform holding high quality information of accidents and incidents related to hydrogen technologies. The main goal of HIAD was to become not only a standard industrial accident database but also an open communication platform suitable for safety lessons learned and risk communication as well as a potential data source for risk assessment; it has been set up to improve the understanding of hydrogen unintended events to identify measures and strategies to avoid incidents/accidents and to reduce the consequence if an accident occurs.<br/>In order to achieve that goal the data collection is characterized by a significant degree of detail and information about recorded events (e.g. causes physical consequences lesson learned). Data are related not only to real incident and accidents but also to hazardous situations.<br/>The concept of a hydrogen accident database was generated in the frame of the project HySafe an EC co-funded NoE of the 6th Frame Work Programme. HIAD was built by EC-JRC and populated by many HySafe partners. After the end of the project the database has been maintained and populated by JRC with publicly available events. The original idea was to provide a tool also for quantitative risk assessment able to conduct simple analyses of the events; unfortunately that goal could not be reached because of a lack of required statistics: it was not possible to establish a link with potential event providers coming from private sector not willing to share information considered confidential. Starting from June 2016 JRC has been developing a new version of the database (i.e. HIAD 2.0); the structure of the database and the web-interface have been redefined and simplified resulting in a streamlined user interface compared to the previous version of HIAD. The new version is mainly focused to facilitate the sharing of lessons learned and other relevant information related to hydrogen technology; the database will be public and the events will be anonymized. The database will contribute to improve the safety awareness fostering the users to benefit from the experiences of others as well as to share information from their own experiences.

An experimental study of hydrogen/air premixed flame propagation in a closed rectangular channel with the inhibitions (N2 or CO2) was conducted to investigate the inhibiting effect of N2 and CO2 on the flame properties during its propagation. Both Schlieren system and the pressure sensor were used to capture the evolution of flame shape and pressure changes in the channel. It was found that both N2 and CO2 have considerable inhibiting effect on hydrogen/air premixed flames. Compared with N2 CO2 has more prominent inhibition which has been interpreted from thermal and kinetic standpoints. In all the flames the classic tulip shape was observed. With different inhibitor concentration the flame demonstrated three types of deformation after the classic tulip inversion. A simple theoretical analysis has also been conducted to indicate that the pressure wave generated upon the first flame-wall contact can affect the flame deformation depending on its meeting moment with the flame front. Most importantly the meeting moment is always behind the start of tulip inversion which suggests the non-dominant role of pressure wave on this featured phenomenon.

A core theme of the UK Government's new Industrial Strategy is exploiting opportunities for domestic supply chain development. This extends to a special ‘Automotive Sector Deal’ that focuses on the shift to low emissions vehicles (LEVs). Here attention is on electric vehicle and battery production and innovation. In this paper we argue that a more straightforward gain in terms of framing policy around potential economic benefits may be made through supply chain activity to support refuelling of battery/hydrogen vehicles. We set this in the context of LEV refuelling supply chains potentially replicating the strength of domestic upstream linkages observed in the UK electricity and/or gas industries. We use input-output multiplier analysis to deconstruct and assess the structure of these supply chains relative to that of more import-intensive petrol and diesel supply. A crucial multiplier result is that for every £1million of spending on electricity (or gas) 8 full-time equivalent jobs are supported throughout the UK. This compares to less than 3 in the case of petrol/diesel supply. Moreover the importance of service industries becomes apparent with 67% of indirect and induced supply chain employment to support electricity generation being located in services industries. The comparable figure for GDP is 42%.

<br/>Cyclic Voltammetry Measurements performed on a Cobaloxime Catalyst designed for photochemical hydrogen production.

Hydrogen vehicles may emerge as a leading contender to replace today’s internal combustion engine powered vehicles. A Phenomena Identification and Ranking Table exercise conducted as part of the European Network of Excellence on Hydrogen Safety (HySafe) identified the use of hydrogen vehicles in road tunnels as a topic of important concern. An internal project called HyTunnel was duly established within HySafe to review identify and analyse the issues involved and to contribute to the wider activity to establish the true nature of the hazards posed by hydrogen vehicles in the confined space of a tunnel and their relative severity compared to those posed by vehicles powered by conventional fuels including compressed natural gas (CNG). In addition to reviewing current hydrogen vehicle designs tunnel design practice and previous research a programme of experiments and CFD modelling activities was performed for selected scenarios to examine the dispersion and explosion hazards potentially posed by hydrogen vehicles. Releases from compressed gaseous hydrogen (CGH2) and liquid hydrogen (LH2) powered vehicles have been studied under various tunnel geometries and ventilation regimes. The findings drawn from the limited work done so far indicate that under normal circumstances hydrogen powered vehicles do not pose a significantly higher risk than those powered by petrol diesel or CNG but this needs to be confirmed by further research. In particular obstructions at tunnel ceiling level have been identified as a potential hazard in respect to fast deflagration or even detonation in some circumstances which warrants further investigation. The shape of the tunnel tunnel ventilation and vehicle pressure relief device (PRD) operation are potentially important parameters in determining explosion risks and the appropriate mitigation measures.

This paper reports experimental results from a series of experiments in which gaseous hydrogen was released into a 31 m3 enclosure and the hydrogen concentrations at a number of points within the enclosure were monitored to assess whether hydrogen accumulation occurred and whether a homogeneous or stratified mixture was formed. The enclosure was located in the open air and therefore subject to realistic and therefore variable wind conditions. The hydrogen release rate and the passive vent arrangements were varied. The experiments were carried out as part of the EU Hyindoor Project.

The objectives of the IDEALHY project which receives funding from the European Union’s 7th Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013) for the Fuel Cells and Hydrogen Joint Technology Initiative under grant agreement No. 278177 are to design a novel process that will significantly increase the efficiency of hydrogen liquefaction and be capable of delivering liquid hydrogen at a rate that is an order of magnitude greater than current plants. The liquid hydrogen could then be delivered to refueling stations in road tankers. As part of the project the safety management of the new large scale process and the transportation of liquid hydrogen by road tanker into urban areas are being considered. Effective safety management requires that the hazards are identified and well understood. This paper describes the scope of the safety work within IDEALHY and presents the output of the work completed so far. Initially a review of available experimental data on the hazards posed by releases of liquid hydrogen was undertaken which identified that generally there is a dearth of data relevant to liquid hydrogen releases. Subsequently HAZIDs have been completed for the new liquefaction process storage of liquid hydrogen and its transportation by road. This included a review of incidents relevant to these activities. The principal causes of the incidents have been analysed. Finally the remaining safety work for the IDEALHY project is outlined.

Shipping is a very important source of pollution worldwide. In recent years numerous actions and measures have been developed trying to reduce the levels of greenhouse gases (GHG) from the marine exhaust emissions in the fight against climate change boosting the Sustainable Development Goal 13. Following this target the action of hydrogen as energy vector makes it a suitable alternative to be used as fuel constituting a very promising energy carrier for energy transition and decarbonization in maritime transport. The objective of this study is to develop an ex-ante environmental evaluation of two promising technologies for vessels propulsion a H2 Polymeric Electrolytic Membrane Fuel Cell (PEMFC) and a H2 Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) in order to determine their viability and eligibility compared to the traditional one a diesel ICE. The applied methodology follows the Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) guidelines considering a functional unit of 1 kWh of energy produced. LCA results reveal that both alternatives have great potential to promote the energy transition particularly the H2 ICE. However as technologies readiness level is quite low it was concluded that the assessment has been conducted at a very early stage so their sustainability and environmental performance may change as they become more widely developed and deployed which can be only achieved with political and stakeholder’s involvement and collaboration.

This paper aims to improve prediction capability of the vent sizing correlation presented in the form of functional dependence of the dimensionless deflagration overpressure on the turbulent Bradley number similar to our previous studies. The correlation is essentially upgraded based on recent advancements in understanding and modelling of combustion phenomena relevant to hydrogen-air vented deflagrations and unique large-scale tests carried out by different research groups. The focus is on hydrogen-air deflagrations in low-strength equipment and buildings when the reduced pressure is accepted to be  below 0.1 MPa. The combustion phenomena accounted for by the correlation include: turbulence generated by the flame front itself; leading point mechanism stemming from the preferential diffusion of hydrogen in air in stretched flames; growth of the fractal area of the turbulent flame surface; initial turbulence in the flammable mixture; as well as effects of enclosure aspect ratio and presence of obstacles. The correlation is validated against the widest range of experimental conditions available to date (76 experimental points). The validation covers a wide range of test conditions: different shape enclosures of volume up to 120 m3; initially quiescent and turbulent hydrogen-air mixtures; hydrogen concentration in air from 6% to 30% by volume; ignition source location at enclosure centre near and far from a vent; empty enclosures and enclosures with obstacles.

Emerging hydrogen energy technologies are creating new avenues for bring hydrogen fuel usage into larger public domain. Identification of possible accidental scenarios and measures to mitigate associated hazards should be well understood for establishing best practice guidelines. Accidentally released hydrogen forms flammable mixtures in a very short time. Ignition of such a mixture in congestion and confinements can lead to greater magnitudes of overpressure catastrophic for both structure and people around. Hence understanding of the permissible level of confinements and congestion around the hydrogen fuel handling and storage unit is essential for process safety. In the present study numerical simulations have been performed for the hydrogen-air turbulent deflagration in a well-defined congestion of repeated pipe rig experimentally studied by [1]. Large Eddy Simulations (LES) have been performed using the in-house modified version of the OpenFOAM code. The Flame Surface Wrinkling Model in the LES context is used for modelling deflagrations. Numerical predictions concerning the effects of hydrogen concentration and congestion on turbulent deflagration overpressure are compared with the measurements [1] to provide validation of the code. Further insight about the flame propagation and trends of the generated overpressures over the range of concentrations are discussed.