Safety
A Turbulent Combustion Model for Ignition of Rapidly Expanding Hydrogen Jets
Mar 2013
Publication
A turbulent combustion model based on the Linear Eddy Model for Large Eddy Simulation (LEM- LES) is currently proposed to study self-ignition events of rapidly expanding hydrogen jets. The model is a one-dimensional treatment of a diffusion-reaction system within each multi-dimensional LES cell. This reduces the expense of solving a complete multi-dimensional problem while preserving micro-scale hotspots and their effects on ignition. The current approach features a Lagrangian description of fluid particles on the sub-grid for increased accuracy. Also Adaptive Mesh Refinement (AMR) is implemented for increased computational efficiency. In this paper the model is validated for various inviscid laminar 1-D mixing and ignition problems shock tube problems flames and detonations.
Experimental and Numerical Study on Spontaneous Ignition of Hydrogen-methane Jets in Air
Sep 2013
Publication
This paper is an investigation of the spontaneous ignition process of high-pressure hydrogen and hydrogen-methane mixtures injected into air. The experiments were conducted in a closed channel filled with air where the hydrogen or hydrogen–methane mixture depressurised through different tubes (diameters d = 6 10 and 14 mm and lengths L = 10 25 40 50 75 and 100 mm). The methane addition to the mixture was 5% and 10% vol. The results showed that only 5% methane addition may increase even 2.67 times the pressure at which the mixture may ignite in comparison to the pressure of the pure hydrogen flow. The 10% of methane addition did not provide an ignition for burst pressures up to 15.0 MPa in the geometrical configuration with the longest tube (100 mm). Additionally the simulations of the experimental configuration with pure hydrogen were performed with the use of KIVA numerical code with full kinetic reaction mechanism.
Experimental Investigation of Nozzle Aspect Ratio Effects on Under Expanded Hydrogen Jet Release Characteristics
Sep 2013
Publication
Most experimental investigations of underexpanded hydrogen jets have been limited to circular nozzles in an attempt to better understand the fundamental jet-exit flow physics and model this behaviour with pseudo source models. However realistic compressed storage leak exit geometries are not always expected to be circular. In the present study jet dispersion characteristics from rectangular slot nozzles with aspect ratios from 2 to 8 were investigated and compared with an equivalent circular nozzle. Schlieren imaging was used to observe the jet-exit shock structure while quantitative Planar Laser Rayleigh Scattering was used to measure downstream dispersion characteristics. These results provide physical insight and much needed model validation data for model development.
Pressure Cycling Of Type 1 Pressure Vessels with Gaseous Hydrogen
Sep 2011
Publication
Type 1 steel pressure vessels are commonly used for the transport of pressurized gases including gaseous hydrogen. In the majority of cases these cylinders experience relatively few pressure cycles over their lifetime perhaps in the hundreds. In emerging markets such as hydrogen-powered industrial trucks hydrogen fuel systems are expected to experience thousands of cycles over just a few year period. This study investigates the fatigue life of Type 1 steel pressure vessels by subjecting full- scale vessels to pressure cycles with gaseous hydrogen between nominal pressure of 3.5 and 43.8 MPa. In addition engineered defects were machined on the inside of several pressure vessels for comparison to fatigue crack growth measurements on materials sectioned from these pressure vessels. As-manufactured pressure vessels have sustained >35000 cycles with failure while vessels with machined defects leaked before bursting after 8000 to 15000 pressure cycles. The measured number of cycles to failure in these pressure vessels is two to three times greater than predicted using conservative methods based on fatigue crack growth rates measured in gaseous hydrogen.
Risk Assessment on Life Safety and Financial Loss for Road Accident of Fuel Cell Vehicles
Sep 2017
Publication
Vehicular use of hydrogen is the first attempt to apply hydrogen energy in consumers’ environment in large scale and has raised safety concerns in both public authorities and private bodies such as fire services and insurance companies. This paper analyzes typical accident progressions of hydrogen fuel cell vehicles in a road collision accident. Major hydrogen consequences including impinging jet fires and catastrophic tank ruptures are evaluated separately in terms of accident duration and hazard distances. Results show that in a 70 MPa fuel cell car accident the hazards associated with hydrogen releases would normally last for no more than 1.5 min due to the empty of the tank. For the safety of general public a perimeter of 100 m is suggested in the accident scene if no hissing sound is heard. However the perimeter can be reduced to 10 m once the hissing sound of hydrogen release is heard. Furthermore risks of fatalities injuries and damages are all quantified in financial terms to assess the impacts of the accident. Results show that costs of fatalities and injuries contribute most to the overall financial loss indicating that the insurance premium of fatalities and injuries should be set higher than that of property loss.
Hydrogen Safety Sensor Performance and Use Gap Analysis
Sep 2017
Publication
Hydrogen sensors are recognized as an important technology for facilitating the safe implementation of hydrogen as an alternative fuel and there are numerous reports of a sensor alarm successfully preventing a potentially serious event. However gaps in sensor metrological specifications as well as in their performance for some applications exist. The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Fuel Cell Technologies Office published a short list of critical gaps in the 2007 and 2012 Multiyear Project Plans; more detailed gap analyses were independently performed by the Joint Research Centre (JRC) and the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL). There have been however some significant advances in sensor technologies since these assessments including the commercial availability of hydrogen sensors with fast response times (t90 < 1 s which had been an elusive DOE target since 2007) improved robustness to chemical poisons improved selectivity and improved lifetime and stability. These improvements however have not been universal and typically pertain to select platforms or models. Moreover as hydrogen markets grow and new applications are being explored more demands will be imposed on sensor performance. The hydrogen sensor laboratories at NREL and the JRC are currently updating the hydrogen safety sensor gap analysis through direct interaction with international stakeholders in the hydrogen community especially end users. NREL and the JRC are currently organizing a series of workshops (in Europe and the United States) with sensor developers end-users and other stakeholders in 2017 to identify technology gaps and to develop a path forward to address them. One workshop was held on May 10 in Brussels Belgium at the Headquarters of the Fuel Cell and Hydrogen Joint Undertaking. A second workshop is planned at NREL in Golden CO USA. This paper reviews improvements in sensor technologies in the past 5 to 10 years identifies gaps in sensor performance and use requirements and identifies potential research strategies to address the gaps. The outcomes of the Hydrogen Sensors Workshops are also summarized.
Numerical Investigation of Hydrogen Leakage from a High Pressure Tank and its Explosion
Oct 2015
Publication
We numerically investigated the initial behaviour of leakage and diffusion from high-pressure hydrogen storage tank assumed in hydrogen station. First calculations are carried out to validate the present numerical approach and compare with the theoretical distribution of hydrogen mass fraction to the direction which is vertical to the jet direction in the case of hydrogen leaking out from the circular injection port whose diameter is 0.25 mm. Then performing calculations about hydrogen leakage and diffusion behaviour on different tank pressures the effects are examined to reduce damage by gas explosion assumed in the hydrogen station. There is no significant difference in the diffusion distance to the jet direction from a start to 0.2 ms. After 0.2 ms it is seen the difference in the diffusion distance to the jet direction in different pressure. As tank pressures become large the hydrogen diffusion not only to the jet direction but also to the direction which is vertical to the jet direction is remarkably seen. Then according to histories of the percentage of the flammable mass to total one in the space it drastically increases up to 30%2between 0 and 0.05 ms. After 0.05 ms it uniformly increases so it is shown that the explosion risk becomes high over time. The place where mass within flammability range distributes at a certain time is shown. Hydrogen widely diffuses to jet direction and distributes in each case and time. Therefore it is found that when it is assumed that ignition occurs by some sources in place where high-pressure hydrogen is leaked and diffused the magnitude of the explosion damage can be predicted when and where ignition occurs.
Effects of the Injector Direction on the Temperature Distribution During Filling of Hydrogen Tanks
Sep 2017
Publication
The development of the temperature field in hydrogen tanks during the filling process has been investigated with Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). Measurements from experiments undertaken at the JRC GasTef facility have been used to develop and validate the CFD modelling strategy; by means of the CFD calculations the effect of the injector direction on the temperature distribution has been analysed. It has been found that the dynamics of the temperature field including the development of potentially detrimental phenomena like thermal stratification and temperature inhomogeneity e.g. hot spots can be significantly affected by the injector orientation.
Hydrogen Emergency Response Training for First Responders
Sep 2011
Publication
The U.S. Department of Energy supports the implementation of hydrogen fuel cell technologies by providing hydrogen safety and emergency response training to first responders. A collaboration was formed to develop and deliver a one-day course that uses a mobile fuel cell vehicle (FCV) burn prop designed and built by Kidde Fire Trainers. This paper describes the development of the training curriculum including the design and operation of the FCV prop; describes the successful delivery of this course to over 300 participants at three training centers in California; and discusses feedback and observations received on the course. Photographs and video clips of the training sessions will be presented.
Determination of Distribution Function Used in Monte Carlo Simulation on Safety Analysis of Hydrogen Vessels
Sep 2019
Publication
The test data of static burst strength and load cycle strength of composite pressure vessels are often described by GAUSSian normal or WEIBULL distribution function to perform safety analyses. The goodness of assumed distribution function plays a significant role in the inferential statistics to predict the population properties by using limited test data. Often GAUSSian and WEIBULL probability nets are empirical methods used to validate the distribution function; Anderson-Darling and Kolmogorov-Smirnov tests are the mostly favorable approaches for Goodness of Fit. However the different approaches used to determine the parameters of distribution function lead mostly to different conclusions for safety assessments.<br/>In this study six different methods are investigated to show the variations on the rates for accepting the composite pressure vessels according to GTR No. 13 life test procedure. The six methods are: a) Norm- Log based method b) Least squares regression c) Weighted least squares regression d) A linear approach based on good linear unbiased estimators e) Maximum likelihood estimation and f) The method of moments estimation. In addition various approaches of ranking function are considered. In the study Monte Carlo simulations are conducted to generate basic populations based on the distribution functions which are determined using different methods. Then the samples are extracted randomly from a population and evaluated to obtain acceptance rate. Here the “populations” and “samples” are corresponding to the burst strength or load cycle strength of the pressure vessels made from composite material and a plastic liner (type 4) for the storage of hydrogen. To the end the results are discussed and the best reliable methods are proposed.
Prediction of Pressure Reduction Rate in 30 m3 Liquid Hydrogen Tank Based on Experimental and Numerical Analysis
Sep 2019
Publication
Liquid hydrogen (LH2) compared to compressed gaseous hydrogen offers advantages for large scale transport and storage of hydrogen with higher densities and potentially better safety performance. Although the gas industry has good experience with LH2 only little experience is available for the new applications of LH2 as an energy carrier. Therefore the European FCH JU funded project PRESLHY conducts pre-normative research for the safe use of cryogenic LH2 in non-industrial settings. The work program consists of a preparatory phase where the state of the art before the project has been summarized and where the experimental planning was adjusted to the outcome of a research priorities workshop. The central part of the project consists of 3 phenomena oriented work packages addressing Release Ignition and Combustion with analytical approaches experiments and simulations. The results shall improve the general understanding of the behaviour of LH2 in accidents and thereby enhance the state-of-the-art what will be reflected in appropriate recommendations for development or revision of specific international standards. The paper presents the status of the project at the middle of its terms.
Influence of Doping Element in Distributed Hydrogen Optical Fiber Densors with Brillouin Scattering
Sep 2013
Publication
Distributed hydrogen optical fiber sensor with Brillouin scattering is an innovative solution to measure hydrogen in harsh environment as nuclear industry. Glass composition is the key point to enhance the sensing parameter of the fiber in the target application. Several optical fiber with different doping element were used for measuring hydrogen saturation. Permeability of optical plays a major role to the kinetic of hydrogen diffusion. Fluorine doped fiber increase the sorption and the desorption of hydrogen.
Lessons Learned from Safety Events
Sep 2011
Publication
The Hydrogen Incident Reporting and Lessons Learned website (www.h2incidents.org) was launched in 2006 as a database-driven resource for sharing lessons learned from hydrogen-related safety events to raise safety awareness and encourage knowledge-sharing. The development of this database its first uses and subsequent enhancements have been described at the Second and Third International Conferences on Hydrogen Safety [1] [2]. Since 2009 continuing work has not only highlighted the value of safety lessons learned but enhanced how the database provides access to another safety knowledge tool Hydrogen Safety Best Practices (http://h2bestpractices.org). Collaborations with the International Energy Agency (IEA) Hydrogen Implementing Agreement (HIA) Task 19 – Hydrogen Safety and others have enabled the database to capture safety event learning’s from around the world. This paper updates recent progress highlights the new “Lessons Learned Corner” as one means for knowledge-sharing and examines the broader potential for collecting analyzing and using safety event information.
Hydrogen Monitoring Requirements in the Global Technical Regulation on Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Vehicles
Oct 2015
Publication
The United Nations Economic Commission for Europe Global Technical Regulation (GTR) Number 13 (Global Technical Regulation on Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Vehicles) is the defining document regulating safety requirements in hydrogen vehicles and in particular fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEVs). GTR Number 13 has been formally adopted and will serve as the basis for the national regulatory standards for FCEV safety in North America (led by the United States) Japan Korea and the European Union. The GTR defines safety requirements for these vehicles including specifications on the allowable hydrogen levels in vehicle enclosures during in-use and post-crash conditions and on the allowable hydrogen emissions levels in vehicle exhaust during certain modes of normal operation. However in order to be incorporated into national regulations that is to be legally binding methods to verify compliance with the specific requirements must exist. In a collaborative program the Sensor Laboratories at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory in the United States and the Joint Research Centre Institute for Energy and Transport in the Netherlands have been evaluating and developing analytical methods that can be used to verify compliance with the hydrogen release requirements as specified in the GTR.
Threshold Stress Intensity Factor for Hydrogen Assisted Cracking of Cr-Mo Steel Used as Stationary Storage Buffer of a Hydrogen Refueling Station
Oct 2015
Publication
In order to determine appropriate value for threshold stress intensity factor for hydrogen-assisted cracking (KIH) constant-displacement and rising-load tests were conducted in high-pressure hydrogen gas for JIS-SCM435 low alloy steel (Cr-Mo steel) used as stationary storage buffer of a hydrogen refuelling station with 0.2% proof strength and ultimate tensile strength equal to 772 MPa and 948 MPa respectively. Thresholds for crack arrest under constant displacement and for crack initiation under rising load were identified. The crack arrest threshold under constant displacement was 44.3 MPa m1/2 to 44.5 MPa m1/2 when small-scale yielding and plane-strain criteria were satisfied and the crack initiation threshold under rising load was 33.1 MPa m1/2 to 41.1 MPa m1/2 in 115 MPa hydrogen gas. The crack arrest threshold was roughly equivalent to the crack initiation threshold although the crack initiation threshold showed slightly more conservative values. It was considered that both test methods could be suitable to determine appropriate value for KIH for this material.
Uncertainties in Risk Assessment of Hydrogen Discharges from Pressurized Storage Vessels Ranging from Cryogenic to Ambient Temperatures
Sep 2013
Publication
Evaluations of the uncertainties resulting from risk assessment tools to predict releases from the various hydrogen storage types are important to support risk informed safety management. The tools have to predict releases from a wide range of storage pressures (up to 80 MPa) and temperatures (at 20K) e.g. the cryogenic compressed gas storage covers pressures up to 35 MPa and temperatures between 33K and 338 K. Accurate calculations of high pressure releases require real gas EOS. This paper compares a number of EOS to predict hydrogen properties typical in different storage types. The vessel dynamics are modelled to evaluate the performance of various EOS to predict exit pressures and temperatures. The results are compared to experimental data and results from CFD calculations.
Strong and Mild Ignition Mechanism behind Reflected Shock Waves in Hydrogen Mixture
Sep 2013
Publication
A reflected shock wave in two-dimensional shock tube is studied numerically using Navier-Stokes equations with the detailed oxy-hydrogen reaction mechanism. The results show detailed process of mild ignition. The interaction between the reflected shock wave and the boundary layer yielded behind the incident shock wave produces clockwise and counter-clockwise vortices. These vortices generate compression waves. The future study related wall conditions (adiabatic or isothermal) will be shown at the conference site.
Socio-economic Analysis and Quantitative Risk Assessment Methodology for Safety Design of Onboard Storage Systems
Sep 2017
Publication
Catastrophic rupture of onboard hydrogen storage in a fire is a safety concern. Different passive e.g. fireproofing materials the thermally activated pressure relief device (TPRD) and active e.g. initiation of TPRD by fire sensors safety systems are being developed to reduce hazards from and associated risks of high-pressure hydrogen storage tank rupture in a fire. The probability of such low-frequency highconsequences event is a function of fire resistance rating (FRR) i.e. the time before tank without TPRD ruptures in a fire the probability of TPRD failure etc. This safety issue is “confirmed” by observed recently cases of CNG tanks rupture due to blocked or failed to operate TPRD etc. The increase of FRR by any means decreases the probability of tank rupture in a fire particularly because of fire extinction by first responders on arrival at an accident scene.<br/>This study of socio-economic effects of safety applies a quantitative risk assessment (QRA) methodology to an example of hydrogen vehicles with passive tank protection system on roads in London.<br/>The risk is defined here through the cost of human loss per fuel cell hydrogen vehicle (FCHV) fire accident and fatality rate per FCHV per year. The first step in the methodology is the consequence analysis based on validated deterministic engineering tools to estimate the main identified hazards: overpressure in the blast wave at different distances and the thermal hazards from a fireball in the case of catastrophic tank rupture in a fire. The population can be exposed to slight injury serious injury and fatality after an accident. These effects are determined based on criteria by Health and Safety Executive (UK) and a cost metrics is applied to the number of exposed people in these three harm categories to estimate the cost per an accident. The second step in the methodology is either the frequency or the probability analysis. Probabilities of a vehicle fire and failure of the thermally activated pressure relief device are taken from published sources. A vulnerability probit function is employed to calculate the probability of emergency operations’ failure to prevent tank rupture as a function of a storage tank FRR and time of fire brigade arrival. These later results are integrated to estimate the tank rupture frequency and fatality rate. The risk is presented as a function of fire resistance rating.<br/>The QRA methodology allows to calculate the cost of human loss associated with an FCHV fire accident and demonstrates how the increase of FRR of onboard storage as a safety engineering measure would improve socio-economics of FCHV deployment and public acceptance of the technology.
Development of a Generalized Integral Jet Model
Sep 2017
Publication
Integral type models to describe stationary plumes and jets in cross-flows (wind) have been developed since about 1970. These models are widely used for risk analysis to describe the consequences of many different scenarios. Alternatively CFD codes are being applied but computational requirements still limit the number of scenarios that can be dealt with using CFD only. The integral models however are not suited to handle transient releases such as releases from pressurized equipment where the initially high release rate decreases rapidly with time. Further on gas ignition a second model is needed to describe the rapid combustion of the flammable part of the plume (flash fire) and a third model has to be applied for the remaining jet fire. The objective of this paper is to describe the first steps of the development of an integral-type model describing the transient development and decay of a jet of flammable gas after a release from a pressure container. The intention is to transfer the stationary models to a fully transient model capable to predict the maximum extension of short-duration high pressure jets. The model development is supported by conducting a set of transient ignited and unignited spontaneous releases at initial pressures between 25bar and 400bar. These data forms the basis for the presented model development approach.
Helium Release in A Closed Enclosure- Comparisons Between Simple Models, CFD Calculations And Experimental Results
Sep 2011
Publication
In the prospect of a safe use of hydrogen in our society one important task is to evaluate under which conditions the storage of hydrogen systems can reach a sufficient level of safety. One of the most important issues is the use of such system in closed area for example a private garage or an industrial facility. In the scope of this paper we are mainly interested in the following scenario: a relatively slow release of hydrogen (around 5Nl/min) in a closed and almost cubic box representing either a fuel cell at normal scale or a private garage at a smaller scale. For practical reasons helium was used instead of hydrogen in the experiments on which are based our comparisons. This kind of situation leads to the fundamental problem of the dispersion of hydrogen due to a simple vertical source in an enclosure. Many numerical and experimental studies have already been conducted on this problem showing the formation of either a stably stratified distribution of concentration or the formation of a homogeneous layer due to high enough convective flows at the top of the enclosure. Nevertheless most of them consider the cases of accidental situation in which the flow rate is relatively important (higher than 10Nl/min). Numerical simulations carried out with the CEA code Cast3M and a LES turbulence model confirm the differences of results already observed in experimental helium concentration measurements for a same injection flow rate and two different injection nozzle diameters contradicting simple physical models used in safety calculations.
No more items...