Safety
H21- Phase 1 Technical Summary Report
May 2021
Publication
The UK Government signed legislation on 27th June 2019 committing the UK to a legally binding target of Net Zero emissions by 2050. Climate change is one of the most significant technical economic social and business challenges facing the world today.
The H21 NIC Phase 1 project delivered an optimally designed experimentation and testing programme supported by the HSE Science Division and DNV GL with the aim to collect quantifiable evidence to support that the UK distribution network of 2032 will be comparably as safe operating on 100% hydrogen as it currently is on
natural gas. This innovative project begins to fill critical safety evidence gaps surrounding the conversion of the UK gas network to 100% hydrogen. This will facilitate progression towards H21 Phase 2 Operational Safety Demonstrations and the H21 Phase 3 Live Trials to promote customer acceptability and ultimately aid progress towards a government policy decision on heat.
DNV GL and HSE Science Division were engaged to undertake the experimentation testing and QRA update programme of work. DNV GL and HSE Science Division also peer reviewed each other’s programme of work at various stages throughout the project undertaking a challenge and review of the experimental data and results to provide confidence in the conclusions.
A strategic set of tests was designed to cover the range of assets represented across the Great Britain gas distribution networks. The assets used in the testing were mostly recovered from the distribution network as part of the ongoing Iron Mains Risk Reduction Replacement Programme. Controlled testing against a well-defined master testing plan with both natural gas and 100% hydrogen was then undertaken to provide the quantitative evidence to forecast any change to background leakage levels in a 100% hydrogen network.
Key Findings from Phase 1a:
The H21 NIC Phase 1 project delivered an optimally designed experimentation and testing programme supported by the HSE Science Division and DNV GL with the aim to collect quantifiable evidence to support that the UK distribution network of 2032 will be comparably as safe operating on 100% hydrogen as it currently is on
natural gas. This innovative project begins to fill critical safety evidence gaps surrounding the conversion of the UK gas network to 100% hydrogen. This will facilitate progression towards H21 Phase 2 Operational Safety Demonstrations and the H21 Phase 3 Live Trials to promote customer acceptability and ultimately aid progress towards a government policy decision on heat.
DNV GL and HSE Science Division were engaged to undertake the experimentation testing and QRA update programme of work. DNV GL and HSE Science Division also peer reviewed each other’s programme of work at various stages throughout the project undertaking a challenge and review of the experimental data and results to provide confidence in the conclusions.
A strategic set of tests was designed to cover the range of assets represented across the Great Britain gas distribution networks. The assets used in the testing were mostly recovered from the distribution network as part of the ongoing Iron Mains Risk Reduction Replacement Programme. Controlled testing against a well-defined master testing plan with both natural gas and 100% hydrogen was then undertaken to provide the quantitative evidence to forecast any change to background leakage levels in a 100% hydrogen network.
Key Findings from Phase 1a:
- Of the 215 assets tested 41 of them were found to leak 19 of them provided sufficient data to be able to compare hydrogen and methane leak rates.
- The tests showed that assets that were gas tight on methane were also gas tight on hydrogen. Assets that leaked on hydrogen also leaked
- on methane including repaired assets.
- The ratio of the hydrogen to methane volumetric leak rates varied between 1.1 and 2.2 which is largely consistent with the bounding values expected for laminar and turbulent (or inertial) flow which gave ratios of 1.2 and 2.8 respectively.
- None of the PE assets leaked; cast ductile and spun iron leaked to a similar degree (around 26-29% of all iron assets leaked) and the proportion of leaking steel assets was slightly less (14%).
- Four types of joint were responsible for most of the leaks on joints: screwed lead yarn bolted gland and hook bolts.
- All of the repairs that sealed methane leaks also were effective when tested with hydrogen.
Investigation of Turbulent Premixed Methane/Air and Hydrogen-enriched Methane/Air Flames in a Laboratory-scale Gas Turbine Model Combustor
Feb 2021
Publication
Methane and hydrogen-enriched (25 vol% and 50 vol% H2 -enriched CH4) methane/air premixed flames were investigated in a gas turbine model combustor under atmospheric conditions. The flame operability ranges were mapped at different Reynold numbers (Re) showing the dependence on Re and H2 concentrations. The effects of equivalence ratio (Φ) Re and H2 enrichment on flame structure were examined employing OH-PLIF measurement. For CH4/air cases the flame was stabilized with an M shape; while for H2 -enriched cases the flame transitions to a П shape above a specific Φ. This transition was observed to influence significantly the flashback limits. The flame shape transition is most likely a result of H2 enrichment occurring due to the increase in flame speed higher resistance of the flame to the strain rate and change in the inner recirculation zone. Flow fields of CH4/air flames were compared between low and high Re cases employing high-speed PIV. The flashback events led by two mechanisms (combustion-induced vortex breakdown CIVB and boundary-layer flashback BLF) were observed and recorded using high-speed OH chemiluminescence imaging. It was found that the CIVB flashback occurred only for CH4 flames with M shape whereas the BLF occurs for all H2 -enriched flames with П shape.
Evaluation of Safety Measures of a Hydrogen Fueling Station Using Physical Modeling
Oct 2018
Publication
Hydrogen fueling stations are essential for operating fuel cell vehicles. If multiple safety measures in a hydrogen fueling station fail simultaneously it could lead to severe consequences. To analyze the risk of such a situation we developed a physical model of a hydrogen fueling station which when using the temperature pressure and flow rate of hydrogen could be simulated under normal and abnormal operating states. The physical model was validated by comparing the analytical results with the experimental results of an actual hydrogen fueling station. By combining the physical model with a statistical method we evaluated the significance of the safety measures in the event wherein multiple safety measures fail simultaneously. We determined the combinations of failures of safety measures that could lead to accidents and suggested a measure for preventing and mitigating the accident scenario.
Loss of Integrity of Hydrogen Technologies: A Critical Review
Jul 2020
Publication
Hydrogen is one of the main candidates in replacing fossil fuels in the forthcoming years. However hydrogen technologies must deal with safety aspects due to the specific substance properties. This study aims to provide an overview on the loss of integrity (LOI) of hydrogen equipment which may lead to serious consequences such as fires and explosions. Substantial information regarding the hydrogen lifecycle its properties and safety related aspects has gathered. Furthermore focus has placed on the phenomena responsible for the LOI (e.g. hydrogen embrittlement) and material selection for hydrogen services. Moreover a systematic review on the hydrogen LOI topic has conducted to identify and connect the most relevant and active research group within the topic. In conclusion a significant dearth of knowledge in material behaviour of hydrogen technologies has highlighted. It is thought that is possible to bridge this gap by strengthening the collaborations between scientists from different research fields.
Homogeneous Hydrogen Deflagrations in Small Scale Enclosure. Experimental Results
Sep 2017
Publication
University of Pisa performed experimental tests in a 1m3 facility which shape and dimensions resemble a gas cabinet for the HySEA project founded by the Fuel Cells and Hydrogen 2 Joint Undertaking with the aim to conduct pre-normative research on vented deflagrations in real-life enclosures and containers used for hydrogen energy applications in order to generate experimental data of high quality. The test facility named Small Scale Enclosure (SSE) had a vent area of 042m2 which location could be varied namely on the top or in front of the facility while different types of vent were investigated. Three different ignition location were investigated as well and the range of Hydrogen concentration ranged between 10 and 18% vol. This paper is aimed to summarize the main characteristics of the experimental campaign as well as to present its results.
Residual Performance of Composite Pressure Vessels Submitted to Mechanical Impacts
Sep 2017
Publication
Type IV pressure vessels are commonly used for hydrogen on-board stationary or bulk storages. During their lifetime they can be submitted to mechanical impacts creating damage within the composite structure not necessarily correlated to what is visible from the outside. When an impact is suspected or when a cylinder is periodically inspected it is necessary to determine whether it can safely stay in service or not. The FCH JU project Hypactor aims at creating a large database of impacts characterized by various non destructive testing (NDT) methods in order to provide reliable pass-fail criteria for damaged cylinders. This paper presents some of the tests results investigating short term burst) and long term (cycling) performance of impacted cylinders and the recommendations that can be made for impact testing and NDT criteria calibration.
Validation of a 3d Multiphase-multicomponent CFD Model for Accidental Liquid and Gaseous Hydrogen Releases
Sep 2017
Publication
As hydrogen-air mixtures are flammable in a wide range of concentrations and the minimum ignition energy is low compared to hydrocarbon fuels the safe handling of hydrogen is of utmost importance. Additional hazards may arise with the accidental spill of liquid hydrogen. Such a release of LH2 leads to a formation of a cryogenic pool a dynamic vaporization process and consequently a dispersion of gaseous hydrogen into the environment. Several LH2 release experiments as well as modelling approaches address this phenomenology. In contrast to existing approaches a new CFD model capable of simulating liquid and gaseous distribution was developed at Forschungszentrum Jülich. It is validated against existing experiments and yields no substantial lacks in the physical model and reveals a qualitatively consistent prediction. Nevertheless the deviation between experiment and simulation raises questions on the completeness of the database in particular with regard to the boundary conditions and available measurements.
The Residual Strength of Automotive Hydrogen Cylinders After Exposure to Flames
Sep 2017
Publication
Fuel cell vehicles and some compressed natural gas vehicles are equipped with carbon fiber reinforced plastic (CFRP) composite cylinders. Each of the cylinders has a pressure relief device designed to detect heat and release the internal gas to prevent the cylinder from bursting in a vehicle fire accident. Yet in some accident situations the fire may be extinguished before the pressure relief device is activated leaving the high-pressure fuel gas inside the fire-damaged cylinder. To handle such a cylinder safely after an accident it is necessary that the cylinder keeps a sufficient post-fire strength against its internal gas pressure but in most cases it is difficult to accurately determine cylinder strength at the accident site. One way of solving this problem is to predetermine the post-fire burst strengths of cylinders by experiments. In this study automotive CFRP cylinders having no pressure relief device were exposed to a fire to the verge of bursting; then after the fire was extinguished the residual burst strengths and the overall physical state of the test cylinders were examined. The results indicated that the test cylinders all recorded a residual burst strength at least twice greater than their internal gas pressure for tested cylinders with new cylinder burst to nominal working pressure in the range 2.67–4.92 above the regulated ratio of 2.25.
Deflagration-to-detonation Transition of H2-CO-Air Mixtures in a Partially Obstructed Channel
Sep 2019
Publication
In this study an explosion channel is used to investigate flame dynamics in homogeneous hydrogencarbon monoxide-air (H2-CO-air) mixtures. The test rig is a small scale 6 m channel at a rectangular cross section of 300x60 mm. Obstacles of a blockage ratio of BR=60% and a spacing of s=300mm are placed in first part of the channel. A 2.05 m long unobstructed part in the rear of the channel allows for investigation of freely propagating flames and detonations. The fuel composition is varied from 100/0 to 50/50 Vol.-% H2/CO mixtures. The overall fuel content ranges from 15 to 40 Vol.-% in air aiming to obtain fast flames and deflagration-to-detonation transition (DDT). Flame speed and dynamic pressure data are evaluated. Results extend data obtained by [1] and can be used for validation of numerical frameworks. Limits for fast flames and DDT in homogeneous H2-CO-air mixtures at the given geometry are presented.
Review of the Durability of Polymer Electrolyte Membrane Fuel Cell in Long-Term Operation: Main Influencing Parameters and Testing Protocols
Jul 2021
Publication
Durability is the most pressing issue preventing the efficient commercialization of polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) stationary and transportation applications. A big barrier to overcoming the durability limitations is gaining a better understanding of failure modes for user profiles. In addition durability test protocols for determining the lifetime of PEMFCs are important factors in the development of the technology. These methods are designed to gather enough data about the cell/stack to understand its efficiency and durability without causing it to fail. They also provide some indication of the cell/stack’s age in terms of changes in performance over time. Based on a study of the literature the fundamental factors influencing PEMFC long-term durability and the durability test protocols for both PEMFC stationary and transportation applications were discussed and outlined in depth in this review. This brief analysis should provide engineers and researchers with a fast overview as well as a useful toolbox for investigating PEMFC durability issues.
Ignition of H2-NO2/N2O4 Mixtures Under Volumetric Expansion Conditions
Sep 2019
Publication
The competition between chemical energy release rate and volumetric expansion related to shock wave’s dynamics is of primary importance for a number of situations relevant to explosion safety. While studies have been performed on this topic over the years they have been limited to mixtures with monotonous energy release profile. In the present study the ignition of H2-NO2/N2O4 mixtures which exhibit a single-step or a two-step energy release rate profile depending on the equivalence ratio has been investigated under volumetric expansion conditions. The rate of expansion has been calculated using the Taylor-Sedov solution and accounted for using 0-D numerical simulations with time-dependent specific volume. The results were analyzed in terms of a Damkohler number defined as the ratio of the expansion to ignition times. For mixtures with non-monotonous energy release rate profiles two critical Damkohler numbers can be identified one for each of the steps of energy release. It was also shown that the fluid element which is the most likely to ignite corresponds to the one behind a shock propagating at the Chapman-Jouguet velocity. The thermo-chemical dynamics have been analyzed about the critical conditions using energy release rate per reaction rate of production and sensitivity analyses.
Hydrogen Odorant and Leak Detection: Part 1, Hydrogen Odorant - Project Closure Report
Nov 2020
Publication
This work programme was focused on identifying a suitable odorant for use in a 100% hydrogen gas grid (domestic use such as boilers and cookers). The research involved a review of existing odorants (used primarily for natural gas) and the selection of five suitable odorants based on available literature. One odorant was selected based on possible suitability with a Polymer Electrolyte Membrane (PEM) based fuel cell vehicle which could in future be a possible end-user of grid hydrogen. NPL prepared Primary Reference Materials containing the five odorants in hydrogen at the relevant amount fraction levels (as would be found in the grid) including ones provided by Robinson Brothers (the supplier of odorants for natural gas in the UK). These mixtures were used by NPL to perform tests to understand the effects of the mixtures on pipeline (metal and plastic) appliances (a hydrogen boiler provided by Worcester Bosch) and PEM fuel cells. HSE investigated the health and environmental impact of these odorants in hydrogen. Olfactory testing was performed by Air Spectrum to characterise the ‘smell’ of each odorant. Finally an economic analysis was performed by E4tech. The results confirm that Odorant NB would be a suitable odorant for use in a 100% hydrogen gas grid for combustion applications but further research would be required if the intention is to supply grid hydrogen to stationery fuel cells or fuel cell vehicles. In this case further testing would need to be performed to measure the extent of fuel cell degradation caused by the non-sulphur odorant obtained as part of this work programme and also other UK projects such as the Hydrogen Grid to Vehicle (HG2V) project would provide important information about whether a purification step would be required regardless of the odorant before the hydrogen purity would be suitable for a PEM fuel cell vehicle. If purification was required it would be fine to use Odorant NB as this would be removed during the purification step.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the ENA Smarter Networks Portal here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the ENA Smarter Networks Portal here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.
Simulation of Deflagration-to-detonation Transition of Lean H2-CO-Air Mixtures in Obstructed Channels
Sep 2019
Publication
The possibility of flame acceleration (FA) and deflagration-to-detonation transition (DDT) when homogeneous hydrogen-carbon monoxide-air (H2-CO-air) mixtures are used rises the need for an efficient simulation approach for safety assessment. In this study a modelling approach for H2-CO-air flames incorporating deflagration and detonation within one framework is presented. It extends the previous work on H2-air mixtures. The deflagration is simulated by means of the turbulent flame speed closure model incorporating a quenching term. Since high flow velocities e.g. the characteristic speed of sound of the combustion products are reached during FA the flow passing obstacles generates turbulence at high enough levels to partially quench the flame. Partial flame quenching has the potential to stall the onset of detonation. An altered formulation for quenching is introduced to the modelling approach to better account for the combustion characteristics for accelerating lean H2-CO-air flames. The presented numerical approach is validated with experimental flame velocity data of the small-scale GraVent test rig [1] with homogeneous fuel contents of 22.5 and 25.0 vol-% and fuel compositions of 75/25 and 50/50 vol-% H2/CO respectively. The impact of the quenching term is further discussed on simulations of the FZK-7.2m test rig [2] whose obstacle spacing is smaller than the spacing in the GraVent test rig.
CFD Modelling of Underexpanded Hydrogen Jets Exiting Rectangular Shaped Openings
May 2020
Publication
Underexpanded jet releases from circular nozzles have been studied extensively both experimentally and numerically. However jet releases from rectangular openings have received much less attention and information on their dispersion behaviour is not as widely available. In this paper Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) is used to assess the suitability of using a pseudo-source approach to model jet releases from rectangular openings. A comparative study is performed to evaluate the effect of nozzle shape on jet structure and dispersion characteristics for underexpanded hydrogen jet releases. Jet releases issuing from a circular nozzle and rectangular nozzles with aspect ratios ranging from two to eight are modelled including resolution of the near-field behaviour. The experimental work of Ruggles and Ekoto (2012 2014) is used as a basis for validating the modelling approach used and an additional case study in which jets with a stagnation-to-ambient pressure ratio of 300:1 are modelled is also performed. The CFD results show that for the 10:1 pressure ratio release the hazard volume and hazard distance remain largely unaffected by nozzle shape. For the higher pressure release the hazard volume is larger for the rectangular nozzle releases than the equivalent release through a circular orifice though the distance to lower flammability limit is comparable across the range of nozzle shapes considered. For both of the release pressures simulated the CFD results illustrate that a pseudo-source approach produces conservative results for all nozzle shapes considered. This finding has useful practical implications for consequence analysis in industrial applications such as the assessment of leaks from flanges and connections in pipework.
Risk Assessment and Ventilation Modeling for Hydrogen Vehicle Repair Garages
Sep 2019
Publication
The availability of repair garage infrastructure for hydrogen fuel cell vehicles is becoming increasingly important for future industry growth. Ventilation requirements for hydrogen fuel cell vehicles can affect both retrofitted and purpose-built repair garages and the costs associated with these requirements can be significant. A hazard and operability (HAZOP) study was performed to identify key risk-significant scenarios related to hydrogen vehicles in a repair garage. Detailed simulations and modeling were performed using appropriate computational tools to estimate the location behaviour and severity of hydrogen release based on key HAZOP scenarios. This work compares current fire code requirements to an alternate ventilation strategy to further reduce potential hazardous conditions. It is shown that position direction and velocity of ventilation have a significant impact on the amount of flammable mass in the domain.
Transferring the Retail of Hydrogen Economy and Missing Safety Assurance
Sep 2019
Publication
Australian regional communities are moving ahead of governments. Enterprising individuals are pushing ahead to find global solutions to local issues that governments (local or state or federal) have abandoned stalled mothballed or failed to resolve. We are faced with a flaw in retail of hydrogen economy as fatal as Walgett running dry or a million fish killed in Murray-Darling. The challenge in Australian regional communities will be to interpret safety assurance requirements in an appropriate manner even in severe economic swings such as drought bushfire or floods. In this context the efficacious cultural embrace by regional communities of three key program elements is essential - Australian Hydrogen Safety Panel Hydrogen Safety Knowledge Tools and Dissemination Hydrogen Safety First Responder Training. What are the odds of no accident in retailing hydrogen for examples to vehicles? Place is everything in regional communities of Australia because in nature (as in the ocean) there is no spin. This paper examines the safety assurance issues associated with the cultural integration of Hydrogen’s three key program elements in a country Australia that is fed-up with government.
Vented Explosion of Hydrogen/Air Mixtures: Influence of Vent Cover and Stratification
Sep 2017
Publication
Explosion venting is a prevention/mitigation solution widely used in the process industry to protect indoor equipment or buildings from excessive internal pressure caused by an accidental explosion. Vented explosions are widely investigated in the literature for various geometries hydrogen/air concentrations ignition positions initial turbulence etc. In real situations the vents are normally covered by a vent panel. In the case of an indoor leakage the hydrogen/air cloud will be stratified rather than homogeneous. Nowadays there is a lack in understanding about the vented explosion of stratified clouds and about the influence of vent cover inertia on the internal overpressure. This paper aims at shedding light on these aspects by means of experimental investigation of vented hydrogen/air deflagration using an experimental facility of 1m3 and via numerical simulations using the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) code FLACS
Experimental Investigation of Unconfined Spherical and Cylindrical Flame Propagation in Hydrogen-air Mixtures
Sep 2019
Publication
This paper presents results of experimental investigations on spherical and cylindrical flame propagation in pre-mixed H2/air-mixtures in unconfined and semi-confined geometries. The experiments were performed in a facility consisting of two transparent solid walls with 1 m2 area and four weak side walls made from thin plastic film. The gap size between the solid walls was varied stepwise from thin layer geometry (6 mm) to cube geometry (1 m). A wide range of H2/air-mixtures with volumetric hydrogen concentrations from 10% to 45% H2 was ignited between the transparent solid walls. The propagating flame front and its structure was observed with a large scale high speed shadow system. Results of spherical and cylindrical flame propagation up to a radius of 0.5 m were analyzed. The presented spherical burning velocity model is used to discuss the self-acceleration phenomena in unconfined and unobstructed pre-mixed H2/air flames.
Analysis of Hydrogen-Induced Changes in the Cyclic Deformation Behaviour of AISI 300–Series Austenitic Stainless Steels Using Cyclic Indentation Testing
Jun 2021
Publication
The locally occurring mechanisms of hydrogen embrittlement significantly influence the fatigue behaviour of a material which was shown in previous research on two different AISI 300-series austenitic stainless steels with different austenite stabilities. In this preliminary work an enhanced fatigue crack growth as well as changes in crack initiation sites and morphology caused by hydrogen were observed. To further analyze the results obtained in this previous research in the present work the local cyclic deformation behaviour of the material volume was analyzed by using cyclic indentation testing. Moreover these results were correlated to the local dislocation structures obtained with transmission electron microscopy (TEM) in the vicinity of fatigue cracks. The cyclic indentation tests show a decreased cyclic hardening potential as well as an increased dislocation mobility for the conditions precharged with hydrogen which correlates to the TEM analysis revealing courser dislocation cells in the vicinity of the fatigue crack tip. Consequently the presented results indicate that the hydrogen enhanced localized plasticity (HELP) mechanism leads to accelerated crack growth and change in crack morphology for the materials investigated. In summary the cyclic indentation tests show a high potential for an analysis of the effects of hydrogen on the local cyclic deformation behaviour.
Thermal Radiation from Cryogenic Hydrogen Jet Fires
Sep 2017
Publication
The thermal hazards from ignited under-expanded cryogenic releases are not yet fully understood and reliable predictive tools are missing. This study aims at validation of a CFD model to simulate flame length and radiative heat flux for cryogenic hydrogen jet fires. The simulation results are compared against the experimental data by Sandia National Laboratories on cryogenic hydrogen fires from storage with pressure up to 5 bar abs and temperature in the range 48–82 K. The release source is modelled using the Ulster's notional nozzle theory. The problem is considered as steady-state. Three turbulence models were applied and their performance was compared. The realizable k-ε model showed the best agreement with experimental flame length and radiative heat flux. Therefore it has been employed in the CFD model along with Eddy Dissipation Concept for combustion and Discrete Ordinates (DO) model for radiation. A parametric study has been conducted to assess the effect of selected numerical and physical parameters on the simulations capability to reproduce experimental data. DO model discretisation is shown to strongly affect simulations indicating 10 × 10 as minimum number of angular divisions to provide a convergence. The simulations have shown sensitivity to experimental parameters such as humidity and exhaust system volumetric flow rate highlighting the importance of accurate and extended publication of experimental data to conduct precise numerical studies. The simulations correctly reproduced the radiative heat flux from cryogenic hydrogen jet fire at different locations.
No more items...