United Kingdom
Hydrogen or Batteries for Grid Storage? A Net Energy Analysis
Apr 2015
Publication
Energy storage is a promising approach to address the challenge of intermittent generation from renewables on the electric grid. In this work we evaluate energy storage with a regenerative hydrogen fuel cell (RHFC) using net energy analysis. We examine the most widely installed RHFC configuration containing an alkaline water electrolyzer and a PEM fuel cell. To compare RHFC's to other storage technologies we use two energy return ratios: the electrical energy stored on invested (ESOIe) ratio (the ratio of electrical energy returned by the device over its lifetime to the electrical-equivalent energy required to build the device) and the overall energy efficiency (the ratio of electrical energy returned by the device over its lifetime to total lifetime electrical-equivalent energy input into the system). In our reference scenario the RHFC system has an ESOIeratio of 59 more favorable than the best battery technology available today (Li-ion ESOIe= 35). (In the reference scenario RHFC the alkaline electrolyzer is 70% efficient and has a stack lifetime of 100 000 h; the PEM fuel cell is 47% efficient and has a stack lifetime of 10 000 h; and the round-trip efficiency is 30%.) The ESOIe ratio of storage in hydrogen exceeds that of batteries because of the low energy cost of the materials required to store compressed hydrogen and the high energy cost of the materials required to store electric charge in a battery. However the low round-trip efficiency of a RHFC energy storage system results in very high energy costs during operation and a much lower overall energy efficiency than lithium ion batteries (0.30 for RHFC vs. 0.83 for lithium ion batteries). RHFC's represent an attractive investment of manufacturing energy to provide storage. On the other hand their round-trip efficiency must improve dramatically before they can offer the same overall energy efficiency as batteries which have round-trip efficiencies of 75–90%. One application of energy storage that illustrates the trade-off between these different aspects of energy performance is capturing overgeneration (spilled power) for later use during times of peak output from renewables. We quantify the relative energetic benefit of adding different types of energy storage to a renewable generating facility using [EROI]grid. Even with 30% round-trip efficiency RHFC storage achieves the same [EROI]grid as batteries when storing overgeneration from wind turbines because its high ESOIeratio and the high EROI of wind generation offset the low round-trip efficiency.
Shining the Light on Clean Hydrogen
Jun 2021
Publication
Clean hydrogen:
- What's driving the excitement?
- Will hydrogen stay on the main stage of the energy transition?
- What is the market for clean hydrogen today?
Deep-Decarbonisation Pathways for UK Industry
Dec 2020
Publication
The Climate Change Committee (CCC) commissioned Element Energy to improve our evidence base on the potential of industrial deep-decarbonisation measures (fuel switching CCS/BECCS measures to reduce methane emissions) and develop pathways for their application. This report summarises the evidence and results of the work including:
- Evidence on the key constraints and costs for technology and infrastructure deployment
- The methodology and new Net Zero Industry Pathway (N-ZIP) model used to determine deep-decarbonisation pathways for UK industry (drawing on the evidence above)
- A set of pathways and wider sensitivities produced using the N-ZIP model which fed into the CCC’s Sixth Carbon Budget pathways
- Recommended actions and policy measures as informed by the study.
Hydrogen Jet Fires in a Passively Ventilated Enclosure
Oct 2015
Publication
This paper describes a combined experimental analytical and numerical modelling investigation into hydrogen jet fires in a passively ventilated enclosure. The work was funded by the EU Fuel Cells and Hydrogen Joint Undertaking project Hyindoor. It is relevant to situations where hydrogen is stored or used indoors. In such situations passive ventilation can be used to prevent the formation of a flammable atmosphere following a release of hydrogen. Whilst a significant amount of work has been reported on unignited releases in passively ventilated enclosures and on outdoor hydrogen jet fires very little is known about the behaviour of hydrogen jet fires in passively ventilated enclosures. This paper considers the effects of passive ventilation openings on the behaviour of hydrogen jet fires. A series of hydrogen jet fire experiments were carried out using a 31 m3 passively ventilated enclosure. The test programme included subsonic and chocked flow releases with varying hydrogen release rates and vent configurations. In most of the tests the hydrogen release rate was sufficiently low and the vent area sufficiently large to lead to a well-ventilated jet fire. In a limited number of tests the vent area was reduced allowing under-ventilated conditions to be investigated. The behaviour of a jet fire in a passively ventilated enclosure depends on the hydrogen release rate the vent area and the thermal properties of the enclosure. An analytical model was used to quantify the relative importance of the hydrogen release rate and vent area whilst the influence of the thermal properties of the enclosure were investigated using a CFD model. Overall the results indicate that passive ventilation openings that are sufficiently large to safely ventilate an unignited release will tend to be large enough to prevent a jet fire from becoming under-ventilated.
Potential Development of Renewable Hydrogen Imports to European Markets until 2030
Mar 2022
Publication
This paper considers potential import routes for low-carbon and renewable hydrogen (H2) to main European markets like Germany. In particular it analyses claims made by Hydrogen Europe and subsequently picked up by the European Commission in its Hydrogen Strategy that there will be 40GW of electrolyser capacity in nearby countries providing hydrogen imports to Europe by 2030. The analysis shows that by 2030 potential demand for H2 could be high enough to initiate some limited international hydrogen trade most likely between European countries initially rather than from outside Europe. Geographically a northern hydrogen cluster around Netherlands and NW Germany will be more significant for hydrogen demand while southern Europe is more likely to have surplus low cost renewable power generation. The paper considers potential H2 exporters to Europe including Ukraine and North African countries (in line with the proposal from Hydrogen Europe) as well as Norway and Russia. (The research pre-dates recent political and military tensions between Russia and Ukraine which are likely to influence future development pathways). The supply cost of hydrogen in 2030 is predicted to be in a reasonably (and perhaps surprisingly) narrow band around €3/kg from various sources and supply chains. The paper concludes that overall while imports of hydrogen to Europe are certainly possible in the longer term there are many challenges to be addressed. This conclusion supports the growing consensus that development of low carbon hydrogen certainly within Europe is likely to start within relatively local hydrogen clusters with some limited bilateral trade.
The research paper can be found on their website
The research paper can be found on their website
Safety and Environmental Standards for Fuel Storage Sites
Jan 2009
Publication
The main purpose of this report is to specify the minimum standards of control which should be in place at all establishments storing large volumes of gasoline.<br/>The PSLG also considered other substances capable of giving rise to a large flammable vapour cloud in the event of a loss of primary containment. However to ensure priority was given to improving standards of control to tanks storing gasoline PSLG has yet to determine the scale and application of this guidance to such substances. It is possible that a limited number of other substances (with specific physical properties and storage arrangements) will be addressed in the future.<br/>This report also provides guidance on good practice in relation to secondary and tertiary containment for facilities covered by the CA Control of Major Accident Hazards (COMAH) Parts of this guidance may also be relevant to other major hazard establishments.
International Association for Hydrogen Safety ‘Research Priorities Workshop’, September 2018, Buxton, UK
Sep 2018
Publication
Hydrogen has the potential to be used by many countries as part of decarbonising the future energy system. Hydrogen can be used as a fuel ‘vector’ to store and transport energy produced in low-carbon ways. This could be particularly important in applications such as heating and transport where other solutions for low and zero carbon emission are difficult. To enable the safe uptake of hydrogen technologies it is important to develop the international scientific evidence base on the potential risks to safety and how to control them effectively. The International Association for Hydrogen Safety (known as IA HySAFE) is leading global efforts to ensure this. HSE hosted the 2018 IA HySAFE Biennial Research Priorities Workshop. A panel of international experts presented during nine key topic sessions: (1) Industrial and National Programmes; (2) Applications; (3) Storage; (4) Accident Physics – Gas Phase; (5) Accident Physics – Liquid/ Cryogenic Behaviour; (6) Materials; (7) Mitigation Sensors Hazard Prevention and Risk Reduction; (8) Integrated Tools for Hazard and Risk Assessment; (9) General Aspects of Safety.<br/>This report gives an overview of each topic made by the session chairperson. It also gives further analysis of the totality of the evidence presented. The workshop outputs are shaping international activities on hydrogen safety. They are helping key stakeholders to identify gaps in knowledge and expertise and to understand and plan for potential safety challenges associated with the global expansion of hydrogen in the energy system.
Effect of Syngas Fuel Compositions on the Occurrence of Instability of Laminar Diffusion Flame
Dec 2020
Publication
The paper presents a numerical investigation of the critical roles played by the chemical compositions of syngas on laminar diffusion flame instabilities. Three different flame phenomena – stable flickering and tip-cutting – are formulated by varying the syngas fuel rate from 0.2 to 1.4 SLPM. Following the satisfactory validation of numerical results with Darabkhani et al. [1] the study explored the consequence of each species (H2 CO CH4 CO2 N2) in the syngas composition. It is found that low H2:CO has a higher level of instability which however does not rise any further when the ratio is less than 1. Interestingly CO encourages the heat generation with less fluctuation while H2 plays another significant role in the increase of flame temperature and its fluctuation. Diluting CH4 into syngas further increases the instability level as well as the fluctuation of heat generation significantly. However an opposite effect is found from the same action with either CO2 or N2. Finally considering the heat generation and flame stability the highest performance is obtained from 25%H2+75%CO (81 W) followed by EQ+20%CO2 and EQ+20%N2 (78 W).
A Critical Review on the Principles, Applications, and Challenges of Waste-to-hydrogen Technologies
Sep 2020
Publication
Hydrogen sourced from energy recovery processes and conversion of waste materials is a method of providing both a clean fuel and a sustainable waste management alternative to landfill and incineration. The question is whether waste-to–hydrogen can become part of the zero-carbon future energy mix and serve as one of the cleaner hydrogen sources which is economically viable and environmentally friendly. This work critically assessed the potential of waste as a source of hydrogen production via various thermochemical (gasification and pyrolysis) and biochemical (fermentation and photolysis) processes. Research has shown hydrogen production yields of 33.6 mol/kg and hydrogen concentrations of 82% from mixed waste feedstock gasification. Biochemical methods such as fermentation can produce hydrogen up to 418.6 mL/g. Factors including feedstock quality process requirements and technology availability were reviewed to guide technology selection and system design. Current technology status and bottlenecks were discussed to shape future development priorities. These bottlenecks include expensive production and operation processes heterogeneous feedstock low process efficiencies inadequate management and logistics and lack of policy support. Improvements to hydrogen yields and production rates are related to feedstock processing and advanced energy efficiency processes such as torrefaction of feedstock which has shown thermal efficiency of gasification up to 4 MJ/kg. This will affect the economic feasibility and concerns around required improvements to bring the costs down to allow waste to viewed as a serious competitor for hydrogen production. Recommendations were also made for financially competitive waste-to-hydrogen development to be part of a combined solution for future energy needs.
Progress in Biofuel Production from Gasification
May 2017
Publication
Biofuels from biomass gasification are reviewed here and demonstrated to be an attractive option. Recent progress in gasification techniques and key generation pathways for biofuels production process design and integration and socio-environmental impacts of biofuel generation are discussed with the goal of investigating gasification-to-biofuels’ credentials as a sustainable and eco-friendly technology. The synthesis of important biofuels such as bio-methanol bio-ethanol and higher alcohols bio-dimethyl ether Fischer Tropsch fuels bio-methane bio-hydrogen and algae-based fuels is reviewed together with recent technologies catalysts and reactors. Significant thermodynamic studies for each biofuel are also examined. Syngas cleaning is demonstrated to be a critical issue for biofuel production and innovative pathways such as those employed by Choren Industrietechnik Germany and BioMCN the Netherlands are shown to allow efficient methanol generation. The conversion of syngas to FT transportation fuels such as gasoline and diesel over Co or Fe catalysts is reviewed and demonstrated to be a promising option for the future of biofuels. Bio-methane has emerged as a lucrative alternative for conventional transportation fuel with all the advantages of natural gas including a dense distribution trade and supply network. Routes to produce H2 are discussed though critical issues such as storage expensive production routes with low efficiencies remain. Algae-based fuels are in the research and development stage but are shown to have immense potential to become commercially important because of their capability to fix large amounts of CO2 to rapidly grow in many environments and versatile end uses. However suitable process configurations resulting in optimal plant designs are crucial so detailed process integration is a powerful tool to optimize current and develop new processes. LCA and ethical issues are also discussed in brief. It is clear that the use of food crops as opposed to food wastes represents an area fraught with challenges which must be resolved on a case by case basis.
Cross-regional Drivers for CCUS Deployment
Jul 2020
Publication
CO2 capture utilization and storage (CCUS) is recognized as a uniquely important option in global efforts to control anthropogenic greenhouse-gas (GHG) emissions. Despite significant progress globally in advancing the maturity of the various component technologies and their assembly into full-chain demonstrations a gap remains on the path to widespread deployment in many countries. In this paper we focus on the importance of business models adapted to the unique technical features and sociopolitical drivers in different regions as a necessary component of commercial scale-up and how lessons might be shared across borders. We identify three archetypes for CCUS development—resource recovery green growth and low-carbon grids—each with different near-term issues that if addressed will enhance the prospect of successful commercial deployment. These archetypes provide a framing mechanism that can help to translate experience in one region or context to other locations by clarifying the most important technical issues and policy requirements. Going forward the archetype framework also provides guidance on how different regions can converge on the most effective use of CCUS as part of global deep-decarbonization efforts over the long term.
Unattended Hydrogen Vehicle Fueling Challenges and Historical Context
Sep 2019
Publication
Hydrogen fuelling in the US is unattended activity although this precedent is not without several challenges that have been addressed in the past decade. This paper provides the recent history and the generic safety case which has established this precedent for hydrogen. The paper also explores the longer history of unattended gasoline fuelling and attempts to help place hydrogen fuelling into the longer history of fuelling personal vehicles.
Closing the Low-carbon Material Loop Using a Dynamic Whole System Approach
Feb 2017
Publication
The transition to low carbon energy and transport systems requires an unprecedented roll-out of new infrastructure technologies containing significant quantities of critical raw materials. Many of these technologies are based on general purpose technologies such as permanent magnets and electric motors that are common across different infrastructure systems. Circular economy initiatives that aim to institute better resource management practices could exploit these technological commonalities through the reuse and remanufacturing of technology components across infrastructure systems. In this paper we analyze the implementation of such processes in the transition to low carbon electricity generation and transport on the Isle of Wight UK. We model two scenarios relying on different renewable energy technologies with the reuse of Lithium-ion batteries from electric vehicles for grid-attached storage. A whole-system analysis that considers both electricity and transport infrastructure demonstrates that the optimal choice of renewable technology can be dependent on opportunities for component reuse and material recycling between the different infrastructure systems. Hydrogen fuel cell based transport makes use of platinum from obsolete catalytic converters whereas lithium-ion batteries can be reused for grid-attached storage when they are no longer useful in vehicles. Trade-offs exist between the efficiency of technology reuse which eliminates the need for new technologies for grid attached storage completely by 2033 and the higher flexibility afforded by recycling at the material level; reducing primary material demand for Lithium by 51% in 2033 compared to 30% achieved by battery reuse. This analysis demonstrates the value of a methodology that combines detailed representations of technologies and components with a systemic approach that includes multiple interconnected infrastructure systems.
Towards Net-zero Smart System: An Power Synergy Management Approach of Hydrogen and Battery Hybrid System with Hydrogen Safety Consideration
May 2022
Publication
The building system is one of key energy consumption sector in the market and low-carbon building will make a significant contribution for the worldwide carbon emission reduction. The multiple energy systems including renewable generations hydrogen energy and energy storage is the perspective answer to the net-zero building system. However the research gap lies in the synergy power management among the renewable flexible loads batteries and hydrogen energy systems and at the same time taking the unique characteristic of different energy sectors into account by power managing. This paper proposed the power management approach based on the game theory by which the different characteristics of the energy players are described via creating the competing relationship against net-zero emission objective so that to achieve the power synergy. Under the proposed power management method the hydrogen and battery hybrid system including the fuel cell electrolyzer and battery is designed and investigated as to unlock the power management regions and control constraints within the building system. Particularly for the hydrogen system within the hybrid system the safe and long-lifetime operation is considered respectively by high-efficiency and pressure constraints within the power management. Simulation results show that providing the same energy storage services for the building system the fuel cell with the proposed power management method sustains for 9.9 years much longer than that of equivalent consumption minimization (4.98) model predictive control (4.61) and rule-based method (7.69). Moreover the maximum tank temperature of the hydrogen tank is reduced by 3.4 K and 2.9 K compared with consumption minimization strategy and model predictive control. Also the real-time of the proposed power management is verified by a scaled-down experiment platform.
Hydrogen Generation by Photocatalytic Reforming of Potential Biofuels: Polyols, Cyclic Alcohols, and Saccharides
Jan 2018
Publication
We have studied hydrogen gas production using photocatalysis from C2-C5 carbon chain polyols cyclic alcohols and mono and di-saccharides using palladium nanoparticles supported on a TiO2 catalyst. For many of the polyols the hydrogen evolution rate is found to be dictated by the number of hydroxyl groups and available a-hydrogens in the structure. However the rule only applies to polyols and cyclic alcohols while the sugar activity is limited by the bulky structure of those molecules. There was also evidence of ring opening in photocatalytic reforming of cyclic alcohols that involved dehydrogenation and decarbonylation of a CC bond.
Heat Pump Manufacturing Supply Chain Research Project Report
Dec 2020
Publication
The Department for Business Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) commissioned a study to research the capacity of the manufacturing supply chain to meet expected future demand for heat pumps. This report contains analysis of the existing supply chain including component parts and also assesses the risks to and opportunities for growth in domestic heat pump manufacture and export.<br/><br/>Alongside a literature review the findings in this report were supported by interviews with organisations involved in the manufacture of heat pumps and an online workshop held with a range of businesses throughout the supply chain.
Transitioning to Hydrogen - Assessing the Engineering Risks and Uncertainties
Jun 2016
Publication
Transitioning to Hydrogen a joint report from five engineering organisations focuses on the engineering challenges of replacing natural gas in the gas distribution network with hydrogen in order to reduce emissions. The production of this report is timely following the commitment from Government this week to legislate for net zero emissions by 2050. It is expected that hydrogen will play a big part in the reduction of emissions from the heating transport and industrial sectors.<br/><br/>The report concludes that there is no reason why repurposing the gas network to hydrogen cannot be achieved but there are some engineering risks and uncertainties that need to be addressed. In the development of the report many questions were posed and members of IMechE IChemE IET and IGEM were surveyed to better understand the challenges faced by the hydrogen production and gas industries planning to undertake this ambitious transition. Further information was obtained from the Health and Safety Laboratories.<br/><br/>The report also highlights 20 ongoing projects in the UK that are looking at various aspects of hydrogen production distribution and use.
Tees Valley Multi-modal Hydrogen Transport Hub Masterplan
Mar 2021
Publication
Study setting out a vision and plan for a multi-modal hydrogen transport hub within the UK. The study considers the:
- size of operational trials
- quantity of green hydrogen required
- research and development facilities which will support a living lab
- green hydrogen infrastructure required including:
- production
- storage
- distribution
- The study uses Tees Valley as an example region although the blueprint may be applied to other areas.
Non-adiabatic Under-expanded Jet Theory for Blowdown and Fire Resistance Rating of Hydrogen Tank
Sep 2019
Publication
The European Regulations on type-approval of hydrogen vehicles require thermally-activated pressure relief device (TPRD) to be installed on hydrogen onboard storage tanks to release its content in a fire event to prevent its catastrophic rupture. The aim of this study is to develop a model for design of an inherently safer system TPRD-storage tank. Parameters of tank materials and hydrogen external heat flux from the fire to the tank wall TPRD diameter time to initiate TPRD are input parameters of the model. The energy conservation equation and real gas equation of state are employed to describe the dynamic behaviour of the system. The under-expanded jet theory developed previously for adiabatic release from a storage tank is applied here to non-adiabatic blowdown of a tank in a fire. Unsteady heat transfer equation is used to calculate heat conduction through the tank wall. It includes the decomposition of the wall material due to high heat flux. The convective heat transfer between tank wall and hydrogen is modelled through the dimensionless Nusselt number correlations. The model is validated against two types of experiments i.e. realistic (non-adiabatic) blowdown of high-pressure storage tank and failure of a tank without TPRD in a fire. The model is confirmed to be time efficient for computations and accurately predicts the dynamic pressure and temperature of the gas inside the tank temperature profile within the tank wall time to tank rupture in a fire and the blowdown time.
Numerical Study of Spontaneous Ignition of Pressurized Hydrogen Release into Air
Sep 2007
Publication
Numerical simulations have been carried out for spontaneous ignition of pressurized hydrogen release directly into air. Results showed a possible mechanism for spontaneous ignition due to molecular diffusion. To accurately calculate the molecular transport of species momentum and energy in a multi-component gaseous mixture a mixture-averaged multi-component approach was employed in which thermal diffusion is accounted for. To reduce false numerical diffusion extremely fine meshes were used along with the ALE (Arbitrary Lagrangian-Eulerian) method. The ALE method was employed to track the moving contact surface with moving clustered grids. A detailed kinetic scheme with 21 elementary steps and 8 reactive chemical species was implemented for combustion chemistry. The scheme gives due consideration to third body reactions and reaction-rate pressure-dependant “fall-off” behavior. The autoignition of pressurized hydrogen release was previously observed in laboratory tests [2-3] and suspected as possible cause of some accidents. The present numerical study successfully captured this scenario. Autoignition was predicted to first take place at the tip region of the hydrogen-air contact surface due to mass and energy exchange between low temperature hydrogen and shock-heated air at the contact surface through molecular diffusion. The initial flame thickness is extremely thin due to the limiting molecular diffusion. The combustion region extends downward along the contact surface as it moves downstream. As the hydrogen jet developed downstream the front contact surface tends to be distorted by the developed flow of the air. Turbulence plays an important role in mixing at the region of the distorted contact surface. This is thought to be a major factor for the initial laminar flame to turn into a final stable turbulent flame.
Vapour Cloud Explosions from the Ignition of Methane, Hydrogen, Air Mixtures in a Congested Region
Sep 2007
Publication
To facilitate the transition to the hydrogen economy the EU project NATURALHY is studying the potential for the existing natural gas pipeline networks to transport hydrogen together with natural gas to end-users. Hydrogen may then be extracted for hydrogen fuel-cell applications or the mixture used directly by consumers in existing gas-fired equipment with the benefit of lower carbon emissions. The existing gas pipeline networks are designed constructed and operated to safely transport natural gas mostly methane. However hydrogen has significantly different properties that may adversely affect both the integrity of the network and thereby increase the likelihood of an accidental leak and the consequences if the leak finds a source of ignition. Consequently a major part of the NATURALHY project is focused on assessing how much hydrogen could be introduced into the network without adversely impacting on the safety of the network and the risk to the public. Hydrogen is more reactive than natural gas so the severity of an explosion following an accidental leak may be increased. This paper describes field-scale experiments conducted to measure the overpressures generated by ignition of methane/hydrogen/air mixtures in a congested but unconfined region. Such regions may be found in the gas handling and metering stations of the pipeline networks. The 3 m x 3 m x 2 m high congested region studied contained layers of pipes. The composition of the methane/hydrogen mixture used was varied from 0% hydrogen to 100% hydrogen. On the basis of the experiments performed the maximum overpressures generated by methane/hydrogen mixtures with 25% (by volume) or less hydrogen content are not likely to be much more than those generated by methane alone. Greater percentages of hydrogen did significantly increase the explosion overpressure.
Committee for Climate Change Fifth Carbon Budget: Central Scenario Data
Jul 2016
Publication
This spreadsheet contains data for two future UK scenarios: a "baseline" (i.e. no climate action after 2008 the start of the carbon budget system) and the "central" scenario underpinning the CCC's advice on the fifth carbon budget (the limit to domestic emissions during the period 2028-32).<br/>The central scenario is an assessment of the technologies and behaviours that would prepare for the 2050 target cost-effectively while meeting the other criteria in the Climate Change Act (2008) based on central views of technology costs fuel prices carbon prices and feasibility. It is not prescriptive nor is it the only scenario considered for meeting the carbon budgets. For further details on our scenarios and how they were generated see the CCC report Sectoral scenarios for the Fifth Carbon Budget. The scenario was constructed for the CCC's November 2015 report and has not been further updated for example to reflect outturn data for 2015 or changes to Government policy.
Meeting Carbon Budgets – 2014 Progress Report to Parliament
Jul 2014
Publication
This is our sixth statutory report to Parliament on progress towards meeting carbon budgets. In it we consider the latest data on emissions and their drivers. This year the report also includes a full assessment of how the first carbon budget (2008-2012) was met drawing out policy lessons and setting out what is required for the future to stay on track for the legislated carbon budgets and the 2050 target. The report includes assessment at the level of the economy the non-traded and traded sectors the key emitting sectors and the devolved administrations. Whilst the first carbon budget has been met and progress made on development and implementation of some policies the main conclusion is that strengthening of policies will be needed to meet future budgets.
Heat Network Detailed Project Development Resource: Guidance on Strategic and Commercial Case
Jul 2016
Publication
This document provides guidance on the commercial and strategic elements of a heat network project to support completion of a project business case.
The guidance is intended for local authorities and heat network developers to support their investigations and enable progression from feasibility stage through to business case delivery. The guidance has been drafted with reference to policy legislation and regulation in England and Wales; however much of the guidance is likely also to be relevant to projects in Scotland and Northern Ireland.
The guidance specifically supports the HMT Green Book Five Cases Business Model (the Five Cases Model) and the derived DBEIS Business Case Template (DBEIS BCT) that follows this structure but will also be applicable in other instances. The Five Cases Model (and similarly the DBEIS BCT) considers the viability of the project from five perspectives:
Although all five elements are relevant this guide particularly focuses on the Strategic and Commercial cases.
Related Document Heat Networks 2020
The guidance is intended for local authorities and heat network developers to support their investigations and enable progression from feasibility stage through to business case delivery. The guidance has been drafted with reference to policy legislation and regulation in England and Wales; however much of the guidance is likely also to be relevant to projects in Scotland and Northern Ireland.
The guidance specifically supports the HMT Green Book Five Cases Business Model (the Five Cases Model) and the derived DBEIS Business Case Template (DBEIS BCT) that follows this structure but will also be applicable in other instances. The Five Cases Model (and similarly the DBEIS BCT) considers the viability of the project from five perspectives:
- Strategic
- Economic
- Commercial
- Financial
- Management
Although all five elements are relevant this guide particularly focuses on the Strategic and Commercial cases.
Related Document Heat Networks 2020
Public Acceptability of the Use of Hydrogen for Heating and Cooking in the Home: Results from Qualitative and Quantitative Research in UK<br/>Executive Summary
Nov 2018
Publication
This report for the CCC by Madano and Element Energy assesses the public acceptability of two alternative low-carbon technologies for heating the home: hydrogen heating and heat pumps.
These technologies could potentially replace natural gas in many UK households as part of the government’s efforts to decrease carbon emissions in the UK.
The report’s key findings are:
These technologies could potentially replace natural gas in many UK households as part of the government’s efforts to decrease carbon emissions in the UK.
The report’s key findings are:
- carbon emissions reduction is viewed as an important issue but there is limited awareness of the need to decarbonise household heating or the implications of switching over to low-carbon heating technologies
- acceptability of both heating technologies is limited by a lack of perceived tangible consumer benefit which has the potential to drive scepticism towards the switch over more generally
- heating technology preferences are not fixed at this stage although heat pumps appear to be the favoured option in this research studythree overarching factors were identified as influencing preferences for heating technologies.
- perceptions of the negative installation burden
- familiarity with the lived experience of using the technologies for heating
- perceptions of how well the technologies would meet modern heating needs both hydrogen heating and heat pumps face significant challenges to secure public acceptability
The Fourth Carbon Budget Review – Part 2 The Cost-effective Path to the 2050 Target
Nov 2013
Publication
This is the second document of a two-part review of the Fourth Carbon Budget which covers 2023 to 2027. The Fourth Carbon Budget agreed by the Government in June 2011 was scheduled to be reviewed in 2014. The first part of the review is available here: The Fourth Carbon Budget Review – part 1: assessment of climate risk and the international response (November 2013).<br/>According to the Climate Change Act 2008 carbon budgets can only be altered if there is a significant change in circumstances upon which the budget was set. Any such change in circumstances must be demonstrated through evidence and analysis.<br/>The Fourth Carbon Budget Review – part 2 considers the impacts of meeting the 2023-2027 budget. The review concludes that the impacts are small and manageable and identifies broader benefits associated with meeting the fourth carbon budget including: improved energy security improved air quality and reduced noise pollution.
Quantifying Greenhouse Gas Emissions
Apr 2017
Publication
In this report Quantifying Greenhouse Gas Emissions the Committee on Climate Change assesses how the UK’s greenhouse gas emissions are quantified where uncertainties lie and the implications for setting carbon budgets and measuring progress against climate change targets. The report finds that:
- The methodology for constructing the UK’s greenhouse gas inventory is rigorous but the process for identifying improvements could be strengthened.
- There is high confidence over large parts of the inventory. A small number of sectors contribute most to uncertainty and research efforts should be directed at improving these estimates.
- UK greenhouse gas emissions for 2014 were within ±3% of the estimated level with 95% confidence which is a low level of uncertainty by international standards.
- Methodology revisions in recent years have tended to increase estimated emissions but these changes have been within uncertainty margins.
- Statistical uncertainty in the current greenhouse gas inventory is low but could rise in future.
- Uncertainty also arises from sources of emissions not currently included in the inventory and from potential changes to IPCC guidelines.
- Independent external validation of greenhouse gas emissions is important and new monitoring techniques should be encouraged.
- Government should continue to monitor consumption-based greenhouse gas estimates and support continued research to improve methodology and reduce uncertainty in these estimates.
The Sixth Carbon Budget & Welsh Emissions Targets Summary of Responses to Call for Evidence Summary
Jul 2020
Publication
In late 2019 the Committee launched a Call for Evidence to inform its advice to the UK Government on the Sixth Carbon Budget due to be published in December 2020. In addition the Committee sought input on Wales’ third carbon budget and interim emissions targets. These summary documents – one for the Sixth Carbon Budget and a second covering Wales’ carbon budget and emissions targets – provide an overview of the 170+ responses received along with the original submissions which are also published below.<br/>As background in 2019 the UK Government and Parliament adopted the Committee on Climate Change’s (CCC) recommendation to reduce UK emissions of greenhouse gases (GHGs) to Net Zero by 2050 (at least a 100% reduction in emissions compared to 1990 levels). The Climate Change Act 2008 requires the Committee to provide advice to the Government about the appropriate level for each carbon budget (sequential five-year caps on GHGs) on the path to the long-term target. To date in line with advice from the Committee five carbon budgets have been legislated covering the period to 2032. The Sixth Carbon Budget covers the period from 2033-37.
The Fourth Carbon Budget Review – Part 1 Assessment of Climate Risk and the International Response
Nov 2013
Publication
This is the first document of a two-part review of the Fourth Carbon Budget which covers 2023 to 2027. The Fourth Carbon Budget agreed by the Government in June 2011 was scheduled to be reviewed in 2014. The second part of the review is available here: The Fourth Carbon Budget Review – part 2: the cost effective path to the 2050 target (December 2013).<br/>According to the Climate Change Act 2008 carbon budgets can only be altered if there is a significant change in circumstances upon which the budget was set. Any such change in circumstances must be demonstrated through evidence and analysis.<br/>The Fourth Carbon Budget Review – part 1 focuses on developments in three categories of circumstance on which the budget was set: climate science international circumstances and European Union pathways. The report also looks at findings by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and assesses the implications for carbon budgets.
Reducing Emissions in Scotland – 2018 Progress Report
Sep 2019
Publication
This is the Committee’s seventh report on Scotland’s progress towards meetings emissions targets as requested by Scottish Ministers under the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009.
Overall Scotland continues to outperform the rest of the UK in reducing its greenhouse gas emissions but successful strategies for energy and waste mask a lack of progress in other parts of the Scottish economy.
The report shows that Scotland’s total emissions fell by 10% in 2016 compared to 2015. The lion’s share of this latest drop in emissions came from electricity generation.
The key findings are:
Overall Scotland continues to outperform the rest of the UK in reducing its greenhouse gas emissions but successful strategies for energy and waste mask a lack of progress in other parts of the Scottish economy.
The report shows that Scotland’s total emissions fell by 10% in 2016 compared to 2015. The lion’s share of this latest drop in emissions came from electricity generation.
The key findings are:
- Overall Scotland met its annual emissions targets in 2016.
- Scotland’s progress in reducing emissions from the power sector masks a lack of action in other areas particularly transport agriculture forestry and land use.
- Low-carbon heat transport agriculture and forestry sector policies need to improve in order to hit 2032 emissions targets.
- The Scottish Government’s Climate Change Plan – published in February 2018 – now has sensible expectations across each sector to reduce emissions.
Power Sector Scenarios for the Fifth Carbon Budget
Oct 2015
Publication
This report sets out scenarios for the UK power sector in 2030 as an input to the Committee’s advice on the fifth carbon budget.<br/>These scenarios are not intended to set out a prescriptive path. Instead they provide a tool for the Committee to verify that its advice can be achieved with manageable impacts in order to meet the criteria set out in the Climate Change Act including competitiveness affordability and energy security.
Future Regulation of the Gas Grid
Jun 2016
Publication
The CCC has established a variety of viable scenarios in which UK decarbonisation targets can be met. Each has consequences for the way in which the UK’s gas network infrastructure is utilised. This report considers the implications of decarbonisation for the future regulation of the gas grid.<br/>The CCC’s 5th Carbon Budget envisaged different scenarios that would enable the UK to meet its emissions targets for 2050. These scenarios represent holistic analyses based on internally consistent combinations of different technologies which could deliver carbon reductions across different sectors of the economy.<br/>The CCC’s scenarios incorporate projections of the demand for natural gas to 2050. The scenarios imply that the volume of throughput on the gas networks1 and the nature and location of network usage is likely to change significantly to meet emissions targets. They are also characterised by significant uncertainty.<br/>Under some decarbonisation scenarios gas networks could be re-purposed to supply hydrogen instead of natural gas meaning there would be ongoing need for network infrastructure.<br/>In other scenarios gas demand in buildings is largely replaced by electric alternatives meaning portions of the low pressure gas distribution networks could be decommissioned.<br/>Patchwork scenarios are also possible in which there is a mixture of these outcomes across the country.<br/>In this project the CCC wished to assess the potential implications for gas networks under these different demand scenarios; and evaluate the associated challenges for Government and regulatory policy. The challenge for BEIS and Ofgem is how to regulate in a way that keeps options open while uncertainty persists about the best solution for the UK; and at the same time how best to make policy and regulatory decisions which would serve to reduce this uncertainty. Both Government and Ofgem have policy and regulatory levers that they can use – and we identify and evaluate such levers in this report.
CFD Computations of Liquid Hydrogen Releases
Sep 2011
Publication
Hydrogen is widely recognized as an attractive energy carrier due to its low-level air pollution and its high mass-related energy density. However its wide flammability range and high burning velocity present a potentially significant hazard. A significant fraction of hydrogen is stored and transported as a cryogenic liquid (liquid hydrogen or LH2) as it requires much less volume compared to gaseous hydrogen. In order to exist as a liquid H2 must be cooled to a very low temperature 20.28 K. LH2 is a common liquid fuel for rocket applications. It can also be used as the fuel storage in an internal combustion engine or fuel cell for transport applications. Models for handling liquid releases both two-phase flashing jets and pool spills have been developed in the CFD-model FLACS. The very low normal boiling point of hydrogen (20 K) leads to particular challenges as this is significantly lower than the boiling points of oxygen (90 K) and nitrogen (77 K). Therefore a release of LH2 in the atmosphere may induce partial condensation or even freezing of the oxygen and nitrogen present in the air. A pool model within the CFD software FLACS is used to compute the spreading and vaporization of the liquid hydrogen depositing on the ground where the partial condensation or freezing of the oxygen and nitrogen is also taken into account. In our computations of two-phase jets the dispersed and continuous phases are assumed to be in thermodynamic and kinematic equilibrium. Simulations with the new models are compared against selected experiments performed at the Health and Safety Laboratory (HSL).
Hydrogen in Aluminium-Coated Steels Exposed to Synthetic Seawater
Jul 2020
Publication
Thermally sprayed aluminium (TSA) coatings provide protection to offshore steel structures without the use of external cathodic protection (CP) systems. These coatings provide sacrificial protection in the same way as a galvanic anode and thus hydrogen embrittlement (HE) becomes a major concern with the use of high strength steels. The effect of TSA on the HE of steel seems to remain largely unknown. Further the location of hydrogen in TSA-coated steel has not been explored. To address the above knowledge gap API 5L X80 and AISI 4137 steel coupons with and without TSA were prepared and the amount of hydrogen present in these steels when cathodically polarised to −1.1 V (Ag/AgCl) for 30 days in synthetic seawater was determined. One set of TSA-coated specimens was left at open circuit potential (OCP). The study indicates that the amount of hydrogen present in TSA-coated steel is ~100 times more than the amount found in uncoated steel and that the hydrogen seems to be largely localised in the TSA layer.
Energy Essentials: A Guide to Hydrogen
Jan 2020
Publication
Climate change and air quality concerns have pushed clean energy up the global agenda. As we switch over to new cleaner technologies and fuels our experience of using power heat and transport are going to change transforming the way we live work and get from A to B. Explore this guide to find out what hydrogen is how it is made transported and used what the experience would be like in the home for transport and for businesses and discover what the future of hydrogen might be.
Visit the Energy Institute website for more information
Visit the Energy Institute website for more information
Modelling and Simulation of High-pressure Hydrogen Jets Using H2FC European Cyber-laboratory
Oct 2015
Publication
The Hydrogen and Fuel Cell (H2FC) European research infrastructure cyber-laboratory is a software suite containing ‘modelling’ and ‘engineering’ tools encompassing a wide range of H2FC processes and systems. One of the core aims of the H2FC Cyber-laboratory has been the creation of a state-of-the-art hydrogen CFD modelling toolbox. This paper describes the implementation and validation of this new CFD modelling toolbox in conjunction with a selection of the available ‘Safety’ engineering tools to analyse a high pressure hydrogen release and dispersion scenario. The experimental work used for this validation was undertaken by Shell and the Health and Safety Laboratory (UK). The overall goal of this work is to provide and make readily available a Cyber-laboratory that will be worth maintaining after the end of the H2FC project for the benefit of both the FCH scientific community and industry. This paper therefore highlights how the H2FC Cyber-laboratory which is offered as an open access platform can be used to replicate and analyse real-world scenarios using both numerical engineering tools and through the implementation of CFD modelling techniques.
CFD Study of the Unignited and Ignited Hydrogen Releases from TRPD Under a Fuel Cell Car
Oct 2015
Publication
This paper describes a CFD study of a scenario involving the vertical downward release of hydrogen from a thermally-activated pressure relief device (TPRD) under a fuel cell car. The volumetric source model is applied to simulate hydrogen release dynamics during the tank blowdown process. Simulations are conducted for both unignited and ignited releases from onboard storage at 35 MPa and 70 MPa with TPRD orifice 4.2 mm. Results show that after TPRD opening the hazards associated with the release of hydrogen lasts less than two minutes and the most hazardous timeframe occurs within ten seconds of the initiation of the release. The deterministic separation distances for unignited releases are longer than those for ignited releases indicating that the separation distances are dominated by delayed ignition events rather than immediate ignition events. The deterministic separation distances for both unignited and ignited hydrogen downward releases under the car are significantly shorter than those of free jets. To ensure the safety of people a deterministic separation distance of at least 10 m for 35 MPa releases is required. This distance should be increased to 12 m for the 70 MPa release case. To ensure that the concentration of hydrogen is always less than 4% at the location of the air intake of buildings the deterministic separation distance should be at least 11 m for 35 MPa releases and 13 m for 70 MPa releases.
Roadmap to Hydrogen in the NTS - National Grid Gas Transmission
Jan 2020
Publication
DNV GL believes that the National Transmission System (NTS) will be central to the future of decarbonised energy in the UK. The future NTS could transmit natural gas hydrogen blends of the two and carbon dioxide. New pipelines will be built however a large cost-saving is available if the existing NTS assets can also be re-purposed. To move towards this future National Grid Gas Transmission wants to develop a project to trial injection hydrogen into the NTS. This is an opportunity to show that National Grid is part of the solution to achieving Net Zero. The trial will demonstrate to the Government and public that re-purposing the NTS is cost-effective safe and involves minimal disruption.
This report sets out a roadmap of projects to provide the knowledge needed for the trial. The roadmap was developed by assessing the knowledge required and how much of it already existed. The knowledge already available is summarised in this report with references to where further details can be found. Gaps in the knowledge are then described. The roadmap consists of projects to conduct work to close the knowledge gaps. The results are summarised in the figures below and in the box to the right.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the ENA Smarter Networks Portal here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.
This report sets out a roadmap of projects to provide the knowledge needed for the trial. The roadmap was developed by assessing the knowledge required and how much of it already existed. The knowledge already available is summarised in this report with references to where further details can be found. Gaps in the knowledge are then described. The roadmap consists of projects to conduct work to close the knowledge gaps. The results are summarised in the figures below and in the box to the right.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the ENA Smarter Networks Portal here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.
The Interaction of Hydrogen Jet Releases With Walls and Barriers
Sep 2009
Publication
It has been suggested that separation or safety distances for pressurised hydrogen storage can be reduced by the inclusion of walls or barriers between the hydrogen storage and vulnerable plant or other items. Various NFPA codes (1) suggest the use of 60° inclined fire barriers for protection against jet flames in preference to vertical ones.<br/>This paper describes a series of experiments performed in order to compare the performance of 60° barriers with that of 90° barriers. Their relative efficiency at protecting from thermal radiation and blast overpressure was measured together with the propensity for the thermal radiation and blast overpressure to be reflected back to the source of the leak. The work was primarily focused on compressed H2 storage for stationary fuel cell systems which may be physically separated from a fuel cell system or could be on board such a system. Different orifice sizes were used to simulate different size leaks and all releases were made were from storage at 200 bar.<br/>Overall conclusions on barrier performance were made based on the recorded measurements.
The Fifth Carbon Budget: The Next Step Towards a Low-carbon Economy
Nov 2015
Publication
This report sets out our advice on the fifth carbon budget covering the period 2028-2032 as required under Section 4 of the Climate Change Act; the Government will propose draft legislation for the fifth budget in summer 2016.
Zero Emission HGV Infrastructure Requirements
May 2019
Publication
The Committee on Climate Change commissioned Ricardo Energy and Environment to carry out research to assess the infrastructure requirements and costs for the deployment of different zero emission heavy goods vehicle (HGV) technology options. The infrastructure considered includes hydrogen refuelling stations ultra-rapid charge points at strategic locations electric overhead recharging infrastructure on the roads and hybrid solutions combining these options.
The research concluded:
It is feasible to build refuelling infrastructure to support the deployment of zero emission HGVs so that they constitute the vast majority of vehicles on the roads by 2050.
Looking at infrastructure alone deploying hydrogen refuelling stations is the cheapest of the options costing a total of £1.7bn in capital expenditure in the time period from now until 2060. The strategic deployment of ultra-rapid charge points is the most expensive at £10.7bn. In all scenarios a significant number of smaller electric HGVs are deployed as these options are available and operating on the streets today. The cost of installing chargers at depots for these vehicles is included.
When the costs of the fuel as well as the infrastructure are included the costs of deploying electricity or hydrogen HGVs are cheaper compared to the continued use of diesel.
Moving to zero-carbon infrastructure for HDVs is a significant challenge and requires planning co-ordination supply chains resource and materials and a skilled workforce as well as strong government policy to enable the market to deliver.
The Report can be found here
The research concluded:
It is feasible to build refuelling infrastructure to support the deployment of zero emission HGVs so that they constitute the vast majority of vehicles on the roads by 2050.
Looking at infrastructure alone deploying hydrogen refuelling stations is the cheapest of the options costing a total of £1.7bn in capital expenditure in the time period from now until 2060. The strategic deployment of ultra-rapid charge points is the most expensive at £10.7bn. In all scenarios a significant number of smaller electric HGVs are deployed as these options are available and operating on the streets today. The cost of installing chargers at depots for these vehicles is included.
When the costs of the fuel as well as the infrastructure are included the costs of deploying electricity or hydrogen HGVs are cheaper compared to the continued use of diesel.
Moving to zero-carbon infrastructure for HDVs is a significant challenge and requires planning co-ordination supply chains resource and materials and a skilled workforce as well as strong government policy to enable the market to deliver.
The Report can be found here
SGN Aberdeen Vision Project: Final Report
May 2020
Publication
The Aberdeen Vision Project could deliver CO2 savings of 1.5MtCO2/y compared with natural gas. A dedicated pipeline from St Fergus to Aberdeen would enable the phased transfer of the Aberdeen regional gas distribution system to 20% then 100% hydrogen.
The study has demonstrated that 2% hydrogen can be injected into the National Transmission System (NTS) at St Fergus and its distribution through the system into the gas distribution network. Due to unique regional attributes the Aberdeen region could lead the UK in the conversion to largescale clean hydrogen. A 200MW hydrogen generation plant is planned to suit 2% blend into the NTS followed by a build out to supply the Aberdeen gas networks and to enable low cost hydrogen transport applications.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the ENA Smarter Networks Portal here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.
The study has demonstrated that 2% hydrogen can be injected into the National Transmission System (NTS) at St Fergus and its distribution through the system into the gas distribution network. Due to unique regional attributes the Aberdeen region could lead the UK in the conversion to largescale clean hydrogen. A 200MW hydrogen generation plant is planned to suit 2% blend into the NTS followed by a build out to supply the Aberdeen gas networks and to enable low cost hydrogen transport applications.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the ENA Smarter Networks Portal here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.
Results of the HySafe CFD Validation Benchmark SBEPV5
Sep 2007
Publication
The different CFD tools used by the NoE HySafe partners are applied to a series of integral complex Standard Benchmark Exercise Problems (SBEPs). All benchmarks cover complementarily physical phenomena addressing application relevant scenarios and refer to associated experiments with an explicit usage of hydrogen. After the blind benchmark SBEPV1 and SBEPV3 with subsonic vertical release in a large vessel and in a garage like facility SBEPV4 with a horizontal under-expanded jet release through a small nozzle SBEPV5 covers the scenario of a subsonic horizontal jet release in a multi-compartment room.<br/>As the associated dispersion experiments conducted by GEXCON Norsk Hydro and STATOIL were disclosed to the participants the whole benchmark was conducted openly. For the purpose of validation only the low momentum test D27 had to be simulated.<br/>The experimental rig consists of a 1.20 m x 0.20 m x 0.90 m (Z vertical) vessel divided into 12 compartments partially even physically by four baffle plates. In each compartment a hydrogen concentration sensor is mounted. There is one vent opening at the wall opposite the release location centrally located about 1 cm above floor with dimensions 0.10 m (Y) times 0.20 m (Z). The first upper baffle plate close to the release point is on a sensitive location as it lies nearly perfectly in the centre of the buoyant jet and thus separates the flow into the two compartments. The actual release was a nominally constant flow of 1.15 norm liters for 60 seconds. With a 12mm nozzle diameter this corresponds to an average exit velocity of 10.17 m/s.<br/>6 CFD packages have been applied by 7 HySafe partners to simulate this experiment: ADREAHF by NCSRD FLACS by GexCon and DNV KFX by DNV FLUENT by UPM and UU CFX by HSE/HSL and GASFLOW by FZK. The results of the different participants are compared against the experimental data. Sensitivity studies were conducted by FZK using GASFLOW and by DNV applying KFX.<br/>Conclusions based on the comparisons and the sensitivity studies related to the performance of the applied turbulence models and discretisation schemes in the release and diffusion phase are proposed. These are compared to the findings of the previous benchmark exercises.
Ignition Energy and Ignition Probability of Methane-Hydrogen-Air Mixtures
Sep 2009
Publication
The European Commission are funding an investigation of the feasibility of using existing natural gas infrastructures to transport and distribute hydrogen as a mixture of natural gas and hydrogen from the point of hydrogen production to the point of use. Since hydrogen has different chemical and physical properties to that of natural gas and these will affect the integrity and durability of the pipeline network and the ignition and combustion behaviour of released gas it is necessary to assess the change in risk to the public that would result. The subject of this paper is an experimental study of the effect of the hydrogen content of the natural gas-hydrogen mixture on the minimum energy required for ignition and the probability of achieving ignition given a particular level of energy discharge. It was possible to normalize the results for ignition energy such that given information on the minimum ignition energy and the equivalence ratio at which the minimum ignition energy occurs the lowest ignition energy for any other equivalence ratio can be predicted. The results also showed that the ignition process has a probabilistic element and that the probability of ignition is related to the equivalence ratio and the energy level of the source. It was observed that the probability of ignition increased with increasing energy of the source and that the rate of rise in probability was steepest for the equivalence ratios close to the equivalence ratio at which the minimum ignition energy occurs.
Hy4Heat Hydrogen Odorant - Work Package 2
Nov 2020
Publication
This work programme was focused on identifying a suitable odorant for use in a 100% hydrogen gas grid (domestic use such as boilers and cookers). The research involved a review of existing odorants (used primarily for natural gas) and the selection of five suitable odorants based on available literature. One odorant was selected based on possible suitability with a Polymer Electrolyte Membrane (PEM) based fuel cell vehicle which could in future be a possible end-user of grid hydrogen. NPL prepared Primary Reference Materials containing the five odorants in hydrogen at the relevant amount fraction levels (as would be found in the grid) including ones provided by Robinson Brothers (the supplier of odorants for natural gas in the UK). These mixtures were used by NPL to perform tests to understand the effects of the mixtures on pipeline (metal and plastic) appliances (a hydrogen boiler provided by Worcester Bosch) and PEM fuel cells. HSE investigated the health and environmental impact of these odorants in hydrogen. Olfactory testing was performed by Air Spectrum to characterise the ‘smell’ of each odorant. Finally an economic analysis was performed by E4tech. The results confirm that Odorant NB would be a suitable odorant for use in a 100% hydrogen gas grid for combustion applications but further research would be required if the intention is to supply grid hydrogen to stationery fuel cells or fuel cell vehicles. In this case further testing would need to be performed to measure the extent of fuel cell degradation caused by the non-sulphur odorant obtained as part of this work programme and also other UK projects such as the Hydrogen Grid to Vehicle (HG2V) project[1] would provide important information about whether a purification step would be required regardless of the odorant before the hydrogen purity would be suitable for a PEM fuel cell vehicle. If purification was required it would be fine to use Odorant NB as this would be removed during the purification step.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the Hy4Heat website here. The report can also be downloaded directly by clicking on the pdf icon above
This report and any attachment is freely available on the Hy4Heat website here. The report can also be downloaded directly by clicking on the pdf icon above
Hy4Heat Conversion of Industrial Heating Equipment to Hydrogen - Work Package 6
Jan 2020
Publication
The study focuses on converting current industrial natural gas heating technologies to use 100% hydrogen considering the evidence which must be available before a decision on the UK’s decarbonisation pathway for heating could be made. The aim of the study is to assess the technical requirements and challenges associated with industrial hydrogen conversion and estimate the associated costs and timeframes.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the Hy4Heat website here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the Hy4Heat website here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.
Numerical Studies of Dispersion and Flammable Volume of Hydrogen in Enclosures
Sep 2007
Publication
Hydrogen dispersion in an enclosure is numerically studied using simple analytical solutions and a large-eddy-simulation based CFD code. In simple calculations the interface height and temperature rise of the upper layer are obtained based on mass and energy conservation and the centreline hydrogen volume fraction is derived from similarity solutions of buoyant jets. The calculated centreline hydrogen volume fraction using the two methods agree with each other; however discrepancies are found for the calculated total flammable volume as a result of the inability of simple calculations in taking into account local mixing and diffusion. The CFD model in contrast is found to be capable of correctly reproducing the diffusion and stratification phenomena during the mixing stage.
Hydrogen-air Deflagrations in Open Atmosphere- Large Eddy Simulation Analysis of Experimental Data
Sep 2005
Publication
The largest known experiment on hydrogen-air deflagration in the open atmosphere has been analysed by means of the large eddy simulation (LES). The combustion model is based on the progress variable equation to simulate a premixed flame front propagation and the gradient method to decouple the physical combustion rate from numerical peculiarities. The hydrodynamic instability has been partially resolved by LES and unresolved effects have been modelled by Yakhot's turbulent premixed combustion model. The main contributor to high flame propagation velocity is the additional turbulence generated by the flame front itself. It has been modelled based on the maximum flame wrinkling factor predicted by Karlovitz et al. theory and the transitional distance reported by Gostintsev with colleagues. Simulations are in a good agreement with experimental data on flame propagation dynamics flame shape and outgoing pressure wave peaks and structure. The model is built from the first principles and no adjustable parameters were applied to get agreement with the experiment.
Hydrogen Impact on Gas Engine CHP - Cadent Ltd
Feb 2019
Publication
The key project objectives include:
The output from this project will also inform the HyDeploy NIC project in relation to potential hydrogen content limits. The project will be presented at the IGEM Gas Quality Working Group (IGEM GQWG).
This report and any attachment is freely available on the ENA Smarter Networks Portal here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.
- Understand the range size type mode of operation and control system of installed gas engines in the UK. This will include equipment for CHP and for stand-by power operation.
- Produce data sets on the impact of hydrogen on gas engine operational performance.
- Develop knowledge on the impact of hydrogen content on the operation of the gas engine including overall efficiency changes to emissions profiles overall system operability.
- Providing outline guidance on a potential hydrogen limit that should be considered regarding use of natural gas/hydrogen mixed fuels in gas engines.
- Outlining a high-level view on the reliability and impact on maintenance and replacement regimes if gas engines operate on natural gas/hydrogen mixed fuels for extended time periods.
- Highlight any existing barriers to use of natural gas and hydrogen blends in gas engine and through contact with OEMs develop an understanding of future technology developments that may be needed to enable the use of “high” hydrogen blends.
The output from this project will also inform the HyDeploy NIC project in relation to potential hydrogen content limits. The project will be presented at the IGEM Gas Quality Working Group (IGEM GQWG).
This report and any attachment is freely available on the ENA Smarter Networks Portal here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.
An Intercomparison Exercise on the Capabilities of CFD Models to Predict Distribution and Mixing of H2 in a Closed Vessel.
Sep 2005
Publication
This paper presents a compilation and discussion of the results supplied by HySafe partners participating in the Standard Benchmark Exercise Problem (SBEP) V1 which is based on an experiment on hydrogen release mixing and distribution inside a vessel. Each partner has his own point of view of the problem and uses a different approach to the solution. The main characteristics of the models employed for the calculations are compared. The comparison between results together with the experimental data when available is made. Relative deviations of each model from the experimental values are also included. Explanations and interpretations of the results are presented together with some useful conclusions for future work.
Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Technologies for Heating: A Review
Jan 2015
Publication
The debate on low-carbon heat in Europe has become focused on a narrow range of technological options and has largely neglected hydrogen and fuel cell technologies despite these receiving strong support towards commercialisation in Asia. This review examines the potential benefits of these technologies across different markets particularly the current state of development and performance of fuel cell micro-CHP. Fuel cells offer some important benefits over other low-carbon heating technologies and steady cost reductions through innovation are bringing fuel cells close to commercialisation in several countries. Moreover fuel cells offer wider energy system benefits for high-latitude countries with peak electricity demands in winter. Hydrogen is a zero-carbon alternative to natural gas which could be particularly valuable for those countries with extensive natural gas distribution networks but many national energy system models examine neither hydrogen nor fuel cells for heating. There is a need to include hydrogen and fuel cell heating technologies in future scenario analyses and for policymakers to take into account the full value of the potential contribution of hydrogen and fuel cells to low-carbon energy systems.
Health & Safety Laboratory - Gas Detection for Hydrogen Enriched Gas Distribution Networks
Jul 2019
Publication
The UK has committed to significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 2050 to help address climate change. Decarbonising heating is a key part of this and using hydrogen (H2) as a replacement to natural gas (NG) can help in achieving this. The objective of current research including HyDeploy is to demonstrate that NG containing levels of H2 beyond those currently allowed of 0.1 vol% (1000 ppm) [1] can be distributed and utilised safely and efficiently. Initial projects such as HyDeploy are studying the effects of introducing up to 20 vol% H2 in NG but later projects are considering using up to 100 vol% H2.
A key element in the safe operation of a modern gas distribution system is gas detection. However the addition of hydrogen to NG will alter the characteristics of the gas and the impact on gas detection must be considered. It is important that sensors remain sufficiently sensitive to the presence of hydrogen natural gas carbon monoxide (CO) and oxygen (O2) deficiency and that they don’t lead to false positive or false negative readings. The aim of this document is to provide a summary of the requirements for gas detection of hydrogen enriched natural gas for the gas distribution industry and other potentially interested parties. As such it is based on gas detectors presently used by the industry with the only major differences being the effects of hydrogen on the sensitivity of flammable gas sensors and the cross sensitivity of carbon monoxide gas sensors to hydrogen.
There is further information of gas detector concepts and technologies in the appendices.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the ENA Smarter Networks Portal here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.
A key element in the safe operation of a modern gas distribution system is gas detection. However the addition of hydrogen to NG will alter the characteristics of the gas and the impact on gas detection must be considered. It is important that sensors remain sufficiently sensitive to the presence of hydrogen natural gas carbon monoxide (CO) and oxygen (O2) deficiency and that they don’t lead to false positive or false negative readings. The aim of this document is to provide a summary of the requirements for gas detection of hydrogen enriched natural gas for the gas distribution industry and other potentially interested parties. As such it is based on gas detectors presently used by the industry with the only major differences being the effects of hydrogen on the sensitivity of flammable gas sensors and the cross sensitivity of carbon monoxide gas sensors to hydrogen.
There is further information of gas detector concepts and technologies in the appendices.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the ENA Smarter Networks Portal here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.
Hy4Heat Understanding Commercial Appliances - Work Package 5
Nov 2020
Publication
The 'Hydrogen for Heat' (Hy4Heat) programme aims to support the UK Government in its ambitions to decarbonise the UK energy sector in line with the targets of the Climate Change Act 2008 by attempting to evaluate and de-risk the natural gas to hydrogen network conversion option. The impact on the commercial sector is an important factor in understanding the feasibility of utilising hydrogen to decarbonise heat in the UK. The overall objective of the market research study Work Package 5 (WP5) was to determine if it is theoretically possible to successfully convert the commercial sector to hydrogen. This work will contribute to the understanding of the scale type and capacity of gas heating appliances within the sector providing a characterisation of the market and determining the requirements and feasibility for successfully transitioning them to hydrogen in the future.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the Hy4Heat website here. The report can also be downloaded directly by clicking on the pdf icon above
This report and any attachment is freely available on the Hy4Heat website here. The report can also be downloaded directly by clicking on the pdf icon above
The Journey to Smarter Heat
Mar 2019
Publication
As the UK’s largest emitter of greenhouse gases the supply of domestic industrial and commercial heat must be decarbonised if the UK is to meet its climate change targets.<br/><br/>This report publishes the outcomes from Phase 1 of the Energy Technologies Institute’s Smart Systems and Heat programme highlighting that for the UK to transition to a low carbon heating system it must understand consumer needs and behaviours while connecting this with the development and integration of technologies and new business models.<br/><br/>Written by the ETI with support from the Energy Systems Catapult this report tackles three interconnected areas: heating needs and controls within the home; heating infrastructure and building retrofit at a local level; and the operation and governance of the whole system.<br/><br/>The research also shows that as part of a low carbon heating system upgrade advanced controls are critical to performance sizing and operating costs enabling smaller appliances and lower peak electricity demands and maximising the efficiency of existing infrastructure. With significant fabric retrofits potentially required in around 10 million of the existing 28 million dwellings in the UK housing stock the report recommends that building new homes to be both very efficient and “low carbon ready” is a low regret decision which should be progressed with some urgency.
Hydrogen Safety- From Policies to Plans to Practices
Sep 2005
Publication
Safety is an essential element for realizing the “hydrogen economy” – safe operation in all of its aspects from hydrogen production through storage distribution and use; from research development and demonstration to commercialization. As such safety is given paramount importance in all facets of the research development and demonstration of the U.S Department of Energy’s (DOE) Hydrogen Fuel Cells and Infrastructure Technologies (HFCIT) Program Office. The diversity of the DOE project portfolio is self-evident. Projects are performed by large companies small businesses DOE National Laboratories academic institutions and numerous partnerships involving the same. Projects range from research exploring advances in novel hydrogen storage materials to demonstrations of hydrogen refuelling stations and vehicles. Recognizing the nature of its program and the importance of safety planning DOE has undertaken a number of initiatives to encourage and shape safety awareness. The DOE Hydrogen Safety Review Panel was formed to bring a broad cross-section of expertise from the industrial government and academic sectors to help ensure the success of the program as a whole. The Panel provides guidance on safety-related issues and needs reviews individual DOE-supported projects and their safety plans and explores ways to bring learnings to broadly benefit the DOE program. This paper explores the approaches used for providing safety planning guidance to contractors in the context of their own (and varied) policies procedures and practices. The essential elements that should be included in safety plans are described as well as the process for reviewing project safety plans. Discussion of safety planning during the conduct of safety review site visits is also shared. Safety planning-related learnings gathered from project safety reviews and the Panel’s experience in reviewing safety plans are discussed.
Advanced Steam Reforming of Bio-Oil with Carbon Capture: A Techno-Economic and CO2 Emissions Analysis
Apr 2022
Publication
A techno-economic analysis has been used to evaluate three processes for hydrogen production from advanced steam reforming (SR) of bio-oil as an alternative route to hydrogen with BECCS: conventional steam reforming (C-SR) C-SR with CO2 capture (C-SR-CCS) and sorption-enhanced chemical looping (SE-CLSR). The impacts of feed molar steam to carbon ratio (S/C) temperature pressure the use of hydrodesulphurisation pretreatment and plant production capacity were examined in an economic evaluation and direct CO2 emissions analysis. Bio-oil C-SR-CC or SE-CLSR may be feasible routes to hydrogen production with potential to provide negative emissions. SE-CLSR can improve process thermal efficiency compared to C-SR-CCS. At the feed molar steam to carbon ratio (S/C) of 2 the levelised cost of hydrogen (USD 3.8 to 4.6 per kg) and cost of carbon avoided are less than those of a C-SR process with amine-based CCS. However at higher S/C ratios SE-CLSR does not have a strong economic advantage and there is a need to better understand the viability of operating SE-CLSR of bio-oil at high temperatures (>850 ◦C) with a low S/C ratio (e.g. 2) and whether the SE-CLSR cycle can sustain low carbon deposition levels over a long operating period.
Predicting the Probability of Failure of Gas Pipelines Including Inspection and Repair Procedures
Sep 2007
Publication
This paper is concerned with predicting the impact on the probability of failure of adding hydrogen to the natural gas distribution network. Hydrogen has been demonstrated to change the behaviour of crack like defects which may affect the safety of pipeline or make it more expensive to operate. A tool has been developed based on a stochastic approach to assess the failure probability of the gas pipeline due to the existence of crack-lie defects including the operational aspects of the pipeline such as inspection and repair procedures. With various parameters such as crack sizes material properties internal pressure modelled as uncertainties a reliability analysis based on failure assessment diagram is performed through direct Monte Carlo simulation. Inspection and repair procedures are included in the simulation to enable realistic pipeline maintenance scenarios to be simulated. In the data preparation process the accuracy of the probabilistic definition of the uncertainties is crucial as the results are very sensitive to certain variables such as the crack depth length and crack growth rate. The failure probabilities of each defect and the whole pipeline system can be obtained during simulation. Different inspection and repair criteria are available in the Monte Carlo simulation whereby an optimal maintenance strategy can be obtained by comparing different combinations of inspection and repair procedures. The simulation provides not only data on the probability of failure but also the predicted number of repairs required over the pipeline life thus providing data suitable for economic models of the pipeline management. This tool can be also used to satisfy certain target reliability requirement. An example is presented comparing a natural gas pipeline with a pipeline containing hydrogen.
Reducing Emissions in Scotland – 2016 Progress Report
Sep 2016
Publication
This is the Committee’s fifth report on Scotland’s progress towards meeting emission reduction targets as requested by Scottish Ministers under the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009.<br/>The Scottish Act sets a long-term target to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases (GHGs) by at least 80% in 2050 relative to 1990 with an interim target to reduce emissions by 42% in 2020. Secondary legislation passed in October 2010 and October 2011 also set a series of annual emission reduction targets for 2010 to 2022 and 2023 to 2027 respectively. We advised the Scottish Government on annual targets for the period 2028 to 2032 in March 2016 and July 2016.<br/>The report reveals that Scotland’s annual emissions reduction target for 2014 was met with gross Scottish greenhouse gas emissions including international aviation and shipping falling by 8.6% in 2014. This compares to a 7.3% fall for the UK as a whole. Since 1990 gross Scottish emissions have fallen nearly 40% compared to nearly 33% at a UK level.
Meeting Carbon Budgets – Ensuring a Low-carbon Recovery
Jun 2010
Publication
As part of its statutory role the Committee provides annual reports to Parliament on the progress that Government is making in meeting carbon budgets and in reducing emissions of greenhouse gases.<br/>Meeting Carbon Budgets – ensuring a low-carbon recovery is the Committee’s 2nd progress report. Within this report we assess the latest emissions data and determine whether emissions reductions have occurred as a result of the recession or as a result of other external factors. We assess Government’s progress towards achieving emissions reductions in 4 key areas of: Power Buildings and Industry Transport and Agriculture.
An Intercomparison Exercise on the Capabilities of CFD Models to Predict Deflagration of a Large-Scale H2-Air Mixture in Open Atmosphere
Sep 2005
Publication
This paper presents a compilation of the results supplied by HySafe partners participating in the Standard Benchmark Exercise Problem (SBEP) V2 which is based on an experiment on hydrogen combustion that is first described. A list of the results requested from participants is also included. The main characteristics of the models used for the calculations are compared in a very succinct way by using tables. The comparison between results together with the experimental data when available is made through a series of graphs. The results show quite good agreement with the experimental data. The calculations have demonstrated to be sensitive to computational domain size and far field boundary condition.
2050 Energy Scenarios: The UK Gas Networks Role in a 2050 Whole Energy System
Jul 2016
Publication
Energy used for heat accounts (in terms of final consumption) for approximately 45% of our total energy needs and is critical for families to heat their homes on winter days. Decarbonising heat while still meeting peak winter heating demands is recognised as a big perhaps the biggest challenge for the industry. The way heat has been delivered in the UK has not fundamentally changed for decades and huge investments have been made in gas infrastructure assets ranging from import terminals to networks through to the appliances in our homes. Changing how heat is delivered whichever way is chosen will be a major economic and practical challenge affecting families and businesses everywhere. Any plan to decarbonise will need to address power and transport alongside heat. Our report has also looked at potential decarbonisation of power and transport as part of a whole energy system approach.
In this report we explore ways that the heat sector can be decarbonised by looking at four possible future scenarios set in 2050. These stylised scenarios present illustrative snapshots of alternative energy solutions. The scenarios do not present a detailed roadmap – indeed the future may include some elements from each. We have analysed the advantages disadvantages and costs of each scenario. All our scenarios meet the 2050 Carbon emissions targets. In this report we have concentrated on reductions to CO2 emissions and we have not considered other greenhouse gases.
In this report we explore ways that the heat sector can be decarbonised by looking at four possible future scenarios set in 2050. These stylised scenarios present illustrative snapshots of alternative energy solutions. The scenarios do not present a detailed roadmap – indeed the future may include some elements from each. We have analysed the advantages disadvantages and costs of each scenario. All our scenarios meet the 2050 Carbon emissions targets. In this report we have concentrated on reductions to CO2 emissions and we have not considered other greenhouse gases.
HyDeploy Gas Safe Webinar
Nov 2020
Publication
HyDeploy is a pioneering hydrogen energy project designed to help reduce UK CO2 emissions and reach the Government’s net zero target for 2050.
As the first ever live demonstration of hydrogen in homes HyDeploy aims to prove that blending up to 20% volume of hydrogen with natural gas is a safe and greener alternative to the gas we use now. It is providing evidence on how customers don’t have to change their cooking or heating appliances to take the blend which means less disruption and cost for them.
As the first ever live demonstration of hydrogen in homes HyDeploy aims to prove that blending up to 20% volume of hydrogen with natural gas is a safe and greener alternative to the gas we use now. It is providing evidence on how customers don’t have to change their cooking or heating appliances to take the blend which means less disruption and cost for them.
Spontaneous Ignition of Hydrogen Leaks, a Review of Postulated Mechanisms
Sep 2005
Publication
Over the last century there have been reports of high pressure hydrogen leaks igniting for no apparent reason and several ignition mechanisms have been proposed. Although many leaks have ignited there are also reported leaks where no ignition has occurred. Investigations of ignitions where no apparent ignition source was present have often been superficial with a mechanism postulated which whilst appearing to satisfy the conditions prevailing at the time of the release simply does not stand up to rigorous scientific analysis. Some of these proposed mechanisms have been simulated in a laboratory under superficially identical conditions and appear to be rigorous and scientific but the simulated conditions often do not have the same large release rates or quantities mainly because of physical constraints of a laboratory. Also some of the release scenarios carried out or simulated in laboratories are totally divorced from the realistic situation of most actual leaks. Clearly there are gaps in the knowledge of the exact ignition mechanism for releases of hydrogen particularly at the high pressures likely to be involved in future storage and use. Mechanisms which have been proposed in the past are the reverse Joule-Thomson effect; electrostatic charge generation; diffusion ignition; sudden adiabatic compression; and hot surface ignition. Of these some have been characterized by means of computer simulation rather than by actual experiment and hence are not validated. Consequently there are discrepancies between the theories releases known to have ignited and releases which are known to have not ignited. From this postulated ignition mechanisms which are worthy of further study have been identified and the gaps in information have been highlighted. As a result the direction for future research into the potential for ignition of hydrogen escapes has been identified.
An Inter-Comparison Exercise on the Capabilities of CFD Models to Predict the Short and Long Term Distribution and Mixing of Hydrogen in a Garage
Sep 2007
Publication
Alexandros G. Venetsanos,
E. Papanikolaou,
J. García,
Olav Roald Hansen,
Matthias Heitsch,
Asmund Huser,
Wilfried Jahn,
Jean-Marc Lacome,
Thomas Jordan,
H. S. Ledin,
Dmitry Makarov,
Prankul Middha,
Etienne Studer,
Andrei V. Tchouvelev,
Franck Verbecke,
M. M. Voort,
Andrzej Teodorczyk and
M. A. Delichatsios
The paper presents the results of the CFD inter-comparison exercise SBEP-V3 performed within the activity InsHyde internal project of the HYSAFE network of excellence in the framework of evaluating the capability of various CFD tools and modelling approaches in predicting the physical phenomena associated to the short and long term mixing and distribution of hydrogen releases in confined spaces. The experiment simulated was INERIS-TEST-6C performed within the InsHyde project by INERIS consisting of a 1 g/s vertical hydrogen release for 240 s from an orifice of 20 mm diameter into a rectangular room (garage) of dimensions 3.78x7.2x2.88 m in width length and height respectively. Two small openings at the front and bottom side of the room assured constant pressure conditions. During the test hydrogen concentration time histories were measured at 12 positions in the room for a period up to 5160 s after the end of release covering both the release and the subsequent diffusion phases. The benchmark was organized in two phases. The first phase consisted of blind simulations performed prior to the execution of the tests. The second phase consisted of post calculations performed after the tests were concluded and the experimental results made available. The participation in the benchmark was high: 12 different organizations (2 non-HYSAFE partners) 10 different CFD codes and 8 different turbulence models. Large variation in predicted results was found in the first phase of the benchmark between the various modelling approaches. This was attributed mainly to differences in turbulence models and numerical accuracy options (time/space resolution and discretization schemes). During the second phase of the benchmark the variation between predicted results was reduced.
UK Climate Action Following the Paris Agreement
Oct 2016
Publication
The Paris Agreement marks a significant positive step in global action to tackle climate change. This report considers the domestic actions the UK Government should take as part of a fair contribution to the aims of the Agreement.<br/>The report concludes that the Paris Agreement is a significant step forward in global efforts to tackle climate change. It is more ambitious in its aims to limit climate change than the basis of the UK’s existing climate targets. However it is not yet appropriate to set new UK targets. Existing targets are already stretching and the priority is to take action to meet them.
Pathways to Net-Zero: Decarbonising the Gas Networks in Great Britain
Oct 2019
Publication
Natural gas plays a central role in the UK energy system today but it is also a significant source of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. The UK committed in 2008 to reduce GHG emissions by at least 80% compared to 1990 levels by 2050. In June 2019 a more ambitious target was adopted into law and the UK became the first major economy to commit to “net-zero” emissions by 2050. In this context the Energy Networks Association (ENA) commissioned Navigant to explore the role that the gas sector can play in the decarbonisation of the Great Britain (GB) energy system. In this report we demonstrate that low carbon and renewable gases can make a fundamental contribution to the decarbonisation pathway between now and 2050.
The Techno-economics Potential of Hydrogen Interconnectors for Electrical Energy Transmission and Storage
Dec 2021
Publication
This research introduces a ‘Hydrogen Interconnector System’ (HIS) as a novel method 7 for transporting electrical energy over long distances. The system takes electricity from 8 stranded renewable energy assets converts it to hydrogen in an electrolyser plant transports 9 hydrogen to the demand centre via pipeline where it is reconverted to electricity in either a 10 gas turbine or fuel cell plant. This paper evaluates the competitiveness of the technology with 11 High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) systems calculating the following techno-economic 12 indicators; Levelised Cost Of Electricity (LCOE) and Levelised Cost Of Storage (LCOS). The 13 results suggest that the LCOE of the HIS is competitive with HVDC for construction in 2050 14 with distance beyond 350km in case of all scenarios for a 1GW system. The LCOS is lower 15 than an HVDC system using large scale hydrogen storage in 6 out of 12 scenarios analysed 16 including for construction from 2025. The HIS was also applied to three case studies with 17 the results showing that the system outperforms HVDC from LCOS perspectives in all cases 18 and has 15-20% lower investment costs in 2 studies analysed.
Effect of Carbon Dioxide, Argon and Hydrocarbon Fuels on the Stability of Hydrogen Jet Flames
Sep 2005
Publication
Experimental studies were carried out to examine the lift-off and blow-out stability of H2/CO2 H2/Ar H2/C3H8 and H2/CH4 jet flames. The experiments were carried out using a burner with a 2mm inner diameter. The flame structures were recorded by direct filming and also by a schlieren apparatus. The experiments showed that the four gases affected the lift-off and blow-out stability of the hydrogen differently. The experiments showed that propane addition to an initially attached flame always produced lifted flame and the flame was blown out at higher jet velocity. The blow-out velocity decreased as the increasing in propane concentration. Direct blow-off of hydrogen/propane was never observed. Methane addition resulted in a relatively stable flame comparing with the carbon dioxide and propane addition. Comparisons of the stability of H2/C3H8 H2/CH4 and H2/CO2 flames showed that H2/C3H8 produced the highest lift-off height. Propane is much more effective in lift-off and blow out hydrogen flames. The study carried out a chemical kinetic analysis of H2/CO2 H2/Ar H2/C3H8 and H2/CH4 flames for a comparison of effect of chemical kinetics on flame stability.
Gas Future Scenarios Project- Final Report: A Report on a Study for the Energy Networks Association Gas Futures Group
Nov 2010
Publication
When looking out to 2050 there is huge uncertainty surrounding how gas will be consumed transported and sourced in Great Britain (GB). The extent of the climate change challenge is now widely accepted and the UK Government has introduced a legislative requirement for aggressive reductions in carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions out to 2050. In addition at European Union (EU) level a package of measures has been implemented to reduce greenhouse gas emissions improve energy efficiency and significantly increase the share of energy produced from renewable sources by 2020. These policy developments naturally raise the question of what role gas has to play in the future energy mix.
To help inform this debate the Energy Networks Association Gas Futures Group (ENA GFG) commissioned Redpoint and Trilemma to undertake a long-range scenario-based modelling study of the future utilisation of gas out to 2050 and the consequential impacts of this for gas networks. Our modelling assumptions draw heavily on the Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC) 2050 Pathways analysis and we consider that our conclusions are fully compatible with both DECC‟s work and current EU policy objectives.
Link to document
To help inform this debate the Energy Networks Association Gas Futures Group (ENA GFG) commissioned Redpoint and Trilemma to undertake a long-range scenario-based modelling study of the future utilisation of gas out to 2050 and the consequential impacts of this for gas networks. Our modelling assumptions draw heavily on the Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC) 2050 Pathways analysis and we consider that our conclusions are fully compatible with both DECC‟s work and current EU policy objectives.
Link to document
Net Zero – Technical Report
May 2019
Publication
This technical report accompanies the ‘Net Zero’ advice report which is the Committee’s recommendation to the UK Government and Devolved Administrations on the date for a net-zero emissions target in the UK and revised long-term targets in Scotland and Wales.<br/>The conclusions in our advice report are supported by detailed analysis that has been carried out for each sector of the economy plus consideration of F-gas emissions and greenhouse gas removals. The purpose of this technical report is to lay out that analysis.
H21- Science and Research Centre - HSE Buxton Launch Video
Aug 2019
Publication
The site at the Health and Safety Executive’s Science and Research Centre in Buxton will carry out controlled tests to establish the critical safety evidence proving that a 100% hydrogen gas network is equally as safe as the natural gas grid heating our homes and businesses today. The results will be critical in determining if it is safe to convert millions of homes across the country from natural gas to hydrogen. H21 which is led by Northern Gas Networks (NGN) the gas distributor for the North of England in partnership with Cadent SGN and Wales & West Utilities HSE Science and Research Centre and DNV-GL is part of a number of gas industry projects designed to support conversion of the UK gas networks to carry 100% hydrogen. Currently about 30% of UK carbon emissions are from the heating of homes businesses and industry. H21 states that a large-scale conversion of the gas grid from natural gas to hydrogen is vital to meeting the Government’s Net Zero targets.
State-of-the-Art and Research Priorities in Hydrogen Safety
Sep 2013
Publication
On October 16-17 2012 the International Association for Hydrogen Safety (HySafe) in cooperation with the Institute for Energy and Transport of the Joint Research Centre of the European Commission (JRC IET Petten) held a two-day workshop dedicated to Hydrogen Safety Research Priorities. The workshop was hosted by Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing (BAM) in Berlin Germany. The main idea of the Workshop was to bring together stakeholders who can address the existing knowledge gaps in the area of the hydrogen safety including identification and prioritization of such gaps from the standpoint of scientific knowledge both experimental and theoretical including numerical. The experience highlighting these gaps which was obtained during both practical applications (industry) and risk assessment should serve as reference point for further analysis. The program included two sections: knowledge gaps as they are addressed by industry and knowledge gaps and state-of-the-art by research. In the current work the main results of the workshop are summarized and analysed.
Hydrogen: A Critical Part of Heat Decarbonisation
Feb 2021
Publication
The use of clean hydrogen is likely to form a key part of a net-zero emissions future and has the potential to replace natural gas for end use heating. As part of BDR Thermea Group Baxi Heating UK are at the forefront of hydrogen boiler development. Working with the Hy4Heat programme hydrogen fuelled boilers have been produced for inclusion in trial sites across the UK. This presentation will explore progress to date together with the hydrogen-ready boiler concept.
Numerical Study of Spontaneous Ignition in Pressurized Hydrogen Release Through a Length of Tube with Local Contraction
Sep 2011
Publication
Numerical investigations have been conducted on the effect of the internal geometry of a local contraction on the spontaneous ignition of pressurized hydrogen release through a length of tube using a 5th-order WENO scheme. A mixture-averaged multi-component approach was used for accurate calculation of molecular transport. The auto-ignition and combustion chemistry were accounted for using a 21-step kinetic scheme. It is found that a local contraction can significantly facilitate the occurrence of spontaneous ignition by producing elevated flammable mixture and enhancing turbulent mixing from shock formation reflection and interaction. The first ignition kernel is observed upstream the contraction. It then quickly propagates along the contact interface and transits to a partially premixed flame due to the enhanced turbulent mixing. The partially premixed flames are highly distorted and overlapped with each other. Flame thickening is observed which is due to the merge of thin flames. The numerical predictions suggested that sustained flames could develop for release pressure as low as 25 bar. For the release pressure of 18 bar spontaneous ignition was predicted but the flame was soon quenched. To some extent this finding is consistent with Dryer et al.'s experimental observation in that the minimum release pressure required to induce a spontaneous ignition for the release through a tube with internal geometries is only 20.4 bar.
A Turbulent Combustion Model for Ignition of Rapidly Expanding Hydrogen Jets
Mar 2013
Publication
A turbulent combustion model based on the Linear Eddy Model for Large Eddy Simulation (LEM- LES) is currently proposed to study self-ignition events of rapidly expanding hydrogen jets. The model is a one-dimensional treatment of a diffusion-reaction system within each multi-dimensional LES cell. This reduces the expense of solving a complete multi-dimensional problem while preserving micro-scale hotspots and their effects on ignition. The current approach features a Lagrangian description of fluid particles on the sub-grid for increased accuracy. Also Adaptive Mesh Refinement (AMR) is implemented for increased computational efficiency. In this paper the model is validated for various inviscid laminar 1-D mixing and ignition problems shock tube problems flames and detonations.
Cyclic Voltammetry of a Cobaloxime Catalyst
Jul 2019
Publication
<br/>Cyclic Voltammetry Measurements performed on a Cobaloxime Catalyst designed for photochemical hydrogen production.
Industrial Decarbonisation Strategy
Mar 2021
Publication
The UK is a world leader in the fight against climate change. In 2019 we became the first major economy in the world to pass laws to end its contribution to global warming by 2050. Reaching this target will require extensive systematic change across all sectors including industry. We must get this change right as the products made by industry are vital to life in the UK and the sector supports local economies across the country.<br/><br/>This strategy covers the full range of UK industry sectors: metals and minerals chemicals food and drink paper and pulp ceramics glass oil refineries and less energy-intensive manufacturing. These businesses account for around one sixth of UK emissions and transformation of their manufacturing processes is key if we are to meet our emissions targets over the coming decades (BEIS Final UK greenhouse gas emissions from national statistics: 1990 to 2018: Supplementary tables 2020).<br/><br/>The aim of this strategy is to show how the UK can have a thriving industrial sector aligned with the net zero target without pushing emissions and business abroad and how government will act to support this. An indicative roadmap to net zero for UK industry based on the content in this strategy is set out at the end of this summary. This strategy is part of a series of publications from government which combined show how the net zero transition will take place across the whole UK economy.
The Sixth Carbon Budget: The UK's Path to Net Zero
Dec 2020
Publication
The Sixth Carbon Budget report is based on an extensive programme of analysis consultation and consideration by the Committee and its staff building on the evidence published last year for our Net Zero advice. In support of the advice in this report we have also produced:
- A Methodology Report setting out the evidence and methodology behind the scenarios.
- A Policy Report setting out the changes to policy that could drive the changes necessary particularly over the 2020s.
- All the charts and data behind the report as well as a separate dataset for the Sixth Carbon Budget scenarios which sets out more details and data on the pathways than can be included in this report.
- A public Call for Evidence several new research projects three expert advisory groups and deep dives into the roles of local authorities and businesses.
Socio-economic Analysis and Quantitative Risk Assessment Methodology for Safety Design of Onboard Storage Systems
Sep 2017
Publication
Catastrophic rupture of onboard hydrogen storage in a fire is a safety concern. Different passive e.g. fireproofing materials the thermally activated pressure relief device (TPRD) and active e.g. initiation of TPRD by fire sensors safety systems are being developed to reduce hazards from and associated risks of high-pressure hydrogen storage tank rupture in a fire. The probability of such low-frequency highconsequences event is a function of fire resistance rating (FRR) i.e. the time before tank without TPRD ruptures in a fire the probability of TPRD failure etc. This safety issue is “confirmed” by observed recently cases of CNG tanks rupture due to blocked or failed to operate TPRD etc. The increase of FRR by any means decreases the probability of tank rupture in a fire particularly because of fire extinction by first responders on arrival at an accident scene.<br/>This study of socio-economic effects of safety applies a quantitative risk assessment (QRA) methodology to an example of hydrogen vehicles with passive tank protection system on roads in London.<br/>The risk is defined here through the cost of human loss per fuel cell hydrogen vehicle (FCHV) fire accident and fatality rate per FCHV per year. The first step in the methodology is the consequence analysis based on validated deterministic engineering tools to estimate the main identified hazards: overpressure in the blast wave at different distances and the thermal hazards from a fireball in the case of catastrophic tank rupture in a fire. The population can be exposed to slight injury serious injury and fatality after an accident. These effects are determined based on criteria by Health and Safety Executive (UK) and a cost metrics is applied to the number of exposed people in these three harm categories to estimate the cost per an accident. The second step in the methodology is either the frequency or the probability analysis. Probabilities of a vehicle fire and failure of the thermally activated pressure relief device are taken from published sources. A vulnerability probit function is employed to calculate the probability of emergency operations’ failure to prevent tank rupture as a function of a storage tank FRR and time of fire brigade arrival. These later results are integrated to estimate the tank rupture frequency and fatality rate. The risk is presented as a function of fire resistance rating.<br/>The QRA methodology allows to calculate the cost of human loss associated with an FCHV fire accident and demonstrates how the increase of FRR of onboard storage as a safety engineering measure would improve socio-economics of FCHV deployment and public acceptance of the technology.
What Role for Hydrogen in Turkey’s Energy Future?
Nov 2021
Publication
Since early 2020 Turkey has been considering the role of hydrogen in its energy future with a view to producing a hydrogen strategy in the next few months. Unlike many other countries considering the role of hydrogen Turkey has only recently (October 2021) ratified the Paris Agreement addressing climate change and its interest is driven more by geopolitical strategic and energy security concerns. Specifically with concerns about the high share of imported energy particularly gas from Russia it sees hydrogen as part of a policy to increase indigenous energy production. Turkey already has a relatively high share of renewable power generation particularly hydro and recent solar auctions have resulted in low prices leading to a focus on potential green hydrogen production. However it still generates over half of its electricity from fossil fuel including over 25% from coal and lignite. Against that background it provides an interesting case study on some of the key aspects that a country needs to consider when looking to incorporate low-carbon hydrogen into the development of their energy economy.
The research paper can be found on their website
The research paper can be found on their website
H21- Hydrogen Boilers Installed in Demonstration Houses
Nov 2020
Publication
Hydrogen boilers have been developed by Worcester Bosch and Baxi and are being trialled in demonstration houses. They look and feel just like the boilers we use today. Hydrogen produces no carbon when used and a hydrogen gas network could provide the least disruptive route to a net zero carbon future.
The Effect of Tube Internal Geometry on the Propensity to Spontaneous Ignition in Pressurized Hydrogen Release
Sep 2013
Publication
Spontaneous ignition of compressed hydrogen release through a length of tube with different internal geometries is numerically investigated using our previously developed model. Four types of internal geometries are considered: local contraction local enlargement abrupt contraction and abrupt enlargement. The presence of internal geometries was found to significantly increase the propensity to spontaneous ignition. Shock reflections from the surfaces of the internal geometries and the subsequent shock interactions further increase the temperature of the combustible mixture at the contact region. The presence of the internal geometry stimulates turbulence enhanced mixing between the shock-heated air and the escaping hydrogen resulting in the formation of more flammable mixture. It was also found that forward-facing vertical planes are more likely to cause spontaneous ignition by producing the highest heating to the flammable mixture than backward-facing vertical planes.
Ia-HySafe Standard Benchmark Exercise Sbep-V21- Hydrogen Release and Accumulation within a Non-Ventilated Ambient Pressure Garage at Low Release Rates
Sep 2011
Publication
The successful Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) benchmarking activity originally started within the EC-funded Network of Excellence HySafe (2004-2009) continues within the research topics of the recently established “International Association of Hydrogen Safety” (IA-HySafe). The present contribution reports the results of the standard benchmark problem SBEP-V21. Focus is given to hydrogen dispersion and accumulation within a non-ventilated ambient pressure garage both during the release and post-release periods but for very low release rates as compared to earlier work (SBEP-V3). The current experiments were performed by CEA at the GARAGE facility under highly controlled conditions. Helium was vertically released from the centre of the 5.76 m (length) x 2.96 m (width) x 2.42 m (height) facility 22 cm from the floor from a 29.7 mm diameter opening at a volumetric rate of 18 L/min (0.027 g/s equivalent hydrogen release rate compared to 1 g/s for SBEP-V3) and for a period of 3740 seconds. Helium concentrations were measured with 57 catharometric sensors at various locations for a period up to 1.1 days. The simulations were performed using a variety of CFD codes and turbulence models. The paper compares the results predicted by the participating partners and attempts to identify the reasons for any observed disagreements.
A Dynamic Performance Diagnostic Method Applied to Hydrogen Powered Aero Engines Operating under Transient Conditions
Apr 2022
Publication
At present aero engine fault diagnosis is mainly based on the steady-state condition at the cruise phase and the gas path parameters in the entire flight process are not effectively used. At the same time high quality steady-state monitoring measurements are not always available and as a result the accuracy of diagnosis might be affected. There is a recognized need for real-time performance diagnosis of aero engines operating under transient conditions which can improve their condition-based maintenance. Recent studies have demonstrated the capability of the sequential model-based diagnostic method to predict accurately and efficiently the degradation of industrial gas turbines under steady-state conditions. Nevertheless incorporating real-time data for fault detection of aero engines that operate in dynamic conditions is a more challenging task. The primary objective of this study is to investigate the performance of the sequential diagnostic method when it is applied to aero engines that operate under transient conditions while there is a variation in the bypass ratio and the heat soakage effects are taken into consideration. This study provides a novel approach for quantifying component degradation such as fouling and erosion by using an adapted version of the sequential diagnostic method. The research presented here confirms that the proposed method could be applied to aero engine fault diagnosis under both steady-state and dynamic conditions in real-time. In addition the economic impact of engine degradation on fuel cost and payload revenue is evaluated when the engine under investigation is using hydrogen. The proposed method demonstrated promising diagnostic results where the maximum prediction errors for steady state and transient conditions are less than 0.006% and 0.016% respectively. The comparison of the proposed method to a benchmark diagnostic method revealed a 15% improvement in accuracy which can have great benefit when considering that the cost attributed to degradation can reach up to $702585 for 6000 flight cycles of a hydrogen powered aircraft fleet. This study provides an opportunity to improve our understanding of aero engine fault diagnosis in order to improve engine reliability availability and efficiency by online health monitoring.
Scottish Hydrogen Assessment
Dec 2020
Publication
During 2020 the Scottish Government in partnership with Highlands and Islands Enterprise and Scottish Enterprise commissioned Arup and E4Tech to carry out a hydrogen assessment to deepen our evidence base in order to inform our policies on hydrogen going forward. The assessment aims to investigate how and where hydrogen may fit within the evolving energy system technically geographically and economically. To assist in this consideration a key part of the Hydrogen Assessment is the development of distinct viable scenarios for hydrogen deployment in Scotland and the economic assessment of those scenarios.<br/>From our assessment it is clear that hydrogen is not just an energy and emissions reduction opportunity; it could also have an important role in generating new economic opportunities in Scotland. The assessment forms an important part of the evidence base that informed the development of the Hydrogen Policy Statement.
Materials Aspects Associated with the Addition of up to 20 mol% Hydrogen into an Existing Natural Gas Distribution Network
Sep 2019
Publication
The introduction of hydrogen into the UK natural gas main has been reviewed in terms of how materials within the gas distribution network may be affected by contact with up to 80% Natural Gas : 20 mol% hydrogen blend at up to 2 barg. A range of metallic polymeric and elastomeric materials in the gas distribution network (GDN) were assessed via a combination of literature review and targeted practical test programmes.
The work considered:
The work considered:
- The effect of hydrogen on metallic materials identified in the network
- The effect of hydrogen on polymeric materials identified in the network
- The effect of hydrogen exposure on polyethylene pipeline techniques (squeeze off and collar electrofusion)
Hydrogen Bubble Dispersion and Surface Bursting Behaviour
Sep 2013
Publication
In many processes where hydrogen may be released from below a liquid surface there has been concern regarding how such releases might ultimately disperse in an ullage space. Knowledge of the extent and persistence of any flammable volume formed is needed for hazardous area classification as well as for validation of explosion modelling or experiments. Following an initial release of hydrogen the overall process can be subdivided into three stages (i) rise and possible break-up of a bubble in the liquid (ii) formation and bursting of a thin gas-liquid-gas interface at the liquid surface and (iii) dispersion of the released gas. An apparatus based on a large glass sided water tank has been constructed which employs two synchronised high-speed imaging systems to record the behaviour of hydrogen bubble release and dispersion. A high-speed digital video system records the rising of the bubbles and the formation and bursting of the gas-liquid-gas interface at the liquid surface. An additional schlieren system is used to visualise the hydrogen release as bubbles burst at the liquid surface. The bubble burst mechanism can clearly be described from the results obtained. Following the nucleation of a hole surface tension causes the liquid film to peel back rapidly forming a ring/torus of liquid around the enlarging hole. This process lasts only a few milliseconds. Although some hydrogen can be seen to be expelled from the bubble much seems to remain in place as the film peels away. To assess the extent of the flammable plume following a bubble burst the apparatus was modified to include an electric-arc igniter. In order to identify plumes coincident in space with the igniter a schlieren system was built capable of recording simultaneously in two orthogonal directions. This confirmed that clouds undetected by the schlerien imaging could not be ignited with the electric arc igniter.
Operation of UK Gas Appliances with Hydrogen Blended Natural Gas
Sep 2019
Publication
The HyDeploy project has undertaken a programme of work to assess the effect of hydrogen addition on the safety and performance of gas appliances and installations. A representative set of eight appliances have been assessed in laboratory experiments with a range of test gases that explored high and low Wobbe Number and hydrogen concentrations up to 28.4 % mol/mol. Tests have demonstrated that the addition of hydrogen does not affect the key hazard areas of CO production light back flame out or the operation of flame failure devices. It was identified that for some designs of gas fire appliances the operation of the oxygen depletion sensors may be affected by the addition of hydrogen and further studies in this area are planned. A laboratory based study was supported by an onsite testing programme where 133 installations were assessed for gas tightness appliance combustion safety and operation against normal line natural gas G20 reference gas and two hydrogen blended gases. Where installations were gas tight for natural gas analysis showed that no additional leakage occurred with hydrogen blended gases. There were also no issues identified with the combustion performance of appliances and onsite results were in line with those obtained in the laboratory testing programme.
Annual Science Review 2020
Mar 2020
Publication
HSE maintains a national network of doctors appointed doctors and approved medical examiners of divers who are appointed to deliver certain vital functions under our regulatory framework.1 Over the last year or so we have been reaching out to them and offering training and networking opportunities so that we can learn from each other. Their intelligence from real workplaces helps ensure that our medical approach is grounded by what actually happens and this helped us ensure that our health and work strategy took account of their views. I think that it is increasingly important to share our approaches and our research outcomes on the global stage in an attempt to learn from other researchers around the world. A good example is the work described in this report on the artificial stone issue. I have been lucky enough to work with the Australian research group who identified an epidemic of silicosis from this exposure in their country and helped to facilitate some cross-comparison of materials with our hygienists and measurement scientists. The dialogue continues and I hope that by doing so we can help to prevent such an epidemic from occurring in the UK.<br/>All HSE research findings are published as soon as we are able to do this and this demonstrates both my and Andrew Curran’s commitment to ensure that we publish the evidence we generate to make workplaces healthier for all.
Gas Detection of Hydrogen/Natural Gas Blends in the Gas Industry
Sep 2019
Publication
A key element in the safe operation of a modern gas distribution system is gas detection. The addition of hydrogen to natural gas will alter the characteristics of the fuel and therefore its impact on gas detection must be considered. It is important that gas detectors remain sufficiently sensitive to the presence of hydrogen and natural gas mixtures and that they do not lead to false readings. This paper presents analyses of work performed as part of the Office for Gas and Energy Markets (OFGEM) funded HyDeploy project on the response of various natural gas industry detectors to blended mixtures up to 20 volume percent (vol%) of hydrogen in natural gas. The scope of the detectors under test included survey instruments and personal monitors that are used in the gas industry. Four blend ratios were analysed (0 10 15 and 20 vol% hydrogen in natural gas). The laboratory testing undertaken investigated the following:
- Flammable response to blends in the ppm range (0-0.2 vol%);
- Flammable response to blends in the lower explosion limit range (0.2-5 vol%);
- Flammable response to blends in the volume percent range (5-100 vol%);
- Oxygen response to blends in the volume percent range (0-25 vol%); and
- Carbon monoxide response to blends in the ppm range (0-1000 ppm).
Simulation of Hydrogen Dispersion under Cryogenic Release Conditions
Sep 2013
Publication
The use of hydrogen as fuel should always be accompanied by a safety assessment in case of an accidental release. To evaluate the potential hazards in a spill accident both experiments and simulations are performed. In the present work the CFD code ADREA-HF is used to simulate the liquefied hydrogen (LH2) spill experiments (test 5 6 7) conducted by the Health and Safety Laboratory (HSL). In these tests LH2 was spilled at a fixed rate of 60lt/min in several directions and for several durations. The factors that influence the vapor dispersion under cryogenic release conditions that were examined in this study are: the air humidity the wind direction and the slip effect of droplets formed by both the cryogenic liquid and the condensation of air humidity. The numerical results were compared with the experimental measurements and the effect of each abovementioned factors in the vapor dispersion is being discussed.
A New Sustainable Hydrogen Clean Energy Paradigm
Feb 2018
Publication
We analyze the feasibility of a novel hydrogen fuel cell electric generator to provide power with zero noise and emissions for myriad ground based applications. The hydrogen fuel cell electric generator utilizes a novel scalable apparatus that safely generates hydrogen (H2) on demand according to a novel method using a controlled chemical reaction between water (H2O) and sodium (Na) metal that yields hydrogen gas of sufficient purity for direct use in fuel cells without risk of contaminating sensitive catalysts. The sodium hydroxide (NaOH) byproduct of the hydrogen producing reaction is collected within the apparatus for later reprocessing by electrolysis to recover the Na reactant. The detailed analysis shows that the novel hydrogen fuel cell electric generator will be capable of meeting the clean power requirements for residential and commercial buildings including single family homes and light commercial establishments under a wide range of geographic and climatic conditions.
Flow Loop Test for Hydrogen
Jul 2020
Publication
National Grid (NG) needs to understand the implications that a hydrogen rich gas mix may have on the existing pipeline network. The primary network consists extensively of X52 steel pipe sections welded together using girth welds. Different welding specifications that have been used in the past 40 years and girth welds with different specifications may behave differently when coming into contact with hydrogen gas.
The aim of the flow loop test programme is to begin to evaluate the durability of pipeline materials in the context of future proofing of gas grid service where the gas mix may include a significant proportion of hydrogen. One specific objective is to investigate the resistance to hydrogen embrittlement of a conventional steel (X52) with commonly used girth welds. The primary concern is that the phenomenon of hydrogen embrittlement may cause unexpected or early failure mechanisms especially in older pipe sections with less stringent girth weld specifications.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the ENA Smarter Networks Portal here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.
The aim of the flow loop test programme is to begin to evaluate the durability of pipeline materials in the context of future proofing of gas grid service where the gas mix may include a significant proportion of hydrogen. One specific objective is to investigate the resistance to hydrogen embrittlement of a conventional steel (X52) with commonly used girth welds. The primary concern is that the phenomenon of hydrogen embrittlement may cause unexpected or early failure mechanisms especially in older pipe sections with less stringent girth weld specifications.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the ENA Smarter Networks Portal here. IGEM Members can download the report and any attachment directly by clicking on the pdf icon above.
Numerical Simulation of Diverging Detonation in Hydrogen Air Mixtures
Oct 2015
Publication
Propagation and stability of diverging cylindrical detonation in hydrogen air mixture is numerically simulated and the mechanism of the transverse waves is analysed. For the numerical modelling a new solver based on compressible transient reactive Navier–Stokes equations is developed which can the simulate detonation propagation and extinction in hydrogen-air mixture. A single step reaction mechanism is tuned to ensure the detonation and deflagration properties (in case of detonation failure) can be simulated accurately. The solver is used for modelling various detonation scenarios in particular cylindrical diverging-detonations because most of accidental industrial detonations start from a spark and then a diverging-detonation propagates outwards. The diverging detonation its cellular structure and adoption with the increased surface area at the detonation front as well as interactions with obstacles leading to detonation failure and re-initiation are studied.
Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Stationary Applications: Key Findings of Modelling and Experimental Work in the Hyper Project
Sep 2009
Publication
Síle Brennan,
A. Bengaouer,
Marco Carcassi,
Gennaro M. Cerchiara,
Andreas Friedrich,
O. Gentilhomme,
William G. Houf,
N. Kotchourko,
Alexei Kotchourko,
Sergey Kudriakov,
Dmitry Makarov,
Vladimir V. Molkov,
Efthymia A. Papanikolaou,
C. Pitre,
Mark Royle,
R. W. Schefer,
G. Stern,
Alexandros G. Venetsanos,
Anke Veser,
Deborah Willoughby,
Jorge Yanez and
Greg H. Evans
"This paper summarises the modelling and experimental programme in the EC FP6 project HYPER. A number of key results are presented and the relevance of these findings to installation permitting guidelines (IPG) for small stationary hydrogen and fuel cell systems is discussed. A key aim of the activities was to generate new scientific data and knowledge in the field of hydrogen safety and where possible use this data as a basis to support the recommendations in the IPG. The structure of the paper mirrors that of the work programme within HYPER in that the work is described in terms of a number of relevant scenarios as follows: 1. high pressure releases 2. small foreseeable releases 3. catastrophic releases and 4. the effects of walls and barriers. Within each scenario the key objectives activities and results are discussed.<br/>The work on high pressure releases sought to provide information for informing safety distances for high-pressure components and associated fuel storage activities on both ignited and unignited jets are reported. A study on small foreseeable releases which could potentially be controlled through forced or natural ventilation is described. The aim of the study was to determine the ventilation requirements in enclosures containing fuel cells such that in the event of a foreseeable leak the concentration of hydrogen in air for zone 2 ATEX is not exceeded. The hazard potential of a possibly catastrophic hydrogen leakage inside a fuel cell cabinet was investigated using a generic fuel cell enclosure model. The rupture of the hydrogen feed line inside the enclosure was considered and both dispersion and combustion of the resulting hydrogen air mixture were examined for a range of leak rates and blockage ratios. Key findings of this study are presented. Finally the scenario on walls and barriers is discussed; a mitigation strategy to potentially reduce the exposure to jet flames is to incorporate barriers around hydrogen storage equipment. Conclusions of experimental and modelling work which aim to provide guidance on configuration and placement of these walls to minimise overall hazards is presented. "
World Energy Issues Monitor 2019 Managing the Grand Energy Transition
Oct 2019
Publication
This is the tenth consecutive year of the World Energy Council’s (the Council) annual survey of key challenges and opportunities facing energy leaders in managing and shaping Energy Transitions. This year’s Issues Monitor report provides seven global maps six regional maps and fifty national maps.
These maps have been developed by analysing the responses of nearly 2300 energy leaders drawn from across the Council’s diverse and truly global energy community.
The Council’s Issues Monitor identifies the strategic energy landscape of specific countries and regions in the world through an analysis of 42 energy issues and 4 digitalisation-specific issues affecting the energy system. It provides a unique reality check and horizon scanning of persistent and emerging concerns involved in whole energy systems transition. This year’s report welcomes a significant increase in both the participation of global leaders (up over 75% from 1300 to nearly 2300) as well as the participation of 86 countries.
Each Issue Map provides a visual snapshot of the uncertainties and action priorities that energy policymakers CEOs and leading experts strive to address to shape and manage successful Energy
Transitions. Maps can be used in the following ways:
These maps have been developed by analysing the responses of nearly 2300 energy leaders drawn from across the Council’s diverse and truly global energy community.
The Council’s Issues Monitor identifies the strategic energy landscape of specific countries and regions in the world through an analysis of 42 energy issues and 4 digitalisation-specific issues affecting the energy system. It provides a unique reality check and horizon scanning of persistent and emerging concerns involved in whole energy systems transition. This year’s report welcomes a significant increase in both the participation of global leaders (up over 75% from 1300 to nearly 2300) as well as the participation of 86 countries.
Each Issue Map provides a visual snapshot of the uncertainties and action priorities that energy policymakers CEOs and leading experts strive to address to shape and manage successful Energy
Transitions. Maps can be used in the following ways:
- To promote a shared understanding of successful Energy Transitions
- To appreciate and contrast regional variations to better understand differing priorities and areas of concern
- To follow the evolution of specific technology trends related to the energy sector
Benchmark Exercise on Risk Assessment Methods Applied to a Virtual Hydrogen Refuelling Station
Sep 2009
Publication
A benchmarking exercise on quantitative risk assessment (QRA) methodologies has been conducted within the project HyQRA under the framework of the European Network of Excellence (NoE) HySafe. The aim of the exercise was basically twofold: (i) to identify the differences and similarities in approaches in a QRA and their results for a hydrogen installation between nine participating partners representing a broad spectrum of background in QRA culture and history and (ii) to identify knowledge gaps in the various steps and parameters underlying the risk quantification. In the first step a reference case was defined: a virtual hydrogen refuelling station (HRS) in virtual surroundings comprising housing school shops and other vulnerable objects. All partners were requested to conduct a QRA according to their usual approach and experience. Basically participants were free to define representative release cases to apply models and frequency assessments according their own methodology and to present risk according to their usual format. To enable inter-comparison a required set of results data was prescribed like distances to specific thermal radiation levels from fires and distances to specific overpressure levels. Moreover complete documentation of assumptions base data and references was to be reported. It was not surprising that a wide range of results was obtained both in the applied approaches as well as in the quantitative outcomes and conclusions. This made it difficult to identify exactly which assumptions and parameters were responsible for the differences in results as the paper will show. A second phase was defined in which the QRA was determined by a more limited number of release cases (scenarios). The partners in the project agreed to assess specific scenarios in order to identify the differences in consequence assessment approaches. The results of this phase provide a better understanding of the influence of modelling assumptions and limitations on the eventual conclusions with regard to risk to on-site people and to the off-site public. This paper presents the results and conclusions of both stages of the exercise.
Safe Operation of Combined Cycle Gas Turbine and Gas Engine Systems Using Hydrogen Rich Fuels
Oct 2015
Publication
This paper describes work performed by a consortium led by the UK Health and Safety Laboratory(HSL)to identify the safe operating conditions for combined cycle power generating systems running on high hydrogen fuels. The work focuses on hydrogen and high hydrogen syngas and biogas waste-stream fuel mixtures which may prove hazardous in the event of a turbine or engine flame out resulting in a flammable fuel mixture entering the hot exhaust system and igniting. The paper describes the project presenting some initial results from this work including the development of large scale experimental facilities on the550 acre HSL site near Buxton Derbyshire UK. It describes the large scale experimental facility which utilises the exhaust gas from a Rolls-Royce Viper jet-engine (converted to run on butane) feeding into a 12 m long 0.60 m diameter instrumented tube at a pre-combustion velocity of 22 m/s. A variable geometry simulated heat exchanger with a 40 %2blockage ratio is present in the tube. Flammable mixtures injected into the tube close to the Viper outlet together with make-up oxygen are then ignited. Extensive optical ionisation temperature and pressure sensors are employed along the length of the tube to measure the pressures and flame speeds resulting from the combustion event. Some preliminary results from the test programme are discussed including deflagration to detonation transitions at high equivalence ratios.
Hydrogen Transport and Trapping: From Quantum Effects to Alloy Design
Jun 2017
Publication
This discussion session concerned experimental and theoretical investigations of the atomistic properties underlying the energetics and kinetics of hydrogen trapping and diffusion in metallic systems.
This article is a transcription of the recorded discussion of ‘Hydrogen transport and trapping: from quantum effects to alloy design.‘ at the Royal Society Scientific Discussion Meeting Challenges of Hydrogen and Metals 16–18 January 2017. The text is approved by the contributors. Y.-S.C. transcribed the session. H.L. assisted in the preparation of the manuscript.
Link to document download on Royal Society Website
This article is a transcription of the recorded discussion of ‘Hydrogen transport and trapping: from quantum effects to alloy design.‘ at the Royal Society Scientific Discussion Meeting Challenges of Hydrogen and Metals 16–18 January 2017. The text is approved by the contributors. Y.-S.C. transcribed the session. H.L. assisted in the preparation of the manuscript.
Link to document download on Royal Society Website
Hy4Heat Hydrogen Purity - Work Package 2
Feb 2020
Publication
The report makes a recommendation for a minimum hydrogen purity standard to be used by manufacturers developing prototype hydrogen appliances and during their subsequent demonstration as part of the Hy4Heat programme. It makes a recommendation for a hydrogen purity level with the aim that it is reasonable and practicable and considers implications related to hydrogen production the gas network and cost.
This report and any attachment is freely available on the Hy4Heat website here. The report can also be downloaded directly by clicking on the pdf icon above
This report and any attachment is freely available on the Hy4Heat website here. The report can also be downloaded directly by clicking on the pdf icon above
No more items...